Think Progress

ThinkFast: September 9, 2006 — Path to 911 Edition


Path to 9/11 graphic“Official True Story.” How Path to 9/11 is being marketed in Europe. The commerical also features the scene slandering Sandy Berger.

Widowed husband of Disney executive killed on 9/11 writes to ABC’s Iger: I “urge you not to air this film.” TPMCafe has the full text.

Another example of Path to 911 contradicting the 9/11 Commission Report. Americablog notes that the film wrongly points the finger at American Airlines.

Video of a Path to 9/11 protest outside of Disney headquarters.

The Washington Post’s Tom Shales has a review: “Factually shaky, politically inflammatory and photographically a mess, The Path to 9/11…has something not just to offend everyone but also to depress them.”



68 Responses to “ThinkFast: September 9, 2006 — Path to 911 Edition”

  1. Alan says:

    I am beginning to wonder if this perfidy by ABC is actually turning out to be a good thing for the reality based community.

    People you would have never heard from are getting quoted in places. The target market for the film will hear controversy that at one time they had no clue over. Is it possible that when the dust settles that more people will understand what truly happened than there were last month?


  2. Jane E. Schneider says:

    Hey, TP, what just happened? A moment ago, there were two posts, and after each of them, where the time of the posting is shown, there was a link(?) that said “Edit this”

    Now comment #2 is gone (I’m assuming because of its content, which was on a subject that you frown on), and the “edit this” is gone. I’m confused (but that’s my normal state anyway:-).


  3. Jane E. Schneider says:

    Hey, Trueblue, I don’t know what’s going on, but it’s definitely weird. I had also just posted a comment on this thread, and I don’t see it here.

    I have to run, but I’ll try to check in tomorrow to see what comments end up staying posted.


  4. gk says:

    While we boycott Disney and it’s entertainment divisions, let’s not forget about the actors who agreed to participate in this “slander festival”. Harvey Keitel and the others will hopefully be put in the position of never again working on a major project.


  5. fs says:

    Isn’t Disney the one who wanted to turn Gettysburg into a theme park?


  6. Your New Chinese Overlords says:

    Sharia law will rule America and the call to prayer will be heard everywhere. Thanks to Leftists like you!

    Comment by Red Wolf —

    No, CHINESE law will rule the land! And for your convienience, you will live in brand new barracks, donated by the People’s Revolutionary Re-education Council. But don’t let me dissuade you from your fantasies, they are very useful.


  7. the fly-man says:

    Are there any questions people have regarding 911 that they are waiting to see how the film adress them, other than the previously mentioned situations regarding the Clinton administration?


  8. libra says:

    I wonder where the guy who wrote about the airline screw-up got his preview disc from and why he got it


  9. Hit Escape says:

    Harvey Keitel, you used to be one of my favorite actors, but not any more! If you’re in it, I’m not watching it. Too little, too late sucker.


  10. the fly-man says:

    I think it’s a little unfair to blame Harvey Keitel for doing his job. Reservoir Dogs was a brutal movie but he was awesome. Does anyone remember the cast of ConAir? That was the biggest waste of Hollywood talent that I can think of in recent memory.


  11. Cathy Weselby says:

    Boycott every single company that advertises on this program. That will send a message! It’s what the Christian Right has been doing for years. Let’s make them hurt where they’ll feel it–on the bottom line.


  12. ann says:

    How long until Ann Coulter smears John Beug?


  13. gk says:

    It’s not a question of appearing in a bad movie, it’s appearing in a piece of propoganda and he read the script and obviously agreed with enough of it to sign up. Now if someone had re-editied the entire movie and changed the context I could possibly excuse Harvey and the others, but this script had all of the trappings of a Leni Riefenstahl film.

    “Doing his job”, doesn’t cut it….he had a choice to do the film….he wasn’t being forced at gunpoint.


  14. gk says:

    Harvey didn’t have to appear in this….he read the script and agreed to appear in this Leni Riefenstahl like film. It’s not like he was forced at gunpoint and he should pay for his decision.


  15. budpaul says:

    I’m watching the Ohio State/Texas football game on ABC right now, and as far as I can tell, they have not run a single promo for the hatchet job. Nothing. And this is one of the bigger games to be televised on the schedule this year so there are a lot of eyes watching this game. For them to not promo the heck out of it leads me to believe that it’s going to be pulled.
    America’s Least Wanted


  16. p.lukasiak says:

    Harvey didn’t have to appear in this….he read the script and agreed to appear in this Leni Riefenstahl like film. It’s not like he was forced at gunpoint and he should pay for his decision.

    this assumes that Keitel was fully aware of the distortions and lies in the script — and there is no reason to make that asssumption. When a actor reads a script, he’s primarily looking at the character(s) that he is/might be asked to portray. So when Keitel is handed a script in which he plays the hard-as-nails hero, and is told that its based on the 9-11 Commission report, he’s going to assume that the show is true. Now that he knows that its not true, he has spoken out about it (unlike every other actor associated with the project so far.)

    so give Keitel a break…


  17. Marie says:

  18. GSD says:

    Triumph of the Shills.

