Think Progress

McCain Adviser: McCain ‘Helped Create’ The Blackberry

mccain4.jpg Speaking to reporters today, McCain campaign adviser Douglas Holtz-Eakin claimed that Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) is responsible for the “miracle” of PDAs. Politico reports:

“He did this,” Douglas Holtz-Eakin told reporters this morning, holding up his BlackBerry. “Telecommunications of the United States is a premier innovation in the past 15 years, comes right through the Commerce committee so you’re looking at the miracle John McCain helped create and that’s what he did.”

Although he doesn’t e-mail, McCain told the New York Times in July that he does “use the Blackberry.” Campaign aide Mark Salter added, “He uses a BlackBerry, just ours.”

According to the AP, Holtz-Eakin also pointed today to McCain’s service leadership of the Senate Commerce Committee, which “put him at the intersection of a number of economic interests, including the telecommunications industry.” Similarly, McCain yesterday told scienceblogs.com:

Under my guiding hand, Congress developed a wireless spectrum policy that spurred the rapid rise of mobile phones and Wi-Fi technology that enables Americans to surf the web while sitting at a coffee shop, airport lounge, or public park.

However, what McCain failed to accomplish has left a bigger impression on tech experts than anything that McCain actually did. “The thing that stands out for his entire tenure is that he has never had a priority, and has never had, to my knowledge, any accomplishment of any kind at all,” former FCC chairman Reed Hundt told Salon last month. When McCain took over his second tenure of Senate Commerce Committee, the United States ranked fourth in broadband penetration. In 2007, two years after he had given up that position, the United States had dropped to 15th in the world.

Note to the McCain campaign: The Blackberry was invented in Canada.

Update Washington Wire reports that according to senior McCain aide Matt McDonald, the senator "laughed" when told about Holtz-Eakin's comment. "He would not claim to be the inventor of anything, much less the BlackBerry. This was obviously a boneheaded joke by a staffer,” McDonald said.
Update In 1999, McCain made fun of Al Gore for allegedly saying that he invented the Internet.


93 Responses to “McCain Adviser: McCain ‘Helped Create’ The Blackberry”

  1. raynman says:

    Didn’t the media crucify Gore for something similar?

    Think they’ll do the same for McCain?


  2. Fan of Man says:

    ROFLMAO! but how? he is a pow with injuries that keep him from knowing how to type an email… must be the hand of god.


  3. joe cantwell says:

    he and cindy were the inspiration

    for the novel “love story” by eric segal.

    *

    and he said “thanks but no thanks”

    to the federal government for the

    bridge to nowhere.

    #

    he’s done so much.

    @


  4. citizen_pain says:

    UM, the company that owns the Blackberry is from Canada…


  5. Badmoodman says:

    McCain ‘Helped Create’ The Blackberry

    – - Two tin cups attached by a string doesn’t count, Johnny Luddite.


  6. Kay says:

    Yes. And I help paint the Sistine Chapel.


  7. Kay says:

  8. superid says:

    So if you drive a tanker could you take credit for inventing petrol?


  9. Badmoodman says:

    Yesterday, McCain also told scienceblogs.com, “Under my guiding hand, Congress developed a wireless spectrum policy that spurred the rapid rise of mobile phones and Wi-Fi technology that enables Americans to surf the web while sitting at a coffee shop, airport lounge, or public park.”

    – - Geeze, and THIS from the crowd that mocked Al Gore for “inventing the internet,” which Gore actually DID help foster into existence.


  10. Uncle Ho says:

    and just think, McPutz also discovered penicillin(after repeated VD at Subic Bay), created the electric light bulb, invented the camera, and cured polio.


  11. Badmoodman says:

    So, now he’s Johnny McMarconi.


  12. sluggo says:

    The outright lies and distortions come thick and fast from the McCain camp.

    Why?

    Remember, these are “messages” to his new base (the crazy fundamentalist/Bush supporters). His new base is not bothered by logic, reason, or even facts. All they want are talking points they can tell each other in order to keep the faith.

    Don’t bother coming up with facts to refute such crazy talk, McCain’s base doesn’t really care (remember, most of these people believe the Earth is only 6 thousand years old).


