Think Progress

Five former secretaries of State call for Gitmo closure.

At a University of Georgia roundtable discussion yesterday, five former secretaries of State — Henry Kissinger, James Baker, Warren Christopher, Madeleine Albright, and Colin Powell — agreed that the next president should move quickly to close Guantanamo Bay. Highlights from the Atlanta Journal Constitution:

Powell, who was in office when the notorious prison opened in Cuba, was the first Thursday to call for it to be shuttered. The most recent holder of the office on the stage, Powell served the current president from 2001 to 2005.

“Our image abroad has dropped significantly,” Powell said. He put some of that blame on his former boss. [...]

Guantanamo “gives us a very, very bad name, not just internationally,” [James] Baker said. “I have a great deal of difficulty understanding how we can hold someone, pick someone up, particularly someone who might be an American citizen, even if they were caught somewhere abroad, acting against American interests, and hold them without ever giving them an opportunity to appear before a magistrate.”



73 Responses to “Five former secretaries of State call for Gitmo closure.”

  1. misshusseinmolly says:

    Bipartisan cooperation is so rare that when it happens, it’s worth listening to.

    Will Bushco listen? I predict their only reaction (if there is one at all) will be “So?”


  2. misshusseinmolly says:

    Condi isn’t on that list. Of course, she’s not a “former” SoS yet — she’s still functioning as the Bush Wind-up Doll of State.

    But when she becomes a “former” Secretary of State, will she join in this particular chorus?


  3. Zimzone says:

    5 former Secretary’s of State and…

    243 Million Americans!


  4. ralph the wonder llama says:

    misshusseinmolly Says:
    March 28th, 2008 at 2:37 pm
    Bipartisan cooperation is so rare that when it happens, it’s worth listening to.

    Will Bushco listen? I predict their only reaction (if there is one at all) will be “So?

    Oh, missmolly, you are so charmingly naive sometimes.

    To BushCo, what we see as “bipartisan cooperation”, they see as “treason”. Still, you may be right. Their only reaction may be a sneering, “So?” The alternative would be for The Lying Sack of Cute™ Dana Perino to question the patriotism of five former Secretaries of State (three of them Republican).


  5. L. Hussein Annie says:

    Guantanamo “gives us a very, very bad name, not just internationally,” [James] Baker said.

    No chit, Cherlock. You just figured that out…?


  6. Fan of Man says:

    “I have a great deal of difficulty understanding how we can hold someone, pick someone up, particularly someone who might be an American citizen, even if they were caught somewhere abroad, acting against American interests, and hold them without ever giving them an opportunity to appear before a magistrate.”

    lets just give bush crime family a pass… that’ll help!


  7. EdgeOnIt says:

    What a sorry, photo-op! Each of these people has made a career of APOLOGIZING for this ill, or that (for the Republican chimera!) How many times can ‘talking heads’ shoot themselves in the foot? If our reputation in the world is bad, and comment is called for, then logically why not include a ‘values assessment’ of just how bad it is? These Re-heads are jumping to a solution, without discussing the politcal problems we face! Pitiful!!


  8. JohnR says:

    Where was Colin Powell’s backbone when it mattered – when he was in the administration? Now he wants it closed. Real profile in courage.


  9. Shayne says:

    Sure they’re asking the NEXT president to close Gitmo. Because they’re AFRAID to tell this one what to do?


  10. Badmoodman says:

    Or what, they’ll use harsh language in a nasty letter to the President….Congress? Cheney trumps them all.


  11. Red Pill says:

    …agreed that the next president should move quickly to close Guantanamo Bay.

    Because they know that Chimpy McFlightsuit would neither understand nor act on their common sensical recommendation.


  12. Zimzone says:

    Cheney is the Anti-christ.

    Bush is the Court Jester.

    The only logic in this house is, we have no logic.


  13. Evil Spaniard says:

    POWELL: WHY were you so quiet when you were part of the GOP?


  14. Red Pill says:

    To skippy at 16:

    And you neocons want to discard two hundred years of due process and legal tradition like so much toilet paper because you haven’t the courage to recognize human rights as universal.


  15. Frosty Cupcake says:

    James Baker worked tirelessly to get the boy-king installed in the White House. Thanks for nothing, Baker.


  16. WaltTheMan says:

    ES,
    Powell had one fault, he was a loyal soldier and would always bow to his commander. He even stayed on post-election when he and W were at odds.


