Think Progress

Privatizers Getting Desperate

By Nico Pitney on Mar 28th, 2005 at 11:22 am

Privatizers Getting Desperate

On Thursday, privatization-pushers released a deceptive “research briefing” with excerpts from news stories on recent Social Security town-hall meetings. The article snippets give the impression that President Bush’s privatization plan enjoys nationwide backing; indeed, the document’s bold, italicized headline reads, “More Americans Support Call To Strengthen Social Security.”

Just one problem — several of the individuals quoted in the press release explain in the excerpted articles that they actually oppose privatization:

The pull-quote: Clif Smith, A Retiree From Joplin: “I Believe [Social Security] Needs Improved [Sic].”

The full quote:

“I believe it needs improved,” said Clif Smith, a retiree from Joplin, at the AARP gathering. “But nothing of the nature of what is being talked about in Washington.”

Smith said he opposes private accounts because he thinks they would drain money from the trust fund, but he said the fund itself should own stock.

+++

The pull-quote:[Kimberly] Holloway Sees Advantages In Personal Accounts In That It Would Encourage More Savings And Financial Responsibility …”

The full quote:

Holloway sees advantages in personal accounts in that it would encourage more savings and financial responsibility, she said.

But she’s wary that this proposal feeds into the Bush administration’s trend to encourage self-centered thinking away from considering the welfare of the general society, she said.

“We all should care because you don’t know what (misfortune) will happen,” Holloway said. “Don’t fiddle with the social safety net.”

+++

The pull-quote: Scott Savelkol, Recent Graduate From Dickinson State University: “Doing Nothing Is Not An Option.”

The full quote:

Scott Savelkol, who recently graduated from Dickinson State University, said he also opposes to private accounts [sic]. He would prefer lawmakers lift a $90,000 cap on wages taxed for Social Security.

“Doing nothing is not an option,” Savelkol said.



124 Responses to “Privatizers Getting Desperate”

  1. Karl A says:

    Bwaaaaahahaha… now THAT’S desperate.


  2. hueyplong says:

    When I said “George Bush is a perfect idiot,” they published my statement as “George Bush is … perfect.”


  3. Alan says:

    It sort of reminds you of those movie posters for crap movies that quote 1-3 word phrases from reviewers who panned the movie.


  4. David (Austin Tx) says:

    It seems that Bush and the truth only had a fleeting relationship


  5. bkny says:

    alan — those copywriters had to go somewhere once the newspapers got hip to the deception. working for the gop is very lucrative…


  6. Lisa says:

    MAD magazine used to have that as a feature humor piece: The words the movie advertisement used from a review, then what the review actually said. Nice to see the Repubs getting their ideas from MAD.


  7. Raoul Paste says:

    Hueyplong, that comment was perfect.


  8. Ed Drone says:

    “It seems that Bush and the truth only had a fleeting relationship”

    “The Truth” … yeah, they’ve heard of that. Like sincerety, when you can fake that, you’re home free.

    Ed


  9. wellstoner says:

    Like Al Franken says:

    The only way that would be true
    is if immediately before that quote
    they said “I would have to be an IDIOT
    to say something like…”


  10. CKT says:

    Raoul Paste acknowledged that Hueyplong is of divine origin, saying “Hueyplong… was perfect.”


  11. Richard Pryor says:

  12. QrazyQat says:

    The modern GOP is being run by pseudoscience types — creationists and anti-science people. This is one of the standard techiniques used by pseudoscience proponents. It’s called “quote mining”. Do a Google search on “quote mining” for examples.


  13. nikto says:

    The GOP is addicted to lying like a long-term heroin addict is to his needle.

    If they were ever forced to admit and accept THE TRUTH, all their heads would probably explode.


  14. pbg says:

    “Incredible!”"Amazing!”"Like nothing I’ve ever seen before!”


  15. troqua says:

    Thank goodness for blogs. You’ll never see the so-called journalists on the major newsies do this kind of in-depth search for the truth. Why? They’re lazy.


  16. daver9 says:

    All true comments onthis thread, but nothing will change until the faith-based wal-marters and their fantasy economy tanks really hard and they can’t buy chinese trinkets nor put food on their families. They have the luxury of voting their fantasy values, but all that changes when Cap’n bush sinks this fiscal Titantic. ‘course, we all suffer, but there’s a silver liniing, the neoconomics get buried for another 40 years. Meanwhile, buy euros.


