Think Progress

Schmidt caught plagiarizing in newspaper column.»

In her recent column on bus safety, Rep. Jean Schmidt (R-OH) warned school children to “never bend down near or under the bus to pick something up that has fallen.” An observant Ohio blog, The Daily Bellwether, noticed that parts of Schmidt’s column were strikingly similar to columns written by former Ohio State Highway Patrol Col. Paul McClellan. The Cincinnati Enquirer confirmed Schmidt’s cut-and-paste plagiarism today:

schmidtdress3-700776.jpgIf Rep. Jean Schmidt’s latest column on school bus safety looked familiar, there’s a good reason why.

Six sentences from her column of last Tuesday appear to be cut and pasted in identical form from a column written in October 2005 by then-Ohio State Highway Patrol Col. Paul McClellan. […]

For example, Schmidt’s column says: “When exiting the bus, care should be taken to check that clothing with drawstrings and book bags with straps do not get caught in the handrails or doors. Additionally, students should never go back for anything left on the bus, and never bend down near or under the bus to pick something up that has fallen.”

McClellan’s column says: “When exiting the bus, care should be taken to check that clothing with drawstrings and book bags with straps do not get caught in the handrails or doors. Additionally, students should never go back for anything left on the bus, and never bend down near or under the bus to pick something up that has fallen.”

This isn’t the first time Schmidt has been caught passing off other people’s words as her own. In September 2006, Schmidt appropriated passages from Rep. Deborah Pryce’s (R-OH) press releases for a column on Medicare.




Sort Comments By: Top Rated | Date

131 Responses to “Schmidt caught plagiarizing in newspaper column.”


  1. dlet Says:

    Hasn’t that thing been called back to hell yet?


  2. citizen_pain Says:

    No! An intellectually lazy republican? Coudn’t be!


  3. crassus Says:

    Is it a lesser plagiarism when “everbody’s doing it”?


  4. LibertyLover Says:

    When you are used to getting talking points everyday, you tend to get lazy, I guess.


  5. James Says:

    First troll to mention Joe Biden wins a free subscription to the Limbaugh Letter


  6. Hillary Whacked Vince Says:

    #8 - that would be me!!! AT least Schmidt is not running for President. She’s just a right-wing attack dog. Republicans know better than to let attack dogs run for President. With Hillary leading the polls, Democrats cannot say the same.


  7. Toliver Says:

    “When exiting the bus, care should be taken to check that clothing with drawstrings and book bags with straps do not get caught in the handrails or doors. Additionally, students should never go back for anything left on the bus, and never bend down near or under the bus to pick something up that has fallen.”

    It’s a small part of a child safety column TP, not a novel or research paper. This is a junk post that falls below your already low standards.


  8. GSD Says:

    We already knew that Schmidt was a hack. She lifted the persona and character of a famous tv and film actress.

    Jean Schmidt give Margaret Hamilton her shtick back.

    -GSD


  9. NastyDiaper Says:

    As if half those rethugs could write anything original.

    Between lobbiests and the RNC, sounds like an easy job. Just chat up some good homophobe on even year summers, and you’re gtg!


  10. Bobwurst Says:

    I guess the republicans aren’t willing to hold their elected officals to the same standards that 4th graders are held to. That explains a lot.


  11. James Says:

    Sorry, #9. You didn’t mention Biden by name. Thanks for playing.


  12. DRxJ Says:

    Six sentences from her column of last Tuesday appear to be cut and pasted in identical form from a column written in October 2005 by then-Ohio State Highway Patrol Col. Paul McClellan.

    Who know that Rep. Schmidt would be related to Jake D.?
    Not I.


  13. katy Says:

    the kind of people who refuse to take personal responsibility
    are the same kind who refuse to give anyone credit where due…


  14. Skippy Says:

    Here come the Republican trolls. They stood up for Mark Foley, Larry Craig, Bob Allen, et al, when they got caught being naughty nasty boys. Of course they’re going to stand up for Mean Jean when she plagiarizes in a newspaper column.


  15. Tom Says:

    Yawn.