    The Bush/Coulter Republican Party is pulling out all of the smear and fear stops in order to prevent the most corrupt regime in US from getting the congressional scrutiny they have avoided for 6 years.

    6 years into the Bush regime and we are still only getting the lens of examination on Clinton….

    The Republican Party is the Police State Party. Check out Zogby’s polling on police state conduct and see how the Republican right wing agree with all of the tools used by authoritarian and police state regimes.

    Heil Mickey!

    -GSD


  19. the fly-man says:

    I haven’t seen any of the 911 film but from what I’ve read about it’s delivery, not the content, I think it would not be fair to compare it to a Leni Riefenstahl. Especially 1938 Olympia: Fest der Volker und Fest der Schonheit.


  20. Marie says:

    I don’t think people around the world think too highly of GW so I am not overly concerned about what propaganda is being marketed there — I think the populations of the rest of the world are more skeptical than we are, and they realized early on that Bush is unfit for the presidency.

    As for the domestic propaganda scheduled by ABC, in addition to the slander and distorted version of history, I see a hyporcisy that I haven’t seen mentioned yet:
    Just this week, when the Senate reported there was NO connection between Hussein and Al Qaeda, the White House and friends replied, So what is new? This is old news. We have to deal with what we have now. And they dismissed it out of hand.
    With this movie, the rightwingers are taking an opposite tack and are eager to place blame on the Clinton administration for something that occurred on Bush’s watch. In this case, they are not willing to dismiss it out of hand as “old news,” as they overlook Bush’s multiple warnings.

    As the rightwingers like to boast of not sustaining another attack on American soil in 5 years – they fail to note that there had not been an attack on American soil between 1993 and 2001. They not only fail to note that Clinton did not blame Bush #1 for the first WTC bombing, the perpetrators were hunted down, tried and imprisoned.

    Finally are they so afraid that when Bush leaves office in January, 2009, there may be a movie based on all the faults and fallacies of the Bush administration? They won’t be able to prevent it; not if this movie goes through as it appears.


  21. cynicalgirl says:

    #3, Alan, I agree. As I stated before, this movie is a perfect example of how the only way Republicans can win elections is by lying. And the wingnuts can no longer claim there is a liberal media.


  22. Marie says:

    Cheney appeared today at a $2500/head fundraiser where he was met by many protestors.
    The gist of his 20 minutes speech was reported as, “he said we need to stay the course.”
    I guess he didn’t get the latest RNC message, denying that they use that phrase.


  23. Marie says:

    Washington Post – Sunday
    The Republiscum will spend $45 million in the next 2 months on personal attack ads.

    “Republicans are planning to spend the vast majority of their sizable financial war chest over the final 60 days of the campaign attacking Democratic House and Senate candidates over personal issues and local controversies, GOP officials said…
    “The National Republican Congressional Committee, which this year dispatched a half-dozen operatives to comb through tax, court and other records looking for damaging information on Democratic candidates, plans to spend more than 90 percent of its $50 million-plus advertising budget on …negative ads,” the article continues.


  24. GSD says:

    Rove and Ken Mehlman are about to pry the lid off of the cesspool and deluge the country in the biggest pile of trash and filth in history of America.

    They would rather destroy the nation than lose. It was called a “scorched earth policy” by warriors of the past.

    Now they are planning on sowing the fields with salt.

    The Bush/Cheney adminstration is about to pull out all of the stops and ruin dozens of lives. The nation is going to be swiftboated. The final battle for the soul America is beginning.

    The Empire Strikes Back.

    -GSD


  25. Bullsmith says:

    Oh but they will claim there is a liberal media.

    These are the people who can tell you with a straight face that Iraq is simply going through the birthing pangs of democracy.

    The seed was planted by the U.S, apparently against the wishes of the mother. The father says “She was asking for it. She was wearing a Wickedlly Mean Dress.”


  26. Mary Malloy says:

    George Orwell is standing up in his prophetic grave right now.


  27. Dave von Ebers says:

    Mary Malloy, I’ll bet you’re right about George Orwell.

    Funny thing is, Orwell went to Spain and actually fought against the fascists. (By the way, “Homage to Catalonia” is a great book, detailing his experiences during the Spanish Civil War.) So, not only was he smarter than Bush, he had real live combat experience – against real live fascists no less. That’s two things Bush knows nothing about …


  28. JD says:

    Tell Our Elected Representatives Whose Salaries We Pay To Do Their Job And To Stop Trying To Distract Us And To Pander To The Religious Right On Stem Cells, “Protecting” Marriage, and Internet Gambling

    The American public entrusted the President and our Elected Representatives to guard our safety and welfare on an economic, political and military level. We deserve more than petty distractions, pandering and hypocrisy.

    Here are the issues that our Elected Officials should be addressing.

    1. The War In Iraq That Our President Led Us Into. It’s a mess largely because we didn’t have any plan to keep the peace. And ask 20 people why we went in and you will get 20 different answers. And the Bush Republicans charge that anyone who dares question the war is unpatriotic. They have forgotten their principles accordingly to their own Great President Teddy Roosevelt, who said correctly even during World War I: “To announce that there must be no criticism of the President, or that we are to stand by the President, right or wrong, is not only unpatriotic and servile, but is morally treasonable to the American public.”

