ThinkProgress Logo

Climate Progress

Sports Illustrated sends clueless supermodels to soon-to-be-inundated Maldives for a blissfully ignorant photo shoot

“We’re kind of channeling, like I said, that old ’70s, ’80s sort of really happy, sunny feeling.”

I apologize in advance for posting a video that some will see as objectifying women — a debate we’ve already had here (see “Supermodel: Why I Took It Off For Climate Change“).

But I think this is a shocking video that must be seen for how it objectifies the Maldives — using the vanishing islands in the Swimsuit Edition as a back drop whose beauty can be exploited and discarded by the priveleged super-rich whose blissfully ignorant comments are so unintentionally ironic that you’d almost think you were watching a video from The Onion:

Read more

Security

Facts Get In The Way Of Conservatives’ Abdulmuttalab Scare Story

Our guest blogger is Ken Gude, Associate Director of the International Rights and Responsibility Program at the Center for American Progress Action Fund.

The revelation that Umar Farouq Abdulmutallab, the failed Christmas Day underwear bomber, has been cooperating with authorities and providing valuable information “for days” demonstrates how irresponsible and ill-informed many conservatives have been in attacking President Obama’s handling of the incident. Using the tough and proven criminal system is producing results, while the Bush administration experiment with these conservatives’ preferred alternative -– the incommunicado detention of Jose Padilla — failed utterly to deliver reliable intelligence.

Conservatives have attacked the decision to charge Abdulmutallab in federal criminal court and give him access to an attorney. Critics like Rep. Pete Hoekstra (R-MI) and Rudy Giuliani went on the attack from the get go, but they were recently joined by former NSA and CIA Director Michael Hayden and Sen. Susan Collins (R-ME).

Gen. Hayden took to the pages of the Washington Post on January 31 to claim “We got it wrong in Detroit on Christmas Day. We allowed an enemy combatant the protections of our Constitution before we had adequately interrogated him.” Sen. Collins delivered the Republican weekly address the day before and castigated “the irresponsible, indeed dangerous, decision on Abdulmutallab’s interrogation.”

It’s terrible when the facts get in the way of a good story.

As we now know, far from being wrong, irresponsible, or dangerous, the path the Obama administration chose for the interrogation of Abdulmutallab is directly responsible for him cooperating with intelligence officials and giving up fresh and actionable intelligence. Abdulmutallab’s family worked with U.S. government officials to encourage him to cooperate, and so, according to them, “because they had complete trust in the US system of justice and believed that Umar Farouq would be treated fairly and appropriately.”

The intelligence gained from Abdulmutallab has been shared widely throughout the intelligence community — and has already produced results. On January 21, Malaysian counterterrorism authorities arrested 10 suspected terrorists tied to Abdulmutallab. The suspected cell was made up of mostly non-Malaysians including two Nigerians who were thought to be part of an international terrorist network.

So by the time Collins and Hayden attacked the Obama administration’s handling of Abdulmutallab’s interrogation it had already produced not just cooperation, but actionable intelligence that allowed an allied government to break up a suspected terrorist cell.

But that’s not all that’s wrong with their argument. Read more

Climate Progress

Stick a fork in the energy-only bill: Lindsey Graham (R-SC) slams push for a “half-assed energy bill”

“If the lesson from health care is let’s not do anything hard, then why don’t we all go home… But if we go home, China won’t.”

If it’s climate and energy independence and clean energy jobs, there is no in between — at least not for the conservative senator from South Carolina.  Today, Graham told a group of 200 business leaders who advocate comprehensive legislation:

Every day we wait in this nation China is going to eat our lunch. The Chinese don’t need 60 votes.  I guess they just need 1 guys vote over there – and that guy’s voted.

What Congress is going to come up here and do all these hard things?  Who are these people in the future? Because we constantly count on them.  I don’t know who they are.  I’ve yet to find them.

So I guess it falls to me and you.  So let’s do it.

Who would have guessed that Lindsey Graham — among the 20 most conservative U.S. Senators in 2008 — would have more of a backbone for a comprehensive bill than many Senate progressives and the President himself!

Yes, as expected, the President set the record straight today on his utterly misinterpreted remarks yesterday that led to TPM’s sensational headline, “Stick A Fork In Cap-and-Trade.”  In remarks to Senate Democrats today, Obama praised Graham’s efforts with Lieberman and Kerry to “find a workable, bipartisan structure so that we are incentivizing and rewarding the future”:

So don’t give up on that.  I don’t want us to just say the easy way out is for us to just give a bunch of tax credits to clean energy companies.  The market works best when it responds to price.

Good statement, but compare it to Graham’s:

Read more

Politics

Will Sarah Palin call on Rush Limbaugh to apologize for saying liberal activists are ‘retards’?

