Think Progress

Bush inartfully suggests Saddam killed Mandela.

In a press conference this morning, President Bush tried to assert that Saddam’s brutal rule over Iraq wiped the country clean of potential democratic reformers — individuals who may have possessed leadership skills like former South African President Nelson Mandela. In doing so, Bush inartfully suggested Saddam killed Mandela:

I thought an interesting comment was made — somebody said to me, I heard somebody say, “Now, where’s Mandela?” Well, Mandela’s dead because Saddam Hussein killed all the Mandelas.

For the record, Nelson Mandela is still alive while Saddam Hussein is dead. Watch it:

[flv http://video.thinkprogress.org/2007/09/mandelabush2.320.240.flv]

Nelson Mandela was a strong opponent of the war in Iraq. Prior to the war, he condemned Bush as “a president who can’t think properly and wants to plunge the world into holocaust.” “Why does the United States behave so arrogantly?” he asked, adding, “They just want the oil. We must expose this as much as possible.”

Digg It!




Sort Comments By: Top Rated | Date

132 Responses to “Bush inartfully suggests Saddam killed Mandela.”

  1. The Republic of Stupidity Says:

    The nose just keeps on growing and growing. When will he take to hagning an American flag off of it?


  2. Politicians all Suq Says:

    Funny, the more he talks, the more he proves what an idiot he is. Makes you wonder, how is it that all these people who meet him "suppossedly" get so wow'd by him.


  3. Mark @ News Corpse Says:

    Crawford's Lost Idiot strikes again.


  4. upside99 Says:

    Makes you wonder, how is it that all these people who meet him “suppossedly” get so wow’d by him.
    Comment by Politicians all Suq — September 20, 2007 @ 12:05 pm

    Maybe Darth has the shotgun loaded and they are afraid NOT to be wow'ed.


  5. raynman Says:

    I think I know what he was trying to say, but he has to be the most inarticulate rube that ever stood behind that podium.


  6. gummitch Says:

    Someone commented on another Bush thread about the lack of Rove's guiding hand. I know that Bush is famous for his verbal gaffes, but either he's doing it a lot more lately or the media is displaying them more often.


  7. interestedlitigant Says:

    Alright. I admire some of your logic but this one just flat floored me. You sound like a bible toting literal evangelical. Never hear of nuance? If you read the words again, and this time actuall impart meaning in the statement instead of concentrating only on the words (ie: the whole and not its parts) you will come to the only possible conclusion, and it is not the literal claim you make. Either you ignored the meaning of the statement or you only care to impose the spin that illogical inductive reasoning could muster. Either way this dissapoints me in your logic.


  8. freeman Says:

    Yes and we ,the USA supported him and armed him in a war against a sovereign nation, Iran, because we couldn't overthrow it a third time .


  9. upside99 Says:

    ....but he has to be the most inarticulate rube that ever stood behind that podium.
    Comment by raynman — September 20, 2007 @ 12:07 pm

    Guess that's what happens when the rover's hand got pulled out of the sockpuppet. Leaves a very wide hole behind.


  10. Ret. Col. Jack Ripper Says:

    Bush has gone from mildly incoherent to completely incoherent. I'm certain that they've got him on mood-altering pharmeceuticals.


  11. missmolly Says:

    Raynman -- if you think you know what Bush was trying to say, could you enlighten me? Because, frankly I am stumped.

    I hope he didn't truly mean Nelson Mandela. I mean -- I know this guy doesn't even know the difference between Slovenia and Slovakia, but surely he's not so stupid he really thinks Mandela got murdered by Hussein?


  12. Badmoodman Says:

    The Crawford Communicator strikes again.


  13. katy Says:

    repugs have put up a resolution at this time
    to put the first steps on the record toward
    suppressing free speech...

    i don't recall resolutions that condemned the swift boaters
    or those who attacked max cleland, and so on...

    dispicable...


  14. Wayne Says:

    Well, Mandela’s dead because Saddam Hussein killed all the Mandelas.

    “That makes sense to me, don't it?”
    ~ George W. Bush, 2006-06-06


  15. bob h Says:

    my jaw broke when it hit my desk just now - holy fecking bleck is he INSANE?

    SPIN THIS JAKE -SPIN IT I SAY!


  16. Red Pill Says:

    Jesus and Mary, Mother of God! I know the man was trying to be metaphorical, but he's come completely unhinged! Republicans, I give you your president. Enjoy.


  17. freeman Says:

    Perhaps we should sought through the 3/4 of a million dead corpses and see if we can find nelson among them ?Maybe he's alive and living as a refugee along with 4 million others along the Syrian border ?


  18. upside99 Says:

    Comment by missmolly — September 20, 2007 @ 12:12 pm

    You are giving Dubya WAAAAY too much credit for his "lack of stupidity".

    Unfortunately, he is playing to his base; the 29%ers who have an IQ to match, and watch roid-rage wrestling and think it is real, which kinda gives you your first clue.


  19. The Republic of Stupidity Says:

    I’m certain that they’ve got him on mood-altering pharmeceuticals.

