ThinkProgress Logo

Economy

NEWS FLASH

Every Hour Spent Auditing Corporate Tax Returns Yields More Than $9,000 In Revenue | Near the top of the list of counterproductive budget cuts is cutting funds for the Internal Revenue Service, as every dollar of tax enforcement yields $4-$5 in revenue in a country where uncollected taxes have hit $385 billion per year. Along those lines, Reuters’ David Cay Johnston noted today that IRS auditors “assigned to the 14,000 or so largest corporations found $9,354 of additional tax owed for every hour spent testing tax returns in the 2009 fiscal year.” “The highest-paid IRS auditors make $71 an hour. Based on a 2,080-hour work year, that works out to around $19 million of lost revenue annually for every senior corporate auditor position cut from the payroll,” Johnston wrote.

Romney Invests In Several Bain Funds That Use Offshore Tax Havens To Boost Profits

Mitt Romney yesterday admitted for the first time that his tax rate is about 15 percent, lower than the rate paid by millions of middle class families. Romney is able to pay such a low rate (even though the top income tax rate is 35 percent) because his income comes overwhelmingly from investments and he is able to use a pernicious loophole available to wealthy money managers.

Romney has been refusing to release his tax returns, finally conceding to releasing his 2011 return after he files it in April. However, only releasing his 2011 returns would give Romney the opportunity to keep under wraps some of the financial engineering he may have done to avoid taxes before the last calendar year. As Reuters noted, those returns “could shed light on how Romney and Bain use offshore strategies to avoid taxes.” In fact, ABC News reported today that Romney has millions of dollars parked in several Bain funds that are set up in tax shelters in order to help their investors avoid U.S. taxes:

Although it is not apparent on his financial disclosure form, Mitt Romney has millions of dollars of his personal wealth in investment funds set up in the Cayman Islands, a notorious Caribbean tax haven…As one of the wealthiest candidates to run for president in recent times, Romney has used a variety of techniques to help minimize the taxes on his estimated $250 million fortune. In addition to paying the lower tax rate on his investment income, Romney has as much as $8 million invested in at least 12 funds listed on a Cayman Islands registry. Another investment, which Romney reports as being worth between $5 million and $25 million, shows up on securities records as having been domiciled in the Caymans.

Even if these funds don’t help Romney directly dodge U.S. taxes, which the campaign claims they don’t, they convey a host of advantages to Bain and Romney, including “higher management fees and greater foreign interest” from investors looking to avoid U.S. taxes. As the Washington Post’s Suzy Khimm noted, “just one of these offshore-linked funds — Bain Capital Fund VIII, based in the Cayman Islands — generated $1 million for the Romneys in 2010.”

Offshore funds are attractive to investors, since they help with tax evasion, and more investor interest translates into more profit for Bain and Romney. As we’ve noted, Romney has a lucrative retirement deal with Bain that is paying him millions each year.

In contrast to Romney’s steadfast refusal to release his tax returns, George Romney (Mitt’s father) released 12 years worth of tax returns when he ran for president in 1968. Those returns showed that the elder Romney paid a 37 percent effective tax rate.

George Romney, Mitt’s Father, Paid A 37 Percent Effective Tax Rate

George and Mitt Romney, 1964

Mitt Romney yesterday finally admitted that he pays a tax rate of about 15 percent, though he continues to put off releasing his full tax returns. However, when Mitt’s father, George Romney, ran for President in 1968, he released 12 years of tax returns, which revealed that he paid a 37 percent effective tax rate. From the Sarasota Herald-Tribune, November 25, 1967:

Romney became a millionaire on company stock options after he introduced a compact car as president of American Motors Corp. The figures show his adjusted gross income ranged from $661,427.68 when he was president of American Motors Corp. to a low of $78,483.85 last year. The figures indicate he paid $1,099,555.18 in taxes on an income of $2,972,923.58.

These numbers show Romney paying a 36.9 percent effective tax rate (but this was also a time when the top income tax rate was 70 percent). Lee Fang noted that the returns also “showed that George Romney donated 19 percent of his income to church, 4 percent directly to charity, and most surprisingly…that the Michigan governor ‘seldom took advantage of tax loopholes to escape his tax obligations.’”

Romney, meanwhile, is the beneficiary of a huge tax loophole that lets private equity managers like himself pay a lower tax rate on their earnings than millions of middle class families. He has also advocated a tax plan that would cut his own taxes nearly in half, while raising taxes on half of middle class families with children.

