Think Progress

Just four GOP senators applaud when Obama calls ‘death panels’ a ‘lie.’

In his speech last night, President Obama addressed some of the various myths and misrepresentations that have been spread about his health care reform efforts. When Obama called claims that he would “set up panels of bureaucrats with the power to kill of senior citizens” a “lie, plain and simple,” he received a standing ovation from the Democrats in Congress. Republicans, on the other hand, largely sat on their hands. Watch it:

According to The Hill’s Walter Alarkon, the only Republican senators seen standing and applauding Obama’s dismissal of the “death panel” myth were Sens. Olympia Snowe (R-ME), Susan Collins (R-ME), Bob Bennett (R-UT) and Judd Gregg (R-NH). “Four or five House Republicans also appeared to stand and applaud Obama’s remark, but it’s unclear which ones they were,” writes Alarkon.

Update Nate Silver pointed out last night "that many Republicans didn't stand up and clap when Obama said 'no one should go broke because they get sick.'"


137 Responses to “Just four GOP senators applaud when Obama calls ‘death panels’ a ‘lie.’”

  1. raynman says:

    Of course they couldn’t stand and acknowledge this, the whole house of cards that they’ve built around that lie would have come tumbling down.



  2. Mike Hunt says:

    The compassion exhibited by the compassionate conservative party simply overwhelms me at times.


  3. Mr. Evil says:

    ‘no one should go broke because they get sick.’

    Because republicans only know how to do 2 things; hold out one hand for a check and hold their pocket open with the other hand.


  4. Mugsy says:

    I noticed the same thing about the lack of Republican applause on the “no one should go broke” line in the comments of last nights thread.

    If last night doesn’t finally expose exactly who these people are to the rest of the country and resign them to the dustbin of obscurity for the next decade, nothing will.


  5. mike from Arlington says:

    They should cut that portion Nate pointed out with a few other sympathetic moments showing how compassionate the GOP are regarding every day American’s health and store it away for some time when they need it.


  6. Dave M. says:

    Republicans wouldn’t applause the denouncing of their #1 talking point against healthcare reform.


  7. WaltinTexas says:

    #1 Raynman- My thought exactly!!! That’s their best lie, they can’t acknowledge it.


  8. hellinabucket says:

    Well said Mugsy. the GOP have shown there true colors.


  9. misscoleopteramolly says:

    Most of these Republicans depend on keeping these myths alive (it’s all they’ve got) and plan to go on perpetuating them after President Obama’s speech. They’re making the assumption that their kool-aid drinkers upon whom they depend for campaign funds didn’t watch the speech anyway.

    But just to make sure, the last thing they want is a YouTube floating around showing them demonstrating any support whatsoever for the man they want to fail.

    I just hope that President Obama was serious when he said he would call people out when they deliberately lie about health care reform.


  10. Chessmaster says:

    Well, props to those that applauded then.


  11. MCMetal says:

    Meanwhile , these same jackasses applauded wildly like retarded wind-up monkeys whenever Chimpy McFlightsuit gave one of his unintelligible , English-butchering speeches……


  12. konchster says:

    Their whole demeanor was rigid spine defiance. Just as it has been since the 5th of Nov. and accelerating on Jan 20th to a full head of hate and unreasonableness. They have demonstrated that Americans best interest is the last thing on their minds such as they are


  13. Dave M. says:

    The death panel talking point is a two-fer. It’s a solid talking point that is impossible to refute in any meaningful way. All you can say is that it’s a lie; and then it’s just a “he says she says” situation where either could be right. It’s a brilliant strawman argument that address fear, uncertainty, and doubt in a way that is just beyond intellectual reason.

    Then of course it conjures up the totalitarian government imagery that conservatives invested so heavily in with the current generation of seniors. Decades ago the notion that governments would put their unfit citizens to death in the interest of a perfect race or in the interest of saving money was commonplace. The up and coming generation of voters have not been exposed to any McCarthyism, in fact it is denounced. “Death panels” builds up fear of a cold government that would kill anyone who stands in its way of a perfect socialistic society for any reason.