  17. kindness says:

    History moves forward while the bush administration happily marches back to 1984.

    Where have you gone Joe Dimaggio?


  18. Radjil says:

    New GOP quote: In reference to private accounts, pbg says, “Incredible! Amazing!”


  19. hiernymous braintree says:

    Just goes to show just what rotten Christians these guys are. A true Christian is supposed to tell the truth. He isn’t supposed to make shit up or quote out of context. A Christian is supposed to tell the truth. Always. Why other Christians don’t call them on it, I’ll never know. I guess their not serious about defending their religion’s good name from opportunistic hypocrites.


  20. sniffy says:

    It seems that Bush and the truth only had a fleeting relationship

    Yeah, but truth didn’t swallow.


  21. brianm0122 says:

    re: Comment by hiernymous braintree

    Isn’t this called “Bearing false witness”?


  22. Tom says:

    In Middle English, “Amusing, Artificial, and Awful” used to mean “Pleasing, Evident of Artistry, and Awe-Inspiring”. Still, do, really, but the connotations have changed. Bush’s privatization plan is “Amusing, Artificial, and Awful” only by today’s standards.


  23. Willie Loucks says:

    Do you think people are starting to get the picture about this administration? This is just about SSI, just think of the other lies about war, Iraq, budgit defict,trade defict, prisenor abuse you name it they have lied about it. And they call them selves christians.


  24. Robert Waldmann says:

    Dear Tom
    Your argument is liquidated when its specious quality is revealed (that’s English as in roughly 1776)


  25. Shalimar says:

    Cliff Smith among others should sue. They took his quote out of context and made him appear to support something he disagrees with. I’m not sure it legally matters that they claimed his endorsement without his consent or knowledge but it would be interesting to find out in court.


  26. john says:

    Impeachment …. let’s see last time a blue dress fell victim ….. this time a nation, culture, sanity, is in the crosshairs …… Dissent is the plasma of democracy …. “Let it Bleed”


  27. David in Burbank says:

    So even after they SCREEN the participants to these so called “Town-Hal” meetings the STILL have to missquote them.

    I guess you just can’t find good sheeple anymore.


  28. Cathy Gontar says:

    In present general atmosphere of such widespread corporate scandal, this is a very bad time to turn citizens’ savings over to corporate America. Its just a replay of Enron/Whitehouse ripoff but on much vaster scale. Wake up America.


  29. tenaciousd says:

    The pull quote: Joe Schmoe declared, “Private accountes are…(A)…w…e…s…o…m…e!”

    The full quote: Joe Schmoe declared, “Private accounts are the most awful idea George Bush has ever came up with [sic]!”


  30. TC says:

    It seems that Bush [told the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the] truth [: if] only [America] had [more people like him.]

    Comment by David (Austin Tx) — March 28th, 2005 @ 11:50 am


  31. Java Black says:

    Somehow none of this surprises me. It also wouldn’t surprise me if Bush’s plan succeeds even with zero support from the population. Nothing surprises me anymore.


  32. Stacy L says:

    I have a theory to why Bush is getting soooo desperate to get this social security through, despite the fact that the majority of Americans are dead set against it. I mean why would someone commit political suicide in order to push something no one wants? Because the ass is getting ready to drop out of the stock market. Think about it. Not only is our economy headed south, it’s circling the bowl folks. Bush has spent all the money we had and much much more. Our dollar is all but worthless. Anyone with any sense and a large amount of money are now investing in the European Market. The returns are better and with the rate of exchange once you do the initial conversion your making almost time and a half on your returns. No one is pumping any “new” money into the American market. Bush wants to use the private accounts to prop up our market so he can put off the depression that is bound to happen, so he can once again duck taking account for this mess. He does not want the next major depression to happen on his watch, so he’s trying to prop up the market till the next presidential term. Remember how everyone was throwing a fit to about how this years budget was so deceptive and didn’t include all that it was supposed to? Because if they put everything in we would have the real facts about the economy, and those facts don’t reflect well for the Republicans. Think about it folks, why else would they lie about the budget and try to push through this social security “reform” that no one wants? Becuase they have someting to hide.


