Think Progress

Kristol: Let’s ‘Stretch Our Army And Marines’ For ‘Another Year Or So’ In Iraq»

On Fox News this morning, Weekly Standard editor William Kristol said that the escalation in Iraq should be extended at least “another six months” or even “another year or so.” “Is the cost of losing in Iraq great enough that we need to stretch our Army and Marines for another year or so,” asked Kristol rhetorically. “I think the President’s gonna make that decision.”

Kristol also attempted to spin the National Intelligence Estimate (NIE) released yesterday, which described a failure of the escalation to successfully provide sufficient security for Iraqis, heralding it as proof that “the surge clearly is working” and that current troop levels should be maintained for “another six months or so.” Watch it:

Screenshot

Kristol’s hawkish desire to “stretch our Army and Marines” for “another year or so” is in direct contradiction to the recommendations of the Joint Chiefs Of Staff, whose outgoing chairman, Gen. Peter Pace, “is likely to convey concerns by the Joint Chiefs that keeping well in excess of 100,000 troops in Iraq through 2008 will severely strain the military.”

But disregarding the views of the Joint Chiefs of Staff is nothing new for Kristol. In December 2006, when the Bush administration began arguing for the current troop escalation, the Joint Chiefs unanimously disagreed with the strategy. For his part, Kristol has never served in the military and was one of the most cocksure voices pushing for the current escalation strategy.

Additionally, Kristol’s interpretation of the NIE is dishonest. While the report observed some “measurable but uneven improvements” in Iraq’s security situation, it also cautioned that violence will remain high, the national government will become more “precarious” and the refugee crisis will continue to worsen due to sectarian violence. Hardly a situation that can be deemed as “clearly working.”

Digg It!

146







Sort Comments By: Top Rated | Date

146 Responses to “Kristol: Let’s ‘Stretch Our Army And Marines’ For ‘Another Year Or So’ In Iraq”


  1. Tobey Tall Says:

    ha ha ha ha , this guys a real prick


  2. chad Says:

    If I was in the military I would be pissed that the administration continues to take the word of outside sources rather than the opinion of their generals and soldiers. Isn’t that the true meaning of support the troops?


  3. chad Says:

    Anybody read the Op-Ed in the New York Times from the 82nd Airborne?


  4. Flamethrower Says:

    He knows by late next year R’s will be able to bash D’s for cut-and-running again. And D’s will sit by and let it happen.


  5. Tobey Tall Says:

    Is the military covenant broken?

    The Guardian reports that there is growing anger among the forces that the Military Covenant, which says soldiers should expect fair treatment from the state for putting their lives in danger, is not being upheld.

    http://blogs.guardian.co.uk/ news/ archives/ 2007/ 08/ 15/ is_the_military_covenant_broken.html


  6. Tobey Tall Says:

    The military covenant states that while a soldier will put his life on the line for his country , he expects his fellow countrymen to look out for the best of his interests

    And we are failing that Covenant Big time

    28, 000 soldiers wounded and being thrown out from the hospitals


  7. O. Bigfoot Says:

    I hear from military people all the time about how noble and effective and successful our efforts in Iraq are. We should listen to them equally if we are going to listen to the naysayers.

    We simply cannot abandon Iraq. And we won’t, regardless of who is elected President, and regardless of which party controls congress. That much has already been proven.

    The Democrats may waffle, and spew a lot of hot air, to get (re-)elected, but when the rubber meets the road, we won’t be leaving Iraq any time soon.


  8. Tobey Tall Says:

    How the Military Covenant is totally failing troops

    Gillan’s story that refers to the case of a civilian typist with the RAF receiving a payment of £484,000 after injuring her thumb at work “while a 23-year-old paratrooper, Ben Parkinson, who will need care for the rest of his life after a serious landmine injury, will be given £152,150″.


  9. drew_ill Says:

    I think stretching Kristol’s bottom lip up over his head and tucking it into his a$$crack is a better strategy.


  10. alp3 Says:

    I hear from military people all the time about how noble and effective and successful our efforts in Iraq are. We should listen to them equally if we are going to listen to the naysayers.

    -o bigfoot

    some people say…


  11. barfly Says:

    “The Democrats may waffle, and spew a lot of hot air, to get (re-)elected, but when the rubber meets the road, we won’t be leaving Iraq any time soon.”

    Comment by O. Bigfoot

    Next spring at the latest.

    Republicans in Congress and running for pres. can’t afford to have the biggest mistake in US political history hanging around their necks just before an election.


  12. Hubris Sonic Says:

    is it wrong to want to beat this guy with a piece of rebar until i get tired?


  13. raynman Says:

    In addition to the time period known as Friedman Units, I think we should add Supplemental Units Created by Kristol Militarily Empty


  14. A Patriot Acting Says:

    The Democrats may waffle, and spew a lot of hot air, to get (re-)elected, but when the rubber meets the road, we won’t be leaving Iraq any time soon.

    Comment by O. Bigfoot — August 24, 2007 @ 11:50 am

    “”we” won’t be leaving Iraq any time soon”
    “WE”? are you in Iraq? Or just another chickenhawk repuke who thinks typing pro-war bs from your mother’s basement counts as fighting the good fight?


  15. Hubris Sonic Says:

    Is it wrong to want to beat the living crap out of this guy with a piece of rebar?


  16. Tobey Tall Says:

    is it wrong to want to beat this guy with a piece of rebar until i get tired?