    So I don’t think this meme will die any time soon. We can probably expect it to exist until the day healthcare reform passes and throughout its implementation.


  14. EnnuiDivine says:

    I would think that a couple more GOP sens DID applaud. Lugar, in particular. The guy’s a class act; my guess is that the cameras never focused on him.

    That said, I doubt he’d vote for the final bill…but you never know.


  15. P.D. says:

    Boo Hoo. The poor Repugs. Acting like defiant, spoiled children ready to stamp their feet when they hear something they don’t like. Even if it’s true. The fact is INSURANCE companies are the ones with ‘Death Panels’. But that’s OK with them. They will let average Americans die needlessly because they are beholden to Insurance Companies and a tired old idealogy that believes all ‘Government’ is a bad, evil entity that must be quashed at all costs. Ironic how they think Government is evil, yet they it doesn’t stop them from obtaining the power to run it at all costs.


  16. kwsventures says:

    This comment has been voted down. Click to read.



  17. kwsventures says:

    This comment has been voted down. Click to read.


  18. cd says:

    Bob Bennett?

    The conservative to the bone Utah Mormon?

    I guess the question is did he applaud because he agrees with Obama or because Bennett’s parents taught him manners unlike the dogs that raised Joe Wilson.


  19. P.D. says:

    My..my… I was wondering when the trolls would show up. By the way. I never mentioned how much money any politician received from insurance companies. In fact. I didn’t mention any particular politicain at all.


  20. Chyron HR says:

    STORM says:

    Reid

    Look, it thinks Progressives like Harry Reid. That’s adorable.


  21. paleolib says:

    Too many Republics repeated the death panel lie to dare applaud its denunciation. As for the failure to applaud a pledge to protect citizens from medical bill bankruptcy, some are too lacking in empathy to care, some are too frightened of the far right to be seen supporting anything the scary black man says and some recognize that if Obama pulls this off and puts together a successful administration the Republic Party may not see power again for decades.


  22. Max Anax junius -1 says:

    .

    Dear STORM,
    Oh yea? I’ll see your Reid Rant and double it with a Wilson Wail…

    Obama speech disruptor a health industry darling
    By Sue Sturgis
    Published: September 10, 2009

    http://rawstory.com/08/news/2009/09/10/obama-speech-disrupter-a-health-industry-darling/

    Whether because of his outspokenness or in spite of it, Wilson is a major recipient of contributions from the health care industry.

    In fact, over his entire congressional career, health professionals represent Wilson’s top industry contributors, donating a total of $244,196 to his campaign, according to the Center for Responsive Politics OpenSecrets.org database. He received another $86,150 from pharmaceutical companies, $73,050 from insurance companies and $68,000 from hospitals and nursing homes.

    Among Wilson’s top contributors are the American Hospital Association, a lobby group that represents the interests of hospitals and health networks, and the American Medical Association, which represents physicians.
    (continued)

    .


  23. Zooey says:

    UPDATE: Nate Silver pointed out last night “that many Republicans didn’t stand up and clap when Obama said ‘no one should go broke because they get sick.’”

    There ya go sheeple — Repubs want you to go broke if you get sick.

    Take that to the voting booth.

    Yeah, right…


  24. Xisithrus says:

    Obama said ‘no one should go broke because they get sick.’”

    [gNOpers sit on hands]

    For the average family, it is clear that without adequate insurance, even normal care can ‘be a financial burden while a catastrophic illness can mean catastrophic debt. -Dick Nixon to congress 1974

    [gNOpers applaud]


  25. Kenneth says:

    This comment has been voted down. Click to read.


  26. Xisithrus says:

    Kenneth says: Who is really drinking the Kool-Aid here? You Radical Lefties have had your Flavor choice since you’ve been in diapers!!! Ha!

    Really? Read my post [#26] from president Nixon above.


  27. Xisithrus says:

    You Radical Lefties have had your Flavor choice since you’ve been in diapers!!! Ha!

    Unlike (R) Vitter, I stopped wearing diapers.


  28. okie dokie says:

    Speaking of open secrets, I noticed Wilson is following a nursing home personal injury lawyer on his twitter.?