    Comment by Ringo

    Yeah, that was my reaction also. So another rethuglican is caught doing something unethical. Geez where have we seen that before?


  16. Bernard Quatermass Says:

    Toliver,

    “This is a junk post that falls below your already low standards.”

    I agree. Your post is junk; however, that is your usual standard.


  17. Ringo Says:

    the kind of people who refuse to take personal responsibility
    are the same kind who refuse to give anyone credit where due…
    …

    Comment by katy
    ———————————————————

    Don’t be so hard on Martin Luther King jr…He was a great man despite his plagiarism.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/ wiki/ Martin_Luther_King%2C_Jr._authorship_issues


  18. Bernard Quatermass Says:

    “Yawn.”

    Someone stayed up waaaaaaaay too late watching reruns of the Vic Morrow show “Combat.”


  19. Pillboxian Gravelite Says:

    Whew…Im glad this outrageous behavior has been brought to light; we cant have simple column about child safety being being a forum for plagiarizing. This is big news!

    Next to appear at TP: a hitherto unheard-of republican from Nebraska was seen wearing white socks with dark slacks. THE HORROR!


  20. Uncle Ho Says:

    “Only cowards cut and paste other people’s work, thinking people don’t.”

    SNARK> Heh, heh :-D


  21. Bobwurst Says:

    But if Clinton had done this during his presidency, these same trolls would have wanted him impeached for it.


  22. Pillboxian Gravelite Says:

    Don’t be so hard on Martin Luther King jr…He was a great man despite his plagiarism.

    Dont forget famous liberal professor Ward Churchill, an artist AND a writer.


  23. Gary Says:

    It’s not plagiarism to quote from a government manual. TP should pull down this post. It is false.


  24. Ringo Says:

    “When exiting the bus, care should be taken to check that clothing with drawstrings and book bags with straps do not get caught in the handrails or doors. Additionally, students should never go back for anything left on the bus, and never bend down near or under the bus to pick something up that has fallen.”
    ————————————————————-

    The immortal words of the great Highway Patrol Col. Paul McClellan stollen by a lazy RePUKElSCUM wingnut!

    I am OUTRAGED!!!….OUTRAGED!!!!

    When will this neo-con-FASCIST tyranny end???????????

    I want my country back!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


  25. hellinabucket Says:

    Ringo is siding with Schmidt. yawn.


  26. Gary Says:

    I find the liberals’ bashing of Schmidt to be pure sexism.


  27. James Says:

    I am not gay.


  28. Dermot Says:

    Love the pic of her


  29. Bobwurst Says:

    Welcome to the dark side ringo.

    there aren’t that many rules, just remember to take a bong hit at exactly 7:14 each night, chug your beer whenever someone says “hi bob” on the Bob Newhart show. and blow off work to get high all day on april 20th.


  30. gummitch Says:

    Plagiarism is never a big deal to “conservatives.” They have much greater crimes to commit.


  31. r Says:

    The immortal words of the great Highway Patrol Col. Paul McClellan stollen by a lazy RePUKElSCUM wingnut!

    I am OUTRAGED!!!….OUTRAGED!!!!

    When will this neo-con-FASCIST tyranny end???????????

    I want my country back!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Comment by Ringo — September 7, 2007 @ 1:04 pm

    THIS PROVES BUSH IS HITLER!!!!!!!!


  32. Bobwurst Says:

    I find the liberals’ bashing of Schmidt to be pure sexism.

    Comment by Gary

    Schmidt is a woman?!!?!?!?


  33. Dermot Says:

    Plagiarism is a required training course at the Bush School of Gumment


  34. Bernard Quatermass Says:

    “I want my country back!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!”

    Is that the country of people who think sarcasm is best applied with a jackhammer and dozens of exclamation points?

    “Ringo,” please leave comedy (and political commentary) to those who do it well. Please. Please.


  35. Vildar Says:

    I guess the republicans aren’t willing to hold their elected officals to the same standards that 4th graders are held to. That explains a lot.

    Or democrats for that matter. Webb(D), you listening?