    Not at all , it me with the problem

    I want to cut his D()ck off and ram it down his throat


  17. Blame Bush Says:

    I can’t afford to go to college because I’m too stupid. I therefore cannot attain any scholarship. It’s all Bush’s fault.

    I drive a beat-up car, and it broke down this morning. It’s all Bush’s fault.

    This list will continue, as many more mistakes in my life are George W. Bush’s fault.


  18. Blame Bush Says:

    Comment by A Patriot Acting — August 24, 2007 @ 11:58 am

    Poor baby had to read the word “WE.”

    It’s all Bush’s fault.


  19. Tobey Tall Says:

    O. Bigfoot why dont you type your stuff into aljazeera.com you could turn public opinion against America far faster than Bush


  20. UpFromTheSkies Says:

    What is the percentage of estimated Al Qaeda fighters in Iraq compared to the thousands of sectarian insurgents? Haven’t the Generals themselves said it’s about 1% of the total number of guerrilla fighters? So we’re supposed to stay in Iraq forever, depleting the national treasury and the lives of our soldiers for a handful of foreign fighters who would be easily dealt with by the Iraqi authorities themselves once they sort out their own civil war?

    Or are we really in Iraq for oil and Israel and that’s what Mr. Kristol is truly all about?


  21. Blame Bush Says:

    I actually have to type this sentence. It’s all Bush’s fault.


  22. barfly Says:

    This list will continue, as many more mistakes in my life are George W. Bush’s fault.

    Comment by Blame Bush

    Well, you voted for him, so suck it up, and soldier on, little chickenhawk.


  23. The Republic of Stupidity Says:

    This list will continue, as many more mistakes in my life are George W. Bush’s fault.

    Comment by Blame Bush — August 24, 2007 @ 12:00 pm

    Irrational, meaningless comment. No facts, no position. Just nonsense.


  24. LividLib Says:

    is it wrong to want to beat this guy with a piece of rebar until i get tired?

    Comment by Hubris Sonic — August 24, 2007 @ 11:57 am

    yes, it is wrong.
    being tired is a lame excuse for stopping. don’t “beat and run”!


  25. gummitch Says:

    Irrational, meaningless comment. No facts, no position. Just nonsense.

    Comment by The Republic of Stupidity — August 24, 2007 @ 12:03 pm

    And FoxNews wonders why their “funny” news show was a bust. You see, this troll is posting what passes for “humor” among the neocons. Har har.


  26. chimpeach Says:

    A couple of questions for all the war-loving neo-cons and chickenhawks:

    1. Would you say there is some point at which a soldier’s combat deployment should end? I mean, is there a limit to the amount of time a soldier can be on the battlefield, after which he is no longer effective? A point in time after which he becomes a danger to himself and others?

    2. If you answer “yes”, what would that length of time be? And how would you know what it should be, being the cowardly little sh*t-talker that you are?

    3. If you answer “no”, are you f*cking retarded?!!


  27. Blame Bush Says:

    Comment by barfly — August 24, 2007 @ 12:02 pm

    Where do you get that I voted for such a meanie pants? I am a liberal just like you. I love you. Please don’t give more power to the trolls.


  28. O. Bigfoot Says:

    “O. Bigfoot why dont you type your stuff into aljazeera.com you could turn public opinion against America far faster than Bush

    Comment by Tobey Tall — August 24, 2007 @ 12:02 pm”

    What, you mean this ISN’T aljazeera.com? Well heck…


  29. barfly Says:

    Comment by Blame Bush

    You’re not fooling anyone, P.


  30. Blame Bush Says:

    Comment by The Republic of Stupidity — August 24, 2007 @ 12:03 pm

    I see. One of the Republicanoids, being you, who wastes their time hating on victims of George W. Bush’s executive reign.

    I almost feel sorry for you, troll.


  31. Zimzone Says:

    The Kristol Kid lies again.

    Any troop extension should have Billy Boy leading the charge.

    Sniveling, self-absorbed, sniping strawman = Billy ‘the kid’ Kristol


  32. Blame Bush Says:

    Comment by gummitch — August 24, 2007 @ 12:05 pm

    I know, right. Fox News….eeww. Their high ratings make my stomach turn.


  33. Tweedster Says:

    Does anyone have any idea what business interests Kristol is tied to? He’s got to be making money off of Iraq in ways beside his bloated “pundit” salary.


  34. Jim G Says:

    Why does any one listen to this guy? Why doesn’t he go to Iraq for 15 months and then maybe he would have some credibility.


  35. PeterW Says:

    I wonder what everyone’s excuse will be when the summer lull (though the most violent summer yet) is over and the killing goes through the roof again. Will they talk about “measurable progress on the security front”? I’m guessing they will.


  36. Vet Says:

    He was on Today this morning, too. Same old BS: Another six months, another six months, another six months, etc., etc., etc.

    When will someone in the MSM grow a pair of cajones and call these guys on this??? The rolling six month extenstion will NEVER end!


  37. dim wit Says:

    I love how Fox “News” references the Weakly Standard as an independent source even though Rupert Murdoch owns both of them.


  38. Blame Bush Says:

    Comment by barfly — August 24, 2007 @ 12:07 pm

    I blame Bush for being turned down for a loan.


  39. O. Bigfoot Says:

    “Next spring at the latest.

    Republicans in Congress and running for pres. can’t afford to have the biggest mistake in US political history hanging around their necks just before an election.

    Comment by barfly — August 24, 2007 @ 11:55 am”

    Uh-huh. And your Democrats said it was going to be this past spring at the latest.

    By next spring, our continued success in Iraq will be well documented, whether you choose to believe it or not is up to you.