  13. Fritz says:

    Uncle Ho Says:

    and just think, McPutz also discovered penicillin(after repeated VD at Subic Bay), created the electric light bulb, invented the camera, and cured polio.

    I heard that he developed nuclear energy and invented ice cream.


  14. deebaser says:

    “you’re looking at the miracle John McCain helped create and that’s what he did.”

    HOW????


  15. AMacPill says:

    Well, since he doesn’t use the e-mail, I guess there wouldn’t be a lost email scandal in a McCain White House, huh…

    [/sarcasm]

    Yeah, how many people actually would oppose such a bill, anyway…


  16. Jamit says:

    Ya Ya that’s the ticket! Big John was just helping a good Canadian company. After all Big John helped found Canada.


  17. Fan of Man says:

    john mccain wrote the bible.


  18. tom says:

    I heard that he developed nuclear energy and invented ice cream.

    This could very well be true. Like nuclear plants and ice cream, McNumbNuts is prone to “melt-downs” I hear.


  19. NOLIESPLEASE says:

    The company that invented the Blackberry is RIM (Research in Motion) a Canadian Co.. That’s the facts…does McShame think Canadians are stupid enough not to say anything or not to take pride in what our people invented.

    The only thing more stupid then McCains advisor…is the poeple that will vote for him. Makes you go hmmm….


  20. AlphaLiberal says:

    Using the Gore Standard we now have McCain claiming to have invented the Blackberry.


  21. spencers mom says:

    Wow, and here I thought he was just another lying dumbph*uck republican.

    PEACE


  22. misshusseinmolly says:

    You would think that after his own party blasted Gore for claiming to have “invented the Internet” (a claim Gore never made), McCain would steer clear from making any claim to inventing or creating anything. Nope.

    Just like skewering Obama repeatedly for his “lack of experience” would drive a reasonable person to choose somebody with a great deal of political experience for a running mate. Nope.

    This has gone from amusing to insulting.


  23. 666lattes says:

    Issues… we don’t need no stinking issues!


  24. Fritz says:

    spencers mom Says:

    Wow, and here I thought he was just another lying dumbph*uck republican.

    He still is that…AND MORE!!!


  25. misshusseinmolly says:

    Fan of Man Says
    September 16th, 2008 at 11:21 am

    john mccain wrote the bible.
    __________________________________________________________

    Careful, there are kool-aid drinkers out there who will believe it.


  26. PatriotActor says:

    Telecommunications of the United States is a premier innovation in the past 15 years

    McCain invented telecommunications?! Or just cell phones and WiFi?


  27. Zimzone says:

    McCain: Older than dirt, but remarkably similar in taste & smell.


  28. bonzo 1958 says:

    Didn’t rove just say mccain couldn’t use the newfangled inventions because he couldn’t type due to war injuries when he was a POW?


  29. bonzo 1958 says:

    PatriotActor Says:

    Telecommunications of the United States is a premier innovation in the past 15 years

    McCain invented telecommunications?! Or just cell phones and WiFi?

    Tin cans and string!


  30. Kay says:

    McStain wrote the book entitled “All you wanted to know about Sleazy NeoCON WarMongers Elitists (But were afraid to ask)”


  31. Zimzone says:

    Fundamentalists believe the Earth is less than 6,000 yrs old.

    If this is the case, McCain DID actually write the Bible, create the Earth and create Palin in his spare time.


  32. hussein toasterhead says:

    “Telecommunications of the United States is a premier innovation in the past 15 years, comes right through the Commerce committee so you’re looking at the miracle John McCain helped create and that’s what he did.”

    Did he just say that innovation comes through the Commerce Committee? A GOVERNMENT entity?

    Well, that’s not very conservative. Isn’t government supposed to stay out of it and let The Free Market® do all that innovating stuff?


  33. RUCerious says:

    Taking credit for another failure, McIIIrd?


