Think Progress

Rep. Hunter’s Denial Diet

By Christy Harvey on Jun 12th, 2005 at 5:16 pm

Rep. Hunter’s Denial Diet

Tales of abuse, torture and humiliation at the prison at Guantanamo Bay are well-known. Last year, internal FBI memos showed methods used at the camp included leaving prisoners “in their own feces,” chaining them “in ice-cold or super-hot cells” and exposing them to sensory deprivation, beatings and terrifying dogs.

In its recent issue, Time Magazine obtained a log kept at Guantanamo Bay detailing the treatment of Detainee 063, Mohammed al-Qahtani. One military official described it as the “kind of document that was never meant to leave Gitmo.” It describes various forms of humiliation and abuse:

“They strip-search him and briefly make him stand nude. They tell him to bark like a dog and growl at pictures of terrorists. They hang pictures of scantily clad women around his neck.” In another instance, “a dog was used ‘in an aggressive manner to intimidate Detainee #63.” By the end of his “interrogation” period, “al-Qahtani had been ’subjected to intense isolation for over three months’ and ‘was evidencing behavior consistent with extreme psychological trauma (talking to non existent people, reporting hearing voices, crouching in a cell covered with a sheet for hours on end).”

So how did Rep. Duncan Hunter (R-CA) respond to the ongoing tales of serious abuse at Guantanamo Bay?

Now, how do we treat these people? I sent down yesterday for the menu from Guantanamo, so that the average American could understand how we’re brutalizing people in Guantanamo, and I’ve got it right here. For Sunday they’re going to be having — let me see — orange-glazed chicken, fresh fruit groupe, steamed peas and mushrooms, rice pilaf, another form of torture for the hijackers. We treat them very well.

Warning to Rep. Hunter: Denial leaves a bitter aftertaste.



136 Responses to “Rep. Hunter’s Denial Diet”

  1. marty says:

    Don’t forget the music – Christina Aguilera. Apparently, the guards were not that serious or they would have played Ashley Simpson


  2. Susan says:

    Are all Republicans sicko’s?
    I know dumb question..


  3. MeToo says:

    Evidently Hunter is name of the WHine they’re serving too.


  4. Johnny American says:

    The Marines stripped prisoners?!! Better than torturing them like Saddam did. All you anti-american dipshits ought to be thrown in Abu Graib when Saddam was under control.


  5. Auntie American says:

    Why would Saddam imprison “anti-American” Americans? I don’t get it, Johnny American. Poor Sean Penn must have had a terrible time there. Maybe he wasn’t “anti-american” enough.

    You do know that the marines seem to attract the most closeted gays, don’t you?


  6. Susan says:

    Hey Johnny,
    If you have been up on things you’d understand that stripping detainees is not all that goes on in our military detention centers.
    And maybe you have forgotten the law of OUR land, INNOCENT UNTIL PROVEN GUILTY BY A COURT OF LAW.
    A REAL American does not stoop to Saddam’s level.
    Remember, we are not third world barbarians.
    But if you agree with it, join the military and have a good time.
    But remember, when the Human Rights groups want justice, don’t expect your superiors to be there for you..
    You get to go it alone like Lindy,


  7. tonya says:

    i think BUSH needs to help some of his own people right here in the states before helping others ,he needs to remember that they can’t vote for him ,but we can vote him out .we have people right in his same city without food and he feels the need to go over seas first . I want to now what he’s smoking ,because he needs to share with the rest of us .


  8. James says:

    http://www.crooksandliars.com/2005/06/12.html#a3409
    here’s the video clip of HUnter and the geat eatings at Gitmo


  9. Seneca says:

    I viewed the video at C&L. I am disturbed that we are feeding the hijackers such excellent fare. It seems such a waste to feed dead people. Or did hunter let it slip that the “hijackers” are actually being held there?


  10. Dick Tuck says:

    How stupid is Hunter? They’re not feeding hijackers at Gitmo. Last time I noticed, all the hijackers were dead.


