ThinkProgress Logo

Health

Pawlenty: Obama Took ‘Romneycare’ And Made It ‘Obamneycare’

Back in March, when I asked Tim Pawlenty what he thought about Mitt Romney’s health care law in Massachusetts, the former Minnesota governor took a pass at hitting the GOP front runner, saying, “everyone has their own approach and record. [...] I’ll speak to my own record.” But this morning, during an appearance on Fox News Sunday, Pawlenty — who is preparing to debate Romney in New Hampshire on Monday — came out swinging against Romney’s law. “President Obama designed Obamacare after Romneycare and basically made it Obamneycare”:

PAWLENTY: We now have the same features, essentially the same features. The President’s own words is that he patterned Obamacare in large measure after what happened in Massachusetts. What I don’t understand is that they both continue to defend it. I took a different approach in Minnesota, we did market based reforms.

Host Chris Wallace also pressed Pawlenty on his past flirtation with universal health care and the individual mandate. In 2006, Pawlenty praised Romney’s leadership on the issue and called the mandate a “potentially helpful,” if incomplete, solution to covering the uninsured but “one that we’re intrigued by and I think at least open to.” Pawlenty said he considered the mandate option, but ultimately rejected it. Watch it:

Pawlenty is eager to put up his health care record next to Romney’s, but the comparison is far from flattering. While “Romneycare” has extended health care coverage to 98 percent of all state residents, the number of uninsured increased under Pawlenty’s governorship. Pawlenty experimented with different methods of bundling payments to providers — creating baskets for certain conditions — and implemented pay-for performance initiatives, but the uninsurance rate rose from 395,000 citizens without health insurance in 2003, to 446,000 in 2008 — the last year before the recession.

Justice

Santorum: Doctors Providing Abortions To Rape And Incest Victims Should Be Criminally Charged

Appearing on NBC’s Meet the Press this morning, former Senator and GOP presidential candidate Rick Santorum offered two stunningly maximalist positions on abortion — abortion should be flatly banned even in cases of rape or incest, and doctors who perform abortions should face criminal charges:

QUESTION: Do you believe that there should be any legal exceptions for rape or incest when it comes to abortion?

SANTORUM: I believe that life begins at conception, and that that life should be guaranteed under the Constitution. That is a person.

QUESTION: So even in the case of rape or incest, that would be taking a life?

SANTORUM: That would be taking a life, and I believe that any doctor that performs an abortion, I would advocate that any doctor that performs an abortion, should be criminally charged for doing so.

Watch it:

It’s worth noting that Santorum’s statement that “life begins at conception” also indicates that he would make it a crime to provide many forms of birth control to victims of rape or incest. During a debate with Sen. Bob Casey (D-PA), who defeated Santorum in 2006, Santorum took the position that the morning after pill is the exact same thing as abortion if it is taken after “the egg has been fertilized.”

Moreover, Santorum’s position that the Constitution compels laws protecting fetuses places him at odds with the Supreme Court’s most conservative members. In DeShanney v. Winnebago County, the Supreme Court held that the Constitution’s guarantee that no person shall be denied “life . . . without due process of law” does not actually require the government to criminalize anything — a decision that runs directly counter to Santorum’s position on abortion. Justice Antonin Scalia, who has gone so far as to say that the Constitution does not prevent gender discrimination, was in the majority in DeShanney.

Nevertheless, this kind of over-the-top social conservatism is exactly the kind of thing Americans have come to expect from Rick Santorum. Santorum has previously called laws protecting the health of a pregnant woman “phony,” and he is best known for spouting a frothy mixture of anti-gay rhetoric comparing same-sex couples with people who have sex with dogs.

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up