Think Progress

Six-Year-Old Girl ‘On Verge Of Never Hearing Again’ Due To Insurance Company Denial

cigna_logoOne of the worst abuses of the private health insurance industry is its practice of denying claims to pay for necessary care for patients. This practice has become so rampant in the industry that a recent study by the California Nurses Association found that a whopping 21 percent of all insurance claims filed in the first half of 2009 in the state of California were denied by insurers.

As the story of six-year-old Madison Leuchtmann of Franklin County, MO, demonstrates, even children are victims of this insurance company abuse. Madison was born with bilateral atresia, which means she lacks ear canals in both ears. In order to hear, she wears a special device on a headband that allows her to make out sounds. Despite her disability, Madison is at the top of her kindergarten class and is slowly learning to read.

Yet Madison, due to her growth, will soon require a new hearing implant to be able to recognize sounds. Her hearing and speech therapist warns that “if she doesn’t get her implants by age seven, she’s not going to be able to blend her words. … She won’t be able to hear herself [talk].” Madison’s pediatrician, Dr. Randall Clary, also insists that without the implant, the girl may never be able to hear again.

Unfortunately, the Leuchtmann’s family insurer, Cigna, has issued “one denial after another,” flatly refusing to cover the $20,000 bill for the implant. In a written statement to the local news station Fox 2, Cigna explained, “It is not unusual for commercial benefit plans to exclude hearing assisted devices,” prompting Dr. Clary to angrily respond, “This is obviously medically necessary. You have a child that has no ear canals!” Dr. Clary also told Fox 2 that he sees these sort of denials “on a weekly basis.” Watch Fox 2’s report:

 

The United States is the only developed country without a universal, cradle-to-the-grave health care system. In no other developed country would a girl be on “the verge of never hearing again” because a for-profit insurance company decided that its bottom line was more important than keeping a child from going deaf.



144 Responses to “Six-Year-Old Girl ‘On Verge Of Never Hearing Again’ Due To Insurance Company Denial”

  1. pastcaring says:

    TTTC…do you know you are being used as a tool?

    Probably not…do you even have a pulse?


  2. EnnuiDivine says:

    It’s obvious that the Cigna executives are as deaf as the girl they’re condeming to a life without the ability to hear.

    This isn’t a cosmetic procedure. The girl and her family aren’t asking for anything that isn’t a medical necessity.

    For as much shit as the Senate/House bills contain, both eliminate the kind of absolutely callous indifference that Cigna’s exhibiting.


  3. USNclerk says:

    Used as a tool?! He is a tool! Insurance companies do this all the time. Books have been written about the crap they pull to make a profit. Wake up TTTC! On second thought, just go back to sleep, I really don’t want to hear anymore from you.


  4. Purple State says:

    Three words, TTTC: John Shadegg’s prop.


  5. Buckie Boy says:

    Republican response -

    Are there no Emergency Rooms?

    Are there no Charities to handle this?

    Where’s her boot straps?

    But then, we can always count on TTTC (Scumbag supreme) to show us just how stupid stupid can get.


  6. barfly says:

    TTTC says:

    Does this girl no she’s being used as a propaganda pawn?

    Does that invalidate the assertion that for profit healthcare is atrocious? No, it doesn’t, and I know from personal experience that they routinely reject first claims, in order to reduce their expenses. it happened to me, when I blew my knee out, and had to wait over three months to be ok’s for surgery – afte rfirst being denied, and having to file an appeal.


  7. Chickenbone Bill says:

    The person that signed off on the “Denial of Services” letter needs a red hot coat hanger stuck in both their ear canals, live on TV!


  8. USNclerk says:

    And TTTC, as an aside, if you want me to name one, try Insult to Injury. By Ray Bourhis. It’s available on Amazon for 19.95, if you learn to read, try it out.


  9. geoman77 says:

    TTTC:
    Does this girl no she’s being used as a propaganda pawn?

    No, she probably hasn’t heard.


  10. raynman says:

    Propaganda Pawn? Do the names Pat Tillman and Jessica Lynch mean anything to you?

    At least in this young girl’s case, the ‘propaganda’ is based on fact, instead of a fiction created by the White House spinmeisters…


  11. USNclerk says:

    I’m sorry, I got the price wrong. It’s $18.21


  12. pastcaring says:

    TTTC says:

    Does harry’s plan give everyone blanket coverage? Everything is covered, no matter what?

    No tittycaca…that would be called single-payer and that’s something you evil beings are against…tool


  13. wolfsinger says:

    TTTC is a turd like the rest of the Christian Family Values GOP jack-booted thugs.

    This story would make any American with even a modicum of compassion want to puke.

    Not so soulless Christian GOP corporatist trolls and the God companies they prostrate themselves to.


  14. Chyron HR says:

    TTTC says:

    I just expect the rest of you to work hard for what you get in life, like I had to. But you’d rather sit back and wait for the government to rob me so they can take care of you, you lazy bastard.

    So you think this little girl should have “worked hard” if she wanted to be able to hear? You think this six-year-old is a “lazy bastard” who wants the government to rob you so she can have medical care? You’re a sick, sick man.


