Think Progress

Rep. Cao Succumbs To GOP Arm-Twisting

By Faiz Shakir on Feb 14th, 2009 at 2:30 pm

Rep. Cao Succumbs To GOP Arm-Twisting

cao.jpgEarlier this week, New Orleans’ freshman congressman Joseph Cao (R) stated that he would vote for the economic recovery package. “I believe that more likely than not, I will vote for it because the 2nd Congressional District needs a stimulus package,” he said. Even on the day of the vote, Cao was telling reporters that he was “leaning yes.”

When the vote occurred yesterday, Cao voted no, succumbing to the GOP’s pressure tactics. Politico reports:

Beforehand, Cao acknowledged that Republican leaders had put “pressure” on him to oppose the package, and the party’s chief deputy whip, California Rep. Kevin O. McCarthy, stood near Cao during the entire vote.

Rep. Eric Cantor (R-VA), the Republican whip, “said he had talked to Cao regularly, including the last 24 hours.” Cao emphasized that the leadership did not apply “extreme pressure,” however.

After flip-flopping, Cao couldn’t get his story straight. He claimed, “Personally I was always against the bill.” He also told the Times-Picayune that the Obama administration made little effort to court his vote, but he told The Hill, “There was a White House representative who came over to my office [on Thursday], specifically assigned to me.”

Norman Ornstein, a congressional scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, said Cao’s hopes for winning a second term depended on “people in the district identifying him as a thoroughly independent person who is not in the thrall of the Republican leadership. Now anyone running against him can say, ‘He’s a Republican mouthpiece.’”



159 Responses to “Rep. Cao Succumbs To GOP Arm-Twisting”

  1. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    Rep. Cao Succumbs To GOP Arm-Twisting»

    Beforehand, Cao acknowledged that Republican leaders had put “pressure” on him to oppose the package, and the party’s chief deputy whip, California Rep. Kevin O. McCarthy, stood near Cao during the entire vote.
    ____________

    It was the horse’s head in his bed when he woke up that did it…


  2. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    I so look forward to the astonishing displays of tap-dancing the GOOPers will be doing as they accept the stimulus money on behalf of their districts WHILST continuing to decry all that wasteful pork…


  3. ralph the wonder llama says:

    Rep. Eric Cantor (R-VA), the Republican whip, “said he had talked to Cao regularly, including the last 24 hours.” Cao emphasized that the leadership did not apply “extreme pressure,” however.

    I guess that means they stopped short of slicing his testicles.


  4. Little Freep Goofballs says:

    One could say that McCarthy “Cao-ed” him.


  5. Buford says:

    Party before country… no surprise here.


  6. Wayne A. Schneider says:

    benmaller,

    Why don’t you try to understand what this site is about before posting meaningless drivel like that.


  7. had enough says:

    so typical of Gopigs lying to their constituents for votes but at the same time, voting for party/lobbyists interest.


  8. Mathazar says:

    Ralph, they didn’t have to, he needs to grow a pair first.


  9. Jane E. Schneider says:

    I don’t know if having Eric Cantor talk to me for 24 hours would make me change my vote, but it sure would make me long to be deaf. Or dead.


  10. nycbassist says:

    I hope Obama is taking names. It’s time that the country knows who is standing in the way, when 2010 comes around.


  11. grover nerdkissed says:

    Cao emphasized that the leadership did not apply “extreme pressure,” however.

    whats “extreme pressure”, waterboarding?


  12. Alecto says:

    Fromt he “Extreme Pressure” link
    “When that moment arrived Friday, he concluded that there was not enough in the bill for infrastructure, for education, and for genuinely stimulative projects to justify eschewing his basic frugality.”

    So, he felt it should have been LARGER. More spent! But, but, that is not what the GOOPERS were saying.


  13. Alecto says:

    Jane E. Schneider Says:

    I don’t know if having Eric Cantor talk to me for 24 hours would make me change my vote, but it sure would make me long to be deaf. Or dead.

    It would make me rip off my ears.


  14. Jane E. Schneider says:

    Alecto, good point. (And I see you made the same typo that I always make, attaching the ‘t’ in ‘the’ to the end of the previous word. Glad it’s not just me.)


  15. Jane E. Schneider says:

    Oops, Alecto, my ‘good point’ was for #13, but you also have a point at #14. ;-)


  16. Sahu says:

    What’s really troubling to me is Ornstein’s analysis: It’s spot on, and that’s the weird part.

    Take that, combined with Yglesias’ report of one of Norm’s fellow AEI hacks backing bank nationalization, and I’m beginning to wonder if I’m suddenly in bizarro world.

    Since when did anyone at AEI talk sense?


  17. Jane E. Schneider says:

    Hey, my smile fell off my winky face!


  18. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    Jane E. Schneider Says:

    Oops, Alecto, my ‘good point’ was for #13, but you also have a point at #14. ;-)
    ___________

    Nice, Jane…

    ***tap… tap…***

    Smoke all my dope then run off…


  19. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    benmaller Says:
    ___________

    Somebody’s feeling sorry for themselves… ;-)…


  20. Michael Lafferty says:

    It’s truly amazing—and, rather appalling—that the minority leadership of both houses of Congress are able to hold the feet of their members to the fire as they march lockstep off the cliff and into their long walk in the desert.

    It’s truly reminiscent of a political ‘Jonestown’ or equivalent mass suicide, where the true believers and sympathizers hang together in their pathetic effort to exert some control—any control—over an outcome.

    All for one, and one for all! And, all for naught. Sad…


  21. Jane E. Schneider says:

    TRoS, that was all of it?


  22. McWars says:

    benmaller

    Don’t worry about the messiah, just Go Shopping ™!


  23. Old Goat says:

    benmaller says:

    FUnny how the breaking news of Obamaran’s “skillfully planned, highly surgical strike on the “evil doers” in Pakistan hasn’t been posted on TP with flashing lights and sirens by Faiz yet. Are we still waiting for the talking points from the Messiah?

