Think Progress

Presidential Debate Live-Blogging

By Think Progress on Oct 7th, 2008 at 8:50 pm

Presidential Debate Live-Blogging

10:59: McCain made zero mentions of “middle class” tonight — the same number he offered in the first debate. (UPDATE: McCain mentioned “middle-income” Americans three times.)

10:42: On Fox, Nina Easton notes that we observed the “sinking ship of free-market Republicans” go to the “bottom of the sea,” with McCain’s proposal of a $300 billion “nationalization” of the U.S. mortgage market.

10:41: CNN’s Jeffrey Toobin: “When he referred to Barack Obama as ‘that one,’ I thought that was something people will remember.”

10:40: Kristol says Brokaw did a “disservice” to the McCain campaign by asking “conventional, inside the Beltway” questions. (UPDATE: Fred Barnes says it “was not a real town hall” meeting.)

10:37: Chris Matthews notes the most “bizarre moment of the night” was when McCain “took a shot” at moderator Tom Brokaw, saying “not you Tom” in response to who he would pick as Treasury Secretary.

10:35: CBS’ Katie Couric noted that McCain referred to Obama as “that one.” (UPDATE: NBC’s Brian Williams notes it too.)

DEBATE ENDS… POST-DEBATE COMMENTARY BEGINS

10:29: It’s worth noting that if Iran attacked Israel, there would be no need to wait for a UN Security Council resolution even according to the UN Charter before responding. Article 51 of Chapter VII of the UN Charter enshrines the “inherent right of individual or collective self-defence if an armed attack occurs against a Member of the United Nations.”

10:25: McCain said Russia has to understand that “they are facing a strong and determined America.” Fortunately, from her well-positioned perch in Alaska, Sarah Palin has been keeping a close eye on Putin for any time he might “rear his head.”

10:23: McCain said that when he looks into Putin’s eyes, he sees the letters K-G-B. But in 2001, after President Bush looked into Putin’s eyes and saw his soul, McCain gave him “an A” for how he did in his meeting with Putin.

10:21: McCain argued that the U.S. needs to execute the “same” surge strategy in Afghanistan as we’ve had in Iraq, but Gen. David D. McKiernan, the new top U.S. commander in Afghanistan, “stated emphatically that no Iraq-style ’surge’ of forces will end the conflict there.”

10:17: Earlier in tonight’s debate, McCain referred to Obama as “that one.”

10:14: McCain chastised Obama for saying that he would strike Osama Bin Laden in Pakistan without Pakistan’s permission if need be. Just recently, McCain defended Sarah Palin when she said essentially the same thing. (UPDATE: McCain “announced” on multiple occasions his desire to attack Iraq.)

10:13: McCain misquoted his “hero” Teddy Roosevelt tonight, quoting him as saying, “Walk — Talk softly and carry a big stick. The exact quote is: “Speak softly and carry a big stick.”

10:11: McCain suggested that he opposed Ronald Reagan’s deployment of US forces to Lebanon. In fact, he initially favored deploying the troops and only later argued for their withdrawal making arguments, one should note, that sound an awful lot like the arguments for redeploying from Iraq that he now deplores.

10:08: McCain doesn’t seem to understand that General David Petraeus currently heads up U.S. Central Command and is not at all the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs.

10:06: McCain just said that if we’d withdrawn from Iraq, Iranian influence would have increased and Al Qaeda would have set up a base. Both of these things happened because we invaded Iraq.

10:03: Discussing when to intervene militarily, McCain mentioned Kosovo. Back in 2000, McCain referred to the conduct of the Kosovo intervention as “the most obscene chapter in recent American history.

10:02: McCain criticized Obama’s foreign policy background, saying the country can’t afford a president who will engage in “on-the-job training.” However, Laura Bush has said that Palin doesn’t have any foreign policy experience, but “she’s a very quick study.”

9:59: McCain said Americans should be able to go across state lines to purchase health insurance. But this approach would erode important consumer protections and allow companies to exclude from coverage pre-existing conditions, deny claims, and increase premiums.

9:57: While McCain said health care should be a “responsibility,” Obama said, “I think it should be a right, for every American.”

9:55: McCain is disparaging the idea of government involvement in the health care system, but he’s enjoyed government-provided health care all his life and appears to trust it fine to deal with his own health problems.

9:54: McCain said he would give every family a $5,000 tax credit to buy health insurance. But McCain’s credit would not cover the average price of a family health care plan. According to the latest Kaiser Foundation Benefits Survey, “premiums for employer-sponsored health insurance rose to $12,680 annually for family coverage” in 2008.

9:49: Obama just warned of the threat of the “climate crisis,” Al Gore’s preferred terminology for global warming. McCain referred to it as “climate change” earlier.

9:45: McCain said that Obama voted 94 times for tax increases or against tax cuts. Using the same methods that the McCain campaign used to calculate that number, McCain has voted for 477 tax increases.

9:44: McCain claims that the best way of “fixing” global warming is nuclear power, which he also praised as a job creator. McCain’s nuke here, nuke now plan is estimated at “$315 billion, with taxpayers bearing much of the financial risk” and would tie our energy future to a toxic, deadly fuel that is mined in nations like Kazakhstan, Russia, Niger, and Uzbekistan — and would only generate 10,000 jobs a year.

9:44: For the second time tonight, McCain just repeated the attack that Obama has “never taken on” members of his own party, whereas he has. However, McCain has voted with Bush 95 percent of the time and once said, “I don’t have to show I’m different from Bush.”

9:43: McCain’s plan for Medicare is to . . . appoint a commission. What happened to leadership? Doesn’t he have any substantive thoughts on this issue?

9:42: McCain said, “I’m not in favor of tax cuts for the wealthy.” A recent analysis from the non-partisan Tax Policy Center found that McCain’s plan “would primarily benefit those with very high incomes, almost all of whom would receive large tax cuts that would, on average, raise their after-tax incomes by more than twice the average for all households.”

9:41: Tonight, McCain is wearing a red striped tie that appears wavy and distorted on television. He apparently hasn’t learned his lesson. During the last debate, McCain wore a similarly dizzying red and white striped tie.

9:40: Brokaw editorialized that we can all agree in a “bipartisan way” that entitlement programs are “a big ticking time bomb.” In fact, in 2005 – as President Bush tried to “reform” Social Security with a privatization scheme – “barely one in four Americans believe[d] that a crisis exists.” (UPDATE: As Paul Krugman explains, “No matter how many times you try to kill the mythical Social Security crisis, it just keeps coming back.”)

9:39: McCain said that the last president to raise taxes amidst a downturn was Herbert Hoover. But of course Bill Clinton was elected amidst a weak economic situation, passed an Obama-esque tax increase on wealthy people, and ushered in an era of broadly shared prosperity.

9:37: Obama said that McCain’s tax cut proposals would give corporate CEOs a $700,000 tax cut. McCain’s tax proposals would also give his own family a $300,000 tax cut.

9:35: While discussing health care, McCain said, “I’m not going to tell that person without health insurance, I’m sorry you’ll have to wait.” Ironically, under McCain’s Guaranteed Access health plan, individuals with pre-exisiting conditions would have to wait months for coverage of their illness.

9:33: Obama just mentioned the need for “volunteer corps all across this country.” McCain has no national service plan.

9:32: In addition to reducing many vital services, John McCain’s proposed spending freeze – a cut in inflation-adjusted terms – would serve as an anti-stimulus to the economy at a time of recession.

9:31: McCain said that he wants to eliminate some government programs. In the 1990s, he said that he would support “doing away” with both the Department of Education and the Department of Energy.

9:30: Discussing earmarks, McCain said he wanted to eliminate not just bad programs, but also some “really good projects” as well. But if the programs are really good, why eliminate them?

9:29: By mocking the Chicago planetarium earmark, McCain has twice mocked federal spending on science education, despite saying he recognizes the need for more scientists and engineers in America. Upon becoming the Republican nominee, he has advocated offshore drilling and selected global warming denier Sarah Palin to be his running mate – despite saying he recognizes the threat of global warming. As Lawrence Krauss said, “McCain risks becoming the anti-science candidate.”

9:27: Speaking about entitlements, John McCain said “we are not going to be able to provide the same benefit for future retirees that we have today.” In other words, he wants to cut entitlements. And yet, it was just earlier today that Sarah Palin said: “John McCain and I will protect the entitlement programs that Americans depend on – and above all, Social Security.” (UPDATE: McCain’s top adviser admitted on Sunday that McCain would slash $1.3 trillion from Medicare and Medicaid over 10 years.)

9:26: McCain praised investments in solar and wind energy. A few minutes before, he challenged the audience to look at his record as well as his rhetoric. Despite his words in favor of renewable energy in recent months, McCain has a clear record of opposition to clean energy.

9:25: McCain highlighted his support for campaign finance reform as an example of his “clear record of bipartisanship.” However, he has called Justices Roberts and Alito “model justices,” even though both oppose campaign finance reform.

9:23: McCain said that he worked across the aisle with Joe Lieberman on climate change, but he refused to endorse Lieberman’s climate change bill when it came up for a vote in the Senate last year.

9:21: McCain claims he warned about the coming economic crisis. However, in 2007, he admitted he was “surprised” by the crisis. “So, I’d like to tell you that I did anticipate it, but I have to give you straight talk, I did not,” he said.

9:20: McCain spoke of the need to end “cronyism” that corrupts Washington. Perhaps he had in mind things like when Freddie Mac decided to hire a close McCain associate specifically in order to influence McCain’s actions and then, after he succeeded, McCain tapped him to serve as his Senate Chief of Staff.

9:19: McCain said he wanted to “get rid of” the “special interests” in Washington to solve the economic crisis. Roughly 164 former lobbyists, however, run his campaign, raise money for him, and set his policy agenda.

9:16: When asked who he would potentially name as his Treasury Secretary, McCain did not mention his previous leading candidate — Phil Gramm, who called America a “nation of whiners” in a “mental recession.”

9:15: McCain is saying that two years ago, he stood up and warned against the excesses of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. NPR has fact-checked this claim as an exaggeration, saying that it was Sen. Chuck Hagel who actually took the lead to tighten regulation in 2005.

9:14: McCain repeated the conservative myth that problems at Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are at the root of the financial crisis. In fact, Fannie and Freddie were late to the subprime party and had been losing market share to other firms who plunged ahead more recklessly. It’s true that better regulation would have been a good idea, but regulators — members of the Bush administration — declined to use the authority they already had.

9:13: McCain once again claimed to have suspended his campaign to deal with the crisis, but in fact his surrogates continued to appear on television attacking Obama.

9:12: McCain decries sending billions of dollars “to countries that don’t like us very much,” by which we assume he means, among others, Iran and Russia. But because of the rise in oil prices resulting from the Iraq war, Iran and Russia are raking in billions of dollars in oil revenues. It’s a simple equation: War John McCain supports waging indefinitely = regional destabilization = increased oil prices = higher revenues for regimes John McCain wants to contain.

9:11: McCain said he supported helping homeowners renegotiate the terms of their mortgages. However, he opposed a proposition to allow bankruptcy judges to rewrite mortgage payment terms on first homes.

9:09: McCain asserted that he doesn’t want to raise taxes on “anybody.” But last month, he admitted his health care plan may raise taxes.

9:08: McCain says we’ve got to “stop the spending spree” here in Washington to deal with the economic crisis. But reducing spending during a recession – especially at a time when the Fed is maintaining low interest rates — is a pro-cyclical measure likely to deepen a recession.

9:05: McCain smiled and made prolonged eye contact when he greeted Obama — already making more eye contact than the last debate.

9:03: Like the first presidential debate, McCain isn’t donning a flag pin on his lapel. Barack Obama is.

debatetemplate1444new.jpg

We’re about to get started with our live-blog of tonight’s presidential debate. Like our previous two live-blogging extravaganzas, the entire ThinkProgress family — TP, Wonk Room, and Yglesias — will join forces to provide you research, insight, and analysis.

Tonight’s debate is in a townhall format. We’ve been told repeatedly by the media that townhalls are McCain’s strength. In June, ThinkProgress noted the following comments from political pundits:

– MSNBC’s Andrea Mitchell: “One of the points there is to take advantage of McCain’s presumed strength in the town hall format and in loose conversations.”

– MSNBC’s Monica Novotny: “So it seems that these town halls would work to his strength.”

– Fox News’s Juan Williams: “That’s his strength. That format, when you get John McCain doing town hall meetings, he’s at his best.”