  15. Hoodathunk says:

    This is common for most insurance companies. Hearing impairment is seldom covered.


  16. Oval12345678 aka James K. Sayre says:

    Morally deaf, morally dumb and morally blind: that’s what greed creates in private insurance companies and their Republicant and Bleu-dawg enablers…


  17. EugeneDebs says:

    TTTC

    Why are you still commenting? We already know you are STUPID and that you are an ignorant soulless pile of dogshit and you have no OTHER message.


  18. Purple State says:

    TTTC says:

    Does harry’s plan give everyone blanket coverage? Everything is covered, no matter what?

    Is that you, Gretchen Carlson?


  19. MrBlueSky says:

    The only way to get this little girl some justice is to make the video go viral. It will give the insurance company (yet another) black eye… even if they don’t reverse themselves, the public will still be warned against this company.

    Any Missouri lawyers out here in the Blogosphere willing to take this case pro-bono?????


  20. Levi the Oracle says:

    TTHC said Does this girl no she’s being used as a propaganda pawn?

    The use of “propaganda” to help a child not lose her hearing is far superior to spamming liberal web sites in a desperate effort to save a dying conservative movement.


  21. belaccifer lacca says:

    I bet she’d listen to you tell her all about how she’s ‘a propaganda tool,’ TTTC and listen happily… if that meant she was able to hear for the rest of her life.

    Jeebuz.


  22. PatrioticLiberalChristian says:

    $20,000 for one implant for one girl? That’s an awful lot of money! Why, it’s 1% of somebody’s bonus! What do you expect from CIGNA?

    /snark off


  23. Hoodathunk says:

    Isn’t it wonderful that in TTTC’s wonderful free market world this child doesn’t have to worry about the evil government getting between her doctors and her health care? Her family paid their money to the insurance company and poof, she is being taken care of.

    /very angry snark


  24. hellinabucket says:

    TTTC translation “are there no workhouses? are there no prisons?”


  25. Purple State says:

    You know, they do have a point, though. I ask for Harry Reid’s plan to cover 110% of the people!


  26. Hoodathunk says:

    But you’d rather sit back and wait for the government to rob me so they can take care of you, you lazy bastard

    Just how valuable are a few bags of Cheetos and a half a case of Red Bull?


  27. Chyron HR says:

    TTTC says:

    I just expect the rest of you to work hard for what you get in life, like I had to. But you’d rather sit back and wait for the government to rob me so they can take care of you, you lazy bastard

    Make stuff up much? I never said that.

    Oh, I’m sorry aaronk, but it’s a direct quote from comment #59 of this thread. If you have to be a shameless liar, at least try to lie about things that can’t be disproven in five seconds.


  28. P.D. says:

    $20,000? What the Fu*k is 20 grand to an insurance company. These SOBs rake in billions and they have the BALLS to deny a girl the sense of hearing because they are to friggin greedy? There is a specisl place in Hell for these people. What ever happened to empathy?


  29. majii says:

    I am in tears. I am so hurt that Cigna is denying this beautiful child an implant that will help make her more successful. This particulary affects me because I am a retired teacher who saw this same situation over and over again for 33 years. I can’t type much more right now because I am too upset. Does anyone posting here have a way to get a donation to this family?


  30. indi1216 says:

    TTTC is not American.


  31. belaccifer lacca says:

    TTTC obviously gets such pleasure from hearing himself talk, I wonder why he would deny that pleasure to others?


  32. MrBlueSky says:

    wolfsinger says:

    ——————————————————————————–

    TTTC is a turd like the rest of the Christian Family Values GOP jack-booted thugs.

    This story would make any American with even a modicum of compassion want to puke.

    Not so soulless Christian GOP corporatist trolls and the God companies they prostrate themselves to.

    ==============================================================

    You know, Wolfsinger, in the 80s I too was a Christian fundamentalist. Back in those days, I would never have supported those who would deny a little girl her surgery. We actually did have compassion back then. The Christian Right Wing of today is completely unrecognizable compared to back then. There is no Biblical view that could possibly support or justify the insurance company’s position… just goes to show… how they’ve moved from moralism in the 80s to naked corporatism today! Jesus would be so ashamed. Reminds me of Him who said that if you don’t do it for the least of my brethren, you don’t do it unto me.


  33. Purple State says:

    Chyron, it’s our good friend Olby Sucks.


  34. app203 says:

    I searched google but couldn’t find anybody else carrying this story. What’s the deal with that? I’m also wondering like majii if there’s a place to donate for her.


  35. P.D. says:

    @36, We have had enough of you. Defending something like this is immoral. What would Jesus do? Side with a billion dallor industry or the plight of an innocent child. Get lost you friggin loser.


  36. EugeneDebs says:

    I’m not sure TTTC qualifies as HUMAN. What with the lack of a soul and the subhuman moronity


  37. rastaman says:

    THAT’S CALLED “DEAF PANELS”


  38. wolfsinger says:

    Start here. Usually, I tell people to “be polite” when they call.

    In this case, tell them to go to hell.