    There will be no mood in either party to quit while we are ahead. Turning tail while winning will not win elections.

    The front-runners of both parties have already pledged to continue the fight.

    Watch, and learn.


  40. Tutmosis Says:

    Sure, Straussian/Fascist Kristol wants the military to be stretched out into non-existence just as he wants to destroy this democracy once and for all. This man is madness and evil - all rolled into one. He needs psychiatric intervention and soon!


  41. upside00 Says:

    Why won’t this irrelevant A$$Klown just STF up!!!

    Luckily that logo on the bottom left of the screen is all you need to know about how rediculous this Chickenhawk NeoCon is!

    He needs to move to Tel Aviv and take his butt-hole buddy Joe L with him.


  42. Blame Bush Says:

    Comment by Vet — August 24, 2007 @ 12:10 pm

    You can always blame bush. It works for me! Makes me feel sorry for myself in no time.


  43. tutmosis Says:

    Just google William Kristol and see his involvement in PNAC (Project for a new american century) and their composition of the patriot act well in advance of 911….his grandfather (Irving Kristol) is dubbed “Grandfather of the Neocon Fascist Movement” aka: Bush regime.


  44. tutmosis Says:

    Who’s giving this moron any legitimate time on the air anyway? He’s nothing but a mentally ill windbag who is intent on driving this democracy into the ground to bring about the rise of a fascist dictatorship. Everyone knows his gig and is well onto this demented sicko.


  45. r€nato Says:

    Just like we’ve all been saying… nothing will change until 1/20/09.

    Of course that’s just a coincidence.


  46. r€nato Says:

    the military is already stretched to the breaking point. Why doesn’t Kristol enlist? I’d like to see him stretched a bit.


  47. Blame Bush Says:

    I blame Bush for that human-rights-violating show, ‘To Catch a Predator.’

    I don’t think I can forgive him for what he has caused our healthy nation. Running from the police used to be easy.


  48. nanlichi Says:

    Well O. Bigfoot, if you are right about staying in Iraq, you have some tough decisions ahead of you with 5 boys, the oldest being 14.

    It’s easy to support Bush’s War when you don’t have a dog in the hunt, but would you really sacrifice your kid’s arms, legs, brain, life for Bush’s catastrophic mistake?

    Please take that as a rhetorical question and don’t answer. You will of course respond here with some patriotic pap, but you might answer that to your wife.


  49. Vet Says:

    You can always blame bush. It works for me! Makes me feel sorry for myself in no time.

    Comment by Blame Bush — August 24, 2007 @ 12:11 pm
    ————————
    I notice that you don’t address my question - you just spout garbage - which is because you have no answer.

    Here’s an idea: Go visit your local Army recruiter and be the man you wish you were.


  50. chimpeach Says:

    Blame Bush

    You’re right. We shouldn’t blame Bush for the war he started. We shouldn’t blame him for telling us there were WMDs when there weren’t. We shouldn’t blame him for leaving Osama bin Laden at Tora Bora and launching a war against a country that had nothing to do with 9/11 and was not a threat to us. We shouldn’t blame Bush for all the lies he’s told. We shouldn’t blame Bush for all the people he’s responsible for killing.

    We shouldn’t blame Bush for anything. He’s the Bubble Boy. He can do anything he wants. His daddy can give him a company to run and when it folds, he gets to keep lots of money. He can skip out on the draft. Daddy fixed that for him. He can even skip out on the Guard duty he signed up for. Can’t blame him for that. Can’t blame him for ignoring the warnings about 9/11 and the warnings about the levees in New Orleans. He’s not responsible for anything. He’s the president and can do anything he wants. But, if things go bad, he’s not responsible for it, because braindead turds like you want to keep him in his protective bubble.


  51. O. Bigfoot Says:

    “Please take that as a rhetorical question and don’t answer. You will of course respond here with some patriotic pap, but you might answer that to your wife.

    Comment by nanlichi — August 24, 2007 @ 12:15 pm”

    Nothing rhetorical about it.

    We already discussed in another thread here on TP about how my oldest (who is actually my wife’s son from her first marriage) is entering a Military Academy next year, just as his grandfather did.

    This is with both his mother’s, and his father’s, blessing. And is being paid for by his grandparents.

    In our home, and in our family, we support our country, our troops, and our President.


  52. Vet Says:

    In our home, and in our family, we support our country, our troops, and our President.

    Comment by O. Bigfoot — August 24, 2007 @ 12:18 pm
    ————————-
    It’s good to know you supported Pres. Clinton during all his scandals! I was worried you were a hypocrite!


  53. Blame Bush Says:

    Comment by Vet — August 24, 2007 @ 12:17 pm

    What are you talking about? I was just giving you some wholesome advice, that’s all.


  54. barfly Says:

    “By next spring, our continued success in Iraq will be well documented, whether you choose to believe it or not is up to you.”

    The current head of media liason is on C-Span right now, talking about the difficulties she’s experienced getting out the good news in Iraq - and given this chance to demonstrate the great successes “on the ground” that the traditional media just aren’t reporting, she gives the truly impressive example of ” the opening of a kebab stand, that wasn’t there the preceding week.”

    Yup, I’m convinced.


  55. tarazan Says:

    And how much military experience did Kristol accumulate in his life outside Fox Network Studios to make such assessments.

    While soldiers are dying in Iraq,Kristol is looking to extend war time in Iraq..looking also to help Bush’s legacy of ‘Bring’em on’.

    This is not the first time he and other Neocons claimed six more months are now needed to bring us close to victory.


