ThinkProgress Logo

Security

Gonzales Backs Away From Administrations Previous Attacks Over Eavesdropping

On multiple occasions leading up to the November elections, President Bush accused opponents of his domestic warrantless wiretap program of not wanting to listen to terrorist phone calls:

BUSH: In all these vital measures for fighting the war on terror, the Democrats just follow a simple philosophy: Just say no. When it comes to listening to the terrorists, what’s the Democrats’ answer? It’s, just say no. [10/30/06]

BUSH: If the people of the United States don’t think we ought to be listening in on the conversations of people who could do harm to the United States, then go ahead and vote for the Democrats. [10/4/06]

BUSH: The stakes in this election couldn’t be more clear. If you don’t think we should be listening in on the terrorist, then you ought to vote for the Democrats. If you want your government to continue listening in when al Qaeda planners are making phone calls into the United States, then you vote Republican. [10/3/06]

As Glenn Greenwald first noted, during today’s Senate Judiciary Committee hearing, Sen. Russ Feingold (D-WI) confronted Attorney General Gonzales with these accusations. Gonzales denied they referred to elected officials, but instead to unnamed “blogs today”:

FEINGOLD: Do you know of anyone in this country, Democrat or Republican, in government or on the outside, who has argued that the United States government should not wiretap suspected terrorists?

GONZALES: Sure. I mean, if you look on the blogs today, there are all kinds of people who have very strong views about the ability of the government to surveil anyone for any reason. And so…

FEINGOLD: Do you know of anybody in government that has said that?

GONZALES: No. But my remarks — that’s not what I said. [...]

FEINGOLD: [...] Mr. Attorney General, as I said when Director Mueller was here, to me these comments are blatantly false. I think they do a disservice to the office of the attorney general. Falsely accusing the majority of this committee of opposing the wiretapping of terrorists is not going to be helpful to you, to the Justice Department, to Congress or to the American people.

GONZALES: Senator, I didn’t have you or this committee in mind when I made those comments.

[Ed. note: Since this post was published, we replaced a paraphrased transcript with the official, accurate transcript above.]

Politics

Snow: Things Were ‘Going Okay’ In Iraq A Year Ago, No One Anticipated ‘Eruption Of Sectarian Violence’

In today’s press briefing, White House Press Secretary Tony Snow argued that the “picture” in Iraq “constantly changes,” and that while the future looks bleak now, a year ago “Democrats and Republicans both coming back from the region saying, you know, we think things are going okay.” He added that no one anticipated the “eruption of sectarian violence.” Watch it:

[flv http://video.thinkprogress.org/2007/01/snowiraqv.320.240.flv]

The administration has repeatedly tried to claim that Feb. 2006 — when Sunni extremists blew up the Shiia Golden Mosque of Samarra — was the start of sectarian violence in Iraq. While sectarian warfare did skyrocket after that incident, the situation was not “going okay” before that point:

– “The numbers of car bombs, suicide car bombs and roadside bombs all doubled from 2004 to 2005.”

– In 2005, there were more U.S. casualties in Iraq (846) than there were in 2006 (821).

– On Feb. 27, 2005, Knight Ridder quoted then-Iraqi Interior Ministry spokesman Sabah Kadhim warning about sectarian violence, “It’s the beginning, and we could go down the slippery slope very quickly. … Both sides are sharpening their knives.”

– On Sept. 26, 2005, CBS News reported that “there is an undeclared civil war already underway in Iraq, between the Sunni minority who ruled this country under Saddam and the Shiite majority.”

Transcript: Read more

Yglesias

Regulatory Conquest

John Judis details the sweet deal foreign oil companies are about to get in Iraq. Opening the Iraqi oil industry up to foreign investment is a perfectly reasonable idea, but the clearly correct way to do this would be to have different firms offer competing bids so the Iraqi state gets the best deal possible. Instead, the Bush administration just had BearingPoint devise some arbitrary terms that — surprise! — are super-favorable to oil companies.

Politics

FISA court judge wants NSA order shared with Congress.

As TPMmuckraker notes, the Bush administration “has refused to release any part of the order issued yesterday by the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court authorizing NSA surveillance within the United States, saying doing so would risk exposing operational details.” But in a letter to Sens. Patrick Leahy (D-VT) and Arlen Specter (R-PA), the presiding judge notes that she has “no objection” to the material being made available to Congress; it is the Attorney General who refuses to share it.

