ThinkProgress Logo

Economy

Education

Oklahoma State Rep. Says Race To The Top Was Designed By The United Nations

Oklahoma State Rep. Sally Kern (R)

Oklahoma State Rep. Sally Kern (R)

Today, applications for the second round of Race to the Top — a program pioneered by the Obama administration providing $4 billion in competitive grants to states that implement education reforms — are due to the Department of Education. Delaware and Tennessee won a collective $600 million in the competition’s first round, but that still leaves $3.4 billion to be dispersed.

At least nine states have opted out of the competition this time around, after they fared poorly in the first round and failed to enact the kind of reforms necessary to bolster their applications. But many other states are passing legislation lifting caps on charter schools, improving teacher evaluations, and adopting the National Governors Association’s common academic standards, in order to boost their chances.

One of the states looking to adopt the common standards and establish a new teacher evaluation system was Oklahoma, and the debate on the floor of the Oklahoma state House of Representatives took a turn for the absurd, with one member claiming that the Race to the Top program was designed by the United Nations:

Rep. Sally Kern, R-Oklahoma City, said she was concerned that some of the standards being proposed to win the federal government’s Race to the Top grant were developed by the United Nations. “These are standards that are not American standards,” she said.

Kern, a former teacher, said she also is leery about the program because it is developed by Democratic President Barack Obama. “Race to the Top is Obama’s baby,” Kern said. “With this money will come strings…I’m not willing to sell out our children.”

For the record, the common academic standards that are worth 40 points on the Race to the Top application were designed by the National Governors Association, not by the Obama administration or the United Nations. But Kern is not the only one making nonsensical claims about the program. This morning, Gov. Bob McDonnell (R-VA) falsely claimed that adopting common standards would actually make Virginia lower its academic standards.

After being subjected to such hysterical rhetoric, Oklahoma’s legislature initially voted down the reform package. However, to its credit, it quickly reversed course just one day later and voted to pass the package. One lawmaker who switched his position said that his first vote had been based on “bad information.” “I’m going to give it the benefit of the doubt. We need these reforms,” said Rep. Paul Wesselhoft (R).

In addition to adopting the NGA’s common standards, the reform package passed in Oklahoma includes a new regimen for evaluating teachers that employs a number of criteria to rank teachers as superior, highly effective, effective, needing improvement or ineffective. Those judged to be ineffective for two consecutive years can be let go, while effective teachers will be eligible for bonuses.

Will Congress Let Deficit Hysteria Undermine Support For Laid Off Workers?

Unemployed workers at a job fair in Ft. Lauderdale, Florida

Unemployed workers at a job fair in Ft. Lauderdale, Florida

When the Senate comes back from its Memorial Day recess next Monday, one of the most pressing issues that it needs to address is the current expiration of extended unemployment benefits and other social safety net programs for laid off workers. On Friday, the House passed an extension (which did not create a new tier of benefits for workers who have completely exhausted theirs), but the Senate departed before even considering the bill.

Already, the House’s legislation is pared back from an earlier version, as it only extends jobless benefits through November (instead of through the end of the year) and doesn’t include an extension of COBRA subsidies, which help laid off workers purchase health insurance. These cuts were made to assuage the deficit hysteria shown by many members of Congress who, despite long-term unemployment remaining at an all-time high, are ready to cut and run from various recovery programs. And even with the House’s extension, such hysteria continues unabated.

“There is a sense that the economy is recovering and this is not a new entitlement,” Rep. Earl Pomeroy (D-ND) said. Rep. Baron Hill (D-IN) voted against the extension, saying “last year, I held my nose. But the economy is starting to get on its feet again.” Rep. Gerald Connolly (D-VA) also voted no, and said that the slim margins of the vote means “moving forward, what worked a year ago is not going to work now.”

It’s incredibly worrisome how many policy makers are ready to begin fiscal tightening, leaving those still out of work out to dry. As Paul Krugman put it, “demands that governments switch from supporting their economies to punishing them have been proliferating in op-eds, speeches and reports from international organizations. Indeed, the idea that what depressed economies really need is even more suffering seems to be the new conventional wisdom”:

Last week conservative members of the House, invoking the new deficit fears, scaled back a bill extending aid to the long-term unemployed — and the Senate left town without acting on even the inadequate measures that remained. As a result, many American families are about to lose unemployment benefits, health insurance, or both — and as these families are forced to slash spending, they will endanger the jobs of many more. And that’s just the beginning. More and more, conventional wisdom says that the responsible thing is to make the unemployed suffer. And while the benefits from inflicting pain are an illusion, the pain itself will be all too real.

According to the Center for American Progress’ Christian Weller, the average length of unemployment is currently 31.2 weeks, “and 44.1 percent of the unemployed were out of a job for 27 weeks or more.” “This is a new record for long-term unemployment,” he wrote. And even though the economy added jobs in April, the unemployment rate in minority communities is still astronomical, hitting 16.5 percent for African-Americans and 12.6 percent for Hispanics.

As Mark Zandi, chief economist of Moody’s Economy.com, said “in this environment, the job market is so bad, I think it’s still premature to give up on those emergency benefits.” “I mean, just a statistic, for every one job opening there’s five people that are looking for work. That is incredibly unusual, so therefore it’s premature to give up on those emergency benefits,” he added. But Congress seems ready to start giving in, potentially leaving millions with no safety net on which to fall back upon.

Lobbyists Claim That Ending Executive Pay Tax Loophole Targets Cancer Patients And Pensioners

Congress is currently working on a bill that extends popular tax credits and unemployment benefits to help combat the effects of the poor economy. Sen. Max Baucus (D-MT) and Rep. Sanders Levin (D-MI) have designed a series of offsets to pay for part of the bill; one of these is a change in the way carried interest is taxed.