    Sheesh, “talking points” “phantom earmarks”, these are not words we are familiar with. You assume our behavior is like your behavior. G’wan… crawl off to your cave.


  24. DutchHenry says:

    Cao’s district perhaps more than most need “stimulus help” & he votes against helping his community.Now why in the world would the people in his district re-elect this “ungrateful” tool.The ball is in his constituents court,kick him out come 2010.


  25. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    Jane E. Schneider Says:

    TRoS, that was all of it?
    _________

    Well… YOU could always bring some too, ya know…

    Uh, Jane… don’t look know, but Wayne just showed up wearing a tiara…

    Wayne? Is there sumpin’ you’d like to tell us all?


  26. Kid Charlemagne says:

    If any of these politicians voted against the Recovery Plan, then maybe they shouldn’t take any of the money for their district or state.


  27. Wayne A. Schneider says:

    You don’t see me sitting here making fun of your tiara, TRoS.


  28. Jane E. Schneider says:

    Alright, TRoS, I’ll contribute a little something, too. And maybe Wayne couldn’t find his own medals? I want a sparkly tiara, too!


  29. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    Kid Charlemagne Says:

    If any of these politicians voted against the Recovery Plan, then maybe they shouldn’t take any of the money for their district or state.
    _________

    My point EXACTLY… so… how’s the HRE doin’ these days?


  30. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    Wayne A. Schneider Says:

    You don’t see me sitting here making fun of your tiara, TRoS.
    ____________

    Dang… did I forget to take it off?

    No wonder folks bin starin’ at me… at least I hope that;s the only reason…

    Sheesh… whatever that got over on that party thread… the silliness seems to be spreading.


  31. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    Jane E. Schneider Says:

    I want a sparkly tiara, too!
    __________

    Oh great… now they’re going to start fighting over the tiara…

    Wayne… just let her wear the ruby slippers… at least for today, m’kay?


  32. curious says:

    What a guy. For the sake of his party he threw his own constituents under the bus. What backbone, what a conscience. This man is the perfect Republican tool. He is the picture of an idiot and the frame looks good on him.

    I love the picture of someone standing by him during the vote, just in case a moment of courage should overcome his party’s pressure. Not to worry. I hope his stupid constituents remember this congressman’s caving in.


  33. Jane E. Schneider says:

    TRoS, I think we’re staring ’cause your tiara clashes with your pajamas.


  34. dixie blood says:

    Does anyone need further proof that the RePugniScum party is the new Mafia?

    RePugniScums = Gangsters!


  35. Wayne A. Schneider says:

    No wonder folks bin starin’ at me… at least I hope that;s the only reason…

    Yeah, I hate it when the other drivers stare at me, too.


  36. McWars says:

    The GOP milked the Cao for all it’s worth.


  37. dbearton says:

    Vote the RepubliCon sheeple out. Are these stooges unable to think for themselves!


  38. Bozo The Neoclown says:

    apparently “the party of ideas” has turned into “the party of coercion, led by a billovating, impotent, drug addicted comedian.


  39. iamwhoiam says:

    I’m surprised he didn’t find horse head in his bed.


  40. Uncle Fester Lurks says:

    The party of fear, lies and intimidation live on. This seems to answer my question from the previous thread about the possible reasons why republican Judd Gregg withdrew his name as Secretary of Commerce. First he withdraws his name and then he announces he will not seek re-election in 2010. Interesting, very interesting.

    By the way, I’ve read that one of Gregg’s staffers was being investigated for receiving tickets to hockey and baseball games from some lobbyists and this same staffer is under invetigation for involvement with the infamous Jack Abramoff. Gregg himself has been told he isn’t under investigation but it really makes me wonder what really made him change his mind and decide to retire from politics.


  41. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    iamwhoiam Says:

    I’m surprised he didn’t find horse head in his bed.
    _____________

    See Comment 1.


  42. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    Gotta go out for a while.

    I’m trusting you guys to not trash the place completely while I’m gone.

    Just ask yourselves… if I (You) were TROS… would I (You) do that?

    After nodding yes and giggling to yerself… PLEASE DO THE OPPOSITE.


  43. WAYNEBRO says:

    Well no wonder he wanted to vote against it. After his republican buddies bartered it down to the somewhat ineffectual bill we have now I’d probably not have voted for it either. Not without putting back some of the stuff they took out, and getting rid of the wasteful nonsense.

    Like this from AP.

    Millions of workers can expect to see about $13 extra in their weekly paychecks, starting around June, from a new $400 tax credit to be doled out through the rest of the year. Couples would get up to $800. In 2010, the credit would be about $7.70 a week, if it is spread over the entire year.

    Wow.

    13 dollars a week.

    Man you can eat good on that, huh?

    What a windfall.

    With that 13 bucks a week in our pockets at least we will have some pocket change to buy ourselves a cup of coffee once a day at the McDonalds while we’re standing on the street corners with our “Will Work for Food” signs.


  44. WAYNEBRO says:

    How many billions of our borrowed tax dollars did it cost to give us all that whopping 13 bucks a week I wonder?

    I’ll be looking for Geitners new book, “How I turned a 100 Billion in cash into 13 bucks a week”.


  45. Cats r Flyfishn says:

    How very disappointing. Cao turned out to be a coward along with the rest of the Republican cowards. After the 2nd District learns that Cao put politics before the people that he represents, he will be a one term congressman.


  46. Alecto says:

    Michael Lafferty Says:

    It’s truly amazing—and, rather appalling—that the minority leadership of both houses of Congress are able to hold the feet of their members to the fire as they march lockstep off the cliff and into their long walk in the desert.

    It’s truly reminiscent of a political ‘Jonestown’ or equivalent mass suicide, where the true believers and sympathizers hang together in their pathetic effort to exert some control—any control—over an outcome.