    Recommend | Report Abuse

    Comment by Ret. Col. Jack Ripper — September 20, 2007 @ 12:12 pm

    I think George went clinically psychotic quite some time ago, and he's propped up full time by pills these days. And I'm not being flip.


  20. bob h Says:

    isnt there a doctor that can declare our preznit unfit for duty at anyhting like on star trek? yet again a fictional show has more safeguards than reality.


  21. bob h Says:

    jake? have you managed to gather some spin for this guy yet? im waiting.


  22. gummitch Says:

    I hope he didn’t truly mean Nelson Mandela. I mean — I know this guy doesn’t even know the difference between Slovenia and Slovakia, but surely he’s not so stupid he really thinks Mandela got murdered by Hussein?

    Comment by missmolly — September 20, 2007 @ 12:12 pm

    Doesn't know Austria from Australia, either.

    I think his intent is pretty obvious: he meant to say something about how there was no Nelson Mandela to rise to the presidency after Saddam was deposed because Saddam had executed all the potential Mandelas.


  23. freeman Says:

    After listening to this I too am beginning to wonder if there are limits to free speach !Think of the embarrasment we would be saved if someone would censor this guy .


  24. bob h Says:

    his speechwriter must have committed seppuku today.


  25. Zimzone Says:

    I believe he was referring to Martha & the Vandellas.

    So, we should be Dancing in the Streets, celebrating!

    And it wasn't Mandela that killed Saddam, it was George Michaels.

    And Al Sharpton is George Allen's grandmother.

    Geesh, don't you reporters know anything?


  26. TripMaster Monkey Says:

    Wow...this thread is 100% troll-free.

    Even Shakey Jake shies away from defending Chimpy in this instance.


  27. Kay Says:

    Another Day.
    More Lies.


  28. bob h Says:

    poet laureats around the world will attend the funeral of yet another butchered metaphor in the capitol of the united states.


  29. Stupid Git Says:

    So, Bush is stating that Saddam (metaphorically) killed terrorists?

    "Before he became vice president, Dick Cheney and the U.S. State Department denounced Nelson Mandela, leader of the African National Congress, as a terrorist."


  30. IALib Says:

    Barely able to repeat what he heard someone else say. How many meds is he on? Scary...............


  31. Candyce Says:

    Ohmygosh, just when I think he can't be any more stupider, there he goes. Am I missing some context here?


  32. bob h Says:

    nope, just coherence...no context needed if it cant be understood anyway


  33. Wayne Says:

    Bush has gone from mildly incoherent to completely incoherent. I’m certain that they’ve got him on mood-altering pharmeceuticals.

    Comment by Ret. Col. Jack Ripper — September 20, 2007 @ 12:12 pm

    He has been completely incoherent for some time.

    “And so, in my State of the — my State of the Union — or state — my speech to the nation, whatever you want to call it, speech to the nation — I asked Americans to give 4,000 years — 4,000 hours over the next — the rest of your life — of service to America.”
    ~ George W. Bush, Bridgeport, CT, 2002-09-04

    “Like generations before us, we have a calling from beyond the stars to stand for freedom.”
    ~ George “Earth-to-Mothership” W. Bush at GOP Convention, 2004-09-02

    “I’ve made mistakes.. I haven’t done cocaine during the past seven, no twenty-five years.”
    ~ George W. Bush

    “Families is where our nation finds hope, where wings take dream.”
    ~ George W. Bush

    “We’ll let our friends be the peacekeepers and the great country called America will be the pacemakers.”
    ~ George W. Bush

    “Russia's big and so is China.”
    ~ George W. Bush, G-8 summit, 2006-07-17

    I could keep posting almost forever, but you get the idea.


  34. The Republic of Stupidity Says:

    Doesn’t know Austria from Australia, either.

    Comment by gummitch — September 20, 2007 @ 12:17 pm

    Albania from Alabama?


  35. bob h Says:

    “Like generations before us, we have a calling from beyond the stars to stand for freedom.”
    ~ George “Earth-to-Mothership” W. Bush at GOP Convention, 2004-09-02

    you...fecking....bastage....cant ......BREATHE....laughing....tooo....hard


  36. bob h Says:

    i swear some day george will come up with the deadly joke -laughing millions into early graves due to his own stupidity....nearly got me there


  37. mongo Says:

    Well played, mr. president. Well played.


  38. KingCranky Says:

    Nice, W's rambling, bizarre answer is right up there with Miss Teen South Carolina's take on why people can't find the US on a map


  39. The Republic of Stupidity Says:

    I have to say, I really liked the Harry Potter outfits he and Howard were wearing in that thread from yesterday. Did they really not think people would be taking their pictures, and those pix would be all over the world immediately.

    Question, was that pic taken before or after they wore the pointy hats and the big round glasses, and didn't anyone get that moment on film too?


  40. The Republic of Stupidity Says:

    Nice to see the humor come back to a TP thread. Haven't seen one this funny in weeks and weeks.


  41. katy Says:

    most anyone who COULD leave iraq has left...
    that would be the people of any means and education...
    the mid-to-upper classes... the "mandelas"...
    it's not just ETHNIC cleansing...
    ...
    kinda like what he's working on here in the states...
    ...