  34. alphainfinityomega says:

    I noticed yesterday how the Reich wing talkers started saying McCain couldn’t use a computer because of his injuries as a POW.
    I didn’t buy it for a minute because it begs the questions:
    1] Has he never heard of a laptop?
    2] Can’t he put a desk top keyboard in his lap?
    3] How come some totally cripple, from the neck down, still can use a computer?
    If McPOW can’t move his arms enough to use a computer, who, then, wipes his butt?

    ¶ AIO


  35. RUCerious says:

    Did I mention that I helped create the Googles, Yahoos and Intranet?


  36. Evil Spaniard says:

    McCain invented the Blackberry… but he doesn’t know why or what is his utility.


  37. RUCerious says:

    Yes, that’s right. I was a programmer during the time all those things came about, so I can claim responsibility for helping invent all of them.


  38. BillinChicago says:

    These people are so stupid it really is starting to cause me physical pain.

    The fact is we are not the great innovators with wireless telecommuications. The Japanese have been a generation or two ahead of us technologically for decades now. I was stationed in Japan in from 1996 to 2000 and there was just no comparison between what the average guy had on the street over there and what was still considered cutting edge over here.

    Or maybe McCain was serving in the Japanese Diet, too. That’s probably the next bald faced lie coming down the pike.


  39. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    “When I was a POW, we didn’t have newfangled communication devices, my friends…”


  40. RUCerious says:

    Yo! McIIIrd! I’ve got a shitload of blackberries in my back yard that you can come pick. That’s as close as you’ll get to creating blackberries, despite the ridiculous claims by your campaign.


  41. Evil Spaniard says:

    alphainfinityomega Says:

    I noticed yesterday how the Reich wing talkers started saying McCain couldn’t use a computer because of his injuries as a POW.
    3] How come some totally cripple, from the neck down, still can use a computer?

    ¶ AIO

    September 16th, 2008 at 11:40 am

    Maybe McCant needs some lessons from prof. Hawking.


  42. BillinChicago says:

    Here’s just one example of what I’m talking about:

    http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/4306834/

    McCain-san bakayaro!


  43. Michael Lafferty says:

    I am trying to think of a nice way to say this, but cannot seem to find one: the man is an idiot.

    “Congress developed a wireless spectrum policy that spurred the rapid rise… Wi-Fi technology that enables Americans to surf the web while sitting at a coffee shop, airport lounge, or public park.”

    Nice try, Senator. 802.11x WiFi in any flavor is UNLICENSED spectrum, over which neither the Congress nor the FCC have any control or influence. Whatsoever. Except to mandate non-interference with regulated spectrum.

    Geez: this guy is a troglodyte. I mean, seriously. Even if you presume that his advisor was referring to the infrastructure required to support the RIM Blackberry—and not the device itself which simply was held up to reinforce the idea of what it represented as a holistic technology platform—it’s a relatively stupid claim to make. His role with the FCC has been one largely of interference at the behest of special interest contributors and their lobbyist representatives, and not of one demanding change in the public good. Um, net neutrality, anyone?

    And that broadband penetration figure? It was just announced that we’ve slipped from 15th place to 30th place. Way to go, Senator: rushing headlong into the past, one might say. Back to the future. Or, something.


  44. hussein toasterhead says:

    Ok, I figured it out:

    See, as a young man, McCain probably watched a lot a Heddy Lamarr movies. And as everyone knows, Lamarr’s invention of frequency-hopped spread spectrum communication became the basis for modern CDMA and WiFi devices.

    Therefore, by the McCain/Palin rule of osmotic policy experience, McCain invented wireless telephony.

    It’s simple, libs!!!


  45. Cal Malenky says:

    It’s all part of that “composite character” so important to Rick Davis, since issues aren’t important to voters.


  46. Alejandro says:

    I thought he had trouble with email and the intertubes?


  47. Jamit says:

    Old John put together the Keating Five to fund the development of the blackberry.


  48. tom says:

    Didn’t rove just say mccain couldn’t use the newfangled inventions because he couldn’t type due to war injuries when he was a POW?

    He does, however, seem to be able to put his hands together and fiddle with his wedding band while standing on stage behind Failin’ Palin and staring at her arse. Seems to me that he should be able to tap out emails on his Blackberry, too.


