ThinkProgress Logo

Climate Progress

Exorcising Gale Norton

Our guest blogger is Tom Kenworthy, a Senior Fellow at the Center for American Progress Action Fund.

It’s been too long in coming, but today Interior Secretary Ken Salazar is repealing a sneak attack on millions of acres of pristine public lands in the West launched by his Bush administration predecessor Gale Norton.

In a lamentable tenure that included corruption and ethics scandals, attacks on scientific integrity, and a campaign to turn federal lands into a playground for the oil and gas industry, Norton’s backroom “no more wilderness” deal with a Utah Governor in 2003 was among her most egregious betrayals of the public trust. In it Norton repudiated the Bureau of Land Management’s long accepted authority to protect public lands possessing characteristics that would qualify them as wilderness under the 1964 Wilderness Act.

That authority, accepted by every previous administration — Democratic and Republican — since the mid-1970’s, allowed Bureau of Land Management (BLM) to shield special places among the 245 million acres it manages from development, giving Congress the opportunity to decide whether to include them in the national wilderness system. Once developed, such as by roads constructed for oil and gas activities, such areas are rendered forever ineligible for wilderness designation.

Though it affected federal lands in several western states, the Norton policy had by far its biggest impact in Utah, where it removed the umbrella of protection from millions of acres of BLM-managed land. It was a disastrous policy mistake, recognized as such by moderate western newspapers such as the Salt Lake Tribune and Denver Post, and thoroughly repudiated by dozens of legal experts on public lands law.

The anti-conservationist right will no doubt launch predictable attacks on Salazar for undoing the Norton policy. They will describe it as a Washington “land grab” that “locks up” vast areas of public land, hamstrings local economies, kills jobs, and keeps us from achieving energy independence. As usual, they will ignore the facts in their rush to shill for narrow interests intent on plundering our public lands. Their voices are a modern echo of those who in generations past opposed the creation of most of our iconic national parks and monuments, places that today are revered by most Americans and are powerful tourism-based economic engines throughout the West.

Norton’s rejection of Interior’s authority to protect special places on federal lands from development was a radical departure: Even James Watt’s Interior Department during the Reagan administration agreed that the BLM has the authority to continually update its inventory of wilderness quality lands and safeguard them so they remained eligible for permanent protection by Congress.

Salazar’s overturning the Norton policy won’t affect many public uses of these lands including hunting, fishing and livestock grazing. Off-road vehicle use could be curtailed in these special places, but vast areas of western public lands remain open to motorized recreation.

With a new, more conservative Congress taking office next month, and with retrograde lawmakers like Rep. Doc Hastings (R-Oregon) and Rep. Rob Bishop (R-Utah) assuming leadership of key panels that oversee public lands, the oil and gas industry is already firing up its propaganda machine to demand a “drill baby drill” resurgence.

Earlier this month, the Western Energy Alliance, a regional oil and gas trade association, lamenting a recent drop in oil and gas leasing and development in the West, implied it was the result of Obama administration policies. Two months ago, the alliance’s Utah representative Lowell Braxton charged that “Federal land policies are stifling oil and gas activity and preventing $1.8 billion of investment and about 7,500 associated jobs in Utah.”

The Western Energy Alliance totally overlooks simple facts: The decline in oil and gas activity on western public lands is largely due to market forces, and producers have millions of acres of federal land under lease that they have yet to develop.

With vast new quantities of shale gas recently discovered in fields stretching from Texas to New York State, producers are much less interested in exploring hard-to-access places on public lands in the remote west, such as those affected by Salazar’s new policy.

The charge that oil and gas companies are being denied reasonable access to federal lands is ludicrous. At the end of fiscal 2009, the latest year data is available, more than 45 million acres of federal land were under lease to the oil and gas industry, but only about 13 million of those acres were actually under development, leaving the industry an already-leased-but-not-developed inventory of 32 million acres. That’s more than enough for the foreseeable future by any reasonable measure. Ken Salazar’s new directive on wilderness quality western public lands is rightly tilting the scales back toward a proper balance between protection and development.

The year of living dangerously. Masters: “The stunning extremes we witnessed gives me concern that our climate is showing the early signs of instability”

Munich Re: “The only plausible explanation for the rise in weather-related catastrophes is climate change”

A year of deadly record-smashing weather extremes from Nashville to Moscow, from the Amazon to Pakistan, ended with staggering deluges from California — “Rainfall records weren’t just broken, they were obliterated” — to Australia:

More than a year’s rain fell in Carnarvon in just 24 hours this week.  A monsoonal low hovering over the Gascoyne dumped a 24-hour record 204.8mm, smashing the previous record of 119.4mm set on March 24, 1923.

NASA reported that it was the hottest ‘meteorological year’ [December to November] on record and likely to be the hottest calendar year.