Last week, the Wall Street Journal reported that White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel had called a group of liberal activists “f—ing retarded” last August for planning to air ads attacking conservative Democrats critical of health care reform. On Monday, former Alaska governor Sarah Palin called for Emanuel to be fired for his “slur on all God’s children with cognitive and developmental disabilities.” Emanuel, who had actually apologized for the remark to Special Olympics CEO Tim Shriver the week before, now plans to host “a delegation of advocates, including two people with mental disabilities, at the White House” as part of his effort to make amends. Claiming Emanuel’s regrettable remarks gave him permission, hate radio talker Rush Limbaugh endorsed the language and said the liberal activists truly are “retards”:

LIMBAUGH: Our political correct society is acting like some giant insult’s taken place by calling a bunch of people who are retards, retards. I mean these people, these liberal activists are kooks. They are looney tunes. And I’m not going to apologize for it, I’m just quoting Emanuel. It’s in the news. I think their big news is he’s out there calling Obama’s number one supporters f’ing retards. So now there’s going to be a meeting. There’s going to be a retard summit at the White House. Much like the beer summit between Obama and Gates and that cop in Cambridge.

Listen here:

Palin has called into Limbaugh’s show at least twice. Will she now call on him to apologize for his slur?

Yglesias

Max Baucus: Hero or Villain?

He's got the beet sugar.

Ezra Klein October 15, 2009:

To put it slightly differently, if you imagine that Max Baucus was given responsibility for keeping conservative Senate Democrats committed to health-care reform (and that’s how his role was often described at the beginning, with Kennedy and then Dodd playing the same role for liberals), it appears he has succeeded. Indeed, if Baucus’s schedule partly led to the long month of August, you also have to give him credit for not losing a single Democrat in its aftermath, and for having the savvy to use the release of his bill and CBO score to change the media’s narrative and refocus the conversation on the advancing legislative process.

And today:

The point is that process is, arguably, as important as politics or policy. But it’s not managed with the same ferocious attention as the other two. And that’s a mistake, because it poisons everything else. I don’t think that Democrats made critical political mistakes in the health-care reform fight, and I think their policy decisions were defensible. But they made a number of terrible process errors, from letting Max Baucus spend three months playing footsie with the Gang of Six to holding their concessions for the end of the process rather than running through them at the beginning.

I think today’s version of the argument is correct. But more generally, I think this illustrates that nothing succeeds like success. If the Senate gets its act together and passes a “sidecar” bill of modifications under reconciliation order, then the House will pass the sidecar and pass the original Senate bill and everyone will look like geniuses. If the Senate doesn’t get its act together, then everyone will look like idiots.

Economy

Rep. Miller: Congress’ Jobs Proposals ‘Are Not Adequate To The Scope Of The Problem’

AP090519019815The Senate is expected to finally unveil some new jobs legislation as early as tomorrow, which Sens. Byron Dorgan (D-ND) and Dick Durbin (D-IL) have been working on for the last few months. It will reportedly be in the neighborhood of $80 billion, which means it will be substantially smaller than the $154 billion effort that the House passed at the end of last year.

The Senate bill — which Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) says is part of a “jobs agenda” — will reportedly include small business tax credits, a one-year extension of highway funding, bonds for state infrastructure projects, and a payroll tax credit for hiring proposed by Sens. Chuck Schumer (D-NY) and Orrin Hatch (R-UT).

This makeup reflects the Senate’s evident fear of doing anything that significantly adds to the deficit more than its determination to actually put people back to work. As Rep. George Miller (D-CA), who crafted the House’s plan, said, all of the job proposals that are on the table right now are pretty small-ball compared to the large unemployment problem:

The current proposals, [Miller said] “are not adequate to the scope of the problem. You still have a big gap between the resources we’re offering and where we need to be. Clearly, more has to be done”…”If you’re really going to make a dent in the unemployment numbers, you have to move in the direction of public jobs,” says Miller. “We could create a lot of those jobs — not with a great wage, but a decent wage. We could put people to work in local agencies.”

The Washington Post’s Harold Meyerson agreed, writing that the employment effect of the proposals “isn’t likely to be great.” The hiring tax credit in particular — which would waive the payroll tax for any employer that hires a worker that has been unemployed for 60 days — seems like it will be pretty ineffective. Much like the hiring credit proposed during the stimulus debate, it lends itself to being gamed (think of a restaurant firing its whole wait staff to go and find a bunch of unemployed waiters that it can hire and claim the credit) and has a lot of dead weight cost, as most of the hiring that will take place likely would have occurred even in the absence of a credit (think of the wasteful homebuyer’s tax credit).

And it really can’t be said enough just how weak the labor market is and how pressing it is to get serious about addressing unemployment. By the administration’s own estimates, unemployment will be 9.8 percent at the end of 2010, 8.9 percent at the end of 2011, and 7.9 percent at the end of 2012. That’s too high to let the deficit peacocks get their way and blunt the necessary steps to get people back to work.