  56. The Republic of Stupidity Says:

    Im a retard and have nothing to say except

    “Irrational, meaningless comment. No facts, no position. Just nonsense.”

    Doesnt matter what the comment is thats all i have to say cause im retarded


  57. O. Bigfoot Says:

    In fact, just last night, our oldest came home from school yesterday and during the course of our after school conversation he asked me to please do him a favor: “Don’t vote for Bill Richardson.” (We live in New Mexico, if you didn’t already know that.)

    I stated not to worry, I hadn’t yet, and didn’t plan on changing anything.


  58. upside00 Says:

    In our home, and in our family, we support our country, our troops, and our President.

    Comment by O. Bigfoot — August 24, 2007 @ 12:18 pm

    As we do in my home, except I respect the OFFICE of the President, not the clown currently codpiecing his way through his last lame duck term.

    Being a Vietnam vet and having some basic intelligence, I have seen what bad leadership does and we now have even worse leadership then we did when we were in the Vietnam CLusterf@ck.

    I just hope your child survivesphysically and mentally. But they might be long odds.


  59. ronjazz Says:

    I hear from military people all the time about how noble and effective and successful our efforts in Iraq are. We should listen to them equally if we are going to listen to the naysayers.

    We simply cannot abandon Iraq. And we won’t, regardless of who is elected President, and regardless of which party controls congress. That much has already been proven.

    The Democrats may waffle, and spew a lot of hot air, to get (re-)elected, but when the rubber meets the road, we won’t be leaving Iraq any time soon.

    Comment by O. Bigfoot — August 24, 2007 @ 11:50 am

    you lie all the time.


  60. O. Bigfoot Says:

    “It’s good to know you supported Pres. Clinton during all his scandals! I was worried you were a hypocrite!

    Comment by Vet — August 24, 2007 @ 12:20 pm”

    Nahh..during the Clinton Presidency, Charlton Heston was my President.

    Actually, I did support Clinton’s Welfare Reform, and maybe one or two other things. But certainly didn’t support his military excercises on U.S. soil which resulted in the slaughter at Ruby Ridge and Waco. Nor Clinton’s stormtroopers stealing kids and sending them to Cuba.

    I havn’t had to worry about President Bush attacking our own people. He knows who the enemy is.

    And I havn’t had to worry about President Bush’s personal indescretions, as there havn’t been any.


  61. Blame Bush Says:

    Comment by The Republic of Stupidity — August 24, 2007 @ 12:22 pm

    I blame Bush for you blaming Bush out of the bush.


  62. ronjazz Says:

    What, you mean this ISN’T aljazeera.com? Well heck…

    Comment by O. Bigfoot — August 24, 2007 @ 12:06 pm

    Usually it’s up to us to demonstrate your level of ignorance. Now you’ve taken that job on y8ourself. Are you still sending money to Al Qaeda as well?


  63. O. Bigfoot Says:

    “you lie all the time.

    Comment by ronjazz — August 24, 2007 @ 12:25 pm”

    And here’s ronjazz! Which his illuminating commentary! Welcome back, ronjazz! How’s your mother this morning?


  64. Blame Bush Says:

    Comment by O. Bigfoot — August 24, 2007 @ 12:27 pm

    How could you possible achieve anything in life without blaming Bush?


  65. Vet Says:

    And I havn’t had to worry about President Bush’s personal indescretions, as there havn’t been any.

    Comment by O. Bigfoot — August 24, 2007 @ 12:27 pm
    ———————————–
    Could your IQ be any lower???

    Bush LIED in order to launch an illegal war, but God forbid he cheats on his wife!!! Nice priorities.

    WHY ARE YOU STILL ONLINE??? GO TO YOUR RECRUITER AND SIGN UP - BE THE MAN YOU WISH YOU WERE!!!


  66. Tobey Tall Says:

    Sorry Bush you have failed to bring security to the Iraqi people after all that was the idea of the Surge

    Get out , you cant even bring electricity or water to them


  67. ronjazz Says:

    The front-runners of both parties have already pledged to continue the fight.

    Watch, and learn.

    Comment by O. Bigfoot — August 24, 2007 @ 12:10 pm

    more lies. what a surprise.


  68. The High Road into the Null Anus of God Says:

    >we won’t be leaving Iraq any time soon.

    Good to see Bigtwat is happy to give as many american lives as necessary to ensure that Iraqis have the right to live in a country that “has no law that contradicts islam”.

    Good to see that Bigtwat is happy to give as many american lives as necessary to ensure that Iraqis have the right to a pro-iranian, pro-syrian government that supports and funds groups like Hamas and Hezbollah.

    Good to hear that Bigtwat supports Al-Maliki because that is the leader the Iraqi democracy chose.

    Because thats what iraqis having the freedom to choose is all about, right Bigtwat?

    (waiting for you to explain to me how we can avoid all these things happeneing if we just apply enough military force)


  69. gummitch Says:

    In our home, and in our family, we support our country, our troops, and our President.

    Comment by O. Bigfoot — August 24, 2007 @ 12:18 pm

    In my home and my family, we support our country, our troops and the Constitution. We also recognize that, for much of our nation’s history, domestic and foreign policy has been formulated to serve the needs of the wealthy and powerful and quite often does little to serve the needs of the rest of us.

    We also recognize that a wise person learns from one’s mistakes and knows when it’s idiocy to throw good money after bad.


  70. MurkanBurgerBoy Says:

    I thought Bill Kristol was pretty funny when he played that homosexual character in the sitcom SOAP. I see he’s still doing outrageous comedy routines.