    CIGNA Corporate Offices*
    900 Cottage Grove Road
    Bloomfield, CT 06002
    860.226.6000

    CIGNA Corporate Headquarters*
    Two Liberty Place
    1601 Chestnut Street
    Philadelphia, PA 19192
    215.761.1000


  39. Hoodathunk says:

    Why is it that auto insurance companies are out there competing against each other, providing services and there is a genuine free market type dynamic happening there but for some reason health insurance is in its own little world?


  40. Pilotshark says:

    So is not Cigna the one who’s doing gods work>>>>>>>

    what a bunch of crap


  41. pastcaring says:

    MrBlueSky says:

    just goes to show… how they’ve moved from moralism in the 80s to naked corporatism today! Jesus would be so ashamed. Reminds me of Him who said that if you don’t do it for the least of my brethren, you don’t do it unto me.

    The metamorphosis is all about a naked power grab…


  42. Obdurodon says:

    Has a fund been set somewhere to help this girl privately? I for one am willing to put my money where my mouth is on providing quality health care for all. There are those who use the possibility of private charity as an excuse for opposing any policy for the public good, despite never having shown one bit of charity themselves. Let’s show them what it looks like.


  43. Leftside Annie says:

    Perhaps Rush can send the family a Homedics massager!

    (/snark)


  44. P.D. says:

    Eugene@41, You got that right. I can handle dumb trolls, whacked out trolls, even comically sad trolls. But this dirt-bag, forget it. Now these guys are siding with an industry that denies ill children? WTF?


  45. zxbe says:

    And the way our system works, even if they find another carrier that does cover this, they’ll deny it due to being a pre-existing condition. We should be embarrassed as a nation.


  46. Purple State says:

    My guess is Olby Sucks doesn’t have to worry about health care coverage, since Keith’s insurance likely covers him too. Or does he need to buy his own if he’s in the wrong state?


  47. Zaid Jilani says:

    I am in tears. I am so hurt that Cigna is denying this beautiful child an implant that will help make her more successful. This particulary affects me because I am a retired teacher who saw this same situation over and over again for 33 years. I can’t type much more right now because I am too upset. Does anyone posting here have a way to get a donation to this family?

    Her mother is a teacher within the school district. Her work e-mail is here: jleuchtmann@stclair.k12.mo.us


  48. EugeneDebs says:

    TTTC

    You have no soul, you have no brain, you have no decency. THAT is strike three. YOU are out so STFU


  49. pete says:

    MrBlueSky,

    Unfortunately, today’s group of Christian extremists thinks that Jesus was a Chuck Norris character.


  50. tombaker says:

    only a soulless righty

    like T(eeny)T(eeny)T(iny)C(onscience) here,

    could be so callous about this girl’s plight.

    you’re a real class act there, friend…


  51. Chyron HR says:

    TTTC says:

    Wrong again, loser.

    Come on, you can do better than that. Why don’t you blame ACORN for letting you get caught in a blatant lie?


  52. Rab says:

    Another example why there should be single-payer universal health care.


  53. livelongandprosper says:

    Hoodathunk says:
    Why is it that auto insurance companies are out there competing against each other, providing services and there is a genuine free market type dynamic happening there but for some reason health insurance is in its own little world?

    Because there are only a handful of corporations that provide insurance – in fact in some places there is only ONE provider for an entire town – and the rules they helped pass make it near impossible for new players.

    Also, the corporations have ‘captured’ the government by controlling the regulators. Fact is, most of the health insurance and drug companies higher ups at one time worked for the regulators/government.

    For this reason a single payer system will never happen. And don’t be fooled, both parties are implicit in allowing it to happen and to continue it’s ’success’.


  54. USCKitty says:

    TTTC says:
    This comment has been voted down. Click to read.

    Does this girl no she’s being used as a propaganda pawn?

    Better question is do you know you’re saying exactly what the Insurance companies want you to say?


  55. toasterhead says:

    TTTC says:

    I just expect the rest of you to work hard for what you get in life, like I had to. But you’d rather sit back and wait for the government to rob me so they can take care of you, you lazy bastard

    November 19th, 2009 at 3:09 pm
    ____________

    Please. You’ve never worked a day in your life, Trajan.


  56. angels81 says:

    TTTC, you are one sick piece of shit. I don’t let trolls get under my skin, but you have. You are just one lucky person, that I can’t reach out and touch, because you would find out real quick how good your insurance company is.


  57. USCKitty says:

    TTTC, What would you rather have us do? Not talk about these stories? Then who will know the insurance companies’ systematic abuse? Oh wait, that’s what they want and your post serves to further their goals…


  58. RUCerious says:

    TooTighwaddedToCare:

    Just wanted to let you know that even though your cold hearted posts have already been voted down, I’m opening them up and voting you down as well.

    A$$Hat.


  59. missmolly says:

    Hoodathunk says
    November 19th, 2009 at 3:05 pm

    This is common for most insurance companies. Hearing impairment is seldom covered.
    _____________________________________________________________

    True for most private insurance companies. However, Medicare covers most hearing issues, and Medicaid often does (coverage varies from state to state, but children are almost always covered for hearing impairment).

    One of our trolls snidely asks if “Harry’s plan” would give everyone blanket coverage for hearing impairment, no matter what.