  42. jcasey@thenonsequitur.com Says:

    I think Bush probably meant that Saddam killed all dissidents--those who could have taken the lead in Iraq now. Pointing out that Mandela is alive missed that point.

    But, (1) Bush should have known that in advance of trying to remake Iraqi society;

    (2) Mandela was a poor example of Bush's point, as Mandela did not advocate (as far as I know) democracy through violent regime change.


  43. Wayne Says:

    you…fecking….bastage….cant ……BREATHE….laughing….tooo….hard

    Comment by bob h — September 20, 2007 @ 12:22 pm

    You're welcome =D


  44. bob h Says:

    wheres jake?

    his take on this his spin would surely make me laugh for another hour. cmon jake dont pussnboots out on me


  45. Zimzone Says:

    Melson Nandela hung with Saddam, but he didn't hang him.

    Somebody once said, ...I heard someone say once that...umm, you can

    fool a man once, but you can't make him drink. Yeah, that's it.


  46. bob h Says:

    thats it jake? woosey. cmon - spin his idocy


  47. bob h Says:

    spin jake spin....your the forrest gump of bushes fanbois


  48. upside99 Says:

    If anyone NOT on the “Ignore List” wants to discuss the topic, please let me know.
    Comment by Jake D. — September 20, 2007 @ 12:30 pm

    It's your dime, Jake. Go for it.


  49. bob h Says:

    dont disappoint jake your being called out


  50. Kay Says:

    Bush is a dumbass.


  51. upside99 Says:

    Bush is a dumbass.
    Comment by Kay — September 20, 2007 @ 12:33 pm

    But he is the Repug's dumbass. And makes them all SOOO proud.


  52. The Republic of Stupidity Says:

    Geez, just when we were havin' fun, You-Know-Who shows up and makes yet another incoherent comment.

    Kinda like the big scene at the end of "O Brother Where Art thou" when Homer Stokes tries to stop the Foggy Bottom Boys...

    "We all were havin' fun... Shakey..."


  53. dim wit Says:

    Between this post and the last two, I think Bush is starting to mentally lose it.


  54. missmolly Says:

    I think his intent is pretty obvious: he meant to say something about how there was no Nelson Mandela to rise to the presidency after Saddam was deposed because Saddam had executed all the potential Mandelas.

    Comment by gummitch — September 20, 2007 @ 12:17 pm

    Thanks, gummitch -- I usually pick up on metaphorical references pretty well, but this one was garbled enough that I really didn't have a clue what he meant.

    I suspect that one of Bush's handlers gave him the metaphor to use without giving him the proper training along with it.


  55. Jeremy in Denver Says:

    “Like generations before us, we have a calling from beyond the stars to stand for freedom.”
    ~ George “Earth-to-Mothership” W. Bush at GOP Convention, 2004-09-02

    --------------

    Unfortunately, he misinterpreted the message from 'beyond the stars'...

    It actually was:

    "We are the Borg. Lower your shields and surrender your ships. We will add your biological and technological distinctiveness to our own. Your culture will adapt to service us. Resistance is futile."


  56. Doc Rock Says:

    Was Bush trying to use a full-Nelson or just a half-Nelson?


  57. helenahandbasket Says:

    Come on jaked. Explain to us why bush never preps for anything. He always just "wings" it. This is the hallmark of a C minus student and an F minus president.


  58. Wayne Says:

    If anyone NOT on the “Ignore List” wants to discuss the topic, please let me know.
    Comment by Jake D.

    That. is. just. Lame.


  59. Starve-A-Bush_Feed-A-Beaver Says:

    Maybe Bush actually meant to say "Mandala", which is a Sanskrit word for circle or "completion". In Buddhism, the mandala is a painted circle that represents the cosmos metaphysically or symbolically, a microcosm of the Universe from the human perspective. Buddhists meditate before the circle of the mandala to go into a trance-like state where consciousness and subconsciousness are joined.

    He must have been talking about Mandalas, right? Bush could not possibly have meant to say "Mandela's dead", could he when Mandela is not dead. He could not possibly be that big an out-of-touch blithering drooling brain-dead idiot and national embarrassment could he?


  60. mongo Says:

    #44

    "2) Mandela was a poor example of Bush’s point, as Mandela did not advocate (as far as I know) democracy through violent regime change."

    Actually, he *did* advocate violence as a legitimate mechanism for regime change by the ANC in South Africa; that's why he was sentenced to life in prison.


  61. Menehune Says:

    Wasn't Allawi supposed to be the Mandela of Iraq? Or was it Chalabi?


  62. Ret. Col. Jack Ripper Says:

    Wayne: "I could keep posting almost forever, but you get the idea."

    Right. There are literally books of them. One of my personal favorites:

    "I understand small business growth. I was one."


  63. Exley Says:

    #44, jcasey@thenonsequitur.com,

    "I think Bush probably meant that Saddam killed all dissidents–those who could have taken the lead in Iraq now. Pointing out that Mandela is alive missed that point."

    Congratulations! You are the only other person here who understood the rather obvious historical analogy Bush was making.


