4 Responses to Why McCain hates renewables but pretends he loves them
McCain has been an opponent of renewable energy all his political life. Why?
- He is a conservative — and that is what conservatives do (see “Who got us in this energy mess? Start with Ronald Reagan“).
- The GOP’s ultra-rich big energy donors don’t like competition and dole out millions to get their way.
- He has long been uncomfortable around cutting edge technology — witness his Internet illiteracy. As a former FCC chair put it, “Basically, John is a technological troglodyte, and proud of it.”
And yet in his speeches and ads and photo ops, McCain links himself again and again to the very energy sources that he has done everything to thwart.
Why does McCain pretend to love what he really hates, like some modern-day Iago to renewables’ Othello [campaign analogy intended]? Because the public understands that clean tech is a core solution to our energy problems, and no serious candidate for president could possibly campaign on McCain’s actual record.
Fundamentally, McCain hopes the public is as gullible as the traditional media. This election will determine whether he is right.
And make no mistake — McCain hates renewables as much as every other conservative ideologue. Tom Friedman has a rare MSM article, “Eight Strikes and You’re Out,” calling out McCain for missing eight straight votes on renewable tax credits, an article that details all the economic harm McCain’s votes have done to this burgeoning global industry — but hey, McCain would be happy to take a break from campaigning to push pointless coastal drilling to please his Big Oil
But these eight missed votes are just the tip of McCain’s anti-renewable iceberg:
As the Center for American Progress has documented, McCain has repeatedly opposed a renewable electricity standard that would have set a minimum requirement for utilities to generate part of their power from sources like wind. Half the states have such requirements, a key reason the industry has not died out entirely in this country. Most European countries have such requirements, a key reason their countries had become leaders. Where was McCain:
In 2002 and 2005, there were votes in the Senate to require utilities nationwide to generate 10 percent or 20 percent of their electricity from renewable energy resources. Sen. McCain voted against renewable electricity every time.
McCain opposes subsides for renewables, as he told Grist in October:
Grist: What’s your position on subsidies for green technologies like wind and solar?
McCain: I’m not one who believes that we need to subsidize things. The wind industry is doing fine, the solar industry is doing fine. In the ’70s, we gave too many subsidies and too much help, and we had substandard products sold to the American people, which then made them disenchanted with solar for a long time.
Seriously! Subsidies for rich, entrenched industries like oil and nuclear are fine, though.
The wind industry is about 1% of US electricity. The nuclear industry is 20%. But McCain supports further subsidies for nuclear power, which has already received nearly $100 billion in direct and indirect subsidies (see “Nuclear Pork — Enough is Enough“), so this country can be like the French and get 80% of all our power from nukes, which would require building probably 500 to 700 more (see “McCain calls for 700+ new nuclear plants (and seven Yucca mountains) costing $4 trillion).
But in spite of this history,
- McCain fills his fraudulent energy ads with pictures out of wind turbines and other clean energy technologies
- He claims over and over again that he supports an “all of the above” energy policy, and
- He actually had the nerve to give a speech on climate in front of a wind turbine manufacturer.
That last hypocritical photo up was actually quite revealing, since conservatives like McCain, or more accurately, conservatives including John McCain, are the main reason McCain has to go to a Danish wind turbine manufacturer to give a climate speech (see “Anti-wind McCain delivers climate remarks at foreign wind company“).
With the major government investments in wind in the 1970s, the United States was poised to be a dominant player in what was clearly going to be one of the biggest job creating industries of the next hundred years. But conservatives started with President Reagan repeatedly gutted the wind budget, then opposed efforts by progressives to increase it, and repeatedly blocked efforts to extend the wind power tax credit. The sad result can be seen here:
That’s right. The United States is now a bit player in an industry we launched (we had 90% of global installed capacity in the mid-1980s) — thanks to conservatives, including McCain.
I guess that renewables are simply too new-fangled for the technologically illiterate McCain.
- The Big Energy Lie — Blog round-up
- EIA says offshore drilling will have “insignificant” impact on prices. Saudis just proved EIA’s point.
- McCain proposes another energy gimmick, Part 1 — pointless battery prize. Is this another $300M to ExxonMobil?
- McCain’s new energy ad — the media is (almost) on to his cynical doubletalk
- Even the Wall Street Journal is baffled by McCain’s “all over the map” energy policies
- President McCain pushes offshore drilling in support of presumptive GOP nominee Bush …
- McCain energy bombshell: More oil + dirty coal. That’s Bush-lite, crude, and not sweet.
- Memo to media: McCain doubletalks to woo conservatives and independents at the same time
- On energy policy, is better than Bush enough?
- McCain, NOT the candidate of change, says no to Boxer-L-W without giga-subsidies for nukes
- Speech, Part 4: Will McCain bring conservatives with him on climate? As if!
- Climate speech, part 3: John McCain loves big government
- McCain speech, Part 2: Relying on offsets = Rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic
- Speech, Part 1: Anti-wind McCain delivers climate remarks at foreign wind company
- McCain reveals cynicism, hypocrisy with call for summer gas-tax holiday, energy budget freeze
- Campaign stunner: McCain “might take [new CAFE standards] off the books”
- McCain’s non-straight talk on nuclear power
- McCain opposes ‘mandatory’ carbon limits
- No climate for old men: Why John McCain isn’t the candidate to stop global warming