    I don’t have the answer to that, but it appears that government programs are much better at hearing impairment coverage than private insurers, so I’d be willing to bet that the public option portion of “Harry’s plan” would indeed cover this child.


  60. NinerFan says:

    The troll is so irrelevant it’s painful to watch him not only make fool, but demonstrate the worst qualities humanity has to offer.

    What is relevant is that ours is the only developed country in the world where this happens. Even a semi-corporate-friendly bill like what Senate Dems are offering would prevent something like this from happening. It’s time to tune out the sociopaths, religious fanatics, fascists, corporate apologists and even the unfortunate individuals who find themselves defending the indefensible because they work in the industry. We need to move on and demand that this, at least, gets done.


  61. wolfsinger says:

    MrBlueSky @ 37 says:

    wolfsinger says:
    ——————————————————————————–
    TTTC is a turd like the rest of the Christian Family Values GOP jack-booted thugs.

    ==============================================================

    You know, Wolfsinger, in the 80s I too was a Christian fundamentalist. Back in those days, I would never have supported those who would deny a little girl her surgery. We actually did have compassion back then. The Christian Right Wing of today is completely unrecognizable compared to back then. There is no Biblical view that could possibly support or justify the insurance company’s position… just goes to show… how they’ve moved from moralism in the 80s to naked corporatism today! Jesus would be so ashamed. Reminds me of Him who said that if you don’t do it for the least of my brethren, you don’t do it unto me.

    Here Here! I grew up in a vibrant Protestant church as well. Time was, all a minister had to say was little more than what is in the headlines here and the entire congregation would weep and the cash would flow. Calls would be made on her behalf and they would have done it anonymously!

    We weren’t cowards. We didn’t get taught fear. We were chastised for our petty biases and we tried to be better than our selves. Today’s Christian GOP thugs are truly the most mean spirited jackals I’ve ever encountered since the Neo-Nazi movements of the mid to late 70’s.


  62. P.D. says:

    TTTC, What the hell is up with the ‘Strikes’? And NOBODY mentioned ‘death’ As*hole. Are you scared or something?


  63. lokidog says:

    Good luck defending this denial, CIGNA (I worked for them for 10 years).

    While it’s true that the vast majority of policies I’ve dealt with do not cover hearing aids, tests, etc., it’s always been in the context they are considered “routine” (as in almost everyone’s hearing eventually gets worse as part of the aging process). This girl’s situation, however, is clearly not “routine”, and I’m surprised CIGNA is trying to deny it.

    Besides that, CIGNA is being short sighted (and stupid) in that therapy and other medical services that will probably end up being necessary (and covered) due to the girl not receiving a hearing aid will end up costing them more in the long run than the hearing aid. Dumb.

    The girl’s parents need to get a lawyer involved – I know from my experience when that happened, CIGNA usually would pay the claim as the legal expenses usually end up costing them a lot more.


  64. EugeneDebs says:

    TTTC

    Why would anyone threaten you. It is BIG fun to laugh at morons as stupid as you. MY GOD you are so stupid that if stupidity were physically painful you would be on a morphine drip. What is even more amusing is you KNOW you are the stupidest pile of dogshit in the yard. That is why you dont even TRY to engage in a conversation. You just drop your ignorant trollturds like the cowardly moron you are then skip away. Why dont you just CRY at the thought of how stupid and pathetic you are? You are embarassing all mankind with your abject stupidity


  65. RUCerious says:

    Gotta wonder how our little trollie would take it if its doctor informed him that he’s got some ’suspicious lesions’ in his lungs, and his insurance company wanted him to wait 90 days to see if they went away or didn’t grow before they’d authorize to pay for tests to see if it might be malignant.

    My guess is you’d hear the wailing and gnashing of trolltooth stumps from miles out.


  66. angels81 says:

    TTC, Are you talking to me? If so, lets make one thing perfectly clear. I don’t make threats, but I would like to meet you in person.


  67. missmolly says:

    So where’s Virginia Foxx to tell this child to go to an emergency room?


  68. Hoodathunk says:

    Sooner or later, this country will realize that health care is as basic a need as police & fire protection. As clean water and sewage treatment. And as important as providing for the common defense. We cannot have a viable society if the basic needs are not met and it is up to all of us to contribute to insure these needs are met.


  69. Shayne says:

    TTTC couldn’t wait to post his callous comments. Obviously he doesn’t have children and though he probably never will he ought to be very worried about karma.


  70. pluege says:

    the horror of America’s corportist system

    its indecent

    its inhumane


  71. Fritz says:

    One of the big problems of Financial industry is that some companies have gotten too big to fail.
    The insurance industry has a similar problem…they are too big to care.

    These people can do whatever they want now. As long as the insurance industry keeps giving money to politicians (Dems and Repubs), and we allow the politicians to take and keep the money, nothing will change.


  72. angels81 says:

    TTTC, so you have a little beagle? I bet its real cute, is it house trained yet? I hope when you take it out for a walk, you pick up the poop.


  73. Fritz says:

    P.D. says:

    TTTC, What the hell is up with the ‘Strikes’? And NOBODY mentioned ‘death’ As*hole. Are you scared or something?

