Last week, TP and CP wrote about how FSU accepts funds from petrochemical billionaire Charles Koch in return for control over its academic freedom. The story is taking off:
- “Under fire this week for an unusual deal that gives a billionaire donor control over some faculty positions, Florida State University President Eric J. Barron has insisted that his institution’s academic freedom has not been compromised. But internal FSU emails show that top academic officers who reviewed drafts of the 2008 agreement with the Charles G. Koch Charitable Foundation had precisely those concerns.”
- “Some faculty members at Florida State University say their school has sold out to a conservative group that dangled a big donation. Recently released details show the university gave the Charles Koch Foundation a role in hiring decisions, in exchange for a big grant.”
ThinkProgress details how FSU is just the tip of the (rapidly melting) iceberg of Koch’s efforts to control academic freedom in universities around the country:
The simmering controversy sheds light on the vast influence of the Koch political machine, which spans from the top conservative think tanks, Republican politicians, a small army of contracted lobbyists, and Tea Party front groups in nearly every state.
As reporter Kris Hundley notes, Koch virtually owns much of George Mason University, another public university, through grants and direct control over think tanks within the school. For instance, Koch controls the Mercatus Center of George Mason University, an institute that set much of the Bush administration’s environmental deregulation policy. And similar conditional agreements have been made with schools like Clemson and West Virginia University. ThinkProgress has analyzed data from the Charles Koch Foundation, and found that this trend is actually much larger than previous known. Many of the Koch university grants finance far right, pro-polluter professors, and dictate that students read Charles Koch’s book as part of their academic study:
- West Virginia University: As ThinkProgress reported last year, Koch funds an array of academic programs at West Virginia University, a public university. One Koch-funded academic at WVU, economics professor Russell Sobel, has written a book blasting regulations of all types. He even argues that less mine safety regulations will make coal miners more safe. As the St. Petersburg Times reported, a similar arrangement has been made with WVU as with FSU in accepting at least $480,000 from Koch.
- Brown University: The Charles Koch Foundation funds the Political Theory Project at Brown, which provides funding for “Seminar Luncheons for undergraduates, academic conferences, research fellowships for graduate students, support for faculty research, and a postdoctoral fellowship program.” Amity Shales, a pop-conservative writer who argues that the New Deal made the Great Depression worse, an odd theory promoted by Charles Koch himself, has been a featured speaker at the Koch-funded Project at Brown. Moreover, Koch’s donation of at least $419,254 to Brown has underwritten a number of research projects in the Economics and Political Science deparments, including a paper arguing that bank deregulation has helped the poor.
- Troy University: The Charles Koch Foundation, along with the Manuel Johnson and the BB&T Foundation, provided Troy University, a public university, a gift of $3.6 million to establish the Center for Political Economy last year. The Center’s stated goal is to push back against the belief following the financial crisis that markets need regulation. Notably, the entire Advisory Council for the Center is made up of Koch and BB&T-funded professors at other universities, including Russell Sobel at West Virginia University and Peter Boettke at George Mason University. Currently, the Center’s only staffer, Professor Scott Beaulier, is a board member of the ExxonMobil-funded attack group, American Energy Alliance, and a former staffer for Koch’s think tank at George Mason.
- Utah State University: The Charles Koch Foundation has given nearly $700,000 to Utah State University, mostly for the Huntsman School of Business. The money has been used to hire five new faculty members, and establish a program for undergraduates to enroll and learn about Charles Koch’s “Science of Liberty” management theory. Professor Randy Simmons, the “Charles G. Koch Professor of Political Economy” at the school, helps select students “” who must provide information about their ideological interests in their application form “” to the Koch program. Simmons also works for several Koch-funded front groups, and writes papers against environmental regulations. Charles Koch’s book, “The Science of Success,” a book Forbes mocked for proclaiming a “Marxist faith in ‘fixed laws’ that govern ‘human well-being,’” is part of the required reading list for the program. A representative for Utah State did not return ThinkProgress’ calls about conditional strings attached to the Koch grant.