  71. B K Says:

    Crystal can’t spend 1 day in Iraq, as a Soldier. But sits in a
    cushy office, advising the poor Troops that are already burnt
    out to spend yet another year with a bullseye painted on
    their backs. Pathetic read area swine. So typical of republicans.
    Christ these people make you want to vomit.


  72. Blame Bush Says:

    Faiz and Amanda must be out to lunch.

    I blame Bush.


  73. kelso Says:

    After seeing this guy on the daily show again, it’s clear that he doesn’t really believe the garbage that comes out of his mouth.

    His stances on these issues are nothing but a paycheck. It’s his job to be an ass. What I can’t understand is why he’s taken seriously any network other than FOX. It seems that as long as you take the pro-war position, no matter how assinine your statements are, you’ll always be taken ’seriously’.


  74. Blame Bush Says:

    Comment by Vet — August 24, 2007 @ 12:30 pm

    Bush lied…Frence fries are too fried….Merv Griffin died…I pour Coca-Cola on termites.

    I blame Bush.


  75. ronjazz Says:

    We already discussed in another thread here on TP about how my oldest (who is actually my wife’s son from her first marriage) is entering a Military Academy next year, just as his grandfather did.

    This is with both his mother’s, and his father’s, blessing. And is being paid for by his grandparents.

    In our home, and in our family, we support our country, our troops, and our President.

    Comment by O. Bigfoot — August 24, 2007 @ 12:18 pm

    No you don’t. You sacrifice your wife’s son so that you don’t have to actually do anything about your fake cause and your phony patriotism. Anybody that sends their kid into the military during a Republican administration is just sending them to enrich the aleady bloated pigs at the trough. Shame on you. Not that you have a conscience.


  76. Jim Says:

    What a dick. Kristol is the typical neo-con coward. pretty brave with other peoples lives.


  77. The High Road into the Null Anus of God Says:

    >In my home and my family, we support our country, our troops and the >Constitution.

    Can you envision any situation where supporting one of these three things would not be supporting one or more of the others?

    yes or no?


  78. ronjazz Says:

    I stated not to worry, I hadn’t yet, and didn’t plan on changing anything.

    Comment by O. Bigfoot — August 24, 2007 @ 12:23 pm

    you have the best drugs in New Mexico. Your mother must have sampled all of them when she was pregnant with you.


  79. ronjazz Says:

    What a dick. Kristol is the typical neo-con coward. pretty brave with other peoples lives.

    Comment by Jim — August 24, 2007 @ 12:36 pm

    exactly like bigmouth the sissy.


  80. O. Bigfoot Says:

    “more lies. what a surprise.

    Comment by ronjazz — August 24, 2007 @ 12:31 pm”

    Yup, I’m a liar, just like these guys:

    http://kcindymedia.org/ newswire/ display/ 73368/ index.php


  81. The High Road into the Null Anus of God Says:

    >is entering a Military Academy next year, just as his grandfather did.

    all this flaghumping military namedropping is sounding suspiciously familiar..
    methead, is that you?


  82. Blame Bush Says:

    Comment by ronjazz — August 24, 2007 @ 12:34 pm

    If I stop blaming Bush, could you seriously shut up? Accusing parents of “sending their kid to a military academy for the sake of a Republican administration” makes one classified as the “loony type,” wouldn’t you agree?

    I blame Bush for bringing out your natural political-hackish state.


  83. Blame Bush Says:

    Comment by The High Road into the Null Anus of God — August 24, 2007

    I blame Bush for causing you to feel comfortable in revealing your terrorist-humping state of mind.


  84. NorCalBill Says:

    He was on Today this morning, too. Same old BS: Another six months, another six months, another six months, etc., etc., etc.

    When will someone in the MSM grow a pair of cajones and call these guys on this??? The rolling six month extenstion will NEVER end!

    And the saddest part regarding the Today show appearance is concerned, is that he followed the call by Senator Warner for 5,000 troops to be withdrawn by Christmas — but of course he wouldn’t vote to force any timelines on Bush.

    So the Today show has Warner as a starting point — a Senator who occasionally sees the disaster that is Iraq, but somehow can’t bring himself to vote for a real change — and then has to balance that radical call for 5,000 troops to be withdrawn by the “Serious Person” Kristol.


  85. The High Road into the Null Anus of God Says:

    Blame Bush I’m sure you were as deeply troubled by the endless investigations of clinton’s christmas card list and sex life, right?


  86. O. Bigfoot Says:

    “you have the best drugs in New Mexico. Your mother must have sampled all of them when she was pregnant with you.

    Comment by ronjazz — August 24, 2007 @ 12:38 pm”

    More wonderful and relevant commentary by that fine liberal representative, ronjazz!

    Actually, my mother did grow up in the 1960’s, so she may have sampled of the era, however, she’s never lived in New Mexico.

    I suggest either knowing of what you speak, or keeping silent. Then you don’t show your ignorance uduly.


  87. The High Road into the Null Anus of God Says:

    >in revealing your terrorist-humping state of mind.

    ah, I hate bush to therefore I love terrorists, right?

    my enemies enemy is my friend,right?

    Saddam hated our enemy Iran so therefore he was our friend, right?
    how did that work out for you?

    maybe you could answer some of my questions or encourage your cellmate Bigtwat to do so instead of simply hurling baseless allegations that everyone that hates bush loves terrorists..


  88. michael cochran Says:

    everybody’s talking at me,I can’t hear a word they say,just the echos in my mind.