  36. Dermot Says:

    Her columns are probably compiled by a computer bot that trolls the net for crap that is easy to steal


  37. Bobwurst Says:

    I find the liberals’ bashing of Schmidt to be pure sexism.

    Comment by Gary

    Are you sure she’s a woman? Look at the picture. She looks like a male republcan in a public restoom….


  38. Bernard Quatermass Says:

    “Love the pic of her”

    It reminds me somewhat of the planet destroyer from “The Doomsday Machine” episode of Star Trek, except that the only thing it destroys is my remaining faith in the human race.


  39. Dermot Says:

    Watch out Ringo

    Her computer bot may steal your crap for one of her columns


  40. Dermot Says:

    It looks like she tried to eat the microphone but it was tooooo hard


  41. Luis M Says:

    I remember the time one of the regular trolls here decided to explain their philosophy… by plagiarizing Rorschach from the Watchmen comic, nearly verbatim. And he never even admitted it, even when caught red-handed.

    Fun times, fun times.


  42. katy Says:

    Schmidt is a woman?!!?!?!?
    Comment by Bobwurst — September 7, 2007 @ 1:10 pm

    at best, i could agree that she is “female”…


  43. Dermot Says:

    I especially like her outfit. Is that the confederate flag redone in a sexy moo moo


  44. Bobwurst Says:

    remember the time one of the regular trolls here decided to explain their philosophy… by plagiarizing Rorschach from the Watchmen comic, nearly verbatim. And he never even admitted it, even when caught red-handed.

    Fun times, fun times.

    Comment by Luis M

    Yeah…and remember when jake plagiaized that korean war veteran’s bio and got busted?


  45. Dumb_Fox Says:

    Caption:

    Jean Schmidt prepares to bite O’Reilly’s falafel thing.


  46. Vildar Says:

    She is female all right, one of the reasons that the lib males here are so scared of her.

    Now if Schmidt were a transgender interpretive dancer, the libs would be drooling over her pic.


  47. Dermot Says:

    The title of the picture when you rollover is schmidtdress3.jpg

    I wonder what the other two dresses look like.


  48. katy Says:

    I remember the time one of the regular trolls […]… by plagiarizing […]
    Comment by Luis M — September 7, 2007 @ 1:14 pm

    sounds like frankj… NEVER sources what it cutsnpastes…


  49. margaret Says:

    She looks as crazed as some of the trolls that come here! Yikes!


  50. r Says:

    Is it really plagiarism if it states “According to the Ohio State Highway Patrol…”?


  51. trollbuster Says:

    Yeah, maybe she plagiarized, but… she’s so nice.

    And nice-lookin’, too.


  52. Dermot Says:

    Schmidt bites O’Reilly’s falafel thing but it’s too soapy


  53. Bobwurst Says:

    Margret,

    you may be on to something, is it firehead or imamoronwhopostspointlessrants?


  54. WaltinTexas Says:

    Un-American POS’s clueless enough to vote for this… person, don’t care about things like this. All that matters to some is that there is a little (R) behind her name at the ballot box. It’s those types of sheeple that we can thank for the totally screwed up mess we’re ALL in now.


  55. Dermot Says:

    51

    Still needs quotes or a source if exact words are used. If it’s re-worded then no.


  56. Vildar Says:

    Jean Schmidt should be impeached and tossed down the nearest well!
    B!TCH!!!!!!!!!
    (how am I doing?)

    Fine, just fine.

    Now get yourself an American flag, run outside and burn it in front of a soldier and then spit on him when youre done.

    Do it right and you gain official acceptance into the modern DFL. Congrats.


  57. Bobwurst Says:

    (how am I doing?)

    Comment by Ringo

    you’re doing ok for a beginner, you still need to put some logic in your post, but at least you’re heading in the right direction. now try pIt will be easier if you try it wish something more serious, like pointing that bush lied about the WMD.

    ps hi bob


  58. Dermot Says:

    Caption

    Large black ball emerges from Schmidt’s mouth during speech


  59. margaret Says:

    is it firehead or imamoronwhopostspointlessrants?