  11. Debra McDaniel says:

    Yeah wake up. The highjackers are dead. Who cares what they’re fed at Gitmo anyway. That wasn’t in any of the complaints about their treatment. But Bonehead Hunter’s even bringing up the menu while ignoring the real problem and refering to the prisoners as highjackers tells me that this administration is living in an alternate universe. They don’t and won’t get it because they are all rich white conservative elitists who haven’t got a clue.


  12. david says:

    The stuff about the menu was a cynical attempt to distract people from the facts. The point is that the people being held at Guantanamo are being denied their rights to a trial by a jury of their peers.

    They’d never dare to do that to US citizens, would they????


  13. t0m says:

    How hard can it be to get a conviction? Were you captured fighting for the Taliban? Yes? Then you’re guilty. Need a witness? Then bring the soldier who captured him. After all, Bush said we won the war in Iraq over two years ago, so those soldiers must have a lot of free time on their hands now.

    How incompetent do you have to be to not be able to convict blatant terrorists? Oh, right.


  14. Bill Floyd says:

    Menu’s don’t mean a thing. For 3 months on active duty our dining facility fed us ham 2 times a day until the food services officer and NCOIC were caught selling the food to locals, we were supposed to get.


  15. Jim Allen says:

    The problem with “abuse” is not that it violates “rules of war” but that it doesn’t work.
    By definition, and almost as a job requirement, the soldiers manning Gitmo are thugs. What the commanders fail to realize is that the detainees are USED to rotten treatment, since that is how they treat their prisoners (or worse).
    The only thing that will work is controlled reverse-psychology. Get them fat and comfortable and they will not want to fight.
    (And I am serious.)


  16. Princeton Progressive Review says:

    As If an Apple Made Up for Torture
    The latest attempt by the right-wing apologists to justify torture has been to point out what the Guantanamo detainees get to eat. That’s what Congressman Duncan Hunter tried to do recently on Fox News when he tried to justify the…


  17. David F Mishiwiec Sr says:

    This independant, moderate voter cannot beleive what Hunter did and said to justify the mistreatment of prisoners at Gitmo. As a constituent of his I have written him many times and his responses are often trite and condenscending. I am distessed by the fact that those who attacked us on 9-11 seem to have won by making us change our core philosophies. We now have less freedom and liberty since the attacks and argue against the principles of the various Geneva Conventions. Dick Durbin’s comment is now being taken totally out of context thanks to our media with ADD. If you read, or saw the speech iteself, about the specific prisoner mistreatment to which Durbin was referring you certainly would think it was that which took place under Hitler, Stalin or the Khmer Rouge if you didn’t know where or when the mistreatment took place. After all, we pride ourselves as being a nation of laws and better than the rest of the world for our rights of due process and equal protection.


  18. Otto J Hunt says:

    Torture is NOT American, nor is denial of such. Please be more truthful with your constuents.


  19. San DiegoPatriot says:

    ITs funny how Duncan Hunter talks about the Detainees to have such a delicious dinner after a grueling day of torture. I wonder if that is what wife beaters say after they beat their wife? ” I know i beat you but look at what i provide for you”. These so called Republicans have serious Pyscological problems to believe this behavior could ever be acceptable.


  20. fake but accurate says:

    What I Saw at Gitmo
    By Lt. Col. Gordon Cucullu
    FrontPageMagazine.com | June 27, 2005

    Last week, I was privileged to be part of a Department of Defense trip to the Joint Task Force – Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. I got to see the operations of this “controversialâ€? facility up-close – something particularly important after Sen. Richard Durbin’s comparison of its guard to Nazi stormtroopers and calls of leftists to shut the center down. Our group went to GITMO to check out tales that the military was being too tough on these terrorist detainees. We left convinced that America is being extraordinarily lenient – far too lenient.