    All for one, and one for all! And, all for naught. Sad…

    It is like I said in another thread, the Repulicons cannot even fathom reality. They think they can just conger up a reality like Rove depicted, and we will be forced to live in their reality.

    HELLLLOOOO Republitraitors, we won, get with the program. The line to shake President Obama’s hand starts here. Make sure you address him as PRESIDENT Obama.

    Reality is not always what you have planned.


  47. McWars says:

    TRoS, trash the place? Oh, the irony, look at all those dirty diapers left behind. YOU cut-and-run and leave us the mess to clean.

    Have you no shame, sir?


  48. katy says:

    ok Cao (how to pronounce that?)… those kudos i sent your way yesterday? never mind. chump.
    .

    … Norman Ornstein… haven’t heard from him since the old al franken radio days… always thought he was very reasonable and smart… the kind of republican i remember my dad and his group were…

    norman should’ve been a lot louder all these years…


  49. WAYNEBRO says:

    Every American should be outraged at this waste of money with this 13 dollars a week dole. It’s like a CHILDS ALLOWANCE! Heck most middle class kids get 20. 13 bucks? It’s an insult. As if it would make any difference to anyone other than a homeless person.

    The 100 billion or more that it cost out of the package to offer this nonsense tax rebate could have been put to good use. Like backing home mortgages or building infrastructure.
    Or better yet, putting back that 15,000 dollar tax credit for home buying. That’d actually do something, by getting middle class families to feel better about buying homes since the 15 k just happens to be the typical closing costs on a median priced home.

    But dividing it up into such a tiny, insignificant amount is stupid. Criminally stupid. And it disturbs me that no on is speaking up about it. 13 dollars a week won’t do anything other than waste billions, perhaps hundreds of billions of our tax dollars.

    If they want to give a tax rebate to workers then fine. Make it something that counts. 1500. 2500. That’d make a difference.

    13 bucks a week is the worst example of stupidity as I have ever seen.


  50. Vincennes says:

    the party’s chief deputy whip, California Rep. Kevin O. McCarthy, stood near Cao during the entire vote.

    Wow, that’s really creepy.


  51. Game of Life says:

    It’s impossible to work with these asholes.

    repug idiots come in all ethnicity. repugs will have one from each group just for show. It will be hard for them to find them though. Most people of color don’t like to be degraded and humiliated, especially for nothing.

    cao/steele when are y’all gonna visit Moonshine, Mississippi?

    HAHAHAHAHA

    repugs haven’t figured it out yet we don’t need their stinkin obstructionist votes.

    Try doing what is right repugs!


  52. Alixman984 says:

    Could one of you kindly explain to me what exactly is “extreme pressure“?

    Did the poor guy expected to be waterboarded?


  53. Constant Weader says:

    It wasn’t even arm-twisting. According to the Politico story, the party’s chief deputy whip “stood near Cao during the entire vote.” Sounds more like Mafia-style “encouragement” to me. Wonder if Cao will join with other Republicans who voted against the bill & our now singing its praises in their districts (without mentioning their ‘nay’ vote, of course.

    I hope in all the science stuff there’s supposed to be in the stimulus bill there’s a grant for finding the ‘Republican’ gene & eradicating it.

    The Constant Weader at http://www.RealityChex.com


  54. Bozo The Neoclown says:

    “the party’s chief deputy whip “stood near Cao during the entire vote.”
    sounds like someone was a candidate for a beat-down on the floor of the house if he voted the wrong way.


  55. fergus says:

    McCarthy had to stand close during the vote. He had Caos nuts in his fist. Cao knew that there would be some extreme pressure if he voted “yea” on the bill. It was a choice of conscience or crushed nuts. Conscience lost.


  56. Game of Life says:

    Haven’t these dumbass repugs realized yet, they are blamed for the economic crisis and are being blamed for preventing needed aid to help restore our economy?

    It’s sad that the repugs want to stuff their failed policies down our throats. and wish to hold the weak, poor, sick and the challenged hostage.

    It’s laughable that they put a restraint on any thing. For 8 long yrs we put up with their spending sprees, while never paying their fair share in taxes.


  57. Wayne A. Schneider says:

    Beforehand, Cao acknowledged that Republican leaders had put “pressure” on him to oppose the package, and the party’s chief deputy whip, California Rep. Kevin O. McCarthy, stood near Cao during the entire vote.

    And Mark Foley was standing next to Cao’s son.


  58. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    McWars Says:

    Have you no shame, sir?
    _____________

    I’m surprised you even need to ask that question…

    HEY!! You!!! That fire extinguisher is NOT a toy!


  59. Game of Life says:

    How much more proof do we need to prove these buttdrips want a one world order?

    Look at what they have done and is doing to their very own stinkin party. A bunch of warmongering nastyass vampires.

    repugs are arrogant sore losers


  60. tokin librul says:

    “Now anyone running against him can say, ‘He’s a Republican mouthpiece.’”

    Why do you think that’s gonna hurt him? He ran as a Puke, and won handily. They don’t value independence much among their pols down along the bayou…


  61. Fox News Alert says:

    By putting the screws to Cao, Eric Cantor insures that the GOP remains a monolith of obedience, greed, and stupidity.


  62. tokin librul says:

    Haven’t these dumbass repugs realized yet, they are blamed for the economic crisis and are being blamed for preventing needed aid to help restore our economy?

    Who’s blaming them? you and me, mebbe…but I don’t see it in the press or the news shows. For them, history began yesterday..


  63. tokin librul says:

    I wish the Dims had had the stones to include language in the bill stipulating that no economic srimulus aid would be spent in districts whose representatives voted against it…

    gutless phuques would never do it. But it would have been instructive…


  64. Bullsmith says:

    Look if the Republicans want to succeed as fascists they’re going to have to pick a dictator.


