ThinkProgress Logo

Security

FBI: Center For Security Policy Sharia Report Made ‘Unsubstantiated Assertions’

Center for Security Policy president Frank Gaffney finds himself increasingly isolated from the mainstream Republican party. Last year, Gaffney was barred from CPAC after accusing Suhail Kahn, who directed Muslim outreach efforts for the Bush White House, and anti-tax activist Grover Norquist of being moles for the Muslim Brotherhood. And last month, Edward Meese, a former Reagan administration Attorney General and Ronald Reagan Chair in Public Policy at the Heritage Foundation, slammed Gaffney and his allies for disparaging Muslim Americans “solely because of their religion or their background when there’s no basis for it.”

But Gaffney, who has said “it is now public knowledge that nearly every major Muslim organization in the United States is actually controlled by the MB [Muslim Brotherhood] or a derivative organization,” doesn’t hold much credibility with the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI).

As part of a September 2010 Senate Homeland Security committee hearing, “Nine Years After 9/11: Confronting The Terrorist Threat To The Homeland,” the FBI issued written responses to questions posed by committee members. Sen. Joe Lieberman (I-CT) issued the following question to the FBI (see page 123-123 in the PDF):

LIEBERMAN: What is your perspective on the Center for Security Policy’s recent report entitled “Shariah: The Threat To America”?

FBI: The FBI believes the report underestimates the United States Government’s (USG) level of knowledge and understanding of the activities taking place in the United States and overstates the threat posed by those activities. The report also fails to note that some of the threats were disrupted by the USG and are no longer viable, and it makes unsubstantiated assertions regarding limitations on our ability to respond to ongoing threats. Among other reasons, this may be because the report relies on outdated information.

David Yerushalmi, a coauthor of the report and CSP’s general counsel, is the author of the model “anti-Sharia” legislation introduced in over twenty states. As the “anti-Sharia” movement spreads across the country, members of communities facing the Islamophobia campaigns led by Yerushalmi and Gaffney — both of whom are discussed in the Center for American Progress’s report, “Fear Inc.: The Roots Of the Islamophobia Network” — should note that the FBI largely disregarded their report as making “unsubstantiated assertions” and relying “on outdated information.”

Health

Gillibrand Challenger: No One Would Notice If Roe V. Wade Were Overturned

Wendy Long, a conservative judicial activist challenging Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY) said yesterday that no one would miss Roe v. Wade, the landmark Supreme Court case that legalized abortion, if it were overturned. Long clerked for Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas and served as a counsel for the conservative Judicial Confirmation Network, but is perhaps best known for spearheading several inaccurate race baiting attacks against Justice Sonia Sotomayor during her confirmation process.

Long made the abortion comment to Capital New York’s Reid Pillfant at the Manhattan GOP’s annual Lincoln Day Dinner last night:

“I think there is a universal understanding among the legal community that Roe v. Wade was a very flawed legal decision,” she said. “It’s a horrible decision from a constitutional law standpoint, and even liberal law professors will tell you that.

“I believe that the issue of abortion should be left to the people to decide. The Constitution doesn’t mention the word abortion. So I think that’s what it’s really all about. And if Roe v. Wade were overturned tomorrow, nobody would even notice, because the states are legislating their own laws about abortion, completely independent.”

Republican-controlled legislatures are attempting to restrict women’s access to abortion services, but Roe is preventing them from outlawing abortion entirely. Should the precedent be overturned, a lot of women would almost certainly notice as plenty of states would criminalize the procedure.

NEWS FLASH

Ellen DeGeneres Previews JC Penney Commercials | Ellen DeGeneres previewed some of the outtakes from her forthcoming JC Penney commercials on her daytime talk show today. The spots — and DeGeneres’ partnership with the outlet — inspired controversy after the social conservative group One Million Moms accused the store of “jumping on the pro-gay bandwagon” and called for a boycott. Both JC Penney and DeGeneres, however, defended the arrangement and the commercials will air in their entirety during Sunday’s Oscars broadcast:

NEWS FLASH

High-School Student Tells Heartland Institute To Stop Climate Denial Curriculum | Corey Husic, a 17-year-old high school student from Pennsylvania, is sending a message to Joseph Bast, President and CEO, Heartland Institute that he cease and desist his effort to bring climate change denial into our schools. Al Gore’s Climate Reality has a petition to allow people to join Corey in standing up for reality. They have also made a video of children explaining that global warming is fake and gravity is just a theory — because, they say, they learned it in school.