    Of course the boy is scared – he’s a coward.


  74. EugeneDebs says:

    TTTC

    You ignorant soulless pile of dogshit take the Desert Beagle into the next room and do the right thing


  75. Hoodathunk says:

    You went to which law school?

    Probably the one down the street from the day care center you flunked out of.


  76. angels81 says:

    TTTC, I went to the UofM A-hole.


  77. EugeneDebs says:

    Fritz

    Yes he is. A very VERY STUPID coward the worst kind. Like a fearbiting dog


  78. zenster666 says:

    Forget the Tsetse Fly troll. He’s a parasite just like his corporate masters. If a family is paying for insurance then they have shown good faith. Insurance corporations that deny coverage to paying customers are showing bad faith. To hell with them. The whole idea is that we all pay into a pool so that everyone’s needs are met. Some are more affilcated than others. That’s life. What we don’t have to continue living with is these corporate monsters who look only to their own interests. The social contact is broken. I look for the day when we are rid of these pests.


  79. EugeneDebs says:

    Fritz

    Yes he is. A very VERY STUPID coward the worst kind. Like a fearbiting dog, only not NEARLY as smart or decent


  80. Levi the Oracle says:

    People are trying to guess who the puppeteer is behind TTHC, and after they guess, he claim they are incorrect by saying “strike” (I think).

    Comment at 63 is definitely not a death threat, but it might be construed a threat of bodily injury. I can certainly understand the frustration with the troll, but expressing your desire to cause them harm only plays into their hands.


  81. RUCerious says:

    TheTotalTrashCan ~ With your Karma, I just feel really sorry for your son having a father like you.


  82. pete says:

    I think the stupid troll meant “desert eagle” which is a highly impractical handgun designed for guys who use weapons to compensate for their stunted junk. It’s kinda the Hummer of handguns.


  83. livelongandprosper says:

    TTTC says:

    My desert beagle is safely within reach. ;)

    I’ve heard of the Desert Fox but that was just a nickname.

    Oh I see, you are gun freak!


  84. wolfsinger says:

    Anyone with a mind like the cesspool that is TTTC’s is very likely like Bush and the other neo-con psychopaths that when growing up were pyros, bed-wetters and killers of animals.

    I should be concerned about TTTC’s mental health as no one normal could be so cold. But, they’re so busy being turds, that I don’t care.


  85. EugeneDebs says:

    TTTC

    You drag down the IQ and decency level of the entire world just by existing. Fruitflies are smarter than you will ever be. Leeches are less parasitic. Three day old dogshit isnt as putrid as your very souless existance. Every human being you have ever met is diminished for the fact they have been in your disgusting presence. I pity you. You are beneath contempt


  86. Chyron HR says:

    TTTC says:

    I have a son and he’s well taken care of, ty.

    Wait, he doesn’t “work hard” for what he “gets in life”? Does that mean you think he’s a “lazy bastard”?


  87. angels81 says:

    TTTC, god we run into tough guys like you all the time. We walk into the bar your in and your the first one’s to shit in their pants. Its easy to be a tough guy on some blog, but its a little different in the real world.


  88. deblacksmith says:

    My grandson has a similar child to this in his class — big difference is that this child gets the implant without problems. Why? Because he lives in Canada. And we want to call the USA a great place to live?


  89. Fritz says:

    Awww…you gonna cry, troll? Did Chyron HR hurt your widdle feelings?


  90. EugeneDebs says:

    TTTC

    Shove it up your ASS you moronic pile of dogshit


  91. Chyron HR says:

    TTTC says:

    Your pie hole, shut it.

    My “pie hole”? No matter how many times you deny it, I’m quoting your words. You’re the one claiming that your supposed son is “robbing you”.

    Or are you just a hypocrite?


  92. Freword says:

    What are you a joke


  93. Fritz says:

    TTTC The Troll is a yellow coward.


  94. EugeneDebs says:

    TTTC

    I highly recommed you just STFU. You have already established your monumental stupidity and lack of both decency AND a soul


  95. hellinabucket says:

    TTTC you have proven to be less than worthy to conduct any rational debate with. You bring nothing to the table and only confirm to others here that ignorance prevails with those who oppose the healthcare reform that the Democrats are presenting.

    This is the last time I will address you. You are dead to me.


  96. angels81 says:

    TTTC, I think you got the point right?


  97. EugeneDebs says:

    TTTC

    No CH is RIGHT. You are a stupid, soulless, ignorant pile of dogshit


  98. Uncle Ho says:

    TTTC says:

    It would be poetic justice(not to mention Karma) if something happened to YOUR child, and your insurance rejected any claim for treatment.
    Remember, what goes around comes around and payback is a motherf**ker


  99. Chyron HR says:

    TTTC says:

    you’re delusional

    Oh, so you have a good reason for thinking your child deserves free health care, but the little deaf girl doesn’t?

    So what is it?


  100. EugeneDebs says:

    TTTC

    Piles of dogshit like YOU dont know what class IS. You DISGUST all decent human beings. The world suffers from the fact you exist in it at all you subhuman moron


  101. livelongandprosper says:

    Would someone please start some Single Payer rallies?