  64. progressive homeschooler Says:

    Nice, W’s rambling, bizarre answer is right up there with Miss Teen South Carolina’s take on why people can’t find the US on a map
    Comment by KingCranky

    Maybe Dumbya was one of those kids who grew up without a map. He should be the first recipient of the new Maps for Kids program. /snark


  65. upside99 Says:

    Dubya:

    "You mean there are Shiaa and Sunnis in the Muslim culture? WOW!! Who'da thunk? Guess I got an "Incomplete" in that Mid-East History class. Too busy cheerleadin' and stuff."


  66. JM Says:

    As others have mentioned above, it's obvious what Bush meant to imply - that there really aren't any "potential Mandelas" left in Iraq.

    His inability to understand why that might be the case is the spooky part.

    It's also incredibly spooky, to me at least, that it's clear that Bush actually believes the things he spouts. He believes that history will vindicate him; he believes that he will be seen as a great leader.

    Let's only hope that this unbelievable narcissistic rube doesn't drag us further into the abyss.


  67. Zimzone Says:

    #59, Was Bush trying to use a full-Nelson or just a half-Nelson?
    -Comment by Doc Rock

    Doc, I believe it was the 'Dead Nelson'.


  68. Bartolo Says:

    This is funny. The original quote was something like "Where's the next Mandela? Sadly, they're all dead now."

    He doesn't listen to his advisors, so this is what we get: authentic Texas Idiot jibberish.


  69. Zimzone Says:

    Bush was a C student before he was an F student.


  70. Wayne Says:

    One of my personal favorites:
    “I understand small business growth. I was one.”
    Comment by Ret. Col. Jack Ripper — September 20, 2007 @ 12:43 pm

    lmao
    My personal favorite Bushism, that I use quite a bit:

    “That makes sense to me, don't it?”
    ~ George W. Bush, 2006-06-06


  71. Keith H. Says:

    Memo to Junior:

    Crawl back under the rock you were conceived on.


  72. toasterhead Says:

    “I understand small business growth. I was one.”

    Comment by Ret. Col. Jack Ripper — September 20, 2007 @ 12:43 pm

    I like that quote.

    It's especially ironic since one of the investors in his small business was Salem bin Laden, Usama's half-brother.


  73. Starve-A-Bush_Feed-A-Beaver Says:

    My favorite Bushism:

    "And so, in my State of the - my State of the Union - or state - my speech to the nation, whatever you want to call it, speech to the nation - I asked Americans to give 4,000 years - 4,000 hours over the next - the rest of your life - of service to America. That's what I asked - 4,000 hours."

    I crack up every time I see that he refers to the State of the Union speech as "whatever you want to call it". It sounds like the class clown in Junior High.


  74. mrnetop Says:

    I don't believe that people are calling him an idiot because they don't understand the point he was trying to make. He's an idiot cause he cant make his point clear. I am not the most articulate person around, but I believe he should have said.

    "People are asking, 'Where are all the Mandelas' Well, all the Mandelas are dead, Saddam killed them all"

    When the president speaks, we should not have to "figure" out what he said and come to a "Logical" conclusion.


  75. toasterhead Says:

    Wasn’t Allawi supposed to be the Mandela of Iraq? Or was it Chalabi?

    Comment by Menehune — September 20, 2007 @ 12:40 pm

    Allawi's more the Thabo Mbeki of Iraq. And Chalabi is, I dunno, Dr. Beetroot.


  76. nigel Says:

    I seem to recall something about Cheney objecting to Madella being released......I'm sure it was because he thought of him as a terrorist, I could be wrong


  77. Sean Says:

    More hilarious clips from our national monkey. Duh-duh-duhbya.

    ~Sean


  78. MCMetal Says:

    #59, Was Bush trying to use a full-Nelson or just a half-Nelson?
    -Comment by Doc Rock

    Doc, I believe it was the ‘Dead Nelson’.

    Comment by Zimzone — September 20, 2007 @ 12:46 pm

    More like Major Nelson from "I Dream Of Jeannie"...........


  79. Sean Says:

    #83 - Yes... that's exactly what TP reported.

    In a press conference this morning, President Bush tried to assert that Saddam’s brutal rule over Iraq wiped the country clean of potential democratic reformers — individuals who may have possessed leadership skills like former South African President Nelson Mandela. In doing so, Bush inartfully suggested Saddam killed Mandela

    ...?

    Maybe the headline is a bit misleading, but they did report it correctly.

    ~Sean


  80. missmolly Says:

    I, too, regret that Iraq has no Nelson Mandela. If there was a Mandela to take over as soon as Saddam was driven out, he would have kicked the foreign occupiers out. And without any oil, either.


  81. MCMetal Says:

    TP is really pathetic. Watch the clip again. He doesn’t say Nelson Mandella was killed by Saddam. He says Saddam killed all the Mandellas (plural) (as in the people who would have desented Hussein in Iraq, if he hadn’t killed them all).

    You people should be smarter than this.

    Comment by CaptainMantastic — September 20, 2007 @ 1:08 pm

    Yeah , it was ALL SADDAM ............Chimpy's idiotic and illegal invasion and subsequent occupation of Iraq , with about 1 million Iraqis killed and millions more displaced from their homes has absolutely nothing to do with it ................