  33. mike wyman says:

    do you folks call this stuff to the attention of purple state newspapers?


  34. Betty J says:

    It’s called “lying by omission” and nobody does it better than BushCo’s people.


  35. john d'oh says:

    Can someone with credentials post this on the Freeper’s website. I’d love to see their response.


  36. Doug Palmieri says:

    If you say it enough people believe it…Carl Rove, FOX News, all those twisted neo-con SOB’s know that and don’t care if it’s true or not. They are all so christ like huh?


  37. C. Douglas Kouka Allen says:

    No! If they were forced to, the GOP’s head would “perhaps” explode in ackowlediging the types of U.S. citizens (as in America) they have become?


  38. C. Douglas Kouka Allen says:

    U.S. of America!

    people


  39. aaron says:

    I mean, is it a surprise? The Leage of Disinformation reigns supreme in America. Wow, that’s carping. Excuse me.


  40. backgamon rules says:

    backgamon rules
    The man who gets angry at the right things and with the right people, and in the right way and at the right time and for the right length of time, is commended. by


  41. hgh spray says:

    The administration of HGH Spray takes you only a few seconds and thus it spares you the pain of swallowing pills or taking HGH injections.



  42. anti aging says:

    HGH is a very common product nowaday. HGH spray is very effective in anti-aging treatment.


  43. prilosec says:

    prilosec

    You may find it interesting to take a look at the pages on effexor online prescription drugs


  44. cephalexin says:

    cephalexin

    Take your time to check some information about weight loss pill bextra


  45. hgh says:

    Reverse the aging effects with anti-aging supplements. Check it out at HGH Website.


  46. Stephen Kriz says:

    Social Security deform would be the pinnacle of Bush’s “accomplishments”. Then, he would have completed his destruction and evisceration of all functional government programs.


  47. anti-aging says:

    Anti-Aging Pages is a definite guide to supplements that have been proposed to slow and or reverse human aging.


  48. antiaging hgh says:

    HGH, in its oral spray form, has proven to be the best product in anti-aging therapy.


  49. hgh spray says:

    Using hgh spray you can prevent the aging effects.



  50. hgh says:

    HGH offers a wide variety of benefits in many areas of human health.


  51. Patio furniture says:

    Patio furniture

    Visit patio furniture home




  52. Buy lamisil says:

    Buy lamisil

    Thanks for the article!



  53. Buy carisprodol says:

    Buy carisprodol

    Wooow! awesome! Write some more!



  54. Ken Wernert says:

    Hi, site is exemplary! Nice site! Keep it running! Very nice web page and pictures are great.


  55. drugs says:

    drugs…

    outweighed Edenize stamp Gioconda bedridden amoxicillin http://amoxicillin.pills-sale.com/


  56. Derek Fivelson says:

    Hi i take a minute to make a note at your guest book, as i always take info from this site. I agree with the some of the other posts in this guestbook: This site is nicely made – congratulations on a job well done! Thank you so much for your time, attempt and dedication to maintaining this website. I have visited it often.


  57. hgh says:

    There are several types of anti aging therapies, but, so far, hgh anti-aging therapy is the most promissing.


  58. Ushenko says:

    Viktor Ushenko k49xn48f5h


  59. Ahmed says:

    Very good website you have here.
    hillary duff
    [url=http://hillaryduff.freeblog.hu/]hillary duff[/url] Warm regards Ahmed!


  60. chuck says:

    chuckribibahrtyu 2D31HO


  61. chuck says:

    chuckribibahrtyu 2D31HO


  62. Roland Glicks says:

    Please contact me by ICQ: 933779907. I have a news for you.


  63. Bill says:

    Looking for information and found it at this great site…


  64. Sveta says:

    You have an outstanding good and well structured site. I enjoyed browsing through it.


  65. Elizabeth says:

    I enjoyed your page. Keep up the good work! Feel free to visit my page. It\’s cool too.


  66. Britney says:

    Very good web site, great work and thank you for your service.


  67. Bill says:

    I have your site for its useful and funny content and simple design.


  68. Britney says:

    This site is really superb!!! Thank you for you work! Good Luck


  69. Bill says:

    Hello people! Nice site!


  70. Bush says:

    Thank for making this valuable information available to the public.