Over the last 24 hours, political analysts have repeated the assertion:

CNN’s Ed Henry: “This format — the good news for McCain is this format suits him well. It sort of plays to his strengths.”

CNN’s Anderson Cooper: “John McCain has done very well in these townhalls that he has. And the critics say even Barack Obama has less experience doing that.”

MSNBC’s Savannah Guthrie: “McCain has always been very good in these townhall formats. This is one of his strengths.

We look forward to the show.



514 Responses to “Presidential Debate Live-Blogging”

  1. blue state bob says:

    I just made myself a drink, I may make popcorn. Let the beatdown begin!


  2. pete says:

    Time to grab a barf-bucket and make sure that heavy objects are not conveniently close. TVs are too dang expensive to throw things at.


  3. Oval12345678 aka James K. Sayre says:

    And don’t furgit ’bout Hateful Palin and her BrownSkirts…


  4. spencers mom says:

    So the pundits have set the bar very high for McStain. And when you’re up on high, there’re only two options: stay up there, or fall far.

    Hmmmm…. which to pick, which to pick…

    PEACE


  5. barfly says:

    My friends, let the carnage begin!

    Will McCain bring up Ayers? How will he work it into his answers?


  6. Badmoodman says:

    The townhall setting works the best for McCain because ALL of his are in populated with GOP sycophants.


  7. barfly says:

    I’m betting McCain also doesn’t answer the questions posed to him, in favor of canned talking points.


  8. RUCerious says:

    I hear Brokaw is allowed follup up questions.
    McIIIrd can’t have him drafted, you jerk! Can He?


  9. IBTunion4obama says:

    He’s a maverick, hahahahah.


  10. Another Joe says:

  11. galmud says:

    Dare McCain look at his opponent tonight?


  12. Another Joe says:

    LOL

    mclame has already changed the subject in his first answer


  13. barfly says:

    Tax cuts and drilling.

    McCain is offering nothing new.


  14. IBTunion4obama says:

    How is energy independence going to help people stay their homes?


  15. 5th Estate says:

    MC “let’s not raise taxes..” um OB just said tax CUTS for middle class. Tool.
    Mc Cain knows how to get AMerica working again—like winning wars?


  16. Another Joe says:

    not you tom….

    mclame won’t answer it



  17. blue state bob says:

    Meg Whitman??? Ebay is laying off 10% of its staff, great choice moron


  18. pete says:

    Didn’t Ebay just announce they are laying off 10% of their workforce?


  19. Bobwurst says:

    Mccain’s depends are already full.


  20. pete says:

    Flippy says, :I know how” but he ain’t telling us his plan.


  21. blue state bob says:

    What the hell is the ancient one babbling about?


  22. Jim Wolf359 says:

    That actually wasn’t bad answer by McCain. I’ll give him points on that one.


  23. tbone says:

    attack the trickle!


  24. blue state bob says:

    Dr. Hussein Matt Says:
    ——————————————————————————–

    I’m already drunk as hell from the “my friends” drinking game.

    October 7th, 2008 at 9:09 pm Recommend (0) |

    I see myself needing to call 911 by 10:00


  25. Bobwurst says:

    Great. mccain is is pushing sellling our crap on ebay as way out of this mess. I guess if you have expensive crap lying around your 8 mansions you could make some serious money…


  26. Bobwurst says:

    brokaw just told grampy to not get all rambly.


  27. Jim Wolf359 says:

    His follows wasn’t too good though. He didn’t really answer that one on his Sec Treas. at ;east he didn’t mention Gramm.


  28. galmud says:

    First ridiculous attack. Hit him back Obama


  29. blue state bob says:

    Good God, he’s just lying through his teeth


  30. tbone says:

    So the examples of the legislation to regulate FM and FM are?


  31. 5th Estate says:

    Not to OB…don’t say McCain is right! Jeez!


  32. 5th Estate says:

    Oh boy,,,McCain tying OB to Fannie and Freddie? And he’s lying right now about regulating Fanning and Freddie…–oh and thanks for the insult about probably never having heard of them—putz!!


  33. IBTunion4obama says:

    McCain isn’t very engaging…


  34. Laszlo Panaflex says:

    McCain wants to buy up all the bad mortgages … and cut taxes. Wow. He’s counting on people to not remember what he has said from one sentence to the next.


  35. Jim Wolf359 says:

    Oh boy! Here he goes about suspending his campaign! He just slimed Obama about Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae! He’s not answering the question. He’s doing his campaign slime dance.


  36. tbone says:

    Good clear concise explanation of the problem from Barak.


  37. nycbassist says:

    Did McCain just call Obama’s associates CRONIES??? DID OBAMA JUST LET HIM GET AWAY WITH IT????


  38. 5th Estate says:

    Ah. Nice approach to the crowd by OB…


  39. Another Joe says:

    real smart – mclame looks down on a black man and says, “you probably never heard of freddie mac…”


  40. barfly says:

    Obama goes to specifics, leaving McCain mumbling generalities.

    Point to Obama.


  41. Another Joe says:

    obama is starting to attack, calling him on his lies


  42. Jim Wolf359 says:

    What a contrast between Obama and McCain. He answered the guy’s question directly. Now he rebuts McCain. Beautiful!


  43. tbone says:

    Good comment on the finger-pointing. Get back to the people and their concerns


  44. Another Joe says:

    LOOK AT MCLAME LOOK DOWN AND AWAY FROM OBAMA


  45. tbone says:

    What is it with the looking away? What message is that supposed to send? I’m incapable of acting like an adult?


  46. 5th Estate says:

    Oh snap! OB on specifics. And a direct appeal to the crowd…nice!


  47. Jim Wolf359 says:

    Great answer by Obama. He just turned it back on McCain and got back to the meat of the question.


  48. Another Joe says:

    OH OH – wingnuts are gonna nail him on “coordinate with other countries.” I can just hear alex jones now, “SEE – HE IS A GLOBALIST!!”


  49. Another Joe says:

    damn – how dare obama not sign little johnny’s letter…


  50. Jim Wolf359 says:

    OB iss off to a great start. I think the Town Hall style works well for him. So much for the MSM’s Ideas about who this works better for.


  51. barfly says:

    John’s serving canned corn again.


  52. tbone says:

    I’m biased, but I perceive a**hole in McCain’s finger wagging at Obama.


  53. IBTunion4obama says:

    I agree Jim Wolf359. Obama is really hitting the nail on the head.


  54. 5th Estate says:

    McCain: if we do things… .oh and I wrote a letter too… and Americans are the best import/exporters so….we can do it.
    Say what?


  55. questioneverything says:

    CNN is in the tank for McCain–whether by desire to make more ad money or via intimidation. If you predict that this format will help McCain, you announce you will applaud his every word.


  56. tbone says:

    Obama is doing a nice job of pointing to McCain’s record without sounding too negative.


  57. galmud says:

    I’m a reformer because I say I am a reformer. Facts be damned!



  58. Another Joe says:

    F#CK – mclame is gonna do the “pair of maverick” thing…


  59. mocha says:

    Obama is ON FIRE!


  60. 5th Estate says:

    Q: How can we trust either party with our money?
    OB should have pointed out the GOP regime more there.


  61. barfly says:

    No flag pin on McCain’s lapel!


  62. tbone says:

    Like the vets association that gave you a D rating?


  63. Jim Wolf359 says:

    McCain is lying through his teeth! “A cossistent reformer” What a crock!


  64. IBTunion4obama says:

    McCain is panting and breathing hard!


  65. strat15 says:

    Make it up as you go along John. Mistrust? It is hard to trust people who can not tell the truth.


  66. galmud says:

    “I know how to fix this economy.”

    Classic McCain


  67. 5th Estate says:

    If McCain has fought against all this spending, well then he’s no good at it is he?


  68. IBTunion4obama says:

    My friends. Take another shot.


  69. 5th Estate says:

    No no John BEARS! BEAR DNA!… NOT ‘overhead projectors’!


  70. tbone says:

    So, again, what are these reforms you propose? Oh that is right. Drilling. That will take care of everyting.


  71. barfly says:

    He’s rambling again!


  72. Jim Wolf359 says:

    Oh my god!! McCain is just over the top! He just can’t help himself.


  73. IBTunion4obama says:

    My friends. Another shot.


  74. Another Joe says:

    oh oh – mclame just TOUCHED THE THIRD RAIL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


  75. Another Joe says:

    mclame cannot even keep track of three things

    what a mental midget and an ass


  76. barfly says:

    Refuses to answer a question!


  77. tbone says:

    Don’t forget what your talking points are!


  78. galmud says:

    Answer the question McCain


  79. IBTunion4obama says:

    He’s stumbling….whoooopssss


  80. nycbassist says:

    Okay… I’m going to calm down…. deep cleansing breaths..


  81. strat15 says:

    He is drifting and drifting — like a ship lost out at sea.


  82. MCMetal says:

    “Across the aisle” mentioning LIEberman ………What a dope.


  83. 5th Estate says:

    McCain just admitted he’s going to screw the public by confirming they will get less entitlements than before.


  84. Michael Lafferty says:

    I sense a set of recurring themes:

    “My friends…”
    “Washington DC is broken…”
    “I have been a consistent reformer…”
    “I have taken on the special interests…”
    “I have a clear record of reaching across the aisle…”
    “Energy independence, offshore drilling and nuclear power…”

    Did I mention POW?


  85. IBTunion4obama says:

    My friends. Do another shot.


  86. barfly says:

    Is that a silk suit he’s wearing?

    It’s very shiny.


  87. Another Joe says:

    gee, mclame is cheating and not following the rules

    is anyone surprised?


  88. Jim Wolf359 says:

    McCain just told future retirees YOUR SCREWED! Doesn’t offer any alternative.


  89. bronzbootz says:

    JM is all over the place and nowhere at the same time.


  90. Laszlo Panaflex says:

    On the CNN graph, Obama is maxing it out on every question; McCain went the entire last question without moving the line up at all. Again with the priority question.

    Let’s do it all at once, and buy the bad mortgages, and fight all the wars … and cut taxes. It’s magic!


  91. Another Joe says:

    I think mclame should start winking….

    It worked for palin, right?


  92. bronzbootz says:

    barfly Says:
    ——————————————————————————–

    Is that a silk suit he’s wearing?

    It’s very shiny.

    It’s too tight on him


  93. MCMetal says:

    Obama comes out with the average price of gas to those he’s speaking to face-to-face with in a totally different state than the one he represents in the Senate ; McDepends can’t even remember to not shit himself……………


  94. IBTunion4obama says:

    Ask the American people to not vote for Grampie InSane.


  95. Jim Wolf359 says:

    Obama is on his specifics. And he’s doing a good job of selling his points. Convincing, through and concise. Well done.


  96. barfly says:

    Another Joe Says:

    I think mclame should start winking….

    It worked for palin, right?

    Voters might think he’s having a stroke…


  97. 5th Estate says:

    Jim @100 … you are correct sir.


  98. strat15 says:

    Got McCain with that one.


  99. IBTunion4obama says:

    I agree. Obama is really on his game tonight.


  100. tbone says:

    It’s interesting that many of McCain’s examples are from the early 80’s. There quite a few voters who weren’t alive then!


  101. thefunksobruva says:

    Why aren’t there any entries for Obama in the live blogging?


  102. Another Joe says:

    mclame is really reaching – throwing in the projector thing again.

    Guess we should be grateful he hasn’t called him a terrorist yet or incited the crowd to chant for murder.


  103. blue state bob says:

    Another Joe Says:
    ——————————————————————————–

    I think mclame should start winking….

    It worked for palin, right?

    To the 25% of the population that are complete idiots, maybe. To the rest of us, it was just weird and a bit scary


  104. IBTunion4obama says:

    “That’s what America’s been doing”.


  105. blue state bob says:

    What the hell is a rifle shot??


  106. barfly says:

    McCain’s offering nothing but a spending freeze.

    Worthless.


  107. 5th Estate says:

    McCain just mentioned the Air Tanker…which is being re-written, no money saved at all.


  108. Another Joe says:

    spot on bob – she made an ass of herself to the majority of Americans.


  109. Jim Wolf359 says:

    Cut the Defense Budget first. It is so bloated. Apply those savings to the needed domestic programs and to getting this country energy independent.


  110. MCMetal says:

    Funny how McDepends has never raised a peep about Halliburton’s no-bid contracts and the shoddy job they are doing …………..


