ThinkProgress Logo

Health

Republicans Will Likely Renege On Their Pledge To ‘Replace’ Obamacare

Congressional Republicans have promised to “repeal and replace” President Obama’s health care reform law, but they still have not agreed on what that should look like. Today, Speaker John Boehner said every part of Obamacare needs to be removed:

“We voted to fully repeal the president’s healthcare law as one of our first acts as a new House majority, and our plan remains to repeal the law in its entirety,” Boehner said to reporters. “Anything short of that is unacceptable.”

But Republicans have yet to offer a viable alternative that would that would fill the void left by the law and provide coverage to the 30 million Americans who would lose insurance without Obamacare. Politico reported this morning that GOP leaders have quietly begun to float a piecemeal plan that may provide limited insurance coverage to a small portion of the uninsured. Republicans have said they would preserve the most popular provisions, like allowing young adults to stay on their parents’ health insurance until age 26, without the individual mandate that helps pay for the regulations.

But the GOP’s internal disagreement and unwillingness to offer a unified comprehensive plan suggests that they consider health care a low legislative priority. For instance, Rep. Paul Ryan (R-WI) — the GOP’s spokesman on economic issues — told the Washington Examiner on Thursday that the party will “articulate our vision” to replace the law, but wouldn’t necessarily offer a legislative solution.

This approach contrasts sharply from Republican’s pledge to “replace” reform as soon as it became law in 2010. Boehner promised in 2010 to “replace it with common-sense reforms,” and Ryan said in a 2011 speech that Republicans can’t stop at simply repealing the law and “have a responsibility to fix the broken network of government policies that have made such a mess of health care.”

But now that their strategy looks like nothing more than tossing out a law that helps expand access to health insurance while controlling costs, Republicans are telling the uninsured and those worried about rising health care costs that they are not concerned about fixing their problems.

NEWS FLASH

Louisiana Legislature Advances Two Anti-Abortion Bills | A Louisiana Senate committee approved two anti-choice bills yesterday. One bill would ban abortions after 20 weeks based on the disputed claim that a fetus can feel pain at that point. That bill would make an exception for instances where the mother’s life was at risk, but doctors who violate the measure could face two years in prison. Seven other states have “>approved similar laws. Another bill would require a woman to hear the fetal heartbeat before having an abortion. The bill’s sponsor, Sen. Sharon Weston Broom (D), called it an update of a bill she sponsored last year which required women receive an ultrasound before an abortion could be performed. -Zachary Bernstein

NEWS FLASH

Another Catholic Colleges Drops Its Student Insurance Plan And Blames Obamacare | Ave Maria University, a Catholic college in Florida, plans to drop its student health insurance plan because of “moral and economic concerns,” and officials are blaming the Obama administration’s contraception rule and the Affordable Care Act. University President James Towey said students would see premiums job 65 to 82 percent because of Obamacare requirements restricting annual limits on insurance policies. Because of the cost increase and contraception coverage requirement, Towey told Fox News that “we just might get out of this business.” In Februay, Ave Maria University filed a lawsuit claiming the contraception coverage mandate violated the college’s religious liberties, despite the fact that the regulation offers accommodations to religious institutions so that they do not have to pay for contraception.

Missouri House Passes A Bill Allowing Medical Professionals To Deny Women’s Access To Contraception

The Missouri House passed a “conscience bill” yesterday to allow health care workers to deny health care to women. Under the law, medical professionals cannot be fired or discriminated against for refusing to provide contraception or perform abortions if it conflicted with their personal views, while employers do not have to cover contraception.

But as opponents of the measure point out, there is more at stake than religious convictions for doctors or pharmacists:

Most of the opposition in the House came from Democratic lawmakers representing districts near St. Louis and Kansas City who argued the legislation would inhibit access to health care for some Missourians. Several opponents said it seemed the measure was aimed particularly at birth control.

Rep. Stacey Newman, D-St. Louis, said the medical procedures at issue in the legislation would affect women most directly. Speaking with a male opponent of the measure, Newman said, “You will be putting your stamp on what you think I should be doing and also deciding if your religious beliefs will supersede my religious beliefs and my moral convictions.”

This bill now goes to the state Senate for consideration before the Missouri legislative session ends on Friday.

Missouri is not the only state to consider this kind of bill. On Tuesday, Kansas Gov. Sam Brownback (R) signed a similar bill allowing pharmacists to refuse to fill a prescription that they think could be used to induce an abortion. Opponents claim the law is broad enough that it could allow pharmacists to deny birth control or emergency contraception, or even procedures like chemotherapy if they would put a pregnancy at risk.

Update

The St. Louis Beacon reports that House and Senate leaders appear to have agreed on a compromise bill, which passed the Senate 29-5 today. Some of the provisions in the House bill have been stripped, including one which would have allowed pharmacies to decline to stock a drug or medical device, but employers could still opt out of providing insurance coverage for abortion or contraception. The House is also expected to pass the compromise bill and send it to Gov. Jay Nixon (D), who is raising some objections to parts of the bill, according to the Beacon.