  29. Kenneth says:

    This comment has been voted down. Click to read.


  30. belaccifer lacca says:

    Kenneth says:

    Care to explain?

    Did we miss all those Republicans applauding while we were drinking that Kool-Aid?

    Or do you have nothing really to say except nonsense?


  31. belaccifer lacca says:

    Kenneth says:
    We don’t need Healthcare Reform!

    Well, most of America disagrees with you, Kenneth… who’s been drinking what now?


  32. Fred says:

    Kenneth says:
    Who is really drinking the Kool-Aid here? You Radical Lefties have had your Flavor choice since you’ve been in diapers!!! Ha!

    mr jones seems to qualify. ha


  33. Xisithrus says:

    kwsventures says: This health care plan will not add to the federal deficit. LMAO.

    It will by the time the lobbyists water it dowm with subsidies.


  34. Fred says:

    Kenneth says:
    We don’t need Healthcare Reform! We need corruption and fiscal responsibility reform in Congress.

    We’re working on that, getting rid of one republican at a time……the work goes on.


  35. hellinabucket says:

    corruption and fiscal responsibility reform. Good call Kenneth. That’s exactly what the President described lastnight on how much of his program will be paid for. Glad to hear you are on board with this.


  36. P.D. says:

    “No one should go broke because they get sick.” The Repugs couldn’t even be bothered to stand and clap for that?? Are they that callous? Yes, they are.


  37. Ashen Shard says:

    Notice that republicans also did not applaud when obama made comments on upholding medicare and not cutting the program or trying to privatize it. Wish democrats would run with this and go after republicans for wanting to cut medicare. would be a great way to get more senior citizens on board.


  38. hellinabucket says:

    Where was kweupiedoll when the skyrocketing costs of invading Iraq was tucked into supplemental spending year after year.

    Don’t get all high and mighty now when you walked lock step with Bush.


  39. dbadass says:

    You Radical Lefties have had your Flavor choice since you’ve been in diapers!!! Ha!
    —-
    Radical Righties shouldn’t try and do humor… It is painful.


  40. Kenneth says:

    This comment has been voted down. Click to read.


  41. Xisithrus says:

    Kenneth says: We need corruption and fiscal responsibility reform in Congress. Dems and Repubs included.

    I agree, unfortunately many people fall for the astroturfers BS which is the cause of alot of pork barrel spending subsidies and bailouts.

    When you attend a grass roots movement thats been co-opted by big business you are helping to create more federal debt. Wake up.


  42. dbadass says:

    40
    kwsventures has argued that they did not support such spending. The problem has been when asked to point us to the supporting posts, none have been made available. I suppose you can draw your own conclusion. I have…


  43. Kenneth says:

    This comment has been voted down. Click to read.


  44. Xisithrus says:

    Not True! Town Hall meetings and national polls say otherwise.

    Nope. 67% of people that watched Obamas speech are for health care reform.

    Townhalls..pfft, that just manufactured opposition to make it seem much larger than it is by the very people that are causing a good part of the debt.

    But hey, if you want to keep working against your own interests for a few food and drink vouchers, go ahead.


  45. tombaker says:

    Kenneth says:

    Well, most of America disagrees with you, Kenneth… who’s been drinking what now?

    Not True! Town Hall meetings and national polls say otherwise

    No Kenny, they don’t.


  46. dbadass says:

    with a system (American Medical System) that is the best in the world.

    I suppose you can support this thesis?


  47. ralph the wonder llama says:

    Kenneth says:
    We don’t need Healthcare Reform! We need corruption and fiscal responsibility reform in Congress. Dems and Repubs included.

    Who says it’s one or the other?

    I’d say we need BOTH health care reform AND fiscal responsibility reform in Congress. Although I gotta say, based on results, Democrats have a better record on fiscal responsibility than Republicans over the last, say, fifty years.


  48. tombaker says:

    Kenneth says:

    How about a little Tort reforms first before playing with a system (American Medical System) that is the best in the world.

    Been offered, Kenny.

    catch up on the topic before jumping in with both your little cap-guns blazing, wouldja?


  49. Xisithrus says:

    Kenneth says: How about a little Tort reforms first before playing with a system (American Medical System) that is the best in the world.

