Think Progress

Bush Rewrites History: ‘I Never Said The Taliban Was Eliminated’

Early this morning, during a press conference in Kabul with Afghan President Karzai, President Bush attempted to paper over his previous declarations of victory over the now-resurgent Taliban. Bush claimed emphatically, “I never said the Taliban was eliminated.” Watch it:

In fact, Bush used the word “eliminated” to describe the state of the Taliban on several occasions:

September 2002: “The Taliban’s ability to brutalize the Afghan people and to harbor and support terrorists has been virtually eliminated.”

April 2002: “With the Taliban eliminated and al-Qaida badly damaged, we have moved into the second stage of our war on terror.”

At other times, Bush prematurely declared victory using similar language:

September 2004: “And as a result of the United States military, Taliban no longer is in existence. And the people of Afghanistan are now free.”

December 2004: “In Afghanistan, America and our allies, with a historically small force and a brilliant strategy, defeated the Taliban in just a few short weeks.”

October 2005: “Over the years these extremists have used a litany of excuses for violence — the Israeli presence on the West Bank, or the U.S. military presence in Saudi Arabia, or the defeat of the Taliban, or the Crusades of a thousand years ago.”

While coalition forces made significant early progress against the Taliban, President Bush allowed the situation to deteriorate after deciding to invade Iraq in 2003. Since the U.S. invasion of Iraq, troops and resources have been diverted from Afghanistan. Consequently, the situation in Afghanistan has deteriorated dramatically in recent years. Currently, the Taliban has a “permanent presence” in 75 percent of the country and exercises control over the country’s “political and military dynamic.”

Likewise, the still-classified Afghanistan NIE reportedly paints a “grim” picture of the country. While Bush deserves credit for trying to bring his current rhetoric more in line with reality, he isn’t allowed to pretend that his past rhetoric wasn’t false.

Update The April 2002 quote previously attributed to Bush was actually from a speech delivered by then-National Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice. We apologize for the error.


27 Responses to “Bush Rewrites History: ‘I Never Said The Taliban Was Eliminated’”

  1. Badmoodman says:

    Early this morning, during a press conference in Kabul with Afghanistan President Karzai,

    – - Secret Service Agent, call name “New Balance,” made everyone shed their shoes before entering the press conference.


  2. NOLIESPLEASE says:

    You never said a lot of things….unfortunately we have a thing call the internets that help us search and put to light every word you have said in your miserable presidentcy.

    As far as I am concerned, you never took the oath of office.


  3. raynman says:

    I hope that when the history books are written, mention is made of the mainstream media’s culpability in all that has been allowed to happen.


  4. LiberalVoter says:

    Bush lying? Imagine that!


  5. vinylspear says:

    Have you got that turd shiny yet George?


  6. LividLib says:

    Damnit!
    Where’s my shoe?

    INCOMING!


  7. Fred says:

    raynman Says:
    I hope that when the history books are written, mention is made of the mainstream media’s culpability in all that has been allowed to happen.

    At least now the gop doesn’t get to write the history books. It aint going to be like the raygun era where bush I was able to cover for raygun……this is out in the open, exposed and the gop owns the failures of the last 8 years. Just the facts.


  8. RUCerious says:

    BushitCo Revisionism is a little bit like Mad Magazine.
    What? Me Worry?


  9. wiley says:

    Working hard for that 18%, ain’t he?

    Sheesh.


  10. stateofthedivision says:

    Now that’s Clintonesque word pasing.


  11. Jackie says:

    The secret was out as must of us Military families got emails from soldiers that the idiot was on the way. Baghram is a very safe and nice people. Our troops given respect to the Afghan people and they life our troops. Now one day Cheney came to Baghram and the post was fired apon for the first time. After Cheney left things went back to normal. Now Bush is visiting and who knows what will happen but he will have a wag the dog scene this time because it might be more then a dirty shoe being tossed at him. Bush/Cheney are hated by all citizens in the Middle East and the puppet Law Makers are getting paid.

    I told our soldiers that George W. Bush had the Taliban as his guest when they visited the US. Yes Bush called them his friends and gave them a US tour. I guess the love is gone now.


  12. shoeless says:

    wiley Says:
    ——————————————————————————–

    Working hard for that 18%, ain’t he?

    Sheesh.

    He doesn’t have to work hard for them. They aren’t exactly the brightest bulbs in the chandelier.


  13. theswan says:

    Bush is the taliban. And his days are numbered.


  14. shoeless says:

    Jackie Says:
    ——————————————————————————–

    I told our soldiers that George W. Bush had the Taliban as his guest when they visited the US. Yes Bush called them his friends and gave them a US tour. I guess the love is gone now.

    Their relationship turned sour in early 2001. Bush wanted the Taliban to allow a Unocal pipeline through Afghanistan, and they turned him down. He told them they could “choose between a carpet of gold or a carpet of bombs.” We know how that turned out.


  15. PatrioticLiberalChristian says:

    I just had this cartoon image of Bush splattered spread eagle on the bottom of a tennis shoe with the brand name “History”. “Just Do It!”, indeed.


  16. Bozo The Neoclown says:

    the taliban? you mean the group the uber republiscum ronnie raygun subsidized in the 80’s, that taliban?


  17. crooksNliars says:

    Just like everything else this brainless wonder says, it will be argued that his comments are ‘technically’ true…. he’s the posterchild for symantical argument for why his statements are ‘true’


  18. Leftside Annie says:

    Awwww, now, crap – it would be news if Chimpy WASN’T lying and revising history.


  19. trollsbwild says:

    It is amazing that the Neocons seem to forget there is a thing called the internets.


  20. realist says:

    Bush lies, repeatedly and with impunity. He’s Baghdad Bob with a fake Texas accent and a fake ranch to go with it.


  21. MapleStreet says:

    YouTube has a liberal Bias ?


  22. ucsbclassics53 says:

    What?! Did they have a History Revision class at Yale or wherever he went?


  23. shoeless says:

    MapleStreet Says:
    ——————————————————————————–

    YouTube has a liberal Bias ?

    In other words, the right-wing propaganda machine can’t control it.


  24. EugeneDebs says:

    Bush is a liar. Its what he does, its who he is.


  25. COProgressive says:

    Whoop! Whoop! Whoop!
    Revisionist History Alert!
    Bush Legacy Project At Work!
    Revisionist History Alert!
    Whoop! Whoop! Whoop!


  26. sacopenapa says:

    Bush also said ‘mission acomplished, he told us that Saddam had WMD and were in touch with Al-Queida, that Saddam was responsible for 9/11, and that the USA did not Torture…

    We all know what ‘cocaine’ and alchohool does to people…


  27. drago says:

    Worst.

    (lying, c**ksucking, motherf**king)

    President.

    EVER.



Jump to Top

About Think Progress | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2009 Center for American Progress Action Fund
View Most Popular

Advertisement

What We're About

Featured

image
Subscribe to the Progress Report



imageTopic Cloud


Visit Our Affiliated Sites

image image
Reports


Got a hot tip?
Have a hot news tip? We'd love to hear from you. Use the form below to send us the latest.

Name:
Email:
Tip:
(required)


imageArchives


imageBlog Roll