Gov. Christie Proposes ‘Across The Board’ Tax Cut That Significantly Benefits The Wealthy

In his State of the State address yesterday, New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie (R) announced his plan to institute a 10 percent tax cut across all income tax brackets. Celebrating his rather draconian budget cuts over the past two years, Christie said, “because we have put our fiscal house in order, we can budget for our priorities and give tax relief to all of our people.”

Not surprisingly, this tax cut will benefit the wealthy significantly more. While a family making $600,000 would keep $4,000 of their income, a middle-class family making $50,000 would save only $130:

High-income families would get the biggest boost from his proposed tax cut. Families making more than $500,000 now pay just under 9 percent of their incomes in state taxes. Under Christie’s plan, the highest rate would drop to just over 8 percent, meaning that the annual state income tax paid by a family with $600,000 in taxable income would drop from about $39,000 to around $35,000.

A family making $50,000 would see its tax bill fall from about $1,270 to about $1,140.

Noting that millionaires would reap $7,200 from the tax cut, New Jersey Assembly Speaker Sheila Oliver (D) said, “A 10 percent across-the-board income tax cut might make a nice sound bit, but ultimately it benefits the wealthiest far more than low and middle income earners.” State Senate President Stephen Sweeney (D) just called it “a B.S. tax cut.” “This is another windfall for multi-millionaires at the expense of schools, because that’s where the money comes from,” he said.

Indeed, Christie took an $820 billion bite out of public education in 2010, a cut so severe that it violated the state’s constitution. Christie merely labeled the court “crazy” and complained that he had no way of balancing the budget without gutting education, even when atwo percent tax increase on millionaires would completely plug the hole.

Even now, Christie has not mentioned how he plans to pay for the 10 percent income tax cut that could cost the state over $1.1 billion. But he still managed to blast the state Supreme Court regarding his education cuts. He called on the court to “admit” that its ruling “requiring poor, often urban schools to get increased funding was ‘a failure‘ because pupil performance at those schools has not improved.” Judging by his past and future plans, neither has the governor’s.

Romney Fundraises At Home Of Wall Streeter Who Compared Closing Tax Loopholes To Nazi Invasion

Blackstone CEO Stephen Schwarzman

If Mitt Romney is trying to shed his image as an out-of-touch banker, yesterday did not help. On the same day the GOP frontrunner revealed that he pays a much lower tax rate than many middle-class Americans, the founder and CEO of the world’s largest private equity fund hosted Romney and a select group of other financial elites for a top-dollar fundraiser and strategy session at his ultra-posh Manhattan home.

The venue was the Park Avenue apartment of Stephen Schwarzman, the 66th richest person in the world, a 24-room duplex once owned by John D. Rockefeller Jr. that Schwarzman purchased for “$30-something-million” — the highest price ever paid for a New York apartment at the time. There’s even a book about Schwarzman’s building: 740 Park: The Story of the World’s Richest Apartment Building. (Mega-conservative donor David Koch and former Merrill Lynch CEO John Thain also live in the building, though no word if they attended the fundraiser.)

But more noteworthy than Schwarzman’s apartment is the conversation that was likely going on inside. CNBC reports the discussion was sure to be how to “counter attacks from President Obama about Romney’s record at the helm of private equity-firm Bain Capital.” Here’s one approach of Schwarzman’s from 2010 that Romney probably shouldn’t follow:

“It’s a war,” Schwarzman said of the struggle with the [Obama] administration over increasing taxes on private-equity firms. “It’s like when Hitler invaded Poland in 1939.”

Attendees at the board meeting (who provided details on condition that they and the organization not be identified) were shocked. “War? Hitler? Poland? A little over the top for a proposal to make hedge-fund managers pay their fair share in taxes,” one attendee says about the comments.

The tax in question is a particularly pernicious loophole (called “carried interest”) that lets private equity executives and hedge fund managers pay a lower tax rate on their income than other working Americans. As ThinkProgress economics editor Pat Garofalo notes in the Atlantic, “private equity managers are allowed to pay the [lower] capital gains rate on the profits they make managing someone else’s money, not for any risk that they take themselves.” It’s a loophole that benefits only people like Schwarzman, who are already extremely wealthy, and does nothing to encourage investment. Congress has tried to eliminate it several times, but has been always been thwarted by concerted lobbying and Republican intransigence.

NEWS FLASH

One Unemployed Youth Costs Taxpayers $14,000 Each Year | According to work done by researchers from Columbia University and the City University of New York, each unemployed youth — someone between the ages of 16 and 24 who is in neither work nor school — costs taxpayers nearly $14,000 dollars per year in direct costs for things like medical bills and government aid, while ultimately creating a “social burden” of more than $37,000 annually (when accounting for the costs of crime and lost tax revenue). As the Atlantic’s Jordan Weissmann noted, the current generation of unemployed youth “will cost taxpayers $437 billion over the next five years, and $1.15 trillion over the course of their lifetime.”

