ThinkProgress Logo

Health

Pro-Life Dem Bob Casey: We Can Solve Abortion Issue, ‘Must Pass Health Care Legislation This Month’

This afternoon, Sen. Bob Casey (D-PA) a pro-life Democrat who is co-sponsoring Sen. Ben Nelson’s (D-NE) amendment to prohibit federal funds from being used for abortions or for plans that include abortion services, reiterated that he would not oppose a health reform bill that excludes his amendment. “I believe we can get this issue, this divisive issue correct in this bill. We’re not there yet. I believe we can,” Casey said. “I also believe we must pass health care legislation this month through the Senate and then on from there to get it enacted into law.”

Casey highlighted the bill’s investment in improving women’s health care:

The third thing I think we can agree on is that no matter what happens on this vote, this debate will continue even in the context of this bill, and I believe we have to pass health care legislation this year, and there are all kinds of consumer protections in this bill that will help men and women. Prevention services that are — have never been part of our health care system before. Insurance reforms to protect families. And finally, the kind of security that we’re going to get by passing health care legislation for the American people.

Watch it:

While Democrats seek to table Nelson’s abortion amendment with a simple majority, Congressional staffers are likely developing new language to “get this diverse issue correct in the bill” and introduce stricter accounting requirements for segregating public and private funds. That kind of compromise could satisfy conservative Democrats while still preserving a woman’s right to purchase abortion coverage with private dollars.

During the House debate, for instance, Rep. Brad Ellsworth (D-IN) offered a compromise that would have established “clear, strict rules for separating public funds from the premiums of private individuals” and allowed the public option to provide abortion coverage if it hired “a private contractor to pay abortion providers, thus avoiding direct federal payments.”

“If the Nelson amendment fails, I’m happy to work with him on this. If he doesn’t succeed, I’m happy to work with him on something else,” Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) told reporters earlier today.

Update

The Senate just voted to table the Nelson abortion amendment by 54-45. Sens. Conrad, Pryor, Nelson, Casey, Dorgan and Bayh voted for the amendment (against the motion to kill it).

Howard Dean Endorses Medicare Buy-In: ‘Must Be Available To Americans From Day One’

HowardDean1The Senate is considering opening the Medicare program to Americans under 65 years of age alongside a public option compromise that would allow the Office of Personnel Management to regulate competition among private nonprofit insurers. “Howard Dean, the former Democratic National Committee chairman, injected the buy-in concept back into the negotiations two weeks ago,” Politico reports and “the turning point in the debate occurred over the past few weeks, as some progressives began to question whether the public option had been watered down too much for it to even be effective. Dean called Reid and Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) to suggest that they revisit the Medicare buy-in proposal, which he pushed during his 2004 campaign.”

In an exclusive statement for ThinkProgress, Howard Dean — a longtime proponent of the public health insurance option and co-author of Howard Dean’s Prescription For Health Care Reform — explains why he supports expanding the Medicare program:

Proponents of the public option should be happy to hear that the Senate is considering a provision that would allow Americans to buy into the existing Medicare program. Throughout this debate, advocates of a strong public option have had to repeatedly compromise with lawmakers who continue to protect large for-profit corporations and ignore the well being of their constituents. Allowing younger Americans to buy into Medicare represents the best and possibly final opportunity to truly reform the health care system as a whole.

I’ve been a long-time strong supporter of opening up the Medicare system to any American who wants to enroll in it, and I continue to believe that Medicare is a proven success story that delivers quality care efficiently. Allowing Americans under 65 to enroll in this program would generate the kind of competition that lowers costs and improves the delivery of care within the private sector. In order to be effective, however, this option must be available to Americans from day one and should be offered as an option within the exchanges, once they become operational.

Ultimately, if Democratic health reform forces Americans to purchase coverage from private insurers and does not give everyone the choice of a public plan, Democrats and the President will have to face the consequences of their watered down proposals at the voting booth.

Offering younger Americans the option of purchasing Medicare coverage could lower costs, improve the delivery of health care and strengthen Medicare over the long-term. Medicare’s administrative efficiencies and greater bargaining leverage has led the program to spend less per enrollee than private health insurers, suggesting that the program could control costs over time. A recent study found that “since Medicare payment controls were put in place in the early 1980s, Medicare spending has grown much more slowly than in the past.” Medicare has also been the source of important payment “innovations that private plans have generally adopted.” An expansion of the Medicare program would allow policymakers to spearhead the kind of payment reforms that would gradually change the incentives in the health care system from quantity to quality care.

The current proposal would expand Medicare eligibility to 55 year olds, but policy makers may also consider a provision that would trigger a reduction in eligibility age if national health care expenditures don’t decrease by a set amount over time.

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up