ThinkProgress Logo

Home Page

Justice

BREAKING: Johnson & Johnson Drops ALEC

Pharmaceutical giant Johnson and Johnson announced today that they are dropping their membership from the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC).

Johnson and Johnson has been facing mounting pressure following a push from Color of Change and other progressive groups to leave the conservative agenda-setting group.

ALEC is responsible for crafting voter suppression legislation that has been used in state houses across the country, and the “Stand Your Ground” law that originally protected Trayvon Martin’s killer, George Zimmerman. Johnson and Johnson is the latest in a huge wave of groups leaving ALEC.

Other groups that have dropped ALEC include: Walmart, Amazon.com, Coca-Cola, PepsiCo, Kraft, Wendy’s, Mars, Inc., Arizona Public Service, the National Board for Professional Teaching StandardsScantron, The National Association of Charter School Authorizers, Kaplan, Procter & Gamble, Yum! Brands, five Pennsylvania legislators, Blue Cross/Blue Shield, Reed Elsevier, American Traffic Solutions, Intuit, and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.

Economy

NOTE TO ROMNEY: The Federal Government Does Fund Teachers, Firefighters, And Police

Mitt Romney dismissed criticisms that he does not want to hire more teachers, firefighters, and police officers as “absurd” on Tuesday morning, telling Fox News Channel that if elected president, he would not have the ability to control the hiring decisions of local governments:

ROMNEY: Of course, teachers and firemen and policemen are hired at the local level and also by states. The federal government doesn’t pay for teachers, firefighters or policemen. So obviously that’s completely absurd.

But Romney’s comment demonstrates a disturbing lack of understanding of both federal funding and his own published plans. While it is true that teachers, firefighters, and police are hired at the local level, a significant portion of their funding, recruiting, and training comes from the federal government.

Here are just some of the ways the federal government funds:

Teachers

Firefighters

Police

Justice

GOP Front Group Suing States To Force Voter Purges

A screen shot from True the Vote's website

A Tea Party group is suing states to try to purge their voter rolls before November’s election. True the Vote, an arm of the King Street Patriots, has filed a suit against the state of Indiana, alleging that the state has poor “list maintenance” of its voters.

This suit kicks off a series of state-focused attempts by True the Vote, serving as a co-plaintiff with the conservative “watchdog” group Judicial Watch, to limit voter turnout this election season. Voter purges may be presented under the guise of fairer elections, but the idea of “cleaning” a list usually results in legal voters — overwhelmingly voters of color — being kicked off the rolls.

True the Vote’s agenda is clearly political, as can be evidenced from their website that lists Wisconsin’s recall election as a ‘victory’ (despite day-of claims of voter fraud) and Florida as an upcoming target. Other states on the list for lawsuits include more than half are swing states in play this election season:

According to a Judicial Watch investigation voter rolls in the following states appear to contain the names of individuals who are ineligible to vote: Mississippi, Iowa, Indiana, Missouri, Texas, Ohio, Pennsylvania, West Virginia, Florida, Alabama, and California. As part of its 2012 Election Integrity Project, Judicial Watch has put these states on notice that they must clean up their voter registration lists or face Judicial Watch lawsuits.

The Obama Justice Department has failed to enforce Section 8 the NVRA in court, having last filed a lawsuit to enforce voter list maintenance requirements of the NVRA in 2007. The current DOJ it is now opposing Florida’s Section 8 efforts to remove non-citizens from the voting rolls.

“This lawsuit is a historic step in restoring integrity to the American system of electing its leaders,” stated True the Vote President Catherine Engelbrecht. “Dirty election rolls can lead to election fraud and stolen elections.”

Attempts at “list management” aren’t quite as clear-cut as the press release makes it out to be. Florida’s recent tussles over voter rolls have resulted in voter suppression efforts — though it was technically aimed at non-citizens, those kicked off the rolls included two 90-plus world war two veterans. But while those voters were purged under the banner of protecting elections, fraud in the state is still less likely than getting hit by lighting.