    Comment by Bobwurst — September 7, 2007 @ 1:19 pm

    Hmm, maybe the second one, but then again maybe it’s M A/ V V? That troll usually sounds wild-eyed and generally unhinged.


  60. Buck Fush Says:

    And that hag still holds office because…….? Her district must be full of mental challenged dolts.


  61. Bobwurst Says:

    I think you may be right margaret, from the pic it looks like schmidt is spewing all caps, bolded, and she’s building to a !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


  62. Brilliant Pebble Says:

    Her district must be full of mental challenged dolts.

    Yes it is, but the republicans outnumber them and so Schmidt gets elected.


  63. hellinabucket Says:

    Do violent mood swings run in your family Ringo?


  64. Snidely Whiplash Says:

    I hope she’s sued for copyright infringement. Aren’t Republicans the ones who always shout, “enforce the laws on the books.”


  65. ForTruth Says:

    It reminds me somewhat of the planet destroyer from “The Doomsday Machine” episode of Star Trek, except that the only thing it destroys is my remaining faith in the human race.

    Comment by Bernard Quatermass

    That was my favorite episode. It was like a reverse cornacopia. Seems it didn’t re-run as much as most episodes did.


  66. Ringo Says:

    Do violent mood swings run in your family Ringo?

    Comment by hellinabucket
    ——————————————————-

    I come from a family of Leftists….They’re not violent but they are moody.


  67. ForTruth Says:

    Amazing to me that these people once earned college degrees and likely other credentials, just to end up being robots.


  68. Chairman Truther Says:

    This is no different than President Chimpy McHitler lying about WMD in order to fool us into an imperialist war of greed and aggression against an innocent and harmless country!

    Jean Schmidt and George Bush and Dick Cheney should all be tried for treason and then sent to HELLLLLLLLLLLLLLL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Comment by Ringo — September 7, 2007 @ 1:33 pm

    Do violent mood swings run in your family Ringo?

    Comment by hellinabucket — September 7, 2007 @ 1:36 pm

    Correction, Do violent mood swings run in your family, Jake D(ermot)?


  69. gummitch Says:

    I come from a family of Leftists….They’re not violent but they are moody.

    Comment by Ringo — September 7, 2007 @ 1:41 pm

    And clearly, one of them dropped you on your head early on.


  70. dennis Says:

    Seriously, if this story is even the vaguest bit interesting to you, you need to get a life. Plagiarism on a piece about bus safety? Who TF cares.


  71. ForTruth Says:

    Jean likes stupid little white poodles too.


  72. Toliver Says:

    It’s a child safety column you gloids. A .gov link is not a private enterprise. A CPR cut and paste would likewise be a non-event.

    http://webpages.acs.ttu.edu/ charshey/ pics/ ThisThreadSucks.jpg


  73. Ringo Says:

    This is all about RepubliSCUM fear-mongering.

    Jean Schmidt is trying to scare our kids from taking the bus so that they won’t go to school and get an education.

    She wants are kids to be stupid so that they will grow up to vote for RePUKElians!!!!!!


  74. hellinabucket Says:

    Ringo is full of Schmidt.


  75. dennis Says:

    This is all about RepubliSCUM fear-mongering.
    Jean Schmidt is trying to scare our kids from taking the bus so that they won’t go to school and get an education.
    She wants are kids to be stupid so that they will grow up to vote for RePUKElians!!!!!!

    Comment by Ringo

    Ringo- I think you’ll make a fine leftie. 9/11 was an inside job, you know. These next few days will be a good time to post that all over the liberal blogs. Go get ‘em.


  76. Bobwurst Says:

    Keep working it ringo, you still need logic, facts and commonsense, other than that you’re doing fine. You might want to change your screename to john though, he was the real leftie. ringo was a stooge.


  77. hellinabucket Says:

    Wasn’t Ringo the dumb one of the group?


  78. Polly Mathe Says:

    Caption:

    “Give me those slippers!”


  79. Dr. Truther Says:

    Hows that?
    Comment by Ringo — September 7, 2007 @ 2:07 pm

    Try harder, Jake D(ermot).