Alyssa

Boulevard of Broken Songs

So, I haven’t listened to Green Day in a while, y’all.  But after their sort of weird, off-sounding Grammy performance of “21 Guns” with the cast of their Broadway show American Idiot, I figured I’d check out the song to see if sounded any better in a studio recording.  The verdict, not so much, and the video’s dopey, too:

Maybe I’ve just gotten old, cranky, and establishmentarianism, but I don’t know that putting a guy and girl in a room, shooting the hell out of it, and having her brave her fear of getting shot to pieces to go smooch him out of his funk says a single thing about alienation in America today, political or otherwise.  I’m not unsympathetic to the vagueness and posturing that’s accompanied Green Day’s more recent work: “Boulevard of Broken Dreams” was on my mope rotation for a while in college.  But the generic questions here just aren’t remotely doing it for me.

Yglesias

Predictions Are Hard, Especially About the Future

crystal-ball 1

Tom Friedman is bullish on China “First, a simple rule of investing that has always served me well: Never short a country with $2 trillion in foreign currency reserves.”

Felix Salmon notes that this is a bad rule of thumb:

In fact, if you decided to short only countries whose foreign exchange reserves reached some large proportion of gross world product, you’d be batting 2 for 2 right now as you started shorting China. First you would have shorted the USA in the 1920s, and then you would have shorted Japan in the 1980s.

On the other hand, this seems to set up a converse wrong lesson “always short countries with massive foreign currency reserves.” As Ryan Avent notes, this mostly seems to be a coincidence. Both American policymakers in the 1930s and Japanese policymakers in the 1990s made serious avoidable errors.

For China, I think this just shows that nobody can forecast the future reliably. China’s had a great 20 years. In many ways, its outlook looks bright and you could easily imagine another great 20 years going forward. On the other hand, there are always bumps in the road. And for a country to prosper, policymakers need to navigate those bumps and not drive into ditches. Will China’s leaders continue to make deft decisions? Who knows? Certainly the existence of big reserves aren’t going to magically solve problems for them.

Politics

Conservatives Use Rich Canadian Politician’s Trip To Deny High Quality Care For Millions Of Americans

Newfoundland Premier Danny Williams

Newfoundland Premier Danny Williams

Danny Williams, the Premier of the Canadian province of Newfoundland and Labrador announced this morning that he is heading to the U.S. for heart surgery. The right wing, which often claims that Democrats wish to secretly transform America’s health care into a Canadian single-payer system, pounced on the news as proof that Canada’s system does not work. “Where will all our elitist overlords go,” American Thinkers’ Wesley Clark wrote about William’s trip to the U.S., when we “replace our best-in-the-world medical care system with a technologically second-rate and rationed system like Canada’s[?].”

Anti-health reform group Patients First — a project of Americans For Prosperity — cited Williams’ trip as a reason to oppose health care reform:

For the last nine months, we’ve fought against a government takeover of our health care not only because of its high cost but also its debilitating effect on the quality and accessibility of care to patients. Yesterday, we were given a reminder from fifty-nine-year-old Newfoundland Premier Danny Williams that this is the case in Canada where they have a single payer, government-run health care system…. The Premier’s upcoming trip underscores the brilliance of our system—something that hasn’t been emphasized enough lately. We have state-of-the-art facilities run by trained and caring professionals who quickly diagnose and treat health problems.

Of course, there is little evidence to suggest that Williams couldn’t have received the same heart treatment in Canada. Deputy premier Kathy Dunderdale said that Williams “has gone to a renowned expert in the procedure that he needs to have done,” but did not reveal if he exhausted all of his options in Canada. Canadian health experts, meanwhile are insisting that “when it comes to heart procedures, there’s nothing you can get in the U.S. that you can’t get here. You just have to wait a bit longer, and the accommodations aren’t as nice.” The Cardiac Care Network of Ontario “classifies heart patients for care on three bases: ‘emergent – you’re done right away,’ ‘urgent – you’re done in a few days’ or ‘elective – you may have to wait for a while, because you’re not at any significant risk.’” There is “no question” Williams could have chosen to remain in Canada, Dr. Wilbert Keon, a heart surgery pioneer in Ottawa and a Conservative senator, said.

Williams — a former lawyer and wealthy businessman — is “known as Danny Millions.” To Canadians, Williams’ trip suggests that “if you have money, you can forgo the hassles of public health care and pay for quicker service south of the border,” but it also underscores the high cost of American health care. “Every year, thousands of Americans undergo surgery in other countries” where they can receive the same care “at half the price.” “In 2007, an estimated 750,000 Americans traveled abroad for medical care; this number is anticipated to increase to six million by 2010″ — far outpacing the number of Canadians coming into the United States for medical treatment.

Williams traveled to America to receive the best care, so why are conservatives using his visit as an argument for opposing reform and denying millions of uninsured Americans access to “state-of-the-art facilities” where “trained and caring professionals” can “quickly diagnose and treat health problems”?

Cross-posted on The Wonk Room.

Older

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up