  102. Pilotshark says:

    This troll TTTC is making all of his friends trolls and the white wing wrong side party look very bad.

    I have more respect for pond scum then you and your coward un-american un-patriotic azzz holes.


  103. angels81 says:

    TTC,

    You are calling someone classy, after the shit you have posted about this little six year old and her mother? What a sad sorry piece of shit you are.


  104. wolfsinger says:

    So, TTTC. For your abject stupidity and mean spirited trolling, you’ve received more justifiable criticism than just about any other troll that has posted here. Ever!

    This clearly demonstrates that you are a pathetic masochist who has abandonment issues. You want to drop a steamer of a troll message and leave but you crave attention, even if its not favorable to you. So you grab your gun and wet your pants and troll on. One hand on your keyboard. The other with your thumb in your mouth.

    Listen, TTTC. I think your mommy is calling.

    By the way? What do you want to be when you grow up?


  105. Chyron HR says:

    TTTC says:

    We have private insurance and we are very happy with it.

    The deaf girl has private insurance, too. The insurance company is refusing to pay for the medical treatment she requires.

    When your insurance company denies vital treatment to your son, will you explain to him that whatever illness he has isn’t “so bad”?


  106. smidget says:

    Classy, he says.

    Like suggesting that this girl is lucky to be deaf because at least she doesn’t have cancer.

    I’m sure her mother feels EXTREMELY fortunate that she’s been paying for health insurance for all these years just to be denied a legitimate claim for her nearly-deaf daughter. Who the fcuk wouldn’t feel fortunate, right?

    BTW, please tell me someone else has custody of that child. It would be a real tragedy for you to raise a human being as horrible as you are.


  107. kuvasz says:

    It is my personal opinion that none of the people who head these organizations will act to reduce such suffering without their own personal experience with pain and suffering. They have traded in human compassion for mammon, and mere humane behavior is of no consequence to them.

    I want to be clear about the aforementioned remark. I DO NOT advocate, nor condone violence, but if legal means do not produce a change in their attitudes and actions violence against these executives will be the only way to alter their predatory behavior and prevent them from hurting others just like six-year-old Madison Leuchtmann. For sure, knowing human nature, someday blood will be spilled over this lack of decency in the pursuit of profits. I don’t think that time is far off.

    Recently, I had a startling conversation with an acquaintance who one could refer to as a right wing militia-type. He told me that while it was true that shooting a federal politician was a federal crime, shooting one of their family members was not. It basically scared the shit out of me because this fellow was a college educated man who had simply “had enough,” and had already widened his sphere of potential enemy targets to include family members of those whom he thought were responsible for his own troubles. Once society reaches such a critical mass of potential violence it is going to require tremendous efforts of civilized society to pull these people back from the edge of such madness. Once some distraught parent, child, or spouse begins shooting executives of health insurance companies because corporate decisions to increase profits kills their relative all hell will break loose in this country and a real class war could erupt.


  108. livelongandprosper says:

    Does this girl no she’s being used as a propaganda pawn?

    I guess ‘classy’ only goes one way for TTTC. Typical.


  109. Pilotshark says:

    TTTC says:
    Maybe this girl and her mother should visit a childrens cancer hospital. Being deaf wouldn’t be so bad. Just a thought.

    and a very very stupid thought at that!!!!!!!!!


  110. angels81 says:

    TTTC,

    Hope and pray that your son doesn’t come down with something that some pencil pusher at your health insurance company doesn’t want to pay for. What is happening to the six year old, could be you and your family.


  111. WaltTheMan says:

    To those wanting to give, here’e the original article on on the station’s (KTVI)web site: http://www.fox2now.com/news/ktvi-contact-2-girl-denied-insurance-claim-111809,0,2076612.story
    I am sending a note to the reporter.


  112. smidget says:

    This is my favorite:

    TTTC says:

    Maybe this girl and her mother should visit a childrens cancer hospital. Being deaf wouldn’t be so bad. Just a thought.
    November 19th, 2009 at 4:02 pm Vote Up | Vote Down | (-7) | Report Abuse

    What kind of disgusting piece of dog shit do you have to be to even go there?


  113. smidget says:

    This is my favorite:

    TTTC says:

    Maybe this girl and her mother should visit a childrens cancer hospital. Being deaf wouldn’t be so bad. Just a thought.
    November 19th, 2009 at 4:02 pm Vote Up | Vote Down | (-7) | Report Abuse

    What kind of disgusting piece of dog shit do you have to be to even go there? I am atheist, so I don’t believe in hell….but I really hope I’m wrong, so you can burn there.


  114. smidget says:

    Sorry about the double post. Don’t know what happened there. My bad.


  115. missmolly says:

    TTTC says
    November 19th, 2009 at 4:05 pm

    My son is taken care of by myself and his mother. We have private insurance and we are very happy with it.
    _____________________________________________________________

    It’s good that you have private insurance. People who have insurance are likely to be healthier than people who don’t.

    Are you paying for your insurance entirely out of your own pocket? If so, congratulations on being able to afford it. Insuring a family of three isn’t cheap. But your insurance will last until one of you requires some expensive care and your insurance company decides it’s cheaper to rescind your coverage (they’ll find a reason) than to pay your claims.

