ThinkProgress Logo

Health

Rick Perry Factors Into State Budget Obamacare Funds He Had Pledged To Reject

Eight days after the Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act’s individual mandate and ruled that the federal government cannot penalize states that refuse to expand Medicaid, Texas Gov. Rick Perry (R) announced that he would not open the program to more applicants. But while he was making a public show of turning down federal funds, Perry was using the additional dollars in state budget projections.

In a letter explaining how he would fill a budget gap left by Texas’ decision to defund Planned Parenthood, Perry’s office uses the money the federal government will pay states that make Medicaid available to individuals up to 133 percent of the Federal Poverty Line in its budgetary assumptions:

Greta Rymal, Deputy Executive Commissioner for Financial Services, has projected the fiscal impact of this rule for three years, assuming that all clients will be eligible for Medicaid following the expansion of the Medicaid program in January 2014 [...]

Several months ago, the Texas health commissioner signed a rule to ban Planned Parenthood or any organization the state considers an “abortion affiliate” from participating in Medicaid’s Women’s Health Program, which “provides low-income women with family planning exams, related health screenings and birth control” throughout Texas. The state’s discrimination against a specific health provider violated federal rules and led Washington, which had financed 90 percent of the WHP through Medicaid funds, to block Texas from receiving further funding for the program.

According to a new report from the George Washington University School of Public Health, more than 52,000 people benefited from Planned Parenthood’s services as part of the Women’s Health Program in Texas in 2010.

Update

The Dallas Morning News reports that the original letter was rendered incorrect by Gov. Perry’s decision to turn down the expansion. However, state officials have no moved to correct the letter.

NEWS FLASH

HHS Official: Discrimination Against Transgender People Is Illegal Under Obamacare | In response to a letter from a coalition of LGBT groups, the Department of Health and Human Services has confirmed that discrimination against transgender people by federal health care programs and programs funded with federal dollars is illegal under the Affordable Care Act. Leon Rodriguez — the director of HHS’s civil rights office — responded to LGBT advocacy organizations’ concerns that Obamacare’s anti-discrimination Section 1557 did not clarify whether or not it included transgender people in its protections. In the letter, Rodriguez deems discrimination based on “gender identity or failure to conform to stereotypical notions of masculinity or femininity” in ACA-related programs illegal. Before the passage of Obamacare, for example, a transgender woman was denied coverage for routine treatment for a deviated septum because of her “condition.” Thankfully, the HHS has clarified that under Obamacare, this practice would now be forbidden.

Steven Perlberg

(HT: Buzzfeed)

Arizona Student Turns To Twitter, Fundraisers To Pay Medical Bills After Student Insurance Plan Falls Short

Arijit Guha, a 31-year-old doctoral student at Arizona State University, hit his lifetime limit of $300,000 on his student insurance plan very quickly while fighting Stage 4 colon cancer. To pay for the remaining $118,000 in medical bills from his chemotherapy treatments, Guha started selling items on his website, Poop Strong, in February. He said a friend called his fundraiser “the world’s most important bake sale,” and he told Wonkblog’s Sarah Kliff that it “feels like this weird joke, that I’m selling T-shirts to pay for chemotherapy.”

In late July, Guha tried a faster way to address the unpaid bills: Twitter. He used the social media site to call out his insurance carrier, Aetna:

He sent a tweet to his insurance carrier, Aetna: “@Aetna’s 4th qtr profit up 73%: ‘it continued to benefit from low use of health care.’ Helps they can ensure low use.”

After he engaged in a back-and-forth with chief executive Mark Bertolini, the insurance company moved quickly to work out a solution. Within 24 hours, Guha’s 23-word tweet had done more than six straight months of fundraising ever could: It persuaded Aetna to cover all his outstanding medical bills, showcasing the power of social media to catalyze swift action from a major company. [...]

“Although he reached the limits of his plan, Aetna care managers have continued to provide support and we have worked to develop a solution,” the company said in a statement. [...]

Guha has come away with a similar conclusion. He was ecstatic about the result. But he also considers himself as an exception to the rule: Not every American struggling with medical debt gets into a Twitter exchange with a health insurance CEO and catches a lucky break.

Thanks to Obamacare, insurance providers will have to eliminate lifetime limits on health care plans. This regulation kicked in for student insurance plans in July 2012, so Guha will not have to worry about the $300,000 limit he passed long ago the next time he renews his insurance plan. And students who sign up for insurance plans through their universities will be guaranteed more comprehensive coverage.

As ThinkProgress reported in June, the plans some schools offer are mini-med plans that provide almost no protection when students actually get sick or injured. Upping the standards will lead to much better coverage for more students, and it is possible to avoid rising costs while improving benefits. In Massachusetts, for example, a number of schools joined together to buy coverage collectively for 12,000 students without dramatically increasing premiums.

According to the Government Accountability Office, 600,000 students — 7 percent of 18 to 23-year-olds in college — bought insurance through their school’s plans. By providing more comprehensive plans, like removing lifetime limits, future students faced with the same situation as Guha hopefully will not have to turn to T-shirt sales and Twitter to cover their cancer treatments.