  49. spencers mom says:

    alphainfinityomega Says:

    I noticed yesterday how the Reich wing talkers started saying McCain couldn’t use a computer because of his injuries as a POW.
    I didn’t buy it for a minute because it begs the questions:
    1] Has he never heard of a laptop?
    2] Can’t he put a desk top keyboard in his lap?
    3] How come some totally cripple, from the neck down, still can use a computer?
    If McPOW can’t move his arms enough to use a computer, who, then, wipes his butt?

    ¶ AIO

    I guess when McStain becomes as physically capable as Steven Hawking, we can all look forward to J. Sidney’s tech savvy.

    PEACE


  50. RUCerious says:

    So, RaptureRoddy, why does your candidate lie to the American Public? Why isn’t he touting his plans for changing America?


  51. squidbilly says:

    Maybe McCain can solve the iphone 3G problem…Yeah sure.


  52. stewarjt says:

    There is a definite contradiction with underlying ideology here. The right wing position is that private entrepreneurs are responsible for all the dynamism, innovation and creativity in the economy. They argue onerous taxes and regulations stifle these founts of economic growth. Now McBane’s advisor is arguing the opposite, that the government is the source.

    Wow!


  53. Uncle Fester Lurks says:

    McCain helped create the Blackberry!?!

    He helped God create a fruit?


  54. RUCerious says:

    Michael Lafferty, nice post. Love your tech explain…


  55. spencers mom says:

    McStain helped create the Blackberry.

    Palin wants him to change the name to the “Samboberry”

    PEACE


  56. DwH says:

    Sounds more like a bone-headed staffer made a ‘misstatement’ that needed to be spun as a ‘joke.’

    Idiotic.


  57. joe cantwell says:

    oh i get it.

    it was a joke.

    >

    LOL.

    #

    thank you.

    $


  58. RUCerious says:

    spencer’s mom. OUCH.. Nice.


  59. SpoxLogic says:

    Will the same media, that made pretty much helped sink Gore in 2000, help sink McCain now? I doubt it, since the MSM owners all subscribe to the GOP way of thinking.
    Heck, they’ll probably have folks thinking it was Obama that made the comment before the week is out.
    I’m jsut sayin’….


  60. The Dogfather says:

    Maybe what Holtz-Eakin actually meant to say was that McDeathWarmedOver helped create more crackbabies? I mean, with the republican economic policies that are the cornerstone of McSame’s campaign, it’s beyond question that there have been more crackbabies born the last 7-odd years…


  61. jpopphan says:

    McCain’s campaign is based entirely on LIES. Republicans took Al Gore’s comments about helping to craft and enact legislation that created the Internet and twisted them to sound like he was taking credit for creating the Internet completely on his own. Now McCain’s campaign is directly claiming that McCain created the Blackberry – and somehow managed to do it in Canada instead of the USA.

    Sheesh…. why doesn’t the GOP just lay down, curl up in a fetal position, admit that they’re out of ideas, and let the grown-ups take back control of our government?


  62. Michael Lafferty says:

    You know, I’ve been involved in broadcasting, telecommunications or one or another related high technology fields for almost 40 years. And, the fundamental lack of understanding of the ‘issues’ at the level of Senator McCain—generally—is simply breathtaking. It’s no wonder the claims of the campaign staff and their advisers make so little sense.

    In more relaxed and less sober moments, I suppose, I worry about the whacky disciples of McCain-Palin. If announcement of the impending rapture is delivered via a Blackberry Enterprise Server, these people are literally toast. There won’t be time to don the white robes and ascend, unless you’re on the distribution list. And the flock largely won’t be. So sad…


  63. jpopphan says:

    Oh, and someone needs to remind the McCain campaign that using a Blackberry normally involves using email. If McCain is actually using his Blackberry, then he does use email. I wonder where those emails are kept… bet there are some gems in there showing McCain to be the rude hothead we all know him to be.


  64. tom says:

    Here’s a great impersonation of McCain –> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mLYGj7xTOPM&feature=user
    This guy has several “McCain video blogs” up on YouTube.
    Hilarious . . . and hard to tell from the real thing.


