Think Progress

Google to Lieberman: You’re wrong.

By Amanda Terkel on May 20th, 2008 at 9:50 am

Google to Lieberman: You’re wrong.»

Yesterday, Sen. Joe Lieberman (I-CT) sent a letter to Google chairman and CEO Eric Schmidt, asking that he “immediately remove content produced by Islamist terrorist organizations from YouTube.” He charged that by allowing the videos, Google was not enforcing its “Community Guidelines.” In a response on its blog, however, Google rebuffed Lieberman:

Senator Lieberman’s staff identified numerous videos that they believed violated YouTube’s Community Guidelines. In response to his concerns, we examined and ended up removing a number of videos from the site, primarily because they depicted gratuitous violence, advocated violence, or used hate speech. Most of the videos, which did not contain violent or hate speech content, were not removed because they do not violate our Community Guidelines.

We believe that YouTube is a richer and more relevant platform for users precisely because it hosts a diverse range of views, and rather than stifle debate we allow our users to view all acceptable content and make up their own minds.



Featured Comment: Freedom Rebel Says: "Congratulations to YouTube for understanding that debate is healthy. That is what makes this a great country is our diversity. We may not always agree with all opinions,(I’m not including hate based speechs) but it helps broaden our views and ideas. To look at a situation differently through someone elses eyes, so to speak."

Sort Comments By: Top Rated | Date

30 Responses to “Google to Lieberman: You’re wrong.”

  1. ralph the wonder llama Says:

    We believe that YouTube is a richer and more relevant platform for users precisely because it hosts a diverse range of views, and rather than stifle debate we allow our users to view all acceptable content and make up their own minds.

    Uh-oh… sounds like Teh Google is one o’ them liberal fascist moonbat outfits.

    Probably funded by George Soros. No wonder Holy Joe is ag’in ‘em.


  2. Exit Stage Left Says:

    I find it ironic that a Jewish senator is hell-bent on helping America become a fascist state.


  3. Exit Stage Left Says:

    SCARY and ironic.


  4. hussein toasterhead Says:

    I can only hope the senator is just as concerned with the hate-speech peddled on some of the ultra-zionist videos on YouTube.


  5. robertoroberto Says:

    Umm if they moved anything that offended the senses of the Neo-cons from Youtube, there would only be music covers and GTA IV clips left, and i’m not even sure about the GTA IV clips..

    Youtube is a haven for 9/11 consipiracies, conspiracies in general and anti-Bush administration ; anti fear propoganada. And i love YouTube for this very reason.

    The internet has not only expanded people’s minds and imaginations ; it has give a voice to those who previously did not have one. No neo-conservative, thought police hack is going to be able to quell the trend.


  6. ctcadguy Says:

    Google should tell that war-mongering holier than tho fascist war criminal to take his fake morality and stick it.

    After next election this fascist will be stripped of his positions on the committees. The Dems should waste no time and do it now before he announces that he will be John W. McSames running mate.


  7. Dr. Hussein Matt Says:

    If LIEberman wants to remove terrorist videos from google, then they should also remove clips from MAnn Coulter, Insane Hannity, Bathtub boy Gibson, herr dubyah, Drugbaugh, O’Racist, etc., etc.,


  8. Freedom Rebel Says:

    Congratulations to YouTube for understanding that debate is healthy. That is what makes this a great country is our diversity. We may not always agree with all opinions,(I’m not including hate based speechs) but it helps broaden our views and ideas. To look at a situation differently through someone elses eyes, so to speak.


  9. Witch1 Says:

    Wow! I didn’t know this..Good thing I visit TP for info…I thought youtube was just for music and cartoon’s….LOL..Guess I need to expand my viewing site’s and usage….Time to get more information…..Wonder how many more list’s I will be on after my searche’s…

    Poor joe, he is loosing his power, maybe he should return to his home land…….Blessings


  10. Zimzone Says:

    But Joe himself thrives on diversity…
    He’s a Democrat, an Independent, but mostly Republican by votes.

    He’s Jewish, American, soldier & flea market shopper.

    He’s for, against, and won’t take a stand on many issues.

    He supports Mavericks, Madmen and even kisses Cheney goodnight.

    What’s not diverse?



  11. misshusseinmolly Says:

    In Lieberman’s world, “hate speech” is any speech he happens to hate.



  12. Chocolate Jesus Says:

    the internet is the wild west of information, its redundant and expansive structure makes it inherently difficult to control, and the fascists trying to turn this world into a police state would definitely love to find a way to control it. the internet is simultaneously the source of both the greatest lunacy and purest truth, and it is that truth that scum-mongering powerhungry pathological liars like liEberman would love to shut down…

    I fear someday some scumbag like Murdock is going to try and take youtube over like he did myspace..


  13. Chocolate Jesus Says:

    >Obama meets Imam

    I got an email saying Obama once received a free Big Gulp from a man in a turban, ergo his campaign is financed by Hamas


  14. theswan Says:

    What makes Joe so different? Some of his statements might be examined as well.