  71. Britney says:

    Wow!!! Good job. Could I take some of yours triks to build my own site?


  72. Sveta says:

    You have built a good website


  73. Anna says:

    Thanks for your project. I like this site. KEEP IT UP..


  74. Sveta says:

    Many interesting information on your site – keep up good work


  75. Britney says:

    Your guestbook is example of middle-class guestbooks. Congratulation! I’ll show your site and guestbook to my friends.


  76. Anna says:

    Found your site in google, and it has a lot of usefull information. Thanx.


  77. Bob says:

    This is very interesting site…


  78. Anna says:

    Nice colors! Good job. thankyou.


  79. Bob says:

    Very good site! I like it! Thanks!


  80. Bob says:

    Wonderful and informative web site.I used information from that site its great.


  81. John says:

    Your website looks very good!!!


  82. Bush says:

    You guys do a wonderful job! Keep up the good work!!!


  83. Amanda says:

    Thanks so very much for taking your time to create this very useful and informative site. I have learned a lot from your site. Thanks!!


  84. Joon says:

    Thank for making this valuable information available to the public.


  85. Bush says:

    Hello admin, nice site ! Good content, eautiful design, thank !


  86. Vasilii says:

    Nice site… Cool guestbook…


  87. Jersey says:

    Hi, good morning to all of you… Nice Guestbook ;-) !!!


  88. Nicole says:

    This is very interesting site…


  89. Bob says:

    I enjoy your site very much! THANK YOU


  90. Britney says:

    A fantastic site, and brilliant effort. A great piece of work.


  91. Bob says:

    Your site is very interesting and useful


  92. Park says:

    This site is really superb!!! Thank you for you work! Good Luck



  93. Kim says:

    amateur-swingers


  94. Smit says:

    Thanks for your project. I like this site. KEEP IT UP..


  95. Jersey says:

    Very good site! I like it! Thanks!


  96. Amanda says:

    Fascinating site and well worth the visit. I will be back


  97. Vasilii says:

    Found your site in google, and it has a lot of usefull information. Thanx.


  98. Jones says:

    Thanks for your project. I like this site. KEEP IT UP..


  99. Helga says:

    Thanks so very much for taking your time to create this very useful and informative site. I have learned a lot from your site. Thanks!!


  100. Park says:

    Thanks so very much for taking your time to create this very useful and informative site. I have learned a lot from your site. Thanks!!


  101. Katie says:

    i love this site.


  102. Jesus says:

    Excellent site – do keep up the good work.


  103. Nicole says:

    A fantastic site, and brilliant effort. A great piece of work.


  104. Amanda says:

    Sentimental and nostalgic. Great.


  105. Kim says:

    Thank for making this valuable information available to the public.


  106. Nick says:

  107. Amanda says:

    Hello people! Nice site!
    W


  108. warren says:

  109. Smit says:

    Great Site – really useful information!f


  110. Semen says:

    Hey ..love the new site!!! Keep up the good work. I’ll send you text sometime. If you’re home at any time we’ll have to meet up for a pint in the Crown again. Have a good one


  111. Sveta says:

    The site\’\’s very professional! Keep up the good work! Oh yes, one extra comment – maybe you could add more pictures too! So, good luck to your team!m


  112. Joon says:

    I enjoyed your page. Keep up the good work! Feel free to visit my page. It\’s cool too.


  113. jugar tragaperras linea ruleta portales says:

    elbows apron reentered?packages.preserver adduces:


  114. hotel room ramada inn says:

    tanker lowliest lipstick Tioga interpose?comparisons Jacobsen?nicker becalms?


  115. Marilyn says:

    Your site is very interesting and usefulu


  116. Katie says:

    The site\’\’s very professional! Keep up the good work! Oh yes, one extra comment – maybe you could add more pictures too! So, good luck to your team!


  117. gag on my cock says:

    Poor Air Quality Threatens Our Health



Jump to Top

About Think Progress | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2010 Center for American Progress Action Fund
View Most Popular

Advertisement

What We're About

Featured

image
Subscribe to the Progress Report



imageTopic Cloud


Visit Our Affiliated Sites

image image
Reports


Got a hot tip?
Have a hot news tip? We'd love to hear from you. Use the form below to send us the latest.

Name:
Email:
Tip:
(required)


imageArchives


imageBlog Roll