  111. Another Joe says:

    WTF – is mclame just wandering in circles while obama speaks?


  112. barfly says:

    Obama’s off on a nuclear fantasy.

    Safely storing waste?


  113. bronzbootz says:

    Obama on oil companies leases : Use it or loose it


  114. tbone says:

    I think conservation was a good selection. It is a good sacrifice that actually has individual benefit in cost savings. Very plausible and practical.


  115. 5th Estate says:

    Sacrifice question: ah, eh,


  116. Jim Wolf359 says:

    Nice connection by Obama.


  117. 5th Estate says:

    OB sharing the burden, nicely done. Hatchet versus scalpel, people who don’t need help like me and McCain. Good.


  118. tbone says:

    5th. ah, eh, I think that caught him off guard. A good bit of stammering there.


  119. MCMetal says:

    SNAP

    The “burden” is not being shared equally ; nicely put , BHO…..


  120. IBTunion4obama says:

    My friends. There it is again.


  121. galmud says:

    Senator Obamas secret Ooooh scary


  122. 5th Estate says:

    LIAR! Last person to “raise Taxes ” was Bush Sr!


  123. bronzbootz says:

    McCain is acting spastic


  124. tbone says:

    What about us single folks? Oh that’s right. NO tax exemption for me.


  125. MCMetal says:

    Why doesn’t this old shitstain mention who was the last moron to cut taxes (for the wealthy) while our entire military was deployed halfway around the world ?

    Gee , I wonder how this old fool proposes to pay off an $11 trillion dollar deficit ……………


  126. Jim Wolf359 says:

    McCain is just talking like an idiot. He’s pulling out the Obama Tax Increase Strawman. He is not going to raise taxes on small buissness’. He just lied to the American People again!. His health care plan would knock people like me off health insurance.
    Brokaw should have let Obama retort.


  127. barfly says:

    Brokaw just misstated the social security problem, in a big way.


  128. strat15 says:

    Like I can get good health insurance with $5K. I am self-employed with a pre-existing condition. I could never get insurance under the McCain “plan”


  129. 5th Estate says:

    Tax credit means if you spend it you get a break. But if you can’t afford it, you don’t spend it, therefore no tax credit! That’s how that works ( or rather doesn’t work).


  130. Another Joe says:

    LOL

    He just called mclame a liar!


  131. Another Joe says:

    brokow is a lying liar


  132. barfly says:

    Brokaw said in a few years, SS would be in deficit – effectively bankrupt.

    It’s a lie.


  133. galmud says:

    I have no plan but look at my shiny record!


  134. Jim Wolf359 says:

    Good answer by Obama. He just turned McCain’s charge upside down. If McCain wants this dicussion to go like this he is going to lose badly.


  135. 5th Estate says:

    OH niceley done Obama.


  136. tbone says:

    This is answering the question?


  137. IBTunion4obama says:

    My friend times 2!


  138. strat15 says:

    I know 5th thanks. This guy just makes me crazy.


  139. barfly says:

    McCain’s attempting to present himself as a populist.

    It’s silly, and sad.


  140. Another Joe says:

    oh oh – the “pair of maverick” lie is comin’ up…


  141. tbone says:

    We have looked at the records and you lose, McCain!


  142. blue state bob says:

    Obama clear concise answers.

    McCain, babbling like a brook

    Another my friends, I AM NOT YOUR FRIEND you trollish ogre


  143. 5th Estate says:

    Fixing Soc Sec is easy and has been done before? NO!
    But medicaid is complicate? Oh and now the debunked 94 times!

    McCain, we know your record, stop pretending it’s any different from what we already know.


  144. galmud says:

    MCCAIN: I have no plan so lets look at my shiny record!


  145. Another Joe says:

    is mclame gonna talk down to this African American too?


  146. strat15 says:

    McCain is getting weird and cranky.


  147. Jim Wolf359 says:

    His Vision?!! He is out of his mind!


  148. barfly says:

    “94 tax increases” – Brokaw is already on record as saying it’s a lie.

    But he says nothing!

    Brokaw just whored for McCain – twice.


  149. onoclea says:

    That answer about ss & medicare was no answer at all.


  150. Another Joe says:

    joe lieberman is really unpopular – even in CT, yet mcinsane wants to constantly hold that rotting corp up and tell us “it smells GOOD!”


  151. IBTunion4obama says:

    McCain is getting grumpy :(


  152. galmud says:

    Yeah John nuclear waste is really clean..


  153. IBTunion4obama says:

    Wind is more efficient dollar for dollar compared to Nuclear.


  154. pete says:

    Lieberman, Lieberman, Lieberman. Hasn’t anyone bothered to tell Flippy that EVERYBODY hates Lieberman?


  155. blue state bob says:

    Why does he think mentioning that odious d-bag Lieberman is a good thing?


  156. tbone says:

    Holy crap. Did he just say that about the nuclear sub?


  157. Jim Wolf359 says:

    It also created tons of waste that never goes away.


  158. barfly says:

    TP, dig up last week’s Meet the Press transcripts.

    Brokaw knows “94″ a lie.


  159. buzzbomb says:

    Yeah, fixing Social Security is easy. But does he say how he will do it? Of course he doesn’t. McCain is so full of crap I had to turn off the tv.


  160. Jim Wolf359 says:

    Good point by Obama. Energy Independence=National Security.


  161. tbone says:

    Is there only 1 environmental issue? Maybe we can talk about dead zones in the ocean? Over fishing? (90% of our fisheries are predicted to COLLAPSE by 2049!) Deforestation? Maybe Rocket fuel in our water!!!


  162. galmud says:

    buzzbomb Says:

    Yeah, fixing Social Security is easy. But does he say how he will do it? Of course he doesn’t. McCain is so full of crap I had to turn off the tv.

    MCCAIN: I have no plan but look at my shiny record!


  163. 5th Estate says:

    Nice one on McCain’s energy record—that’s a scratched 78 that McCain has there.


  164. 5th Estate says:

    Brokaw, if they both are operating on their own rules, then STFU, just keep them even in time.


  165. IBTunion4obama says:

    My friends, once again.


  166. galmud says:

    McCain thats a real cute misleading attack


  167. blue state bob says:

    That one?!?!?!?

    That what?????


  168. Jim Wolf359 says:

    I grow weary of hearing “My Friends”


  169. Another Joe says:

    brokow is also trying to make it look like it is obama that is not following the rules – he is a political hack


  170. tbone says:

    That one? How condescending?


  171. nycbassist says:

    THAT ONE??? HE POINTED AT OBAMA AND SAID “THAT ONE!”..What an unbelievably disrespectful pig.


  172. barfly says:

    Just as Ifill was too loose a moderator, Brokaw’s a nazi…


  173. Jane E. Schneider says:

    Another ‘my friends’ – I’m glad I’m not drinking.

    How ya doing, Dr Matt, you must be pretty loaded by now!


  174. Another Joe says:

    ha ha – brokow and mclaim just scammed the public that it is obama that is not following the rules.

    Nice take team, @ssholes


  175. IBTunion4obama says:

    Another, my friends.


  176. Jim Wolf359 says:

    I’m glad I’m not playing that drinking game!


  177. Morgan423 says:

    Dear Tom: If the candidate has a minute to speak and talks for 61.5 seconds, the world is not going to end. Chill. Thanks.


  178. lurker says:

    If your drinking on “my friends” you must be toast by now.


  179. MCMetal says:

    McDepends ……………So AGAINST the “goodies” in any Senate bill , he voted FOR the bail-out bill that included another $140 billion in pork ……..Real nice


  180. Another Joe says:

    THAT ONE??? HE POINTED AT OBAMA AND SAID “THAT ONE!”..What an unbelievably disrespectful pig.

    You think so? Just wait ’til he starts rilin’ the crowd up changing “TERRORIST TERRORIST TERRORIST” and “KILL HIM KILL HIM KILL HIM!”


  181. galmud says:

    McCain is wandering around like hes lost in a supermarket or something


  182. barfly says:

    That shiny suit of John’s is distracting. And no flag pin. How will Fox spin that?


  183. 5th Estate says:

    I just drink and smoke the whole way through–I like to call it leadership, my friends.


  184. barracks9 says:

    OK, could McStain’s tone and delivery get any creepier? When he lowers his voice like that, and I close my eyes, I think that Chris Hansen from Dateline’s To Catch A Predator is about to walk in the room.

    **shudder**


  185. tbone says:

    Excellent one hand giveth… reference!

    He is very good in talking about healthcare in a way that people can relate to.


  186. Jim Wolf359 says:

    Very comprehensive answer on Health Care by OB “One hand giveth, one hand taketh” SNAP!


  187. barfly says:

    That shiny suit makes him look like an elderly pimp…


  188. buzzbomb says:

    I did the “my friends” drinking game last debate. Pretty good. Glad I’m not doing it tonight, I’d be laying face down in a puddle of my own yechhch.


  189. Another Joe says:

    Let’s put MCLAME’S HEALTH RECORDS ONLINE!


  190. strat15 says:

    McCain is an idiot……..Can I send you my monthly premium bill. I’ll take your federal insurance — deal?


  191. blue state bob says:

    “medical errors as they call them.”

    What do you call them, did they have a different name during the paleozoic era


  192. Another Joe says:

    across state lines? who really can travel for healthcare

    Is anyone really gonna accept “vote with your feet” as the answer to health care.

    he’s insane


  193. tbone says:

    I wonder how many Arizonans are going to Mexico for healthcare and drugs. Do you have any idea, Johnny?


  194. IBTunion4obama says:

    he’s rambling…


  195. 5th Estate says:

    Lets put health care on lin and do lots of things for efficiencies, but the diff is “mandates”, Obama will fine you!
    That’s a lie.

    Say if Arizona offers a better health plan than Tennesee, what’s the point of Tennesees? plan? Huh?


  196. Jim Wolf359 says:

    $5000.00 wouldn’t begin to cover my Insurance. and yes John, I’ve done the Math.
    Gold Plated Plan? What is he talking about?


  197. blue state bob says:

    That joke crashed like one of the planes he couldn’t fly.


  198. IBTunion4obama says:

    Health care is a human right you hack McCain.


  199. 5th Estate says:

    Smack down coming up on the mandate.


  200. Another Joe says:

    Damn smart – HEALTHCARE IS A RIGHT!


  201. Another Joe says:

    health care – responsibility and then he lies about affordability and access


  202. tbone says:

    Yeah Obama. What is the point of having a wealthy country if that wealth doesn’t get used to take care of the country? More bombs perhaps?


  203. civil behavior says:

    Obama needs to try not to be so explain so much. He needs to be more concise.


  204. MCMetal says:

    civil behavior Says:
    ——————————————————————————–

    Obama needs to try not to be so explain so much. He needs to be more concise.

    October 7th, 2008 at 9:56 pm

    Like McDepends has been ?

    Johnny boy is talking bullshit gibberish that makes no sense whatsoever …………


  205. Jane E. Schneider says:

    barfly Says:

    That shiny suit makes him look like an elderly pimp…

    October 7th, 2008 at 9:52 pm

    I think it’s more like he’s ready to be buried.


  206. civil behavior says:

    Sorry, He needs to not explain so much………


  207. Jim Wolf359 says:

    I think he’s doing okay CB.


  208. lurker says:

    I live in AZ and a lot of people do go to mexico for drugs
    and dental.


  209. civil behavior says:

    Neither one of them is answering the questions. Too much elaboration makes people squirm.


  210. Jim Wolf359 says:

    Good Point on McCains vote!


  211. Greytdog says:

    What the heck is wrong with Brokaw? He’s allowing McCain to keep going, but then scolds Obama or cuts him off. . . Brokaw used to be a good journalist. But he ain’t no Walter Cronkite.


  212. nycbassist says:

    Calling McCain on his voting AGAINST child health care coverage was the best shot yet!!!!


  213. 5th Estate says:

    civil…I disagree, if the public mood is ( as I believe) that we want to hear about issues, not point scoring, The points will take care of themselves through the better informed arguments. Obama seems usually to be able to do both and is proving he understands the issues, whereas McCain just pretends.


  214. bronzbootz says:

    galmud Says:
    McCain is wandering around like hes lost in a supermarket or something

    Brings back memories.


  215. civil behavior says:

    People just aren’t that smart or that interested in long explanations.


