69 Responses to “Despite widespread progressive victories,”
RealScientist says:
I agree. The Democrats are slightly right of center. It would be better if the party moved to the left. But the party is nearly as enmeshed with the corporations as the GOP.
What our country need’s right now is a bunch of bleeding heart libral’s like me..Then we could bring it back to a center, front and center that is…LOL..Blessings..Next Peace
I’d say that’s mostly accurate considering how many Democratic candidates were playing up their “Conservative” values to get elected, but remember that even Nixon looks like a “Commie” compared to this administration.
You mean “damn idiot media” The Media isn’t liberal or conservative. They’s stupid.
Eh.. Just labels anyway. The WP article (and the article about it) doesn’t actually SAY anything. Stop worrying about what to call something and just worry about weather it’s a good idea. I get called a Republican by Democrats and a Democrat by Republicans, a Conservative by Libertarians and a Facists by the Greens. None of those labels mean anything unless you know the definition the speakers had in mind when they used them. Since you usually can’t figure that out without being able to read minds, what does it matter?
If you can’t promote an idea without invoking the name of a political party, then how can you convince anyone the idea is sound?
The press, MSM, has yet to receive their “spanking” for all the harm they have done to America over the ast 6 years, for all they havoc they and their misleading stories have wreaked upon our country. They’ll get theirs! They have endorsed the worst of humanity, have backed outrageous behavior, and have fully cooperated in the attempts to ruin the country and make obsolete the Constitution. I am not ready to let them off the hook. They need to start changing, and soon, or maybe, just perhaps, theywill be forced to go the way of their Republican brethren – out. Some are already starting to change their tunes. It has been a bit hilarious over the last 24 hours to see some of them actually start to realize that their “BS as usual” is over. It is funny to witness them becoming hypocrites yet again – but this time, from a different side of the fence. Will Fox survive at all if it does not change (not that I care, but it will be interesting to see – I hope they fold, personally)? I am all for demanding honesty and integrity from the press, as WELL as from politicians. This fight is not not over yet!
So, when are progressive sites like TP going to stop censoring the comments of Americans? It’s about time, kids… we are adults, and we can “handle” the English language, in ALL of it’s glory and horror. Time to grow up, boys! Funny how so many other sites, progressive and liberal, do not censor the way this site does.
In an international sense, this is pretty much accurate, although the country (even democrats) are rather more to the right than “slightly” compared to other nations.
Either way, this is not really a startling statement in an article, but quite accurate.
i think they are correct on this… look at the rest of the “westernized” world in comparison. we’re slightly right still… but with this election we’re moving it back in the proper direction… at last
Um, the Washington Post is correct. We’ve been sliding right since the 60’s. Liberalism didn’t just come back with an election after a long hiatus, especially when you consider that some of those Democrats elected along the Rust Belt are blue dogs.
Bill. I think you’re right. I believe the fact that this nation is right of center probably goes a long way towards explaining that this is the greatest country on the planet.
American Society has been easing further to the right since the Reagan era with the Fundie wingnuts leading the way. The counter-counter culture has been at work and not many people paid attention since they were not acting like self-indulgent hippies dancing naked in the mud.
What happened last night was a revolt against incompetence and corruption not some drastic shift left.
These new Democrats who were elected are NOT right of center, and it’s time the MSM started to realize it. You don’t counter the extreme, far right with a right of center agenda. I think The Post is just hoping this is so–maybe it’s their wish, but it is not reality.
(By the way, I haven’t seen any kudos to Howard Dean for his fifty state strategy. Without that, Democrats would not be taking over the Senate. No more neocon Supremes! Thank you, Governor Dean).
Bill. I think you’re right. I believe the fact that this nation is right of center probably goes a long way towards explaining that this is the greatest country on the planet.
Comment by paul
Actually we were on the list of having the most public corruption this year. And thats what ‘right of center ‘means.
Given that most other countries have universal health care, and the US has all but dismantled the strength of labor unions in this country, and that 23 of the 24 states who’ve had a gay marriage amendment on their ballots have voted to ban it, I’d say slightly right of center is being a little generous. Compared to the rest of the world, we’re pretty solidly to the right.
On a total global perspective you are center of right. The States has high individual ratings, no social health care, low union engagement, low progressive tax system and high corporate invlovlement.
I have a sneaky feeling we won’t be seeing some of the trolls from here on.
This makes me think the payroll just got cut off, Happy Pink Slips, Trolls!!
They only say that because the majority of people have no idea what the parties represent any more. This is evident by the belief that Republicans still represent fiscal responsibility and reducing the rold Gov’t plays in our lives and the belief that Democrats spend too much money on social programs and over tax to make up for it.
Neither of these has been true for decades yet people have essentially branded the parties so they don’t have to think too much about what people really stand for. They just say “I believe in less government and less spending…I must be a republican” and then vote republican no matter what the actual record is.
THe same is also true of the so-called positions being defined by Republicans, such as how they are pro-life yet love war and the death penalty but do nothing about poverty and hate national health care. Liberal or progressive issues require more thought than just “for it or against it” and often you have to look at individual cases and the human effect.
Given that most other countries have universal health care, and the US has all but dismantled the strength of labor unions in this country, and that 23 of the 24 states who’ve had a gay marriage amendment on their ballots have voted to ban it, I’d say slightly right of center is being a little generous. Compared to the rest of the world, we’re pretty solidly to the right.
Comment by Jeremy Henderson
Most other countries, much poorer than we have healthcare and you call right of center a little generous whn the right would rather spend a million dollars on a smart bomb to blow up some date groves?
if you only lean in one direction, all you can ever do is go in a circle, or a spiral – in either case you never actually get anywhere….anyone who’s ever ridden a bicycle should be able to understand this, yet our history is one ever-changing trip to the right – it’s really a shame that so many could be so afraid of leaning a little to the left once in a while
Paul clearly doesn’t measure “greatest country on the planet” by standard of living, infant mortality rate, average level of education, percentage of people with no health care, percentage of people living below the poverty line, knowledge of world history, or percentage of people who participate in elections. Good point, though.