    We are rated number 37. But I will say America leads in technical expertise what with the CAT scans etc etc. But regular health care doesnt require all that expensive equipment and thats why we get a rating of 37.


  50. hellinabucket says:

    National polls say what Kenneth? Like these polls?


  51. belaccifer lacca says:

    How about a little Tort reforms first before playing with a system (American Medical System) that is the best in the world.

    Two problems:

    1) Tort Reform has done nothing to address rising costs in Texas or Missouri. http://www.cleveland.com/nation/index.ssf/2009/09/would_tort_reform_make_much_di.html

    2) We rank well below #1 in any reasonable analysis of Health Care systems…
    http://www.photius.com/rankings/healthranks.html


  52. Kenneth says:

    This comment has been voted down. Click to read.


  53. Xisithrus says:

    Kenneth says: How about a little Tort reforms first before playing with a system (American Medical System) that is the best in the world.

    Gee, why didnt Dubya do something about that?

    Ennyhoo, Health insurance rates doubled+ [120%] from 2000-2008. Question: Do you think tort reform will cause a reduction of a 120% increase every 8-10 years?


  54. ralph the wonder llama says:

    Who knew Kenneth the Intern was a right-winger?

    I just thought he was smarter than this.


  55. Uncle Ho says:

    Kenny-boy says:

    And what about the horse-piss that you are drinking?


  56. Purple State says:

    Best in the world?

    Perhaps, Ken, but only if you can pay to play.


  57. okie dokie says:

    Well of course, kenny.
    Everything in “America” is the best in the world.
    And if somebody has something better than us,
    we’ll steal it, bomb it, or just deny that it exists.
    Isn’t that how it works?

    More kool-aid?


  58. belaccifer lacca says:

    We do rank #1 in spending, Kenny… by a good bit.

    So I can see how you could be confused.


  59. Xisithrus says:

    AM wide Awake! My attendance at Grass-Roots events represents Small Business and the Common Patriotic American. No BS!

    Koch [big oil chemical co] supports alot of these astroturf movements and is NOT small business, but one of the largest private businesses. Kock says he lobbys against subsidies but then says he profits off them greatly [on ethanol]

    He also says he lobbys in his companies interests [IE not yours]

    They are just using people for their gain IE false flag opposition.


  60. dbadass says:

    How come all these self made small business owners usually end up out of business in short order?


  61. Xisithrus says:

    Did you know, Kenny, that the abolishment of alcohol [prohibition] grass roots movement was co-opted by lobbyists?

    If it werent for them prohibition, which lead to a major increase in organized crime, would never have happened.


  62. Kenneth says:

    This comment has been voted down. Click to read.


  63. tombaker says:

    dbadass says:

    How come all these self made small business owners usually end up out of business in short order?

    I don’t know dbad, but I am one of them, and being one doesn’t give me any reason to lean to the right.

    As a real, independent, small business guy, I can tell you that the 1 thing that would do me the most good would be for lots and lots of average people to have more $ in their pockets to spend. Cutting Donald Trump’s taxes didn’t do a damned thing to address that, and neither will anything else the R’s stand for.


  64. STORM says:

    dbadass says:

    How come all these self made small business owners usually end up out of business in short order?

    There is no such thing as a self-made man. you know that. Its really collectively all ours together like one big ant colony.


  65. tombaker says:

    Hoo-weee Kenny – that is some fairy tale you’re spinnin’,

    but as a small business owner, I can tell you you’re dead wrong.


  66. dbadass says:

    A yahoo with a have baked lame ass idea is hardly an entrepreneur. Like women were gonna smoke cigars for more than a brief fad… Piles of half broken shit for sale on the lawn is hardly what builds a nation…


  67. tombaker says:

    Stormy – You know of some businesses that don’t need customers?

    ‘Cause I don’t.


  68. dbadass says:

    Its really collectively all ours together like one big ant colony.

    I suppose that is how things go for species who are defined by a social existence….


  69. Xisithrus says:

    More than likely some small businesses failed because of mis-management, mistakes, inexperience, or an overburden of government taxes and regulations. But, they rebounded because of the entrepreneurial spirit and freedoms this Country offers.