    Are you covered through your employer? Most Americans who have private coverage are. This is also good. And it will last until your employer can no longer afford to provide that benefit for you. Every year, as the cost of insurance skyrockets, more employers stop providing insurance for their employees, or they opt for programs offering reduced coverage, or they require a bigger portion of the premium to come from the employee.

    And, of course, if you are covered through your employer and you lose your job, you’re screwed. COBRA is not only expensive for you (you’ll have to pay 100% of your coverage), but it’s temporary.

    So I’m glad you have insurance. But do not be so smug as to think you are somehow immune to losing it. It can happen to any of us.


  116. smidget says:

    Vote down pussy is back!

    Grow a spine, vote down pussy, and actually make an argument if you disagree.


  117. livelongandprosper says:

    The reality is you THINK your covered by insurance. The reality is you are blind to all the REAL cases where coverage is denied. Perhaps reality is too scary for you.


  118. smidget says:

    I have visited there. I have watched people die of cancer. My mother has cancer. I know exactly how horrible it is. Don’t you DARE fcuking tell me anything like you goddamn know what’s going on, you piece of shit.

    But you know what? The existence of cancer in children doesn’t mean it’s okay that this child is deaf, andit doesn’t mean that they are fortunate to have been paying for private insurance only to be shit on because these cheap bastards don’t want to shell out for the implant.

    THAT’S why you’re a disgusting excuse for a human being.


  119. tombaker says:

    ttc is the stereotypical righty masturbator,

    rambling on about personality issues and policy strawmen and the other types of drivel that preoccupy mediocre minds,

    endlessly engaged in delusional and paranoid analysis, conducted with faulty tools and methods – thinking better suited to developing B movie scripts than managing a Nation.

    i hope he gets to vote for Huck in 2012. tttc’s brand of constituent deserves exactly that kind of representation.


  120. smidget says:

    I’ve had it with the bullshit spewing out of this subhuman piece of filth.

    I’m off to a new thread. Nothing that this subhuman piece of garbage says will ever make this better. NOTHING. It actually is making the argument that because it could be worse, they should feel lucky. What a rare find. I’m sure it’s mother is so fcuking proud of the compassionate person she raised.


  121. angels81 says:

    TTTC says:

    Well I guess you could be right…It could be worse, she could be you.


  122. smidget says:

    By the way – Based on your logic, maybe all those cancer-ridden children should feel lucky because, hey, at least it’s not Tay Sach’s…right?


  123. NinerFan says:

    People, tttc has been here annoying people since the beginning and I, for one, have yet to see a cogent argument other than something like “I take care of myself and everyone else should do the same.” What is the point of engaging someone who clearly has no arguments? The guy’s like a fly buzzing around your head while you’re trying to do something important. If you can’t swat him away, you at least try to ignore him.


  124. Democrat Soldier says:

    For Profit Insurance = Death Panels

    Something the right-whiners refuse to admit as they push their fabricated lies about any other possible option than for-profit death panel status-quo.


  125. wolfsinger says:

    Had a cancer scare? TTTC, you ARE a cancer.

    You have the audacity at 142 to say that its “unfortunate” that is girl is deaf? You truly do not get it and you like it that way.

    I don’t wish cancer on anyone. Not even you.

    But I don’t wish YOU on anyone, either!


  126. Chyron HR says:

    TTTC, stop beating around the bush and tell us why you don’t think this girl’s insurance carrier should provide the medical care that they are being paid to provide?

    Do you think that this girl should have “worked harder” in the womb so that she could have ear canals?


  127. Shayne says:

    TTTC says:

    I have a son and he’s well taken care of, ty.

    And you’ve taught him so much empathy and compassion I can’t wait until you’re old and he tells you he’s too busy and can’t be bothered worrying about your problems.


  128. Democrat Soldier says:

    #133 – smidget says:
    ————————————————
    “TTTC says:

    “Being deaf wouldn’t be so bad.”
    November 19th, 2009 at 4:02 pm Vote Up | Vote Down | (-7) | Report Abuse

    What kind of disgusting piece of dog shit do you have to be to even go there? I am atheist, so I don’t believe in hell….but I really hope I’m wrong, so you can burn there.

    November 19th, 2009 at 4:14 pm

    TTTC is intentionally blind, deaf and dumb to reality, so he sees no problem in allowing children to suffer from treatable illnesses.

    When right-whiners deafen themselves from the truth, is it any surprise they don’t care at all about the health of children, women, or anyone else?


  129. livelongandprosper says:

    TTTC says:
    livelongandprosper says

    Did you and angels81 attend the same school? Wait……never mind.

    Were you home schooled? Wait…never mind.


  130. wolfsinger says:

    NinerFan at 146 says:

    People, tttc has been here annoying people since the beginning and I, for one, have yet to see a cogent argument other than something like “I take care of myself and everyone else should do the same.” What is the point of engaging someone who clearly has no arguments? The guy’s like a fly buzzing around your head while you’re trying to do something important. If you can’t swat him away, you at least try to ignore him.

    You’re right NinerFan.

    TTTC – Go home.