  17. fletc3her says:

    Even James Baker sounds sane compared to this administration?!


  18. tombaker says:

    skippy brought his pointy white hood with him – isn’t that cute.

    skippy, i’d be careful about throwing “-tard” around – your helmet is showing through you hood.


  19. ralph the wonder llama says:

    Man, Troll Central is really giving everyone a shot at the big time, aren’t they?

    They’ll hand a keyboard to any raw recruit who steps through the door (or in skippy’s case, the kid who delivered their lunch order…)


  20. tombaker says:

    skippy – you’re a retarded coward/pussy dittohead and I sincerely wish you the worst of everything life has to offer.


  21. Red Pill says:

    Skippy@20:

    This is the last biscuit you’ll get from me, troll, but I find it all too instructive that you have no specifics to offer in those remarks other than the obvious subtext of racial bigotry.

    Then again, perhaps we should interpret your skill with language and the keyboard as a reflection of your intellectual acumen?


  22. ralph the wonder llama says:

    tombaker Says:
    March 28th, 2008 at 3:12 pm
    skippy – you’re a retarded coward/pussy dittohead and I sincerely wish you the worst of everything life has to offer.

    Not to worry, tombaker — skippy’s kind of psychosis and hatred pretty much guarantees him a life of misery, which he will then blame on others.


  23. ralph the wonder llama says:

    Red Pill Says:
    March 28th, 2008 at 3:13 pm
    Skippy@20:

    perhaps we should interpret your skill with language and the keyboard as a reflection of your intellectual acumen?

    Well, it’s pretty good with ALL CAPS…


  24. tombaker says:

    let’s just close skippy’s tweaker trailer park instead – it would do the whole country a lot more good.


  25. tombaker says:

    skippy i don’t think for a second you have any idea what you’re talking about – you’re a boring re-run of a bad tv show that i never watched in the first place.


  26. ralph the wonder llama says:

    Uh, oh… sounds like skippy’s tweaked one dose too far.

    Could someone who cares call the paramedics?


  27. Shayne says:

    We should close down any place white trash idiots like Skippy live.


  28. Shayne says:

    ralph the wonder llama Says:
    March 28th, 2008 at 3:20 pm

    Uh, oh… sounds like skippy’s tweaked one dose too far.

    Could someone who cares call the paramedics?

    NOBODY cares. Extermination is the only solution.


  29. Who Misspoke Today? says:

    Skippy: May the fleas of a thousand camels infest your genitals, and may your arms be too short to scratch.

    OK, game on…


  30. Shayne says:

    Tell us Skippy, as a white male in America what’s your excuse for being a total failure?


  31. Shayne says:

    Well it’s obvious Asians are genetically smarter than you are Skippy. As are Hispanics and African Americans and every other ethnic group. It’s nobody’s fault but your own for being such a loser.


  32. Shayne says:

    Oh hi CT, thanks for outing yourself. You’re only here for a very short time aren’t you? Too bad you can’t control yourself to last a little bit longer, you must be starving at ten cents a post.


  33. ralph the wonder llama says:

    Oh, it’s our good friend C**T.

    I knew that voice sounded familiar. All that shouting.


  34. Shayne says:

    skippy Says:
    March 28th, 2008 at 3:26 pm

    Shayne,,,, my failure as a white male was letting the JAP get ahead (better than myself) while I was able to hold down the BLACK MAN,,,,,

    Why i did this? The chink is cuter.

    No your failure is blaming others instead of doing work to better yourself. But that is the neocon way isn’t it? Blame minorities for keeping you down while your masters continue to beat you down. What a bunch of idiots.


  35. ralph the wonder llama says:

    Not to mention the poor little C**T’s own unique version of race-baiting…

    Good eye, Shayne.


  36. Shayne says:

    skippy Says:
    March 28th, 2008 at 3:28 pm

    Shayne,,,, I’m positive ALL races are genetically smarter to whitey,,,,

    Why we only need set asides for BLACKS is confusing to me,,,

    THEY are so much smarter and yet the asians done’t need the help,,,, HMMMMMMMMMM

    It’s kind of hard to get here from Asia if you don’t have any money isn’t it. It’s not like we abducted Asians and brought them here on slave boats or anything.


  37. Shayne says:

    I don’t know ralph now I’m beginning to think it’s Mr. P. calling me Shaynee. CT would be more insulting by now.