Alyssa

New Report: Penn State Officials Thought It Was ‘Humane’ Not to Report Sandusky

It’s sort of hard to believe that folks could have behaved even more poorly in the events surrounding the coverup of former Penn State football coach Jerry Sandusky’s alleged sexual abuse and assault of children he met through his Second Mile charity. But as his trial is underway, it appears my beliefs have been confounded: Pennsylvania’s attorney general is now suggesting that former Penn State vice president Gary Schultz kept a file on Sandusky, and that in emails between him and former Penn State president Graham Spanier suggest that university officials thought it would be more “humane” not to report Sandusky than to report him. The full report from a local CBS station is here:

There’s a debate to be had about whether it makes sense for universities to build enormous sports edifices in their midst and to become reliant on the revenue they provide. But if they’re going to make that decision, I think we can all agree that for those institutions to survive, university administrators need to distinguish between athletic programs and the people who run them. And while I want to see the full text of the emails, the idea that not reporting Sandusky would have been the “humane” thing seems grotesque in a way that would be almost impossible to justify even in context, and reflects a profound failure of judgement.

The idea that Sandusky deserved consideration more than the victims’ families deserved justice or that the community deserved a chance to have him go through a fair trial is humane only in a system that values the powerful over the powerless, or the few among the many. Even if your values are so distorted as to put concern for Sandusky before other considerations, wouldn’t the humane thing to do to be to separate him from his capacity to do harm to others, and if he’s mentally ill, to get him treated? Someone who concludes that not reporting Sandusky is the humane things to do seems to lack the moral credentials to effectively administer a large organization, particularly one tasked with preparing young people to become solid citizens. And making the decision not to report Sandusky reveals a bizarre lack of business sense: silence is not the same thing as containing rot.

Economy

FOUL PLAY: Five Cities That Want Taxpayer Money To Finance Pro Sports Stadium Boondoggles

Drawing of the new 49ers stadium in Santa Clara, CA

Cities across the country are turning to taxpayers to finance newer, fancier sports stadiums that feature more luxurious amenities than their predecessors, a trend that has persisted through the Great Recession and economic recovery despite dire state budget situations.

Team owners, with an assist from state and local governments, persuade taxpayers to finance these projects by promising increased economic activity, jobs, and growth, but those promises don’t often come true. The stadiums rarely pay for themselves, leaving local economies engulfed in debt while teams come back asking for even newer stadiums before the current facilities are paid off. Often, if taxpayers don’t agree to finance new facilities, teams threaten to move, leaving dedicated fans and indebted taxpayers behind.

Here are five cities that are currently in the process of financing either new stadiums or expensive renovations to their current facilities for their professional sports teams:

Minneapolis: After years of fighting, the Minnesota state Senate approved a stadium deal handing Minneapolis’ NFL team, the Minnesota Vikings, $348 million in state subsidies. Minneapolis will contribute another $150 million in public financing. That was actually lower than the original plan, which used taxpayer money to pay for more than 60 percent of the stadium’s total cost. The deal comes just two years after the opening of Target Field, the new home of baseball’s Minnesota Twins that was paid for by a new sales tax. The city still owes more than $50 million on the Target Center, home of the NBA’s Minnesota Timberwolves, and neighboring St. Paul still owes $32 million on the Xcel Center, which houses hockey’s Minnesota Wild. The state also paid for nearly half of the $300 million stadium that became of the new home of the University of Minnesota’s football team in 2009.

Santa Clara: In February, Santa Clara’s city council promised the NFL’s San Francisco 49ers more than $878 million in public loans for a new stadium to replace the team’s stadium in San Francisco. The city claims the loan will have no impact on its General Fund, even as its only assurance that the debt will be repaid comes from stadium revenue projections. Voters approved a stadium plan in 2010 but fought for a new referendum this year on grounds that the city didn’t spell out how the deal was financed. The new referendum was ruled invalid, though, and the 49ers broke ground in March.