  80. dennis Says:

    Almost there, Ringo. Always add exclamation points at the end of sentences for effect. All caps every once in a while too if the mods let you get away with it. Might want to start taking your mock pent-up anger on any trolls who disagree with your newfound positions.

    So far so good, though.


  81. Bobwurst Says:

    Ringo,

    the problem is you’ve traded right wing trollling points for left wing trolling points. the left-wing trollers are either ignored or mocked too. why not try easing into it: ask why bush ignored the august 6 nie, or why cheney old company is getting so many no bid contracts when he is going to profit from them. You could also explore the destruction of the constitution, but that may be too big a step. Why don’t you just lean back a for a minute, put on a dead tape from your favorite show, pack your bong and take a long slow toke. that’s it, now hold it, don’t cough, hold it, hold it, ok, let it out. there, don’t you feel better now?


  82. Wayne Says:

    Hows that?

    Comment by Ringo

    Doing good.
    Mr. P should attack you any time now, then you know you’ve got it down.


  83. Bobwurst Says:

    hellinabucket,
    yeah, ringo was the dumb one, john was the political one, paul was the bubblegum one, and george, he was just plain dreamy….


  84. Ringo Says:

    Comment by Bobwurst — September 7, 2007
    ——————————-

    Can I still listen to Merle Haggard?


  85. Ringo Says:

    Aww Mom.


  86. hellinabucket Says:

    Bobwurst hit the nail on the head. Trolling the extremes.

    dreamy, that was funny.


  87. Bobwurst Says:

    Comment by Bobwurst — September 7, 2007
    ——————————-

    Can I still listen to Merle Haggard?

    Comment by Ringo

    Yes you can ringo, yes you can. the dead covered momma tried, the new riders covered working man’s blues, and the flying burrito brothers did a bunch of merle’s songs. You should probably hide your garth brooks cds, and for the love of god, no toby kieth! but real country is acceptable.


  88. Bobwurst Says:

    thanks hellinabucket,

    it’s nice to see folks getting along for a change. thanks for the fun ringo.


  89. hellinabucket Says:

    Real country has always been acceptable. Love momma tried.


  90. j swift Says:

    Ten to one she did not even write it herself. One of her toadies did and she edited a bit and signed off on it. LOL


  91. Ringo Says:

    Bobwurst,

    But my favorite Merle Song is ‘Fighting Side of Me’ :
    —————————————————————–
    Fightin Side of Me
    by Merle Haggard

    Merle Haggard, Fightin’ Side of Me Lyrics
    Looking for Merle Haggard tabs and chords? Browse alphabet (above)

    Artist: Haggard Merle
    Song: Fightin’ Side of Me
    Album: For the Record: 43 Legendary Hits Buy Merle Haggard Sheet Music
    Buy Merle Haggard CDs

    I hear people talkin’ bad,
    About the way we have to live here in this country,
    Harpin’ on the wars we fight,
    An’ gripin’ ’bout the way things oughta be.
    An’ I don’t mind ‘em switchin’ sides,
    An’ standin’ up for things they believe in.
    When they’re runnin’ down my country, man,
    They’re walkin’ on the fightin’ side of me.
    Yeah, walkin’ on the fightin’ side of me.
    Runnin’ down the way of life,
    Our fightin’ men have fought and died to keep.
    If you don’t love it, leave it:
    Let this song I’m singin’ be a warnin’.
    If you’re runnin’ down my country, man,
    You’re walkin’ on the fightin’ side of me.

    I read about some squirrely guy,
    Who claims, he just don’t believe in fightin’.
    An’ I wonder just how long,
    The rest of us can count on bein’ free.
    They love our milk an’ honey,
    But they preach about some other way of livin’.
    When they’re runnin’ down my country, hoss,
    They’re walkin’ on the fightin’ side of me.

    Yeah, walkin’ on the fightin’ side of me.
    Runnin’ down the way of life,
    Our fightin’ men have fought and died to keep.
    If you don’t love it, leave it:
    Let this song I’m singin’ be a warnin’.
    If you’re runnin’ down my country, man,
    You’re walkin’ on the fightin’ side of me.

