Think Progress

Why use your own words

By Nico Pitney on Feb 14th, 2007 at 4:10 pm

Why use your own words

when you’ve got a perfectly good fabricated Abraham Lincoln quote?



33 Responses to “Why use your own words”

  1. Gorge Busch says:

    why, did I say something wrong?


  2. wake-n-bake says:

    Neocons prefer fantasy land, with gum drop trees and bubble gum bees to REALITY.


  3. Liberal in New Mexico says:

    The only thing to fear is Chimpy, the monkey-boy, himself.


  4. dlet says:

    “Congressmen who willfully take actions during wartime that damage morale and undermine the military are saboteurs and should be arrested, exiled, or hanged.” — President Abraham Lincoln.

    The conservative author who touched off the misquotation frenzy, J. Michael Waller, concedes that the words are his, not Lincoln’s. Waller says he never meant to put quote marks around them, and blames an editor [at the magazine Insight] for the mistake and the failure to correct it.

    Someone should tell him that the quotes he used are fine. It’s the placement of President Abraham Lincoln after the statement and not his name that is the morally and professionally reprehensible thing about it all.


  5. Xenon says:

    “…one of our most admired presidents…”?!?
    What the hell is he smoking?


  6. Hector Garcia says:

    Why should Gaffney apologize? He knows dead persons cannot sue anybody….
    Oh wait….reputation…..repudiation…? He does’nt care.


  7. Midwest Product says:

    I think a tip of the hat might be appropriate here; with Glenn Greenwald and Roger Ailes and many others having covered this all day long it seems unlikely to me that reading through E&P was how ThinkProgress discovered the story.


  8. And You Thought REAGAN Was Stupid says:

    Interesting. “A true leader makes his decisions in an open forum and not behind closed doors. Do not trust the man who makes decisions based on facts he cannot share, for the facts are likely to exist only in his mind.” — Thomas Jefferson, Letter to the Peoples of Virginia, 1782

    Or, how about this one:

    “Surely, it is a far more egregious ethical breach to lead your fellow man into a war based on lies than it is to receive a hummer from a woman other than your wife.” — Thomas Paine

    … hey, this is easy!


  9. David says:

    Another vast right wing conspiracy…this time, and for some time, they have been dying to hype up Bush as comparable to Lincoln…but this too will fail.


  10. dlet says:

    #9
    I just googled and found this one.

    “I only hate one person on this Earth and that’s Gorge W. Bush.”
    – Jesus Christ


  11. And You Thought REAGAN Was Stupid says:

    #11. Good one. I hadn’t seen that before. Maybe time to print some t-shirts.


  12. Liberal in New Mexico says:

    #9- Or, this one:

    What a F*ing panty waste these clumsy bastards are.
    Mahatma Gandi


  13. Raven says:

    “Fourplay and seven pages ago, I served cocktails in the closets of Congress..”
    Mark Fooly


  14. Robert says:

    The Lincoln quotes are about as well sourced as the NeoCon WMD and Al Queda evidence that lead the country into this quagmire.


  15. Liberal in New Mexico says:

    What the F* are YOU looking at, F*er? F* you, you F*ing F*!
    Dick Cheney


  16. SKdeA says:

    #15, and the Iranian supplies!


  17. Wayne says:

    “Fourplay and seven pages ago, I served cocktails in the closets of Congress..” — Mark Fooly
    Comment by Raven

    Hilarious =D


  18. Raven says:

    “I will not Quail before Lawyers seeking to Rendition me to truth, yet will I Duck the Hunting of Justices as I head for the Oil Bunker of my Uraguay.”
    ‘Elmer’ Chainee


  19. Marie says:

    Why isn’t Frank Gaffney being censured by his paper? Oh, wait, that’s right, it’s the Washington Times — they don’t reprimand their columnists. Their guys are allowed to make up quotations, facts; imply and infer whatever suits their message. Legitimate papers with legitimate editors would take action.
    Blankley, Rev. Moon where are you?


  20. Democrat Soldier says:

    The neo-cons have nothing to stand on except lies and fabrications.

    Is any one surprised they lied yet again?

    Anyone at all???


  21. jay severin has a small pen1s says:

    “A President who acts like a child should be given to the terrorists in trade for peace and prosperity. His treatment at their hands should be videotaped and be the next big reality show on VH1″ – Ronald Reagen


  22. cynical ex-hippie says:

    “George Bush is a douchebag.”

    – Benjamin Franklin


  23. ClockworkOrange says:

    yay! NewSpeak!
    Thanks, Mr. Orwell!


  24. Gregor Samsa says:

    Well, the Washington Times and Insight Magazine rear their ugly head again.

    Now we know what sources we cannot trust -if there was any doubt left.


  25. Zooey says:

    Moonie Times
    Insight Magazine

    **yawn**


  26. Gregor Samsa says:

    “Those leaders -and their cronies- who mislead their people into a war of choice in a far away land, with no exit strategy, no gauge to measure success, while running the country’s economy into the ground, deserve to be impeached, tarred, feathered, and be put on display in a museum -next to the dinosaur with the smallest brain.”
    –Abraham Lincoln


  27. katy says:

    *
    the E&P article would be a good one to forward on to your local newspaper…

    i found this while there, and sent it along also:

    Radio Station Cries ‘Enough’ — Won’t Quote From Certain News Stories Relying on Unnamed Officials

    By Greg Mitchell
    Published: February 13, 2007 10:55 PM ET
    NEW YORK After the latest widely-publicized stories in national newspapers about weapons from Iran allegedly killing Americans in Iraq — based completely on unnamed sources — at least one smaller news outlet has had enough of it.

    The news director of the public radio station in Santa Fe, New Mexico, has directed his staff to “ignore national stories quoting unnamed sources.” He also called on other news outlets to join this policy.
    [...]
    http://editorandpublisher.com/eandp/news/article_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=1003545357

    .


  28. David Carlisle says:

    I always liked this Lincoln quotation. I think it sums up ‘loyalty’ perfectly:

    “Stand with anybody that stands right, stand with him while he is right and part with him when he goes wrong. ”

    I like to think that there are still Republicans who hold that sentiment. Too bad there aren’t a lot of them in their current leadership. Folks like Gaffney seem to think that having a war gives you an excuse to drop all but your most convenient values and run.


  29. David Carlisle says:

    Lincoln had lots of good stuff. I like this one showing Lincoln being something other than profound:

    People who like this sort of thing will find this the sort of thing they like.

    I think Lincoln also said

    “Let the thing be pressed.”

    which, in my opinion, actually sounds more interesting if you don’t know the context.


  30. StupidGit says:

    “Reality has a well-known liberal bias.”


  31. chancuff says:

    When I provided Brooks Jackson at Factcheck.org my research and he expanded and published our findings here:

    http://factcheck.org/article415.html

    … I had thought this fiction was put to bed, once and for all. I underestimated the complete ignorance of some journalists.

    If interested, I made a youtube video a few weeks before last years’ elections.

    Cliff Hancuff
    Reston, Virginia


  32. chancuff says:



Jump to Top

About Think Progress | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2009 Center for American Progress Action Fund
View Most Popular

Advertisement

What We're About

Featured

image
Subscribe to the Progress Report



imageTopic Cloud


Visit Our Affiliated Sites

image image
Reports


Got a hot tip?
Have a hot news tip? We'd love to hear from you. Use the form below to send us the latest.

Name:
Email:
Tip:
(required)


imageArchives


imageBlog Roll