The last serious effort to enact universal health care, in 1994, helped lead the GOP to victory at the polls that year. The increasing tax burden on the middle class led to the election of anti-tax conservatives. Increasing attacks on the values of people of faith led to a huge conservative turnout for President Bush in 2004. Judicial decrees mandating gay marriage in some states have led to the enactment of two dozen state gay marriage bans.
Yup, despite the results of yesterday’s election, one can make the argument that this election was more about change for the sake of change than it was an endorsement of the “progressive” big government agenda. This is consistent with the re-election election of Joe Lieberman and Ben Nelson. It also is consistent with the election of new Democrats like Tester, Sestak, Webb and Shuler, all of whom ran to the right to win their seats. Time will tell if they told their voters the truth, or just gave them the usual Dem shuck ‘n’ jive.
The guy I’m intrigued by is Shuler. He’s a low-tax, pro-life baptist who hunts. It will be interesting to see what his voting record is two years from now, when he’s running for re-election.
The guys I’m happiest for are Joe Lieberman and Ben Nelson. They are both decent men who deserve a few more conservative Dems to have lunch with.
After spending 3 months in Europe in 1998, I think America is generally conservative in comparision. Had I spent 3 months in the Middle East, I would have thought that America is generally liberal in comparison.
Citizen Dad – 1994 was almost 13 years ago. Come into the 21st century already. Things change. Most Americans want National Healthcare. And we’re the only Industrialized Nation that doesn’t have it.
ThinkProgress, have some heart. It’s a severe case of Stockholm Syndrome. Don’t be intolerant of mental illness, even in the editorial board of a national newspaper.
Right of center has got us where? Invading a Sovereign nation, exercising a ridiculously expensive drain on our most precious resources.Expanding the size of the federal government and solving nothing domestically, you mean that right of center? Does the Post mean “the way it ought to be”, fantasy right of center? It’s all about neighborhoods.
sorry to do this, but my previous post bears repeating:
f you only lean in one direction, all you can ever do is go in a circle, or a spiral – in either case you never actually get anywhere….anyone who’s ever ridden a bicycle should be able to understand this, yet our history is one ever-changing trip to the right – it’s really a shame that so many could be so afraid of leaning a little to the left once in a while
It just typical, but lets us not loose sight of who really rallied the troops. HOWARD DEAN should take credit for this overwhelming decision made by the electorate. But, all the left of center (center money whores) will claim credit, not deserved. Bill and Hill should thank the REAL DEMOCRATIC PARTY(the DNC, lead by DEAN) for their success.
The DEMOCRATIC PARTY is really a little more left than people want to admit. And all will be happy that it is in the future.
NOW THAT WAS FUN…but now its time to go to work. We need to start with some serious oversight and a few investigations. Cheney’s meeting with the big oil companies to start.
Peace to all my brothers and sister that made this a great place to live agait!
But the party is nearly as enmeshed with the corporations as the GOP.
Comment by RealScientist
Well said.
I believe the fact that this nation is right of center probably goes a long way towards explaining that this is the greatest country on the planet.
Comment by paul
Coming from a citizen of that country, thats really meaningless.
We’re actually pretty far to the right. Ask Chomsky.
Comment by DrSinker
Completely right. I mean both rights…you are correct and US is a rightist country whether there are Dems (moderate) or Reps (neocons).
the United States is “a nation that leans slightly right of center.â€
And I’d day that is a very accurate description.
The Democrats are not interested in challenging the status quo but in maintaining it. They simpy disagree with Republicans on exactly how to maintain it. When it comes to foreign policy, both groups will do whatever it takes to further American economic interests, even foistering coups d’etats and “regime changes” (the invasion of Iraq being a notable exception).
remember, newsies are losing their market share to the internet
what happened when william randolph hearst wanted to sell more papers?
he made up news.
any questions?
Good question. The right is fascism, nazism, state power over every social, economical and political activities. The left is a response to oppresive regimes, politics and social programs aimed against the working class.
A million people have already said it and I just want to agree: the United State IS right of center! The average democrat is very far right of the average ThinkProgress visitor. However, history tends to move toward liberalism each generation, with minor setbacks (like the last ten years). So I’m not worried. Eventually, when I’m very old, I might be talking about those darn liberal kids. ;-)
WaHoPo get’s it entirely wrong… most or center to left according to the many polls I’ve read throughout 2003 till today.
Despite that the democrats won I think it’s correct to say that we should remain sceptical about the voting system in America: http://www.prisonplanet.com/articles/november2006/091106electionthrown.htm
As someone above said, it is a question of perspective. Compared to most second or third world countries, the USA is toward the left. Compared to other western/industrialised/democratic nations – the USA is a fair way to the right.
Others also beat me to questioning upon what criteria Americans continue to judge their nation as the greatest country on earth. Is it the number of aircraft carriers?
Well, I know most here hate America and will just consider me a cheerleader, but here goes.
This is a great country. Millions of people immigrate here. Not many are trying to leave. Those in poverty here, generally have a place to live, televisions, major appliances and often cars. There is almost an unlimited freedom of information. The evil U.S. corporations you lament, are mainly responsible for the computer you’re are staring at, as well as countless other technological advances that have benefitted everyone. Because healthcare is not socialized, when the world needs a great doctor, medical advance or a new drug, the first place they turn is here. (those affordable Canadian drugs are mostly developed in American Pharmecutical labs).
Look in the parking lot at work (95% of you have jobs), or in your grocery store, or on television; there is an incredible amount of choice in this country. And an incredible amount of freedom. The best part, if you don’t like it, you can change it. The will of the people here is counted down to the last vote and supercedes everything else. There are many things to be disappointed in about America. No place is perfect. But, if you are not willing to concede that this is the greatest country on the planet, you’re misinformed or just denying the reality.
