Think Progress

Sesktak Warns Iraqi Oil Law Contains ‘Undue Ability Of U.S. Oil Companies To Control Iraqi Profits’

Alternet’s Joshua Holland reported recently, “If passed, the Bush administration’s long-sought ‘hydrocarbons framework’ law would give Big Oil access to Iraq’s vast energy reserves on the most advantageous terms and with virtually no regulation.” The framework law proposes to hand over effective control of as much as 80 percent of the country’s oil wealth.

A recent poll showed that all Iraqi ethnic and sectarian groups across the political spectrum oppose the principles enshrined in the oil law, and 419 Iraqi oil experts, economists and intellectuals recently signed their names to a statement expressing grave concern over the bill. The head of the Iraqi Federation of Union Councils said recently, “If the Iraqi Parliament approves this law, we will resort to mutiny.”

While the Bush administration has prodded the Iraqi government to pass the oil-sharing agreement, few members of Congress have voiced alarms over the details in the current bill. Rep. Joe Sestak (D-PA) recently told ThinkProgress that more attention needs to be paid to the oil legislation. “Who knows what’s in that,” he said. Sestak continued:

The indications from a draft of several months ago that the Kurds were using, is that…there is an undue ability of our oil companies to control the Iraqi profits by controlling the infrastructure and the wells that are there.

I mean they [U.S. oil companies] are going to get much more, if the draft is correct, of profits than we would under a normal oil sharing agreement, of these oil companies to a country like Saudi Arabia or others. Heaven forbid that at the end of this time, after all this, if we find out that there’s undue advantage given to our oil companies.

Watch it:

[flv http://video.thinkprogress.org/2007/08/Sestekiraq.320.240.flv]

In the interview, Sestak also distanced himself from the opinions of Michael O’Hanlon and Ken Pollack. “Even though I have great respect for Michael O’Hanlon and Ken Pollack and their article in the New York Times, I disagree,” said Sestak. He said the security improvements that are being made in Anbar actually pre-date the escalation. Moreover, he argued these improvements in one part of the country don’t mean much if political success can’t follow:

The political situation is the absolute end game. Because even though you might be able to have an improvement in the military security, how long do we have to be there to change the minds, to the change the hearts of the Iraqis?

Transcript:

REP. JOE SESTAK (D-PA): Who has set the metrics of what success is, that, for example, General Petraeus will come back and report, as we heard him give an update two to three weeks ago at the Pentagon via VTC on how we’re doing there. We at Congress should help establish those benchmarks, so what we’re listening to are very sound metrics that can be compared against benchmarks or trends. Take the weapons that you bring up. At one time, we just thought that there might be, which is still a lot, 30,000 missing. Now, 197,000 missing. I don’t think anyone who understands Iraqi society is very surprised that these weapons, which often we have to give to Iraqi citizens, be found to be missing. But the fact that you can’t even track it with proper serial numbers, so that if we find that this Iraqi militia strike, you find a number of weapons there, there’s no serial numbers or others to follow it up, is dismaying. There are so many pieces, so many complex pieces to this Iraqi situation, that I say this tragic misadventure has so many misadventures within it, and this shows the failure of accountability. And that, in my mind, begins at the very top, from the president, who has changed the reasons why we went into Iraq, right through to our senior policy makers, and even those who are our senior leaders of our military, that have to step back and say “how did we permit ourselves not to protect the armed services from bad judgement, from the failure to be accountable,” as General Shenseki did, and as he said it would take 200,000 troops to bring about this issue. Take just one other example. The oil sharing, the hydrocarbon sharing law, that’s trying to be worked through parliament. Who knows what’s in that. Many people believe we might have gone into this war for oil. I think we went in for a variety of reasons. But the indications from a draft of several months ago that the Kurds were using, is that while we’re pushing, even as the Democratic Party is pushing, to say that progress made on the hydrocarbon sharing law, is something that will be a positive benchmark, if we make it. What’s involved in that power sharing. Is it just to make sure the right revenues were there, or as the draft the Kurds were using, actually shows that there is an undue ability of our oil companies to control the Iraqi profits by controlling the infrastructure and the wells that are there. I mean they’re going to get much more, if the draft is correct, of profits than we would under a normal oil sharing agreement, of these oil companies to a country like Saudi Arabia or others. Heaven forbid that at the end of this time, after all this, if we find out that there’s undue advantage given to our oil companies. As I mentioned just earlier, there is the power of our military and the power of our economy that we’re respected for. But the power of our ideals is where we’re admired. That lady sitting in New York harbor means something. C’mon in and believe in these ideals. That’s what I fought for, for 31 years, and I’ll be dismayed if we don’t do that more. And that’s why this issue that you bring up on arms is important. What kind of accountability do we put in. Could we do it, because they didn’t listen to Gen. Shinseki to have the right amount of troops there, if you were to do this, to have the ability, the manpower, to make sure the things were implemented appropriately.[...]