  216. Another Joe says:

    lol – hear the size of the fine?

    what a poor excuse for a human being


  217. Laszlo Panaflex says:

    The second questioner of the night, a young African-American man, was named Oliver Clark. Toward the end of his response to Oliver’s question, however, McCain forgot his name and called him “Alan.”

    To be fair, McCain was referring to the first questioner, whose name was Alan. He pointed back over to Alan, and he was discussing what Alan had asked about. My Friends!

    Obama maxes out the CNN voter meter on most every question; McCain struggles to move the lines at all.


  218. Jim Wolf359 says:

    Lack of attention too CB.


  219. barfly says:

    Choose a memeber of the audience, and watch their reactions to both candidates.


  220. galmud says:

    “Did we hear the size of the fine hehe”

    Nice one John..


  221. civil behavior says:

    McCain doesn’t know what Peace is.


  222. tbone says:

    He is explaining a lot, but he is very clear in his explanations. I think it is a benefit to some degree. There is a lot of s*** going on in the country and I think people will want to hear someone who understands what is happening. Just my $0.02.

    History of the world? Peacemakers? Not recently


  223. Greytdog says:

    McCain and Brokaw are simply too buddy buddy for Brokaw to claim journalistic impartiality. What a mockery – can’t decide who disgusts me more – McCain or Brokaw.


  224. Game of Life says:

    He’s not any better than last time.

    Obama won once again.

    WAR WAR WAR


  225. Jane E. Schneider says:

    Uh-oh, Obama just trashed Joe Biden’s banking mecca of Delaware for their loose laws. That’s been my only beef with Biden, but I didn’t expect Obama to bring it up.


  226. galmud says:

    “on the job training” BS


  227. barfly says:

    Supporting our efforts in Bosnia/Kosovo?

    McCain didn’t.


  228. galmud says:

    “I know how to win wars” any second now


  229. Another Joe says:

    “my judgement” blah blah blah blah

    Ask his first wife…


  230. binx says:

    Did the old man just bust Joe Biden’s hair plugs when he’s at his mother-in-law’s funeral?


  231. Jim Wolf359 says:

    As Obama said in Denver. We do better when we lead by the power of our example, not the example of our power.


  232. Buckie Boy says:

    Can McCondscending be anymore condscending, but a puke.


  233. buzzbomb says:

    I love when McCain says “I know how to win wars.” Which one dipsh$t, Vietnam????


  234. Greytdog says:

    “we’re a nation of good” – so what does that mean? That the other nations are nations of bad?


  235. bronzbootz says:

    HE JUST QUOTED HANNITY!!!

    I digress.

    “America is the greatest force for good in history”

    The South American continent just fell over in disbelief.


  236. 5th Estate says:

    Good. Iraq is part of the broken US economy.


  237. civil behavior says:

    5th…….I’m not saying alot of people don’t get it and want to hear it but I am convinced that the majority of people want to see these candidates go by the rules of the debate. It’s sort of why laws are made. To abide by them. Trust me I’m an Obama voter but I also am listening carefully without some meter to tell me how people are responding.


  238. Game of Life says:

    The way he tossed the mic in his opposite hand, is so silly.
    he thinks he’s on point. What a idiot. He thinks its a gun. The dummy.
    I hope he drops it once.

    Please don’t wink mcchimpy.


  239. Laszlo Panaflex says:

    The way to win wars is apparently to spend half a decade in the enemy’s prison camp – it worked for Hogan’s Heroes!


  240. Jim Wolf359 says:

    Terriffic answer by Obama on Iraq! Well done.


  241. civil behavior says:

    JIm WOlf…..amen


  242. civil behavior says:

    I really really want to believe the American public is smart enough to understand the differences here but then again I’ve been living in West Palm Beach FL for the past five years. Remember 2000? I’m a bit worried.


  243. civil behavior says:

    Honor?? Did he say Honor?? OMG………


  244. galmud says:

    Answer the question McCain

    stop with the old tired surge nonsense


  245. tbone says:

    Does anyone like My Friends? What does the CNN “mood ring” do when he says that? To me it is a clear signal that BS is on its Way!


  246. Another Joe says:

    Look at mclame blink blink blink….

    Is his head gonna explode?


  247. galmud says:

    “That requires a cool hand” LOL like Iraq you fool!


  248. Greytdog says:

    Brokaw’s becoming grumpier. Did he not get a nap today? Gawd, I miss Tim Russert.


  249. 5th Estate says:

    civil… well the rules are v restrictive, but so far, the transgressions of the rules don’t seem to be doing anything except presumably knocking off a few questions at the end I guess. As long as they get equal time and cover as much ground as the topics permit.
    We get sound bytes from the press, It’s good to me to hear both speak at length and demonstrate their grasp of the issues, not their grasp of their own attacks and counter-attacks.


  250. lurker says:

    I we had done what Obama said “before” we went into Iraq
    we would not have gone in the first place.


  251. Another Joe says:

    When you hear “MY FRIEND” over and over, it’s time to hold onto your wallet!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


  252. Buckie Boy says:

    Oh my gawd, would McCancer quit saying “my friends”…how many phucking times has he said it…it is getting stupid.


  253. Morgan423 says:

    “That requires a cool hand…” He did NOT just say that. Either my television is malfunctioning or I’m hallucinating.


  254. Another Joe says:

    “I know those situations”

    “I spent a lot of time with prostitutes and finking on REAL POWS.”


  255. MCMetal says:

    If you’re hero is Ronnie Retard , you have absolutely zero business being in the White House , jackass…………..


  256. Jim Wolf359 says:

    My cousin in Ohio says the same thing CB. A lot of potential problems there. Also Pennsylvania as well. If it happens again, I fear the worst.


  257. barfly says:

    A cool hand at the tiller?

    Bomb, bomb McCain?

    Please.


  258. blue state bob says:

    Has anyone yet defined what the frick “victory” is

    His hero Reagan apparently hated him, read the new Rolling Stone article, long but worth it.


  259. galmud says:

    “I know these situations” I know everything because I’m John McCain


  260. nineteen_and_84 says:

    Senator McCain should be getting struck by lightning any time now. Spin, spin and more spin. He’s talking in generalities and nothing specific.
    McCain has no honor!

    How the hell to you win an occupation.

    Get a clue McCain!!!


  261. tbone says:

    McCain can’t seem to remember anything he has done since 1983.


  262. 5th Estate says:

    McCain does the creepy soft pleading voice again– a bit like Palin?


  263. buzzbomb says:

    Why won’t anyone call out McCain on the surge? What did it cost America. 1000 lives and tens of billions of dollars for what? To get back to square one? What a smashing success. Call him out on this surge bs!


  264. Greytdog says:

    Victory and honor? Dulce et decorum est pro patria more! How many lies will you tell as you send the young off to die? How many tales of your bravery will you recite as you sit by the fire, enclosed in your leather chair and sipping your brandy? How many more must die to bring about a bigger economic surplus in Iraq?


  265. civil behavior says:

    5th…….agreed and agree. I too want more knowledge but I fear for how little most care or know and want brevity at the risk of truth.


  266. barfly says:

    Greytdog Says:

    Gawd, I miss Tim Russert.

    I just threw up in my mouth a little…


  267. 5th Estate says:

    IMHO Pakistan is one hell of a kettle of fish that I don’t expect anyone to make any kind of sense out of right now.


  268. galmud says:

    McCain is gonna go all out condescending and call Obama naive and dangerous now.. “Senator Obama doesnt understand”


  269. Jim Wolf359 says:

    Slam Dunk for Obama on that one.


  270. tbone says:

    Did Roosevelt tell McCain that personally?


  271. Studhorse says:

    Walk softly and carry a big stick…my hero!


  272. galmud says:

    “Turns public opinion against us” Like Iraq and the entire Arab world with the Iraq occupation/invasion?


  273. Jim Wolf359 says:

    Thats called pre-emptive notice McCain. And i agree with it.


  274. 5th Estate says:

    Pakistan needs $100billion bailout right now, apparently.


  275. buzzbomb says:

    and a few more F-16s on our dime.


  276. galmud says:

    “Use force but talk softly” like Iraq and Iran..


  277. blue state bob says:

    I thought your hero was Reagan, did you already forget that?

    And bring out Petraus like he is Eisenhower, MacArthur, Grant, Lee, Jackson rolled up all into one is getting ridiculous.


  278. civil behavior says:

    Ohh, bomb bomb Iran……Gotcha!


  279. pete says:

    Brokaw: “I’m just the hired help”!

    Ya got that right Tom.


  280. Jim Wolf359 says:

    Go Barack, Kick Sum!!


  281. pete says:

    Throw those lies back in his face Barack.


  282. Jim Wolf359 says:

    Okay! Obama forced the issue. Good on him. You can’t let bald faced lies go unanswered like that.


  283. tbone says:

    Excellent response! He just nailed McCain and that was well worth the break in protocol to clear this up.


  284. civil behavior says:

    It was true he did sing bomb bomb bomb Iran…..


  285. civil behavior says:

    It was just a joke huh?


  286. buzzbomb says:

    If you believed McCain and faux news, Petreaus makes Alexander the Great look like a five year playing Risk for the first time.


  287. barfly says:

    OBAMA!OBAMA!OBAMA!OBAMA!OBAMA!OBAMA!OBAMA!

    Right freekin on!

    Bomb, bomb, bomb…


  288. nineteen_and_84 says:

    So McCain has no problem attacking Iraq, a sovereign country but not Pakistan. What’s up with that?


  289. galmud says:

    “I know how to get him. I know how to it.”

    Another bad joke McCain?


  290. tbone says:

    IF you know how to get him, you should consider sharing that info. with Bush, McCain.


  291. pete says:

    I know how to get him“?

    Then why hasn’t he bothered to tell anyone how to do it?


  292. bronzbootz says:

    WTF…McCain called his military career responsible


  293. 5th Estate says:

    Afghanistan, good.


  294. Jim Wolf359 says:

    How are you going to get Bin Ladin McCain? responsible military service? I suggest everyone read Rolling Stone’s piece on McCain. Scary Shit.


  295. Jane E. Schneider says:

    “I’ll get Osama Bin Laden…,I know how to get him, but I won’t telegraph my punches?” In other words, you’re talking BS, gramps. Go shout at a cloud.


  296. barfly says:

    McCain’s lies are mounting.

    Factcheck.org is going to be burning the midnight electrons, tonight.


  297. lurker says:

    John knows how to win? Whats he waiting for?


  298. galmud says:

    pete Says:

    “I know how to get him“?

    Then why hasn’t he bothered to tell anyone how to do it?

    Because hes a maverick. And a maverick works in mysterious ways


  299. Jane E. Schneider says:

    Galmud, I think he plans to sneak up on OBL and brand him.


  300. Game of Life says:

    How in the hell does mcchimpy know what will happen if our troops leave Iraq? He rattles on like an idiot.

    raygun mcchimpy’s hero. Oh great another member of the good old rotten boy’s network.

    mcchimpy doesn’t get it. Sen. Obama is right; trickle down doesn’t work and repugs don’t work.

    Just to let the troll know that raygun was a failure on all fronts, the rich won. Plus raygun was a big time drug dealer.

    Oh shyte mcchimpy just played a lie card again. he said, announcing-attack-is-a-bad-thing bs.

    Doesn’t he read?


  301. 5th Estate says:

    McCain still won’t admit that he was wrong about Iraq “easy, sweets and flowers”…I’m just sayin’


  302. galmud says:

    Iraq is still hell for civilians, but McCain is so out of touch he doesnt realize that


  303. blue state bob says:

    Brokaw sucks, but nothing wants me to see Russert out there, he sucked too. They all suck, some just suck less/more than others.


  304. Michael Lafferty says:

    “The same strategy, but very different conditions.” Say, what?

    It is absolutely and abundantly clear that the US ground forces component commander actually IN Afghanistan—you know, one of those individuals that the present ‘commander guy’ believes that we should listen to—does not believe that a ’surge’ in Afghanistan is the appropriate approach or represents a sort of path to success. Whatever the hell success is…

    McCain, nearly last in his class at the US Naval Academy, would fail the US Army’s Officer Basic Course modules which deal with strategy and tactics. What a pathetic excuse for a military officer he is, and remains.


  305. civil behavior says:

    As a lifelong pacifist I have a real problem with this huge militaristic posture of empire for empire’s sake that we seem to be taking. Thus it’s past time to get our energy act together. Sorry to say but the romanticizing of this military stud stuff is just so 20th century. Sorry but I am simply over it.