    2. The War On Terrorism. It’s taken longer than it took us to win World War II to still not apprehend the man behind no less than America’s modern day Pearl Harbor. On the one hand we hear the President boast he is going to get bin Ladin “dead or alive” and on the other afterwards we hear the President say that, astonishingly, he doesn’t really think about bin Ladin much. What’s more we had a good chance to apprehend bin Ladin and his then ragtag al Qaeda crew when they were on the ropes holed up in caves in Tora Bora, Afghanistan after we overthrew the Taliban there. And yet our military did nothing to block their escape, which included prolonged nightly airlifts and traversing a key mountain pass on the ground over a period of several weeks. Now bin Ladin and al Qaeda are apparently welcome by our “ally” Pakistan. Pakistan recently declared bin Ladin and al Qaeda were welcome to stay as long as they “remain peaceful” (though Pakistan retracted this comment to its English speaking audience but not its Pakistani audience after it became too embarrassing). This past July Fourth the New York Times reported that the Administration dismantled the CIA unit whose sole mission was to apprehend bin Ladin. Where is the focus?

    3. North Korea’s Skyrocketing Number of Nuclear Weapons and Program to Develop Intercontinental Ballistic Missiles. Under Bush, NK have quadrupled their arsenal and now have upwards of 5 nukes. This past Fourth of July they gave us quite a fireworks display by lobbing a test intercontinental ballistic missile in our direction.

    4. Immigration. Our President declared this was an urgent issue, yet he has completely failed to lead his party, which controls both the Senate and the House, to do anything on the issue other than squabble.

    5. Out of control budget deficits. Whatever happened to the so-called fiscal responsibility of the Republican Party? Bush has racked up more debt than every single President in American History before him combined. We have no rainy day fund for the next natural or manmade disaster or economic recession, or for the Social Security economic disaster that Bush keeps predicting but fails to do anything about.

    6. Out of control trade deficits. The hundreds of billions in record trade deficits each year are really hurting us. We hear the giant sucking sound of our manufacturing jobs to China and IT and business process outsourcing to India. Our middle and lower classes have not shared any of the gains of our so-called economic recovery, despite the fact that their productivity has shot way up recently. In other words, they provide more value but are being squeezed.

    7. The Environment and Global Warming. Our Earth’s temperatures have skyrocketed to historic highs over recent years. Gas prices have skyrocketed too. Yet once again our government just stands there like a deer in headlights. They have no plan on this just as they have no plan on anything else. Bush declares we are addicted to oil and then does nothing about it. Just like he declared immigration and Social Security were crises facing America and did nothing about them either. And the Bush Republicans always find someone else to blame for their own failure to lead.

    8. Widespread incompetence and corruption in government. Just think of Bush saying “heck of a job Brownie.” Like we couldn’t see that one coming. FEMA head Michael Brown was a crony hack whose only non-qualification to lead our Federal Emergency Management Agency was getting fired from the International Arabian Horse Association. And think Abramoff, Delay and K-Street. What is up with the Republicans and corruption? Just look at all of the Republican Presidents since Nixon who either (1) resigned in disgrace in the face of imminent impeachment and conviction, and Nixon was pardoned by Ford before he could be tried (no American President other than Nixon resigned in the face of imminent impeachment and conviction in the Senate), (2) have senior officials in their Administration convicted of felonies (Reagan – a record 29, Bush II – his chief Procurement Officer and counting . . .), or (3) pardon under controversial circumstances a President (Ford pardons Nixon) who resigned in disgrace or pardon convicted Administration officials (Bush I pardons 6 including Cap Weinberger) whose trial stands to reveal their own wrongdoing. During this same period no Democratic President or anyone in his Administration was convicted of any wrongdoing, despite politically attacks and in once case impeachment over a petty sex scandal by Republicans controlling the House of Representatives.

    What have the Republicans done to advance the ball on the above major issues facing the Nation. Nothing. Instead we have distraction and pandering.

    First it’s “saving” stem cells destined for the trash bin from life-saving research, which an overwhelming majority of Americans disagree with.

    Then it’s protecting marriage, even though Republican Red States have twice the divorce rate as Blue States (maybe they should start treating marriage decently in their home states first).

    And now, from Republican Senator Bill Frist — the man who incorrectly diagnosed Terry Schiavo by watching her videotape and despite the fact that he’s not a neurologist — it’s . . . stopping Internet gambling? This is despite that polls show Americans overwhelmingly want Internet gambling legalized and regulated like all the other legal gambling in America. Atta way Fristy and cronies.

    And who is this morally righteous, crusading Senator and “Doctor” Bill Frist to take the high ground in disagreeing with America on Internet gambling? Who is this man who declared of Bill Clinton’s efforts to conceal an illicit sexual liaison “I will have no part in the creation of a constitutional double-standard to benefit the president”? Turns out Frist himself is a first-hand expert on real illegal transactions – as opposed to ones he wants to criminalize — and his effort to go after Internet gambling is just another example of the man’s chronic hypocrisy, dishonesty and political pandering:

    1. Frist is under investigation for insider trading. Frist is worth somewhere north of a cool $15 million. To pad his well-lined pockets even more, Frist recently ordered what was supposed to be a “blind trust” to sell a large portion of his family’s HCA stock right before bad news was released that depressed the price of the stock. What a coincidence! Was he tipped? The investigation into this extremely serious matter by the SEC and other authorities continues . . .