    Yeah, walkin’ on the fightin’ side of me.
    Runnin’ down the way of life,
    Our fightin’ men have fought and died to keep.
    If you don’t love it, leave it:
    Let this song I’m singin’ be a warnin’.
    If you’re runnin’ down my country, man,
    You’re walkin’ on the fightin’ side of me.
    ———————————————————–

    http://www.cowboylyrics.com/ lyrics/ haggard-merle/ fightin-side-of-me-496.html


  92. Bobwurst Says:

    Since we’ve strayed this far off the track, does anyone else listent to music from wolfgangs’ vault?

    http://concerts.wolfgangsvault.com/ ConcertDetail.aspx?id=20050393|4633

    I think the story is that some dotcom billionare bought up Bill Graham’s estate for the old concert posters and found this treasure trove of taped concerts from his venues, (fillmore east, west, winterland, among others) and he’s putting them up on the internets and you can stream them for free. It’s an amazing collection. I’m listening to merle right now from a concert that he recorded back in 82 at the grand ole opry. (thanks for the idea ringo).

    If you have the time and inclination, i highly recomend it.


  93. Hamilton Lovecraft Says:

    Let’s see — comment threads almost as productive as Eschaton’s, ever more misleading headlines, and now a gripe about plagiarism in a PSA column.

    I’m done with Think Progress.


  94. Ringo Says:

    If you have the time and inclination, i highly recomend it.

    Comment by Bobwurst
    ——————————————-

    Thanks, I will.


  95. hellinabucket Says:

    Thanks for the link Bowurst. It looks like hours of good fun.


  96. dixie blood Says:

    Jean Schmidt = MORON = CUA!


  97. Bobwurst Says:

    Re 98

    nteresting ringo, I like that song too. I was a big fan of “ramblin fever” back when I was hitchhiking. did you hear his protest song about the iraq war? it’s called “rebuild America first” and it’s on his Chicago Wind CD. I tried to find the lyrics to it, but couldn’t scrounge them up.


  98. dixie blood Says:

    I’m done with Think Progress.

    Comment by Hamilton Lovecraft — September 7, 2007 @ 2:34 pm

    Buh-bye…make sure you keep that promise…


  99. hellinabucket Says:

    Schmidt a moron? isn’t that a little harsh on the morons?


  100. dixie blood Says:

    Sorry morons!!! My bad…


  101. Bobwurst Says:

    I’m done with Think Progress.

    Comment by Hamilton Lovecraft
    Yeah, I can see why you’d leave, after all the thought you’ve put into the conversation…


  102. dixie blood Says:

    I think just calling her what she is is all we need to do here, as I said in #16 post, she is “a Repug Talking Point Whore”, no more, no less.

    Comment by upside00 — September 7, 2007 @ 2:46 pm

    Ohhh..no…way…She is so much less!!!


  103. IgnoranceIsNotBliss Says:

    Schmidt looks like she is set to spew some serious venom in that pic. Not surprising about the plagiarizing.


  104. I Love Barack Obama Says:

    This just goes to show, as has been proven countless times, that any idiot can get elected to Congress. Thus, being a congressperson is in itself not really a mark of distinction: it could be, as it is in most cases, that your campaign advisors convinced a bunch of rubes about as shitbrained as you to vote for you. It’s what you say and do in office that matters. Jean Shit is a perfect example of congressional mediocrity.


  105. dixie blood Says:

    Bumper sticker for her District “I don’t do Schmidt” It works on so many levels. Followed by “Had enough of this Schmidt?”. And even “She’s too ugly for Congress.”

    Hope to see one of those on a bumper when I drive thru her state.

    Comment by hellinabucket — September 7, 2007 @ 2:52 pm

    How ’bout “The Murtha Of All Schmidt”


  106. Ringo Says:

    Bobwurst,

    Do you know the Merle Haggard song “My own Kind of Hat” ?