  306. Greytdog says:

    Hmm. . . maybe McCain has a similar strategy to Reagan’s with the hostages’ release after Carter had left Washington DC airspace. . . all hail the conquering hero. Did you know he’d been a POW?


  307. galmud says:

    “Not another cold war with Russia”

    But hey! lets kick them out of the G8! Lets exclude them from my new League of Democracies club!


  308. tbone says:

    Does this not turn russian public opinion against us?


  309. nineteen_and_84 says:

    McCain keeps saying he’s made the hard decisions. How? He’s a Senator not the President.

    Those who know about the surge know that it wasn’t the only thing that helped reduce some of the violence.


  310. questioneverything says:

    McCain is a bad joke. He long ago believed his press (which was so much bull pucky). I can’t stand listening to him my friends. Do we want another 4 years (or more) of not wanting to watch or listen to our president or vice (and she does seem to be a vice in some very warped circles)?


  311. lurker says:

    He has scarah to take care of Russia.


  312. buzzbomb says:

    McCains gonna suit up, take off, crank up Dangerzone, and bomb, bomb, bomb, Osama into oblivion.


  313. nineteen_and_84 says:

    Hey McCain, Georgia attacked first. And you may not start a cold war but your VP will.


  314. hellinabucket says:

    Of course we can’t follow McCain. He doesn’t have a flag pin on.


  315. galmud says:

    Please bring up the fact Obama, its IMPOSSIBLE to exclude Russia from the G8. Europe will not allow it and its reckless


  316. hussein toasterhead says:

    Grr.

    When is Obama going to stop letting McCain get away with the talking point that the “Surge” has worked? It hasn’t worked. What’s worked has been the Sadrist truce, the ethnic cleansing of the country, and the bribing of Sunni tribes.

    How is a “Surge” going to work in Afghanistan – are all the Pashtuns going to be exported to Pakistan?


  317. binx says:

    @311
    CB I’m with you on that one… all problems are not solved with troops and weapons.


  318. Greytdog says:

    What leverage is McCain talking about? We’re morally, economically, militarily, and globally bankrupt!


  319. hussein toasterhead says:

    galmud Says:

    Iraq is still hell for civilians, but McCain is so out of touch he doesnt realize that
    October 7th, 2008 at 10:18 pm

    ______

    Five rugs for five bucks = problem solved!


  320. civil behavior says:

    Cost us dearly…over and over and over


  321. Jim Wolf359 says:

    Not a very good answer by Obama. He needs more work on the issue of Russia and her intersts. He has to get up to speed there. Quickly.


  322. Another Joe says:

    LOL

    someone says MAYBE


  323. 5th Estate says:

    civil… I agree the military posturing is a throwback attitude and depends a lot on 25 year-old conventional thinking.


  324. Game of Life says:

    mcchimpy is still annoying, stiff, snippy, condescending…

    Obama\Biden
    Presidential


  325. hussein toasterhead says:

    civil behavior Says:

    As a lifelong pacifist I have a real problem with this huge militaristic posture of empire for empire’s sake that we seem to be taking. Thus it’s past time to get our energy act together. Sorry to say but the romanticizing of this military stud stuff is just so 20th century. Sorry but I am simply over it.
    October 7th, 2008 at 10:19 pm

    ______

    Agreed.


  326. 5th Estate says:

    Oh for chrisssake, EVIL Empire? Puhleeze!


  327. Greytdog says:

    Gawd, did Brokaw think up that question about Russia or did Joe Six Pack? Sheesh. What’s next? “Do you believe Barney still loves you?”


  328. Corporate Jesus says:

    Hold on folks I hear Borat has the last audience question!


  329. tbone says:

    I really think there is a large portion of our country that are almost glad (not really, but you know what I mean.) to see the Russia issue comeback. It’s a familiar foe that we can get all jingoistic about. Much easier to comprehend than the middle east.


  330. blue state bob says:

    This entire debate format blows, just want to throw that out there


  331. civil behavior says:

    Israel is not our problem.


  332. buzzbomb says:

    CB- totally agree. More troops to Afghanistan isn’t going to do a thing besides sink us deeper into a region that empires seem to get bogged down in. 7 years and counting…


  333. Morgan423 says:

    McCain’s answer on Russia was probably his best of the night, because it wasn’t full of crap, lies, and misdirection. Maybe he should change strategy…? Oh wait, he can’t, he’s not strong on anything else so misdirection’s all he’s got.


  334. 5th Estate says:

    Do we even have a defense treaty with Israel? Correct me if I’;m wrong but I don’t think so. That’s another–oh wait another lie, “without pre-conditions”


  335. civil behavior says:

    I think it’s time for those of us who believe the military needs to be dismantled to join hands and begin a movement to do so.


  336. bronzbootz says:

    “wipe israel off the map” – lie


  337. hussein toasterhead says:

    THE LEAGUE OF DEMOCRACIES!!!

    That’s so cute. Iran’s a democracy – do they get an invite?


  338. tbone says:

    Don’t the righties hate things like the United Nations and League of Nations? I’ve never understood this League of Democracies crap.


  339. galmud says:

    hussein toasterhead Says:

    THE LEAGUE OF DEMOCRACIES!!!

    That’s so cute. Iran’s a democracy – do they get an invite?

    Israel certainly isnt


  340. hussein toasterhead says:

    civil behavior Says:

    Israel is not our problem.
    October 7th, 2008 at 10:26 pm

    _______

    No. They’re just the ones who do our dirty work.


  341. blue state bob says:

    League of Democracies, is that like the Justice League?

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Justice_League


  342. galmud says:

    I love Israel!
    I love Israel more!
    I love Israel the most!
    I love Israel the mostest!
    I love Israel times infinity!
    Oh yeah? Bomb bomb bomb bomb bomb Iran!!


  343. discovery says:

    10:24: People who submit questions via the Internet are nameless during this debate. Brokaw has introduced them as a “question from the Internet,” unlike the audience members who are identified by their full names.

    I think some of the questions have had names on them. Some of the “from the internet” questions without names may just be FAQs…


  344. 5th Estate says:

    Okay OB just said “it’s important we don’t provide the UN with veto-power against our interests.”
    They don;t have that power, it;s an old canard used by Bush, so I assume Obama said that for the navy CHief’s benefit.


  345. Game of Life says:

    Please kick lieberman out, mcchimpy is using him as an example of being bipartisan. Get real fool.

    THANKYOUTHANKYOUTHANKYOUTHANKYOU


  346. Another Joe says:

    What don’t you know and how will you learn it?

    mclame better not say “I’ll find it online”


  347. Morgan423 says:

    Tom: “Okay, for our next question, I’m going to open a fortune cookie…”

    You’re killing me Tom!


  348. barfly says:

    Brokaw chose the questions that would be asked, didn’t he?

    There are many that seem calculated to put Obama’s positions in sharp detail, while allowing McCain’s to be somewhat fuzzier.

    I think Brokaw was attempting to influence the viewing audience by his selection of questions.


  349. jb says:

    The cranky old one keeps pumping hands up and down as if that will impart some meaning to his rambling prattle.


  350. tbone says:

    Weak! He should’ve made a meal out of that and shown some humility


  351. 5th Estate says:

    Well that last Q. is a tough one ( kinda pointless really).


  352. Another Joe says:

    look at mclame walk – it looks like he has a pants-load full of sh#t


  353. galmud says:

    “Americans are hurting and I understand” and my economic advisor calls you all a bunch of whiners


  354. Another Joe says:

    you know – I bet he does, did anyone else see him shake the poo out of his pants leg?


  355. 5th Estate says:

    barfly…There are many that seem calculated to put Obama’s positions in sharp detail, while allowing McCain’s to be somewhat fuzzier.

    and how would that be a problem? :)


  356. nowickedwitch says:

    Brokaw’s breathy emphysemic voice is beginning to get to me.
    He hasn’t interupted McCain more than once.


  357. galmud says:

    “Steady hand” dont make me laugh


  358. Another Joe says:

    I know what it’s like to need help – that’s why I ditched my first wife when she got sick and married a stoned rich girl.


  359. tbone says:

    Ugh. Also weak. Apparently these candidates have never interviewed for a real job in the past 20 years. Please show me that you can think.


  360. Buckie Boy says:

    “steady hand on the tiller” hahahahahaha….hahahahaha…..ya right, McConfused.


  361. Greytdog says:

    Did Donald Rumsfeld coach on that last question about the known unknowns that we know but don’t know yet?


  362. Game of Life says:

    Please tell me where this “holocaust” meme is coming from? Why does mcchimpy repeat this lie. his argument doesn’t fit when Israel is using nazi tactics to oppress the original owner.

    Somebody tell me what the hell it means.

    Oh shyte, POW time.

    Yuck he patted a voters ears.


  363. 5th Estate says:

    And David Brooks says “SOS from both but the edge to Obama: style fluid, easy to imagine him President”.


  364. lurker says:

    Brooks calls it for Obama.


  365. galmud says:

    Greytdog Says:

    Did Donald Rumsfeld coach on that last question about the known unknowns that we know but don’t know yet?

    In McCains world. There is no known unknowns he dont know about. McCain knows everything even the unknown knowns and the known unknowns that we dont yet know about he knows


  366. blue state bob says:

    Obviously Obama won, he didn’t sound demented and insane, so it wasn’t hard. The pundits will call it a tie. Anyway you look at it, it didn’t help the oldster and Caribou Stacey

    BTW, did McCain just refuse to shake Obama’s hand (on CNN)


  367. civil behavior says:

    As Kucinich said so explicitly in one of his house speeches…… Wake Up America Wake Up . Wake up America, Wkae up America…..


  368. tbone says:

    Game of lIfe:
    I totally agree. Why is it that we are now almost 70 years removed from the holocaust, and we talk about it like the next one could happen tomorrow? It just makes no sense to me.


  369. 5th Estate says:

    Brooks has been looking at the writing on the wall for the past couple of months now. ( Unctuous. opportunistic little jerk).


  370. tbone says:

    I would really like to know what people’s response to McCain’s tone and attitude was. I think he came across very petty, condescending, and spoiled. He sees his opportunity for power is nearly gone.


  371. barfly says:

    On CBS, “uncommitted” voters are saying they’re more inclined to vote for Obama, after Mccain’s dismissive “that one” comment.


  372. Marie says:

    McCain’ speech tonight appeared to be an impression of Peter Lorre in an old 1940’s movie. He was incoherent at times, he was off topic, and his jokes were lame.
    McCain seemed tense while Obama was collected and prepared.


  373. Jim Wolf359 says:

    CNN.com stayed with their live feed for about 5 minutes after the sign off. Barack and Michelle were still talking to people, working the audience. McCain and his wife boogied out after about a minute.


  374. 5th Estate says:

    And now on MSNBC, “It’s Pat” ( with Rachel)


  375. Marie says:

    I agree, Jim.
    The Obamas are gracious – McCain looks like he doesn’t want to be bothered.


  376. Marie says:

    Obama was the winner tonight.


  377. Game of Life says:

    Poor mcchimpy was raised by his mom because daddy doing navy stuff. (This was in response to Sen. Obama’s humble beginnings without his father)

    mcchimpy must have loved the lonely days without dear daddy. Because what does he do he turns around and did the same to his family and joined the navy. Oh so sad.

    Did the Tom say in the beginning “No closing statements?”


  378. tbone says:

    Really. They responded to the “that one” comment? That is interesting. People really respond to how you treat others. It is something that as social animals we have difficulty ignoring.


  379. rcinstlmo says:

    I’m watching MSNBC and they’re showing the Obamas working the crowd. No McCain anywhere.


  380. Jim Wolf359 says:

    I think its a clean win for Obama again. Very steady, good answers, and he did a good job I thought of speaking more directly to the questions.


  381. 5th Estate says:

    Pat Buchannan says Obama looked presidential ( Buchanan’s a nut half the time of course).


  382. IBTunion4obama says:

    I think Obama performed better than his first debate. Clear victory tonight.


  383. Game of Life says:

    mcchimpy was a whinny little bytche. lying about Sen. Obama won’t get him votes.

    pat is full of it.


  384. tbone says:

    ABC seems to be in the Obama won camp.


  385. galmud says:

    I missed the “that one” comment. In what context did McCain say that?


  386. civil behavior says:

    Obama is still in the hall with Michelle …..cspan is covering it…..they are talking, signing autographs, taking pictures, going one on one.