  65. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    Bullsmith Says:

    Look if the Republicans want to succeed as fascists they’re going to have to pick a dictator.
    ____________

    They had one. Didn’t work out too well.


  66. backup says:

    tokin. If they didn’t get the money, would they avoid the obligation to pay it back?


  67. McWars says:

    backup Says:
    tokin. If they didn’t get the money, would they avoid the obligation to pay it back?

    Just what is that supposed to mean….backup?


  68. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    backup Says:

    tokin. If they didn’t get the money, would they avoid the obligation to pay it back?
    ______________

    Sure… if they want to assume all obligation for Botch’s deficits…


  69. SKdeA says:

    I mean, there’s no news in being another cowardly R.


  70. SKdeA says:

    Cao just missed his chance to be votable. Picked the LOSING side. Hey, CAo, switch parties! If you really want a future as a politician, you have to make some news here.


  71. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    We’ll trade ya clean up for that, captain…

    And no more Red State welfare.

    I’m tired of supporting a bunch of delusional evangelicals living in doublewides.


  72. SKdeA says:

    Does anyone else have the problem of your posts showing in reverse order?


  73. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    Gee… where’d b-cup go?


  74. backup says:

    Republic. This idea that you can use federal taxpayer money and only use it for those that support it, is ridiculous.

    How bout this. Everybody that supports stimulus pitch in.


  75. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    Capt?

    Where’d you go?

    We’ll take that deal… we’ll assume the stimulus package debt if you’ll assume Botch’s endless deficits. And no more Red State welfare…

    You can have Alabama, Mississippi, Georgia, & Okalhoma ALL TO YOURSELVES…


  76. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    backup Says:

    Republic. This idea that you can use federal taxpayer money and only use it for those that support it, is ridiculous.
    __________

    But… but… that was YOUR offer!

    If the states willingly refuse that money, they don’t have to pay for it?

    Then why do we, in the blue states have to pay for their leeching Cheneys?

    I didn’t vote for Botch’s misguided blood-soaked adventure in South Asia… why should I have to pay for it? You broke it, you buy it.

    Fair is fair.


  77. Leftside Annie says:

    Got to make sure the new kid toes the line. God forbid any Repuke should be allowed to make up his or her own mind or vote their conscience (that is, even if they actually have one).


  78. katy says:

    SKdeA Says:
    Does anyone else have the problem of your posts showing in reverse order?

    it happens occasionally… some call int time travel…
    i finally figured out what they were talking about…


  79. backup says:

    Republic. Maybe you’re more of a conservative than I am.

    So, you’re saying that whoever funds the police and fire departments (with tax money) should be the only ones they service?

    What about those that can’t afford to pay taxes?

    Should those people be denied emergency care at the hospital? They didn’t help fund it.


  80. backup says:

    Republic. For those progressives that oppose nuclear energy, big oil, clean coal – you get the idea; should they have to pay more for their electricity than someone who doesn’t?

    Maybe you’re on to something.


  81. bexarblue says:

    Doing a crossword here. What’s a four letter word for a Republican from Louisiana? Starts with L.


  82. backup says:

  83. Max-1 says:

    .

    It’s not arm twisting…
    … That’s called LOYALISM!

    .


  84. backup says:

    my bad. long was a democrat


  85. backup says:

    maybe lone. because there aren’t many republicans.


  86. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    backup Says:

    Republic. Maybe you’re more of a conservative than I am.
    ___________

    Geez, b-cup. I’m disappointed in you.
    ___________

    backup Says:

    If they didn’t get the money, would they avoid the obligation to pay it back?
    ___________

    Those are YOUR words. How they not get the money?

    Several of us have wondered here if the GOOPer Congresscritters who were so opposed to the stimulus bill would stick to their principles and refuse the money. Tokin wondered if language should be inserted in the bill to deny money to those that voted against it.

    You wondered if they should have to pay for it if they don’t.

    I agreed w/ you. I VOTED AGAINST Botch, both times. Why should I have to pay for his horrifically stupid miscalculations?

    What’s good for the goose is good for the gander, b-cup.

    Will the GOOPers who were so opposed to the stimulus stick to their principles and refuse the money?


  87. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    bexarblue Says:

    Doing a crossword here. What’s a four letter word for a Republican from Louisiana? Starts with L.
    ________________

    I’d suggest “welfare LEeCH” but that’s too many letters… heh…

    But then, the hum skooled prolly cain’t count that high anyways…


  88. backup says:

    Republic. The problem is you can’t separate the benefit from the cost. We have a system. We have a president and a congress. The idea for stimulus comes up. People can be for it or against it. But, if it passes, it will be all of our money (not just those that supported it) and it will be all our benefit or loss.

    The same thing with Bush and the war. We elected him. You can disagree, but in the end it’s all our money that’s paying for it and it’s all our benefit or loss.

    The stimulus may work or it may not. But, because we have the system we have, the idea that you could somehow segregate those that support the bill from those that don’t isn’t realistic, more importantly, it’s not possible.

    We elected Bush. We elected Obama. Here we are.


  89. backup says:

    There is apparently at least one republican Long:

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerald_Long


  90. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    backup Says:

    The idea for stimulus comes up. People can be for it or against it. But, if it passes, it will be all of our money (not just those that supported it) and it will be all our benefit or loss.
    ________

    Astonishing, b-cup. I’ve always suspected you were a bit of a fraud, but this is an eye popper.

    You’re arguing against your own words… and now, somehow, I SAID THEM.

    Yuo said, if they don’t get the money, do they have to assume the obligation?

    Were you not arguing this position?

    Di I need to go cut and paste your comment again?

    I AGREED w/ you. I said no, they don’t.

    And if they don’t have to pay to back, why should I pay back Botch’s war debt?

    Will the GOOPers who voted AGAINST the stimulus bill do the right thing and refuse to take the money? Wouldn’t that be true to their principles?