    2. While in medical school, Frist obtained cats from animal shelters, under pretense of adoption as pets, for school research experiments in which he killed the animals. In a 1989 autobiography, Frist described how he “spent days and nights on end in the lab, taking the hearts out of cats, dissecting each heart.” After some time, Frist said “[I] lost my supply of cats,” so he chose to deceive animal shelters, an act which he described as “heinous and dishonest.” He attributed his behavior to the pressures of school. The incident sparked controversy after a 2002 Boston Globe story repeated the account.

    3. Frist’s 2000 campaign organization was fined by the Federal Election Commission for failing to disclose a $1.44 million loan taken out jointly with the 1994 campaign organization.

    4. In September 2005, the group Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington named Frist as one of the thirteen most “corrupt” members of Congress, and filed a complaint with the Senate Ethics Committee calling for an investigation of the stock sale, an alleged cover-up, and an allegedly mishandled disclosure of a campaign loan.

    See all these facts at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Frist

    And as a footnote, while Fristy tries to pass dubious new Internet gaming laws, the World Trade Organization has ruled that the United States is in blatant violation of its rules because the WTO does not treat international horse racing companies equally as US horse race betting companies.

    http://www.casinogamblingweb.com/gambling-news/gamblinglaw/us_senate_faces_internet_gambling_bill_upon_reconvening_7965.html
    http://rose.casinocitytimes.com/articles/29077.html
    http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/3032608/
    http://thinkprogress.org/index.php?p=1106
    http://www.laweekly.com/news/news/the-bad-doctor/3253/
    http://www.kxmc.com/getARticle.asp?ArticleId=42112

    Maybe Frist is also trying to save the incumbent Senator from Arizona, Jon Kyl, from getting unseated this Fall. Kyl, a long-time uninspiring Bush drone who receives massive backing from corporate interests, has been on an unsuccessful personal mission against Internet gambling for over a decade. Every year he says the sky is about to fall because of Internet gambling, and every year it doesn’t. And to the well-intentioned liberals on this board who know of someone who went overboard with Internet gambling, I wonder how those stats compare to students who kill themselves and others by driving drunk, or people who kill themselves from smoking, or from eating to the point of unhealthy obesity, or whatever. We cannot ban everything. Prohibition doesn’t work. We need to come up with reasonable regulations. Even Barney Frank has said this of trying to ban Internet gambling – it’s kind of a joke. And a bad one at that because of the serious other problems facing our Nation.

    In any event, if you agree the Bush Republicans have completely lost their focus and need to pursue more important issues like terrorism and those mentioned above, email or even better write a letter to your Congress person by going to http://www.congress.org/congressorg/home/ and entering your zip code in the upper left.


  29. pgw says:

    no matter how much movie magic they use to make the ‘path’, nothing changes the fact that this happened on w.’s watch.


  30. Zooey says:

    pgw,

    No matter how much the right jumps up and down, and gnashes their teeth, it will always be true that 9/11 happened on The Boy King’s Most Excellent Playdate.

    That really pisses them off…


  31. Hardy Haberman says:

    Again this all points to a propaganda piece funded by GOP and fundimentalists.


  32. RadioLeft.com says:

    This movie is only the preview for the Karl Rove Editon of the 2006 Slime Machine. Just watch as the Republicans try to convince the voters they will die if they vote for Democrats.

    The sad part is that the Republicans may get one or two more election victories out of these lies. If the American public really understood what is going on, Bush and his crooked cronies in Congress wouldn’t poll above 10% on anything.

    Don’t forget that not only is Bush ahead of the Democrats by 15 or 20% on domestic security, his numbers are actually improving. This is the result of the last month’s propaganda and the willingnes of the American public to put fear and blood-thirsty revenge ahead of reality.

    When the next terrorist attack occurs on American soil, the Republicans will claim it is because the Democrats obstructed implementing the 9/11 commission recommendations and the public will belive them despite the fact that the Democrats have been pushing the recommendations and the Republicans have been blocking them.


  33. katy says:

    zooey – all those years and you’ve never seen “everybody loves raymond”??? wow…
    it was a good show, especially the first several years…
    i also read a book ray ramono wrote c.’98… pretty funny guy…
    really good family life humor…
    he never deserved the bitch of a wife “debra” became…

    i’m sacked… say g’nite all…

    repeat SNL with AL GORE tonight… :-)


  34. DM says:

    #1 Thanks for pointing that out up front – if you think that Europeans and Australians are stupid enough to believe this garbage then you’re mistaken. They know our government at least as well as we do, having little reason to trust it on it’s best day, and painfully aware of it’s screwups when its at its worst.

    What irks me about the 9/11-thru-Iraq discussion on both sides is how we casually forget the world’s role in our local affair. Prior to the invasion of Iraq we saw the largest global protest in history, yet it’s all but forgotten in the US.


  35. Jay Randal says:

    Do NOT watch the ABC/Disney phony docu-drama propaganda film today > the best way to harm the GOP funders is to NOT watch the docu-drama!
    Their could be subliminal messages in the film, so do NOT allow your children to watch it > PERIOD.