    It’s a good one:

    Cowboys and outlaws, right guys and southpaws,
    Good dogs and all kinds of cats.
    Dirt roads and white lines and all kinds of stop signs,
    But I stand right here where I’m at,
    ‘Cause I wear My Own Kind Of Hat.
    There’s two kind of lovers and two kind of brothers,
    And two kind of babies to hold.
    There’s two kind of cherries and two kind of fairies,
    And two kind of mothers I’m told, and told
    Cowboys and outlaws, right guys and southpaws,
    Good dogs and all kinds of cats.
    Dirt roads and white lines and all kinds of stop signs,
    But I stand right here where I’m at,
    ‘Cause I wear My Own Kind Of Hat.
    There’s two kind of brothers and two kind of lovers,
    And two kind of babies to hold.
    There’s two kind of cherries and two kind of fairies,
    And two kind of mothers I’m told, and told
    Cowboys and outlaws, right guys and southpaws,
    Good dogs and all kinds of cats.
    Dirt roads and white lines and all kinds of stop signs,
    But I stand right here where I’m at,
    ‘Cause I wear My Own Kind Of Hat.


  107. ckerst Says:

    She got elected to congress so she could deal with issues the local school board deals with, what a waste of skin.


  108. hellinabucket Says:

    Good words Ringo.


  109. DRxJ Says:

    Let’s see — comment threads almost as productive as Eschaton’s, ever more misleading headlines, and now a gripe about plagiarism in a PSA column.
    I’m done with Think Progress.
    Comment by Hamilton Lovecraft — September 7, 2007 @ 2:34 pm

    Nooo. Please don’t go! Your thought induced, intelligent responses added so much intellict to these threads.
    Wait…
    Besides just now, when have you ever posted?


  110. citizen_pain Says:

    BoBwurst: been listening to Wolfgang’s vault for some time… wish it wasn’t streaming flash… otherwise I’d have one hell of a concert collection… gotta check out Peter Frampton’s session gig on that deal… awesome


  111. katy Says:

    that’s very interesting, ringo @ 12:58 pm… i hadn’t heard of that…

    this, from the wiki link, is noteable:

    Boston University decided not to revoke his doctorate, which provoked another controversy, saying that although King acted improperly, his dissertation still “makes an intelligent contribution to scholarship”. (Radin, 1991) Other newspaper editorials defended King, saying he was still a great man regardless of his actions. Some articles questioned why the plagiarism went unnoticed.

    couldn’t get away with it these days… and shouldn’t…
    there really is no good excuse today…


  112. K Says:

    If she’s like virtually all other members of Congress, Schmidt has these things written for her by junior staff, usually not-too-smart twenty-somethings. Almost all Congressmen are plagiarists in that sense. People of normal intelligence probably suspect as much, but aren’t too bothered, because it’s obviously trivial PR only tenuously related to the main work of Congress. Schmidt’s special problem is that her staffers evidently are too stupid to even minimally rephrase what they’re copying. Take it as a sign that her office may also do bad work on more important matters.


  113. katy Says:

    and george, he was just plain dreamy….
    Comment by Bobwurst — September 7, 2007 @ 2:16 pm

    that’s what i always thought too… always my fave…
    and, he and i share the same birthdate… 10 yrs different…


  114. katy Says:


    … and the flying burrito brothers …
    Comment by Bobwurst — September 7, 2007 @ 2:21 pm

    graham parsons… R.I.P. … LOVED the burrito brothers…

    and getting hooked on emmylou harris…

    listened to all the others you mentioned in that post…
    memories… heh…


  115. katy Says:

    and again…

    … does anyone else listent to music from wolfgangs’ vault? …
    http://concerts.wolfgangsvault.com/
    Comment by Bobwurst — September 7, 2007 @ 2:30 pm

    thanks for that!


  116. upside00 Says:

    graham parsons… R.I.P. … LOVED the burrito brothers…

    and getting hooked on emmylou harris… by Katy

    OH YEA!! Ever hear the Duets album by Emmy and especially the song she does with Graham. Knocks me out.

    And her “Boulder to Birmingham” is maybe the best song ever written. Especially when sung at Red Rocks with a full moon and 10,000 people singing along! YUMM


  117. katy Says:

    my bad - i meant to correct myself earlier…
    it’s g-r-a-m, american version, i guess…

    ANYthing with emmylou… sigh…


  118. J Lewd Says:

    Ringo: In your case, it’s called an Asshat.