    5th……yes, unctous is right. love it! Brooks is getting liek Scarborough. He wants to keep his job.


  387. Morgan423 says:

    On C-span they’re still on the floor and the Obamas are still chatting it up with the audience (almost ten minutes past the end of the debate). McCain’s disappeared. My suspicion is that McCain is also a mutant superhero and dashed off right after the debate so that he can patrol the streets of Nashville.


  388. Chocolate Jesus says:

    U.S. intelligence warns Iraq war could explode again

    http://news.yahoo.com/s/mcclatchy/20081007/wl_mcclatchy/3066066

    betrayus’s bribing of terrorists and insurgent to give the illusion of peace is only going so far.. i just hope his bribery induced lull starts unravelling before obama takes office, or its all going to get blamed on him..


  389. Chocolate Jesus says:

    hmmm…link is there in my post but not showing up.. click on it..


  390. barfly says:

    CBS is using Dan Bartlett for political insight?

    Truly astounding.



  391. tbone says:

    McCain was talking about a bill (I believe it was a pork laden bill; someone correct me if I am wrong.) and said something to the effect of “and guess who voted for it? That one.” – while pointing at Obama. Very childish and condescending.


  392. Zooey says:

    Obama won tonight.

    He stayed cool, while McCain came out with “Not you, Tom,” “I’ll answer the question!” (while failing to answer), and calling Obama “that one.”

    Wow.

    McCain can’t keep the sleepy grumpy crazies from taking over after less than an hour — how is he going to handle 10-14 hour days?


  393. Game of Life says:

    10:42: On Fox, Nina Easton notes that we observed the “sinking ship of free-market Republicans” go to the “bottom of the sea,” with McCain’s proposal of a $300 billion “nationalization” of the U.S. mortgage market.

    On top of the 700b and the 149b? You have got to be kidding.

    The money thing won’t work by giving it to the crooks. Indict the crooks and have the crooks pay restitution. They don’t deserve the stolen money.


  394. 5th Estate says:

    civil…thank you ;) I’ve watched and listened to Brooks for about 15 years and he smirks and simpers and he just always reminds me of when I swam in the Hudson–I got out feeling all icky even though I looked clean.


  395. galmud says:

    MCCAIN: Damn celebrity.. standing there like a celebrity.. talking to people answering voters questions taking pictures being accessible


  396. civil behavior says:

    5th…..great metaphor!


  397. barfly says:

    It seems that my earlier point, about the questions posed, seems to have worked to Obama’s favor. The voter-focus group on CBS says they are more inclined to favor Obama’s positions, because he gave specifics.


  398. Above the Clouds says:

    McCain pointing at Obama and saying “that one” was hard to watch.


  399. Jane E. Schneider says:

    Jeez, 5th, you swam in the Hudson? Are you insane?


  400. Game of Life says:

    MSNBC mcchimpy shouldn’t talk about jello. HAHAHAHAHA


  401. tbone says:

    Galmud:
    The that one comment is up on Huffpo.


  402. 5th Estate says:

    Jane E Schneider: “Jeez, 5th, you swam in the Hudson? Are you insane?

    LOL! that was back in ‘86 when I lived right by the water back then, great view of Statue of Liberty from my bedroom and kitchen. It seemed like a good idea at the time. No harm done that I know of…I hope.


  403. galmud says:

    tbone Says:

    McCain was talking about a bill (I believe it was a pork laden bill; someone correct me if I am wrong.) and said something to the effect of “and guess who voted for it? That one.” – while pointing at Obama. Very childish and condescending.

    Oh Ok. Very classy, McCain. What a marvelous show of respect for your opponent


  404. dbadass says:

    Has John Kerry dropped by yet? I have prepped a few nice apps for us to share over such insightly dialogue


  405. 5th Estate says:

    LOL. Civil… a metaphor, but a real one!


  406. MCMetal says:

    My reaction to the debate :

    Wonder how many people playing the drinking game with the phrase “My Friends” being the key word(s) , have contracted alcohol poisoning …………………


  407. civil behavior says:

    McMetal..now that is hilarious.


  408. 5th Estate says:

    barfly…on MSNBC the metered independents in PA scored Obama very well. But boy there was one guy they the asked a question of and he was as clueless as Palin. Yeesh!


  409. barfly says:

    The CBS after-debate a<n<a<l<a<s<i<s seems to be that the horserace continues, with no clear leader.

    Just like they like it.

    Now they can parse the debate endlessly, looking for kernels of Ultimate Truth.


  410. lurker says:

    McCan’t needed to smite Obama, but failed. IMHO


  411. civil behavior says:

    Tom Brokaw tried hard not not appear biased but he shamed himself. Too bad I really used to think he was a pretty impartial journalist but his slip was showing tonight


  412. galmud says:

    I just saw a clip just after the end of the debate McCain patted Obama on the back and Obama turned around reached out his hand to shake McCains hand and McCain kinda refused to shake it ending up looking really awkward


  413. Jane E. Schneider says:

    5th, if it was back in ‘86, I guess all of the toxins are out of your system by now. You seem okay, anyway! :D


  414. Shayne says:

    Keith is already kicking McCain’s butt. Yay.


  415. Morgan423 says:

    >>lurker Says:

    McCan’t needed to smite Obama, but failed. IMHO

    > Lurker, agreed. McCain had to hit a home run to really change anything… and he didn’t even get it to the warning track. Heck, he barely cleared the infield.


  416. 5th Estate says:

    Jane E. Schneider: 5th, if it was back in ‘86, I guess all of the toxins are out of your system by now. You seem okay, anyway! :D

    Sorry, what? I was just looking at the colors man….and the spiders…the spiders! :)


  417. barfly says:

    Oops.

    The damned filter torqued me so much, I dropped “y.”


  418. b40 says:

    At the end of the debate, when the candidates and their wives were greeting the crowd, McCain came up behind Obama on the right side, and tapped Obama’s left shoulder. Obama turned around and reached a hand out to McCain and McCain soft of blew him off and pushed Obama’s hand toward Cindy. He didn’t shake his hand.


  419. bronzbootz says:

    CNN Poll

    Who won?

    BO – 54
    JM – 30



  420. Game of Life says:

    This debate proved that Sen. Obama did mcchimpy a big favor by not holding honest townhall meetings.

    mcchimpy looked like cheap-shot arrogant bully that he is.


  421. Shayne says:

    McCain is such a coward he’s afraid to bring up Ayers. He only lets his women do the dirty work for him.


  422. tbone says:

    So where does McCain go from here? Does he keep slinging mud? Does he switch back to the issues? He is really in a tough spot because it looks like the momentum for Obama is very real.


  423. Game of Life says:

    10:59: McCain made zero mentions of “middle class” tonight — the same number he offered in the first debate.

    I heard him mentioned ‘middle class’


  424. 5th Estate says:

    “That one” has been picked up by everyone it seems.


  425. Shayne says:

    That “that one” comment sounds like it was the final nail in McCain’s coffin.


  426. hussein toasterhead says:

    John Oliver is so awesome.


  427. MCMetal says:

    What in the hell was McDepends doing wandering around , BTW ?

    He have a map with the precise location of buried treasure on it ?


  428. hussein toasterhead says:

    tbone Says:

    So where does McCain go from here? Does he keep slinging mud? Does he switch back to the issues? He is really in a tough spot because it looks like the momentum for Obama is very real.
    October 7th, 2008 at 11:08 pm

    ______

    Ayers, Wright, and fear of black people.


  429. Laszlo Panaflex says:

    That Maccaca.

    The YouTube clip will be at the top of the hot list by midnight.


  430. bronzbootz says:

    CBS

    BO – 39

    No one – 34

    JM – 24-29?


  431. tbone says:

    H. Toasterhead:
    You think he sticks with that? I think that is destined to drag him down to the point where people pity him. Unless he comes up with something new and verifiable, I think negative campaigning is the nail in the coffin to his candidacy and his legacy. I think if he has any sense, he change course on that.


  432. bob hussein lablah says:

    Anybody get an official count of how many times the shriv said “My friends”?


  433. barfly says:

    It’s becoming clear from the after-debate spin-room talk, that the DNC has adopted the republican position on energy issues.

    DNC insiders have clearly drunk the offshore drilling/nuclear/clean coal soma.

    I’ve heard it echoed in the rhetoric of several DNC leadership/insiders, like Harold Ford.


  434. jb says:

    Gramps had to scurry off to clean out his pants.


  435. Above the Clouds says:

    The man who has has cancer several time wants more “safe and clean” nuclear power?


  436. galmud says:

    MCMetal Says:

    What in the hell was McDepends doing wandering around , BTW ?

    He have a map with the precise location of buried treasure on it ?

    Yeah a bit weird. Perhaps the chair was too tall and he didnt wanna look short by leaning rather than sitting relaxed like Obama did


  437. Game of Life says:

    b40 Says:

    At the end of the debate, when the candidates and their wives were greeting the crowd, McCain came up behind Obama on the right side, and tapped Obama’s left shoulder. Obama turned around and reached a hand out to McCain and McCain soft of blew him off and pushed Obama’s hand toward Cindy. He didn’t shake his hand.

    Wow. I wanna see that. What a ignorant sissy.


  438. Shayne says:

    Illinois has more nuclear plants than any other state but McStupid loves saying Obama is totally against it. I doubt if he’s for it but do your homework McCain.


  439. galmud says:

    Did a caller on C-span just claim “Obama supports human cloning”???


  440. 5th Estate says:

    “My friends, Franklin D Roosevelt approves my message”


  441. tbone says:

    Barfly:
    It does appear that way. Offshore drilling seems to be on the table for the Dems. I really hope that if it is, it is at the bottom of the list of ways to address energy issues.


  442. galmud says:

    TPM has the video of “the handshake that wasnt”
    http://talkingpointsmemo.com/archives/222684.php


  443. 5th Estate says:

    galmud Says: Did a caller on C-span just claim “Obama supports human cloning”???

    Did it sound like Sarah Palin?


  444. jb says:

    I wonder how much spent nuclear fuel could be stored for how long in the houses of McCain?


  445. bronzbootz says:

    Above the Clouds Says:

    The man who has has cancer several time wants more “safe and clean” nuclear power?

    —-

    He wants cancer patients to rub their bodies against the storage containers as a cheap from of chemo.


  446. 5th Estate says:

    Ah yes, Nuclear power.
    WE can have more of it, but the Iranians can’t have any of it in case they build a nuclear weapon that Israel has about 100 of at the moment with the means to deliver them too. That would be a “game-changer.”


  447. Shayne says:

    Thanks for the clip galmud. Who doesn’t shake the hand of a US Senator.


  448. Shayne says:

    I guess the old fart isn’t as good at the town hall as he thought he was. His campaign has already sent out a complaint that this wasn’t an actual town hall.


  449. AngryOne says:

    Desperate to resuscitate his diminishing hopes for the White House, John McCain during tonight’s presidential town hall meeting dramatically reversed course on a mortgage bailout for home owners. This spring, McCain adamantly stated “it is not the duty of government to bail out and reward those who act irresponsibly, whether they are big banks or small borrowers.” Now with his presidential campaign and the economy in dire straits alike, John McCain decided to open the federal wallet after all.

    For the details on McCain’s past statements and cynical turnabout, see:
    “McCain Flip-Flops on Mortgage Bailout for Homeowners.”


  450. galmud says:

    Shayne Says:

    Thanks for the clip galmud. Who doesn’t shake the hand of a US Senator.

    That one *points at McCain


  451. jb says:

    Don’t forget we are sending nuclear expertise to India and we are getting mangoes. And lets not mention that Pakistan has nukes. Iran should say we will not pursue nuclear weapons when Israel gives up all of theirs.


  452. bronzbootz says:

    cheaper alternative to chemo…

    my B


  453. Game of Life says:

    hussein toasterhead Says:

    tbone Says:

    So where does McCain go from here? Does he keep slinging mud? Does he switch back to the issues? He is really in a tough spot because it looks like the momentum for Obama is very real.
    October 7th, 2008 at 11:08 pm
    ______

    Ayers, Wright, and fear of black people.

    Why? Is seems that people of color and people of good sense are afraid of white people fighting for oil and aggression.


  454. tbone says:

    Not only does it appear that McCain refused to shake hands, but he also seemed to “pass Obama off” on Cindy. That’s a pretty disrespectful (and classless) move.