“Liberal” and “conservative” are as much ways to describe yourself as they are to describe other people and systems. The U.S. might consider itself to be conservative, but a lot of that is due to the fact that they’ve been hearing that from talk radio for years. If we now start 30 years of reinforcing the idea that “liberals are good” and “America is liberal” might eventually mean that fewer people call the U.S. “mostly conservative.”
“Liberal”as a dirty word has gone unchallenged for so long that fewer people are willing to classify themselves as “liberal”, even if a self-declared liberal would label them that way. You ask somebody if they believe in a higher minimum wage, more money spent on education, government regulations on business, government policies to protect the environment. They say “yes” on all counts. But, if you ask them “are you a liberal”, – they don’t want to associate themselves with that word. Today, it’s only people who are proud to call themselves “liberal” who call themselves “liberal”.
You talk to really hard right conservatives and ask them what a liberal stands for, they’ve got no idea. They can’t tell you what liberals want, they can only tell you what they WISH liberals want. They’ve got this imaginary, straw- liberal in their heads. To them, a liberal is somebody whose beliefs are the opposite of their own. “I’m for goodness, so liberals must be against goodness.” On top of that, their ideas about liberals generally aren’t informed by what liberals say, but by what other conservatives have told them that liberals say. “The guy on the radio said that liberals are against goodness.”
There’s even less understanding of socialism, which is why “socialist” is such a popular epithet. It gets thrown around as if government control of services was a completely foreign concept in the U.S., despite the public school system and the postal service.
Here we go- somebody here starts off by saying “I know most people here hate America.” Who told him that? Liberals or conservatives? If you criticize something, that means you hate it? How many people on Think Progress have used the term “I hate America”? It’s a perfect example of conservatives making up their own fanciful ideas about what liberals think. That’s an awful lot of what conservatism in the U.S. is about these days, telling the liberals what their ideas are, no matter what the truth is.
What does it mean that “we have an incredible amount of freedom” in the US? I don’t deny it, but here in the Czech Republic, we’ve got an incredible amount of freedom, freedom of information, expression and otherwise.
Hundreds of thousands of people immigrate to the Czech Republic, too. They don’t immigrate because the country has it’s own reputation for being a bastion of freedom. They come because it’s richer than the country they left.
Have you ever experienced socialized medicine first hand, or just heard about it? Maybe you have. I have, and it wasn’t bad.
I consider myself a patriotic American, and when I return, I’ll have a good amount of knowlege to make a comparison. Patriotism isn’t just saying “my country is best”, it’s making an informed judgement about what is and isn’t good about your country with some perspective.
Paul, thanks for your fine narrative on the benefits of corporations on our existence. Unfortunately corporations are the 800 pound gorilla in the political room. The problem is the fictional Conservative nirvana the right has failed to DELIVER. Go read Restate or the Captain and see how proud they are of the miserable performance of their party to steer the boat. They crashed the party boat after a binge of recklessness for spending that will probably never be equaled. The real loss for them is the squandering of the opportunity the country had to see conservative principles actually function. Guess what? Their principles and execution of them have crushed the conservative movement back to a feeble impotent fantasy. You can’t project what is good, you have to live it and share it with everyone, especially when you take peoples lives and money and treat them like they are yours to waste, as you see fit, just to promote a model of grandeur thinking.
Well, I know that every Progressive poster loves America, no maatter how much the right-whiners try to spin it. Just because we don’t swoon at the sight of Pres. Bush in a flight suit on the deck of an aircraft carrier under the sign his administration put up (Mission Accomplished!) does not mean people automatically hate America!
We posters, here at TP, are excited about the cyclical nature of politics. As the right-whiners have noticed, there are fewer Republicans in power. Not just in the House & Senate, but in state legislatures as well. The majority of Democrats that won did so because they represented a change of the “same old, tired ’stay the course’ and bow to the President” ultra-radical far-right faction of the extreme wing of the Republican party.
The people who lost were the extreme right-wing (FROMER Sen. Santorum) and those who won (for the most part) are the party of the center: higher minimum wage, stop trashing the Constitution in the name of patriotism, fiscal responsibility and no more “borrow and squander”, no more lobbyist special-interest and war profiteering, and an end to corporate welfare programs.
Every Progressive person loves America because it’s not just a reflection of who’s currently in power, but a tapestry of all perspectives that exist in America. Since the majority of American people have decided that the course we’ve been on for the past 6 (or 12 if you like) years are not the best course for America, we now have a differeent party in control.
God has blessed America! (If you don’t believe in God, I’m sure you’ll understand my exhuberance!)
Well, I know most here hate America and will just consider me a cheerleader, but here goes.
I think nobody here hates America. Thats a simplistic POV. I like America: From Chile to Alaska, I guess thats what you meant.
But, if you are not willing to concede that this is the greatest country on the planet, you’re misinformed or just denying the reality.
Comment by paul
I think even when US was born, Franklin and Jefferson had in mind to spread the US so far as South America. First, the name: US of America. Why not just US or something else? Second, right after US got free from George III became the expansion over the indian countries. These really werent peaceful people. Then the spreading to the south to Florida, then the war against Mexico, then Cuba, Panama, Puerto Rico, Hawaii, Okinawa, etc. I think you get my point. There is no doubt, when one looks over real history, that US was born as an empire. Now, if thats the greatest country in the world: the only country to bomb with nukes civilian population, that has a 180+ intervention record across the world, that has a shameful record supporting armed, bloodthirsty groups to repress democratic elected governments for US interests, that has over 700 military bases overseas from WWII (but the Nazis were defeated already) or earlier (Gitmo)…then I dont want to know which one is the worst country in the world.