    I realize you aren't smart enough to realize and comprehend that , CrapstainMantastic.


  82. tablogloid Says:

    #82. The only Nelson Bush really knows is Willie.


  83. Wayne Says:

    You people should be smarter than this.
    Comment by CaptainMantastic — September 20, 2007 @ 1:08 pm

    And You should be actually smart enough to read the article before commenting


  84. tablogloid Says:

    #87 Captain, don't be a party pooper. If you want to read more accurate stuff, go to Fox News


  85. Sean Says:

    CaptainMantastic - I really didn't read this "report" thinking that TP was doing an indepth investigation of whether or not the President thinks Saddam killed Mandela. To me, it looks like Bush was just sounding like an idiot, and they wanted to poke fun of him. Maybe I'm wrong, but that's how I interpret this post.

    ~Sean


  86. Ret. Col. Jack Ripper Says:

    Captain Mantastic: "Whaaaa, snort, sniff, you people are soooooo unfair to our dear leader. Whaaaaa. You've misrepresented one of his intelligent musings. Whaaaa. Mantastic, don't you have some cruising to get to somewhere. Isn't there a public bathroom you need to get to for your daily tappings?


  87. labdad95 Says:

    What a lame...rhymes with duck.


  88. MCMetal Says:

    “For the record, Nelson Mandela is still alive while Saddam Hussein is dead. ”

    Thinkprogress will post information like this, because they believe the audience here is ignorant enough to accept that Bush believes that Mandela is dead and Saddam killed him.

    Please demand more from TP. For the sake of your own credibility.

    Comment by CaptainMantastic — September 20, 2007 @ 1:14 pm

    Like how adamant you Chimpy leg-humpers have been towards this administration's propogandist lies and claims , Crapstain ?


  89. missmolly Says:

    Thinkprogress will post information like this, because they believe the audience here is ignorant enough to accept that Bush believes that Mandela is dead and Saddam killed him.

    Comment by CaptainMantastic — September 20, 2007 @ 1:14 pm

    If we believe that Bush is capable of thinking that Mandela is dead and Saddam killed him, it's because he's got a track record of being an idiot, not because we are ignorant. However, I think most of us gave him credit for knowing that Saddam never killed Mandela -- he just tangled up what he intended to say (and Bush has an even BIGGER track record of misstatements - enough to fill up a couple of books so far).


  90. Nature Rules Says:

    #44

    “2) Mandela was a poor example of Bush’s point, as Mandela did not advocate (as far as I know) democracy through violent regime change.”

    Actually, he *did* advocate violence as a legitimate mechanism for regime change by the ANC in South Africa; that’s why he was sentenced to life in prison.

    Comment by mongo — September 20, 2007 @ 12:39 pm

    Mongo, I think, and of course I could be wrong, but Mandela advocated destruction of infrastructure. Things like communication equipment and such. He vehemently opposed any violence to fellow humans and when his followers were destroying things he was adamant that no one get hurt in the process. This was wishful thinking as I believe some people were killed in these operations.

    In other words, Mandela was doing what the US was doing to Iraq's infrastructure before the ousting of Saddam.


  91. theswan Says:

    George has one thing correct, that Mandela has leadership skills. But George would know nothing about leadership and should just shut up.


  92. ibeglb Says:

    You know what they say, "It's not the heat, it's the stupidity."

    What a boob.


  93. Starve-A-Bush_Feed-A-Beaver Says:

    Most of Iraq's intelligentsia, its writers, poets, philosophers, doctors, college professors, journalists, have fled the country and are now living in places like Jordan and Egypt. Shock and awe and the US policy of dismantling the social order and civil infrastructure of Iraq accomplished that. Bush himself would do away with the Iraqi equivalent of Nelson Mandela or put him in Abu Ghraib because that Iraqi would be a patriot and would oppose the violent invasion and permanent occupation of his country.


  94. IgnoranceIsNotBliss Says:

    I know what he was tryinh to say, but sheesh, could he say it any worse thatn he did? And he actually looked like he believed that Mandella was dead.



  95. Nature Rules Says:

    NOOOOOOO A Test and I haven't studied!


  96. Wayne Says:

    It’s more like you cats are unhinged, “Col.”.
    BDS.
    Comment by Toliver — September 20, 2007 @ 1:22 pm

    Its more like you cannot defend your position without verbal attacks, such as "you cats are unhinged".

    Typical drivel from you Toliver


  97. Bush is a four letter word Says:

    Sadly, I understand what he's trying to say. He's just so goddamned awful at saying it.


  98. Wayne Says:

    The only Nelson Bush really knows is Willie.
    Comment by tablogloid — September 20, 2007 @ 1:14 pm

    And Willie Nelson does NOT like Bush.


  99. Severus Says:

    I'm not fan of Bush but I fully understand what he was saying and he is essentially correct. I see no need for a story or for a 100+ comment thread on it. The guys makkes enough mistakes to jump on that warrent more attention than this.


  100. Severus Says:

    What I was saying is he totally mangled what he was saying, but what he meant to say was correct.