  15. FearandSmear Says:

    Good boy… Sit! GOOD boy….

    Here’s your treat…

    Now ROLL OVER…. GOOD BOY…



  16. Leftside Annie Says:

    Lieberman is a tiresome, sanctimonious, overzealous lying, hypocritical old FART.

    STFU, Joe, you moron!!


  17. hussein toasterhead Says:

    Al Da God Says:

    So Youtube supports Islamists. No suprise there. How come when Anti-Islamic opinions are aired on Youtube, they get banned?

    May 20th, 2008 at 10:43 am
    ______

    Kindly provide us with an example of this.


  18. PatrioticLiberalChristian Says:

    Perhaps Lieberman should spend less time concerned with whether or not YouTube enforces ITS Community Guidelines and more time ensuring that the U.S. government, of which he is a member, enforces its guideline. That guideline is called the United States Constitution, in case he has forgotten.


  19. raynman Says:

    I just can’t get over how these people think that by destroying the freedoms that the Constitution provides us, they are saving freedom.

    Isn’t that like saying you have to kill people for peace… um, okay, bad example…

    Isn’t it like saying that in order to pay for a way, you need to provide tax cuts to the wealthiest…. um…

    nevermind


  20. JMOHR Says:

    This is indeed a troubling development. We must eliminate those forms of speech which attack our country and undermine our safety from those who lurk around every corner and under every bed with the intent of attacking us and destroying our freedoms. TP and other blogs like it are perfect examples of the kind of fellow travelers who aid and abet the dark forces of Islamic Terrorism attempting to overthrow our way of life.

    It is important that blogs, newspapers, television and radio programs as well as books and other publications voicing these un-American sentiments be controlled or closed down. However, this is insufficient. There are also those who unknowingly assist these dark and evil forces by asserting that freedom of speech, due process of law and other such quaint notions can actually be applied in such a violent and dangerous world. We must set aside these freedoms as well as the freedom of privacy and the right to dissent in order to preserve our democracy and maintain those uniquely American freedom and liberty.

    We all know that liberals and Democrats are nothing more than homosexuals and appeasers. There should be no elections this fall. John McCain should be appointed to serve as President by our former glorious leader, George II. After all, we know who the enemy is. We know there is only leadership from one party that can truly protect this nation. It is essential to protect our democracy that this leadership be continued without the divisiveness and opportunity for fifth columnists to strike at the resolve of our democracy that an election would be.

    Long live the Republican party and may Joe Lieberman be appointed to head a new Department of State Loyalty to ensure that we all uniformly conform to the thoughts necessary to save our democracy.


  21. gummitch Says:

    hussein toasterhead Says:

    Al Da God Says:

    So Youtube supports Islamists. No suprise there. How come when Anti-Islamic opinions are aired on Youtube, they get banned?

    May 20th, 2008 at 10:43 am
    ______

    Kindly provide us with an example of this.

    Yes, please do. Because a quick search on “Islam” in YouTube popped up about a 50/50 mix of pro- and anti-Muslim videos, including some that have been up for a year. Not such an efficient job of banning.


  22. Zimzone Says:

    JMOHR,
    You’ve got satire & irony down to a fine art; thank you for comments that routinely make me stop & think.


  23. Tired Of Fighting Says:

    Mr Lieberman (I-Israel)

    When are you going to get to the bottom of the lack of response by the Bush Administration to Hurricane Katrina?

    OOHH you forgot too, so has the media.

    RIP
    SGT Stephen R. Sherman
    C CO 1-5 IN (STRYKER)
    KIA 3 Feb 2005
    Mosul, Iraq


  24. Leftside Annie Says:

    ‘Scuse me, Holy Joe - you can’t have my freedom of speech.

    I’M USING IT.


  25. Evil Spaniard Says:

    Please, remove too the mountain of videos showing one-toothed rednecks shooting at everything, and paying to have their 7 year old sons and daughters shooting an M-60 or a Gatling machine gun. They’re scary fascist fundamentalists.


  26. Dr. Hussein Matt Says:

    Al Da God Says:

    How come when Anti-Islamic opinions are aired on Youtube, they get banned?

    Prove it.


  27. Reasons Says:

    Google and YouTube are still FAR from being neutral and allowing for healthy debate. YouTube and Google have caved into pressure from Scientology VERY recently by canceling Youtube channels of Scientology critics.
    Just Google Mark Bunker and Jason Beghe to see for yourself.


Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.


Jump to Top

About Think Progress | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2008 Center for American Progress Action Fund
View Most Popular

Advertisement


Visit Our Affiliated Sites

image image
What We're About

Featured

image
Subscribe to the Progress Report




Got a hot tip?
Have a hot news tip? We'd love to hear from you. Use the form below to send us the latest.

Name:
Email:
Tip:
(required)



Reports

imageTopic Cloud


imageArchives


imageBlog Roll