    When they’re busy handing out the red state welfare checks will they remind the red state leeches, “Remember, I didn’t want you to get this… make sure you blame the Libruls… and feel free to shoot a couple, like Jim Adkisson…”

    Just asking, b-cup. You seem a little confused today.


  91. backup says:

    Republic. I think your stereotype of home schoolers may be off. Here’s some information on it. (I couldn’t figure out how to put it in a link, but then again, I went to public school).

    Summary of Major Findings

    Major findings: Demographics

    Home school parents have more formal education than parents in the general population; 88% continued their education beyond high school compared to 50% for the nation as a whole.
    The median income for home school families ($52,000) is significantly higher than that of all families with children ($36,000) in the United States.
    Almost all home school students (98%) are in married couple families. Most home school mothers (77%) do not participate in the labor force; almost all home school fathers (98%) do work.
    Home school students watch much less television than students nationwide; 65% of home school students watch one hour or less per day compared to 25% nationally.
    The median amount of money spent annually on educational materials is about $400 per home school student.
    The distribution of home school students by grade in grades 1-6 is consistent with that of all school children. Proportionally fewer home school students are enrolled at the high school level.
    Major findings: Achievement

    Almost 25% of home school students are enrolled one or more grades above their age-level peers in public and private schools.
    Home school student achievement test scores are exceptionally high. The median scores for every subtest at every grade (typically in the 70th to 80th percentile) are well above those of public and Catholic/Private school students.
    On average, home school students in grades 1 to 4 perform one grade level above their age-level public/private school peers on achievement tests.
    The achievement test score gap between home school students and public/private school students starts to widen in grade 5.
    Students who have been home schooled their entire academic life have higher scholastic achievement test scores than students who have also attended other educational programs.
    There are no meaningful differences in achievement by gender, whether the student is enrolled in a full-service curriculum, or whether a parent holds a state issued teaching certificate.
    There are significant achievement differences among home school students when classified by amount of money spent on education, family income, parent education, and television viewing.

    http://epaa.asu.edu/epaa/v7n8/


  92. burro says:

    Yum. How do you like the taste of that Kool-Aid Joey? You better start liking it because you’re going to be drowning in the stuff.

    You’re going to be waterboarded with RepubCo Kool-Aid Joey! But it ain’t torture Joey. It’s just bidness in Repubworld. Persuasion. Not torture. Keep that in mind Joey. It’ll make it all easier to take.


  93. wiley says:

  94. backup says:

    I was responding to this around #64.

    tokin librul Says:
    I wish the Dims had had the stones to include language in the bill stipulating that no economic srimulus aid would be spent in districts whose representatives voted against it…

    This sentiment comes up all the time. If you want to deny those representatives funding from the stimulus, how would you ensure they (or their constituents) would not bear the responsibility to repay the money?

    I understand the argument that those that opposed Bush would rather not pay for his mistakes.

    My point (regardless of how poorly I made it) is our system doesn’t work like that. We have a representative republic. We all get a voice and the representatives in the majority decide what to do.

    But, we all get a voice. And the idea that just because a representative disagrees, doesn’t mean they are then somehow disenfranchised.

    Imagine if the representatives from California opposed the war in Iraq and the administration decided to pull all federal military and homeland security assets out of California?

    Doesn’t make sense to me.


  95. rimhotep says:

    Blackmail is a bi*ch, isn’t it?


  96. Jackie says:

    Be careful what you wish for!!! Now Cao is in a corner and he will have to prove he’s working for the voter again. He was honest when he was elected but we see even a good honest man can be entrapped. I wish him luck but he just might be a one term Rep.


  97. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    backup Says:

    This sentiment comes up all the time. If you want to deny those representatives funding from the stimulus, how would you ensure they (or their constituents) would not bear the responsibility to repay the money?
    ___________

    ‘Course, those red state welfare leeches constantly complain having to pay for other people’s libraries, other people’s kids going to school, other people’s medical bills. You’d think it was THEIR money they’re spending.
    ___________

    But, we all get a voice. And the idea that just because a representative disagrees, doesn’t mean they are then somehow disenfranchised.
    ___________

    Gee, b-cup… all I did was wonder if the GOOPers who voted against the stimulus would DO THE PRINCIPLED THING and turn down the money. Or will they remind their Bible-thumping, evangelical welfare leeching constituents, “Hey… I voted against this. I don’t think you should get this money.’
    ___________

    Imagine if the representatives from California opposed the war in Iraq and the administration decided to pull all federal military and homeland security assets out of California?

    Doesn’t make sense to me.
    ____________

    Makes sense to me. ON its own, california is the world’s 8th largest economy. We always pay more into the Fed than we get back. I’m so tired of supporting red state welfare leeches.


  98. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    Oh, BTW, didn’t Dild O’Rally wish on air that teh terraists would attack California because we were opposed to the Iraq War”?

    Thu, Nov 10, 2005 1:00pm

    O’Reilly to San Francisco: “[I]f Al Qaeda comes in here and blows you up, we’re not going to do anything about it. … You want to blow up the Coit Tower? Go ahead”

    http://mediamatters.org/items/200511100008

    Heh… that Dild… he DID say something very much like that.

    Funny… I don’t recall many righties telling him he was wrong.

    Did you, b-cup? Just asking…


  99. backup says:

    Republic. What O’Reilly said was wrong.

    I agree. But, that makes the point doesn’t it?

    We are in this together. If someone doesn’t think the stimulus is a good idea, his district should be denied funding? Really?


  100. Hoodathunk says:

    Totally backup. If anyone thinks the stimulus program is bad they just have to walk away. Be sure you ask before you drive on a repaved road this summer.


  101. backup says:

    so, hoodathunk, you’re agreeing with O’Reilly? Those that oppose defense initiatives should be denied defense?


  102. ralph the wonder llama says:

    backup Says:
    so, hoodathunk, you’re agreeing with O’Reilly? Those that oppose defense initiatives should be denied defense?