  101. rf7777 Says:

    The audacity of that G*d Damn F*cking MORON! Mandela is a democratic reformer that absolutely hates and denounces Bush and his actions.


  102. Wayne Says:

    The only Nelson Bush really knows is Willie.
    Comment by tablogloid — September 20, 2007 @ 1:14 pm

    And Willie Nelson does NOT like Bush.
    Comment by Wayne — September 20, 2007 @ 2:05 pm

    Lost the rest of my post, blahhh

    Willie wrote this song in 2004

    What Ever Happened To Peace On Earth
    By Willie Nelson

    There's so many things going on in the world
    Babies dying
    Mothers crying
    How much oil is one human life worth
    And what ever happened to peace on earth

    We believe everything that they tell us
    They're gonna’ kill us
    So we gotta’ kill them first
    But I remember a commandment
    Thou shall not kill
    How much is that soldier’s life worth
    And whatever happened to peace on earth

    (Bridge)

    And the bewildered herd is still believing
    Everything we’ve been told from our birth
    Hell they won’t lie to me
    Not on my own damn TV
    But how much is a liars word worth
    And whatever happened to peace on earth

    So I guess it’s just
    Do unto others before they do it to you
    Let’s just kill em’ all and let God sort em’ out
    Is this what God wants us to do

    (Repeat Bridge)

    And the bewildered herd is still believing
    Everything we’ve been told from our birth
    Hell they won’t lie to me
    Not on my own damn TV
    But how much is a liars word worth
    And whatever happened to peace on earth

    Now you probably won’t hear this on your radio
    Probably not on your local TV
    But if there’s a time, and if you’re ever so inclined
    You can always hear it from me
    How much is one picker’s word worth
    And whatever happened to peace on earth

    But don’t confuse caring for weakness
    You can’t put that label on me
    The truth is my weapon of mass protection
    And I believe truth sets you free

    (Bridge)

    And the bewildered herd is still believing
    Everything we’ve been told from our birth
    Hell they won’t lie to me
    Not on my own damn TV
    But how much is a liars word worth
    And whatever happened to peace on earth

    "I said, 'He's not from Texas and he ain't a cowboy, so let's stop trashin' Texas and cowboys.' It got a little chuckle, but I didn't get run out of the country!," Willie Nelson, commenting on the Dixie Chicks getting a raw deal after being publicly criticised over their blasting President Bush's war policies.


  103. Clumberfeet Says:

    Nelson Mandela is dead and Osama bin Laden is alive and an imminent threat to America.
    Nurse Ratched that pain in my head is coming back. May I have another injection of 'support our troops'?


  104. doro Says:

    "Banging head on desk!"


  105. wiseass.org Says:

    #86 TP is really pathetic. Watch the clip again. He doesn’t say Nelson Mandella was killed by Saddam.

    Comment by MCMetal — September 20, 2007 @ 1:14 pm

    Ahhh, YOU need to watch the clip again because he says:

    "I thought an interesting comment was made — somebody said to me, I heard somebody say, “Now, where’s Mandela?” (singluar) Well, Mandela’s (singular contraction of Madela is) dead because Saddam Hussein killed all the Mandelas (plural)."


  106. wiseass.org Says:

    #101 I know what he was tryinh to say, but sheesh, could he say it any worse thatn he did? And he actually looked like he believed that Mandella was dead.

    Comment by IgnoranceIsNotBliss — September 20, 2007 @ 1:30 pm

    Exactly.


  107. tablogloid Says:

    Comment #106: "You may not like what Bush has to say. But, at least, he will do what he says he’s going to do."

    When did Bush say he was going to totally destroy Iraq?
    When did Bush say he was going to ruin America?
    When did Bush say he supports habeas corpus?


  108. sleuth Says:

    First off I hate Bush as much as any sane person should, but the point he is making is that future iraqi "Mandela's" were killed by Saddam's regime.
    Probably true and equally more true of those Mandela's that have been killed or silenced by the american occupation. Yes Bush has handelers telling him to say stupid stuff. Like a bird cage liner he has now been completely used up and is ready to be scape goated for everything that has happened on his watch. That is why the establishment can turn their back on him and now are willing to show us how stupid he is. Don't worry it's all caused by the dumb decision the dumb prez made ( who the voters voted for) This will all go away when he is gone (but no reason for impeachment, Pelosi). Problem is he did more for the establishment in his time than any other sell out leader, (until HITLERY, just wait). It was a success from the elite/police state perspective, and now he must be sacrificed to appease the public while the true agenda (controlling the right and the LEFT) moves forward faster than ever.


  109. foreyes Says:

    I'm not sure, but if Mandela was able to hold on to Bush's neck, America's trouble would be over. Here's a guy who could withstand 27 years of abuse from a South African/Israeli apartheid regime and come out a Statesman. What more can you ask?


  110. Ditch Mitch KY Says:

    OMG -- Bush's comments today left me with a profound sense of shame. We all must apologize to the world for this dim-witted man.


  111. DanCaveman Says:

    You may not like what Bush has to say. But, at least, he will do what he says he’s going to do. Maybe Democrats could fare better, if they took example from him on this one point.