    That statement has some serious contradictions


  70. dbadass says:

    65
    The thing that would do me the most good is not more money in my pocket but more sharing and group cooperation among my neighbors. See I have as little to do with the traditional economy as possible. I am a freegan…


  71. tombaker says:

    Most of the Righties who post “pro-business” rhetoric in support of righty ideas and policies obviously know absolutely nothing about running a business in a competitive market.


  72. STORM says:

    This comment has been voted down. Click to read.


  73. STORM says:

    This comment has been voted down. Click to read.


  74. Kenneth says:

    This comment has been voted down. Click to read.


  75. belaccifer lacca says:

    Kenneth says:

    I see you’ve abandoned your health care ‘reform’ argument completely… wise move.

    You didn’t really have a leg left to stand on and your proposals would only end up costings us all an arm as well.


  76. dbadass says:

    Your stupidly is depressing.


    I think you mean stupidity but you probably don’t wanna go down this path. See I make tons of typos but I also hold levels of education far beyond the average in this country. Now I realize that sarcasm and poking the overly confident multitudes of alledged small business wingers that appear here may not amuse you, it sure does me


  77. Kenneth says:

    This comment has been voted down. Click to read.


  78. dbadass says:

    Like a bee hive?

    — No more like a bonobo troop but with less pe nis fencing. Oops I got a meeting to get to. You might consider reading a little DeWaal or other background on the nature of scioecology in primates…


  79. ralph the wonder llama says:

    So can we safely conclude that our new friend Kenneth has no contact with reality and thus his comments can be ignored?


  80. SP Biloxi says:

    ‘Just four GOP senators applaud when Obama calls ‘death panels’ a ‘lie.’”

    The House of GOP cards are falling if only 4 GOP Senators applauded Obama for calling out the lie concerning death panels in the healthcare reform bill. Real sad.

    Here some interesting news about Rep. Wilson. Hat tip Raw Story:

    Whether because of his outspokenness or in spite of it, Wilson is a major recipient of contributions from the health care industry.

    In fact, over his entire congressional career, health professionals represent Wilson’s top industry contributors, donating a total of $244,196 to his campaign, according to the Center for Responsive Politics OpenSecrets.org database.

    He received another $86,150 from pharmaceutical companies, $73,050 from insurance companies and $68,000 from hospitals and nursing homes.

    Read on: http://rawstory.com/08/news/2009/09/10/obama-speech-disrupter-a-health-industry-darling/


  81. Xisithrus says:

    Its really collectively all ours together like one big ant colony.

    You know, its funny that thats what many religions want to do. Have everyone believe in their GOD, in their ways, think like them, act like them, dress like them. Quite a communal way of life. Yet these are they very first to accuse others of being socialist.

    But, I guess the question is are we like one huge ant colony? I recall that in the bible that GOD destroyed the tower of Babel because the people all spoke one language and then made it to where they couldnt understand one another.

    GOD then, wanted his children to be indivuals and independent of a hive mind mentality.

    And, yanno, I know of GOD, but he doesnt want me like everyone else, nor do I want everyone like me.

    GODs lesson, I think then, is this. You had better learn to get along whatever your differences are. A lesson humanity has yet to learn.


  82. ralph the wonder llama says:

    Latest poll. 78% favor the Preisdent’s Healthcare Plan — 18% oppose the plan.

    (Hey, I can pull numbers out my ass and present them as fact just as well as Kennth the Intern from 30 Rock.)


  83. NinerFan says:

    Kenneth: “More than likely some small businesses failed because of mis-management, mistakes, inexperience, or an overburden of government taxes and regulations. But, they rebounded because of the entrepreneurial spirit and freedoms this Country offers.”

    And everyone lived happily ever after! That’s a beautiful, story, Ken.


  84. belaccifer lacca says:

    That last one is the important one, Kenneth… just FYI


  85. Xisithrus says:

    Latest poll 67% favor reform


  86. tombaker says:

    Actually Kenny,

    If you’d been paying attention, you’d know that the economy always does better

    with D’s in charge.