The political situation is the absolute end game. Because even though you might be able to have an improvement in the military security, how long do we have to be there to change the minds, to the change the hearts of the Iraqis? So that is, you redeploy, like we saw in the papers today, as the British did in Basra, sectarian violence is still there significantly. What is it that will attract parties, leaders in Iraq, not to agitate their militias to violence. What is the incentive to bring in regional nations that have influence, like Iran, not to have undue, destructive influence, but constructive influence. That’s why I believe a date certain. Much like Samuel Johnson said, although it’s not a great quote at times perhaps, “there’s nothing like the prospect of a hanging to focus the mind.” We need to ensure that as the Iraqis, who have had 32 ministries, by which they’re able to pursue their personal fiefdoms, their personal ambitions, under cover of US military security and political security. And those fiefdoms, and their fights and personal ambitions, are being reflected now in the south, in Basra, those three armies there, fighting among themselves and their issues. When do we say, “wait a minute, you have to understand we won’t be here to permit you to do this, stand up and take responsibility.” So, even though I have great respect for Michael O’Hanlon and Ken Pollack and their article in the New York Times, I disagree. Not that, I disagree that there hasn’t been some improvement, particularly in Anbar province in security, which actually began last fall, not, not just since the surge. But that enough should have been brought out, even though it was mentioned at the end of the article, that what does this really bode for political accomdation. The concern I have, is that we’ve abdicated to a four star general, the whole tone of the debate in September. He’s to come in, where it’s supposed to be a president, president’s report, to say “here’s what happened in the military situation.” Where’s the template, the context, for the political measures of success, as Sunnis withdraw from the government. Or as when i was there with Sen. Hagel, and we went to Anbar province several months ago, saw the improvements in security, in the Sunni part, but as they looked to the East, and wanted to be part of the government. We went to the East because the Baghdad government was saying “nah nah no, ” and we asked them, what about the re-Baathification law, that’s supposed to bring them back into the government, the unified government. And the highest levels, after meeting with Prime Minister Maliki and other senior levels, the highest levels of government told us, it was only appeasement to the Sunnis and not important. How long do we keep our men and women there, until we change the incentives to make them say “whoa whoa whoa,” we’re not going to have you have your only personal feelings, believes run a government while our men and women are dying for you. We’re going to set a date - it’s gonna take us a certain amount of time, and it will take a certain amount of time, I’ve gone through the plans, the planning aspects of it, you know, minimum probably 15 up to 24 months, but to say, we’re going to set a date. Here’s your incentive to begin to step to the plate. And Iran, you don’t want, as our National Intelligence Council said, a failed, fractionalized government, or Iraqi state, because you don’t want that instability to overthrow. And bring them together with confidence, by we remain in the region, in our bases we have in several countries there, and on our carrier battle groups and things they do, and deal with confidence in the political,diplomatic sphere. That’s the change in strategy. The last arrow in the arsenal that for some reason we have not used. The road out of Iraq is through Tehran. We need to deal with confidence with that country, we can do it. And when I say engage with them, I mean with consequences for bad behavior on the diplomatic and economic side. You saw the riots that ensued, just last year, early July. That came out because they had raised the gas prices from 25 to 38 cents. We’ve got a lot of ability to influence their behavior. And we should be about that business so the behavior becomes positive. Because the incentive that they want, we won’t be in that country.




Sort Comments By: Top Rated | Date

125 Responses to “Sesktak Warns Iraqi Oil Law Contains ‘Undue Ability Of U.S. Oil Companies To Control Iraqi Profits’”

  1. Zooey Says:

    The "oil law" is a frickin' joke, and the Iraqis would be insane to agree to it.


  2. Egreggious Says:

    But, Zooey, you know the "oil law" is the keystone to winning the GWOT! :D


  3. Dr. Dog Says:

    test


  4. katy Says:

    yea... "heaven forbid"...

    ugh...


  5. Dr. Dog Says:

    I'm writing this right now from my lap top on wireless internet. I'm in Bruce's KO boxing gym right now in Austin, Texas. So far Wayne is a no show.


  6. Frank J Says:

    Another obscure Congressman with a 14% approval rating telling the moonbats what they want to hear.


  7. bilbobaggins Says:

    That has been the objective of the Bush government all along, steal Iraq's oil. For the life of me I can't understand why they think that the Iraqi's would go along with the deal. First we destroy their country and then we get control of 80% of their only real resource. If we really cared about the people in Iraq we would not be attempting to steal the only resource they can use to rebuild their country.

    The next time a neoCON troll says something about Genocide in Iraq, remind them that if we are allowed to steal 80% of their oil profits, we will be the ones committing Genocide because the people in Iraq will starve to death in much greater numbers than they are now because they will have no way to earn an income.


  8. UpFromTheSkies Says:

    ChimpCo had better hurry and find some puppets in the Iraqi government to sign the law. Al Maliki's government is disintegrating a bit more every day.


  9. Dr. Dog Says:

    There is nobody here except two teenagers and their father sparing in the boxing ring. Wayne has not shown up.


  10. bilbobaggins Says:

    Hey folks, let's not step in Francine J's poop on this thread. Just step around the poop, it's really easy.


  11. bilbobaggins Says:

    Oops..didn't realize Dr. Dog was here sh1tting on the floor. Just walk around his poop too. Actually, just walk around all the troll poop. Stepping in it just makes a big stink.