    If I may, Hoodathunk…?

    I think you’re confusing things needlessly, b-cup.

    You’re trying to say that Hoodathunk or TRoS or anyone else here would like to DENY benefits of the stimulus package to those who voted against it.

    In fact, they are saying that those who voted against it should have the integrity to refuse those benefits themselves.

    You see the difference? You, like most conservatives immediately assume that we call for government responsibility for everything, even when we’re calling for personal responsibility.


  103. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    ralph the wonder llama Says:

    You see the difference? You, like most conservatives immediately assume that we call for government responsibility for everything, even when we’re calling for personal responsibility.
    ____________

    Nicely put, ralph. That’s a slippery issue. It’s all in the wording, no?

    Considering just how totally opposed GOOPers were to the stimulus package, one can’t help but wonder if they will stick to their principles and refuse to accept any of the money.

    Or will they make sure they tell their constituents, “Remember… I voted against making this money available to you… but it’s still the Libruls’ fault… feel free to go shoot some… especially unarmed women in church.”

    But given that red states have been getting more from the Fed than they pay in for DECADES now, I’m betting a solid NO on that one.

    I’d be curious to know if b-cup condemned O’Rally for his comment at the time.

    What you say, b-cup? Thumbs up… or down?


  104. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    My bad, b-cup… I didn’t see your comment agreeing w/ me on O’Reilly.


  105. Hoodathunk says:

    Thank you Ralph. You said it much nicer than I would have. My response would have been…no, moron what I said in a very sarcastic manner was, if you don’t like the idea that American money is being spent in America, walk in the ditch.


  106. backup says:

    In fact, they are saying that those who voted against it should have the integrity to refuse those benefits themselves.

    ralph. I see the point. But, the problem with the logic is that we, collectively, will be responsible for paying back the money.


  107. backup says:

    I’ll try it this way:

    We’re all members of a club. The end of year we’re going to take a group trip. Most people want to go to Disneyland, but some don’t.

    Regardless of who goes, we’re going to spend all the dues on the trip.

    The ones that didn’t want Disneyland should be excluded from the trip; just because they spoke up?

    Once we make up our minds, let’s all go to Disneyland. Together.


  108. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    backup Says:

    In fact, they are saying that those who voted against it should have the integrity to refuse those benefits themselves.

    ralph. I see the point. But, the problem with the logic is that we, collectively, will be responsible for paying back the money.
    ___________

    Right back where we were before.

    If righties don’t want to take that filthy, tainted lucre, they don’t have to.

    I for one, will gladly release them from their obligation to pay it back… and in turn, since I didn’t vote for Botch’s endless fiascos, I shouldn’t have to pay for them either. Fair is fair.

    Or keep shelling out to support red state welfare leeches.

    Can’t have it both ways, captain.


  109. 08Dariana says:

    backup Says:

    We get your point but you’re not getting ours you’re fighting your own ARGUMENT.

    67
    backup Says:
    ——————————————————————————–

    tokin. If they didn’t get the money, would they avoid the obligation to pay it back?


  110. Kllwhity says:

    I say propping up failing companies and bailing out fraudulant lending banks with taxpayers money is going to be a huge problem that this country cant handle.Let them fail.Let well run companies take over.Dont point your fingers at the GOP for the failures brought on by the Clinton era.Remember that we ALL have to pay for those wonderfull boom years that were all a borrowed party!!!


  111. backup says:

    It’s impossible to separate an initiative paid by the federal treasury into those that pay and those that benefit.

    We have a government, led by representatives. Everybody’s got a voice. The decisions will be made by the majority.

    If a representative disagrees with the stimulus, there is no way exempt his district from funding it. It’s being funded from the federal treasury. In part, by the people that live in his district.

    If his constituents are going to help pay for it, why would he refuse the stimulus money?


  112. Kllwhity says:

    Pelosi thinks a peanut butter and jelly sandwich will stimulate the economy,so line up and vote for that PB&J!!!
    Even die hard Dems know this is a piniada full of aimless spending that will cripple this country for decades.Call me what you will,but I will stick to my opposition of this plan and this President if he continues on his puppet strings.It is clearly transparent that he is passing out the paychecks to the engines that got him there!


  113. LiberalVoter says:

    Kllwhity, lay off the cheap rotgut, it has affected your brain. And find a better rant than blaming Clinton. That is so passe. Do you still use dial-up? Try hanging out at the library rather than redstate.org. It may not be too late for you if you act now.


  114. Hoodathunk says:

    There is obviously no cure for terminal stupidity.


  115. Kllwhity says:

    If you made a 34,000 dollar mistake on YOUR taxes,you would be in jail!!!! Dems think it makes you more qualified!!
    Maybe when it comes time to pay back the stinkulis,Gietner will just act like we forgot we owed it!!


  116. LiberalVoter says:

    If you made a 34,000 dollar mistake on YOUR taxes,you would be in jail!!!!

    As should 90% of the Republicans in Congress.


  117. Kllwhity says:

    I call a spade a spade and then you call ME stupid! That makes sense! Of course they leaned on him to vote no. And he will be glad he did when the smoke clears and all the DEms have spent themselves out of Washington.I will want to hear from you all when we all have to pay this embezellment back.Nothing stimulates consumer spending like a huge bill ahead!!!


  118. alpuz3 says:

    oh, kilwhity… keep on keeping on, brother.


  119. LiberalVoter says:

    Well, since the Republicans have sprayed TRILLIONS of dollars, the Democrats will have to hold some night sessions to catch up. One good thing is at least the Democrats are spending it on Americans in need rather than the to 1% war profiteers. Do you actually believe the Republicans give a flying crap about you other than the money they can bleed out of you and the rights they can take away? So yes, I can believe Hoodathunk called you stupid,and was being kind as well.