  36. disneycorpse says:

    “No one could have predicted that terrorists would fly into buildings


  37. disneycorpse says:

    that should read “Dumbo jets into buildings”


  38. Contemporary Protest Music (#4) » Sound On The Sound says:

    [...] We have seen it in this last few days with the “dramatized” account of events on 9/11 that ABC is marketing to the rest of the world as being the“Official True Story”. Former President Clinton’s lawyers are respectfully requesting ABC refrain from slandering the former president and his cabinet officers by airing this (fake)docudrama. We’ll see what happens. My sense is that this movie is highly political and essentially paints Clinton (and hence Democrats in general) as weak on Security/Terrorism. Its airing arrives right at the beggining of an electoral season where being an incumbent is no longer a guarantee of success in the General Election (much less the Primary for that matter, right Joe?). The only reason ABC is putting up such a fight is because of its potential for Republican gain in enforcing their version of the story and hence history. Just how they think that they can rewrite the history of such a pivotal event in our national conciousness is beyond me. The populous is not stupid, just kept in the dark most of the time. They are finally being told the depths those in power go to stay in power and realize it is time for some accountability. [...]


  39. TomPaine says:

    This storm surrounding this stupid show is all based on the ignorant assumption that the US government story is true at all. The government was at the very least complicit in allowing the attacks to happen. Start with that assumption and the entire movie is bullshit.


  40. paul lukasiak says:

    OOPS! (I think)

    upon further reflection, it seems that what appears on the “Path to 9-11″ website is not an except from the show, but part of a “Making of” documentary.

    What we may be seeing is actress Penny Johnson Girard, in full Condoleeza Rice costume, explaing how she (the actress) heard about 9-11.

    (moderator–if you view this clip, and feel that the previous comment is inaccuate, feel free to delete it, and this one.)


  41. Darryl Mason says:

    “Path To 9/11″ has just started airing in Sydney.

    Despite the fact that it was advertised, on television and newspapers and radio, as being the story of “exactly how it happened” and “this is the true story of how 9/11 became a reality”, the show just started with the LONGEST DISCLAIMER I’ve ever seen at the start of any doco, drama or docudrama.

    It basically said, “this is not a documentary”, this is a “dramatic recreation” and that it was based on “oral histories” and the “9/11 Commission Report”.

    The disclaimer also used a few paragraphs on screen to declare that some dramatic lisence was taken, that not all characters are represented as they are in real life, etc.

    In other words, an extraordinary effort at arse-covering.

    Interesting to note that the white-writing-on-black-background disclaimer had a pixelly quality to it, like it had been downloaded from the internet? Sent to Australia at the last minute as an e-mail attachment?

    There’s already been a few moments that seem completely absurd.

    Updates on the blog below as it unfolds :

    Your New Reality


  42. onion says:

    Maybe the neocons felt threatened by the conspiracy theories becoming all too believable, so they quickly put on another layer of brainwash – and distraction.


  43. Kay says:

    Since my post was “mysteriously erased” :

    The entire Bush Cabal (Bush I, Bush II, Cheney, Rumsfeld, Wolfowitz, Perle,
    Myers, Rice, Rice ETC) Should be tried in an International Independent Court of Law and tried and convicted of Treason against the worst violent crimes against it’s own people : 9/11

    All the people involved in “Path to 9/11″ should be ashamed of themselves.
    But, like this current administration there is no shame : just arrogance, lie and hubris.


  44. Kay says:

    Since my post was “mysteriously erased” :

    The entire Bush Cabal (Bush I, Bush II, Cheney, Rumsfeld, Wolfowitz, Perle,
    Myers, Rice, Rove ETC) Should be tried in an International Independent Court of Law and tried and convicted of Treason against the worst violent crimes against it’s own people : 9/11

    All the people involved in “Path to 9/11″ should be ashamed of themselves.
    But, like this current administration there is no shame : just arrogance, lies and hubris


  45. Kay says:

    Since my post was “mysteriously erased” :

    The entire Bush Cabal (Bush I, Bush II, Cheney, Rumsfeld, Wolfowitz, Perle,
    Myers, Rice, Rice ETC) Should be tried in an International Independent Court of Law and tried and convicted of Treason against the worst violent crimes against it’s own people : 9/11

    All the people involved in “Path to 9/11″ should be ashamed of themselves.
    But, like this current administration there is no shame : just arrogance, lies sand hubris.


  46. Kryten42 says:

    Hi all,

    I am recording part one of this travesty that is airing now in Australia. I will also copt part two tomorrow. I will make DVD copies and send them to one of our LM bloggers in the US for a comparison.

    So far, they showed a B/W text disclaimer stating that it was not a documentary and some parts were fictional.

    They have shown Clinton/Lewinsky 3 times so far!

    I have to say, the production quality is about what I would expect from a high-school student project! (Not that they are bad, just obviously low budget)! For something costing $40 mill… I’d love to know what they spent the money on!