  131. Shayne says:

    TTTC says:

    Then you’ll agree with me in that this girl won’t die a horrible death from being deaf. Btw, I’ve had loved ones die from cancer and had a cancer scare, myself. It’s very unfortunate that this girl is deaf, but, it could be worse.

    AND IT COULD BE BETTER IF THE INSURANCE HER PARENTS HAVE WOULD PAY FOR THE PROCEDURE A$$HOLE.


  132. carlyt says:

    Since CIGNA also insures the RNC I wonder how many of the RNC’s claims have been denied. My guess is none.

    Someone should investigate how many of the RNC participants in the plan putm in claims for abortions since the plan was instituted in 1991 and how many of all RNC claims were denied by CIGNA since 1991.


  133. thatwriterguy says:

    Why all the arguing? The plain and simple truth is that the GOP could care less about providing a comprehensive health care package for all americans, because we aren’t fetuses. health care for people from cradle to the grave is socialism. Republicans will execute prisoners by the dozens, allow American citizens to die from curable diseases or maladies; but, they will kill you if you decide to have an abortion.


  134. MapleStreet says:

    IF the insurance companies do this while they are under intense scrutiny because of the healthcare debate, what do they do when they aren’t under such scrutiny ?


  135. missmolly says:

    MapleStreet says
    November 19th, 2009 at 5:29 pm

    IF the insurance companies do this while they are under intense scrutiny because of the healthcare debate, what do they do when they aren’t under such scrutiny ?
    ____________________________________________________________

    Whatever they can get away with. And they get away with more when they’re under less scrutiny. I’m sure they’re just waiting…


  136. dbadass says:

    Nope. My desert beagle is safely within reach. ;)

    —pretend tough guys make me laugh…


  137. tombaker says:

    It’s very unfortunate that this girl is deaf, but, it could be worse.

    because nothing would be worse than paying a couple more bucks in taxes, right mr. values??

    like most righties, you’re a sorry, petty, ingrate.


  138. dbadass says:

    Can’t you use words you little sissy?


  139. USCKitty says:

    TTTC says:
    Maybe this girl and her mother should visit a childrens cancer hospital. Being deaf wouldn’t be so bad. Just a thought.

    I’m looking for a sarcasm tag…hmmmm doesn’t seem to be one…I really hope you forgot it…because that’s just…


  140. WaltTheMan says:

    carlyt says at 5:13 PM:
    I tried to vote you up, but the clergy here says that I had already put forward a vote – not true!


  141. had enough says:

    As the physician said this happens on a weekly basis.

    No words to describe the evil, inhumane and calloused method of business the HC insurance companies engage in. And I suppose the CEO’s enjoy their millions in bonuses without even giving a thought of the death and destruction they cause. These bastards do not deserve the give away the House and senate bill will give them.

    I will bet cable news media will not touch this story.


  142. John Hoover says:

    In all fairness though, the article says “This practice has become so rampant in the industry that a recent study by the California Nurses Association found that a whopping 21 percent of all insurance claims filed in the first half of 2009 in the state of California were denied by insurers.”

    California isn’t exactly the easiest place to make money, as an insurance business. I’d just wonder what the ratings are for the other states to see if they are similarly bad.


  143. MapleStreet says:

    Regarding the propaganda pawn arguments above (I don’t agree, but running with that argument).

    Do you realize that her parents are forced into a situation such that going public is the only way they can get the needed care for their daughter ??????


  144. BigGuy says:

    But if Cigna did this type of thing for everyone, think how much their profits would decline. Would you take a dividend check away from an old lady depending upon just her dividends — in addition to her social security, municipal bond interest, cd interest, and annuities — to survive? How can anyone even conceive of treating the egregiously wealthy so horribly? Do you realize that if insurance firms are required to pay for the healthcare of young ladies like this, it could end up with the top 1/100 of 1% of our country no longer being worth over $25 million a household? Do you realize you’ll be forcing them to be worth perhaps less than $24 million per household? Their per capita income (of the top 1/100 of 1%, that is, about 30,000 people nationwide) might even fall from over $250,000 to as little as $245,000?

    OH, THE HUMANITY.

    We could end up with families of 4 forced to survive on less than $1 million per year. How can you live with yourselves to let that happen? I know for a fact, because I’ve seen it, that the enormously wealthy here in NYC on the upper East Side — mainly the folks living at the Plaza and at the Pierre because I’ve spoken to the doormen at both — have consistently tipping taxi drivers at least 50 cents more, on every trip they take. If we just rely upon all the enormously wealthy to give more to all, rather than to tax them more, our financial troubles will all be over in less than one thousand years, for sure. Isn’t that enough? 40 generations from now, your progeny will be doing well — maybe.



Jump to Top

About Think Progress | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy (off-site) | RSS | Donate
© 2005-2010 Center for American Progress Action Fund
View Most Popular

Advertisement

What We're About

Featured

image
Subscribe to the Progress Report



imageTopic Cloud


Visit Our Affiliated Sites

image image
Reports


Got a hot tip?
Have a hot news tip? We'd love to hear from you. Use the form below to send us the latest.

Name:
Email:
Tip:
(required)


imageArchives


imageBlog Roll