Washington, DC: Taxpayers in the nation’s capital need no reminder about the negative effects of financing a stadium. Less than a decade ago, the city approved a taxpayer-financed stadium for its new Major League Baseball team, the Washington Nationals. Now, Major League Soccer’s D.C. United are seeking a new facility that would cost $157 million — and that’s before the cost of land is added. It’s unclear how the stadium would be financed, though city officials have reportedly expressed willingness to fund new infrastructure projects to serve the stadium. And the United are taking a page from the books of teams in larger sports in an attempt to get a stadium, exploring a move to Baltimore at the same time.

Atlanta: The Georgia Dome is a premier sports facility that hosts major sporting events nearly every year and is the home of the NFL’s Atlanta Falcons. But Falcon’s owner Arthur Blank is seeking a new stadium, even though the Dome is only 20 years old. Construction of the new stadium would rely on $300 million in taxpayer funds, even as the state’s education budget remains drained from the effects of the Great Recession.

St. Louis: In 1995, the city of St. Louis opened a new dome for its NFL team, the St. Louis Rams. The dome was financed in part by $126 million in bonds that will ultimately cost $720 million. (The same year, the city agreed to help finance a new stadium for its professional baseball team after it threatened to move to suburban Illinois.) Just 17 years into their 30-year lease, the Rams are asking for major renovations to the stadium thanks to a deal that requires the city to maintain its “first-tier” status. St. Louis recently rejected the Rams’ renovation proposal, but reports surfaced yesterday showing that it offered the team $48 million in public subsidies in a counter-offer.

In these cities and others, state and local governments are cutting services, slashing education budgets, and selling local hospitals, even as they ask taxpayers to pay for new and existing sports facilities. Pro teams that want new stadiums have an easy solution for getting them: instead of holding their hand out to taxpayers, they should foot the bill themselves.

NEWS FLASH

Study: Stand Your Ground Laws Increase Homicides | Additional legal protections for self-defense killings — including the controversial “stand your ground” laws (the subject of new a U.S. Civil Rights Commission Inquiry) — do not deter crime, according to a new study from Texas A&M University examining laws that “widen the scope for the justified use of deadly force in self-defense.” In fact, according to the study’s authors, the laws do the opposite, increasing the chances of murder or manslaughter “by lowering the expected costs associated with using lethal force,” according to the study. “[W]e find the laws increase murder and manslaughter by a statistically significant 7 to 9 percent, which translates into an additional 500 to 700 homicides per year nationally across the states that adopted” such laws, the authors wrote, noting that those could be cases “driven by the escalation of violence in situations that otherwise would not have ended in serious injury for either party.”

Health

Romney Confirms He Will Deny Insurance To Millions With Pre-Existing Conditions If Obamacare Is Struck Down

Mitt Romney confirmed on Tuesday that he would allow insurers to deny coverage to millions of Americans with pre-existing conditions if the Supreme Court strikes down Obamacare later this month. During a speech at Con-Air Industries in Orlando, Florida, the former Massachusetts governor said that Americans who have not been “continuously insured” would not be protected from discrimination if they suffer from pre-existing conditions:

ROMNEY: So let’s say someone has been continuously insured and they develop a serious condition. And let’s say they lose their jobs or they change jobs or they move and go to a different place, I don’t want them to be denied insurance because they have some pre-existing conditions. So we’re going to have to make sure that the law that we replace Obamacare with, ensures that people who have a pre-existing condition, who have been insured in the past, are able to get insurance in the future so they don’t have to worry about that condition keeping them from getting the kind of health care they deserve.

Watch it:

While the Affordable Care Act would prevent insurers from denying coverage to anyone with a pre-existing condition beginning in 2014, Romney’s provision is far more limited — and would only protect Americans who already have coverage.

As The New Republic’s Jonathan Cohn has pointed out, the federal government already forbids insurers from denying coverage to the continuously covered through the 1996 Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). But the measure has been seen as a failure because “there is no limit on what insurers can charge under HIPAA” and the law does “little to regulate the content of coverage, leaving the door open to insurers to offer bare-bones policies. In addition, HIPAA notice requirements are weak, making it hard for people to know about this protection.”