    I should also mention that I believe that Disney were not conned into anything. I belive they have been a willing participant since day one. I have posted a blog at LM with my reasons.

    http://loadedmouth.com/node/3925

    Cheers all! And thanks a lot for all your great work! :D


  47. Mark says:

    If this film portrays 911 as 100% CLintons fault. Then we can assume that for 8 months Bush did everything perfect and it still happened? So what does that tell us about Bush’s efforts?


  48. A friend from Europe says:

    Path to 9/11 is not the only inaccurate and misleading docudrama.
    The movie United 93 is described as “meticulously researched” and “based on fact”, but there is not any indication that the German passenger Christian Adams was indeed a coward and appeaser and tried to stop the American heroes from storming the cockpit as the movie shows. The Guardian’s film critic writes: “The film United 93 finds old Europe literally standing in the way of US derring-do. The only trouble is, it didn’t happen that way.”
    Perhaps you are interested in my take on this in the Atlantic Review: German 9/11 Victim Defamed in “United 93″ Movie.
    Thanks.


  49. LibGrrl says:

    I think that Europeans are too smart too fall for Disney’s bullshit. It’s the American sheeple that will eat it up with a spoon.


  50. Michelle says:

    It really makes me laugh when the right wingers say libs are getting paid by Islamic fascists. PMSL I must have missed that pay day. Hey, Iran where is my check???? PMSL Their definition of concerned citizens is “conspiracy theorist.” Since when did it become a theory when most of it is fact? And…btw, what the hell is Islam winning? I thought this was about a war on terrorism? Or, is it a religious war? We know how that goes don’t we? The Christians have been at the forefront of inquisitions since it’s birth. Hey, Red Wolf, I have a new/old word for you (saying it slow so you can understand) repeat after me G-E-N-O-C-I-D-E.


  51. Michelle says:

    I can’t believe that ABC would take this chance on a movie that is not even good quality production. Usually Disney has high standards with movie making. I guess their magic couldn’t fix this one. On the other hand, I think they are making Walt Disney very proud. He was one of the bunch that went after communists in the 1940’s. Even testifying before Congress. He did not want labor parties to organize, so he labeled them communists. Artist’s organized strikes against ole Walt and he didn’t like that, not one bit.


  52. Chad says:

    Path to 9/11 will turn out to be this decade’s HEIDI, the famous incident where the movie about a pig-tailed, alpine goat-herder pre-empted the ending of one of the great football comebacks in history, Daryle Lamonica leading the Oakland Raiders to an improbable, last-minute victory against Joe Namath’s NY Jets and henceforth dubbed ‘The Heidi Game.’


  53. Nikita Sergeyevich says:

    Comrades Bravo!

    These traitors at ABC are betrayers of our new mother land. Where I come from, this Robert A. Iger would be dragged through the streets in front of the tomb of our glorious leader Vladimir Lenin and shot in public. The producers, directors, writers and anyone associated with this propaganda would be picked up in the early hours of the morning by our State Security Chief Lavrenty Beria (The Black Hand) and taken to a Siberian labor camp never too be heard from again.

    For many years I have been loyal to ABC and the Pravda (truth) that our Socialist Liberal ally has put forth in order to progress our ultimate goal; the decline and absolute destruction of America and the capitalist traitorous pig’s like ABC.

    I ask you Mr. Robert A. Iger, “Have you no shame Sir”?

    Comrades, we must not give up the fight. It has taken us many years to groom you and your elected leaders.

    Remember what our great leader Nikita Khrushchev said:

    “ We can’t expect the American People to jump from Capitalism to Communism, but we can assist their elected leaders in giving them small doses of Socialism, until they awaken one day to find that they have Communism ”

    It’s more important now then ever before that we stand together and stay focused! We can not allow this abomination of propaganda to go forward.

    We must do whatever it takes to keep this film from airing on Sunday the 10th, 2006, we only have a few hours left.

    It is your duty as loyal Liberal Socialist Democrats to rise up in solidarity and put a stop to this immediately!

    Senator Harry Reid, one of our courageous and distinguished Senatorial leaders from the state of Nevada, reminded the capitalist traitorous pigs at ABC of their license from the FCC. Please Senator Reid, we’re your loyal comrades in arms and begging you to use all the glorious power you possess. You must stop this film! You must push forward with an iron fist and crush this despicable display of propaganda.

    If this film isn’t stopped from airing on ABC, Sunday night, I’m afraid all our efforts since the cold war and the aspirations of our great leaders from glorious years past and Nikita Khrushchev’s dreams and predictions will have been lost.

    If we loose now, the great Liberal Socialist Democratic Party, we have nurtured, will decline into the ash heaps of history never too be heard from again.

    You must!…. I repeat, you must contact our comrades in arms at their offices in Washington.

