Think Progress

TVC: 80% Of Public Just Like Hitler

By Jon Baskin on Mar 25th, 2005 at 10:51 am

TVC: 80% Of Public Just Like Hitler

Think Congress should have stayed out of the Terri Schiavo case? According to the Traditional Values Coalition (TVC), you’re just like Hitler. Here’s an excerpt from one of TVC’s recent press releases, entitled, “Hitler Targeted The Handicapped First”:

The roots of Hitler’s euthanasia program began in 1920 with the publishing of an essay by Dr. Alfred Hoche and law professor Karl Binding. The essay, “Releasing Persons from Lives Devoid of Value,” recommended a new medical ethic to deal with mental patients and those whose lives were considered worthless.

According to Hoche and Binding, useless individuals were to be killed to save money and to release them from the perceived miseries of living a life devoid of value.

Hoche introduced the concept of “mental death” to describe the retarded or those who suffered from other forms of brain damage (much like Terri Schiavo’s condition). He described these people as “‘human ballast” and said that killing them would be useful and allowable act under the law.

The release goes on to detail how “doomed patients,” including “handicapped infants and small children,” were exterminated in concentration camps and gas chambers.

The 80 percent of Americans who think the Court’s decision on Schiavo should be allowed to stand: TVC is talking to you.



21 Responses to “TVC: 80% Of Public Just Like Hitler”

  1. Bei says:

    Can I be Goebbels?? Oh, please, please, please – let me be Goebbels!


  2. Calitex says:

    Or, he could be referring to Bush and his 1999 Texas law…


  3. Paul Salcido says:

    There is a major problem with that statement, in the fact that the government was empowered to kill individuals that were disabled, etc. The power was not in the hands of the family.

    The only law that puts corporations or government in control of someones life is the one that was signed by Bush in Texas, that allows the hospital to pull the plug on someone that has no chance of improvement.

    Therefore, it is my opinion that Bush’s Texas law is closer to the description, and that because this is the choice of the family and the individual, this is quite a bit separated from what the Nazis did.

    Man, some people just tick me off.


  4. Jon says:

    Does the Schiavo tragedy show that the conservative movement is approaching a meltdown?

    Maybe not, but the yawning chasm between economic and social conservatives, dormant for two presidential elections is reemerging and with it, a serious threat to the Republicans’ majority status.

    For more, see:

    “Achilles’ Heels”


  5. spyder says:

    Also it failed to mention all those laws where in governments selectively choose to kill people for their inability to have enough money to prevent themselves from being prosecuted and convicted of capital crimes; or when they are not US citizens, under US military control and just happen to end up dead at the end of the day in various detention facilities although they were never charged with crimes; or when CIA supported death squads acting in the interests of US corporations kill US and foreign citizens in order to enact regimes more friendly to our imperialism. But those are okay, right? TVC is only worried about a person here and there.


  6. labinge says:

    As a wheelchair/homebound individual, I fear the current right-wing lunatics because of their perversions of history. I’m tired of watching a bunch of practicing fascists compare dissenters to Nazis.
    Because of current Medicare/Medicade reductions, I maybe forced into poverty simply to deter further deterioration. I may be denied medications that supress my pain because of “addiction” fears, and when I really want to check out, I may be denied that choice because of a bunch of fanatics are using the government to advance a particular narrow religious view. If forcing government control over my life and forced adherence to a particular religious dogma isn’t Nazism” I’d love to know what it is.


  7. Bones says:

    Right wingers are out of control.

    Here’s another example of them having their children arrested over the Schiavo matter.



  8. alex says:

    The article fails to mention that someone in Schiavo’s condition would have died within a week in the 1940’s. There weren’t the machines necessary to keep someone in her condition alive back then, so I don’t see how they can claim that Nazis would have killed someone in that condition.


  9. Wills says:

    I agree with the comments so far and especially Paul Salcido. There is a difference between a request to stop treatment by an individual and a government killing people. Wasn’t the bush administration going to use poor children to test the effect of pesticides on children? Forget goebbels – let’s go straight to old joe mengels.


  10. Jorge says:

    Anyone who thinks that Terri Shiavo should die is actually WORSE than Hitler.

    Oh wait, no there not.

    This woman should die, her brain is rotted, she ain’t coming back.


  11. Linda says:

    It isn’t just TVC who insults 80 percent of Americans. Most cable news networks, including the very slimely CNN, also insult us.


  12. hgh says:

    The administration of HGH Spray takes you only a few seconds and thus it spares you the pain of swallowing pills or taking HGH injections.


  13. hgh says:

    HGH Spray at a incredible low price. HGH spray contains no hormones.


  14. anti aging says:

    HGH is a very common product nowaday. HGH spray is very effective in anti-aging treatment.



  15. Cars Ake stall says:

    bdsm spanking slave free video clips les

    Think Progress »…


  16. human growth hormone says:

    HGH comes from Human Growth Hormone… a hormone that helps your body grow when you’re young, regenerate and stay in shape after puberty.


  17. euro exchange rates says:

    euro exchange rates

    opposes.recycled!communes boxtops italicize bunkmates maples appendices Robertsons list of foreign currency http://www.realestatehotbuys.com/list-of-foreign-currency.html


  18. hgh antiaging says:

    HGH supplements are used in anti-aging therapy.


  19. hgh says:

    There are several types of anti aging therapies, but, so far, hgh anti-aging therapy is the most promissing.



Jump to Top

About Think Progress | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2009 Center for American Progress Action Fund
View Most Popular

Advertisement

What We're About

Featured

image
Subscribe to the Progress Report



imageTopic Cloud


Visit Our Affiliated Sites

image image
Reports


Got a hot tip?
Have a hot news tip? We'd love to hear from you. Use the form below to send us the latest.

Name:
Email:
Tip:
(required)


imageArchives


imageBlog Roll