LGBT

Anti-Gay Stigma And Criminalization Help Maintain HIV Epidemic

Map of State-Sponsored Homophobia (via International Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex Association)

A new report in the medical journal The Lancet details the available data about how stigma against homosexuality across the globe is interfering with efforts to slow down the spread of HIV. The article notes that “most global cases of HIV are not due to homosexual transmission,” but anti-gay laws, harassment, intimidation, silence, and invisibility still have a major impact on the effectiveness of HIV advocacy and outreach:

Almost everywhere, rates of HIV infection are higher in men who have sex with men than in the rest of the population. This is partly because of inadequate information, denial of resources for prevention services of all sorts, and because heterosexism and homophobia marginalise people and make them less able to adopt preventive techniques, even if they are available. Although difficult to prove conclusively, good evidence shows that greater stigma and criminalisation helps increase vulnerability to infection.[...]

Homophobia both increases vulnerability and reduces access to services. Prevention programmes directed towards homosexual men are often harassed by police, and official silence means that some men mistakenly believe that homosexual intercourse is safe. In much of the former Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, Africa, and the Middle East, where any recognition of rights or citizenship is denied to homosexuals, programming of services to include MSM is difficult to achieve. Homophobia affects HIV in direct ways by driving discussion about MSM and homosexuality underground, legitimising fear and prejudice, and compromising AIDS service organisations so that they cannot work publicly with LGBT and MSM communities.

This argument jibes with reports that HIV rates in Uganda actually increased as what seems to be a backfire of the abstinence-based advocacy required by President George W. Bush’s AIDS relief plan (PEPFAR). When all gay sex is condemned — or even simply when marriage equality is denied — abstinence messages sound to gay men like sentences to a life of chastity, a life without love. Sexual health can only be addressed when sex is actually acknowledged and discussed, and homophobia continues to be the largest barrier to that education taking place.

 

NEWS FLASH

Iowa Official Rejects Republican Attempt To Ban Funding For Abortion Care In Case Of Rape, Incest | A top Iowa health official rejected a costly effort by state Republicans to forbid state funding for abortions in the cases of rape and incest. Iowa Department of Human Services director Charles Palmer, who was appointed by Gov. Terry Branstad (R), sent a letter to House Republicans arguing their efforts to strong-arm his agency could result in the loss of $2.1 billion in federal funding. House Republicans originally argued that only $6 million in Medicaid funding would be in jeopardy if the state defied federal requirements, but the governor’s office differed. Palmer’s letter came in response to the Iowa House’s June petition requesting that DHS cease funding for abortions in the cases of rape or incest. A familiar theme in the Iowa legislature this year, Republicans also attempted to pass a bill that would punish doctors who perform abortions to life imprisonment without the chance for parole.

Steven Perlberg

GOP Lawmaker: Planned Parenthood Is ‘Getting Wealthy On Murder For Hire’

State Rep. Larry Pittman (R-NC)

According to one North Carolina Republican, Planned Parenthood’s health clinics — which provide critical health services for thousands of women at their nine locations throughout the state — are doing nothing more than “getting wealthy on murder for hire.”

State Rep. Larry Pittman (R) had a strong reaction to a recent email from Planned Parenthood that appealed state legislators not to cut funding to the organization. Pittman responded to the email, which was sent to each member of the NC House of Representatives Health and Human Services Appropriations committee at the end of May, with allegations that Planned Parenthood is a “murderous organization”:

PITTMAN: [Planned Parenthood] is a murderous organization…getting wealthy on murder for hire. It deals out nothing but deception, death, personal devastation, and moral degradation. Never will I agree to give that bloody, indecent, immoral organization one penny. I will not be satisfied until it is outlawed.

North Carolina’s Planned Parenthood clinics are facing budget cuts that will essentially serve to defund the organization, a tactic that Republicans across the country are using to attack Planned Parenthood. The Republican-controlled legislature passed a budget in July that strips state funding for the organization and its affiliates.

Some North Carolina residents are criticizing Rep. Pittman’s harsh email response, pointing our that “regardless of anyone’s stance on abortion, the point of this story is how unprofessional and inappropriate our elected government official has acted.” When the Independent Tribune asked Pittman to comment on this criticism, he simply doubled down on his overblown rhetoric:

PITTMAN: My sources tell me that 75 percent of [Planned Parenthood’s] income comes through abortions. To say that they would try to reduce the incidence of abortion is like saying a baker would go around trying to get people to stop eating bread.

Pittman’s sources are wrong. Nationwide, abortion services contribute to just three percent of Planned Parenthood’s total health services. In North Carolina alone, Planned Parenthood’s health clinics provide over 18,000 tests for sexually transmitted infections, over 11,000 breast and cervical cancer screenings, and contraceptive services to more than 61,000 women.

This is not the first instance that Pittman, who is running unopposed for reelection in his district, has circulated his radical anti-choice views over email. In January, he sent an email to every member of North Carolina’s General Assembly to say he favors bringing back public hangings for abortion providers.

NEWS FLASH

Notre Dame Students Ask College To Drop Obamacare Lawsuit | More than 100 students, faculty, and alumni at the University of Notre Dame have signed a petition opposing the college’s decision to join a lawsuit against the constitutionality of an Obamacare regulation that requires employers and insurers to offer preventive health services — including contraception — without additional cost sharing for consumers. Notre Dame was one of 43 religious institutions that filed 12 lawsuits against rule, arguing that it infringed on their religious liberty. The petition began as a personal letter to university President Fr. John Jenkins from Kathryn Pogin, a philosophy graduate student, according to Notre Dame’s student newspaper The Observer. Polgin said, “It’s not clear to us that the University couldn’t comply with the mandate without remaining within Catholic practice.”

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up