Romney could offer to bolster the existing law, but given his general laissez-faire approach to health care and opposition to “government interference” in the private sector, it’s unlikely that he would want to impose new regulations on insurers. Without a mandate for everyone to purchase coverage, the protection would also attract sicker people who need care and increase premiums for all enrollees. In other words, it’s a poor solution that will leave millions still searching for coverage.

Economy

Romney Reverses Course, Claims It’s ‘Completely Absurd’ To Say He Doesn’t Want To Hire More Teachers

Mitt Romney slammed President Obama last week for wanting to hire “more firemen, more policemen, and more teachers,” making a clear assertion that those workers belong among the 700,000 public sector workers who have lost their jobs in the last three years.

Romney’s campaign chair and other endorsers have backed him up on this desire to keep public employees out of work. But during an appearance on Fox News Tuesday morning, Romney contradicted his own remarks, saying that the Obama campaign was making “a very strange accusation” when it claimed he didn’t want to hire more teachers:

KILMEADE: He says you’re out of touch. He says you want to cut firefighters and teachers, that you don’t understand what’s going on in these communities. What do you say to that, governor?

ROMNEY: That’s a very strange accusation. Of course, teachers and firemen and policemen are hired at the local level and also by states. The federal government doesn’t pay for teachers, firefighters or policemen. So obviously that’s completely absurd. He’s got a new idea, though, and that is to have another stimulus and to have the federal government send money to try and bail out cities and states. It didn’t work the first time. It certainly wouldn’t work the second time.

Watch it:

Romney may be trying to rhetorically distance himself from his comments, but his policy position remains the same. And it isn’t just bad for America’s schools and public safety departments, it’s bad for the overall economy too. Replacing the lost public sector jobs would reduce unemployment by a full percentage point and make the economic recovery stronger.

Justice

EXCLUSIVE: GOP Election Supervisor Blasts Florida’s Lawsuit Against Feds, Won’t Restart Purge Regardless Of Outcome

Volusia County Supervisor of Elections Ann McFall (R)

Volusia County Supervisor of Elections Ann McFall (R)

Even if Gov. Rick Scott’s (R-FL) administration prevails in its new lawsuit against the Obama administration, his efforts to purge voters before November’s election still faces a major obstacle — the county elections supervisors, including 30 Republicans, who have the ultimate authority over the voting rolls.

Republican Ann McFall, county supervisor of elections for Volusia County, told ThinkProgress that the lawsuit does not have her support and she will not resume purging voters before the elections, regardless of the suit’s outcome:

No I do not support the lawsuit. It is [about] helping the Governor and Secretary of State improve their image. I am not doing any further voter purge until after Nov 2012.

After every one of Flordia’s 67 Democratic, Republican, and Independent county elections supervisors joined together last week to stop Gov. Rick Scott’s (R) error-riddled and likely illegal attempt to remove what his administration said were non-citizen voters from the voter rolls, Scott is pursuing a new tactic in his voter suppression campaign. Yesterday, he announced he will sue the U.S. Department of Homeland Security in an attempt to get more accurate immigration data than the wildly-inaccurate earlier list his administration had originally claimed contained “sure-fire” non-citizens. A DHS representative told the Orlando Sentinel last week that even their list would not provide Florida with an accurate picture of who is and is not a U.S. citizen.

McFall’s fellow Republican Jerry Holland, supervisor of elections for Duval County, told ThinkProgress that he does support the Scott administration’s lawsuit. But even he did not commit to resuming the purge, saying he would do “what ever the law requires and permits.”

Update

Palm Beach Supervisor of Elections Susan Bucher (D) told ThinkProgress that she too opposes the lawsuit and would only begin a purge based on it if the courts rule that doing so would not violate the National Voter Registration Act, the Help America Vote Act, or the Voting Rights Act.

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up