  65. Wayne says:

    RUCerious Says:

    Yes, that’s right. I was a programmer during the time all those things came about, so I can claim responsibility for helping invent all of them.

    I helped set up one of the first ISPs and commercial wi-fi networks in Texas back in the 90s, and was a sysadmin for their server system. Only businesses could afford the wi-fi back then. Does that mean I helped invent it also? hahahaha

    Someone needs to hang this around McCain’s neck like they did with the “Gore invented the internet” talking point.


  66. MapleStreet says:

    But seriously folks, McCain **REALLY DID** help invent fire and the wheel.


  67. raynman says:

    McCain invented the Barbie Doll and he wanted some improvements so he created Sarah Palin….


  68. Uncle Fester Lurks says:

    “In the beginning, POW was sleepy and took a nap.”

    “And on the second day POW fed multitudes of lobbiests, banksters and crooksters and gave them high paying jobs within his Kingdom.

    “And on the third day POW soiled his diaper, and took a long nap.”

    “And on the fifth day POW lifted his arms to his waist and wiped out all taxes for the wealthy and it was good”

    “And on the sixth day POW threw a temper tantrum, pushed the button and scorched 2/3’s of the earth, making ash of millions of innocent lives, while refusing to follow the scourge Bin Laden and his plague of followers to the fiery gates of hell.”

    “And on the seventh day POW woken early from his nap, angrily calls his queen, who sat to the right of him on the throne a pig with lipstick, a trollop and a c**t before being put out to pasture permanently, the queen takes over and the end of time begins.”

    ~ The Book Of Palin


  69. Zimzone says:

    68, Tom, thanks! That guy is nailing McCan’t.


  70. Doc Rock says:

    Lies, damned lies, and BIG LIES. Don’t it make my Blackberries Blue?


  71. krdaddy says:

    and Cindy has a recipe for blackberry muffins she invented


  72. Buckie Boy says:

    Repukes love their liars, they are like gods to them.

    McGoingtodiesoon tells a big lie.

    Response from the Repuke Nutballs – We worship the ground you piss on.

    Fck these neanderturds.


  73. Uncle Ho says:

    Unka fester! damn! I need a new keyboard, coughed up my water. LOL!


  74. Uncle Fester Lurks says:

    McAncient also invented the wheel.


  75. stateofthedivision says:

    And McCon brought us telecom immunity


  76. Michael Lafferty says:

    Sweet! It’s gone mainstream:

    “Adviser says McCain helped create the BlackBerry
    31 minutes ago

    MIAMI (AP) — Move over, Al Gore. You may lay claim to the Internet, but John McCain helped create the BlackBerry.

    At least that’s the contention of a top McCain policy adviser, Douglas Holtz-Eakin. Waving his BlackBerry personal digital assistant and citing McCain’s work as a senator, he told reporters Tuesday, “You’re looking at the miracle that John McCain helped create.”

    A McCain aide later dismissed the remark as “a boneheaded joke by a staffer.”

    http://ap.google.com/article/ALeqM5g1MSY3Bgt7YC5XHmxAdt9VkOlvhwD937TFHO0

    Yeah, just some staffer. No one important. Just one of principal advisers—and lobbyists—formulating strategy and policy for the campaign, and speaking on its behalf.

    MEMO to Senator McCain: you campaign is swinging out of control.


  77. Marie says:

    This is beyond LOL, beyond ROTFLOL, beyond ROTFLMAO –

    This is the guy whose staff was attacking Obama’s ads pointing out how out of touch McCain is in being unable to use the internet. McCain’s staffers attacked Obama with the defense that McCain’s fingers are incapable of using a keyboard since he was a POW — so shame on you Obama they said.
    NOW today, we hear that McCain uses a blackberry — if he can’t use a keyboard, how can he use the tiny keypad of a blackberry.
    Is there nothing they don’t lie about?


  78. kasinca says:

    KKKarl Rove just told us that it is unfair to mention that McSame is computer illiterate bacause he was a POW. The blackberry is a computer so this cannot be true.


  79. Shayne says:

    McCain can’t use a Blackberry. Somebody pull up a page and he reads it. I’d pay to watch him try to Google something.