  119. jophusa Says:

    I am certainly not a Jean Schmidt supporter, but good advice is good advice. Maybe it was the first time someone heard it. I think this criticism is very petty.


  120. Solitaire Says:

    If I had to write about bus safety (yawn), I might copy down a few good points from whatever (ho hum) library book I could find on the subje…. *zzzzzzz.


  121. Kilo Says:

    Er… repeating safety messages is plagiarism ?
    You want to get cracking on the 4.8 billion cases of that happening with statements by the surgeon general now or what ?


  122. chazaroo Says:

    What else would you expect from a pathetic cunt?


  123. Ytterbius Says:

    Actually, if I had my say, I’d say that the rule should be that when exiting the bus, care should be taken to check that clothing with drawstrings and book bags with straps do not get caught in the handrails or doors. Additionally, students should never go back for anything left on the bus, and never bend down near or under the bus to pick something up that has fallen.


  124. Jeremiah Says:

    Mean Jean the Plagiarizing Machine! (R-OH)


  125. Chris Says:

    Ok, first off, I dislike Schmidt as much as the next liberal democrat.

    But, the sentences that she is being accused of lifting from McClellan, also appeared in a 1998 article by Colonel Kenneth B. Marshall, Superintendent, Ohio State Highway Patrol.

    http://www.statepatrol.ohio.gov/colcolumn/1998/0998MESS.HTML

    And I bet he lifted them from someplace else. These tips smack of basic recommendations provided in safety lists for decades. In fact, I think I recall some of them from my bus riding days, 30 years ago…


  126. Wayne A. Schneider Says:

    Er… repeating safety messages is plagiarism ?
    You want to get cracking on the 4.8 billion cases of that happening with statements by the surgeon general now or what ?

    Comment by Kilo — September 7, 2007 @ 10:03 pm

    No, but trying to pretend they’re your own words (when clearly they’re not) is plagiarism. All she had to do was say something like, “According to the State Secretary of Education, children exiting…”. Instead, she tried to make it look the words were her own original ones. That is plagiarism.


  127. Kilo Says:

    No, but trying to pretend they’re your own words (when clearly they’re not) is plagiarism. All she had to do was say something like, “According to the State Secretary of Education, children exiting…”. Instead, she tried to make it look the words were her own original ones. That is plagiarism.

    Comment by Wayne A. Schneider — September 8, 2007 @ 5:24 am

    What are you fkn slow ?
    Why would anyone do anything other than repeat precisely what the authorities want children told about road safety ?
    You would be happier if she came up with her own statements would you ?
    You even think that was what was being attempted apparently. That a government official was expanding their literary career with a road safety message. FFS use you brain idiot.


  128. Kilo Says:

    Here’s the one guy who saw Bush continuing to read my pet goat on 9/11 and had a problem with that because he may have breached copyright laws on public use.


  129. Bernard Quatermass Says:

    “She is female all right, one of the reasons that the lib males here are so scared of her.

    Now if Schmidt were a transgender interpretive dancer, the libs would be drooling over her pic.”

    I am going to use this in a class I am teaching on “Why Just Saying Scattered Random Things in an Attempt to be Cutting and Sardonic Doesn’t Work Real Well.” Hope that’s okay.

    It’s a graduate course.


  130. Lora Says:

    Now if Schmidt were a transgender interpretive dancer, the libs would be drooling over her pic.
    Comment by Vildar — September 7, 2007 @ 1:17 pm

    No libs/progs I know of drool over your rightwing transgender idol Ann Coulter.



Jump to Top

About Think Progress | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2008 Center for American Progress Action Fund
View Most Popular

Advertisement

Visit Our Affiliated Sites

image image
What We're About

Featured

image
Subscribe to the Progress Report




Got a hot tip?
Have a hot news tip? We'd love to hear from you. Use the form below to send us the latest.

Name:
Email:
Tip:
(required)



Reports

imageTopic Cloud


imageArchives


imageBlog Roll