ThinkProgress Logo

Election

Justice

Paul Ryan and Todd Akin Partnered On Radical ‘Personhood’ Bill Outlawing Abortion And Many Birth Control Pills

From left, Rep. Paul Ryan (R-WI) with Rep. Todd Akin (R-MO)

Yesterday, ThinkProgress reported that Rep. Todd “Legitimate Rape” Akin (R-MO) and GOP vice presidential candidate Paul Ryan both cosponsored the bill that introduced America to the despicable term “forcible rape.” As it turns out, this may only be the second most sweeping attack on reproductive freedom that both men partnered on. Ryan and Akin also cosponsored a federal personhood bill, the Sanctity of Human Life Act of 2009, which declares that a fertilized egg is entitled to the exact same legal rights as a human being:

(1) the Congress declares that–

(A) the right to life guaranteed by the Constitution is vested in each human being, and is the paramount and most fundamental right of a person; and

(B) the life of each human being begins with fertilization, cloning, or its functional equivalent, irrespective of sex, health, function or disability, defect, stage of biological development, or condition of dependency, at which time every human being shall have all the legal and constitutional attributes and privileges of personhood; and

(2) the Congress affirms that the Congress, each State, the District of Columbia, and all United States territories have the authority to protect the lives of all human beings residing in its respective jurisdictions.

Lest there be any doubt, this bill is unconstitutional. Congress does not have the power to overrule Roe v. Wade by an ordinary statue, only a constitutional amendment could serve that purpose. Moreover, even if Roe were overruled by the Supreme Court, Ryan and Akin’s bill still attempts to redefine who “the right to life guaranteed by the Constitution” applies to. Again, changing the meaning of the Constitution can only be done through an amendment, not through an ordinary Act of Congress.

Should Ryan and Akin’s personhood agenda take effect, however, it would drastically reduce women’s reproductive choice. The bill declares that a human egg obtains “all the legal and constitutional attributes and privileges of personhood” the moment it merges with a human sperm. Thus, a Blastocyst-American would not only enjoy the same constitutional status as a fully grown adult, it would also enjoy any “legal” attributes enjoyed by adults. Because every states’ law makes it a crime to kill a human adult, the likely effect of Ryan and Akin’s personhood bill would be to treat killing a fertilized egg as the same thing as homicide.

Such an interpretation would not simply ban abortion, it could turn many forms of birth control into the legal equivalent of a murder weapon. Many forms of contraception, including many birth control pills, function in part by inhibiting a fertilized egg from implanting in a woman’s uterus. Thus, Ryan and Akin’s personhood bill could render the act of using many forms of oral contraception the equivalent of a homicide crime.

Update

Recent scientific studies have called into question whether birth control pills can act by preventing implantation, although this view is still held by many medical professionals.

Influential Conservatives Defending Akin

Rep. Todd Akin (R-MO) has apologized for his suggestion that women who have suffered a “legitimate rape” cannot be impregnated, admitting his serious error in biology. Much of the pressure for this move has come from Republican figures who have called on him to resign, including Senator Ron Johnson, S.E. Cupp, former Rep. Heather Burns, Adam Hasner, Ramesh Ponnuru, and Ric Grennell. But several prominent Republicans and right-wing organizations have come out in support of the beleaguered Senate candidate. Here, in no particular order, is a list of five of them:

1. Erick Erickson. The RedState honcho and CNN contributor excused Akin’s scientifically illiterate remarks as simply “inarticulate” and then accused President Obama of being pro-infanticide, saying: “the people horrid by Todd Akin’s remarks are, I’m sure, thrilled to have a President who defended infanticide. I’ll take Todd Akin’s inarticulate remarks over an infanticide supporter any day of the week.” Somewhat ironically, Erickson is now claiming that Akin will withdraw from the race.

2. Tony Perkins. The head of the Family Research Council said “we support [Akin] fully and completely” and that “I think that Todd Akin is getting a really bad break here.”

3. Chris and Dana Loesch. The conservative commentary power couple both lept to Akin’s defense. Chris claimed that “what [Akin] said was medically correct” while Dana wrote that Akin’s comments were less bad than his opponent Claire McCaskill’s record by “any real standard of measurement.”

4. Bryan Fischer. The American Family Association’s “director of issue analysis” straight-up defended Akin’s position, tweeting “Todd Akin is right: physical trauma of forcible rape can interfere w/ hormonal production, conception.”

5. Marjorie Dannenfelser. The head of the anti-abortion Susan B. Anthony list said that “We are proud to support Congressman Akin,” but later backtracked, amending her statement to “Congressman Akin has been an excellent partner in the fight for the unborn.”

6. Glenn Reynolds. The popular pundit and law professor simply wrote “BY THE TIME I NOTICED THIS STORY, IT WAS OVER, but Todd Akin’s “legitimate rape” remarks pale in comparison with Whoopi Goldberg’s.”

A seventh example, a bizarre foray into pseudoscience by the The Daily Caller’s Matt Lewis, was definitively debunked earlier today.

NEWS FLASH

Obama Draws Distinction With Romney While Condemning ‘Legitimate Rape’ Remarks | President Obama has weighed in on Rep. Todd Akin’s (R-MO) comments that women don’t get pregnant from “legitimate rape” because “the female body has ways to try to shut that whole thing down.” During an impromptue press conference on Monday, Obama said, “The views expressed were offensive. Rape is rape. And the idea that we should be parsing and qualifying and slicing what types of rape we’re talking about doesn’t make sense to the American people.” “So what I think these comments do underscore is why we shouldn’t have a bunch of politicians — a majority whom are men — making health care decisions on behalf of women,” he added. “Those are broader issues and that is a significant difference and approach between me and the other party.”