    R’s just put money in the Donald Trump’s pocket, not average people’s.

    Are you just too young to know about that?


  87. Kenneth says:

    Your stupidly is depressing.

    Typical Educated, Arrogant Liberal Elitest!


  88. Kenneth says:

    Tombaker,
    What about when Reagan reduced the top tax rates and the economy turned around and the common folk had money to spend. I was there when it happened. Were you born yet?


  89. Xisithrus says:

    Here, let me get that log out of your eye Kenny.


  90. belaccifer lacca says:

    Kenneth says:
    Tombaker,
    What about when Reagan reduced the top tax rates and the economy turned around and the common folk had money to spend. I was there when it happened. Were you born yet?

    How’d he pay for those tax cuts, again?

    Oh yeah…
    http://zfacts.com/metaPage/lib/National-Debt-GDP-L.gif

    and a fun poll from a little but ago…
    http://theplumline.whorunsgov.com/president-obama/poll-bankrolled-by-foes-of-health-care-reform-finds-overwhelming-support-for-public-plan/


  91. tombaker says:

    Oh Kenny,

    You righties just amaze me,

    with your freestyle blending of cause and effect…

    don’t go changin’ k, bud?


  92. Kenneth says:

    When the Dems taxed the crap out of Luxury boats in my state years ago it put hundreds of people out of work in the boat building business. i.e. Tax the Rich and put the common worker out of a job. Great Liberal policy!—-NOT!


  93. hellinabucket says:

    Kenneth, you are proving to be a typical follower of fear. I’m guessing you stood right behind the Bush administration even after no WMD’s were found in Iraq. You were probably silent when a covert agent’s identity was released by the Bush administration. I’d venture to say you still believe that Sadam was secretly working with Al Qiada.

    You followed the emperor with no clothes and can’t bring yourself to realize you were wrong so you keep digging that hole.


  94. hellinabucket says:

    Kenneth, Deficits don’t matter. Or are you only going to cherry pick from Reagan’s chest?


  95. Xisithrus says:

    What about when Reagan reduced the top tax rates and the economy turned around and the common folk had money to spend.

    Heres a graph of national debt as percentage of GDP. Notice the climb once Nixon shut the gold window and our money was no longer backed by gold.
    http://zfacts.com/metaPage/lib/National-Debt-GDP.gif


  96. Xisithrus says:

    And on that same graph you will see how much GWB raised the debt.


  97. Purple State says:

    Kenneth, how’s the boat-building business in your state now?


  98. belaccifer lacca says:

    Kenneth says:
    When the Dems taxed the crap out of Luxury boats in my state years ago it put hundreds of people out of work in the boat building business

    When the Republicans mismanaged the economy in my country a couple of years ago it put MILLIONS of people out of work in the auto industry, the housing industry, the food service industry, the fashion industry, the technology sector, industrial industry, the arts, non-profits, for profits, etc. etc.

    Great work! If you can get any…


  99. Kenneth says:

    R’s just put money in the Donald Trump’s pocket, not average people’s.

    Put money in Donald Trumps pocket and buildings get built and workers get work. — Carpenters, plumbers, Electricians, brick-layers, cement contractors, etc, etc, etc. Then the average construction worker has money in his pocket to buy a beer and spend money on other things. Economics 101!


  100. Kenneth says:

    Kenneth, how’s the boat-building business in your state now?

    It came back and boomed after the boat tax was rescinded!


  101. Xisithrus says:

    According to David MacFarlane, president of Alden Yachts, Dockery’s order brought the company back from the brink of collapse. MacFarlane thinks back to November 1990, when President Bush and the Democratic majority in Congress agreed to levy the luxury tax. He says he still can’t believe they did it.

    Yes, Kenneth, it was only the dems.

    *rolls eyes*


  102. Oval12345678 aka James K. Sayre says:

    4 out of 40 Republican Senators are in touch with reality. That leaves 90% of the Republican Senators as mentally ill. These 36 guys need some mental health care…


  103. tombaker says:

    Righty Fantasy Economics 101, maybe.

    Which employs more:

    Building 1 Imperial Palace, or

    10,000 family homes?