    Now I’ve done all the work all you have to do is contact our comrades below by e-mail or call:

    Clinton, Hillary Rodham- (D – NY) Class I
    476 RUSSELL SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-4451
    Web Form: clinton.senate.gov/contact

    Reid, Harry- (D – NV) Class III
    528 HART SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-3542
    Web Form: reid.senate.gov/contact/email_form.cfm

    Kerry, John F.- (D – MA) Class II
    304 RUSSELL SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-2742
    Web Form: kerry.senate.gov/v3/contact/email.html

    Landrieu, Mary L.- (D – LA) Class II
    724 HART SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-5824
    Web Form: landrieu.senate.gov/contact/index.cfm

    Levin, Carl- (D – MI) Class II
    269 RUSSELL SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-6221
    Web Form: levin.senate.gov/contact/index.cfm

    Rockefeller, John D., IV- (D – WV) Class II
    531 HART SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-6472
    Web Form: rockefeller.senate.gov/services/email.cfm

    Schumer, Charles E.- (D – NY) Class III
    313 HART SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-6542
    Web Form: schumer.senate.gov/SchumerWebsite/contact/webform.cfm

    Kennedy, Edward M.- (D – MA) Class I
    317 RUSSELL SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-4543
    Web Form: kennedy.senate.gov/senator/contact.cfm

    Feinstein, Dianne- (D – CA) Class I
    331 HART SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-3841
    Web Form: feinstein.senate.gov/email.html

    Leahy, Patrick J.- (D – VT) Class III
    433 RUSSELL SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-4242
    E-mail: senator_leahy@leahy.senate.gov

    Stabenow, Debbie- (D – MI) Class I
    133 HART SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-4822
    Web Form: stabenow.senate.gov/email.htm

    Durbin, Richard- (D – IL) Class II
    332 DIRKSEN SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-2152
    Web Form: durbin.senate.gov/contact.cfm

    Lincoln, Blanche L.- (D – AR) Class III
    355 DIRKSEN SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-4843
    Web Form: lincoln.senate.gov/webform.html

    Feingold, Russell D.- (D – WI) Class III
    506 HART SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-5323
    E-mail: russell_feingold@feingold.senate.gov

    Harkin, Tom- (D – IA) Class II
    731 HART SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-3254
    Web Form: harkin.senate.gov/contact/contact.cfm

    Bayh, Evan- (D – IN) Class III
    463 RUSSELL SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-5623
    Web Form: bayh.senate.gov/WebMail1.htm

    Biden, Joseph R., Jr.- (D – DE) Class II
    201 RUSSELL SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-5042
    E-mail: senator@biden.senate.gov

    Boxer, Barbara- (D – CA) Class III
    112 HART SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-3553
    Web Form: boxer.senate.gov/contact

    Menendez, Robert- (D – NJ) Class I
    502 HART SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-4744
    Web Form: menendez.senate.gov/contact/contact.cfm

    Nelson, Bill- (D – FL) Class I
    716 HART SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-5274
    Web Form: billnelson.senate.gov/contact/email.cfm

    Obama, Barack- (D – IL) Class III
    713 HART SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-2854
    Web Form: obama.senate.gov/contact/

    Byrd, Robert C.- (D – WV) Class I
    311 HART SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-3954
    Web Form: byrd.senate.gov/byrd_email.html

    Cantwell, Maria- (D – WA) Class I
    717 HART SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-3441
    Web Form: cantwell.senate.gov/contact/index.html

    Conrad, Kent- (D – ND) Class I
    530 HART SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-2043
    Web Form: conrad.senate.gov/webform.html

    Dayton, Mark- (D – MN) Class I
    123 RUSSELL SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-3244
    Web Form: dayton.senate.gov/contact/email.cfm

    Dodd, Christopher J.- (D – CT) Class III
    448 RUSSELL SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510
    (202) 224-2823
    Web Form: dodd.senate.gov/index.php?q=node/3130


  54. wilgo says:

    SHAME on ABC – DISNEY!!!! – for their GOEBELS-LIKE POLITICAL LIES in the docudrama “Path to 9/11.” Truth never was the point, only shameful political mileage under the deceptive label of … “ENTERTAINMENT.”

    ABC is on our airwaves to give us the news – truthful accounts, not to “entertain” us into the ever-closer FASCHIST STATE. Whatever became of ABS’s great investigative reporting? I know, I know, it’s a lot easier to write fiction than it is to search for and publish the truth.

    Regarding the “Entertainment” dodge, do any of us look back on Goerbels as entertaining the German masses?

    Disney/ABC, TRULY BE ASHAMED.

    FASCISM:
    1 often capitalized : a political philosophy, movement, or regime (as that of the Fascisti) that exalts nation and often race above the individual and that stands for a centralized autocratic government headed by a dictatorial leader, severe economic and social regimentation, and forcible suppression of opposition
    2 : a tendency toward or actual exercise of strong autocratic or dictatorial control


  55. MCD says:

    I have realized the biggest threat to America isn’t terrorism but idiotic Americans. The majority of comments here come from the simplistic minds of morons. You should be embarrassed by you stupidity, but alas, you’re too stupid to know.


  56. Tank says:

    Official True Story.” How Path to 9/11 is being marketed in Europe. The commerical also features the scene slandering Sandy Berger.

    Official number of people in Europe who know or care who Sandy Berger is: 4.


  57. Armn Hammer says:

    The first half of “The Path to 911” that aired last night was KIND to Former President BJ Clinton. Anyone who can’t see that is blinded by political bias. I, unfortunately have read the entire 911 report, and I’d like to challenge anyone to please explain any lies, that they think were displayed.