  12. katy Says:

    and, why DOES he "have great respect for Michael O’Hanlon and Ken Pollack and their article in the New York Times" ?

    i hate when politicians dance around, all polite and gentelmanly...
    it's just way past time for mincing words...

    just say you disagreed with their assessment... it doesn't matter what you FEEL about the messengers - just the message...
    and theirs was WRONG...
    ...


  13. Raven Says:

    Comment by Dr. Dog — August 18, 2007 @ 1:05 pm

    Wrong ring, sir.....
    The Vick Memorial Pit Bull Pit is to your right.
    Sir.


  14. Zooey Says:

    But, Zooey, you know the “oil law” is the keystone to winning the GWOT! :D
    Comment by Egreggious — August 18, 2007 @ 1:00 pm

    I have this land I need to sell. It's in Louisiana, and it's just a teeny bit swampy....but I think you're just the guy who needs to buy it. :-D


  15. bilbobaggins Says:

    "ChimpCo had better hurry and find some puppets in the Iraqi government to sign the law. Al Maliki’s government is disintegrating a bit more every day.
    Comment by UpFromTheSkies"

    It's not going to happen. The Kurds have stated that they are against the law and the Iraqi Parliament has said that they are not going to let it happen. And even if it were to happen, it wouldn't last long. The Iraqi's would revolt and then nationalize the oil fields. The only way we would be able to hang on to our ill gotten gains would be to completely subjugate the population of Iraq and continue to occupy the country from now to kingdom come.


  16. Zooey Says:

    I’m writing this right now from my lap top on wireless internet. I’m in Bruce’s KO boxing gym right now in Austin, Texas. So far Wayne is a no show.
    Comment by Dr. Dog — August 18, 2007 @ 1:02 pm

    Liar.


  17. Dr. Dog Says:

    I'll give Wayne 15 more minutes and then I'm going to Super Wal-Mart.


  18. Egreggious Says:

    I’ll give Wayne 15 more minutes and then I’m going to Super Wal-Mart.

    Comment by Dr. Dog — August 18, 2007 @ 1:10 pm

    ... to buy a fresh diaper.


  19. katy Says:

    i heard something the other day about maliki looking for more of a certain sect (sunni?) to join the govment so that he could get more votes to approve this PSA...
    set me straight... anyone?
    ...


  20. Pat Says:

    OIL...what the entire invasion was about from day one. Anyone who doesn't recognize this is as delusional as our resident chimp in charge.

    You chimpy leg humpers can try to change the subject or somehow cast blame on others who question the motives of the administration...but it's abundantly clear that YOU are the folks who despise America and everything it once stood for.


  21. Justice Says:

    The oil companies built the infrastructure,maintain the equipment, they rightly deserve their FAIR share of profit. The problem is they want far more than they are rightfully due.

    Iraqis will unite on THAT issue. Bad enough we invaded their country illegally and killed many innocents and destroyed their lives, jobs, country and their hearts but now they want to steal their national treasure? That will NEVER happen. Bush is a fool, the Iraqi people are very intelligent, tenacious and determined AND the oil BELONGS TO THEM. We should be applying our focus to creating other energy sources HERE at home which would provide jobs AND a new earth safe fuel source and leave these people ALONE.

    Not ONE American would stand for ANY country invading us and attempting to overtake OUR national resources, yet somehow people believe we can do this to Iraq and it's ok? Underestimating the brilliance and fortitude of our fellow beings in the Middle East is King Bushie's fatal flaw the arrogant, smirking wanker that he is.


  22. Dr. Dog Says:

    There are no police officers here either Wayne said he was going to have one referee the boxing match


  23. katy Says:

    HEAR, HEAR, JUSTICE!

    jolly good!


  24. Mrs. Dog Says:

    There are no police officers here either Wayne said he was going to have one referee the boxing match

    Comment by Dr. Dog — August 18, 2007 @ 1:18 pm

    It's true.


  25. Anne Says:

    What? Bush is trying to steal the oil? My gosh, I most certainly did not see that coming! (sarcasm)

    Hopefully, the Iraqis will find a way to keep this from happening. The oil revenue would help them undo some of the damage to their infrastructure that we caused with the invasion. They deserve so much better than what they are getting (which is nothing but pain and suffering), and my heart goes out the them.


  26. Tobey Tall Says:

    and are the demcrats still saying that the occupation is nothing to do Oil

    there in this as well


  27. Tobey Tall Says:

    Mas Murdering Oil Thiefs


  28. Tobey Tall Says:

    This law will lead to all out war


  29. Gregor Samsa Says:

    But the conservative propaganda machine would have us believe that the occupation has nothing to do with Iraq's vat oil reserves.

    Of course, if that were true, there would have been no need to amend Iraq's constitution and/or spend so much time and energy crafting an oil law to "help" Iraq develop a "free market" -which, of course, is anything but free, and is tightly controlled to give Big Oil the upper hand.


  30. dbadass Says:

    I’ll give Wayne 15 more minutes and then I’m going to Super Wal-Mart.

    Comment by Dr. Dog — August 18, 2007 @ 1:10 pm

    Helping to unionize? If not try the local mom and pop for all your purchasing needs. Do you really want to support the homogenization of everytown USA?