  120. Kllwhity says:

    As should 90% of the Republicans in Congress.
    And that is how you justify hiring a crook!! Well,he is surrounded by crooks,so he’ll do fine.I for one am tired of letting crooks in both parties run the show.The lessor of two evils?
    How about no evils!!
    Well,I guess sheep will always be sheep.
    You will never hear me say “Bahh!!”
    Arod For President!!!!!


  121. LiberalVoter says:

    Well, Republicans wrote the book on hiring crooks. Do you really want to go there? Take a deep breath and think, if that is not too difficult for you.


  122. The Republic of Stupidity says:

    Kllwhity Says:

    Dont point your fingers at the GOP for the failures brought on by the Clinton era.
    ________

    Ya mean, that budget surplus and the 22 million jobs created?
    ________

    “kllwhity”… wow.. that’s clever… “kill whity”… saaaay, is this gopny back under a different name?


  123. Leftside Annie says:

    So, kll – where were you when Bush was making America his bendover boy, eh?


  124. Kllwhity says:

    Yeah ,I know. I’m stupid.I’m a drunk.Yep funny funny.I guess it makes you feel good to call me stupid.If it stimulates you,go ahead.
    See,I own my home.I own a business.I am married and have three beautiful children.And before you start spewing “life of priviledge” I came from a single parent family with two siblings.(NO welfare thank you!) I have done for me and mine!
    So call me names. I will take it from the source.
    just dont expect me to sit quietly while this REGIME flushes my country and my childrens future down the toilet.


  125. Kllwhity says:

    As for my user name,dont read into it to much.I am not racist.
    But we do live in an age “Where White Will Embrace What Is Right” Or did we forget that already.


  126. LiberalVoter says:

    Who is spewing ‘life of priviledge’? And where were you for the past 8 year while that REGIME flushed OUR country down the toilet? A bit of tunnel vision there, you might want to get out more.


  127. LiberalVoter says:

    Don’t read too much into your user name? How clueless are you?


  128. alpuz3 says:

    oh, kilwhity… you are what you is. No one has forgotten nothing, sport.


  129. Xisithrus says:

    just dont expect me to sit quietly while this REGIME flushes my country and my childrens future down the toilet. -=KW=-

    Have you forgotten that these stimulus and bailout packages started under the Bush administration?

    Have you forgotten that under that same admin that the banksters were promised some 5.7 trillion in assistance that was not voted on?

    The money will probably be printed into existence because the government and the banks are basically all insolvent?


  130. Kllwhity says:

    Yep, and the Clinton administration didn’t christen the ship that is subprime mortgage? I guess we as Americans owe it to everyone who cant afford their mortgages, to pay it for them.Poor have the right to own,minorities have the right to own,illegals have the right to own.
    Wrong!!! they have the right to earn,THEN OWN!!!
    If you cant afford it! Dont buy it!
    Argue all you want,The Clinton Admin, created it and the Bush admin, looked the other way.
    So why should we be bailing out banks again? Or borrowing money we dont have?
    But what do I know,I’m stupid.


  131. LiberalVoter says:

    Is that the same Clinton administration where the Republicans had the majority in the House and Senate from 1994 and until 2006 when it was a wash and then in 2008 where the American people sent an even stronger message the Republicans are out of favor, to be polite?


  132. alpuz3 says:

    Yo, whity… you’re not only stupid, you don’t want to learn.
    Go on with your bad self, sport.


  133. Jess Wonderin says:

    kil . . . your posts do nothing . . . the rambin’ of a sloth ASLEEP for the past 8 YEARS and a head full of old Rush/Dobbs Reports (VERY OLD) . . . all really adds nothing but makes you feel good . . . glad for your “success”, NOW maybe you can spend some free time on CONTEMPORARY POLITICS and FACTS . . . .


  134. Kllwhity says:

    Ya mean, mean that budget surplus and the 22 million jobs created?
    How many of those jobs were empty tech jobs?
    How much of that so called surplus was overinflated market value and earnings?
    Roads do not get paved,houses do not get built, cars do not roll off the line when everyone is sitting behind a keyboard!
    Clinton era boom was a bust in the making and he left it for Bush.Granted Bush didn’t do much to fix it,but wait and see where we are in eight years.Bush will seem like a saint by then.


  135. alpuz3 says:

  136. JaneaneTheAcerbicGoblin says:

    Can you say “one term” congressman?

    This reminds me when Rostenkowski lost his seat in 1994 to Michael Flanagan, who was a Republican mouthpiece, and he lost the seat in 1996 (I think it was Rahm who won it if I remember right).


  137. Jess Wonderin says:

    Kil . . . ??? give it a break and STUDY some facts or take an economics class . . . maybe a CONTEMPORARY HISTORY one too


  138. LiberalVoter says:

    Thrashing a bit there Kllwhity? Try to follow the thread. Take your time. We can wait.


  139. Jess Wonderin says:

    naw, he’s a waste of time – goodng’t


  140. LiberalVoter says:

    Yeah, you’re right Jess. No matter how we try some types keep eating the pages out of the books. Sad. Later.


  141. Kllwhity says:

    And just for Ha Ha’s ,quote me were I have taken a side.
    You cant, because I never have.
    That is part of my arguement.
    How many of you are just going with it to go with it?
    This stimulis is bad for EVERYONE!!
    You cant tell me everyone on this board thinks this is the right thing to do.


  142. alpuz3 says:

    You would like to know what I think, Kllwhity?

    Welp, here goes. I think you’re one confused SOB. I think that for some strange reason you are blaming both Clinton and Obama and giving GWB a free pass. I think you’re a dum bass, I think you’re a fake and a fraud… I think you have nothing to offer to anyone, and you’re having one heck of a time digesting that.

    I think you don’t have a clue, never had a clue, and I’m willing to bet you never will have one.

    The times, they are a changin’, whity. You’re going to feel it… and it aint goin’ to feel good.

    Later, son.


