Think Progress

Wiretapping program sparked legal concerns within hours of its adoption.

bookIn a new book entitled “Bush’s Law: The Remaking of American Justice,” NYT journalist Eric Lichtblau writes that the warrantless wiretapping set off legal concerns inside the Bush administration almost immediately after being implemented in October 2001. Inside the FBI, “technicians stumbled onto the N.S.A.’s program accidentally within 12 hours of its inception, setting off what officials described as a brief firestorm of anxiety among senior officials. … ‘What’s going on here? Is this legal?’ one F.B.I. official asked after learning of the N.S.A. operation on American soil.”



24 Responses to “Wiretapping program sparked legal concerns within hours of its adoption.”

  1. Bilbo Hussein Baggins says:

    almost immediately after being implemented in October 2001

    Why is this lie still being perpetuated. We know now that the Bush Administration started spying weeks after he took office. We have the AT&T whistle blower and the ex President of Qwest who have both testified to this.


  2. AngryOne says:

    In December 2005, New York Times reporters James Risen and Eric Lichtblau broke the shocking story of the Bush administration’s program of illegal domestic surveillance by the NSA. Now, in a new book due out next week, Lichtblau details the White House’s 13-month effort to block the Times’ revelations of its lawlessness. And to be sure, that deceitful stonewalling and the threats of retribution that followed show a Bush administration determined to conceal its criminality at any cost.

    For the details, see:
    “NYT’s Lichtblau Details White House Effort to Block NSA Story.”


  3. artmann11 says:

    Why is this lie still being perpetuated. We know now that the Bush Administration started spying weeks after he took office. We have the AT&T whistle blower and the ex President of Qwest who have both testified to this.

    Why is the Iraqi WND bs perpetrated to this very day? Same thing. Repeat a lie enough and it replaces the truth. Especially in our corporate driven tabloid (ahem) journalism in this country. You could have 200 witnesses saying the same thing and it would make no difference to these liars.


  4. Kay says:

    Ahem.

    The wireless wiretapping started before 9/11.

    Just ask Qwest.


  5. Badger says:

    “technicians stumbled onto the N.S.A.’s program accidentally within 12 hours of its inception, .

    If they STUMBLED onto this program, how do they know when its INCEPTION began???

    I know…they asked Cheney.


  6. TheToonGuy says:

    Badger Says:
    March 30th, 2008 at 11:59 am
    “technicians stumbled onto the N.S.A.’s program accidentally within 12 hours of its inception, .

    If they STUMBLED onto this program, how do they know when its INCEPTION began???

    I know…they asked Cheney.

    Trusting Cheney to tell the truth was their first mistake.


  7. Kay says:

    There has not been one honest day at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue since this Krime Kabal stole the 1st (of 2) elections in 2000.

    This is a fact.


  8. stewarjt says:

    ‘What’s going on here? Is this legal?’ one F.B.I. official asked after learning of the N.S.A. operation on American soil.”

    And then what happened? NOTHING!!!


  9. Chocolate Jesus says:

    telling ya, they were flat out data mining and running pattern algorithms on every domestic email. i predict the telecom lawsuits will eventually hit thier mark, even if immunity is sleazed into some bill, it wont pass constitutional muster…you cant use a law to sanction a constitional violation..


  10. Zooey says:

    But despite the firestorm of anxiety, we moved forward with this illegal activity…


  11. Kay says:

    The Nazi Chimp says his Admin. wiretaps for Our Security against the “terrorists”.

    Bullsh_t.

    This illegal activity occurred before 9/11. This admin are the real terrorists.


  12. Kay says:

    Before 9/11, NSA Asked Qwest for Network Access, Not Phone Records, National Journal Reports
    By Ryan Singel November 02, 2007 | 11:29:08 AMCategories: NSA
    The National Security Agency asked telecom giant Qwest to let the nation’s spies monitor its telecom networks 7 months before 9/11 in order to look for hackers and foreign-government e-attacks, the National Journal’s Shane Harris reports today.

    Though Qwest was seeking contracts from the NSA, its then CEO Joseph Nacchio denied repeated requests to let the NSA monitor its network, and later also turned down requests to turn over billions of customer records to the government, asking both times for legal orders, according to media reports and statements in Nacchio court records.