NOTE: One in a series of posts about the Heartland Institute’s inner workings, from internal documents acquired by ThinkProgress Green. ThinkProgress is among several publications to have published documents attributed to the Heartland Institute and sent to us from an anonymous and then unknown source. The source later revealed himself. Heartland Institute has issued several press releases claiming that one document (“2012 Climate Strategy”) is fake and asserting other claims regarding the other documents. ThinkProgress has taken down the “2012 Climate Strategy” document as it determines the document’s authenticity.

NEWS FLASH

Maryland Fox News Affiliate Promotes Petition Overturning Marriage Equality | The Washington Blade points out that WBFF-45, Baltimore’s local Fox affiliate, is already promoting a referendum to overturn Maryland’s marriage equality law, which Gov. Martin O’Malley won’t even sign until next Thursday. The website’s header links directly to a site where people can show their support for the effort to collect signatures and advance the referendum. According to a station employee, the link was posted by “corporate.”

Alyssa

Hollywood’s Self-Imposed Racial Straightjacket

Gavin Polone just keeps getting more awesome:

Because black films are thought of as “niche,” they end up being marketed as if they are for only one group of people. Take Tyler Perry’s Good Deeds, which opens this Friday. It’s a drama about a wealthy black executive whose life changes when he gets to know a single mother in need of help. Marketing for the film seems overfocused on the African-American audience: You’ll see billboards in black neighborhoods and few in areas where white people live. And like Perry’s previous movies, it will probably get little play outside the U.S.: His Why Did I Get Married Too, which did $60 million at the domestic box office, was only released in South Africa and Crotia overseas, taking in just $578,120. But is Good Deeds any more “niche” than 2006′s The Pursuit of Happyness, a big domestic and international hit about a struggling black businessman who takes custody of his son when his wife leaves him? The main difference is that the latter stars Will Smith, so it is not thought of as “niche” and Columbia marketed it all over the world as a broad-based film. But keep in mind that Will Smith only became the star that he is because he was marketed early as a “star” — not a “black star” — and audiences accepted him as such. The egg has to come before the chicken and that means going for it with certain films and actors to break them out of their niche.

Will Smith is not magically different from all other black actors. He’s just marketed that way. And it’s a huge tragedy that nobody is as desperate to make David Oyelowo or Michael B. Jordan as they are to turn Sam Worthington and Channing Tatum from sides of beef into leading men. It does no one any honor or any good to suggest that a low-talent white man is more valuable than a talented black man.

Justice

Why The Republican AG’s Anti-Birth Control Lawsuits Should Be Over Before They Even Start

Nebraska Attorney General Jon Bruning (R)

Republicans oppose the new rule ensuring that women’s insurance will cover birth control, so they’ve now done what Republicans seem to do whenever they disagree with President Obama — sue:

Seven states sued the Obama administration Thursday over its requirement that employers cover contraception in workers’ health plans.

The lawsuit, led by Nebraska’s attorney general, contends that the proposed rule violates Roman Catholic institutions’ rights under the First Amendment to express their beliefs and practice their religion. . . .

All seven attorneys general behind the lawsuit—from Nebraska, South Carolina, Michigan, Texas, Florida, Ohio and Oklahoma—are Republicans.

This lawsuit, of course, is entirely without merit. As Justice Scalia explained in a Supreme Court opinion more than twenty years ago, the Constitution “does not relieve an individual of the obligation to comply with a ‘valid and neutral law of general applicability on the ground that the law proscribes (or prescribes) conduct that his religion prescribes (or proscribes).’” Thus, because the new regulations apply equally to Catholics and non-Catholics alike, there is no constitutional problem.