Now, if you mean, how the people work, the look for improvements in all aspects of life, the huge support of universities, technology and science, your ONG´s, and the innocence of people…then yeah, US is a beautiful project as a country.
Thank you. I didn’t really doubt your love of country, I guess I just wanted to hear it. Juan C, I know we disagree about many things, but I really appreciate your posts. I came to TP to get a different take on things. Your perspective is especially helpful. Peace and Love.
It took just 1 Republican President, 1 bout of having a fair degree of power, for them to demonstrate just why the Republican Party is not to be trusted with government.
The Rightwhinge claims that the Republicans abandoned the principles which got them into power, that the Republicans acted more like what they call liberals then what they think of as being conservatives. This is nonsense. The Republicans were every bit as conservative as their supporters claimed they wanted them to be: They cut taxes, cut services and spent a lot of money on Arms. They refused to even talk to America’s “enemies” and alienated the UN. They made Christianity a big issue and even undermined teaching science when it conflicted with religious doctrine. Heck even minimum wage was kept low to help big business along.
The Republicans put into practice every principle the Right wanted, and those principles failed. This is because ultimately, when it comes to government effeciency, the left is the side that actually achieves it. Conservatives like to pretend that they are tough, but if you look throughout history the Conservatives are great right up until the situation changes, and then they cannot adapt.
The rightwing likes to point out that the left always talks about how things should be, and never about how things are. Well how things are is fairly obvious to anyone with eyes, and generally it is either fine, in which case its a boring topic of discussion, or not fine in which case it is more constructive thinking about how we would like them to be and how to achieve that “Should be” result.
How things should be in Iraq is America should be out of there. How things are, is that America is currently stuck in the same position as the Spartans were with Athens, you are trying to put in your own form of government and this is alienating everyone. America is losing the peace and right now it looks like it is trapped with a loss. How do we achieve the more desirable end? Get help, stop treating your allies like dirt and start talking to your enemies, and set a schedule which the Army can attain. This is what Rumsfeld refused to do, and what Gates is going to do, because ultimately now that the Left is in a position to force changes, the right is forced to take a more leftwing stance.
One of the chief Rightwing attacks against John Kerry was calling him a flip-flopper, and making a big deal about how George stood firm. Well look at what has happened under standing firm: America’s debt has doubled, North Korea has attained nuclear weaponry and Iran is now effectively untouchable. All because the Rightwing stood firm.
Now that the left has a voice, you will see changes there as Bush is forced to talk to your enemies in a more civil tone of voice, and you will see a more capable man chosen to talk to the UN then Bolton, whose efforts have achieved America not being invited to any serious talks. You will see more compromise and diplomacy.
What one must realise is that it was not just the scandals that killed the Republican Party this year, it was the pure fact that ultimately, the brand of conservatism the Republicans followed failed. Now things are changing, and hopefully they will be changing in time to avoid America hitting a depression or recession. The Democrats have a hard 2 years ahead of them, hopefully they will veer far enough left to change and adapt to those years, so that America gets the best government possible.
America has turned left, and the only reason why you still have the conservative American media calling America Rightwing, is because that media does not even know what the left really is.
–2004 Election Summary–
Desperate voters, fearful that homosexuals might enjoy the sanctity of marriage knowingly elect an Desperate voters, despite their fears that homosexuals incompetent President.
–2006 Election Summary–
might enjoy the sanctity of marriage knowingly elect oversight for an incompetent President.
I agree. The Democrats are slightly right of center. It would be better if the party moved to the left. But the party is nearly as enmeshed with the corporations as the GOP.
November 8th, 2006 at 5:17 pmGeez, where’s the old journalistic integrity of the old Washington Post???
November 8th, 2006 at 5:17 pmWell, I don’t disagree with that statement, actually. Compared to the rest of the world, even most of our liberals aren’t that liberal.
November 8th, 2006 at 5:18 pmThat damn liberal media!
November 8th, 2006 at 5:22 pmPlaced with respect to the rest of the world, this is fairly inaccurate. We’re actually pretty far to the right. Ask Chomsky.
November 8th, 2006 at 5:26 pmWhat our country need’s right now is a bunch of bleeding heart libral’s like me..Then we could bring it back to a center, front and center that is…LOL..Blessings..Next Peace
November 8th, 2006 at 5:26 pmI’d say that’s mostly accurate considering how many Democratic candidates were playing up their “Conservative” values to get elected, but remember that even Nixon looks like a “Commie” compared to this administration.
November 8th, 2006 at 5:31 pmYou mean “damn idiot media” The Media isn’t liberal or conservative. They’s stupid.
Eh.. Just labels anyway. The WP article (and the article about it) doesn’t actually SAY anything. Stop worrying about what to call something and just worry about weather it’s a good idea. I get called a Republican by Democrats and a Democrat by Republicans, a Conservative by Libertarians and a Facists by the Greens. None of those labels mean anything unless you know the definition the speakers had in mind when they used them. Since you usually can’t figure that out without being able to read minds, what does it matter?
If you can’t promote an idea without invoking the name of a political party, then how can you convince anyone the idea is sound?
November 8th, 2006 at 5:31 pmThe press, MSM, has yet to receive their “spanking” for all the harm they have done to America over the ast 6 years, for all they havoc they and their misleading stories have wreaked upon our country. They’ll get theirs! They have endorsed the worst of humanity, have backed outrageous behavior, and have fully cooperated in the attempts to ruin the country and make obsolete the Constitution. I am not ready to let them off the hook. They need to start changing, and soon, or maybe, just perhaps, theywill be forced to go the way of their Republican brethren – out. Some are already starting to change their tunes. It has been a bit hilarious over the last 24 hours to see some of them actually start to realize that their “BS as usual” is over. It is funny to witness them becoming hypocrites yet again – but this time, from a different side of the fence. Will Fox survive at all if it does not change (not that I care, but it will be interesting to see – I hope they fold, personally)? I am all for demanding honesty and integrity from the press, as WELL as from politicians. This fight is not not over yet!
