ThinkProgress Logo

Health

Climate Progress

Oil and Gas Jobs Increase by 75,000 Under Obama — 69,000 More Than Would Be Created By Keystone XL


Approximately 75,000 jobs were created in the oil and gas sector under the Obama Administration between 2009 to 2011, according to analysis of data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

That’s roughly 69,000 more jobs than would be created by construction of the Keystone XL tar sands pipeline.

The figures, reviewed by the Center for American Progress, show that overall employment in oil and gas (extraction, field support, pipeline construction and transportation, and petroleum refineries) increased by 13% in the last two years.

The figures do not include categories such as gasoline stations, fuel dealers, asphalt paving, or lubrication production.

This strong increase in American fossil fuel jobs contradicts the arguments made by supporters of the Keystone XL tar sands pipeline, who have attacked the Obama Administration for denying the initial permit for the pipeline due to environmental concerns.

The oil and gas industry claims that Keystone XL will create up to 20,000 direct and indirect jobs. But more careful research of those jobs claims — analysis that is backed up by the State Department, Cornell University and TransCanada, the company building the pipeline — has shown that the number is closer to 6,000 jobs.

Armed with these inflated figures (which are still about 55,000 less than jobs created in the last two years), Keystone XL supporters have argued that the tar sands pipeline will be a panacea for job creation in America. In response to today’s news that the Obama Administration would reject the Keystone XL permit and ask TransCanada to file for another, Keystone supporters lined up to lambaste the President.

Chamber of Commerce CEO Tom Donahue said it proves “that creating jobs is not a high priority for this administration.”

And Republican Presidential front-runner Mitt Romney laid it on thick: “If Americans want to understand why unemployment in the United States has been stuck above 8 percent for the longest stretch since the Great Depression, decisions like this one are the place to begin.”

But here’s the deep, dirty little secret not mentioned by fossil fuel champions who falsely claim the Administration is killing oil and gas jobs: Since Obama took office, oil production has increased substantially — with more drilling rigs being deployed in America today than at any time since the mid 1980′s.

This increase in production has already resulted in 12 times the jobs that would be created to build the Keystone XL tar sands pipeline. Do you hear any mention of that from political candidates or the fossil fuel lobby? Absolutely not. And you never will.

These jobs figures prove once again that no matter how aggressively this Administration promotes oil and gas — alienating the environmental base in the process — political opponents will attack Obama in any way they can.

You can find the BLS figures here.

Zach Rybarczyk and Daniel J. Weiss contributed to this report.

NEWS FLASH

New Hampshire House Votes To Ban Funds For Planned Parenthood | New Hampshire’s GOP-led House voted to prohibit the state from contracting with “organizations that provide abortions even if private money is used to pay for the service,” including Planned Parenthood. Though the women’s health organization predominantly provides contraceptive, breast cancer, and STD testing services to nearly 16,000 low-income women in New Hampshire, its small abortion practice has led lawmakers to cut off funding. Some hospitals that provide abortion services could be affected, but proponents believe that they and others “could set up a separate business to handle” those specific procedures. The bill does allow “medical procedures to save the life of the child, remove a dead fetus,” or “remove an ecotopic pregnancy,” and, after passing 207-147, will now be considered by the state Senate.

NEWS FLASH

Rick Perry Highlights Support For Government Health Care In South Carolina | Republicans who rail against so-called “government health care” typically exclude the Veterans Health Care Administration from the list of “big government” programs they would want to eliminate or repeal. Mitt Romney, Newt Gingrich, and now Rick Perry have all pledged to expand government involvement in health care through the VA, recognizing that the fully integrated veterans’ health care structure of doctors and hospitals actually provides veterans with benefits that are the envy of the rest of the health care system — including private payers and providers. CNN points to this flyer from Rick Perry highlighting his support for government health care for voters in South Carolina:

House GOP To Repeal ACA’s Long-Term Health Care Provision Next Month

A second House committee has voted to repeal the long-term care health care program in the Affordable Care Act, the Hill’s Sam Baker reports, “clearing the way for a floor vote next month.”

