Last week, Sen. Joe Lieberman (I-CT) defended the inclusion of expanded offshore drilling in the climate bill he will unveil tomorrow, brushing off the deadly Gulf disaster by saying that “accidents happen“:
There were good reasons for us to put in offshore drilling, and this terrible accident is very rare in drilling. I mean, accidents happen. You learn from them and you try not to make sure they don’t happen again.
Today, Sen. Jeff Bingaman (D-NM), chair of the Senate energy committee, rebuked this attempt to excuse the BP oil disaster as an unforeseeable anomaly. Bingaman’s committee today began the Congressional investigation of the April 20 Deepwater Horizon explosion in a hearing with executives of the companies involved “” BP, Halliburton, and rig owner Transocean. Bingaman noted that this disaster is a failure of technology, people, and regulations, not just an “accident” that was, as BP claimed, an unforeseeable mechanical failure:
At the heart of this disaster are three interrelated systems “” a technological system of materials and equipment, second, a human system of persons who operated the technological system, and third, a regulatory system. Those interrelated systems failed in a way that many have said was virtually impossible. We need to examine closely the way each of these systems failed to do what it was supposed to do. I don’t believe it’s enough just to label this catastrophic failure as an unpredictable and unforeseeable occurence. I don’t believe it’s adequate to simply chalk what happened up to a view that accidents do happen. If this was like other catastrophic failures of other technological systems in recent history “” whether it was the sinking of the Titanic, Three Mile Island, or the loss of the Challenger “” we will likely discover there was a cascade of failures and technical and human and regulatory errors.
Watch it:
After fighting off stricter safety regulations and failing to prepare for a major blowout, BP ludicrously described the disaster as “inconceivable” and “unprecedented.”
The final draft of the climate bill, which Lieberman was devising with Sen. John Kerry (D-MA) and Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-SC), will be unveiled tomorrow without Graham’s involvement. After a political squabble with Sen. Harry Reid, Graham has said that the Senate should not consider comprehensive energy reform until the oil disaster is resolved.
Reposted from the WonkRoom.
Previous in TP Climate Progress
Language Intelligence: Lessons on persuasion from Jesus, Shakespeare, Lincoln, and Lady Gaga
Yup, and after Chernobyl we all said, “Oh well, accidents happen.”
I’m beginning to think the Gulf oil spill is our Chernobyl.
Lieberman is a major accident that keeps on happening.
How is it that he keeps ending up in right in the middle of these things?
Good one, Mark.
Joe [Lieberman] is good at worming his way into a lot of situations. Politicians are phonies themselves, and don’t even recognize the kind of man he actually is.
Sen. Lieberman is quoted as saying: “I mean, accidents happen.”
Right. And “freedom’s untidy.”
“You learn from them and you try not to make sure they don’t happen again.”
Did he really say that? Seems like there’s an unwanted “not” in there.
“[Senator] Bingaman noted that this disaster is a failure of technology, people, and regulations, not just an “accident” that was, as BP claimed, an unforeseeable mechanical failure.”
Sen. Bingaman is correct: BP was another accident-prone culture. Tony Hayward may have gone some way toward changing that, but not far enough. I heard this morning (but haven’t seen it in print yet) that monitoring instruments on the platform showed faults in one of the BOP’s hydraulic systems hours before the blowout.
“Unforeseeable” – wrong. Mechanical devices fail all the time and when subjected to extremes in temperature, salinity, pressure, humidity, and other factors they fail that much faster. Blowout preventers on land (and therefore not subject to some of these factors) fail with alarming frequency.
“Inconceivable” – wrong. As soon as you think it can happen, it probably can, and you’ve just conceived of it. Stupid word. See above.
“Unprecedented” – wrong. Look up Ixtoc 1979. There are other examples, too.
Sen. Bingaman’s assessment that it’s a combination of interrelated factors – failure of technology, people, and regulations – is a fair and accurate evaluation. The questions are: What will the U.S. now do to prevent this from happening again? How will the rest of the world’s oil drilling nations follow suit?
I ask these questions because I know the world isn’t giving up it’s oil addiction by Friday. Nor by next year. And maybe not by the end of the next decade.
Lieberman’s an embarrassment to our state and nation. He’s a loyal fop and apologist for every wealthy special interest out there.