So, when are progressive sites like TP going to stop censoring the comments of Americans? It’s about time, kids… we are adults, and we can “handle” the English language, in ALL of it’s glory and horror. Time to grow up, boys! Funny how so many other sites, progressive and liberal, do not censor the way this site does.
November 8th, 2006 at 5:33 pmIn an international sense, this is pretty much accurate, although the country (even democrats) are rather more to the right than “slightly” compared to other nations.
Either way, this is not really a startling statement in an article, but quite accurate.
November 8th, 2006 at 5:33 pmWhen did the Washington Post become the Washington Times? Did I miss something?
November 8th, 2006 at 5:33 pmAmerica’s Least Wanted
Um – our nation IS right of center. Does anything think the American Left is akin to the Euro Left? How about the Latin American Left?
November 8th, 2006 at 5:39 pmSo when is Scooter and DeLay going down? We’re on a roll here.
November 8th, 2006 at 5:41 pmi think they are correct on this… look at the rest of the “westernized” world in comparison. we’re slightly right still… but with this election we’re moving it back in the proper direction… at last
November 8th, 2006 at 5:43 pmUm, the Washington Post is correct. We’ve been sliding right since the 60’s. Liberalism didn’t just come back with an election after a long hiatus, especially when you consider that some of those Democrats elected along the Rust Belt are blue dogs.
November 8th, 2006 at 5:44 pmBill. I think you’re right. I believe the fact that this nation is right of center probably goes a long way towards explaining that this is the greatest country on the planet.
November 8th, 2006 at 5:45 pmAmerican Society has been easing further to the right since the Reagan era with the Fundie wingnuts leading the way. The counter-counter culture has been at work and not many people paid attention since they were not acting like self-indulgent hippies dancing naked in the mud.
What happened last night was a revolt against incompetence and corruption not some drastic shift left.
November 8th, 2006 at 5:49 pmThese new Democrats who were elected are NOT right of center, and it’s time the MSM started to realize it. You don’t counter the extreme, far right with a right of center agenda. I think The Post is just hoping this is so–maybe it’s their wish, but it is not reality.
November 8th, 2006 at 5:49 pm(By the way, I haven’t seen any kudos to Howard Dean for his fifty state strategy. Without that, Democrats would not be taking over the Senate. No more neocon Supremes! Thank you, Governor Dean).
Despite being a bunch of dumfux…
November 8th, 2006 at 5:52 pmActually we were on the list of having the most public corruption this year. And thats what ‘right of center ‘means.
November 8th, 2006 at 5:53 pmGiven that most other countries have universal health care, and the US has all but dismantled the strength of labor unions in this country, and that 23 of the 24 states who’ve had a gay marriage amendment on their ballots have voted to ban it, I’d say slightly right of center is being a little generous. Compared to the rest of the world, we’re pretty solidly to the right.
November 8th, 2006 at 5:55 pmOn a total global perspective you are center of right. The States has high individual ratings, no social health care, low union engagement, low progressive tax system and high corporate invlovlement.
November 8th, 2006 at 5:55 pmThank you, Governor Dean
ditto
November 8th, 2006 at 5:57 pmYou also forget Paul we borrow more,from foreign countries, now than we have since the civil war, to pay for this current war.
November 8th, 2006 at 5:59 pmI have a sneaky feeling we won’t be seeing some of the trolls from here on.
November 8th, 2006 at 6:00 pmThis makes me think the payroll just got cut off, Happy Pink Slips, Trolls!!
At least now we have a chance of achieving an even keel, after having been upside down, backwards and inside out for the past 6 years………
November 8th, 2006 at 6:04 pmThey only say that because the majority of people have no idea what the parties represent any more. This is evident by the belief that Republicans still represent fiscal responsibility and reducing the rold Gov’t plays in our lives and the belief that Democrats spend too much money on social programs and over tax to make up for it.
Neither of these has been true for decades yet people have essentially branded the parties so they don’t have to think too much about what people really stand for. They just say “I believe in less government and less spending…I must be a republican” and then vote republican no matter what the actual record is.
THe same is also true of the so-called positions being defined by Republicans, such as how they are pro-life yet love war and the death penalty but do nothing about poverty and hate national health care. Liberal or progressive issues require more thought than just “for it or against it” and often you have to look at individual cases and the human effect.
November 8th, 2006 at 6:05 pm“You may end up with a different math but you are entitled to your math and I’m entitled to THE math.” Karl Rove (failed math student)
November 8th, 2006 at 6:06 pmGiven that most other countries have universal health care, and the US has all but dismantled the strength of labor unions in this country, and that 23 of the 24 states who’ve had a gay marriage amendment on their ballots have voted to ban it, I’d say slightly right of center is being a little generous. Compared to the rest of the world, we’re pretty solidly to the right.
Comment by Jeremy Henderson
Most other countries, much poorer than we have healthcare and you call right of center a little generous whn the right would rather spend a million dollars on a smart bomb to blow up some date groves?
November 8th, 2006 at 6:07 pmif you only lean in one direction, all you can ever do is go in a circle, or a spiral – in either case you never actually get anywhere….anyone who’s ever ridden a bicycle should be able to understand this, yet our history is one ever-changing trip to the right – it’s really a shame that so many could be so afraid of leaning a little to the left once in a while
November 8th, 2006 at 6:08 pmPaul clearly doesn’t measure “greatest country on the planet” by standard of living, infant mortality rate, average level of education, percentage of people with no health care, percentage of people living below the poverty line, knowledge of world history, or percentage of people who participate in elections. Good point, though.
November 8th, 2006 at 6:10 pm#25, Don’t you worry, RUCerious! Exley is not going anywhere!