  89. Aimee Says:

    Well the GOP/Oil Compaines are hoping that they will have secured the OIL appropriations by then. It’s about power and greed, plus they truly want to bomb Iran, and if Iran fights back the GOP + Lieberman need troops there at the border.


  90. The High Road into the Null Anus of God Says:

    you didnt answer so I’ll ask again:

    >In my home and my family, we support our country, our troops and the >Constitution.

    Can you envision any situation where supporting one of these three things would not be supporting one or more of the others?

    yes or no?


  91. Blame Bush Says:

    Comment by The High Road into the Null Anus of God — August 24, 2007

    I was deeply troubled. To me, defending Bill Clinton’s humping life was the only thing I could defend about his presidency. For that, I somehow blamed Bush (while he was Governor).

    I am for the right of presidents (to date, only Bill has accepted) to hump 3+ times-per-day in the Oval office, for them to redefine the presidential salary into a “nymphodential salary,” because that’s the only thing they should do with their time — hump and think about humping sweatily.

    I blame Bush.


  92. Grand Moff Texan Says:

    I hate bush to therefore I love terrorists, right?

    Pfft. Bush has been the best thing that ever happened to international terrorism.
    .


  93. Grand Moff Texan Says:

    we support our country, our troops and the Constitution

    Well, lessee: the country wants to end the war, the troops’ lives are being pissed away with nothing to show for it, and Bush keeps shredding the constitution.

    So, you’re voting for Obama, I presume?
    .


  94. O. Bigfoot Says:

    “No you don’t. You sacrifice your wife’s son so that you don’t have to actually do anything about your fake cause and your phony patriotism. Anybody that sends their kid into the military during a Republican administration is just sending them to enrich the aleady bloated pigs at the trough. Shame on you. Not that you have a conscience.

    Comment by ronjazz — August 24, 2007 @ 12:34 pm”

    So I take it you would have supported my sons entry into the military had it been ordered by a Democrat…ala’ Korea or Viet Nam? Interesting.


  95. TerrytheTurtle Says:

    That mofo is always cheap with other people’s lives.


  96. Blame Bush Says:

    Comment by O. Bigfoot — August 24, 2007 @ 12:56 pm

    I blame Bush for not following the directive of “Ronald Jazzera”, to have Ted Kennedy nominate your stepson to his military academy, with an attachment your son would sign — Pledge A-6, Providing aid to Al-Qaeda, later to blame Bush for democrat stupidity.

    I blame Bush for EVERYTHING. Progressive patriotism defined — Agree with EVERYTHING WE SAY, or else you are guilty of treason.


  97. The High Road into the Null Anus of God Says:

    >I was deeply troubled.

    Yeah uhhh huhh.. im suuuuure you were…..”we know where the weapons are”…”i was deeply troubled that clinton was impeached over lying under oath about the earthshattering matter of a blowjob”

    wish we could just get bush or cheney under oath about ANYTHING.. for people who claim to be religious, they are awfully phobic about putting their hand on a bible and swearing to tell the truth..


  98. bilbobaggins Says:

    So Kristol things that another 600 to 1000 deaths is worth what? Does he really think that the Iraqi’s will have a functioning government in 6 to 12 months. What is this guy smoking? I would like to try some of it.


  99. bg Says:

    #60
    Ruby Ridge happened under Bush 1.
    Waco happened because an idiot who thought he was god decided to burn himself and his followers up.
    Sending a kid back to live with his father seemed like the right thing to do. I guess you disagree with that, but that’s all that was about.


  100. The High Road into the Null Anus of God Says:

    Bigtwat’s logic : Supporting your leaders = supporting your country = supporting your Constitution.

    There is no distinction in his mind. Mindsets like these are the type that let to things like the holocaust… the king can do no wrong..


  101. big papa Says:

    Baghdad Bill…


  102. Makarios Says:

    Supporting your leaders = supporting your country = supporting your Constitution

    This is exactly right. If you knew what the meaning of “constitution” is, then you wouldn’t sound so ignorant.


  103. Dave C Says:

    This is exactly right. If you knew what the meaning of “constitution” is, then you wouldn’t sound so ignorant.

    Every Republican spouts that crap until a Democrat is in office. Then it’s their right to do the opposite & question the President. What a crock of shit. Given all of the f*ckups that have happened in the last 6 years it’s mutually exclusive to support your country & support GWB.


  104. RUCerious Says:

    Let’s stretch Kristol out on a rack for a year or so, then finish it up with a hearty round of waterboarding.


  105. Makarios Says:

    Not only does the military need to stay for another year or so, but they WILL stay for another year or so.

    Dems and Reps already agree on that one.


  106. pbg Says:

    How many of our troops are fluent Arabic speakers?
    How many officers?
    How many officers in charge of field operations are dependent upon Iraqi interpreters in order to know what’s going on?

    How can Americans pacify a nation in which they can’t carry on an ordinary conversation?
    How can we determine who our allies are if we can’t understand what they’re saying?
    Americans will be played for chumps unless this changes. And it won’t.


  107. Makarios Says:

    Comment by pbg — August 24, 2007 @ 1:24 pm

    Typical Lefto-Defeatist Negative-Nancy


  108. Jack Says:

    Let this m/f’r sign up and we will stretch him in Iraq.


  109. upside00 Says:

    Americans will be played for chumps unless this changes. And it won’t.

    Comment by pbg — August 24, 2007 @ 1:24 pm

    America already is! Go oversoeas and see the reaction when they find out you are an American. They just can’t believe this country has sunk to such a low level and that Commander Codpiece was RE-elected!

