Think Progress

Goldberg falsely claims that DHS reports never “use the all-purpose term ‘left-wing.’”

Joining the chorus of conservative voices that are hyperventilating over the recently-leaked Department of Homeland Security report on “rightwing extremists,” National Review’s Jonah Goldberg wrote yesterday that though “DHS has done reports on anti-war, environmental, and other groups,” it was his “understanding is that they didn’t — and wouldn’t — use the all-purpose term ‘left-wing’ to describe those threats.” Later in the day, when a reader pointed him to an April 2001 DOE report titled “Left-Wing Extremism: The Current Threat,” Goldberg replied that he didn’t know of a report that “came out after 9/11.” But this too is wrong, considering the January 26, 2009 DHS report, “Leftwing Extremists Likely to Increase Use of Cyber Attacks over the Coming Decade.”



40 Responses to “Goldberg falsely claims that DHS reports never “use the all-purpose term ‘left-wing.’””

  1. raynman says:

    Ahhh, Jonah. Never met a fact that you couldn’t ignore or distort, could you?


  2. Mr. Evil says:

    Anything to foment fear.


  3. P.D. says:

    Poor Jonah. Living in denial. First several Conservatives knocked him for his support of Obama’s actions regarding the pirates. Now he is just delusional. Poor man.. He may need therapy.


  4. AIO grasshopper says:

    Wait a minute; Wasn’t Jonah’s mom supposed to be the smart one?


  5. Steppenwoof says:

    Jonah never has known his left from his right anyway. Especially since he tried to reclassify Hitler as left-wing?


  6. SKdeAnt says:

    And who cares what you think, Jonah?


  7. Zooey Lepidoptera says:

    This from the twit who wrote “Liberal Fascism.”

    D’oh!


  8. jjm says:

    J G is seriously undereducated and ill-informed. Why does he get any platform at all?


  9. ralph the wonder locust says:

    The Doughy Pantload strikes another blow for Right-Wing Reality®!

    (Note: “Right-Wing Reality® is a registered trademarked version of “reality” created by conservative pundits expressly for the purpose of “catapulting the propaganda” and popping up their approved agenda. It should not be confused with ordinary reality, nor should a member of the Reality-Based Community try to use it without qualified wingnut supervision.)


  10. Bobwurst says:

    Jonah, when was the last time a lefty went into a church and shot people because the wanted to kill conservatives? When was the last time a lefty shot three cops because he was mad that the president was going to take away his guns? When was the last time a lefty drove a truck bomb up to a federal building and blew it up?


  11. ralph the wonder locust says:

    I have a feeling it’s stunts like this that underlie NRO’s reluctance to allow comments.


  12. christopher wiwi says:

    Hey Jonah,Did you know that Lehman Brothers has a half million pounds of uranium power that they are sitting on and they got some bailout $$$$$$.just another Shill for the wealthy.



  13. paleolib says:

    Why precisely does Jonah the Whale want to take up the defense of the KKK, American Nazi Party and any number of secessionist and/or christian identity groups that have exhibted violent tendencies? Responsible progressives do not defend idiots who burn down laboratories to “save” the lab animals who end up dying in the blaze. Is it the paranoid delusion of the right wing mind that brings on this blather or does Jonah have skinhead connections he isn’t revealing?


  14. kasinca says:

    The DHS report never mentions republicans or conservatives either. It speaks of reichwingnut fringe organizations.


  15. Marie says:

    Another lie from the doughy pantload who exploits the likely fact that his audience never checks into his statements, but takes them as gospel.


  16. DNFP says:

    Lehman Brothers has a half million pounds of uranium

    I wonder what this has to do with the claim of “yellow cake” leading up to the Iraq invasion…

    Since when when have brokerage firms been allowed to purchase radioactive material?

    This is truly bizarre.


  17. DNFP says:

    Zooey Lepidoptera Says:

    Jonah Goldberg: Upper Class Twit of the Year

    I love the medal presentation!


  18. katydid says:

    getting legs:

    Right-wing groups ‘growing’ in US
    BBC News – ?20 minutes ago?
    By Jon Donnison America could be facing a surge in right-wing extremism, according to a new US government report. The Department of Homeland Security study says the election of America’s first black president and the economic slump has helped racist …
    ANDREA TANTAROS: Tea Parties — It’s Not Just About the Benjamins FOXNews
    Right-wing extremism may be on rise, report says CNN
    Kansas City Star – The Associated Press – msnbc.com – The Week Magazine
    all 541 news articles »

    http://news.google.com/news?pz=1&ncl=1332538855&topic=n

    do some clicking on the truthers and help it grow more…


  19. katydid says:

    on the ed schultz show, earlier:

    Eli Lake, National Security Correspondent for the Washington Times, joins the 1st hour of Wednesday’s show to discuss Department of Homeland Security sending out advisories about Right Wing Extremists.

    ed said that this guy “broke” the story about the report…

    huh?


  20. RUCeriousDragonfly says:

    Yes, this is Mr. RUC.

    That’s right, I’d like to order a whale.

    Thank you, yes, a very specific type of whale.

    Right, one big enough to swallow an idiot named Jonah.

    Friday?

    That’d be great! Thanks!



  21. Howard the Duck says:

    Rightwing Extremists are more of a threat than Islamic groups. I say let us free the Gitmo prisoners and send these reactionaries there instead.


  22. chiroptera toasterhead says:

    Howard the Duck Says:

    Rightwing Extremists are more of a threat than Islamic groups. I say let us free the Gitmo prisoners and send these reactionaries there instead.