  31. Gregor Samsa Says:

    Test...


  32. tarazan Says:

    It will not work...This will work on paper.
    The oil exported thru Basra...A hot spot of Shiate different factions that can never agree on this.
    They still not in agreement among themselves who rules the Basra area.
    In the West , it is dominated by Sunni,and a hot spot of fighting,still we have no control over it.
    In the east there are oil fields,but close to Iranian borders with mixture of Shiate,Kurds . Kirkuk City is another hotspot and a disputed area between Kurds and Arabs,produces about 40% of Iraqi oil.

    Baghdad itself a mixture of Shiate,Sunnis and Kurds does not produce oil.

    If this Iraqi Parliament tried to pass such laws against the will of the Iraqis...it will never work.

    Iraqis,Iranians and Middle Eastern people in general are sensitive to this issue.
    It does not take much feul them over this issue.


  33. Tobey Tall Says:

    $20 trillion profit for 5 years war - 1 million dead - absolutely disgusting is the way the world will view America soon


  34. Mrs. Dog Says:

    Someone call an ambulance! I think Wayne has killed my son!


  35. RUCerious Says:

    “If the Iraqi Parliament approves this law, we will resort to mutiny.”
    Installing democracy at the point of the gun barrel.
    Heckuva Farce, chympie!~


  36. BlueArkansas Says:

    And now we get to the motive behind it all. This asinine "war on terra" has all along been nothing more than a rhetorical shroud to transfer control of the preponderance of the world's oil supply to corporate masters tied to the Shrub regime.


  37. Tobey Tall Says:

    PURE EVIL


  38. RUCerious Says:

    One question remains.
    Why would Rep Sestak respect O'Hanlon and his jackass buddy???


  39. vegasbaby Says:

    just had to vent....

    the Dem's just called for $$$

    I gave them a piece of my mind....

    No more $$$ until:

    Iraq funding is stopped

    Gonzo is impeached

    MPG requirments put back into energy bill

    of course this is just the tip of the iceberg

    I'm sick and tired of the spineless talking heads in D.C. taking my $$$ but not acting on the most obvious concerns on voters minds today...IRAQ, GOVERNMENT CORRUPTION/LYING, AND THE ENVIROMENT.

    enough already....grow some nads for god's sake....and take action...enough committees, and hearings, and investigations....we're done with it all...

    we will never solve IRAQ's thousand years old civil strife

    it is documented at least 10 times that Gonzo lied to congress...Martha did hard time for a stock trade fib...what gives?

    Dingall is in Detroits back pocket...fine, but the rest of the Dem's did not need to cave into giving up new MGP standards that would greatly reduce our oil addiction....

    did you know that the US is at the bottom of the list internationally when it comes to MPG....wonder why that is? the whole world can get better gas mileage than us?

    sorry...just had to vent....back to your regular scheduled programming....


  40. dorfenburg Says:

    Go Dr. Dog, I hope you beat the crap out of Wayne.


  41. katy Says:

    i thought the appointment was at 1pm...
    it's 12:52 in austin...


  42. Tobey Tall Says:

    I dont think it will Work ...... Maliki is damned if he does or he dont , he will be living in America just like the Judge who ordered Saddams death Now lives in London

    this plan is pure evil and the evil people of America voted for this demon and still 23% of Amerricans are still evil

    you dirty evil bastards - 1 million dead


  43. RUCerious Says:

    Wayne commented on another thread he was headed over to the gym.
    Watch Dr. Mutt will claim he "waited" for Wayne and then left..betcha..


  44. Wayne's partner Says:

    Is there a Dr. in the house.
    My lover Wayne just got a beating worse than I give him.


  45. barfly Says:

    "Why would Rep Sestak respect O’Hanlon and his jackass buddy???"

    Comment by RUCerious

    It's a debate tactic.

    "Acknowledge, accomodate, refute."

    Acknowledge that they have certain bona fides in geo-political thinking.

    Accomodate the points they make into an alternate viewpoint.

    Refute what they say, outright, by pointing out their past mistakes.


  46. Egreggious Says:

    It’s a debate tactic.

    “Acknowledge, accomodate, refute.”

    Comment by barfly — August 18, 2007 @ 1:58 pm

    It doesn't seem like a very good tactic in this case.


  47. RUCerious Says:

    good point barfly. Forgot that old trick of faint praise!


  48. katy Says:

    well... i just called bruce's to ask if there was wireless, or otherwise, internet capabilities there... NOPE...
    also, even talked to wayne... he's sound fine! got a kick outta
    hearing about this...

    but, of course...


  49. shane Says:

    Someone call an ambulance! I think Wayne has killed my son!

    Comment by Mrs. Dog — August 18, 2007 @ 1:44 pm

    Maybe you should call, unless you really don't want to. We understand your reluctance.


  50. Egreggious Says:

    well… i just called bruce’s to ask if there was wireless, or otherwise, internet capabilities there… NOPE…

    Comment by katy — August 18, 2007 @ 2:00 pm

    Thanks for checking, katy. I wondered if that might be true.

    Michael Deaver died.


  51. RUCerious Says:

    Watch Dr. Mutt will claim he “waited” for Wayne and then left..betcha..