    Oh, and post 59 is the best post in this blog, my hats off to you Nikita. However I think your humor was wasted on the libs. I’m sure several hundred of them are at this very moment debating the construction of a shrine in your honor. They’ll never complete the construction because they’ll have to him and haw over where to place the shrine so that it won’t offend anyone and what type of recycled matter it should be made from, and most importantly how much tax dollars they can get.

    Remember the leftist motto – VOTE DEMECRATE ITS EASIER THAN WORKING!


  58. frenchfries says:

    LOL! Bush is about as popular in Europe as cancer. The Europeans will laugh at some fancy Disney movie about 9/11. Forget it, ABC! They’ll never believe it. Clinton still is the most popular American president since JFK. If there was an election he’d be president of probably every country in Europe. So: ha ha!


  59. Viper says:

    I’ve studied the books and reports, I’ve watched the History Channels many shows by various directors on events up to 9/11 and I must say…Bravo! What a great show. I used to like Clinton but boy did he fail us. Question to everyone….Has Bush done more to protect us now then Clinton did then? Answer YES
    Question….Has the hornets nest been struck…Yes


  60. iamanamerican says:

    i wish all you morons who keep bashing Bush, are unpatriotic and express hatred for america should wake up after watching the movie. but i doubt that since you are mentally restarded and i can only simple put you are a bunch of useful idiots waiting for them to cut your throats as they have been saying. just keep not paying attention just like the clintons did and you’ll see.


  61. ls says:

    The director of this “docudrama” has a blog open for comments, but since he gets to edit and/or block the comments its no surprise that most of the posters there think the movie is great and that he and ABC are practically heroic.


  62. marty says:

    this take no quarter approach from most on this site is predictable…your abject hatred for President Bush knows no bounds….certainly liberties were taken, as thery are in every so-called docu-drama….but if it was so off the mark why did kean remain as producer?…the show took liberties but the basic thread that we did nothing during the Clinton years resonates with most as the truth…and the imbeciles who go on about “on Bush’s watch” really take disengenuity to new levels….


  63. Michael Casas says:

    Well, it looks like Monica’s blow job has now cost us over $450 billion and over 6,000 deaths in NYC, PA, Washington, D.C., Iraq


  64. Michael Casas says:

    Well, it looks like Monica’s blow job has now cost us over $450 billion and over 6,000 deaths in NYC, PA, Washington, D.C., Iraq


  65. Allan Clark says:

    It’s amazing to me how blind the left and right can be noone here can take it for what it is both bush and the clinton administrations are to blame. however th clinton administration di d give osama plenty of time to plan and succeed with there plans. you cant tell me that when bush became president i 2000 that’s when they started planning. give me a break this film may not be all factual but it sure does make sense. oh yeah at least it’s not all made up crap like that film farenheit 9/11 from biggest nutcase around.

    for those of you who can’t look at the right and left and see the good from both and only choose one side i feel am sorry for your narrow minds and that is why we as a country are not moving forward there are too many rush limbaughs and michael moores not enough common sense people to get past there parties hate for the other parties good ideas.

    just a note from a 28 yr taxpayer. who is tired of everyone thinking their idea is the only right idea.


  66. TexasSaint says:

    Let me see if I have this right…the Sandy Berger who was ‘defamed’ by this TV program is the same Sandy Berger who stuffed documents from the National Archives in his trousers and socks and explained this by saying…

    “I made an honest mistake which I deeply regret,” Berger told reporters outside his office last night. “I dealt with this issue in October 2003 fully and completely. Everything that I have done all along in this process has been for the purpose of aiding and supporting the work of the 9/11 commission, and any suggestion to the contrary is simply absolutely wrong.”

    h’mmm…not buying that, and not buying that he was ‘defamed’, either.


  67. antonysalomi says:

    I am a Filipino and a well-established consultant in the sub-region of West – Africa handling a wide range of trade and investment matters.

    just recently, I was consulted and mandated by a top female client of mine to source for her:

    1. A country that is politically stable that has an excellent climate.

    2. A top personality by whom investment on a large scale could be handled.

    My client has a very huge amount of money to invest in your country on
    viable projects in your care, based on my recommendation due to your
    position. Your main responsibility is to ensure the total evacuation of the funds from Ghana where it is secured at the moment.
    Should you however be in a position to secure these funds and to handle the
    investment desire of my client, please notify me as a matter of urgency so
    that I can give the details and also arrange for an early meeting where we
    shall discuss among others, investment areas, evacuation or transfer of the funds and above all the percentage/benefits for you.

    Please i will like you to reply me on my private mail
    antonysalomi_two_2@yahoo.com

    Note that this transaction is confidential and should be treated as
    such.
    Expecting your early response.

    Sincerely yours,
    antony salomi,


  68. NWA ASABAA GUY says:

    is a nice site so keep it up hope visit again



Jump to Top

About Think Progress | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2009 Center for American Progress Action Fund
View Most Popular

Advertisement

What We're About

Featured

image
Subscribe to the Progress Report



imageTopic Cloud


Visit Our Affiliated Sites

image image
Reports


Got a hot tip?
Have a hot news tip? We'd love to hear from you. Use the form below to send us the latest.

Name:
Email:
Tip:
(required)


imageArchives


imageBlog Roll