Carried interest is “the share of profits that investors pay to compensate certain people for managing their money.” Currently, investment managers who receive carried interest are taxed “at the low capital gains rate of 15 percent rather than the regular rate of 35 percent that other highly compensated workers pay.” Here’s an illustration by MoveOn of the impact of the loophole:

hfm_loophole_chart

Levin and Baucus are proposing that their carried interest be subject to normal income tax rates. Politico reports today that lobbyists for the venture capital and private equity industries have “worked hard” in the past few weeks, making the case that requiring wealthy investment managers to pay the same income tax rate as the rest of us is a “danger to minorities, academics, pensioners, economically depressed Michigan, ‘the average American home,’ the fight against cancer and jobs”:

The venture capital and private equity lobbies have worked hard in the past few weeks to claim that raising the tax rate on executive compensation is less about the executives than it is about the danger to minorities, academics, pensioners, economically depressed Michigan, “the average American home,” the fight against cancer and jobs.

The fight-against-cancer argument comes courtesy of 28 scientists— “members of the U.S. academic and research community,” according to a letter to President Barack Obama — who, while thanking him for increasing grant money for medical research, warned that the tax measure could cut into the funding they get for long-term research from venture capital.

The lobbyists’ claim is ridiculous on its face. While it’s true that various working-class Americans, including the beneficiaries of cancer research, receive venture capital funds for their activities, the Levin effort does not target the investors in venture capital and private equity funds but rather the fund managers, who typically pay lower tax rates than teachers.

As Citizens for Tax Justice notes, “The venture capital industry is lobbying for a carve-out from the carried interest provision. They point out they foster small business, encourage innovation, and create jobs, so we don’t want this type of investment to dry up. It’s a tempting argument, but try to see through the smoke. The change affects only the managers of venture capital funds. It doesn’t change how the investors are taxed. The managers will take home less cash, but they still have plenty of incentive to work hard and make the fund successful — remember that 20 percent interest they get, plus the 2 percent management fee.”

Education

McDonnell Falsely Claims That Race To The Top Would Force Virginia To Lower Its Academic Standards

Last week, Gov. Bob McDonnell (R-GA) pulled his state out of the Race to the Top competition, a $4 billion initiative that provides states with grants for implementing education reforms. In March, Delaware and Tennessee won the first round of the competition — receiving a total of $600 million — and applications for the second round are due today.

McDonnell claimed to take issue with the competition’s emphasis on states adopting the National Governors Association’s common set of academic standards, saying that Virginia’s current standards are “much superior.” Today, on MSNBC’s Morning Joe, McDonnell went one step further, claiming that Race to the Top would actually mandate that Virginia lower its standards, as the common standards act as a “ceiling” that states cannot go beyond:

The problem is one of the criteria Joe, in this federal program, is to adopt a common core set of standards, academic standards, to get the points you need to be competitive, and we can’t do that. We’ve had a great set of standards here in Virginia for 15 years, and we think those common standards ought to be a floor not a ceiling, and so they would require us to essentially reduce the quality of Virginia’s standards, and we just can’t do that. It’s more, I think, overburdensome federal standards.

Watch it:

Mika Brzezinski asked, “and for sure it would have you lower the standards?” She was right to be skeptical. While states do receive 40 points on their Race to the Top application for adopting the NGA’s standards, the program’s executive summary clearly states that they are a floor, not a ceiling, and that states wishing to put in place more ambitious standards are free to do so:

Common set of K-12 standards means a set of content standards that define what students must know and be able to do and that are substantially identical across all States in a consortium. A State may supplement the common standards with additional standards, provided that the additional standards do not exceed 15 percent of the State’s total standards for that content area.

And it’s not like Virginia was in danger of having its hands tied by common standards anyway. According to the Fordham Institute, “in the upper grades [in Virginia], progress in algebra is slow, with students not introduced to the concept of slope by the end of eighth grade,” and “there are serious deficiencies in the Algebra I and II and Geometry requirements, especially in the latter’s development of mathematical reasoning.” Between 2003 and 2009, Virginia made only slight progress in closing the gap between average achievement between low-income and other 8th graders on math scores.

And for McDonnell to call this a “federal mandate” conveniently obscures the fact that the standards were developed by the nation’s governors, not by the Department of Education or anyone else within the Obama administration. Virginia finished 31st out of 41 applicants in the competition’s first round, and now McDonnell is simply digging for excuses for his state’s inability to implement more ambitious reforms that would strengthen its bid.

BP Hires Dick Cheney’s Press Secretary, Anne Womack-Kolton

Under threat of receivership and criminal investigation for its destruction of the Gulf of Mexico, foreign oil giant BP has hired a former top aide for Vice President Dick Cheney to be their new spokeswoman. Anne Womack-Kolton has been hired to be “head of U.S. media relations.” A rising star in the Bush-Cheney White House since the 2000 campaign, Womack-Kolton served as Cheney’s press secretary during the 2004 election before running public affairs in the Bush Department of Energy:

Anne Womack-Kolton

“Back in 2001-02 Anne Womack-Kolton defended Cheney’s secret energy task force,” Daily Kos contributor RL Miller writes. Cheney’s energy group met with several BP representatives, including a private meeting between Cheney and BP CEO John Browne. In 2007 Browne retired from BP “after lying to a court about his relationship with another man.”

With its stock spiralling, BP hired her away from the Brunswick Group, the international communications and crisis management firm which BP has been paying to “craft its public response to the spill.” Womack-Kolton joined the Brunswick Group in 2007 to manage “high stakes communications surrounding public affairs issues and political risk management for domestic and global corporate clients.”

Cross-posted on the Wonk Room.

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up