    Comment by RUCerious — August 18, 2007 @ 1:54 pm

    Calling Dr Mutt, Dr Mutt, where are you??


  52. katy Says:

    “Acknowledge, accomodate, refute.”
    [...]
    Comment by barfly — August 18, 2007 @ 1:58 pm

    well, that answers my question @ 1:07 pm...
    ok... chalk one up for debate skills...

    i'm kinda tired of it though...
    ...


  53. shane Says:

    i thought the appointment was at 1pm…
    it’s 12:52 in austin…

    Comment by katy — August 18, 2007 @ 1:52 pm

    Dr. Dog is probably out east and doesn't know what time it is in Texas.


  54. JoeBlow Says:

    This is a test


  55. Egreggious Says:

    Dr. Dog is probably out east and doesn’t know what time it is in Texas.

    Comment by shane — August 18, 2007 @ 2:04 pm

    He may be out east, but you can bet he'll never be out in the Middle East.


  56. RUCerious Says:

    TP crapping out again, nulling name and email.
    Learn about cookie and session management, kids...


  57. Mrs. Dog Says:

    My son is not out!

    Well, he's out of consciousness.


  58. Raven Says:

    Hey JoeBlow!
    Loud and clear!


  59. shane Says:

    He may be out east, but you can bet he’ll never be out in the Middle East.

    Comment by Egreggious — August 18, 2007 @ 2:07 pm

    Looks like the mutt tucked his tail between his legs and ran off.


  60. Tobey Tall Says:

    BISHKEK, Kyrgyzstan (AP) - The leaders of Russia, China and Iran said Thursday that Central Asia should be left alone to manage its stability and security — an apparent warning to the United States to avoid interfering in the strategic, resource-rich region.


  61. Egreggious Says:

    Walmart must not have wi-fi.


  62. Wayne's partner Says:

    This is a test

    Comment by JoeBlow

    You're hired!


  63. Raven Says:

    Hey, I thought that was a funny one about animal control and the stray dog in my yard, and not so low as to be unfit for posting......


  64. Raven Says:

    But what do I know....


  65. Empire Burlesque Says:

    So far Wayne is a no show.

    Comment by Dr. Dog — August 18, 2007 @ 1:02 pm

    I couldn't imagine a bigger lie beig told, but hey, if you believe it, it's not a lie is it?


  66. Empire Burlesque Says:

    "... absolutely disgusting is the way the world will view America soon..."

    Comment by Tobey Tall — August 18, 2007 @ 1:39 pm

    "will view America soon..."???

    I'm afraid we passed the point of "soon" quite some time ago, Toby.


  67. Wayne Says:

    I’m writing this right now from my lap top on wireless internet. I’m in Bruce’s KO boxing gym right now in Austin, Texas. So far Wayne is a no show.
    Comment by Dr. Dog

    Funny...

    Bruces doesnt have wireless, I was working on weights, then Kay or Katy called there asked for Wayne and I talked to her.

    My police friend didn't come because we figured you were a no show.
    I left 5minutes ago
    Since you were there, describe Bruce, lapdog.


  68. Zooey Says:

    My police friend didn’t come because we figured you were a no show.
    I left 5minutes ago
    Since you were there, describe Bruce, lapdog.
    Comment by Wayne — August 18, 2007 @ 2:22 pm

    **snort**


  69. katy Says:

    bruce has a nice voice...
    so do you, wayne...
    .


  70. RUCerious Says:

    Watch Dr. Mutt will claim he “waited” for Wayne and then left..betcha..
    Comment by RUCerious — August 18, 2007 @ 1:54 pm

    No, I'm not psychic. Just a good bet.


  71. Kevin Good Says:

    Third Beatitude
    Blessed are the meek: for they shall inherit the earth.

    Neo-Third Beatitude
    Get off my damn road you left wing liberal wacko.


  72. Wayne Says:

    bruce has a nice voice…
    so do you, wayne…
    .

    Comment by katy

    Why thank you Katy
    Nice talking to you, that was quite funny =)


  73. Wayne Says:

    Time stamps are eastern time, not central


  74. The Republic of Stupidity Says:

    Since you were there, describe Bruce, lapdog.

    Comment by Wayne — August 18, 2007 @ 2:22 pm

    ...silence... **crickets chirping** ... more silence... **crickets still chirping**... even more silence...

    Mebbe it's time to put out an APB for Da Dawg...


  75. RUCerious Says:

    silence… **crickets chirping** … more silence… **crickets still chirping**… even more silence…
    The Silence of the Mutts


  76. shane Says:

    Mebbe it’s time to put out an APB for Da Dawg…

    Comment by The Republic of Stupidity — August 18, 2007 @ 2:30 pm

    Good thing you're back, there's been some other guy hanging around talking cheese.


  77. katy Says:

    you're welcome, wayne...

    that was one of my spontaneous, why not? moves...
    and free weekend minutes... and yellow.com...

    i bet bruce was a bit weirded out... and you?
    heh...


  78. shane Says:

    Mebbe it’s time to put out an APB for Da Dawg…

    Comment by The Republic of Stupidity — August 18, 2007 @ 2:30 pm

    Or look out on the grass out side the gym and find the dog who can't stop peeing. Don't check out the hydrants, only macho dogs lift their legs. Submissive males squat.