The Department of Health and Human Services announced in October that it did not believe Secretary Kathleen Sebelius had the discretion necessary bring the program in compliance with the health care law’s sustainability provision, which stipulates that CLASS has to remain solvent for a period of 75 years. But administration officials and many Democrats also oppose repealing the measure outright, arguing that it represents an important first step towards reducing the nation’s long-term care crisis and could eventually be modified into sustainability. Under today’s system, Medicaid has evolved to become the nation’s primary payer for long-term services “and supports, financing nearly half (43 percent) of all spending on long-term care services.” The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) predicts that by mid-century 16 percent of anticipated federal revenues will be used to fund care for the baby-boom generation.

The ACA’s long-term care program, CLASS, was designed to minimize beneficiaries’ reliance on Medicaid by encouraging younger Americans to establish a cash benefit in their working years that would be made available to them should they become disabled.

One Democrat voted for repeal this morning on the House Ways and Means Committee, while three supported eliminating the program when it passed the Energy and Commerce Committee in November. “The measure will come to the floor next month, an aide to House Majority Leader Eric Cantor (R-VA)” told the Hill.

NEWS FLASH

Santorum: Medicare Is Like Romneycare | Rick Santorum continued to rail against Medicare during a stop in South Carolina this afternoon, pledging to reform the program by turning it over to private health insurers and “free markets.” “We have to look at how we’re spending our money,” Santorum explained, before awkwardly comparing the health care program to Mitt Romney’s signature law in Massachusetts. “In the area of Medicare, it is incredibly inefficient. The Medicare system is simply like Romneycare in Massachusetts…It will eventually mean that a lot of seniors aren’t going to get the care that they need.” Watch it:

ACA Increasing Coverage For Young People, But Older Households Still Skipping Care

A provision in the health care law that allows young adults to stay on their parents’ health care plans until the age of 26 is working, new analysis from the Employee Benefits Research Institute confirms. According to the Institute, “the percentage of people between ages 19 and 25 being carried as a dependent on a parent’s employment-based coverage increased from 24.7 percent in 2009 to 27.7 percent in 2010. The number of young adults with employment-based coverage as a dependent increased from 7.3 million to 8.2 million” as uninsured teens find coverage or shift into dependent insurance if they lose their employer-sponsored insurance.

However, the economic recession and increasing health care costs are still causing Americans over the age of 50 — or those who actually use more care — to skip health care services. Relying on data from the 2009 Internet Survey of the Health and Retirement Study (HRS), the Institute found that almost 22 percent of “households reported that they have made some changes in their prescription drugs to save money, and nearly as many report that they have either skipped or postponed doctor appointments to do so.” Twenty seven percent of households “reported difficulty in paying their monthly bills”:

Red States Make Progress In Implementing Obamacare, Administration Report Finds

The Obama administration has released a new report tracking the progress of states in building the health care exchanges that are part of the Affordable Care Act. Twenty-eight states and the District of Columbia “are on their way toward establishing their own Affordable Insurance Exchange,” the report notes and have received three rounds of grants from the federal government to set-up the new regulated marketplaces where small businesses and individuals will be able to compare and shop for comprehensive insurance beginning in 2014. States that fail to build their own exchanges will have to turn over their markets to the federal government.

The theoretical concept of encouraging insurers to compete on a level playing field within a new regulated market was originally developed by the Heritage Foundation in the 1990s and later embraced in Mitt Romney’s Massachusetts health care reform law. As the administration’s report notes, it’s also gaining momentum in some right-leaning states, many of which are also suing over the constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act:

– Nevada: The Silver State Health Insurance Exchange was authorized through bipartisan legislation passed unanimously by both chambers of the Nevada Legislature and signed into law by Governor Brian Sandoval (R) on June 16, 2011. [...] Its seven-member board was appointed on September 23, 2011 and met for the first time on October 26, 2011.

– Alabama: Governor Robert Bentley (R), a physician, issued an Executive Order that created the Alabama Health Insurance Exchange Study Commission on June 2, 2011. [...] Alabama received an Exchange establishment grant of $8.6 million on November 29 from HHS. The State also is participating in a technical assistance program run by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. The legislature, which meets in February, is expected to take up legislation to establish an Exchange.

– Mississippi: The State created a Mississippi Health Insurance Exchange Study Commission in 2010, and used its $1 million planning grant to fund research and outreach. On April 26, 2011, then-Governor Haley Barbour (R) signed a law that allowed the Study Commission to continue its work through 2011. [...] After legislation authorizing an Exchange failed to pass, the State determined in October 2011 that the previously authorized non-profit high-risk pool association could broaden its mission to run the State’s Exchange.