    Nacchio was convicted of selling shares in 2001 with knowledge that the company wouldn’t make its revenue targets. According to court documents unsealed in October, Nacchio was blocked from arguing that he believed that the company would make its public projections, thanks to classified NSA contracts, but that the NSA withheld them as punishment for his unwillingness to help the NSA without being legally ordered to do so.

    Those unsealed, but redacted documents explosively hinted that the NSA asked for call records just days after President Bush took office, but Harris reports the requests were different.


  13. Chocolate Jesus says:

    >but Harris reports the requests were different.

    any word on how Harris got that info?


  14. BearCountry says:

    More lying and criminal activity by w and his crew. Actually I don’t think w is smart enough to know exactly what is being done. I think he knows that it is criminal activity for anyone else, but, in his view, the President is above the law and the other two branches of the national government so it doesn’t concern him at all.


  15. Kgprophet says:

    Illegal wiretapping in the Nixon Administration: Impeachable

    Illegal wiretapping in the Bush Administration: “Patriotic”

    At least some people could smell what they were shovelling.


  16. sacopenapa says:

    INDICT IMPRISON BUSH/CHENNEY & Co.


  17. texaslady says:

    It will come out that there has been selective wire tapping, such as those perceived as “enemies” of this administration. Of course this corrupt bunch will be gone and as usual the public will just move on. How about accountability just once !


  18. Max-1 says:

    .

    One defining characterization to what it means to be an American is the ability to be FREE from unwarranted searches and seizures; THE FREEDOM FROM TYRANNY!

    REMEMBER:
    THEY(sic) HATE US FOR OUR FREEDOMS…

    And so THEY(sic) debate the merits to undermining those very Freedoms that define what it means to be an American.

    Anyone who argues to be LESS American is no American to me.

    .


  19. Mia Kulper says:

    President Bush may have to pardon practically everyone in his adinistration (after the election) or let them all move to his alleged new estate in Paraguay.


  20. freedom lover says:

    Bush will ahve to pardon all republicans for being tied to the world’s biggest terrorist organization, the GOP.


  21. old_hack says:

    oops wrong link.. sorry

    viral link


  22. old_hack says:

    great bands out there playing music for activists. you guys should tune in

    viral


  23. ctcadguy says:

    If these clowns starting breaking the FISA prior to 911, then I wonder if all those architects, engineers and scholars who claim 911 was an inside job are really conspiracy nuts or are they on to something.

    Time to finally have an independent 911 investigation. Not antoher farce investigation headed up by a Bush crony like Phillip Zelikow did with the 911 commission.

    Zelikow had closer ties with the White House than he publicly disclosed and that he tried to influence the final report in ways that the staff often perceived as limiting the Bush administration’s responsibility and furthering its anti-Iraq agenda. According to the book, Zelikow had at least four private conversations with former White House political director Karl Rove, and appears to have had many frequent telephone conversations with people in the White House. The Commission staff kept a record only of calls Zelikow received, but Government Accountability Office records show his frequent calls to the 456 telephone exchange in the 202 area code used exclusively by the White House. Also, Zelikow ordered his assistant to stop keeping a log of his calls, although the Commission’s general counsel overruled him. Zelikow had pledged to have no contact with Rove and Condoleezza Rice during his work for the 9/11 Commission.

    The book also reports that some panel staffers believed Zelikow stopped them from submitting a report depicting Rice’s and Bush’s performance as “amounting to incompetence or something not far from it”. Zelikow has denied discussing the commissions work with Rove and further added “I was not a very popular person in the Bush White House when this was going on” and remarked the staffers were disgruntled.


  24. youtube says:

    Though Qwest was seeking contracts from the NSA, its then CEO Joseph Nacchio denied repeated requests to let the NSA monitor its network, and latersohbet
    Bedava mp3 indir
    cet
    also turned down requests to turn over billions of customer records to the government, asking both times for legal orders, according to media reports and statements in Nacchio court records



Jump to Top

About Think Progress | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2009 Center for American Progress Action Fund
View Most Popular

Advertisement

What We're About

Featured

image
Subscribe to the Progress Report



imageTopic Cloud


Visit Our Affiliated Sites

image image
Reports


Got a hot tip?
Have a hot news tip? We'd love to hear from you. Use the form below to send us the latest.

Name:
Email:
Tip:
(required)


imageArchives


imageBlog Roll