    Comment by CaptainMantastic — September 20, 2007 @ 2:03 pm

    Thanks for nothing CaptainMantastic, you had to ruin the best laugh I have had in a while (I don't laugh much anymore) and get me all angry again.

    You mean Bush kept his promise of:
    1. Not nation building?
    2. Using "war" as a last resort?
    3. Helping New Orleans?
    4. Taking care of veterans? (done nothing with Dole Shalaala report)
    5. Catching Osama Bin Laden "dead or alive"?
    6. "I will restore honor and integrity to the white house"?
    7. "I am a Uniter, not a Divider"?
    8. Election reform (well I guess he did this one - just not the way I hoped)
    9. Beefing up Military (still don't have up armor vehicles or blast
    ...
    There are more, but I have spent too much time on here. Thanks for ruining a perfectly funny thread!


  112. Domoso Says:

    It has been said in this thread and I've heard it often from others that we must not take his words out of context, not focus on just the words and understand Bush's meanings when he makes these blunders. I actually have a co-worker who gets pissed off at me when I bring up such "Bushisms" for this very reason. I can tell the difference between Bush's meanings and his words. At some point, due to the frequency of such occurances the words have to speak for themselves. I couldn't get a job if I spoke in the same manner in an interview as Bush speaks to the entire world. It's a sad state of affairs that we must endure such a imbecile as the leader of our country. His actions and more frequently his words denote a lack of understanding, foresight and intelligence to deal with the issues that face the world and this country. Without the teleprompters it should be obvious to anyone that the man does not have a clue about whats's going on beyond what is discussed in the brief briefings before the speaking engagement. So often I watch Bush speak after the "speech" is over (i.e. the teleprompters are off) during the question and answer period, the man is just filling the obligatory time. He is without a doubt the most inept president this country has ever seen.


  113. foreyes Says:

    Saddam, who didn't killed nor liked Mandela knew that George Bush was in fact trying to kill him, even as he knew that Bush's handler, Cheney, tried to get Mandela kept in prison after accussing him of being a "terrorist". Twenty seven years after beginning his fight against the Apartheid regime of South Africa, Mandela stands with many people who thought that, for sure, Americans would choose an idiot for President.


  114. foreyes Says:

    Here’s a guy who could withstand 27 years of abuse from a South African/Israeli apartheid regime and come out to be a statesman. What more can you ask?
    That's what it takes to be a Statesman None like him has ever been borned in South Africa or, Africa as a whole!. I"m a fan of Nelson Mandela, I'm sorry for being so explicit and I understand that if you don't share my enthusiam, it's not because you're wrong!


  115. foreyes Says:

    Who's my hero now? It's Mordechai Vanunu, an israeli who is against nuclear weapons and who has paid with many years of his life for his convictions. If you read his story, (Google it if you want to know), it makes you sad that it is about Israel and how they have treated him all along.


  116. Chocolate Jesus Says:

    Iraqi Mandelas arent dead. They are people like Al-Sadr. We may not find this concept appealing, but its true. The idea that an islamic "mandela" would be something the united states would approve of is farcical at best...


  117. skir Says:

    Hi; new here. I have been a huge fan of this site for a while but only now noticed the post under the headlines of the articles.

    I realize that Bush was trying to say Saddam killed all the would leaders of Iraq; however, he did say point blank that Mandalas is dead. Even metaphorically Mandalas is not dead as is evident by the link to the biography.

    It is true that during Saddam's reign a lot of the people that could lead left or were killed, however; just as many people of those people have left or have been killed since the invasion.


  118. mosh Says:

    Bush wasn't speaking metaphorically. He didn't know what the hell he was saying. And if you right wing lunatics want to keep pretending that your brilliant leader was trying to do so, keep at it. Anyone with a lick of sense and a fourth grade education can see that this guy was just babbling. Keep defending this braindead loser and take your party down even faster.


  119. Poutinepete Says:

    You Yanks always complain about Bush's intelligence (or lack of); and yet you re-elected him for a second term.Let's face it, everyone knew by the end of his first term that thinking and talking weren't his strong points, so what gives?.... You re-elected him because enough people believed that his Iraq plan would eventually work and he had the determination to stick with the plans no matter how unpopular. So you got exactly what you voted for!


  120. IBeAWizard Says:

    It's TOTALLY amazing to me how such an IDIOT was irresponsibly PLACED in charge of a nation!! Cause you KNOW he didn't freakin win. And, his speeches prove WHY!


  121. Carkington Says:

    Not my president. It is a sad chapter in our history that the guy who represents US is an illiterate buffoon.

    No matter what he was trying to say he came off looking and sounding like a fool.


  122. nonDescript Says:

    He might have been trying to tell us about how Saddam killed off all of the Mandela-like leaders in Iraq, but his little giggle lets us know that someone told him to say this stuff. He really thinks it's great that the man he wants to be could do that kind of thing. I think he'd like to kill off all of us who disagree with him.

    Ever notice how much more easy he speaks when he's talking about death and destruction? Even in the same sentence. His cute little smirk, and I just love how he laughs at the thought of killing off great people.