Nevertheless, it is doubtful that the Republican AG’s lawsuit will even receive a decision on the merits because of a doctrine known as “standing.” Under Article III of the Constitution, a plaintiff is not allowed to file a lawsuit unless they have in some way be injured by the defendant. But the states filing this lawsuit have suffered no legal injury whatsoever because of the new regulations, and they don’t even appear to claim that they law impacts them in some meaningful way. Rather, this lawsuit is simply seven state officials suing because they do not like the way the law impacts someone else — in this case, certain Roman Catholic institutions.

As the Supreme Court explained most recently in Massachusetts v. EPA the Constitution “prohibits” states from suing the federal government “to protect her citizens from the operation of federal statutes,” so a responsible judge will dismiss this lawsuit right out the gate. The states simply have no constitutional authority to be in court in the first place.

Sadly, however, there’s nothing in the Constitution preventing these seven AGs from wasting taxpayer money on a frivolous lawsuit.

NEWS FLASH

Gov. Gregoire: Obama Is The ‘Inspiration’ Behind Washington’s Same-Sex Marriage Bill | Washington Gov. Chris Gregoire (D) praised President Obama’s record on gay rights following a meeting between the President and Democratic Governors, thanking him “for his leadership on GLBT issues.” Gregoire, whose state recently passed a same-sex marriage bill, said that it was through his efforts they were able to achieve what they did, adding, “He’s been the inspiration that allowed the state of Washington recognize that we need to have equality.” President Obama says he is still “evolving” in his support for marriage equality. — Fatima Najiy

Economy

Move Your Money: San Francisco Churches Move $10 Million From Wells Fargo

Angry at the Wall Street banks that were at the center of the financial meltdown, Americans have spent the last six months moving their money to credit unions and community banks in unprecedented numbers. More than 650,000 people moved to credit unions in one month last year, and 5.6 million Americans switched banks in the last three months.

Religious organizations have been at the forefront of movements to get consumers to move their money. The New Bottom Line, a coalition of faith groups, pledged to move $1 billion this year, and before Thanksgiving, churches moved $55 million away from Wall Street banks with pledges to remove as much as $100 million more. This week, churches in San Francisco announced they were moving another $10 million, Faith in Public Life reports:

This week, a group of clergy in San Francisco added another $10 million to that total with an Ash Wednesday press conference calling on Wells Fargo to put an immediate freeze on its foreclosures and repent for their misconduct.

Watch a news report about the group’s efforts:

Wells Fargo issued a statement on the protest, saying, “We make every effort to avoid foreclosure.” The bank’s practices, however, tell a different story. Last July, it foreclosed on a family after telling it to skip payments in order to get a loan modification. It was found to have engaged in discriminatory lending practices, investigated for illegal foreclosures on military veterans, and fined for its subprime lending practices.

According to consulting firms, the nation’s 10 biggest banks could lose $185 million in customer deposits because of customer defections.

Politics

Romney Fails His Own ‘Moral Responsibility’ Test, Can’t Balance His Campaign’s Budget

Mitt Romney has previously announced his support for a constitutional amendment to balance the budget. But balancing the budget is more than just an economic platform for the former governor. In campaign speeches, Romney equates fiscal responsibility with moral responsibility, deeming it immoral to spend more than you take in.

A series of ads lift excerpts from a speech Romney gave in November at an event in New Hampshire in which he says “we have a moral responsibility not to spend more than we take in,” and “it is a moral responsibility to believe in fiscal responsibility. We do and I do.” His own campaign, on the other hand, seems to have missed the memo. Watch it:

That raises serious questions about Romney’s morality then, since in January his campaign spent nearly three times more than it brought in during the month. Financial reports filed with the Federal Election Commission shows that the Romney camp raised about $6.5 million in January, but spent almost $19 million during the same period.

As the Huffington Post noted on Tuesday, if the Romney campaign maintained their rate of spending versus fundraising, the campaign would have run out of money last week.

Older

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up