    If your buncum was true, we’d be better off now than ever in history,

    but we’re not – and that is true.

    Thanks for playing, have a super-nice day.


  104. belaccifer lacca says:

    Psst, Kenneth!

    Did you see the chart me and Xisithrus posted?

    Here it is… http://zfacts.com/metaPage/lib/National-Debt-GDP.gif

    Isn’t it weird?


  105. Kenneth says:

    Heres a graph of national debt as percentage of GDP. Notice the climb once Nixon shut the gold window and our money was no longer backed by gold.
    http://zfacts.com/metaPage/lib/National-Debt-GDP.gif

    Send me all the graphs and websites you want. I was there in the trenches when the economy shifted for the POSITIVE in the 80s and watched it work in my industry and in other businesses and with other business friends. SO, don’t tell me reducing taxes doesn’t work.


  106. Xisithrus says:

    It took a relentless grassroots lobbying campaign by the boat builders, but Congress finally did repeal the federal luxury tax on boats in August of 1993.

    Gee, when did the republicans take the senate back?

    1994


  107. Xisithrus says:

    I was there in the trenches when the economy shifted for the POSITIVE in the 80s and watched it work in my industry and in other businesses and with other business friends. SO, don’t tell me reducing taxes doesn’t work.

    Really? The recession began in dec 2007. And did you know how many jobs were crested after GWBs tax cuts of 1.5 trillion?

    Only eight million in eight years.

    But go ahead and ignore graphs and facts, you have obviusly decided that your alternate reality is truth and thus you dont need to be here debating things you dont want to debate.


  108. tombaker says:

    Olympic Boat Centers – a giant west coast boat dealer,

    went out of business just last year. Bankrupt after decades in business.

    Not because of their taxes, and not due to mismanagement, and not because they didn’t pray enough or dress professionally, either…

    but because their sales dried up.

    No businessperson in their right mind would give up a critical percent of their sales, to save a trivial amount in taxes.

    That’s Real Life Business, 101.


  109. Xisithrus says:

    I was there in the trenches when the economy shifted for the POSITIVE in the 80s

    But the boat tax wasnt until the 90s…your memory is off a decade,


  110. belaccifer lacca says:

    Send me all the graphs and websites you want. I was there in the trenches when the economy shifted for the POSITIVE in the 80s and watched it work in my industry and in other businesses and with other business friends. SO, don’t tell me reducing taxes doesn’t work.

    “Show me all the proof you want!
    (Kenneth sticks fingers in ears and sticks tongue out of mouth)
    I can’t hear you! Nyah, Nyah!”

    Oh, Kenneth… sigh.


  111. Xisithrus says:

    Kenneth is deluded with RWTP.


  112. belaccifer lacca says:

    Proof is elitist!
    -Kenneth


  113. Marie says:

    David Shuster of MSNBC was shocked today when Joe Wilson admitted he only apologized because the leadership told him to do so. Another representative from Texas later told Shuster that Wilson wasn’t wrong and didn’t have to apologize.

    That was followed by Rep. Maxine Waters telling him that the public now knows what they are having to deal with in the Republican side of Congress.


  114. okie dokie says:

    Reagan enacted the luxury tax in 1990.


  115. muzz says:

    I see the trolls finally got their talking points and marching orders – took a little longer than usual this time – poor little trolls – collectively dumber than a bucket of hair


  116. Purple State says:

    okie, Reagan wasn’t president in 1990. That was George H.W. Bush. Unless he managed to get it done by remote control?


  117. Marie says:

    OT (from Raw Story)
    U.S. Capitol Police have arrested a Virginia man they say tried to get into a secure area near the Capitol with a gun in his car as the president gave his health care address to Congress.

    Police spokeswoman Sgt. Kimberly Schneider said Thursday that 28-year-old Joshua Bowman of Falls Church, Va., was arrested around 8 p.m. Wednesday. Bowman’s intentions were unclear, police said.


  118. okie dokie says:

    You’re right, Purple State.
    I know that. My search directed me to an interview with a car dealer named Regan…..