– Michigan: On September 14, 2011, Governor Rick Snyder (R) announced his intent to create a State-based Exchange called MIHealth Marketplace. [...] The Senate passed bi-partisan exchange legislation in November, however the House failed to act. On November 29, the State was awarded $9.8 million to establish its Exchange and is seeking the legislature’s authority to spend the funds

— Pennsylvania: On November 23, 2011, Governor Tom Corbett (R) announced his commitment to establishing a State-based Exchange. [...] Pennsylvania used the majority of its Exchange planning grant to award a contract to a consulting firm to conduct extensive background research. This resulted in a comprehensive analysis of Exchange governance models, business operations, structure, plan management and financial management.

Federal regulators have also been eager to allow states additional flexibility in forming the exchanges. States can choose to share responsibilities with the federal government and use their establishment grants “to test their systems for their Exchanges that start later than 2014.”

Romney Claimed Final Massachusetts Health Law ‘Incorporates 95 Percent Of My Original Proposal’

On the campaign trail, Mitt Romney distances himself from his signature health care law by highlighting the eight vetoes he made to the measure the day he signed it, and blaming Massachusetts Democrats for failing to keep costs under control and implement it correctly. As he explains in his book No Apology, “So I vetoed measures I felt were expensive or counterproductive, but there were overridden by the legislature.” He echoed this message on Fox News Sunday: “There are some features I didn’t like that the legislature put in place,” he said, referring to the employer mandate, and they essential health benefits provisions. “I vetoed it, they overrode it, that’s the nature of the legislative process.”

But as Sen. John McCain’s 2008 opposition book on Romney points out, the former Massachusetts governor felt satisfied with the law he ultimately signed. A June 7, 2006 Newsweek article quotes Romney as saying:

The final legislation incorporates about 95 percent of my original proposal. So I think, overall, it is a major step forward. We will have health insurance for all our citizens without a government takeover and without new taxes required.”

Indeed, as Boston Globe reporters Michael Kranish and Scott Helman write in The Real Romney, the GOP candidate had been pleased with the final version of the law, telling reporters, “We are where we’d hoped we’d be.” “This isn’t 100 percent of what anyone in this room wanted,” Romney said at the signing ceremony in April 2006. “But the differences between us are small.”

Romney explained that the law would be “a big part of the legacy I will have personally for my four years of service as governor.” “But,” he added, “I have no way of telling if it’s going to be a help or a hindrance down the road.”

Morning CheckUp: January 18, 2012

U.S. wants Alzheimer’s treatment by 2025: “The government is setting what it calls an ambitious goal for Alzheimer’s disease: Development of effective ways to treat and prevent the mind-destroying illness by 2025.” [AP]

Many New York retailers don’t offer health coverage: “Retail workers in New York City earn a median of $9.50 an hour, most are part-time or temporary, and just 3 in 10 receive health insurance through their jobs, according to a new study of the city’s larger retailers” [NYT]

Obesity epidemic may have peaked: “The nation’s obesity epidemic appears to have hit a plateau, according to the latest federal data released Tuesday. Obesity soared in the U.S. during the 1980s and 1990s, doubling among adults and tripling among children. That raised widespread alarm and debate about the causes and possible solutions. Obesity can increase the risk for diabetes, heart disease, cancer and other serious health problems.” [NPR]

Oregon governor proposes coordinated care plan: “Oregon Gov. John Kitzhaber is proposing to change the state’s Medicaid program by ending its fee-for-service model and instituting ‘coordinated care organizations’ to manage patients’ chronic care to keep them out of hospital rooms.” [AP]

Vermont governor introduces exchange legislation: “Legislation introduced Tuesday could lay the groundwork for the first phase of substantive health care reform in Vermont as the state inches toward universal health care. Rep. Mike Fisher, D-Lincoln, and Rep. Ann Pugh, D-South Burlington, introduced H.559, legislation from the Shumlin administration that would set out the ground rules for a health benefits exchange that the state is required to put into effect in 2014″ [VT Digger]

Maryland governor seeks to establish “health enterprise” zones: “Gov. Martin O’Malley’s administration will seek legislation this year to allow officials to designate underserved communities in Maryland for tax credits and other state incentives to improve health care delivery.” [Gazette.Net]

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up