  79. RUCerious Says:

    Good job katy! Now let's hope Doktor Mutt comes back and tries to weasel his way out of this one...


  80. shane Says:

    i bet bruce was a bit weirded out… and you?
    heh…

    Comment by katy — August 18, 2007 @ 2:36 pm

    That was a brilliant move katy. Good thinking on your feet. Thanks for shutting up the pup.


  81. shane Says:

    Dr. Dog, another troll name we won't see around here anymore.


  82. The Republic of Stupidity Says:

    That was a brilliant move katy. Good thinking on your feet. Thanks for shutting up the pup.

    Comment by shane — August 18, 2007 @ 2:39 pm

    Yeah, but you KNOW that clueless blowhard will be back telling the same silly lies soon. Someone ought to copy this exchange off to a word doc and whenever that pointless SoS (Sack of Sh*t) shows up, just copy and paste into the thread he's defiling.


  83. Wayne Says:


    Since you were there, describe Bruce, lapdog.

    Comment by Wayne — August 18, 2007 @ 2:22 pm

    …silence… **crickets chirping** … more silence… **crickets still chirping**… even more silence…

    Mebbe it’s time to put out an APB for Da Dawg…

    Comment by The Republic of Stupidity — August 18, 2007 @ 2:30 pm
    #

    silence… **crickets chirping** … more silence… **crickets still chirping**… even more silence…
    The Silence of the Mutts

    Comment by RUCerious

    Ding ding
    Times up

    Bruce is about 5'7", stocky built like a sherman tank, and currenty shaved bald.

    I am 5'8" long dark blond/lt brown hair with some grey, also stocky, solid, wear glasses and a hearing aid in my right ear, was wearing my greyT shirt with "American Motorcycles An American Tradition" Text and graphic.

    My white mazda truck and Bruces chevy were in the lot, because saturday's 10am boxing class was over and only me, Bruce and one other guy were there in the building.


  84. Wayne Says:

    i bet bruce was a bit weirded out… and you?
    heh…
    Comment by katy

    Yeah, at first he was like who????

    I heard him say Wayne,and told him it is probably for me.

    I go by my nick name Jay, because I am a Wayne Jr =)


  85. Jay Randal Says:

    Call it > THE OIL STEALING ENACTMENT. The Bush Regime plan is to allow BIG OIL companies to steal Iraq's petroleum reserves. They would get 80% of the OIL free of charge and pay a pittance for the other 20%.


  86. ForTruth Says:

    Someone needs to box someone at this point. That was anti-climactic.

    But its funny the troll is a weenie.


  87. gummitch Says:

    Awww, I was sure Mr. Puppy would show up and throw an "arm bar" on Wayne.

    Genius work by Katy!


  88. Zooey Says:

    But its funny the troll is a weenie.
    Comment by ForTruth — August 18, 2007 @ 3:04 pm

    A weenie AND a f*cking liar.

    Surprise!


  89. Wayne Says:

    Genius work by Katy!
    Comment by gummitch

    That was awsome thinking Katy.

    Yeah I am glad she called.
    3rd party verification.
    otherwise it was my word vs lying troll.

    I also took pics of the clock in Bruces by the ring on my iPhone as proof I was there at 1pm.


  90. Zooey Says:

    I also took pics of the clock in Bruces by the ring on my iPhone as proof I was there at 1pm.
    Comment by Wayne — August 18, 2007 @ 3:20 pm

    I find it totally hilarious that the idiot Dog was pretending to be there -- at the wrong time.


  91. katy Says:

    just started giggling, thinking of that conversation...
    "hello - bruce's" ...
    "yea, i wondered if you have the internet there?"...
    "HUH?"...

    i'm sure he thought i was some nut...
    ...

    now, about the Production Stealing Agreement...
    has anyone heard of what i questioned @ 1:14 pm?
    ...


  92. shane Says:

    I find it totally hilarious that the idiot Dog was pretending to be there — at the wrong time.

    Comment by Zooey — August 18, 2007 @ 3:25 pm

    The mudpuppy was probably sitting in his mom's basement in Virginia.


  93. Wayne Says:

    I find it totally hilarious that the idiot Dog was pretending to be there — at the wrong time.
    Comment by Zooey

    Yeah that is funny.

    I was there from 11 till after Katy called at 1:05 or 1:10 and told me Dog was claiming he was there on the none existing wireless connection.

    LMAO

    Ok, got to finish packing and then head to the airport early to get through the security checks before flight time.
    The hotel will have wireless so I won't be off the board all week =)


  94. The Republic of Stupidity Says:

    And still no Dawg sighting...


  95. Wayne Says:

    And still no Dawg sighting…
    Comment by The Republic of Stupidity

    If Mr.P posts on one of his alts, you will see him

    Dog is lying POS Mr. P


  96. Raven Says:

    trial vaccination


  97. Zooey Says:

    Ok, got to finish packing and then head to the airport early to get through the security checks before flight time.
    The hotel will have wireless so I won’t be off the board all week =)
    Comment by Wayne — August 18, 2007 @ 3:31 pm

    Have a great time jumping out of perfectly good aircraft!! :-)



  98. Zooey Says:

    trial vaccination
    Comment by Raven — August 18, 2007 @ 3:38 pm

    We are not immune....


