Critic Of Offshore Drilling Safety Regulation Helps Run Company That Owns Failed Natural Gas Rig


A fire is seen on the Hercules 265 drilling rig in the Gulf of Mexico off the coast of Louisiana, Wednesday, July 24, 2013. (Credit: AP Photo/Gerald Herbert)

The Hercules 265 drilling rig, ablaze until Thursday morning. (Credit: Coast Guard)

The executive VP of a company that owns an offshore natural gas rig that suffered a blowout Tuesday is an active critic of stronger offshore drilling regulations. Though federal officials confirmed the gas flow had stopped on Thursday morning, the accident raises serious concerns about the safety improvements taken since the disaster caused by a blowout three years ago aboard the Deepwater Horizon.

On Tuesday morning in the Gulf of Mexico, the Hercules 265 drilling rig had been drilling a natural gas well and when gas began spewing uncontrollably (video) from the well, the crew of the rig tried to use a blowout preventer to shut down the well’s flow of gas. This is the same device that failed to close the out-of-control oil well under the Deepwater Horizon, and the blowout preventer under the Hercules 265 also failed to shut down the flow of gas.

Once the conditions aboard the rig became too dangerous, all 44 workers evacuated on two lifeboats. They watched the uncontrolled gas continue to jet into the atmosphere, and the rig caught fire Tuesday night. It burned through Wednesday, and some time Wednesday evening or Thursday morning, sand or debris shifted underwater and “bridged over“, which seemingly plugged the leaking well. The fire has slowly dissipated as the remaining gas burned up. Ironically, because methane (which is the prime ingredient of natural gas) is such a potent greenhouse gas, the fact that it burned for most of the accident is actually slightly better for the climate and the environment.

There is no guarantee that the natural bridge currently blocking the free flow of gas will not open up again.

Hercules Offshore, which owns the rig that was drilling the well, had been attempting to drill a relief well to lower the pressure on the initial well when the spewing gas stopped. The company may still drill another relief well or pursue a tactic familiar to anyone who followed the Deepwater Horizon disasterL “top kill.”

Since it has been three years since the BP spill, what progress has been made in strengthening safety equipment and protocols on offshore wells?

In May, federal regulators assured the industry that any proposed new rules to strengthen offshore emergency drilling protocols would be implemented with with plenty of time for industry to adapt. Earlier in July, twelve Republican lawmakers sent a letter to James Watson, director of the Interior Department’s Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement pressing for more input from industry on what they called “sweeping new rules” on blowout preventers and offshore drilling disaster prevention standards.

Hercules Offshore’s executive VP is Jim Noe. Noe is also executive director of the Shallow Water Energy Security Coalition, which said on the three-year anniversary of the Deepwater Horizon disaster:

The continued, even perpetual, regulatory uncertainty limits long-term business confidence. It also reflects a fundamental misconception: that any new regulation makes things safer than they were before, even if we haven’t fully analyzed the effectiveness of previous regulations. Spending too much time complying with new and ever changing regulations can distract us from ensuring that industry is focusing on holistic and practical risk management.

Newly-minted Senator Ed Markey (D-MA) noted on Wendesday that Congress needs to ensure that blowout preventers are failsafe:

“Congress still needs to act to ensure that oil companies are drilling safely offshore and that companies are held fully accountable for any spills, including when natural gas is released into the environment. Blowout preventers also need to be failsafe, and this recent incident indicates that they may still be not.”

6 Responses to Critic Of Offshore Drilling Safety Regulation Helps Run Company That Owns Failed Natural Gas Rig

  1. Merrelyn Emery says:

    “Holistic and practical’ is industry code for as minimal as possible. Effective risk management would cut into profits and that’s like tucking into a juicy sacred cow, ME

  2. Spec says:

    I imagine their insurance provider has a different view on safety regulation.

    Well, at least it is great that no one was hurt.

  3. catman306 says:

    Or were they self-insured?

  4. Neo says:


    How the heck would ou know? Do you personally know anyone in the oil and as industry? Statements such as this are little more than pure demagoguery. I suggest you go to work on an rig for a couple of months and then Mae your opinion known.

  5. Merrelyn Emery says:

    As it happens, I have worked with the oil as well as some other dangerous industries. Following regs costs money and any worker will tell you how they are ducked, particularly the environmental and OHS. Why do you think so many resist unionization? But don’t take my word for it – just look at the evidence from legal cases over the years, ME

  6. Oty says:

    how muck leaks of oil lost ? there must be cost a fortune….