Rep. Akin Apologizes For ‘Legitimate Rape’ Comments, Refuses To Drop Senate Bid

In an interview on The Mike Huckabee Show, Republican Senate nominee Rep. Todd Akin (R-MO) apologized for saying that women don’t get pregnant from “legitimate rape” because “the female body has ways to try to shut that whole thing down.”

“I’ve really made a couple of serious mistakes here that were just wrong, and I need to apologize for those,” Akin told Huckabee. The Missouri Republican went on to concede that women can indeed be impregnated by rapists.

In the interview, Akin said he simply misspoke when he used the phrase “legitimate rape,” saying he actually meant “forcible rape.” He went on to say that rape is “equally tragic” to abortion.

Despite a growing number of Republicans calling for him to withdraw from the race, including two sitting United States senators, Akin pledged to fight on. “I’m not a quitter,” said the congressman. “I’ve not yet begun to fight.”

Update

Despite speculation on Twitter that Akin was preparing an exit, he reiterated his pledge to stay in the race during an interview on The Sean Hannity Show.

Akin also explained the story behind his “legitimate rape” comment: “I had heard from medical reports that rape is such a traumatic thing that there’s a reaction. But that’s wrong.”

LGBT

Better Know An Anti-LGBT Senate Candidate: Former Gov. Tommy Thompson (R-WI)

Former Gov. Tommy Thompson (R-WI)

Former Gov. Tommy Thompson (R-WI)

Third in a series examining how anti-LGBT Senate candidates have worked to hurt the cause of equality.

With his primary win last Tuesday, four-term former Gov. Tommy Thompson (R-WI) will be the Republican nominee against Rep. Tammy Baldwin (D) for the open seat of retiring Sen. Herb Kohl (D). Unlike Baldwin, the nation’s first openly lesbian Member of Congress and a 100 percent supporter of LGBT equality, Thompson has opposed the LGBT community on several major issues.

Over his time as a Wisconsin state legislator (1967 to 1986), Governor (1987 to 2001), President George W. Bush’s Secretary of Health and Human Services (2001 to 2005), an unsuccessful candidate for the Republican presidential nomination (2008), and this Senate race:

1. Thompson ran for governor opposing his predecessor’s pioneering efforts to protect gay and lesbian people from discrimination. In 1983, then-Gov. Tony Earl (D) created a Council on Lesbian and Gay Issues. Thompson, in his successful 1986 campaign to succeed Earl, repeatedly pledged to eliminate the council. Dick Wagner, who co-chaired the council, told ThinkProgress that Thompson did not reauthorize the Council on Lesbian and Gay Issues but “did continue the Bicycle Coordinating Council.”

2. Thompson said it should be legal to fire someone for being LGBT — and then said it shouldn’t. During a 2007 Republican presidential primary debate, Thompson was asked whether employers who believe “homosexuality is immoral” should be allowed to fire gay employees. Thompson forcefully responded that “business people have to make their own determination” on whether to fire employees based on sexual orientation. A day later, he reversed himself, saying “I didn’t hear the question properly and I apologize. It’s not my position. There should be no discrimination in the workplace and I have never believed that.” Thompson later blamed his answer on a dead hearing aid, illness, and a urgent need to go to the bathroom. Indeed, back in 1981, then-Assemblyman Thompson voted against the Assembly version of the nation’s first statewide gay rights bill (he later voted to accept the Senate’s amended version in a largely uncontested vote).

3. Thompson opposes marriage equality and strongly supports DOMA. Earlier this month, he backed the unconstitutional Defense of Marriage Act, telling a Wisconsin TV station “I believe very strongly in the Defense of the Marriage Act [sic], that marriage is between one man and one woman. I support that. That’s the federal law.” While he expressed reservations about a federal constitutional amendment, he pledged to “defend the federal law – one man, one woman for marriage.” Thompson declined to join the bipartisan coalition of former governors who opposed Wisconsin’s 2006 state constitutional amendment against same-sex unions.

4. Thompson has proudly promoted his anti-LGBT backers. His campaign website endorsement list prominent features one of the nation’s most notorious anti-gay extremists — Fox News Channel host and Chick-fil-A appreciator former Gov. Mike Huckabee (R-AR). Huckabee also appeared in a TV ad backing Huckabee in the primary and praising him for defending “our conservative values.”

5. Thompson lead the Bush administration’s failed “abstinence-only” programs. In 2001, Lambda Legal Defense and Education Fund gave Thompson an “F” for “throwing money into ineffective and discriminatory ‘abstinence-until-marriage’ sex education programs in the face of skyrocketing rates of HIV infection among young people.” In addition to being highly ineffective in general, pushing abstinence until marriage while simultaneously opposing allowing same-sex couples to marry at all has an especially damaging effect on LGBT youths.

Watch Thompson argue in favor of legal workplace discrimination:

Though Thompson has taken a few pro-equality positions over his more than 45 years in politics, he has all too often been on the wrong side of issues of LGBT rights. His election to the U.S. Senate would be a huge threat to LGBT people and families.

NEWS FLASH

Romney Finally Condemns Todd Akin’s Rape Comments | After initially making only a tepid statement disagreeing with Missouri Republican Senate candidate Rep. Todd Akin’s highly offensive comments Sunday that female victims of “legitimate rape” rarely become pregnant, the Romney-Ryan campaign finally denounced Akin’s comments Monday. “Congressman’s Akin comments on rape are insulting, inexcusable, and, frankly, wrong,” Romney told the National Review Online, adding “Like millions of other Americans, we found them to be offensive.”

Update

Romney campaign senior adviser and Virginia state legislator Barbara Comstock, in an MSNBC interview Monday, refused to call on Akin to apologize. She also failed to acknowledge that Ryan has previously opposed the rape exception.

Update

Romney won’t be calling on Akin to step aside:

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up