  99. katy Says:

    mr.p posted a short idiocy at the "good reason" thread...

    Comment by Liberator — August 18, 2007 @ 3:07 pm

    i dread the later hours, after the meth rage kicks in...

    be ready to let TP know...
    ...


  100. dbadass Says:

    I realize the topic is boxing but please do not purchase Fiji water.


  101. Zooey Says:

    I realize the topic is boxing but please do not purchase Fiji water.
    Comment by dbadass — August 18, 2007 @ 3:40 pm

    I purchase tap water. :)

    Why shouldn't we buy Fiji water?


  102. Raven Says:

    We are not immune….

    Comment by Zooey

    Apparently... I was trying to chime in on the dog fight, and TP was having none of it....


  103. katy Says:

    take care, wayne... have fun! ...

    y'know... i can't even watch jumping on the teevee...
    things like that make me dizzy...
    ...


  104. Zooey Says:

    Apparently… I was trying to chime in on the dog fight, and TP was having none of it….
    Comment by Raven — August 18, 2007 @ 3:42 pm

    Isn't that frustrating? That kept happening to me last week. Grrrr....


  105. Raven Says:

    Bow wow wow wow, bow wow, woof bow woof woof!


  106. Liberator Says:

    Dog is lying POS Mr. P

    Comment by Wayne — August 18, 2007 @ 3:35 pm
    ------

    Sorry, Wayne. I'm not Dr. William Dog.


  107. The Republic of Stupidity Says:

    Sorry, Wayne. I’m not Dr. William Dog.

    Comment by Liberator — August 18, 2007 @ 3:45 pm

    Whether or not Mr P=Liberator=Tha Dawg doesn't matter. All 3 are POs.

    Seeing as getting "tutored" worked for That Dawg (made him smart enough to NOT show up in Austin...), perhaps Mr P and Libbie-rator would benefit from it too! Jes' sayin'...

    This is as funny as Mr P's classic "Saudis ain't Moslems"...

    BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!


  108. Frank J Says:

    Tough days for the moonbats. Their Al Qaeda friends are getting their collective asses kicked by the USA and not even their spinmisters can keep the news from getting out.

    Congressman Baird sees need for longer U.S. role in Iraq

    http://www.theolympian.com/news/story/192500.html

    U.S. Rep. Brian Baird said Thursday that his recent trip to Iraq convinced him the military needs more time in the region, and that a hasty pullout would cause chaos that helps Iran and harms U.S. security. "I believe that the decision to invade Iraq and the post-invasion management of that country were among the largest foreign-policy mistakes in the history of our nation. I voted against them, and I still think they were the right votes," Baird said in a telephone interview from Washington, D.C. "But we're on the ground now. We have a responsibility to the Iraqi people and a strategic interest in making this work." Baird, a five-term Democrat, voted against President Bush ordering the Iraq invasion — at a time when he was in a minority in Congress and at risk of alienating voters. He returned late Tuesday from a trip that included stops in Israel, Jordan and Iraq, where he met troops, U.S. advisers and Iraqis, whose stories have convinced him that U.S. troops must stay longer.


  109. The Republic of Stupidity Says:

    “I believe that the decision to invade Iraq and the post-invasion management of that country were among the largest foreign-policy mistakes in the history of our nation. I voted against them, and I still think they were the right votes,” Baird said in a telephone interview from Washington, D.C

    All he really said was adults will have to take over for the Boy Emperor and fix the mess he made.


  110. Jay Randal Says:

    Frank that Rep. must be a stupid Blue Dog Democrat.


  111. Probus Says:

    No US oil company should profit from the oil revenues. All the profits must go to the Iraqis themselves. The Bush administration should stay out of the oil law. It is up to the Iraqis to decide how the revenues should be distributed among the different ethnic groups.


  112. Probus Says:

    Sestak is right the progress in Anbar predates the surge. Neo-cons like to cite it as progress as there is no other progress to cite. The most recent violence in Iraq betrays the alleged progress cited by O'Hanlon and Pollack and other war supporters. The lack of political progress means the surge hasn't worked the way Bush said it would.


  113. Jo-Ann Says:

    Many blogs were warning these Blue Dogs that they were handing Bush more than he requested. They have de facto authorized all the illegalities that Bush was guilty of. Six months is too long to correct this mistake. They should have READ the damn bill before rushing to pass it. Bush is great at dissembling and crying 'Hurry, hurry." It's all a game and he's winning.


  114. big papa Says:

    Bushiva and L'il Dick...

    ...should be FORCED to embark on a cross country Iraq tour...

    ...giving townhall type speeches to the Iraqi masses...

    ...to promote their oil law...

    ...IMMEDIATELY!