Uber-meteorologist and former NOAA Hurricane hunter Dr. Jeff Masters of Weather Underground reported, “The year 2010 now has the most national extreme heat records for a single year–nineteen. These nations comprise 20% of the total land area of Earth. This is the largest area of Earth’s surface to experience all-time record high temperatures in any single year in the historical record.”

This was a year that the scientific literature became clearer that global warming is driving more extreme weather, hell and high water (see Study: Global warming is driving increased frequency of extreme wet or dry summer weather in southeast, so droughts and deluges are likely to get worse) — and it is likely to get much, much worse if we stay anywhere near our current emissions path (see “A stunning year in climate science reveals that human civilization is on the precipice” and “Must-read NCAR analysis warns we risk multiple, devastating global droughts even on moderate emissions path“).

But this was also very much a year of living dangerously right now for people around the globe:

As Craig Fugate, who heads the U.S. Federal Emergency Management Agency, put it last week, “The term ’100-year event’ really lost its meaning this year.”  Tamino calculates (at length) that global warming made the Moscow heat wave roughly eight times more likely:  “Without global warming, this once-in-a-century-or-two event would have been closer to a once-in-a-millenium event.”  On our current emissions path, Russia’s grain-export-ending heat wave and drought could be a once every decade event — or even more frequent.

I queried both Masters and Dr. Peter Hoeppe, Head of the Geo Risks Research Department at Munich Re, one of the world’s leading reinsurers, about this astonishing year.  Here’s what Masters wrote me:

Read more

Energy and global warming news for December 23: More scrapped coal plants, oil hits $90, and Big Oil works to whitewash the history of BP disaster

More scrapped plans, retirements for U.S. plants in 2010

Over the course of this year, more U.S. coal-fired power plants were tapped for retirement and more proposed plants were canceled than in 2009, according to an end-of-year report by the Sierra Club, which is fighting the continued use of coal.

Read more

Global Boiling: Year 2010 In Climate Photos

The headlines of 2010 were driven by global warming disasters — involving the dangers of fossil fuel extraction or the biblical might of the climate they have polluted. Hundreds of thousands of people died in climate disasters, and hundreds of millions more affected by floods, droughts, storms, and wildfires. Below is a small selection of the most striking and iconic news photography of 2010, from the BP disaster to the Pakistan floods. Meanwhile, polluters successfully blocked enactment of climate policy or oil industry regulation in the United States, as the Obama administration advanced health care reform and other legislative priorities.


OILPOCALYPSE: A bird is mired in oil on the beach at East Grand Terre Island along the Louisiana coast on Thursday, June 3, 2010. Crude oil flowed from a hole in the bottom of the Gulf of Mexico for three months after the Deepwater Horizon oil rig exploded and sank on April 20th, 2010. (AP Photo/Charlie Riedel)


SUDAN DROUGHT: Two-year-old Dhoal, a child suffering from severe malnutrition, is swarmed with flies as he cries on a bed at a local hospital in the southeast Sudanese town of Akobo on April 10, 2010. The population in Akobo and the surrounding counties in the Jonglei state in southern Sudan are suffering from the effects of a devastating drought and tribal conflict. Aid officials have called Akobo the “hungriest place on earth,” after a survey showed that 46 percent of children under five are malnourished. (ROBERTO SCHMIDT/AFP/Getty Images)


RUSSIA BURNING: As central Russia suffered through its hottest summer in thousands of years, hundreds of wildfires swept the countryside, causing billions in damage. Russians here try to stop a fire from spreading near the village Golovanovo, Ryazan region, on August 5, 2010. (NATALIA KOLESNIKOVA/AFP/Getty Images)

Read more

Energy Information Administration projects U.S. will lead world into dangerous levels of CO2 emissions

Fortunately, EIA projections are usually wrong!

The U.S. Energy Information Administration has projected that the United States will lead the world into levels of CO2 emission over the next twenty five years that would almost certainly lead to catastrophic global warming.  Brad Johnson has the story (and I add some comments at the end).

Read more

˜Tis the season to manufacture

Why “Made in America” is the gift that keeps on giving

Schott Solar employee Jose Zaragosa trims a photovoltaic panel in a glass room at the company’s plant in Albuquerque, New Mexico [in an AP photo]. Clean energy technology represents a promising area for innovation-led investment where the United States has historically led in dramatic growth and technology-led productivity gains, in turn creating new, well-paying jobs.

Tis the holiday season, when Santa’s workshop hums with elfin activity. But what about America’s workshop?
In this cross-post, CAP’s Kate Gordon , Bracken Hendricks, and Lisbeth Kaufman reflect on the state of America’s manufacturing sector, and our prospects for economic recovery if we lose the ability to make things here at home.

Read more

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up