Think Progress

Anonymous Senate hold put on Harold Koh.

By Ali Frick on Jun 4th, 2009 at 12:45 pm

Anonymous Senate hold put on Harold Koh.

When Yale Law School Dean Harold Koh was nominated to be top legal counsel at the State Department, the right wing unleashed its hysteria, charging Koh of being an “transnationalist” who was bent on imposing Sharia law in the U.S. Now an anonymous senator has placed a hold on Koh’s nomination, a source told Talking Points Memo:

Koh, who if confirmed will serve as legal adviser to the State Department, was reported out of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee about three weeks ago, but has languished ever since — a fact which, I’d imagine, makes him thrilled that he resigned as Dean of Yale’s Law School in order to serve in government.

Recall that before the committee vote, Sen. Jim DeMint (R-SC) also placed a hold on Koh’s nomination. That delay only lasted a week.

The Facebook group “We Support Harold Hongju Koh” and Jay Michaelson at the Huffington Post both write that the hold has been placed by Sens. John Cornyn (R-TX) and David Vitter (R-LA). ThinkProgress called both Cornyn’s and Vitter’s offices, but was unable to confirm that they are responsible for the hold.



41 Responses to “Anonymous Senate hold put on Harold Koh.”

  1. AIO says:

    Don’t blame Vitter, he was busy procuring a fresh batch of diapers.


  2. PatrioticLiberalChristianMantisReligiosa says:

    Are they waiting for him to change the pronunciation of his last name to something “easier”?


  3. DallasNE says:

    Sounds like the August recess would be a good time for a recess appointment. That way he could serve until January, 2011 when a new Congress comes in.


  4. PatrioticLiberalChristianMantisReligiosa says:

    Is someone try to find a quote to misconstrue as “proof” that Dean Koh is a racist?


  5. jaimymoore says:

    the hold has been placed by Sens. John Cornyn (R-TX) and David Vitter (R-LA).

    That explains the “wants to impose Sharia law” bit. Texas and Louisiana are places you can sell that crap.


  6. Max Anax junius -1 says:

    .

    What…?
    … Of course it’s not transnationalism when US Officials pander to Israel, is it?

    .


  7. shoeless says:

    …the right wing unleashed its hysteria, charging Koh of being an “transnationalist” who was bent on imposing Sharia law…

    You mean like the Sharia law of post-invasion Iraq?


  8. Max Anax junius -1 says:

    .

    Q U E S T I O N:
    When the Constitution comes wrapped in the leather bound cover of a Holy Bible, carrying an AK-47, how is that NOT any different than Sharia law?

    .


  9. hanshiro the antlion says:

    Corporations, for years, have funded obstructions to anything that may threaten their power. People like Vitter, Limbaugh and anyone associated with FOX are paid to retain and support the corporate conglomerates’ various tentacles by pushing laws and legislation that is favorable to corporations.

    The republican party is finally being revealed as solely soulless corporate champion, at the direct expense of the people they gulled into voting for them.

    Make no mistake, there are corporate servants amongst dems too, they just have to be less blatant, like the difference between closet racists, and racists who belong to whites-only country clubs.


  10. Zooey says:

    Anonymous hold?

    Senators, grow a set and boldly state why you’re holding up this nomination.

    You would be howling bloody murder if a Republican president nominations were held up — and you have.

    Have the courage of your convictions — go public.

    Chickenshits.


  11. ranus69 says:

    Does Vitter have to go and consult his call girls again first and # 4 I think your correct or there just trying to find a good made up talking point.

    Aren’t both Vitter and Cornyn up for re-election?


  12. ElBruce says:

    The anonymous hold rule has to go. Senatorial procedure should be open, and Senators should have all official actions they take go on the public record so that they can be held accountable for them.

    So, I’m guessing from their smears that Koh is a Muslim?


  13. linkwray says:

    The b.s. of the far right is just delay..delay.. delay… oh, he’s probably facing criminal indictment somewhere and I don’t think it is a stretch to suggest these guys get their money from the “oily boys’ who have been killing activists with impunity around the world. It’s not sharia law they’re worried about but the world courts and the jurisdictional arguments which will insue. The Supreme is squabbling internally about the world courts and me thinks Sottomayor would recognize them if appointed. These guys are protecting Rummybear, Dickybear and Georgiebear so they don’t get served some really scalding legal porridge.


  14. ElBruce says:

    … nope, just fer’n-looking. Stay classy, GOP.


  15. SkepticRising says:

    We really need to get rid of this anonymous hold crap in the Senate. There simply is not legitimate need for anonymity in Senate business.


  16. fletc3her says:

    The Senate really has to stop allowing “anonymous” holds on legislation. It usually isn’t too hard to figure out who is actually doing the hold, but the Senate should require them to come down into the chamber and tell everyone why they are holding up the nominee. Otherwise these cowards will continue to snipe from their private offices.


  17. spencers mom says:

    The anonymous hold is akin to hiding behind mommy’s skirts.

    Man up, obstructionists! If you’re going to put a hold on someone’s confirmation, do it with some pride!

    PEACE


  18. Prairie Sunshine says:

    So…having lost the African-American vote for generations…and in the process of losing the Hispanic vote likewise, the wily Republicans go for the trifecta, the Asian-American vote.


  19. Bilbo Hussein Baggins says:

    They really do need to do something about this arcane rule. Having a single Senator be able to stop something, anonymously, is NOT democratic in any way.

    Congress should kill the filibuster and this arcane rule. Then maybe we will be able to go back to being a democracy.