    After speaking with soldiers, sailors, and civilians who collectively staff Gitmo, I left convinced that abuse definitely exists at the detention facilities, and it typically fails to receive the press attention it deserves: it’s the relentless, merciless attacks on American servicemen and women by these terrorist thugs. Many of the orange jumpsuit-clad detainees fight their captors at every opportunity, openly bragging of their desire to kill Americans. One has promised that, if released, he would find MPs in their homes through the internet, break into their houses at night, and “cut the throats of them and their families like sheep.� Others claim authority and vindication to kill women, children, and other innocents who oppose their jihadist mission authorized by the Koran (the same one that hangs in every cell from a specially-designed holder intended to protect it from a touching the cell floor – all provided at U.S. taxpayer expense). One detainee was heard to tell another: “One day I will enjoy sucking American blood, although their blood is bitter, undrinkable….� These recalcitrant detainees are known euphemistically as being “non-compliant.� They attack guards whenever the soldiers enter their cells, trying to reach up under protective facemasks to gouge eyes and tear mouths. They make weapons and try to stab the guards or grab and break limbs as the guards pass them food.

    We dined with the soldiers, toured several of the individual holding camps, observed interrogations, and inspected cells. We were impressed by the universally high quality of the cadre and the facilities. While it may not be exactly “Club GITMO,� as Rush Limbaugh uses to tweak the hard-Left critics who haven’t a clue about reality here, GITMO is a far cry from the harshness experienced even by maximum security prisoners in the U.S.

    Meals for detainees are ample: we lunched on what several thought was an accumulated single day’s ration for detainees. “No,� the contract food service manager said with a laugh, “what you’re looking at there is today’s lunch. A single meal. They get three a day like that.� The vegetables, pita bread, and other well-prepared food filled two of the large Styrofoam take-home containers we see in restaurants. Several prisoners have special meal orders like “no tomatoes� or “no peanut products� depending on taste or allergies. “One prisoner,� General Hood said, “throws back his food tray if it contains things he has specifically said he doesn’t want.� How is he punished for this outrageous behavior? His tray is numbered, the food he requested is put on it, and the corrected “order� is delivered to his cell.

    The detainees are similarly catered to medically. Almost every one arrived at GITMO with some sort of battlefield trauma. After all, the majority were captured in combat. Today they are healthy, immunized, and well cared for. At a visit to the modern hospital facility – dedicated solely to the detainees and comparable to a well-equipped and staffed small-town hospital with operating, dental, routine facilities – the doctor in charge confirmed that the caloric count for the detainees was so high that while “most detainees arrived undernourished,� medics now watch for issues stemming from high cholesterol and being overweight. Each of approximately 520 terrorists currently held in confinement averages about four medical visits monthly, something one would expect from only a dedicated American hypochondriac. Welcome to the rigors of detention under American supervision.

    Of the estimated 70,000 battlefield captures that were made in Afghanistan, only a tiny percentage, something on the order of 800-plus, were eventually evacuated to GITMO. These were the worst of the worst. More than 200 have been released back to their home country – if the U.S. is assured that the detainees would not be tortured by local authorities upon return. These men were freed because they were deemed by ongoing official military review processes to no longer pose a threat, or to possess no useful intelligence. And this process has proven too generous at times: more than 10 released GITMO detainees have been killed or recaptured fighting Americans or have been identified as resuming terrorist activities. Still, the process is up and running for review of cases, and if a Washington DC circuit court approves a government appeal, the system for military tribunals will get started. All mechanisms are in place and ready to go as soon as DoD gets a green light.

    There is a good reason these unlawful combatants are being confined. They are evil and dangerous individuals. Yet these thugs are treated with an amazing degree of compassion: They are given ice cream treats and recreational time. They live in clean facilities, and receive a full Muslim religious package of Koran, prayer rug, beads, and prayer oils. An arrow in every cell points to Mecca. The call to prayer is played five times daily. They are not abused, hanged, tortured, beheaded, raped, mutilated, or in any way treated the way that they once treated their own captives – or now treat their guards.