    Everytime he speaks I wish I lived in Canada.


  123. James Says:

    I'm leaving the country - somewhere I won't be ashamed of. Anyone want to join me?


  124. sexagenarian Says:

    Someone, anyone, please give me one example of a genuine (as opposed to one tinkled into his ear) apt Bush metaphor. All I'm asking is for one example that wasn't just another failed attempt to utilize the same word in a different tense or in a different place in a sentence.
    The man wouldn't know a metaphor from a meta-5. And his anger and arrogance when forced to face his own ignorance, as in this video, is chilling.


  125. Poutinepete Says:

    If Bush was given the "opportunity" (snicker) to debate the Iraq war question(to leave or stay?) against Bill Clinton, on national TV...who do you think would win?


  126. CommonSense2007 Says:

    I watched and listened to the President's press conference when this comment was made. I can tell you that anyone with even a minimum cluster of intelligent brain cells would have known that his allusion to Mandella was not that "Nelson Mandella" is dead, but that Iraqis of Mandella's character are dead because of Saddam Hussein. Are we so quick to belittle our President that all common sense flies out the window in order to take a verbal or written "pot-shot" at him?


  127. sexagenarian Says:

    Hey Big Brother:
    Americans of Mandela's (not Mandella) character are also apparently "dead" - not because of Saddam Hussein but because of fear of this "lack of one iota of common sense administration" which is a deserving magnet for any and all pot shots.
    War is the lowest form of human endeavor; and that sadly is what this administration is all about. The attempt to spin another unfortunate gaffe is just so pathetic and wearisome.
    CS07:You can spy on some of us some of the time and all of us some of the time, but you can't spy on all of us all of the time.


  128. smartdust Says:

    What perfect teatre!
    Go George ! (what kind of medication do you need or perhaps get to much of ?)
    To bad for all the good people of Usa, that this dude makes the rest of the world just loose respect and laugh of Usa.
    Oslo Norway.


  129. CommonSense2007 Says:

    I agree that war is the lowest form of human endeavor. As to the pot shot theory towards the President, whatever your politics, you don't have to respect the man (or his administration), but we should respect the position. If we could do better we'd be sitting there.


  130. Lizzie Hobbit Says:

    Are we so quick to belittle our President that all common sense flies out the window in order to take a verbal or written “pot-shot” at him?
    Comment by CommonSense2007 — September 22, 2007 @ 9:59 am

    Menstruating Women March on Washington: Red Bush on G Bush.
    Pot shot accomplished, commander.


  131. President Bushybits Says:

    The whole world should wake up and act now. Boycott ALL American products. Every country in the world should stop supplying America with its consumables. Every Oil country in the world should start trading their oil in Euros not US Dollars because why should we trade in a currency that has no value and if their is a value then its certainly not stable enough. The world is united on one thing, they ALL hate America and its totally ignorant leaders who are bombing countries they cant even spell, let alone point out on a map. 70% of Americans don't even know where England is on the map. Hello!
    So what if America puts sanctions on every country that doesn't want to play ball. Nobody wants to play ball with America anyway. All Americans should take a step back, and if they are not to ignorant contemplate what America is doing to the rest of the world. Take a long good look at yourselves and the Monkeys YOU voted into power. Are You happy the way things are? Are you happy that in YOUR country you don't even have the basic human right of Habeas Corpus - Free Speech.
    How can a nation of idiots who don't even practice free speech and democracy impose those rights onto other nations by force?
    Bush is the spokes person for the free world and America. Sorry, I live in a free part of this world, and we are not Bush fans and he does not speak for me or my countrymen. Bush is a Joke, and all Americans who follow this Joke are being laughed at all around the world. You Americans need to educate yourselves and listen to what other people from around the world are saying.
    Why do you think they tell all Americans who travel outside on the states to keep a low profile and no openly shout out they are Americans? (There was a time it was cool to be an American).
    Only 2% of All Americans have a passport. Out of that 2% over half are military people. That leaves a handful of Americans who are Worldly. Surely a nation with absolute NO knowledge or interest of the rest of the world should reflect that knowledge by pulling their necks in and stop telling US (The rest of the world) what to do.
    Only then, once America sorts out their own mess at home, apologizes to Iraq and any other country they have illegally invaded, cleaned up their mess and actually becomes an example to the rest of the world, only then will America possibly be respected again. But until then, I speak for a huge global majority from hundreds of countries. Nobody respects Americans anymore. Nobody likes Americans anymore. Soon, people are going to do something about it and it isn't going to look good for Bush and his followers. So take head America, your days are numbered and come the elections or in 483 Days when Bush leaves office you better vote in an President and not some dumb monkey.
    Your future and lives depend on it.



Jump to Top

About Think Progress | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2009 Center for American Progress Action Fund
View Most Popular

Advertisement

What We're About

Featured

image
Subscribe to the Progress Report



imageTopic Cloud


Visit Our Affiliated Sites

image image
Reports


Got a hot tip?
Have a hot news tip? We'd love to hear from you. Use the form below to send us the latest.

Name:
Email:
Tip:
(required)


imageArchives


imageBlog Roll