Charles Koch Foundation grants, along with direct Koch Industries grants, are distributed to dozens of other universities around the country every year, to both public and private institutions. Some of the programs, like the Charles Koch Student Research Colloquium at Beloit College, are funded by grants of little over $130,000 and simply support conservative speakers on campuses. We have reached out to several of the schools to learn more about the agreements, but none so far have returned our calls.
Budget constraints and other problems at universities have allowed a small set of oligarchs to use school donations to interfere with academic integrity on campuses. A group of hedge fund managers, working through the Manhattan Institute’s Veritas Fund, have created entire departments dedicated to advancing failed supply side ideas and climate skepticism. John Allison, the former CEO of BB&T Bank, a bailout recipient, has used his corporation’s money to force college campuses to adopt Ayn Rand readings into their programs.
Overall, Koch is still a dominate player when it comes to meddling with academic integrity. Part of the effort is coordinated through operatives like Richard Fink, who doubles as a vice president at Koch’s corporate lobbying office. Through an organization called the Association of Private Enterprise Education, Koch organizes these corporate-funded university departments into a powerful intellectual movement. The organization allows Koch staffers in Washington DC to request certain types of studies, interfere with hiring decisions, and reward loyal free market academics with hefty research grants.
Related Posts:
- From promoting acid rain to climate denial “” over 20 years of David Koch’s polluter front groups
- What we’re up against: Polluter-funded Tea Party climate zombie astroturfing
- Must-see video: Polluter-funded Smithsonian exhibit whitewashes danger of human-caused climate change
- Tea party pollutocrat David Koch denies climate change, shrugs off his carbon pollution
- Rolling Stone names 12 politicians and executives blocking progress on global warming
Previous in TP Climate Progress
Language Intelligence: Lessons on persuasion from Jesus, Shakespeare, Lincoln, and Lady Gaga

Strictly speaking, this is not “limiting academic freedom”, because they are funding academic points of view that they prefer, not preventing other points of view from being presented.
It’s more like providing an amplifier and electrical power to a rock band on the public square: It doesn’t prevent someone from playing a flute, but it sure does make it easy to drown him out.
Of course, it’s closely related to the “Citizens United” case, in which it was decided that funding selection is free speech, and corporations are entitled to free speech.
Interesting Constitutional issues…
Though it isn’t the Koch brothers, the sell-out of Texas A&M University by governor Perry to Jeff Sandefer and his father is much more comprehensive than these examples.
The Kochs would bribe the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court and the Pope if they could get away with it. I think they enjoy being evil.
Curiously enough, FSU is also the home of economist James Gwartney, co-author of a book that received the lowest grade in a review I did last year on the treatment of climate change in economics textbooks. CP covered that here, noting that the book (Gwartney, Stroup, Sobel, and Macpherson) says things like “[T]he earth has experienced both warming and cooling trends in the past, and the current warming trend may well be unrelated to the emissions of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases into the atmosphere.”
The Koch’s are behaving as expected, like parasitic wasps – destroy academic rationality and credibility from the inside out.
Wait for their placemen to start undermining the science curriculum of Universities across the US and next stop Europe, using the creationist playbook. Thus they will also probably extend to setting up their own Universities (somebody will probably pitch in and tell me that they already have) not just for the science but for the lawyers to fight any regulatory battles. After all this was what Liberty University, Lynchburg, Virginia was all about.
Harrumph, Charles Koch is to Ayn Rand as Joseph Stalin is to Karl Marx. Academic corruption indeed…
If you are against private donors funding faculty lines at institutions, are you also against the Saudi government funding Islamic studies programs and professors at Harvard and Georgetown? http://www.nytimes.com/2005/12/13/education/13donation.html What about private companies or individuals funding cancer research? If you are against private funding in universities altogether, fine, but you can’t favor funding from some and not from others and maintain a principled viewpoint.
Let’s also be clear about our terms, specifically “academic freedom.” How exactly is Koch thwarting academic freedom? Academic freedom, according to Merriam-Webster means “freedom to teach or learn without interference.” Koch is not stopping anyone else from teaching or researching, he is simply supporting academic work that is consistent with his worldview. On the other hand, to stop professors from receiving grants from Koch WOULD impede on academic freedom.
[JR: Normally donors don't get to pick staff.]