  38. Shayne says:

    skippy Says:
    March 28th, 2008 at 3:32 pm

    Shayne,,,,

    I think your getting your excuses for failure and race mixed up with the NAACP,,, SHHHHHHHH quiet,, now your stealing thier lines.

    You are avoiding the issue. What’s YOUR excuse, loser?


  39. ralph the wonder llama says:

    Shayne Says:
    March 28th, 2008 at 3:33 pm
    I don’t know ralph now I’m beginning to think it’s Mr. P. calling me Shaynee. CT would be more insulting by now.

    Nah, it’s the poor little C**T. He blew his wad up front (he’s used to that, I’m betting) and now he’s trying to bait you some more while he regains his “energy”.

    Mr. Pee is a little more careful about his use of language.


  40. dbadass says:

    This whole deal is pitiful but still sort of amusing


  41. tombaker says:

    ever hear of Coolies, dummy?

    u keep up the incoherent jibber-jabber, and i’ll keep reminding you how big an idiot you are, OK?

    sooner or later, cooler heads will prevail, and you’ll get flagged the F on out of here

    until then – kiss my libtard moonbat ass – pussy.


  42. Zimzone says:

    Trollshit cleanup detail, please, it’s flooding may aisles…


  43. Shayne says:

    skippy Says:
    March 28th, 2008 at 3:35 pm

    It’s kind of hard to get here from Asia if you don’t have any money isn’t it. It’s not like we abducted Asians and brought them here on slave boats or anything.

    Funny,,, how they are dying to come here,,, considering how awful it is and difficult to get ahead,,,,,

    Just think how much better ASIANS would have done if they were the original slaves and had another 100 years to get ahead in this country with much larger #’s,,,,

    You forgot the subject while you were busy moving the goalpost loser. The question is why are you such a loser?


  44. tombaker says:

    flamin’ jesus – it’s a living breathing Turner Diaries character.

    how’s armed-militia-compound-life-in-Idaho treatin’ ya skippy?

    watch out for the ATF.


  45. tombaker says:

    flag on.

    you’re done, dummy.


  46. McWars says:

    The troll should do more to confront his masters — those oppressing him — instead of blaming disadvantaged minorities.


  47. Shayne says:

    skippy Says:
    March 28th, 2008 at 3:38 pm

    I wonder if the AVG dude in GHANA is happy that his ancestors were not sold into slavery by other black tribes to white traders and that as a consequence he GETS to live in a 3rd world country of HELL…..

    I’m sure he is ecstatic… and would never switch places with some lazy DETRIOT bum…

    If there is a Satan I’m sure you’ve just reserved yourself a special place in Hell. You are suggesting that former slaves should be grateful that they were abducted from their families and brought here. How about the millions that died on the unbearable trip over, I hope they’re waiting for you in Hell.


  48. dbadass says:

    Skippy?
    Did you just skip in from the loo?


  49. hussein toasterhead says:

    Shayne Says:
    March 28th, 2008 at 3:32 pm

    It’s kind of hard to get here from Asia if you don’t have any money isn’t it. It’s not like we abducted Asians and brought them here on slave boats or anything.

    Well they weren’t abducted exactly, but we did import thousands of Chinese laborers to work long hours for extremely low pay in often treacharous conditions to build the Trans-Continental Railroad.

    Not exactly the same as slavery, but it was pretty close.


  50. Nevar says:

    Skippy?

    Remember to latch the kennel gate next time, will ya sonny?


  51. Shayne says:

    hussein toasterhead Says:
    March 28th, 2008 at 3:45 pm

    Not exactly the same as slavery, but it was pretty close.

    But many, many Asians who have come here since have come here with big chunks of change. It’s hard to determine who started with nothing and who started here with a lot.



  52. Shayne says:

    Nevar Says:
    March 28th, 2008 at 3:47 pm

    Skippy?

    Remember to latch the kennel gate next time, will ya sonny?

    He’ll have to figure out how to make those opposable thumbs work first. Perhaps he can use his tail?


  53. misshusseinmolly says:

    Whew — it took me awhile, but I finally managed to flag all of skippy’s posts. Troll-turd cleanup is hard work.


  54. Nevar says:

    From the linked article:
    Kissinger, who served under presidents Nixon and Ford, said that not all of the criticism of the United States is because of American actions. “Some of it is also due to structural changes going on in other parts of the world,” he said.

    Yeah. Like countries trying to stand up to multi-national corporate militarists like you, henry, and reap the benefits of their own natural resources.