  115. Well Well Well Says:

    If another CFR/Trilat/Bilderberger gets elected, Demon or RePubic; We will get business as usual. Paul, Gravel & Kusinich are Not CFR
    John Edwards - CFR (D)
    Rudy Giuliani - CFR (R)
    Hillary Clinton - CFR (D)
    John McCain -- CFR (R)
    Barack Obama -- CFR (D)
    Mitt Romney -- CFR (R)
    Christopher Dodd -- CFR (D)
    Fred Thompson -- CFR (R)
    Bill Richardson -- CFR (D)
    Joseph Biden -- CFR (D)
    Newt Gingrich -- CFR (R)
    YTSearch "CFR/NAU"


  116. grumpyhippy Says:

    Why do you think Cheney wants to keep the "Energy Task Force" participants and what their discussions were a secret? They were planning the war! They wanted to, first, invade and therefore disrupt the flow of oil which would and did raise the prices, and then ultimately get control over the oil so they can control the price of oil forever (and so far the war is going great for them!).


  117. Badger Says:

    Bush's Iraq strategy has changed. The American people are ahead of their representatives...they want OUT of IRAQ.
    Bush's previous strategy was.. Victory First.
    Now Bush's strategy is ...WE ARE GETTING OUT. Just not as fast as the critics demand.
    This is a strategy to stall the inevitable, and dump the war in the Democrats lap next year.
    The viet nam war was a disaster for America and its military...but it was A HUGE SuCCESS for the republicans. Even though Nixon's flawed plans resulted in our less than victorius pullout, the Democrats got the blame for being weak , and anti-military. This resulted in Republicans winning the whitehouse for all but 8 years since 1980.
    They are planning the same strategy with Iraq.
    And as far as the oil deal goes...NO OTHER middle east country has an arrangement like the one proposed for Iraq. I think I know why.


  118. MapleStreet Says:

    Could someone explain to me why the sovereign nation of Iraq (as proclaimed by both Shrub and Iraq) would give up the keys to the gold mine ?


  119. Free RePubic Readers Have Sex with Their MOthers Says:

    > Time stamps are eastern time, not central

    Hahahahah. Yes! F#cking hilarious....I havent laughed that hard at a troll
    since Jake got called out for plagarising a real vets record and Mighty Megan Herpmaphrodite claimed she was a lawyer.

    Now one of his other selves, Mr. P, is even disavowing Dr. Dog. Even if hes not really Dog they are undoubtedly buddies...


  120. Keith Says:

    Cheney's Energy Task Force in March 2001 divided up Iraq into "exploration blocks". Link shows map obtained by Judicial Watch showing oilfields and the "blocks".

    http://farm1.static.flickr.com/211/466503255_f7bb4d5e85_o.jpg

    PNAC said we must take that part of the world because of the oil and natural gas. Remember, only the OIL Ministry was protected from looters.


  121. Keith Says:

    I heard a Free Republic reader got caught having sex with his teacher. But the worst part is that he was "home-schooled"!!!


  122. Keith Says:

    Antonia Juhasz, author of “The Bush Agenda,” wrote in an op-ed for The New York Times on March 13:

    “The Iraq National Oil Company would have exclusive control of just 17 of Iraq’s 80 known oil fields, leaving two-thirds of known—and all of its as yet undiscovered—fields open to foreign control,” Juhasz wrote. “The foreign companies would not have to invest their earnings in the Iraqi economy, partner with Iraqi companies, hire Iraqi workers or share new technologies. . . The international oil companies could also be offered some of the most corporate-friendly contracts in the world.”

    So bothered by this is the Bush Administration that it ordered U.S. fighter jets to circle over and buzz the demonstrators, according to labor journalist David Bacon.


  123. Dean Harrington Says:

    Sestak has some very good things to say about how to get out of Iraq and what should happen with the Iraqis fighting against each other for power but the fact of the matter is that Bush did go into Iraq for the Oil. Bush did lie to the American people knowingly about yellow cake and weapons of mass destruction. Bush has squandered American lives, money and prestige in this folly! There is very little interests for those who are behind this grab for oil to see that Iraq is stable and operating in the interests of the Iraqi people. The war will go on, the oil will be extracted and the American people will be poorer for it.
    This neocon fascist wet dream will rebound on the American people in the form of decreased personal security. There will be those late night knocks on the door and Americans carted off to detention to disappear under the label terrorists.
    It is not good enough to allow the destruction of the Constitution that is going on under this administration to continue. This administration and future administrations continuing this fascist direction must be fought tooth and nail. The writing is on the wall, so, take a good hard look because the new nazi empire is upon us!


  124. PaulD Says:

    Oh no - this war has nothing to do with oil... not at all... we're not spinning - we're going to give you the news straight from the generals on the ground...

    This administration has lost ALL credibility

    VIDEO - White House To Write Iraq Report
    http://beta.redlasso.com/Community/ClipPlayer.aspx?i=bac9f5da-e13e-4aff-8a3d-294bed3007b3



Jump to Top

About Think Progress | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2009 Center for American Progress Action Fund
View Most Popular

Advertisement

What We're About

Featured

image
Subscribe to the Progress Report



imageTopic Cloud


Visit Our Affiliated Sites

image image
Reports


Got a hot tip?
Have a hot news tip? We'd love to hear from you. Use the form below to send us the latest.

Name:
Email:
Tip:
(required)


imageArchives


imageBlog Roll