    They feel sorry for those of us who have to live under this NeoCon A$$Klown Flying Circus .. trouble is, it also impacts the rest of the world as well.


  110. missmolly Says:

    Why does anybody even listen to William Kristol on military matters? Does he have some kind of military expertise I’m not aware of?

    People who DO have military expertise are saying that our military is currently about as stretched as it can go. There comes a point where the horse is running as fast as it can go, and it won’t get any faster no matter how much you whip it.


  111. Dave C Says:

    It’s one thing for posters on a site like this to have not served in the military. But how can anyone justify the long list of architects of this war who would not stand up & fight for their country when their country called & they were fit for combat? Can any Rep troll on this board defend that fact that Bush, Cheney, Rove, Wolfowitz, Ashcroft & a whole host of the other loons (Delay, Frist etc) never served in the U.S. military? Kristol did nothing either but he’s the biggest chickenhawk going. So by all means toss your limp verbal grenades but spend at least a second and come up with a reason why all of these folks with hardons for war never served.


  112. big papa Says:

    Karma says…

    …Baghdad Bill…

    …deserves to be…

    …collateral damage…


  113. TerrytheTurtle Says:

    This is your brain on ‘Kristol math’


  114. upside00 Says:

    Why does anybody even listen to William Kristol on military matters? Does he have some kind of military expertise I’m not aware of?

    People who DO have military expertise are saying that our military is currently about as stretched as it can go. There comes a point where the horse is running as fast as it can go, and it won’t get any faster no matter how much you whip it.

    Comment by missmolly — August 24, 2007 @ 1:36 pm

    In response to your first point, it is because the entire run-up to the invasion and the continuing occupation is controlled by the AEI, PNAC and the rest of the NeoCon Cabal. Rove and Darth sold the Repug soul to that group to get elected.

    As to the last part, THEY DON”T CARE! When you are at the table playing with other people’s money (and lives) IT DOESN’T MATTER!!! Just roll them bones and keep doubling up on the bet. HOO RAA!!


  115. AlphaLiberal Says:

    Kristol’s eyebrows really help him look all nice and warm and fuzzy. Someone should photoshop Newt’s eyebrows onto Kristol Meth to more accurately portray the bloodthirsty man within.


  116. toasterhead Says:

    How many of our troops are fluent Arabic speakers?
    How many officers?
    How many officers in charge of field operations are dependent upon Iraqi interpreters in order to know what’s going on?

    Comment by pbg — August 24, 2007 @ 1:24 pm

    Arabic is really hard, ok? All idafa structures and triconsonant roots and patterned measures and conjugated adjectives and implied vowelling and nuanced word meanings that don’t translate to English. And THEN once you know the written language you have to learn Iraqi dialect which has a completely different grammar and vocabulary and pronunciation. Crazy talk!


  117. Troll Hater Says:

    > This is your brain on ‘Kristol math’

    Damn! Pea-sized! What now?

    Let’s have a hit of Crack Cheney and get it on with Iran, already.

    If the Iranian Elite Schutzstaffel is declared a “terro organization”, will the FBI go down to Manhattan and arrest the Iranian delegation for being in cahoots with a “terrorist organization”?


  118. RUCerious Says:

    Arabic is really hard, ok?

    Absolutely. Killing em is much easier than learning anything about their language or culture.


  119. Dave C Says:

    Weren’t there some homosexuals in the military that spoke Arabic. Where’d they go?


  120. dlet Says:

    Kristol: Let’s ‘Stretch Our Army And Marines’ For ‘Another Year Or So’ In Iraq

    Kristol Meth should “stretch” his neck.


  121. upside00 Says:

    Absolutely. Killing em is much easier than learning anything about their language or culture.

    Comment by RUCerious — August 24, 2007 @ 1:51 pm

    Just like in Vietnam. Made them learn OUR language and had to destroy their villages to save them.

    Dubya has finally got that part of his comparison right!


  122. JG Says:

    You know, if Kristol wants to stretch our army another year, there is nothing preventing he and his children from joining up and helping out beings the army is at the breaking point.. I would like like to see him put his money where his mouth is. He would never do it. He is a coward who talks big. He wants to push for the war as long as it doesn’t touch him personally. I wonder what ‘benefits’ he is receiving for pushing for this war without end..?


  123. had enough Says:

    The nerve of this twisted PNAC author…Why is it he is too good to serve but has no reservations in suggesting others to serve extended multiple torturous duties? To serve in this evil illegal massacre/occupation HE helped write up?

    You go to Iraq Kristol, you perverted worthless vial evil doer.


  124. bewilderbeast Says:

    In the last 6 years, what has Kristol been right about? The only thing I can say he’s been right about is the fact they keep getting another Friendman unit to prolong this mess.


  125. Gus Owens Says:

    Look! Isn’t there anybody else in this country besides me who sees that we are engaged in a global conflict with the Islamic Radicals who amount to 100,000,000-150,000,000 people plus many of the moderates who just don’t want to say what they really believe.
    Iraq is only a part of this problem which also includes Darfur and the world-wide immigration problems with Islamic immigrants.
    Islam wants to regain the glories of their past.
    Until we start talking about the total picture in this war, we are not facing reality.


  126. pete Says:

    FIX YOUR EFFING SITE TP!


  127. PeterW Says:

    #125, I’m afraid your zero button is stuck. It seems to type two every time you push it.