  20. spencers mom says:

    C4P, links please to anonymous holds placed by Democrats on Bush nominees? Thanks.

    PEACE


  21. Buckie Boy says:

    Chinless and Cheater, what a comical pair.

    The Republic Fascist Party is going to try and obstruct anything Obama or the American Democratic Party does…it’s their plan, “Party First, screw America.”

    Fcuk the Republic Fascist Party


  22. RantingTommy says:

    what do you call it when CFP posts? it’s LIES


  23. chiroptera toasterhead says:

    ElBruce Says:

    So, I’m guessing from their smears that Koh is a Muslim?

    June 4th, 2009 at 1:12 pm
    ______________

    Nope. He just allegedly made a statement once that there might be a possibility that under certain circumstances under international law, shari’a law might apply in a U.S. court. There’s no proof that he even made the statement, of course, but that doesn’t stop the conservatives from spreading it.


  24. RantingTommy says:

    chiroptera toasterhead Says:

    ElBruce Says:

    So, I’m guessing from their smears that Koh is a Muslim?

    June 4th, 2009 at 1:12 pm
    ______________

    Nope. He just allegedly made a statement once that there might be a possibility that under certain circumstances under international law, shari’a law might apply in a U.S. court. There’s no proof that he even made the statement, of course, but that doesn’t stop the conservatives from spreading it.

    it may be that he just isn’t sufficiently anti-muslim for the right wing cowards to be comfortable with him


  25. ranus69 says:

    I think Cornyn and Vitter put Koh on hold as Colemen may be ready to give up his fight for the Senate seat if the Minnesota Supreme Court rule in Frankin’s favor as they are likely too.


  26. tombaker says:

    such a very classy bunch of people, those R’s.


  27. kasinca says:

    Congress needs to begin investigation of the torture and war crimes and watch some of this go away. These thugs are afraid of Dawn Johnsen and this guy for their outspoken stance against the wars and conduct of the Bush Crime Family. They will hold on to the NARAL of Johnsen but the crimes are also a big fear.


  28. MapleStreet says:

    The truth is that Koh didn’t attend a prestigious law school, such as Regents U.

    Seriously though, Using this logic we can’t have anyone of English extraction as they would try to impose the Monarchy and Magna Carta. And the French system of Napoleonic Law is unfanthomable. etc. etc.


  29. bug says:

    I just want to make a “general overall statement” not so much about this article but all of the Republicans actions against the Obama administration appointments.
    It seems to me, that President Obama and his administration are running this country with almost a skeleton crew! So many of his appointments are being put on “hold” that he is being forced to run the country without the support of the much needed administration “bench” player (to use a basketball term), AND!! he’s not doing too bad. Good thing he’s smart, young and full of energy.
    I hope the American people are paying attention and can see between the lines and past the Republican B.S.


  30. Marie says:

    I don’t understand this arcane rule of congress — one senator can hold up an appointment —— well, why didn’t the dems do that any number of times over the past 8 years?


  31. kasinca says:

    Dean of Yale Law School scared off the wingnuts. Too much education for them.


  32. kasinca says:

    Think of the shock the wingnuts would give the world if for once they could do their job and give honest counsel, agree with what is happening without taking everything as a threat to their losing failed policies and philosophy. They are so pathetic with their politics of no and obstrucionism. Why the medis continues to interview these morons is beyond me. I turn the channel everytime I see they are interviewing a republican because I know they are going to blow smoke out their behind.


  33. WaltTheMan says:

    Please do not click on the links in the Med_Cezir post – they are com files which have to potentual of introducing a virus, Trojan horse or worm into your machine.


  34. WaltTheMan says:

    ‘to potentual’ s/b ‘the potentual’ in my prior post.


  35. pete says:

    Sigh… Apparently CFP doesn’t see the difference between a filibuster and an anonymous hold. Not to mention the fact that Alito was contested because of some very controversial rulings/writings while the GOoPers are making up crap about promoting “transnationalism” and Sharia law.


  36. ElBruce says:

    chiroptera toasterhead Says:

    Nope. He just allegedly made a statement once that there might be a possibility that under certain circumstances under international law, shari’a law might apply in a U.S. court.

    And it would be perfectly reasonable for a Senator to want to investigate that allegation before confirming. I would have no problem with them doing this through open procedural rules.

    .

    ConservativeForProgress Says:

    Obama and his fellow Senate Democrats were in the minority in 2005…

    Judicial filibuster =/= Cabinet anonymous hold.

    Do try to stay relevant, thx.


  37. wiley says:

    Wonder what’s going on with Dawn Johnsen’s nomination. I look forward to her and transparency in the OLC.


  38. Annie B. says:

    Am I alone in wondering why Mr. Koh resigned a great position at Yale before being approved by the senate as legal advisor for the state department?




  39. Sesli chat says:

    I knew he would still be wallpapering this thread. I take the Holocaust seriously enough not to wear it out. I am not nor have I ever been anti-semitic. I’m agnostic. Why in the world would I be anti-semitic? The assertion that I would “forget” or approve of any persecution and systematic murder is anti-social.
    Sesli Chat
    Sesli Sohbet
    SesliChat
    SesliSohbet



Jump to Top

About Think Progress | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2009 Center for American Progress Action Fund
View Most Popular

Advertisement

What We're About

Featured

image
Subscribe to the Progress Report



imageTopic Cloud


Visit Our Affiliated Sites

image image
Reports


Got a hot tip?
Have a hot news tip? We'd love to hear from you. Use the form below to send us the latest.

Name:
Email:
Tip:
(required)


imageArchives


imageBlog Roll