November 8th, 2006 at 6:17 pmI think I here your mom calling you.
November 8th, 2006 at 6:20 pmNaw RUC, I really don’t think Exley is employable…..
November 8th, 2006 at 6:23 pmNow, here’s my take on Von Rummy’s defection, courtesy of Newman and Redford.
November 8th, 2006 at 6:24 pmThe last serious effort to enact universal health care, in 1994, helped lead the GOP to victory at the polls that year. The increasing tax burden on the middle class led to the election of anti-tax conservatives. Increasing attacks on the values of people of faith led to a huge conservative turnout for President Bush in 2004. Judicial decrees mandating gay marriage in some states have led to the enactment of two dozen state gay marriage bans.
Yup, despite the results of yesterday’s election, one can make the argument that this election was more about change for the sake of change than it was an endorsement of the “progressive” big government agenda. This is consistent with the re-election election of Joe Lieberman and Ben Nelson. It also is consistent with the election of new Democrats like Tester, Sestak, Webb and Shuler, all of whom ran to the right to win their seats. Time will tell if they told their voters the truth, or just gave them the usual Dem shuck ‘n’ jive.
The guy I’m intrigued by is Shuler. He’s a low-tax, pro-life baptist who hunts. It will be interesting to see what his voting record is two years from now, when he’s running for re-election.
The guys I’m happiest for are Joe Lieberman and Ben Nelson. They are both decent men who deserve a few more conservative Dems to have lunch with.
November 8th, 2006 at 6:26 pmAfter spending 3 months in Europe in 1998, I think America is generally conservative in comparision. Had I spent 3 months in the Middle East, I would have thought that America is generally liberal in comparison.
It’s all about perspective.
November 8th, 2006 at 6:29 pmCitizen Dad – 1994 was almost 13 years ago. Come into the 21st century already. Things change. Most Americans want National Healthcare. And we’re the only Industrialized Nation that doesn’t have it.
November 8th, 2006 at 6:32 pmWe are a right of center country.
Look at the other Western Industrialized nations. Clearly we are one of –if not the most –conservative. What’s wrong with someone saying so?
November 8th, 2006 at 6:45 pmcitizen dad – you, and your obsolete antiquated rhetoric, were dismissed.
November 8th, 2006 at 6:49 pmThinkProgress, have some heart. It’s a severe case of Stockholm Syndrome. Don’t be intolerant of mental illness, even in the editorial board of a national newspaper.
November 8th, 2006 at 6:50 pmRight of center has got us where? Invading a Sovereign nation, exercising a ridiculously expensive drain on our most precious resources.Expanding the size of the federal government and solving nothing domestically, you mean that right of center? Does the Post mean “the way it ought to be”, fantasy right of center? It’s all about neighborhoods.
November 8th, 2006 at 7:17 pmsorry to do this, but my previous post bears repeating:
f you only lean in one direction, all you can ever do is go in a circle, or a spiral – in either case you never actually get anywhere….anyone who’s ever ridden a bicycle should be able to understand this, yet our history is one ever-changing trip to the right – it’s really a shame that so many could be so afraid of leaning a little to the left once in a while
November 8th, 2006 at 7:26 pmAll any citizen cares about is that we’ve “cleaned house” and change will come! Dems rock!
November 8th, 2006 at 7:38 pmIt just typical, but lets us not loose sight of who really rallied the troops. HOWARD DEAN should take credit for this overwhelming decision made by the electorate. But, all the left of center (center money whores) will claim credit, not deserved. Bill and Hill should thank the REAL DEMOCRATIC PARTY(the DNC, lead by DEAN) for their success.
November 8th, 2006 at 7:41 pmThe DEMOCRATIC PARTY is really a little more left than people want to admit. And all will be happy that it is in the future.
What defines the “center”?
November 8th, 2006 at 7:44 pmNOW THAT WAS FUN…but now its time to go to work. We need to start with some serious oversight and a few investigations. Cheney’s meeting with the big oil companies to start.
Peace to all my brothers and sister that made this a great place to live agait!
November 8th, 2006 at 7:44 pmBut the party is nearly as enmeshed with the corporations as the GOP.
Comment by RealScientist
Well said.
I believe the fact that this nation is right of center probably goes a long way towards explaining that this is the greatest country on the planet.
Comment by paul
Coming from a citizen of that country, thats really meaningless.
We’re actually pretty far to the right. Ask Chomsky.
November 8th, 2006 at 7:50 pmComment by DrSinker
Completely right. I mean both rights…you are correct and US is a rightist country whether there are Dems (moderate) or Reps (neocons).
the United States is “a nation that leans slightly right of center.â€
And I’d day that is a very accurate description.
The Democrats are not interested in challenging the status quo but in maintaining it. They simpy disagree with Republicans on exactly how to maintain it. When it comes to foreign policy, both groups will do whatever it takes to further American economic interests, even foistering coups d’etats and “regime changes” (the invasion of Iraq being a notable exception).
It’s basically a cosmetic difference, really.
November 8th, 2006 at 8:10 pmremember, newsies are losing their market share to the internet
November 8th, 2006 at 8:20 pmwhat happened when william randolph hearst wanted to sell more papers?
he made up news.
any questions?
What defines the “center�
Comment by Alan
Good question. The right is fascism, nazism, state power over every social, economical and political activities. The left is a response to oppresive regimes, politics and social programs aimed against the working class.
November 8th, 2006 at 8:30 pmIt’s basically a cosmetic difference, really.
November 8th, 2006 at 8:32 pmComment by Gregor Samsa
What a great post.