    I’ve owned a small business for over 25 years, and remember the luxury tax enactment. But, for us business was much better under Clinton than either Bush or Bush Lite…


  119. Purple State says:

    Exactly. My father’s business thrived in the 90s, but now it is struggling to stay afloat. That’s more due to the recession than anything, and recessions do not necessarily have a party affiliation affixed to them.


  120. Shayne says:

    No luxury taxes levied in 2008 but RV manufacturers crashed and burned. Go figure.


  121. okie dokie says:

    Bush Jr.’s relentless taxes on small business, the diminishing amount of liquid income with inflation, and increasing overhead and fees….
    not a good time for our health insurance premiums to double.


  122. Marie says:

    Even with the inevitable passage of the health reform package, it will be a long time before it is fully implemented. An interim program was noted last night for the urgently needy.
    The repugs efforts to stymie or stall this package is pretty transparent — they anticipate having control of congress in the near future and they will bury any reform at that time.


  123. EnnuiDivine says:

    89.

    Anyone else find it hilarious…and pitiful…that rabid right-wingers and the assorted trolls on this site, “educated” is supposedly an insult?


  124. Pilotshark says:

    Well have you all notice that there seems to be only like two trolls per thread?

    I mean we can really start to use only one name for all our misguided trolls you could use Kenny name in place with tundra or kvs or storm.
    picture them all in the same basement pounding away(smiles insert thoughts) on there keyboards.


  125. tombaker says:

    Troll Rationing!!??

    Is that even Constitutional??


  126. Game of Life says:

    I felt like kicking that imbecile in the neck. How dare he yell his racist slant on his bald-face lie. He had nothing to back up his claim, he’s an idiot and is right in line with the rest of the rude, uneducated teabaggers.

    You get out now you liar. RESIGN and go study Robert’s Rules you teabagger.

    Another thing you stupid tables.
    Don’t go around looking more ignorant than you actually are by comparing this looney’s rudeness to our calling out chimpy on his lies. It’s not the same and I really believe you teabaggers don’t know the difference.

    This is why the repugs will never be in the WH EVER again.

    President Obama handled you like the rotten repug you are.


  127. conservative guy says:

    Olympia Snowe and Susan Collins are RINOS so it doesn’t really matter.


  128. tombaker says:

    cg, I think it’s just the “R” part that doesn’t matter.

    sorry.


  129. belaccifer lacca says:

    conservative guy says:
    Olympia Snowe and Susan Collins are RINOS so it doesn’t really matter.

    Keep shrinking that tent!


  130. Mike Hunt says:

    dbadass says:

    with a system (American Medical System) that is the best in the world.

    I suppose you can support this thesis?

    Why does the World Health Organization rank the US system 37 if we have the best in the world?



  131. bluesunflower says:

    Kenneth says:

    ——————————————————————————–

    Tombaker,
    What about when Reagan reduced the top tax rates and the economy turned around and the common folk had money to spend. I was there when it happened. Were you born yet?

    Uhhhh….Voodoo Economics doesn’t work. Even George Bush Sr. was against it, and it certainly didn’t work for George Bush Jr. when he tried it during *his* presidency.

    And I actually recall Reaganomics *not* working, since the recession lasted ALL throughout his presidency. The only thing that ended it was when Bush Sr. ordered Desert Shield and Desert Storm, because history *does* tell us that the one thing that’s almost certain to end a depression is unfortunately a war.


  132. EugeneDebs says:

    conservaTROLL

    YOU are an ignorant pile of dogshit so YOU dont matter


  133. karadagli61 says:

    Thank you for your sharing.!


  134. gunter says:

    I actually agree that Obama didn’t lie, but the way you label people racist over disagreement is despicable estetik ameliyatlar.



Jump to Top

About Think Progress | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2010 Center for American Progress Action Fund
View Most Popular

Advertisement

What We're About

Featured

image
Subscribe to the Progress Report



imageTopic Cloud


Visit Our Affiliated Sites

image image
Reports


Got a hot tip?
Have a hot news tip? We'd love to hear from you. Use the form below to send us the latest.

Name:
Email:
Tip:
(required)


imageArchives


imageBlog Roll