ThinkProgress Logo

Justice

Birther Alan Keyes Slams Herman Cain’s Unconstitutional Assault on Muslims

Former Ambassador and perennial losing candidate Alan Keyes has long been the gold standard for right-wing extremism. Keyes sued President Obama in a birther lawsuit claiming the Obama was born in Kenya. He called the president a “radical communist” and a “usurper.” And he once called embryonic stem cell research the “moral equivalent of Nazi medical experiments on the inmates of death camps during World War II.” Yet, in a column published at the birther website World Net Daily, Keyes slams GOP presidential candidate Herman Cain for saying he would require Muslim federal employees to swear a loyalty oath:

Herman Cain is certainly aware that the First Amendment withholds from the U.S. government the power lawfully to prohibit the free exercise of religion. But has he thought at all about the connection between that provision and the one that says that no religious test shall ever be required as a qualification for “any office or public trust under the United States”? Mr. Cain apparently believes that in today’s world Americans have good reason to distrust any follower of Islam. But the Constitution explicitly prohibits officials of the U.S. government from applying religion as a criterion for public trust, whatever their individual inclinations. This means that whatever his personal predilections, as president of the United States Mr. Cain (and anyone else elected to that office) would be required to set aside his personal views. He could not as a matter of public policy take the position that an office or public trust under the U.S. government (including a seat on the Supreme Court) would be withheld from someone of the Muslim or any other religion until they dispelled to his satisfaction some prejudice (however justified it seems to him, to me or to anyone else) as to their loyalty.

Truer to form, Keyes’s column also makes the alarmist claim that “adherence to Islam is chief among the characteristics of those who pose a threat to U.S.” But his constitutional analysis is uncharacteristically apt. Cain’s proposed assault on Islamic Americans is nothing less than a direct assault on the Constitution.

 

More importantly, the fact that one of America’s leading birthers can’t keep up with Cain’s radicalism is a revealing window into just how far off the deep end the GOP has fallen. Cain skyrocketed from utter obscurity to become one of the leading GOP primary candidates in recent polls. He dominated a focus group of GOP debate watchers, and he enjoys the most intense support of any GOP contender in the race, according to Gallup. And yet Cain’s views are so beyond the pale that Alan Keyes is running away from them.

By clicking and submitting a comment I acknowledge the ThinkProgress Privacy Policy and agree to the ThinkProgress Terms of Use. I understand that my comments are also being governed by Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, or Hotmail’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policies as applicable, which can be found here.

ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up