A million people have already said it and I just want to agree: the United State IS right of center! The average democrat is very far right of the average ThinkProgress visitor. However, history tends to move toward liberalism each generation, with minor setbacks (like the last ten years). So I’m not worried. Eventually, when I’m very old, I might be talking about those darn liberal kids. ;-)
November 8th, 2006 at 8:39 pmThey can say whatever they want. ! HAHAhahaha
The ‘Great Republican Lie’ Finally Failed!!!
http://www.getsomejosh.com
November 8th, 2006 at 10:25 pmThis just in from Captain Obvious:
Glad you all enjoyed my article today in the Post
November 8th, 2006 at 11:32 pmWaHoPo get’s it entirely wrong… most or center to left according to the many polls I’ve read throughout 2003 till today.
November 9th, 2006 at 1:48 amDespite that the democrats won I think it’s correct to say that we should remain sceptical about the voting system in America:
http://www.prisonplanet.com/articles/november2006/091106electionthrown.htm
As someone above said, it is a question of perspective. Compared to most second or third world countries, the USA is toward the left. Compared to other western/industrialised/democratic nations – the USA is a fair way to the right.
Others also beat me to questioning upon what criteria Americans continue to judge their nation as the greatest country on earth. Is it the number of aircraft carriers?
November 9th, 2006 at 3:10 amWell, I know most here hate America and will just consider me a cheerleader, but here goes.
This is a great country. Millions of people immigrate here. Not many are trying to leave. Those in poverty here, generally have a place to live, televisions, major appliances and often cars. There is almost an unlimited freedom of information. The evil U.S. corporations you lament, are mainly responsible for the computer you’re are staring at, as well as countless other technological advances that have benefitted everyone. Because healthcare is not socialized, when the world needs a great doctor, medical advance or a new drug, the first place they turn is here. (those affordable Canadian drugs are mostly developed in American Pharmecutical labs).
Look in the parking lot at work (95% of you have jobs), or in your grocery store, or on television; there is an incredible amount of choice in this country. And an incredible amount of freedom. The best part, if you don’t like it, you can change it. The will of the people here is counted down to the last vote and supercedes everything else. There are many things to be disappointed in about America. No place is perfect. But, if you are not willing to concede that this is the greatest country on the planet, you’re misinformed or just denying the reality.
November 9th, 2006 at 6:58 am“Liberal” and “conservative” are as much ways to describe yourself as they are to describe other people and systems. The U.S. might consider itself to be conservative, but a lot of that is due to the fact that they’ve been hearing that from talk radio for years. If we now start 30 years of reinforcing the idea that “liberals are good” and “America is liberal” might eventually mean that fewer people call the U.S. “mostly conservative.”
“Liberal”as a dirty word has gone unchallenged for so long that fewer people are willing to classify themselves as “liberal”, even if a self-declared liberal would label them that way. You ask somebody if they believe in a higher minimum wage, more money spent on education, government regulations on business, government policies to protect the environment. They say “yes” on all counts. But, if you ask them “are you a liberal”, – they don’t want to associate themselves with that word. Today, it’s only people who are proud to call themselves “liberal” who call themselves “liberal”.
You talk to really hard right conservatives and ask them what a liberal stands for, they’ve got no idea. They can’t tell you what liberals want, they can only tell you what they WISH liberals want. They’ve got this imaginary, straw- liberal in their heads. To them, a liberal is somebody whose beliefs are the opposite of their own. “I’m for goodness, so liberals must be against goodness.” On top of that, their ideas about liberals generally aren’t informed by what liberals say, but by what other conservatives have told them that liberals say. “The guy on the radio said that liberals are against goodness.”
There’s even less understanding of socialism, which is why “socialist” is such a popular epithet. It gets thrown around as if government control of services was a completely foreign concept in the U.S., despite the public school system and the postal service.
November 9th, 2006 at 7:23 amHere we go- somebody here starts off by saying “I know most people here hate America.” Who told him that? Liberals or conservatives? If you criticize something, that means you hate it? How many people on Think Progress have used the term “I hate America”? It’s a perfect example of conservatives making up their own fanciful ideas about what liberals think. That’s an awful lot of what conservatism in the U.S. is about these days, telling the liberals what their ideas are, no matter what the truth is.
November 9th, 2006 at 7:26 amWhat does it mean that “we have an incredible amount of freedom” in the US? I don’t deny it, but here in the Czech Republic, we’ve got an incredible amount of freedom, freedom of information, expression and otherwise.
Hundreds of thousands of people immigrate to the Czech Republic, too. They don’t immigrate because the country has it’s own reputation for being a bastion of freedom. They come because it’s richer than the country they left.
Have you ever experienced socialized medicine first hand, or just heard about it? Maybe you have. I have, and it wasn’t bad.
I consider myself a patriotic American, and when I return, I’ll have a good amount of knowlege to make a comparison. Patriotism isn’t just saying “my country is best”, it’s making an informed judgement about what is and isn’t good about your country with some perspective.
November 9th, 2006 at 7:33 amPaul, thanks for your fine narrative on the benefits of corporations on our existence. Unfortunately corporations are the 800 pound gorilla in the political room. The problem is the fictional Conservative nirvana the right has failed to DELIVER. Go read Restate or the Captain and see how proud they are of the miserable performance of their party to steer the boat. They crashed the party boat after a binge of recklessness for spending that will probably never be equaled. The real loss for them is the squandering of the opportunity the country had to see conservative principles actually function. Guess what? Their principles and execution of them have crushed the conservative movement back to a feeble impotent fantasy. You can’t project what is good, you have to live it and share it with everyone, especially when you take peoples lives and money and treat them like they are yours to waste, as you see fit, just to promote a model of grandeur thinking.
November 9th, 2006 at 7:34 amOh, that liberal press.
November 9th, 2006 at 8:40 amWell, I know that every Progressive poster loves America, no maatter how much the right-whiners try to spin it. Just because we don’t swoon at the sight of Pres. Bush in a flight suit on the deck of an aircraft carrier under the sign his administration put up (Mission Accomplished!) does not mean people automatically hate America!