NEWS FLASH

Newt Gingrich To Release Tax Returns, Says His Tax Rate Is ‘Around 31 Percent’ | GOP presidential candidate Mitt Romney is taking flack from friend and foe alike over his unprecedented refusal to release his tax returns. Offering a small window into his finances yesterday, the millionaire candidate admitted that his current tax rate is “closer to 15 percent,” lower than what many middle-class families pay. Seeking to highlight the difference, his competitor Newt Gingrich announced today that he will release his 2010 tax returns tomorrow which, he says, will show that his tax rate is around 31 percent. CBS News’ Sarah Huisenga reports:

How The GOP Candidates’ Tax Plans Would Give Huge Tax Breaks To South Carolina’s Richest 1 Percent

The GOP 2012 presidential candidates are headed to South Carolina for its Saturday primary largely in lockstep about economic policy. Across the board, the candidates have proposed tax plans that would give huge tax cuts to the already wealthy and blow a hole in the federal budget, while doing next to nothing for the middle class.

In South Carolina specifically, the candidates’ plans would give tens of thousands of dollars (or hundreds of thousands, depending on the plan) in tax breaks to the richest 1 percent of Americans. Citizens for Tax Justice broke down the plans by candidate and income percentage:

As the table shows, the smallest tax break for the richest 1 percent in South Carolina would be Mitt Romney’s, at about $69,000. Newt Gingrich wins the race for largest tax break for the 1 percent, at more than $212,000. In South Carolina, where the median income is about $43,000, the richest 1 percent have an average income of about $945,000.

Overall, the GOP candidates’ tax plans give tax breaks to the wealthy that are up to 270 times as large as those they deign to give to the middle class. Several of them, in fact, would raise taxes on many middle class families. Romney, for instance, would raise taxes on half of middle class families with children, due to his elimination of an expanded child tax credit implemented by President Obama.

Romney-Endorser Chris Christie: ‘I Would Urge’ Romney To Release His Tax Returns

Defying 50 years of precedent set by presidential candidates from both parties, Mitt Romney has so far refused to release his income tax returns, despite calls from the other GOP candidates to do so. Yesterday, he admitted that his effective tax rate is probably about 15 percent — much lower than that of many middle-class families — and said he will probably release his returns in April if he wins the nomination, but only for 2011, which could allow him to hide any embarrassing tax shelters or income sources from previous years.

Now it seems even Romney’s supporters are uncomfortable with his evasiveness on his tax returns. On MSNBC’s Morning Joe today, New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie (R), one of Romney’s most prominent endorsers who has campaigned with the GOP hopeful on the trail, urged Romney to release his tax returns for several years back:

CHRISTIE: First of all, listen, the way I’ve conducted myself in public life all a long is I’ve released all of my tax returns. And I did it during the campaign. I went back a number of years and released my tax returns. And I released them every year after I filed them, right after I filed them to the public of New Jersey so they can see everything, and I think that’s the right way to go and that’s what I would tell governor to do.

He says he’s going to release them in April, and I hope he does. The fact of the matter is that’s what I would advise him to do…That’s the way I’ve conducted myself in public over time, and I were asked by governor Romney, that’s what I would urge him to do as well.

Watch it:

It’s worth noting that Romney’s father, former Michigan Gov. George Romney released 12 years of tax returns when he ran for president.

Meanwhile, Bloomberg News notes that it’s understandable why Romney is reluctant to release his returns: “Romney, one of the richest men to seek the presidency, probably benefits from a controversial tax break that allows him to pay a lower overall rate than do millions of American wage-earners.”

Econ 101: January 18, 2012

Welcome to ThinkProgress Economy’s morning link roundup. This is what we’re reading. Have you seen any interesting news? Let us know in the comments section. You can also follow ThinkProgress Economy on Twitter.

  • Manufacturing employment in the U.S. has grown faster than in any other developed country over the last two years. [Financial Times]
  • Under a new regulation, the nation’s biggest banks will have to draft “living wills,” to be used in the event a bank has to be dismantled by federal regulators. [Housing Wire]
  • State funding for public research universities dropped about 20 percent between 2002 and 2010. [Inside Higher Ed]
  • Fewer than one-tenth of the nation’s cities have gained back the jobs they lost in the Great Recession. [New York Times]
  • The International Monetary Fund would like to boost its lending resources by $1 trillion in order to guard against an expansion of the European debt crisis. [Bloomberg]
  • In the last decade, the Super Bowl has generated more than $1.7 billion in network advertising sales. [Politico]

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up