    That, or you’re incredibly ignorant. Because the number of violent international Islamists not primarily motivated by nationalist or anticolonial impulses numbers in the low thousands, not hundreds of millions.


  128. LividLib Says:

    In our home, and in our family, we support our country, our troops, and our President.

    Comment by O. Bigfoot — August 24, 2007 @ 12:18 pm

    translation - the Bigfoots are lemmings.


  129. had enough Says:

    In our home, and in our family, we support our country, our troops, and our President.

    Comment by O. Bigfoot

    Then you do not support the constitution… and if you support this so called president then you surly do not support the troops


  130. That American Chap Says:

    Let’s give Kristolmeth a little test. Let’s put a rifle in his hands and put him on the Iraqi front lines. Our troops will stay there (behind him) as long as he’s willing to….deal? Methinks that “6 months” would vaporize into “GET ME OUT OF HERE!!” in less than an hour.


  131. Marty Says:

    These people are like gambling addicts playing with other people’s money. They’ve been sitting at the same table for 4 years and they haven’t won a single hand. But they don’t care because they don’t have to sacrifice anything of their own.


  132. Cazzie Russell Says:

    LividLib, you hit another tape-measure shot off Bigfoot, into the upper deck. Excellent!


  133. Jumpy Says:

    PUKE


  134. Ret. Col. Jack Ripper Says:

    Bigfoot @ 12:18 - “In our home, and in our family, we support our country, our troops, and our President.”

    Bigfoot, 10 minutes later - “during the Clinton Presidency, Charlton Heston was my President”

    Bigfoot, you are a frickin jackass.


  135. Ret. Col. Jack Ripper Says:

    Makarios: “Supporting your leaders = supporting your country = supporting your Constitution

    This is exactly right. If you knew what the meaning of “constitution” is, then you wouldn’t sound so ignorant.”

    Why does it always seem as if the most moronic of posters are the quickest to call others ignorant? Here’s a history lesson for you from one of our greatest republican presidents:

    “To announce there must be no criticism of the President, and to stand by the President, right or wrong, is not only unpatriotic and servile, it is morally treasonous to the American public.”

    – President Theodore Roosevelt


  136. fubar Says:

    I am a Marine vet and the mother two kids serving. I have a son in the Marines who will be headed back to Iraq in September. You have no idea how much this pisses me off to hear this wingnut motherf*cker say this stuff. These people have absolutely no soul. I can’t even stand this anymore! It’s enough that I am already freaking out that he is going back but to hear this kind of warmongering, tasteless crap coming from this troll is too much.


  137. Uncle Ho Says:

    Here’s a thought; Let’s stretch Kristol…..on the rack. The Spanish Inquisition did have some good ideas. One good turn deserves another.


  138. nabalzbbfr Says:

    William Kristol is spot on. We are slowly but surely turning the tide. We should do whatever it takes to achieve a total unequivocal victory, decisively defeating al-qaeda, Iran and Syria and completely marginalizing their domestic enablers in Congress.


  139. dudeabides Says:

    William Kristol is spot on. We are slowly but surely turning the tide. We should do whatever it takes to achieve a total unequivocal victory, decisively defeating al-qaeda, Iran and Syria and completely marginalizing their domestic enablers in Congress.

    Comment by nabalzbbfr — August 24, 2007 @ 10:01 pm

    With what Army? We are already stretched too thin. So you’re saying there should be a draft? Why haven’t you signed up yet? Decisively defeating Iran and Syria, that would mean invading and occupying both countries. Yea, that will realllllllllly get the Arabs on are side, they will just love it. Domestic Enablers in Congress? ummm, who gave Congress to the democrats? The american people! So americans are now terrorist enablers?


  140. Probus Says:

    Kristol is out of touch with the reality on the ground in Iraq. Our military is already being stretched to the point of breaking. It is unfair to the troops. Also giving a year more to a flawed policy will make no difference. The surge is likely to fail no matter how much time it gets.


  141. Probus Says:

    If Kristol had bothered to serve in combat he would not recommend putting our troops and their families through such hardship for a policy that has failed to deliver good results.


  142. vinnie Says:

    You libtards can’t even read. It says right on the screen that the surge is working. What part of that don’t you understand?

    :)


  143. Mother Theresa Says:

    Kristol hates people –how sad.


  144. Harry Callahan Says:

    It is very easy for Kristol to blithly declare that the Army and Marines should stretch for six months to a year. He never served in the military and I doubt if any of his family or acquaintences have either. He further puts on as though he knows something about the military in deriding Sen Warner’s suggestion to pull back at least 5000 by Christmas, saying that Warner didn’t think it out and it would do harm to adjacent units.

    Of course, Kristol doesn’t care about the troops, no matter what the JSC and senior officers are saying. Most of them are goyem, anyway. What does he care.


  145. Job Hoogendoorn Says:

    You Americans are unbeatable in straight warfare and that’s why only a megalomaniac like Saddam took you on. No regular army survives in an all-out guerillawar and that’s a simple, historically proven fact. You can’t win, surge or no surge, so pull out, as gracefully as possible…….
    To the hawks I would say: read this again in, say, five years?



Jump to Top

About Think Progress | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2008 Center for American Progress Action Fund
image Register imageimageRSSimageimage imageimage
image
image
View Most Popular
image
image
Visit Our Affiliated Sites
image
image image image
What We're About
image
image
Featured
image
image
Subscribe to the Progress Report



image
image
Got a hot tip?
Have a hot news tip? We'd love to hear from you. Use the form below to send us the latest.

Name:
Email:
Tip:
(required)



image
Reports
image