We posters, here at TP, are excited about the cyclical nature of politics. As the right-whiners have noticed, there are fewer Republicans in power. Not just in the House & Senate, but in state legislatures as well. The majority of Democrats that won did so because they represented a change of the “same old, tired ’stay the course’ and bow to the President” ultra-radical far-right faction of the extreme wing of the Republican party.
The people who lost were the extreme right-wing (FROMER Sen. Santorum) and those who won (for the most part) are the party of the center: higher minimum wage, stop trashing the Constitution in the name of patriotism, fiscal responsibility and no more “borrow and squander”, no more lobbyist special-interest and war profiteering, and an end to corporate welfare programs.
Every Progressive person loves America because it’s not just a reflection of who’s currently in power, but a tapestry of all perspectives that exist in America. Since the majority of American people have decided that the course we’ve been on for the past 6 (or 12 if you like) years are not the best course for America, we now have a differeent party in control.
God has blessed America! (If you don’t believe in God, I’m sure you’ll understand my exhuberance!)
November 9th, 2006 at 9:11 amWell, I know most here hate America and will just consider me a cheerleader, but here goes.
I think nobody here hates America. Thats a simplistic POV. I like America: From Chile to Alaska, I guess thats what you meant.
But, if you are not willing to concede that this is the greatest country on the planet, you’re misinformed or just denying the reality.
November 9th, 2006 at 9:13 amComment by paul
I think even when US was born, Franklin and Jefferson had in mind to spread the US so far as South America. First, the name: US of America. Why not just US or something else? Second, right after US got free from George III became the expansion over the indian countries. These really werent peaceful people. Then the spreading to the south to Florida, then the war against Mexico, then Cuba, Panama, Puerto Rico, Hawaii, Okinawa, etc. I think you get my point. There is no doubt, when one looks over real history, that US was born as an empire. Now, if thats the greatest country in the world: the only country to bomb with nukes civilian population, that has a 180+ intervention record across the world, that has a shameful record supporting armed, bloodthirsty groups to repress democratic elected governments for US interests, that has over 700 military bases overseas from WWII (but the Nazis were defeated already) or earlier (Gitmo)…then I dont want to know which one is the worst country in the world.
Now, if you mean, how the people work, the look for improvements in all aspects of life, the huge support of universities, technology and science, your ONG´s, and the innocence of people…then yeah, US is a beautiful project as a country.
Thank you. I didn’t really doubt your love of country, I guess I just wanted to hear it. Juan C, I know we disagree about many things, but I really appreciate your posts. I came to TP to get a different take on things. Your perspective is especially helpful. Peace and Love.
November 9th, 2006 at 9:55 amIt took just 1 Republican President, 1 bout of having a fair degree of power, for them to demonstrate just why the Republican Party is not to be trusted with government.
The Rightwhinge claims that the Republicans abandoned the principles which got them into power, that the Republicans acted more like what they call liberals then what they think of as being conservatives. This is nonsense. The Republicans were every bit as conservative as their supporters claimed they wanted them to be: They cut taxes, cut services and spent a lot of money on Arms. They refused to even talk to America’s “enemies” and alienated the UN. They made Christianity a big issue and even undermined teaching science when it conflicted with religious doctrine. Heck even minimum wage was kept low to help big business along.
The Republicans put into practice every principle the Right wanted, and those principles failed. This is because ultimately, when it comes to government effeciency, the left is the side that actually achieves it. Conservatives like to pretend that they are tough, but if you look throughout history the Conservatives are great right up until the situation changes, and then they cannot adapt.
The rightwing likes to point out that the left always talks about how things should be, and never about how things are. Well how things are is fairly obvious to anyone with eyes, and generally it is either fine, in which case its a boring topic of discussion, or not fine in which case it is more constructive thinking about how we would like them to be and how to achieve that “Should be” result.
How things should be in Iraq is America should be out of there. How things are, is that America is currently stuck in the same position as the Spartans were with Athens, you are trying to put in your own form of government and this is alienating everyone. America is losing the peace and right now it looks like it is trapped with a loss. How do we achieve the more desirable end? Get help, stop treating your allies like dirt and start talking to your enemies, and set a schedule which the Army can attain. This is what Rumsfeld refused to do, and what Gates is going to do, because ultimately now that the Left is in a position to force changes, the right is forced to take a more leftwing stance.
One of the chief Rightwing attacks against John Kerry was calling him a flip-flopper, and making a big deal about how George stood firm. Well look at what has happened under standing firm: America’s debt has doubled, North Korea has attained nuclear weaponry and Iran is now effectively untouchable. All because the Rightwing stood firm.
Now that the left has a voice, you will see changes there as Bush is forced to talk to your enemies in a more civil tone of voice, and you will see a more capable man chosen to talk to the UN then Bolton, whose efforts have achieved America not being invited to any serious talks. You will see more compromise and diplomacy.
What one must realise is that it was not just the scandals that killed the Republican Party this year, it was the pure fact that ultimately, the brand of conservatism the Republicans followed failed. Now things are changing, and hopefully they will be changing in time to avoid America hitting a depression or recession. The Democrats have a hard 2 years ahead of them, hopefully they will veer far enough left to change and adapt to those years, so that America gets the best government possible.
America has turned left, and the only reason why you still have the conservative American media calling America Rightwing, is because that media does not even know what the left really is.
November 9th, 2006 at 11:44 am“God Forgive Us We Voted Democraticâ€
–2004 Election Summary–
Desperate voters, fearful that homosexuals might enjoy the sanctity of marriage knowingly elect an Desperate voters, despite their fears that homosexuals incompetent President.
–2006 Election Summary–
might enjoy the sanctity of marriage knowingly elect oversight for an incompetent President.
(cognitorex blogspot)
November 9th, 2006 at 6:51 pmcraigajohnson,
What were you trying to say?
November 9th, 2006 at 7:41 pm