Dog bites man becomes man bites dog

Former GOP Senator says “Don’t undercut Clean Air Act”

As a Republican U.S. senator from Minnesota, I worked to craft a bipartisan law to strengthen the Clean Air Act in 1990.

President George H.W. Bush led efforts to ensure a strong bill, and in the end 89 senators voted to pass it.

One of the central tenets of journalism, attributed to various sources, is “When a dog bites a man, that is not news, because it happens so often. But if a man bites a dog, that is news.”

That is why the media loves contrarians, say, environmentalists who like nuclear power or, these days, national Republicans who support the EPA and action on global warming.

A long time ago in a galaxy not so far far away the fact that a Republican Senator would support strengthening the Clean Air Act was strictly dog bites man.  Now it is news.  Well, it would be news, if we could find such a Senator.

The best we can do is a former Republican Senator, David Durenberger in a Star Tribune op-ed, “Don’t undercut Clean Air Act.”  Here’s the rest:

Now, more than 20 years later, Republicans and Democrats in Washington are working to roll back our progress.

The Clean Air Act is one of the great public-health achievements of American history — especially for kids.

The act has prevented more than 18 million child respiratory illnesses and 300,000 premature deaths, and has dramatically reduced the number of children with IQs below 70 by taking lead out of gasoline.

Cutting mercury, soot, smog, carbon dioxide and dioxins means fewer Americans suffer from asthma attacks and respiratory diseases. Further, it will prevent more than 250 million skin cancer cases by 2075 by phasing out ozone-depleting chemicals.

When we passed the sweeping Clean Air Act amendments in 1990, we sought to ensure that the Environmental Protection Agency had the tools to tackle new and emerging air pollution problems.

Today, the EPA is in the process of acting on recent scientific findings to update and modernize air pollution standards as we envisioned over two decades ago.

To this day, I remember the passage of the Clean Air Act as a model for the way national policy should be made where there are a variety of economic, regional and ideological forces at work to challenge its effectiveness as law.

The cooperation between President Bush and the Democratic leadership of the Senate enabled us to move toward practical, realistic and economically feasible health standards and implementation deadlines.

It enabled the Senate to withstand pressures from the House to increase the regulatory pressure. I can’t imagine today anyone wanting to undo an effort that was so fair and so effective.

My understanding of recent public opinion is that Americans — Democrats, independents and Republicans — all support a strong Clean Air Act. This Congress is out of step with both public opinion and history.

David Durenberger represented Minnesota in the U.S. Senate from 1978-1995 and was a member of the conference committee that crafted the Clean Air Act amendments in 1990.

Yes, Americans strongly support the Clean Air Act and even greenhouse gas regulation (see 63% of Americans say “EPA needs to do more to hold polluters accountable and protect the air and water”).  But the GOP doesn’t care.

The dogs may be safe from us, but we aren’t safe from ourselves….

3 Responses to Dog bites man becomes man bites dog

  1. BillD says:

    I saw something today about a 16% cut in the EPA from 2010 levels in the latest budget deal. I hope that Joe can provide more information about how the budget cuts might impact evironmental enforcement, NSF, NIH and other research and stimulus for alternative energy.

    At some point there has to be a more general backlash against the GOP targeting of green industry, clean air and water etc. At least I hope so.

  2. sault says:

    Two things have to happen for the public to get really pissed off at the GOP for their radical behavior:

    1. Democrats from the President on down need to stop being wishy-washy and tell the American people what is actually happening. They need to make it clear that a bunch of extremists want to roll back a lot of programs and precedents that are extremely popular, environmental protection being one of them. Since the GOP hasn’t dealt in good faith with the Dems for over 10 years, it’s time to stop coddling them and bring them to the table fearing for their electoral lives.

    2. The news media has to stop dropping the ball with their false attempts at balance. Sometimes, one side is just wrong and the media is showing a bias by omission when they don’t call people out on their BS.

    Neither of these things look like they are going to happen, so the GOP knows they can get away with this crap.

  3. Wes Rolley says:

    sault (#2) I really agree with your 2nd point. The media is getting better, but there is still has a long way to go. If only they would change the story from the tale of two ideas to a story about the man who lied and lied and lied until no one believe a word they said. It is rather like the establishment GOP wants to treat Trump the birther, calling him out on it before it is too late. We need to call out the Hall’s and the Inhofe’s before it is too late.

    We all have the chance to write a letter to your local paper for Earth Day. Do it. I arranged to have my local paper column run on 4/22. Everyone should use that as an opportunity. Then, make every day into Earth Day.