-Zachary Bernstein

Study: AIDS Program That Romney Is ‘Very Reluctant’ To Fund Has Prevented 741,000 Deaths

Foreign aid in the United States accounts for less than 1 percent of all federal spending. Despite that, several Republicans want to slash, if not eliminate, assistance to poorer nations. But a new report on the effectiveness of one aid program should make policymakers reconsider that broad approach.

A study released Wednesday showed that the U.S. President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief (PEPFAR) averted 741,000 deaths between 2004 and 2008. Previous research found that PEPFAR, created in 2003 by President George W. Bush, had prevented AIDS-related deaths, although researchers did not know if those people were dying of other diseases instead. But this report shows that is no the case, according to Reuters:

Data for the new study came from surveys done with adult women in 27 African countries, including nine with PEPFAR programs. Women were asked about their adult siblings and recent deaths in their families. The researchers used that information to calculate approximately how many adults in each country were dying every year, for any reason.

In 2003, Bendavid and his colleagues found that between eight and nine out of every 1,000 adults died, both in PEPFAR and non-PEPFAR nations. Countries in the new report that weren’t part of the program included Madagascar, Liberia, Senegal and Zimbabwe.

Five years later, death rates had dropped to four per 1,000 in PEPFAR countries and declined more modestly to seven out of every 1,000 without the program. That worked out to a 16 percent lower chance of death in countries with PEPFAR between 2004 and 2008, once other factors such as a country’s overall HIV rate and wealth were taken into account, the researchers reported Tuesday in the Journal of the American Medical Association.

Despite the proven results, Mitt Romney would cut PEPFAR funds if elected president. At a New Hampshire town hall last October, Romney said he was “very reluctant to borrow lots more money to be able to do wonderful things, if those things can be done by people making charitable contributions or if other countries that are wealthy.” But as Bush said of PEPFAR last year, “We’re a blessed nation in the United States of America and I believe we are required to support effective programs that save lives.”

Romney is not always against spending or borrowing more money, however. From 2003 to 2008, Congress appropriated $18.8 billion to PEPFAR, or $3.76 billion a year. In contrast, Romney’s budget plan would increase the military budget by at least $210 billion a year over 10 years. Overall, the tax cuts in his budget would cost $10.7 trillion over the next decade.

-Zachary Bernstein

Steve King Claims Obamacare Will Grow The Number Of Uninsured, Calls For ‘Personal Responsibility’

During an appearance on CSPAN’s Washington Journal Thursday morning, Rep. Steve King (R-IA) claimed that the Affordable Care Act would increase the number of Americans without health insurance, dismissing analysis showing that 30 million people would gain coverage under the law.

“Everybody in America has access to health care, and we even have many many organizations that make sure they fill those holes,” King explained. “The effort was to increase the number of insured in America and that number does not look like it will increase under Obamacare”:

KING: We’re actually going to get more people uninsured under Obamacare and this creates the foundation for a one-size-fits-all federally-run socialized medicine system. We’re not completely there and I think we are a lot better off to let the free markets do this and encourage people to be personally responsible.

Watch it:

King’s analysis of health policy couldn’t be more wrong. While organizations and hospitals do provide emergency services to uninsured Americans, the cost of that uncompensated care is shifted to private premium payers, resulting in higher health care spending system-wide. Obamacare accepts King’s premise of encouraging personal responsibility and will require able-bodied citizens to pay for their own health care expenses beginning in 2014.

During the interview, King also reiterated his opposition to requiring insurers to provide health care coverage to people with pre-existing conditions and said that Republicans should repeal the health care law in its entirety without preserving its popular provisions. This position puts him at odds with Republican leaders, who are drafting a plan to maintain aspects of the law that allow young people to stay on their parents health care plans and outlaw discrimination against sick people.

Morning CheckUp: May 17, 2012

Planned Parenthood pushes back against Ohio bill: “Advocates for Planned Parenthood centers in Ohio packed a legislative hearing to show opposition to a measure that would send them to the back of the line to receive family planning money. Opponents say it will largely cut or altogether eliminate funding for Planned Parenthood.” [AP]

States must submit insurance exchanges plans by November: “States must provide details to the federal government by Nov. 16 – just 10 days after the presidential election – on how they will run online insurance marketplaces, according to guidance released Wednesday. Those that don’t meet the deadline – or that can’t operate their own marketplaces, called exchanges – will have it done for them by the federal government, starting in January 2014.” [Kaiser Health News]

Court weighs whether to life age restriction on emergency contraception: “A federal district court in New York is weighing whether to force the federal government to lift the age restrictions on over-the-counter sale of emergency contraceptives.” [Politico]

FDA delays deadline for sunscreen labels: “The U.S. Food and Drug Administration has delayed by six months rules on the marketing of sunscreen originally set to go into effect this summer, saying the extra time was needed to avoid supply shortages.” [Reuters]

Brain ailments in veterans likened to those in athletes: “Scientists who have studied a degenerative brain disease in athletes have found the same condition in combat veterans exposed to roadside bombs in Iraq and Afghanistan, concluding that such explosions injure the brain in ways strikingly similar to tackles and punches.” [New York Times]

Half as many women die during pregnancy, childbirth as in 1990: “The report finds that 287,000 women died in pregnancy in 2010 – a staggering number that still comes off as progress when compared with the 543,000 women who died in pregnancy in 1990.” [Christian Science Monitor]

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up