    In Europe, for example, governments no longer are the driving forces of national sentiment, Kissinger said. “European governments cannot ask their people to make sacrifices that American presidents can.”

    Yeah, cause the Europeans throw their corrupt asses in the gutter if they do. And the driving force of national sentiment is morality and human rights.

    Go to hell, Henry Kissinger.


  55. Shayne says:

    No db, the skippy on your video is cuter and smells better than our skippy.


  56. hussein toasterhead says:

    skippy Says:
    March 28th, 2008 at 3:48 pm
    Go ask the AVG dude in the 3rd world where HE wishes he lives don’t ask me….

    Your answer will go miles toward your recovery

    I have. I’ve been to the “3rd world.” Average dudes there usually want to stay there. Unfortunately, economic realities often force them to migrate to other countries to support their families through remittances.


  57. Shayne says:

    We’ve all been flagging the turd, I mean troll. The moderators must be out to lunch.


  58. ralph the wonder llama says:

    Shayne, can i offer a little friendly advice…?

    You are coming a little too close to actually engaging the troll on its issue of choice.

    Abuse the troll all you want, ridicule it, point out its foolishness… God knows there’s plenty there to work with. But just ignore its stupid cause d’troll.

    It’s the only way you can help it.


  59. Shayne says:

    skippy Says:
    March 28th, 2008 at 3:55 pm

    HEY,,,, what if we let minorities run GITMO,,,? would that make it OK for ya,,,

    I’m sure your debating the merits of the JOBS vs. that TYPE of job,,,,

    tough one,,, im sure

    Better question is if we send skippy to Gitmo and waterboard him will it make him talk more or shut him up?


  60. Nevar says:

    dbadass Says:
    March 28th, 2008 at 3:50 pm

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uRQnrY5V-rY
    Add Karma Recommend (1) |

    LMAO, I have tears in my eyes, I knew there was something else back there… who came first anyways, the TV show or the peanut butter?

    The final chorus to the theme:
    “Skippy, Skippy, Skippy the Boooosch kangerooooooo…”


  61. Shayne says:

    You are so right ralph. What do you think about waterboarding him? He knows nothing of importance but at least it would shut him up, maybe.


  62. WaltTheMan says:

    It’s finally gone! Sigh :)



  63. ralph the wonder llama says:

    I think waterboarding would be an excellent idea — hey! where’d he go?

    … he probably had to get to his next pizza delivery.


  64. misshusseinmolly says:

    I THOUGHT the air in here smelled cleaner…


  65. WaltTheMan says:

    Pizzas are no longer delivered by trike today. He will have to wait at least ten more years when he gets a driver’s license.
    Dbadass,
    That was a classic find!


  66. Max-1 says:

    .

    If Gitmo is so bad that FIVE FORMER Sec.s of State demand that the NEXT president close it, what of the current president?

    .


  67. tombaker says:

    what’s with the “surge” in abrasive dittoheads with massive chips on their shoulders rolling in here?


  68. ralph the wonder llama says:

    tombaker Says:
    March 28th, 2008 at 4:14 pm
    what’s with the “surge” in abrasive dittoheads with massive chips on their shoulders rolling in here?

    They’re making progress. The severe beating the trolls have been getting here is evidence that they’re winning. They can’t retreat or al Qaeda will take over TP. They’re here to liberate TP. They’ve been told that TPers will greet them with flowers and candy.

    They were misinformed.


  69. Shayne says:

    I wonder if the troll gets paid his ten cents if his post gets deleted.

    ralph, now they’re misinformed AND malformed.


  70. tombaker says:

    silly me – i forgot we were living in a “majority conservative” country again.


  71. zuch says:

    James Baker is one of the strongest critics of the five of the lawless treatment of detainees there, according to the article (as I highlight on my blog). But Baker is one of the “engineers” of the lawless installation of Dubya as preznit in the first place. Guess Guantánamo is too much even for him.

    Cheers,



Jump to Top

About Think Progress | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2009 Center for American Progress Action Fund
View Most Popular

Advertisement

What We're About

Featured

image
Subscribe to the Progress Report



imageTopic Cloud


Visit Our Affiliated Sites

image image
Reports


Got a hot tip?
Have a hot news tip? We'd love to hear from you. Use the form below to send us the latest.

Name:
Email:
Tip:
(required)


imageArchives


imageBlog Roll