    Some questioned whether it were wise to give these radical Islamic fundamentalists the religious supplies that ended up landing them in Gitmo in the first place. “Giving them the Koran is simply something that we think we ought to do as a humane gesture,� said second-in-command Brigadier General Gong. “We’re Americans. That’s how we operate.�

    When we challenged military authorities about the seemingly plush environs these would-be murderers receive, the commanding officers stated this was the most productive course. JTF-GITMO commanding officer Brigadier General Jay Hood radiated confidence and determination when fielding challenges from our group about his overly lenient treatment. “It works,� he says simply. “We do not allow torture or mistreatment, period.� How to they guarantee this? By rigorous, on-going training and constant oversight up and down the supervisory chain. As proof that “establishing rapport� with the detainees is far more effective than coercive techniques, General Hood refers skeptics to the massive amount of usable intelligence information JTF-GITMO continues to produce even three years into the program.

    You are right to worry about inhumane treatment taking place at GITMO. But your concern should be for the dedicated, well-trained, highly professional American men and women who are subjected to a daily barrage of feces, urine, semen, and spit hurled at them along with vile invective as they implement a humane, enlightened system of confinement on men who want nothing more than to kill Americans. These quiet professional Americans, who live under the motto “Honor Bound for Defense of Freedom,� deserve our utmost respect and concern. Shame on anyone who slanders or disrespects them for short-term and short-sighted political advantage.
    ——————————————————————————–
    Lt. Col. Gordon Cucullu has been an Army Green Beret lieutenant colonel, as well as a writer, popular speaker, business executive and farmer. His most recent book is Separated at Birth, about North and South Korea.


  21. bonus says:

    You may find it interesting to visit the pages in the field of… Thanks!!!


  22. game says:

    Please check the pages about- Tons of interesdting stuff!!!


  23. tip says:

    Take your time to take a look at some information about… Thanks!!!


  24. games says:

    Take your time to check out some helpful info dedicated to…


  25. free game keno king says:

    free game keno king

    Please visit some relevant pages on download free keno


  26. game says:

    In your free time, take a look at some relevant information in the field of…


  27. bonus says:

    You may find it interesting to visit some relevant pages dedicated to- Tons of interesdting stuff!!!


  28. dollar pound exchange rate says:

    dollar pound exchange rate

    Take your time to visit some helpful info dedicated to currency exchanges


  29. pound dollar exchange rate says:

    pound dollar exchange rate

    Please visit the pages dedicated to forex professional system trading


  30. plump teens says:

    plump teens

    In your free time, take a look at some information dedicated to hot preteens korean girls


  31. capital one says:

    capital one

    You may find it interesting to take a look at some helpful info about auto loans auto loans


  32. Buy carisprodol says:

    Buy carisprodol

    Wooow! awesome! Write some more!


  33. teen says:

    springier amok Trevelyan igloo innocuousness twisters stringently relates Faust



  34. hoodia cactus supplements says:

    hoodia cactus supplements

    dodger amoral snores Whiteley causing mascara riot blushes acetone didrex http://www.real-estate-shop.com/didrex.html




  35. lightspeed girls dirty girls says:

    frontage agglutinating fang Lehigh drafty cupful inefficiency slacker


  36. Bob Coakley says:

    Hello there, I just wanted to say hello and to thank you for your great website. I really enjoyed looking through it! The set of seminars, conferences, and articles is sacred, but I did not see good sites. Your site became the real find for me. I can find all I need at your site. Keep in touch, your site is worth to visit it!


  37. Tom McNamara says:

    Great site, I added it to my bookmarks I just surfed around and found your site, I really enjoyed the visit and hope to come back soon. I wish you a huge success in further work. Greetings… Tom McNamara %e-mail%


  38. Marti Payne says:

    Ooroo, I am Marti Payne and I am pleasantly surprised ;) Greetings to you for what you’ve done with your site So long, it is possible to hang at such a site all the days long


  39. Bingo says:

    Bingo

    Bingo


  40. Free bingo Websites says:

    Free bingo Websites

    Free bingo Websites


  41. Gala Bingo Sharon says:

    Gala Bingo Sharon

    Gala Bingo Sharon


  42. Watch says:

    Watch

    Watch


  43. Nobody says:

    WHAT’S WITH ALL OF THE SPAM LINKS HERE? Why hasn’t someone deleted all of the spam (comments 21-70).


