ThinkProgress Logo

Election

Ryan Criticizes Romney Comments At Private Fundraiser: ‘Obviously Inarticulate’

In an interview this evening with NBC Reno, Vice Presidential nominee Paul Ryan was critical of comments Romney made at a private fundraiser in May, dismissing 47% of American as people who can will never “take personal resonsibility and care for their lives.”

Ryan said Romney’s remarks were “obviously inarticulate.” Asked if he thought Mitt Romney regreted his comments, Ryan responded “I think he would have said it differently, that’s for sure.” Watch it:

At a press conference last night, Romney called his comments at the May fundraiser “inelegant” but largely defended his remarks.

In a separate interview with a New Hampshire station Ryan was asked if he agree with Romney’s remarks at the fundraiser. He responded, “no.”

NEWS FLASH

New Mexico Governor Breaks With Romney Over 47 Percent Remark | New Mexico Gov. Susana Martinez (R) — who Mitt Romney quoted in a speech on Monday — has joined a growing number of Republicans in backing away from the former Massachusetts governor’s claim that 47 percent of Americans are dependent on government and won’t vote for Republicans anyway. Asked if she was offended by the remarks, “Martinez said New Mexico has many people who are living at the poverty level and their votes count just as much as anyone else.”

NEWS FLASH

Scott Brown Shuns Romney’s ’47 Percent’ Comments | Sen. Scott Brown (R-MA) is dissociating himself from Mitt Romney’s comments about the “47 percent” who he says “believe that they are victims.” In a statement to The Hill, Brown said, “That’s not the way I view the world.” Brown is following the lead of another Republican vying for the Senate in a heavily Democratic area, Linda McMahon. Like McMahon and Romney, however, Brown does not believe in raising taxes on the wealthy, and argues that Obama is increasing Americans’ dependency on government.

NEWS FLASH

Out Of Bounds: Challenger Says Hatch Could ‘Die Before His Term Is Through’ | Sen. Orrin Hatch’s (R-UT) Democratic opponent, Scott Howell, sent a fundraising letter on Sunday that made a case against Hatch based on the incumbent’s age. He said that Hatch, who is 78, “is old enough to be my father and I don’t want my father running the United States Senate Finance Committee.” Howell added that Hatch could “die before his term is through.” Hatch’s campaign called the letter “offensive.” In a June poll, Hatch led Howell 63 percent to 29.

– Greg Noth

OOPS: Akin’s Site Touts Democratic Operative As A Female Supporter


Rep. Todd Akin (R-MO) has been struggling to rebound from the outrage sparked by his claim that women can’t get pregnant from “legitimate rape.” In an apparent effort to win over women voters, Akin’s website features a large picture of the Senate candidate with three women under a banner proclaiming, “I’m A Women [sic] And I Support Todd.”

But the spelling isn’t the only mistake on the page. One of the women ostensibly supporting Akin in the picture is actually a Democratic operative:

The site displayed a large photo showing Akin standing with his wife and two other women. The headline over it read: “I’m a women[SIC], and I support Todd.”
The problem is, one of the women in the photo doesn’t—and his campaign apparently knew it.

Corinne Matti, who is pictured on Akin’s site standing to Akin’s left, is a “tracker” for the Missouri Democratic Party. Her job, which she does openly, is to attend Akin’s public events and report back to the Democrats. She has been doing it for more than a year.

“I suspect they were so desperate to find women that they had to borrow one of ours,” quipped McCaskill spokeswoman Caitlin Legacki.

The Akin campaign told the St. Louis Post-Dispatch that the webpage wasn’t meant to go public when it did and the photo could have been a stand-in. Akin has been essentially disowned by the GOP as other Republicans try to distance themselves from the offensive remarks. His opponent, Sen. Claire McCaskill (D-MO) is overwhelmingly favored by female voters.

Toxic: GOP Senate Candidate Speaks Out Against Romney’s ’47 Percent’ Comments

Linda McMahon, the pro-wrestler-turned-Connecticut-senate-candidate whose race has been neck-and-neck for months, distanced herself from Mitt Romney on Tuesday, one day after his assertion that, “There are 47 percent of the people… who are dependent upon government, who believe that they are victims… my job is is not to worry about those people.” She is the first major Republican candidate to do so.

In a statement from her campaign, McMahon offered a strong indictment of Romney’s sentiment, saying that she disagrees with his “insinuation,”and pointing out that — presumably unlike Mitt Romney — her family has struggled in life:

I disagree with Governor Romney’s insinuation that 47% of Americans believe they are victims who must depend on the government for their care. I know that the vast majority of those who rely on government are not in that situation because they want to be. People today are struggling because the government has failed to keep America competitive, failed to support job creators, and failed to get our economy back on track.

I am sympathetic to the struggles that millions of Americans are going through because I’ve been there. As a young couple Vince and I lost our home and our car. With two small children it was not an easy time for my family.

