ThinkProgress Logo

Politics

Jonah Goldberg Is Bad At Apologizing

Jonah Goldberg has written an “apology” for being “too glib” earlier post about Cindy Sheehan and Nazis. Here’s an excerpt:

I don’t think agreeing with Sheehan on the need to pull out of Iraq makes you akin to Nazis or racists in any meaningful or significant way.

That’s reassuring. Goldberg goes on to make further comparisons between Sheehan and white supremacists:

But, I think Sheehan’s PR operation — including her water-carriers in the liberal press — should no [sic] be surprised that they’re attracting a broad Popular Front which includes a lot of disreputable and unpleasent elements. If you leave yourself no room, rhetorically speaking, between yourself and the crazies don’t be surprised if the crazies respond to your rhetoric.

So Goldberg’s argument is that Sheehan isn’t like the Nazis, she just uses the exact same rhetoric. Nice. In a subsequent post, Goldberg reprints a letter from a fan who says Goldberg is being too “defensive about your original reference to Cindy.” Goldberg includes a link to an article on David Horowitz’s website which notes “Cindy Sheehan’s newfound, seemingly mutual love for anti-Semitic, racist, and neo-Nazi extremists.”

Goldberg’s strategy is to feign an apology to insulate himself from criticism. At the same time, he continues to advance his smear against Sheehan.

Politics

Jonah Goldberg: Sheehan’s Message ‘Resonates’ With Nazis

Jonah Goldberg just posted this on the National Review’s blog, the Corner:

GOOD FOR CINDY! She’s rallied the Nazis to her cause (obviously unintentionally, but it’s interesting how her message resonates in such quarters nonetheless).

Sheehan is a mother who lost her son in Iraq who has a principled, anti-war message. It’s not “interesting” that this message is being manipulated by neo-Nazis to advance their cause of white supremacy. It’s despicable.

Goldberg’s use of the phrase “obviously unintentionally” doesn’t absolve him of anything. He asserts without qualification that “her message” — and not a perversion thereof – appeals to Nazis.

This is the guy NPR chose to fill in for Daniel Shorr.

Politics

McConnell Misleads on Iraqi Constitution

Sen. Mitch McConnell (R-KY), Fox News, 8/28/05:

This is a constitution, certainly, by Middle Eastern standards, that’s astonishing”¦while Islam is mentioned, it is not the controlling law of the country.

Iraqi draft constitution:

Islam is the official religion of the state and is a basic source of legislation. No law can be passed that contradicts the undisputed rules of Islam.

UPDATE: Watch the video.

Security

Moving Beyond Vietnam

Like all analogies, the now clich© comparison between the war in Iraq and the war in Vietnam has its merits and limitations.

On two fronts, it seems to work.

First is the potential impact of declining domestic support for the war as casualties mount without end. President Bush’s astonishing 36 percent job approval rating – lower than Nixon’s at the height of Watergate – can be blamed in large part on the course of the war. Assuming that the military strategy carries on, when will we reach the political breaking point?

Second is the impact of the war on U.S. ground forces. My colleague Larry Korb likes to remind us that Gen. Maxwell Taylor, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff for President Lyndon Johnson, said that while we sent the Army to Vietnam to save Vietnam, we had to withdraw from Vietnam to save the Army. Iraq has had much the same effect, stretching the Army and Marines to their limits through repeated deployments and by unprecedented use of the Guard and Reserves. So much for President Bush’s promise to our armed forces in the 2000 campaign that “help is on the way.” Read more

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up