  455. Laszlo Panaflex says:

    Obama should ask McCain if he wants to do nine more town halls.


  456. Game of Life says:

    jb Says:

    Don’t forget we are sending nuclear expertise to India and we are getting mangoes. And lets not mention that Pakistan has nukes. Iran should say we will not pursue nuclear weapons when Israel gives up all of theirs.

    At least stop hiding them and join the nuke group. This alone should be enough to ban Israel from aid from the US.


  457. 5th Estate says:

    So now that we’ve covered health care, the economy, Pakistan, Iraq, Afghanistan, Russia, Israel, Medicaid, taxes, and oil, what;s the next debate going to be about?

    the DOJ, Gitmo, War Crimes, War Profiteering, Illegal Wiretapping, Vote Caging, Rendition, Net Neutrality, “Contractors”, Lobbyists?

    I’m guessing none of the above.


  458. MCMetal says:

    That Vet who asked a question tonight should have asked McDepends if Johnny Boy’s Chief Petty Officer is the one who taught him how to crash planes so wonderfully and regularly……….


  459. 5th Estate says:

    jb: Don’t forget we are sending nuclear expertise to India and we are getting mangoes.

    Apparently so, though I wonder how much expertise the US has to send as there hasn;t been a new nuclear plant built in the us in 30 years (?) and the last time the US built something in India it was Union Carbide in Bhopal, and that didn’t turn out too well.


  460. liberal traitor says:

    Bwahahahaha! Fox News dot Com doesn’t even have a poll. They have a ‘forum’ where people can write what they think. They don’t want to put a voting poll on their website that will show an overwhelming victory for Obama the way it looks to everyone else.

    Hilarious.


  461. 5th Estate says:

    MCMetal Says: That Vet who asked a question tonight should have asked

    how McCain got such lousy grades from Vet’s organizations.


  462. Shayne says:

    Uh oh, the Obamas schmoozed after the debate and the McCain ran out and the people who were there are PISSED.


  463. wiley says:

    My 93 year old grandmother thinks McCain is too old to run for president, and she’s infinitely sharper than he is. He appears to both of us to be as brain-addled as Reagan was in his last years in office. The press was always laughing off Reagan’s bizarre states as ‘gaffes’, but to the majority (who never loved Reagan like the media did) his dotage was a bit unnerving.

    How can a critical mass of Americans be more afraid of a mulatto being president, than a guy who is stuck in a mindset that is nearly extinct and who appears not to be getting enough oxygen to his brain? There is nothing wrong with being old, but there is something seriously wrong with being OLD and being the president.

    Sounds like he kinda tanked on this town hall meeting(TM). Maybe it wasn’t the way he remembers the 19th century.


  464. tbone says:

    Shayne:
    Apparently, McCain’s social skills are not up to snuff. What are the odds he is currently berating some staffer about his poor performance?


  465. wilytrax.com says:

    For 90 minutes we didn’t have to think of or hear Sarah Palin.

    We are all winners.

    http://www.WilyTrax.com


  466. barfly says:

    What are the odds he is currently berating some staffer about his poor performance?

    Cindy’s probably already dosed herself with a couple five prophylactic Ambiens.


  467. tbone says:

    You think she waited ’til after the debate?


  468. globachio says:

    I just read 474 comments and everybody on here says nothing nice about Senator McCain. come on it can’t be that one sided.


  469. galmud says:

    tbone Says:

    Shayne:
    Apparently, McCain’s social skills are not up to snuff. What are the odds he is currently berating some staffer about his poor performance?

    Maybe it is for the better a president McCain wouldnt talk directly to Iran, Spain or anyone. Instead send pretty little Sarah around the world to charm the men of power.


  470. blue state bob says:

    “globachio Says:
    I just read 474 comments and everybody on here says nothing nice about Senator McCain. come on it can’t be that one sided.”

    Why should we say something nice about him, there is nothing nice to say about him?

    He didn’t call his wife a c__t, I guess that’s a plus. Does that make you happy?


  471. MCMetal says:

    globachio Says:
    ——————————————————————————–

    I just read 474 comments and everybody on here says nothing nice about Senator McCain. come on it can’t be that one sided.

    October 7th, 2008 at 11:56 pm

    You believe lying throughout the entire “debate” as well as blowing off a handshake from your opponent afterwards and then ske-daddling out while the other candidate and his lovely wife schmooze with the crowd is being “nice” ?

    Wake up and get a clue……………


  472. Game of Life says:

    MSNBC pat is ridiculous. He said during mcchimpy’s closing ham statement, “He spoke from his heart.” What heart?

    pat is also saying mcchimpy should be down and dirty because that the only way to win. Yeah, bring up tired old bs and we will bring up yours. These are old tactics for the 20th century.

    mcchimpy will play the grandpappy role next. The lovable old wise pappy.

    HAHAHAHHA


  473. m3vega says:

    What was McCain thinking when he said we would buy up upside down mortgages and then revalue them. Who decides who gets bailed out? Who decides what the value will be?

    Big Brother John McCain? Communist? Is he going to tell us where we can live next?

    He is off the deep end. Bye Bye John. I wonder how fox will spin this. Should be fun to watch them for once.


  474. MCMetal says:

    McDepends spent his entire “closing statement” prattling on about his shitty life and supposed achievements , when he was supposed to answer a direct question that had nothing whatsoever to do with what he was babling about ………

    He’s a fu(king stupid old man………….


  475. Fred says:

    globachio Says:

    You must be lost…..it’s called think progress so mccain….not so much.


  476. Game of Life says:

    MSNBC yeah right, “that one” isn’t a slip.

    It’s what an old white people call color people.

    I learned something every day.


  477. Zooey says:

    Ok, I’ve got a nice thing to say about McCain:

    It’s really nice he didn’t drop dead on the stage.


  478. pete says:

    Something nice? He didn’t wink like a $2.00 hooker.


  479. Shayne says:

    Gee Zooey, tell me why that is a good thing.


  480. Chocolate Jesus says:

    wait.. John McCain is white? and old? and he’s losing…

    wow..


  481. Zooey says:

    Shayne,

    It’s a good thing because we didn’t have to watch Cindy start giggling uncontrollably. ;)


  482. MCMetal says:

    He’s stupid as hell , too…………


  483. Zooey says:

    It’s hours late, but check our live-blogging on TheZoo. :-)


  484. 5th Estate says:

    well I’m done for the night. Good night all.


  485. Zooey says:

    Goodnight, 5th Estate. I’m outta here, too.

    Goodnight, all!


  486. Jane E. Schneider says:

    Why am I not seeing Shayne’s and Zooey’s names and links? (Not that I don’t know them, but…)

    Goodnight, 5th! I’m out, too.


  487. Game of Life says:

    Why are the repugs using this bs:

    Sen. Obama has voted 90% with the dems proposals.

    Idiotic.

    Please tell me that repugs aren’t comparing mcchimpy’s voting over 90% with chimpy’s failed and dangerous policies. How can they be compared? Dumbasses

    It’s a silly ignorant one sided typical repug argument. WTF?


  488. Shayne says:

    Jane, Zooey and I must be wearing our invisibility cloaks. Can you see me now.


  489. Jane E. Schneider says:

    No, Shayne, I still can’t see you. Weird.


  490. Game of Life says:

    OMG I saw the hand dis from mcchimpy. It made Sen. Obama split from the old coot.


  491. tom says:

    Not only does it appear that McCain refused to shake hands, but he also seemed to “pass Obama off” on Cindy. That’s a pretty disrespectful (and classless) move.

    Quite unusual. He normally gets sloppy seconds; in this case, he gave ‘em.


  492. Keith says:

    McCain linked to group in Iran-Contra affair

    Associated Press. October 07, 2008 10:20 PM EDT

    WASHINGTON – Republican Sen. John McCain served on the advisory board to the U.S. chapter of an international group linked to ultra-right-wing death squads in Central America in the 1980s.

    The U.S. Council for World Freedom also aided rebels trying to overthrow the (DEMOCRATIC) leftist government of Nicaragua. That landed the group in the middle of the Iran-Contra affair and in legal trouble with the Internal Revenue Service, which revoked the charitable organization’s tax exemption.

    The council created by retired Army Maj. Gen. John Singlaub was the U.S. chapter of the World Anti-Communist League, an international organization linked to former Nazi collaborators and ultra-right-wing death squads in Central America. After setting up the U.S. council, Singlaub served as the international league’s chairman.


  493. ebbAndflow says:

    Aplomb, élan, style=Obama
    confusion, delusion=JSMcC

    After the debate: The Obama’s exude warmth and a true, caring demeanor.
    The McC’s, cold, aloof and very GWBish.


  494. Game of Life says:

    “That One”

    mcchimpy is a racist mfer like all repugs.

    If he uses those two words at his rallies, that will stir-up his
    racist friends.

    mcchimpy has tanked his campaign on purpose for good. Good riddance old fart.

    Tons of progressive blogs are really pissed off at mcchimpy and plain’s idiotic, erratic behavior.


  495. dotmafia says:

    This one. . .

    THAT WON 08

    copyright d. wince


  496. sectionop92 says:

    McCain probably thinks a China Syndrome can only happen in China.


  497. dfletcher says:

    Well I’m getting into discussion suuuuper late, just watched. Few thoughts. Maybe some folks are still up ;-)

    Wow the debate format was terrible. The audience except for one woman were like robots. The non-followup was just silly. Who agreed to that or thought it was a good idea? They both looked like they wanted to break that rule.

    Hehe couple others here mentioned, yeah McCain was wandering – pacing. Hey, relax guy!

    McCain seemed to have trouble breathing. Between each sentence, he inhaled deeply, loudly. Either something’s up with his health or he’s bottling some serious anger. Maybe both.

    Obama saying outright that he wants to kill OBL and crush Al Quaeda was brilliant. Remember what happened last time? OBL endorsed JK. Then everyone voted Bush. Gah. Well, this time it won’t work I believe. If OBL tried it, all everyone has to do is point to this debate and say – Obama wants to kill OBL, John McCain prevaricated.

    I love those insta-polls. Real reactions, unfiltered. It’s awesome. That works so great it needs to be bigger, give us an even bigger sample size. Highly understandable how the numbers flatline when we get infighting. Bickering is getting boring. Answers are good. Let’s hope this latest Johnny Mac strategy (or is it a tactic, I’m never sure) of mudslinging doesn’t drag Obama down. Use your strengths, Barack! We love it when you have solutions!

    But overall, it was quite a boring debate. I blame the format and rule-monster Tom.



  498. PrahaPartizan says:

    “…McCain said that when he looks into Putin’s eyes, he sees the letters K-G-B. But in 2001, after President Bush looked into Putin’s eyes and saw his soul, McCain gave him “an A” for how he did in his meeting with Putin…”

    OK, let me say something nice about McCain AND Bush, referencing the above statement. McCain was right! So was Bush! It’s just that McCain has never looked into Bush’s eyes to see what’s actually there. The last five years prove that both men were correct in their assessment.


  499. barfly says:

    Well the transcripts are out, and McCain said “my friends” and “my friend” a total of twenty times.

    It seemed like more, but that’s quite a lot of usage for a ninety minute debate. Figuring he spoke roughly half the time, that’s twenty mentions in 45 minutes, or about 1 mention every 2.5 minutes.


  500. DallasNE says:

    McCain just quit. He picked up his toys and left in a huff after the debate ended. The Obama’s stayed a full 20 minutes to chat, shake hands and pose for pictures. This race just ended. Can you say President Obama? I sure can.


  501. Iolair says:

    just scrolling through the live blog it looked like Obama hardly spoke at all? Why not blog both candidates statements?


  502. 00mpp00 says:

    McCain is just an old curmudgeon. His bitter snarl of “That One” in reference to Obama is the epitome of McCain’s “get off my lawn” crabbiness and derangement.

    http://www.sunstateactivist.org


  503. Zimzone says:

    IMHO, Brokaw wasn’t up to the moderation task, nor did he do a thorough job on follow up questions.

    McCain showed Americans who he is…a tired, washed up, lying old Beltway Boob. He’s bitter, forgetful & not real smart.

    Obama was concise, personable & professional, but time limits restricted him from in depth answers.

    Early news ‘rating’s show favorable opinions at 40%+ for Obama, 26% for McCain.

    Watch for an Oct surprise; it’s all McBush has left to try.