Politics

Ward Connerly: Affirmative Action Is ‘Boloney,’ People Should Just ‘Frequent The Racetrack’

conrace.jpg Ward Connerly has led the right wing’s fight against diversity in schools, pushing ballot initiatives to ban affirmative action around the nation. Earlier in the week on PRI’s To The Point radio show, Connerly said that schools don’t need to be integrated because people can find other places to “get along with others.” He then offered the racetrack as an alternate venue, noting, “I love horseracing, and I– whenever I can find the time I will frequent the racetrack, and I find myself thrown in with people from all around the globe.” Listen here:

CLICK HERE TO LISTEN TO CONNERLY

But Connerly is missing the point. The effects of diversity in schools can’t be replicated in casual settings such as the racetrack. A recent study by the Center for American Progress concluded:

African Americans and Hispanics learn more in integrated schools. Minorities attending integrated schools also perform better in college attendance and employment.

Minority students who are desegregated at a younger age, in elementary school, also seem to benefit more than those desegregated later in their school careers. Three-fourths of the studies where desegregation occurred in kindergarten showed achievement gains and the effect sizes were larger than in desegregation efforts aimed at older students.

Racial integration is a rare case where an educational policy appears to improve educational equity at little financial cost.

Read full report HERE.

(HT: Julia)

Transcript: Read more

Yglesias

In Retrospect

With all due respect to both Scott Lemieux and Al Gore himself, I don’t actually think Gore’s Commonwealth Club speech before the war was all that prescient. Frankly, I think expecting people to accurately forecast exactly how a war is going to go south is an unreasonable bar to set, so I don’t take anything away from Gore (he certainly didn’t deserve this) but re-reading the speech isn’t like looking into a crystal ball.

By contrast, given the objective difficulty of the task, I think the Iraq section of Howard Dean’s February 12, 2003 speech at Drake University is strikingly spot-on. It’s notable, in particular, because Dean, has never really acquired a reputation as a national security thinker, even among his fans. The Dean speech is also noteworthy for containing a perfectly good proposal for, even at the late date, extricating the USA from the situation in a favorable manner.

Politics

Another Rudy Can’t Fail Joke

It’s a great song. But not only is “America’s Mayor” obviously doomed as a candidate for the Republican nomination, I’m hugely puzzled as to why Stuart Rothenberg would even concede that “the former mayor might make a terrific general election candidate.” At this particular moment in history what’s the constituency for gay rights, small government, and more war? Does that sound like the sort of ideological package you’d want to bundle up in an individual who has no experience whatsoever with any federal issues other than racketeering? People still have generally warm and fuzzy feelings about Giuliani (heck, I have somewhat warm and fuzzy feelings about it) but if it came down to an actual campaign the realty that almost nobody actually wants someone with Giuliani-esque views to be president.

Politics

GAO Chief: Pentagon Stonewalling Release Of Iraqi Troop Preparedness Data

walkerIn announcing his escalation plan earlier this month, President Bush argued the additional U.S. forces were needed to help support Iraqi forces. Whether the escalation makes any difference to the security situation depends in part on the capability of the Iraqi forces.

According to Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki, Iraqi forces have not been properly equipped to handle their missions. “In the interview yesterday, Maliki said many American and Iraqi lives would have been spared if the Iraqi forces were better equipped.” David Walker, head of the Government Accountability Office (GAO), said the Pentagon is refusing to release data on the troop readiness levels of the Iraqi security forces. GovExec reports:

Comptroller General David M. Walker told audience members at a Government Executive breakfast Wednesday that Defense has not complied with repeated Government Accountability Office requests for evaluations of Iraqi troop preparedness, known as transitional readiness assessments. The Pentagon develops those evaluations for Iraqi and U.S. forces, Walker said, and has a statutory obligation to release them to GAO.

[...]

Walker said he expected to find some embarrassing information that would account for the battle over obtaining them. “You just can’t go by how many people you trained,” he said. “Of the people that you’ve trained, how many are left? To what extent do they have loyalty to the unified government of Iraq? To what extent are they properly equipped? To what extent do they have appropriate support?”

Before the Bush administration commits more U.S. troops to Iraq, Congress must know whether Iraqi forces are presently capable of taking on this difficult mission.

Carpetbagger has more.

Older

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up