Because McMahon is competing in a relatively moderate area, it may help her race to disavow her party’s candidate. But when it comes to her policies, McMahon’s outlook isn’t all that different from Romney’s own. Like Romney, she paid just 15 percent on her income of over $30 million, and opposes any tax increases on the rich that might change that. She also once said the federal minimum wage, whatever it was, needed to be lowered.

Update

McMahon has previously used the same rhetoric as Romney. When she launched her campaign, she said, “”I’d like to see everyone pay their fair share…. Forty-seven percent of the people today don’t pay any taxes, so let’s have a fair tax code where everybody pays their taxes.”

Sticking To Their Guns: Ryan Echoes Romney’s ‘Dependency’ Comments

Paul Ryan didn’t directly address Mitt Romney’s comments that 47 percent of Americans are “dependent upon government” and see themselves as “victims” during his town hall in Dover, New Hampshire Tuesday afternoon. But the Republican vice presidential candidate did reiterate his claim that the “safety net” is “encouraging dependency” among the public:

RYAN: And so, this is what Mitt and I are talking about when we’re worried about more and more people becoming net dependent upon the government than upon themselves. Because by promoting more dependency, but not having jobs and economic growth, people miss their potential. We should not be measuring the progress of our social programs, of programs like food stamps based up on how many people receive them…. We don’t want a safety net that encourages more dependency because there is no economic growth behind it.

Later in the event, Ryan suggested that liberal philosophy considers people to be “victims of circumstances beyond their control” and argued that a Romney/Ryan administration would not see Americans “as some victim.”

Since Mother Jones published a video of Romney at a private fundraiser saying that nearly half of Americans are Obama voters who don’t pay taxes and believe that “the government has a responsibility to care for them,” the campaign has stood by the claims, despite their inaccuracy.

Most of the people who don’t pay federal income taxes still pay federal payroll tax, and state or local sales taxes, gas taxes, and excise taxes or benefit from tax credits for the working poor, the elderly, or students — tax credits that have received bipartisan support. Just 7 percent of the country is non-elderly and has no federal tax liability, and most of them make less than $20,000.

Republicans also argue that more Americans are receiving food stamps under Obama. Enrollment has increased since the Great Recession and the program has reduced the number of children living in extreme poverty by half. More than 3.9 million people were lifted out of poverty by food stamps in 2011.

Rep. King: Obama ‘Doesn’t Believe In Life And Families’

Rep. Steve King (R-IA)

Prompting gasps and boos, Rep. Steve King (R-IA) declared in a debate Monday night that President Obama, a married father of two, doesn’t believe in families.

“[We have] a Commander-in-Chief who disrespects this Constitution, doesn’t believe in free enterprise, doesn’t believe in life and families,” King said during a congressional debate with Democratic opponent Christie Vilsack in Hampton.

KING: Are we going to defend this Constitution that we celebrated tonight, or are we going to watch it be eroded by a Commander-in-Chief who disrespects this Constitution, doesn’t believe in free enterprise, doesn’t believe in life and families. They are core values in this country that we must defend at all costs.

Watch it:

Though King has made a career of controversial and outlandish statements, they’ve come at an increasing clip in the past few months as Election Day nears. In July, he hosted a tele-townhall where he defended dog fighting. During the same event, King suggested Obama’s parents may have telegrammed a fake Hawaii birth announcement from Kenya. In August, King expressed his agreement with Michele Bachmann’s anti-Muslim witch hunt against Hillary Clinton aide Huma Abedin and others. He also bemoaned the existence of multicultural groups on college campuses, dismissing them as “people that feel sorry for themselves.”

NEWS FLASH

Romney Surrogate: 47% Remark Was Intended For ‘Business People’ | On Tuesday morning, former Maryland Gov. Bob Ehrlich (R) was one of the few Mitt Romney surrogates to discuss the recently uncovered video showing the former Massachusetts governor referring to 47 percent of Americans as “victims” and “dependent upon government.” During an appearance on MSNBC, Ehrlich explained that the inarticulate comments as remarks “to a bunch of business people about tax cuts because these folks care about tax cuts.” “When you’re human, you make comments,” he explained. “When you’re off the record, at a private event, you are less careful than when you are at a public event.” He went on to say that the statements are “unimportant” to “what really matters to people.”

NEWS FLASH

Steve King: Illegal Immigrants Using Voter Fraud To Take Over America | At a debate last night with Democratic challenger Christie Vilsack, Rep. Steve King (R-IA) dipped his toes into the debate over voter ID laws, telling the audience that such measures must be passed “before we turn this country over to people who are not American citizens.” King, who has described immigrants as dogs and proposed an electrified fence on the Mexican border, claimed that there is “significant voter fraud in this country” and, according to the Des Moines Register, blamed undocumented immigrants for a significant chunk of it. There is no evidence that voter fraud is a problem and significant evidence that voter ID laws serve to disproportionately disenfranchise minority voters.

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up