    April 15th, 2009 at 1:28 pm
    ______________

    Piss off, Trajan. You aren’t fooling anyone.


  23. mk3872 says:

    No reason to worry about facts when you are repeating right-wing talking points.

    We all know that facts and figures have that inconvenient liberal bias.


  24. Megaloptera McWars says:

    Left-wing extremists likely to increase the use of cyber-attacks? Crack down on them, deter the threat. I welcome the report.

    Right-wing extremists, on the other hand, should receive special treatment and free diaper changes from DHS because their representative element, passed off as mainstream conservatism, cannot take even a line-item of criticism.

    Their ability to screw up big time is protected by “freedom” and any accountability is “tyranny”.


  25. DNFP says:

    Rightwing Extremists are more of a threat than Islamic groups.

    Nah, just on the same level, that’s all…


  26. chiroptera toasterhead says:

    I do find it interesting that left-wing terrorism manages to maintain a philosophy of protecting human and animal life, only inflicting damage on property. You certainly don’t see that attitude from right-wing terrorists.


  27. kasinca says:

    Jonah Goldberg is the reason I cancelled my subscription to the LAT several years ago. He is a worthless, steamy, pantload portraying a chickenhawk but has never even worn a uniform, much less heard an incoming round. Jonah has as much credibilty as his worthless mother.


  28. Joe Sixpack says:

    This from the asswipe who got his career start from his mommy, Lucianne Goldberg, who advised Linda Tripp to record her conversations with Monica Lewinsky and to save the dress. Of course, it helps that Jonah’s wife (Jessica Gavora)was the former chief speechwriter and a senior policy adviser for ex-Attorney General John Ashcroft.

    In truth, this guy is just another well-connected rightwing idiot, cashing in on his mommy and wifey’s accomplishments.


  29. RUCeriousDragonfly says:

    Where’s the whale I ordered!!


  30. Bill-SOCAL says:

    I cannot understand for the life of me how this guy became somebody that anybody listens to. Worse, he acts like he is some sort of respected scholar and people buy into it. I think Joe Sixpack nailed it above:

    “In truth, this guy is just another well-connected rightwing idiot, cashing in on his mommy and wifey’s accomplishments.”


  31. Reist says:

    It’s pure tyranny when all the government can survey among lefties is that they go a little too far playing on the internet. lefties are the same people who plotted to dump urine and feces on hardworking, successful people arriving at the Republican National Convention.


  32. ralph the wonder locust says:

    Nice one, Prod. You worked “libs spit on troops” and George Soros into a deluded whine about a report from the Department of Homeland Security.

    That shows some serious troll chops. Your buddy Reist couldn’t come up with that much craziness in one two-sentence rant — although he gets credit for bringing up feces.


  33. Oval12345678 aka James K. Sayre says:

    On Faux Noise this morning, one of the blonde women said in an odd question, “What is rightwing extremism?” Just hold a mirror, honey…


  34. ElBruce says:

    Oval12345678 aka James K. Sayre Says:

    On Faux Noise this morning, one of the blonde women said in an odd question, “What is rightwing extremism?” Just hold a mirror, honey…

    Rule: if you have to ask, it’s you.


  35. winddancer says:

    I think the reaction from conservative commentators is that the worst of them have actively promoted extreme-right ideas and fostered paranoia. They know it too, or they wouldn’t be so freaked out about this report. And honestly, to use the meme of “supporting our troops,” as a justification for slamming the report’s concerns about disgruntled veterans is more than stupid. Disgruntled vets have joined extremist groups on both the right and the left for years.


  36. pbeeg says:

    The Right has been thinking of ways to spit on veterans since Vietnam–earlier, if you count black WWII vets in the South.

    While there are no documented accounts of hippies spitting on returning troops, the Right has been hurling gobs at vets like George McGovern, John Kerry,Max Cleland, Jack Mutha, and, when they aren’t available, their mothers.

    And just to be fair, I won’t just mention Timothy McVeigh, but the DC Sniper as well, who was arguably a left-wing extremist.

    You’re quiet on Walter Reed abuses. You’re silent on reductions in veterans’ benefits. But you’ll wave any rag around in the air if you think you can score a point, only to drop immediately afterwards.

    The sanctity of the commander in chief,the War on Terror, Christianity, taxes, Supporting Our Troops–you respect none of it. You love nothing except winning.

    Which is why you go insane when you lose.


  37. ElBruce says:

    Proud Says:

    I love how the report mentions vets as a threat. You libs have been finding more and more ways to spit on the troops since Vietnam….

    First of all, “liberals” didn’t write the report, idiot. It’s the same DHS career staffers who have been there the whole time. What they’re concerned foris the forthcoming spike of PTSD sufferers returning from the war you created for no reason, returning to hear your pundits screaming about revolution and arming yourselves against the tyrannical governmental threat. Just statistically speaking, that’s going to create some violent problems. You people really should start taking at least a little responsibility for what you’re trying to do to harm our veterans and society at large.


  38. guzide says:

    OK Pat obviously senile dementia has set in. Time to see the nice young men that will need to take care of you soon.burun estetigi rent a car arac kiralama
    sac ekimi



Jump to Top

About Think Progress | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2009 Center for American Progress Action Fund
View Most Popular

Advertisement

What We're About

Featured

image
Subscribe to the Progress Report



imageTopic Cloud


Visit Our Affiliated Sites

image image
Reports


Got a hot tip?
Have a hot news tip? We'd love to hear from you. Use the form below to send us the latest.

Name:
Email:
Tip:
(required)


imageArchives


imageBlog Roll