  80. Game of Life says:

    Marie:

    Everything outlandish lie the repugs accused Sen. Obama of mcchimpy is doing 1000 worse.

    Those permanent “jazz hand” mcchimpy is always showing are scary as hell. he


  81. Uncle Fester Lurks says:

    LushInterior Says:

    NO, NO, NO……TP! This is a joke set up by the McSame loons and just as they predicted, YOU BIT. The people at Fox are laughing their a$$ off because they were in on it as well………GOD!
    ““““““““““““““““““““““““““`
    You could be right! This could just be another distraction from the issues that the McCain campaign does not want to talk about. Lets see how much media coverage this gets compared to the economy, etc.


  82. Shayne says:

    How many veterans have lost limbs and learn how to drive a car? McCain can’t use a computer? You can make a computer work by blinking your eyes. At least 7 houses but he can’t afford modern technology. That’s why he has to use the Blackberries of his campaign workers. What a joke.


  83. Shayne says:

    Sure LushInterior, it’s the same kind of joke like yesterday when he said the economy is fundamentally sound right? And the same kind of joke where he said he didn’t care if we were in Iraq 100 years. So basically McCain and his stooges can say anything no matter how stupid and all they have to do is say they were just kidding and you sheeple believe him. Heck, you guys believe the lie in the first place what’s the difference.


  84. stewarjt says:

    LushInterior, Lux Interior of the Cramps is probably not happy you bastardized his name.


  85. btruthful says:

    What’s the point of these stories? Its not working and McCain is still ahead. We need to attack him on ecomics, not crap like this. Think Progress, refocus on economic issues, that’s how you will win. These stupid atacks don’t do it.


  86. Game of Life says:

    Those permanent “jazz hands” mcchimpy is always showing are scary as hell. he’s is just stiff from being old.


  87. Game of Life says:

    Ok tide get a turnin.

    McCain has turned ugly. His dishonesty would be unacceptable in any politician, but McCain has always set his own bar higher than most. He has contempt for most of his colleagues for that very reason: They lie. He tells the truth. He internalizes the code of the McCains — his grandfather, his father: both admirals of the shining sea. He serves his country differently, that’s all — but just as honorably. No more, though.

    I never knew mcchimpy to be anything but a liar and freeloader.
    Look what he did to his first wife.


  88. SP Biloxi says:

    “McCain Adviser: McCain ‘Helped Create’ The Blackberry”

    lmao! Thanks for the laugh for the day, TP. I will not comment any further. The title alone did it for me.


  89. Little Freep Goofballs says:

    Tracy__5 Says:

    Dogging old people isn’t a good thing

    We’re talking about McCain here. Why would you submit that post, unless you are admitting McCain is one of the old people…

    BTW, care to comment on the McCain camp’s outrageous Blackberry claim?


  90. Little Freep Goofballs says:

    Tracy__5 Says:

    It’s about as outrageous as the right wing’s claim that Gore claimed that he created the internet.

    Fixed.


  91. Kass says:

    McCain’s plan for the economy, a Blackberry in every pot.


  92. Max-1 says:

    .

    Next they will claim Johnny McInvented sliced bread.

    .


  93. denizerdogan says:

    Just like the cold war when everyone who didn’t agree with the U.S. was either a communist or a communist sympathizer. toki This poor crazy guy spent half a decade being tortured because a bunch of stupid politicians araç sorgulama were sure the NVA was in bed with the Russians (minimal help) and/or the Chinese (ancient enemy of the vietnamese). ssk sorgulama You would think he would have learned from others’ mistakes. Guess not. Republicans need an enemy. key ödemeleri This century it apparently will be all Muslims, health all of whom must be alQaeda operatives.



Jump to Top

About Think Progress | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2009 Center for American Progress Action Fund
View Most Popular

Advertisement

What We're About

Featured

image
Subscribe to the Progress Report



imageTopic Cloud


Visit Our Affiliated Sites

image image
Reports


Got a hot tip?
Have a hot news tip? We'd love to hear from you. Use the form below to send us the latest.

Name:
Email:
Tip:
(required)


imageArchives


imageBlog Roll