  44. Itsamobiles says:

    Best contract phone deals

    some of the greates contract phone deals for anyone to find, jim says that your blog has great deals


  45. takeabreak bingo says:

    takeabreak bingo

    takeabreak bingo


  46. takeabreak bingo says:

    takeabreak bingo

    takeabreak bingo


  47. spain holiday says:

    spain holiday

    spain holiday


  48. lanzarote holiday says:

    lanzarote holiday

    lanzarote holiday


  49. cheap caribbean says:

    cheap caribbean

    cheap caribbean


  50. majorca holiday says:

    majorca holiday

    majorca holiday


  51. tenerife holiday says:

    tenerife holiday

    tenerife holiday


  52. holiday caribbean says:

    holiday caribbean

    holiday caribbean


  53. jamaica holiday says:

    jamaica holiday

    jamaica holiday


  54. caribbean vacation package says:

    caribbean vacation package

    caribbean vacation package


  55. ibiza holiday says:

    ibiza holiday

    ibiza holiday


  56. 2008 cheap holiday says:

    2008 cheap holiday

    2008 cheap holiday


  57. mallorca holiday says:

    mallorca holiday

    mallorca holiday


  58. florida holiday says:

    florida holiday

    florida holiday


  59. 2004 cyprus holiday villa says:

    2004 cyprus holiday villa

    2004 cyprus holiday villa


  60. barbados holiday says:

    barbados holiday

    barbados holiday


  61. 100pp package holidays greece says:

    100pp package holidays greece

    100pp package holidays greece


  62. benidorm holiday says:

    benidorm holiday

    benidorm holiday


  63. ski holiday says:

    ski holiday

    ski holiday


  64. rhodes holiday says:

    rhodes holiday

    rhodes holiday


  65. holiday deal says:

    holiday deal

    holiday deal


  66. zante holiday says:

    zante holiday

    zante holiday


  67. Contract Phone Deals says:

    Contract Phone Deals

    Contract Phone Deals


  68. Contract Phone Deals says:

    Contract Phone Deals

    Contract Phone Deals


  69. free bingo caller says:

    free bingo caller

    free bingo caller


  70. liverpool daily bingo says:

    liverpool daily bingo

    liverpool daily bingo


  71. party bingocom says:

    party bingocom

    party bingocom


  72. liverpool daily bingo says:

    liverpool daily bingo

    liverpool daily bingo


  73. ga bingo says:

    ga bingo

    ga bingo


  74. ga bingo says:

    ga bingo

    ga bingo


  75. takeaway mecca bingo 468x60 says:

    takeaway mecca bingo 468×60

    takeaway mecca bingo 468×60


  76. takeaway mecca bingo 468x60 says:

    takeaway mecca bingo 468×60

    takeaway mecca bingo 468×60


  77. holiday florida says:

    holiday florida

    holiday florida


  78. mallorca holidays says:

    mallorca holidays

    mallorca holidays


  79. holiday tenerife says:

    holiday tenerife

    holiday tenerife


  80. caribbean holiday says:

    caribbean holiday

    caribbean holiday


  81. holidays majorca spain says:

    holidays majorca spain

    holidays majorca spain


  82. benidorm holidays says:

    benidorm holidays

    benidorm holidays


  83. holiday spain says:

    holiday spain

    holiday spain


  84. 2005 cyprus holiday says:

    2005 cyprus holiday

    2005 cyprus holiday


  85. 2007 holidays greece says:

    2007 holidays greece

    2007 holidays greece


  86. cheap royal caribbean cruise says:

    cheap royal caribbean cruise

    cheap royal caribbean cruise


  87. holiday ibiza says:

    holiday ibiza

    holiday ibiza


  88. lanzarote holidays says:

    lanzarote holidays

    lanzarote holidays


  89. abroad cheap christmas holiday says:

    abroad cheap christmas holiday

    abroad cheap christmas holiday


  90. holiday barbados says:

    holiday barbados

    holiday barbados


  91. caribbean package vacation says:

    caribbean package vacation

    caribbean package vacation


  92. jamaica package holidays says:

    jamaica package holidays

    jamaica package holidays


  93. late holiday deal says:

    late holiday deal

    late holiday deal


  94. cheap ski holidays says:

    cheap ski holidays

    cheap ski holidays


  95. rhodes holidays says:

    rhodes holidays

    rhodes holidays


  96. zante holidays says:

    zante holidays

    zante holidays


  97. Samsung Mobile Phones says:

    Samsung Mobile Phones

    Samsung Mobile Phones


  98. Samsung Mobile Phones says:

    Samsung Mobile Phones

    Samsung Mobile Phones


  99. Samsung Mobile Phones says:

    Samsung Mobile Phones

    Samsung Mobile Phones


  100. Samsung Mobile Phones says:

    Samsung Mobile Phones

    Samsung Mobile Phones


  101. Samsung Mobile Phones says:

    Samsung Mobile Phones

    Samsung Mobile Phones


  102. Samsung Mobile Phones says:

    Samsung Mobile Phones

    Samsung Mobile Phones


  103. free sign money play bingo no deposit says:

    free sign money play bingo no deposit

    free sign money play bingo no deposit


  104. party bingocouk says:

    party bingocouk

    party bingocouk


  105. bingo bonus money register cards det says:

    bingo bonus money register cards det

    bingo bonus money register cards det


  106. bingo hall bingo halls says:

    bingo hall bingo halls

    bingo hall bingo halls


  107. free internet bingo says:

    free internet bingo

    free internet bingo


  108. 10 free bingo says:

    10 free bingo

    10 free bingo


  109. bingo picture play says:

    bingo picture play

    bingo picture play


  110. free internet bingo says:

    free internet bingo

    free internet bingo


  111. gagla bingo says:

    gagla bingo

    gagla bingo


  112. free bingo calling software says:

    free bingo calling software

    free bingo calling software


  113. liverpool echo bingo says:

    liverpool echo bingo

    liverpool echo bingo


  114. casino bingo black jack poker says:

    casino bingo black jack poker

    casino bingo black jack poker


  115. bingo cash free play prize real says:

    bingo cash free play prize real

    bingo cash free play prize real


  116. bingo flash games says:

    bingo flash games

    bingo flash games


  117. bingo flash games says:

    bingo flash games

    bingo flash games


  118. cheap holidays barbados says:

    cheap holidays barbados

    cheap holidays barbados


  119. holidays tenerife canary islands says:

    holidays tenerife canary islands

    holidays tenerife canary islands


  120. spain holidays says:

    spain holidays

    spain holidays


  121. holidays lanzarote canary islands says:

    holidays lanzarote canary islands

    holidays lanzarote canary islands


  122. 4x4 holidays greece says:

    4×4 holidays greece

    4×4 holidays greece


  123. cheap holiday ibiza says:

    cheap holiday ibiza

    cheap holiday ibiza


  124. last minute caribbean holiday says:

    last minute caribbean holiday

    last minute caribbean holiday


  125. holiday majorca says:

    holiday majorca

    holiday majorca


  126. tea rooms bingo says:

    tea rooms bingo

    tea rooms bingo


  127. holidays mallorca spain says:

    holidays mallorca spain

    holidays mallorca spain


  128. tea rooms bingo says:

    tea rooms bingo

    tea rooms bingo


  129. abroad cheap holiday says:

    abroad cheap holiday

    abroad cheap holiday


  130. 5 day holiday cyprus says:

    5 day holiday cyprus

    5 day holiday cyprus


  131. florida holiday villa says:

    florida holiday villa

    florida holiday villa


  132. holidays benidorm says:

    holidays benidorm

    holidays benidorm


  133. cheap caribbean cruise says:

    cheap caribbean cruise

    cheap caribbean cruise



Jump to Top

About Think Progress | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2009 Center for American Progress Action Fund
View Most Popular

Advertisement

What We're About

Featured

image
Subscribe to the Progress Report



imageTopic Cloud


Visit Our Affiliated Sites

image image
Reports


Got a hot tip?
Have a hot news tip? We'd love to hear from you. Use the form below to send us the latest.

Name:
Email:
Tip:
(required)


imageArchives


imageBlog Roll