  504. Kay says:

    by Naomi Wolf
    Huffington Post – September 24, 2008
    Global Research, October 3, 2008

    Please understand what you are looking at when you look at Sarah “Evita” Palin. You are looking at the designated muse of the coming American police state.

    You have to understand how things work in a closing society in order to understand “Palin Power.” A gang or cabal seizes power, usually with an affable, weak figurehead at the fore. Then they will hold elections — but they will make sure that the election will be corrupted and that the next affable, weak figurehead is entirely in their control. Remember, Russia has Presidents; Russia holds elections. Dictators and gangs of thugs all over the world hold elections. It means nothing. When a cabal has seized power you can have elections and even presidents, but you don’t have freedom.

    I realized early on with horror what I was seeing in Governor Palin: the continuation of the Rove-Cheney cabal, but this time without restraints. I heard her echo Bush 2000 soundbites (”the heart of America is on display”) and realized Bush’s speechwriters were writing her — not McCain’s — speeches. I heard her tell George Bush’s lies — not McCain’s — to the American people, linking 9/11 to Iraq. I heard her make fun of Barack Obama for wanting to prevent the torture of prisoners — this is Rove-Cheney’s enthusiastic S and M, not McCain’s, who, though he shamefully colluded in the 2006 Military Tribunals Act, is also a former prisoner of war and wrote an eloquent Newsweek piece in 2005 opposing torture. I saw that she was even styled by the same skillful stylist (neutral lipstick, matte makeup, dark colors) who turned Katharine Harris from a mall rat into a stateswoman and who styles all the women in the Bush orbit — but who does not bother to style Cindy McCain.

    Then I saw and heard more. Palin is embracing lawlessness in defying Alaskan Legislature subpoenas — this is what Rove-Cheney, and not McCain, believe in doing. She uses mafia tactics against critics, like the police commissioner who was railroaded for opposing handguns in Alaskan battered women’s shelters — Rove’s style, not McCain’s. I realized what I was seeing.

    Reports confirmed my suspicions: Palin, not McCain, is the FrankenBarbie of the Rove-Cheney cabal. The strategy became clear. Time magazine reported that Rove is “dialed in” to the McCain campaign. Rove’s protege Steve Schmidt is now campaign manager. And Politico reported that Rove was heavily involved in McCain’s vice presidential selection. Finally a new report shows that there are dozens of Bush and Rove operatives surrounding Sarah Palin and orchestrating her every move.

    What’s the plan? It is this. McCain doesn’t matter. Reputable dermatologists are discussing the fact that in simply actuarial terms, John McCain has a virulent and life-threatening form of skin cancer. It is the elephant in the room, but we must discuss the health of the candidates: doctors put survival rates for someone his age at two to four years. I believe the Rove-Cheney cabal is using Sarah Palin as a stalking horse, an Evita figure, to put a popular, populist face on the coming police state and be the talk show hostess for the end of elections as we know them. If McCain-Palin get in, this will be the last true American election. She will be working for Halliburton, KBR, Rove and Cheney into the foreseeable future — for a decade perhaps — a puppet “president” for the same people who have plundered our treasure, are now holding the US economy hostage and who murdered four thousand brave young men and women in a way of choice and lies.

    How, you may ask, can I assert this? How can I argue, as I now do, that there is actually a war being ramped up against US citizens and our democracy and that Sarah Palin is the figurehead and muse for that war?

    Look at the RNC. This is supposed to be McCain’s America. But you see the unmistakable theatre of Rove’s S and M imagery — and you see stages eight, nine and ten of the steps to a dictatorship as I outlined them in The End of America. Preemptive arrest? Abusive arrest? “Newly released footage, which was buried to avoid confiscation, shows riot cops arresting and abusing a giant group of people for nothing.”

    Journalists were arrested — for reporting. Amy Goodman and ABC producers were arrested. Jane Hamsher of Firedoglake and others were forced to lie face down as armed agents tied their hands behind their backs. The riot police wore the black S&M gear of the Rovian fantasy life and carried the four foot batons cops carry in North Korea. All this is not John McCain’s imagery or strategy: it is Karl Rove’s.

    In McCain-Palin’s America, citizens who are protesting are being charged as terrorists. This means that a violent war had been declared on American citizens. A well known reporter leaked to me on background that St Paul police had dressed as protesters and, dressed in Black — shades of the Blackshirts of 1920 — infiltrated protest groups. There were also phalanxes of men in black wearing balaclavas, linking arms and behaving menacingly — alleged “anarchists.” Let me tell you, I have been on the left for thirty years and you can’t get three lefties to wear the same t-shirt to a rally, let alone link arms and wear identical face masks: these are not our guys. Agent Provocateurs framing protesters and calling protest “terrorism” constitutes step ten of a police state:

    “In what appears to be the first use of criminal charges under the 2002 Minnesota version of the Federal Patriot Act, Ramsey County Prosecutors have formally charged 8 alleged leaders of the RNC Welcoming Committee with Conspiracy to Riot in Furtherance of Terrorism… [they] 7 1/2 years in prison under the terrorism enhancement charge which allows for a 50% increase in the maximum penalty.”

    “Paid, confidential informants… infiltrated the RNCWC on behalf of law enforcement. They allege that members of the group sought to kidnap delegates to the RNC, assault police officers with firebombs and explosives, and sabotage airports in St. Paul. Evidence released to date does not corroborate these allegations with physical evidence or provide any other evidence for these allegations than the claims of the informants. Based on past abuses of such informants by law enforcement, the National Lawyers Guild is concerned that such police informants have incentives to lie and exaggerate threats of violence and to also act as provocateurs in raising and urging support for acts of violence.”

    Under the Palin-Rove police state, you will see escalating infringements on your access to a free internet:

    “Sarah Palin was baptized at Wasilla Assembly of God…Last Sunday our research team released a video, a ten-minute mini-documentary, focusing on the Wasilla Assemblies of God and the video seemed on the verge of a massive “viral” breakthrough when YouTube pulled it down, citing ‘inappropriate content’. At the point the video was censored by YouTube it had been viewed by almost 160,000 people. The short of it is that YouTube has censored a video documentary that appeared to be close to having an effect on a hard fought and contentious American presidential election…”

    Under the coming Palin-Rove police state, you will witness the plans now underway to bring Iraqi troops to patrol the streets of our nation. This is not McCain’s fantasy: it is Rove’s and Cheney’s.

    Under the Palin-Rove police state, there will be no further true elections. Mark Crispin Miller has done sensational and under-reported investigating t o establish that — as I warned — indeed the GOP staffers on the US Senate Judiciary Committee have been .

    The evidence is also buried on the Website of the Majority House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence.

    WASHINGTON — Republican staff members of the US Senate Judiciary Commitee infiltrated opposition computer files for a year, monitoring secret strategy memos and periodically passing on copies to the media, Senate officials told The Globe. >From the spring of 2002 until at least April 2003, members of the GOP committee staff exploited a computer glitch that allowed them to access restricted Democratic communications witho ut a password. Trolling through hundreds of memos, they were able to read talking points and accounts of private meetings discussing which judicial nominees Democrats would fight — and with what tactics.

    – “Senate panel’s GOP staff spied on Democrats” By Charlie Savage, Globe Staff | January 22, 2004

    Do you think that spying like this will ever end under a Palin-Rove regime? Dream on. If she and McCain are elected, then every single strategy memo and speech and debate prep note from every opposition candidate from now and on into forever will be read by the regime in power while it is still in the computers of the challengers.

    Under the Palin-Rove police state, citizens will be targeted with state cyberterrorism. Bruce Fein of the American Freedom Agenda, a former Reagan official, warned me three years ago that the Bush team went after a Republican who had crossed them through cyberstalking: they messed with his email, messed with his phones and I believe messed with his bank account — he became a cyber-pariah, unemployable and haunted. With modern technology, there really is less place to hide from the state than there was in East Germany in the Cold War era. I remember feeling a chill: of course. That is the wave of the future once we breach the protections around citizens of FISA and the fourth amendment. That way lies the abyss for us all.

    Am I trying to scare you? I am. I am trying to scare you to death and ask you to scare your Republican and independent friends most of all. How do you know when it is war on citizens? When there are mass arrests, journalists are jailed, the opposition is infiltrated, rights are stripped and leaders start to ignore the rule of law.

    Almost everyone I work with on projects related to this campaign for liberty has been experiencing computer harassment: emails are stripped, messages disappear. That’s not all: people’s bank accounts are being tampered with: wire transfers to banks vanish in midair. I personally keep opening bank accounts that are quickly corrupted by fraud. Money vanishes. Coworkers of mine have to keep opening new email accounts as old ones become infected. And most disturbingly to me personally is the mail tampering I have both heard of and experienced firsthand. My tax returns vanished from my mailbox. All my larger envelopes arrive ripped straight open apparently by hand. When I show the postman, he says “That’s impossible.” Horrifyingly to me is the impact on my family. My childrens’ report cards are returned again and again though perfectly addressed; their invitations are turned back; and my daughters many letters from camp? Vanished. All of them. Not one arrived. Try explaining that to a smart thirteen year old. Try explaining it in a way that still makes her feel secure and comfortable.

    I am not telling you this because it’s about my life. I am telling you this because it is about your life — whoever you are, Conservative or Liberal, independent or evangelical. Your politics will not protect you in a police state. History shows that nothing protects you in a police state. This is not about my fear and anxiety: it is about what awaits you and everyone you love unless you see this for what it is:

    Scharansky divided nations into “fear societies” and “free societies.” Make no mistake: Sarah “Evita” Palin is Rove and Cheney’s cosmetic rebranding of their fascist push: she will help to establish a true and irreversible “fear society” in this once free once proud nation. For God’s sake, do not let her; do not let them.

    Naomi Wolf is the author of ‘The End of America: A Letter of Warning to a Young Patriot’ (Chelsea Green, 2007).


  505. McWars says:

    It’s nice to finally have a presidential candidate who teaches us to come out strong by remaining calm in the face of a challenge — in Obama’s case, multiple challenges in being cut off repeatedly by Tom Brokaw in the name of “time constraints” while McChimpy got in the last word.

    But, that all didn’t matter. They piled the challenges on THAT ONE, and THAT ONE came out with a clean victory. The independents are now securely in the tank for Obama.

    Buh Bye McFlakyMavericky. Take your collection of barbies with you.

    Brokaw: F

    McCain: F

    Obama: A


  506. upnorth says:

    “I know how to fix this economy.”
    Classic McCain

    If that truly was the case why did he have nothing to say at the White House meeting when he supposedly suspended his campaign? Why did he vote for a bill full of unecessary wasteful spending(ie: pork)?


  507. upnorth says:

    “So McCain has no problem attacking Iraq, a sovereign country but not Pakistan. What’s up with that?”

    Nineteen_and_84

    Pakistan = Nuclear armed.
    Iraq = Non nuclear armed.

    Not much more to say!


  508. ForTruth says:

    I actually decided to stomach a debate last night. I haven’t seen any of the others. I was glad I watched. McCain was seething with anger, right under the surface, he was laboring to sound “pleasant”. McCain said “my friends” so many times, like he was talking to people in a nursing home, or TBN viewers. McCain had many “points” that had absolutely no substance. He was a grumpy old man who felt entitled, and couldn’t believe he even “had” to debate Obama.

    Obama was a statesmen, Presidential, intelligent, strong, articulate, and wiped the floor with GrampySauce. Obama was aggressive in discussing Bin Laden. Called grampy out on his “bomb bomb Iran” rhetoric. McCain thought he had a point when criticizing Obama’s “plan” to spend 800 billion dollars on domestic programs, but was a joke in light of the recent “bailout” of Wall Street to the tune of a trillion dollars.

    Grampy needs a nap.


  509. whosbarmynow says:

    Obama was a statesmen, Presidential, intelligent, strong, articulate, and wiped the floor with GrampySauce. Obama was aggressive in discussing Bin Laden. Called grampy out on his “bomb bomb Iran” rhetoric.

    Agreed. But I hated how Obama had to come across as bombier-than-thou.



Jump to Top

About Think Progress | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2009 Center for American Progress Action Fund
View Most Popular

Advertisement

What We're About

Featured

image
Subscribe to the Progress Report



imageTopic Cloud


Visit Our Affiliated Sites

image image
Reports


Got a hot tip?
Have a hot news tip? We'd love to hear from you. Use the form below to send us the latest.

Name:
Email:
Tip:
(required)


imageArchives


imageBlog Roll