  143. telestai2 says:

    Kllwhity Says:

    And just for Ha Ha’s ,quote me were I have taken a side.
    You cant, because I never have.
    That is part of my arguement.
    How many of you are just going with it to go with it?
    This stimulis is bad for EVERYONE!!
    You cant tell me everyone on this board thinks this is the right thing to do.

    We CAN tell you, however, that you cannot spell or use the English language appropriately. And we CAN tell you that most of the posters on this site actually have something to SAY, rather than indulging in the “nyah, nyah” school of expression.


  144. Bilbo Hussein Baggins says:

    Why would anyone with a conscience ever want to be a Republican’t politician knowing full well that they will not be able to vote their conscience without being threatened by their own party.

    I really despise the Blue Dog Democrats sometimes but at least they have the freedom to vote in any way they want without threat of retaliation by their party. Being a Democrat is rather messy, but at least it’s honest.


  145. Theresa says:

    We here in Elecorate Land have protections against voter intimidation; doesn’t Congress have the same thing?


  146. Kllwhity says:

    Welp, here goes. I think you’re one confused SOB. I think that for some strange reason you are blaming both Clinton and Obama and giving GWB a free pass. I think you’re a dum bass, I think you’re a fake and a fraud… I think you have nothing to offer to anyone, and you’re having one heck of a time digesting that.

    I think you don’t have a clue, never had a clue, and I’m willing to bet you never will have one.

    The times, they are a changin’, whity. You’re going to feel it… and it aint goin’ to feel good.

    Later, son.

    Once again, I hope you feel better hating on ME! That will get you far in this world.I will not resort to your brand of discussion.When you have no answer,you blindly throw out rude remarks towards the people who make you question yourself!
    I myself,know I have a clue.I dont have to answer to you.
    The thing that makes me uneasy is that it is people like you that are now in charge of fixing this huge problem.
    Good luck


  147. Kllwhity says:

    And by the way, I ain’t your son.
    Learn to address people with respect.It is the first thing you should learn on your long road to recovery.


  148. alpuz3 says:

    Yeah, that’s it wha whaa whity. You make me question myself.

    *chortle*

    Dig the name… good luck in your search for respect. Kllwhity.. whaa whaa wants respect.


  149. tombaker says:

    Somebody get poor Mr. Cao the Sopranos on dvd, so he can learn how his party operates.

    You don’t go against “the family”, Mr. Cao.


  150. Kllwhity says:

    That’s better than PEOPLE LIKE YOU – that CAUSED IT! See when people KNOW THINGS they can use SKILL and NOT LUCK like you do in the CASINO OF LIFE which you GO THROUGH IGNORANT and WITHOUT A CLUE!@

    Ok,If thats how you want it!!
    That Casino of life S#$T is funny!! I bet you have a poster of Kennedy the Meth addict on your wall!What you have been spoonfed is you deadbeat druggy parents hippy ideals that make you think that everybody has a right to their share of the pie.You gimme,gimme welfare state , handout Liberals make me sick to my stomach!You justify it all by saying We won, We won!!! You won nothing!!!!!! When you are wondering where all your SS went and your kids cant get jobs and they are eating all your oxycontin that you keep for your so called bad migraines,remember this. People who work and pay their bills,their Med Insurance,car payments,college funds,TAXES,and all the other bills that associated with a responsible life,owe you nothing! Your Messiah president is not going to save you or the world as he has promised.Get your grubby little WIC check fingers out of my hard earned pie,and get yourself a job ya sheep!!!
    I guess now I am starting to stoop to your level,so I will go now and feed my own children,which by the way ,do not have coat hanger marks on their necks!


  151. lvdragonlady says:

    He will just be one more puppet of the OLD MEN that have destroyed this country. If that is what he wants to be, so be it.


  152. alpuz3 says:

    That was a great rant, whity. Thanks for the entertainment.


  153. drew3rd says:

    This is news? A congressman voting along party lines? Our Democrat congressman has screwed our region time and time again voting the party line.


  154. Kllwhity says:

    No problem alpuss,I like nothing better than brightening ones day!


  155. alpuz3 says:

    alpuss?

    When i was around ten or so, the local bully got in my face and started calling me a pussy, or mixed the word “pussy” into my name in various ways. He went down w/out much of a fight. I still laugh about it to this day.

    Are you that 10 year old bully, whity?

    hmmmmmmmm… hard earned pie.


  156. Selkirk says:

    I can think of at least 6 reasons why Representative Cao chose to vote against the bill.


  157. drew3rd says:

    Thanks for the link Selkirk. That was interesting. I think we all know that this bill is a mess. That’s why 55-60% of Americans (depending on the poll) opposed this thing. The idea that Cao is a sellout is childish. Both parties adhere to party lines ALL the time.


  158. LiberalVoter says:

    Selkirk, drew3rd, nice parroting of right wing talking points. Do you still get the headaches when you try to think for yourselves? And how many TRILLION dollars did Bernanke spray around followed by almost another TRILLION Paulson gave out for executive bonuses and parties? If Bush and company had not been asleep at the wheel (or continuing to carry out their plan to bankrupt the country to the benefit of their friends) this stimulus package would not be needed. You burn the house down then blame the firemen. How pathetic.


  159. LiberalVoter says:

    Kllwhity Says: Learn to address people with respect.It is the first thing you should learn on your long road to recovery.

    Well, at least you are remembering what they are telling you in therapy. Now all you have to do is internalize it. Keep trying, you can do it if you do.



Jump to Top

About Think Progress | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2010 Center for American Progress Action Fund
View Most Popular

Advertisement

What We're About

Featured

image
Subscribe to the Progress Report



imageTopic Cloud


Visit Our Affiliated Sites

image image
Reports


Got a hot tip?
Have a hot news tip? We'd love to hear from you. Use the form below to send us the latest.

Name:
Email:
Tip:
(required)


imageArchives


imageBlog Roll