On Taxes, McCain Was A Solid Conservative First

Posted on


Our guest bloggers are James Kvaal and Robert Gordon, senior fellows at the Center for American Progress Action Fund.

norq.JPGJohn McCain is campaigning for president on a platform of budget-busting tax cuts for the rich. In fact, he would cut taxes for the top 1 percent of taxpayers by nearly $150 billion a year.

But McCain opposed Bush’s tax policies before he supported them. So would he govern as the moderate on taxes he was in 2001 or the enthusiastic tax-cutter he is today? McCain’s true intentions were one issue discussed by Gene Sperling and Jared Bernstein at McCain U earlier today.

The easiest way to know what McCain would do as president is to ask him – and he says he wants deep, regressive tax cuts.

But his voting record also matters. And it’s true that, on taxes, McCain was a moderate before he was a conservative. But he was also a conservative before he was a moderate. According to Grover Norquist’s right-wing tax group, Americans for Tax Reform, McCain’s record has three stages:

– Between 1994 and 1997, McCain voted with ATR 100 percent of the time, demonstrating a “Reagan-like” record on taxes.

— Between 1998 and 2003, McCain’s ratings were lower, reaching a low of 55 percent in 2001.

— Since 2004, ATR writes, “McCain has slowly tried to reinvent himself as a taxpayer friendly senator.”

It’s not McCain’s current right-wing tax agenda that is the exception to his career-long record. Instead, it’s his opposition to the Bush tax cuts that was the break from his past.