One in ten federal judgeships are currently vacant, a reality that has crippled many federal courts. As ABA president Bill Robinson recently explained, “[d]elay at the federal courts puts people’s lives on hold while they wait for their cases to be resolved. Businesses face uncertainty and costly holdups, preventing them from investing and creating jobs. In sum, judicial vacancies kill jobs.”
Of course, this problem has an easy solution — confirm the people President Obama nominated to fill these vacant seats. Presently, nineteen nominees have cleared the Senate Judiciary Committee. Twelve of these judges cleared the committee without a single objection, and five more were voted out of the committee with Sen. Mike Lee (R-UT) as the only objector. Lee, of course, recently promised to oppose every single one of Obama’s nominees, and he also believes that national child labor laws, Medicare and Social Security are unconstitutional — so his opinion of a nominee’s qualifications for the bench are not really entitled to any weight.
|
Nominee |
Court |
Committee Vote |
|
Gina Marie Groh |
Northern District of West Virginia |
No Objections |
|
Mary Elizabeth Phillips |
Western District of Missouri |
No Objections |
|
Thomas Owen Rice |
Eastern District of Washington |
No Objections |
|
David Nuffer |
District of Utah |
No Objections |
|
Stephanie Dawn Thacker |
Fourth Circuit |
No Objections |
|
Michael Fitzgerald |
Central District of California |
No Objections |
|
Ronnie Abrams |
Southern District of New York |
No Objections |
|
Rudolph Contreras |
District of Columbia |
No Objections |
|
Miranda Du |
District of Nevada |
10-8 (party line) |
|
Susie Morgan |
Eastern District of Louisiana |
No Objections |
|
Jacqueline H. Nguyen |
Ninth Circuit |
No Objections |
|
Gregg Jeffrey Costa |
Southern District of Texas |
No Objections |
|
David Campos Guaderrama |
Western District of Texas |
No Objections |
|
Brian C. Wimes |
Eastern & Western District of Missouri |
Lee Only Objection |
|
Paul J. Watford |
Ninth Circuit |
10-6 (party line, Graham and Kyl not voting) |
|
Kristine Gerhard Baker |
Eastern District of Arkansas |
Lee Only Objection |
|
John Z. Lee |
Northern District of Illinois |
Lee Only Objection |
|
George Levi Russell |
District of Maryland |
Lee Only Objection |
|
John J. Tharp, Jr |
Northern District of Illinois |
Lee Only Objection |
Yesterday, a wave of Democratic senators spoke out of the Senate floor about the growing vacancy crisis and the need to confirm these pending nominees, so it is clear that some action is coming on these nominees. When it comes — and it should not wait one second longer than it needs to — Senate Republicans will have a choice. They can either serve the American people by confirming a slate of judges that no reasonable person has lodged a single objection to, or they can prove that they care about nothing more than obstructionism by blocking these votes.
|
Cal. Number |
Nominee |
Position |
Reported out |
Committee Vote |
|
408 |
Gina Marie Groh |
ND WV |
10/6/11
|
VV |
|
439 |
Mary Elizabeth Phillips |
WD MO |
10/13/11
|
VV |
|
440 |
Thomas Owen Rice |
ED WA |
10/13/11
|
VV |
|
441 |
David Nuffer* |
D UT |
10/13/11
|
VV |
|
460 |
Stephanie Dawn Thacker |
4th Cir (WV) |
11/3/11
|
VV |
|
461 |
Michael Fitzgerald* |
CD CA |
11/3/11
|
VV |
|
462 |
Ronnie Abrams |
SD NY |
11/3/11
|
VV |
|
463 |
Rudolph Contreras |
D DC |
11/3/11
|
VV |
|
464 |
Miranda Du* |
D NV |
11/3/11
|
10-8 (party line) |
|
497 |
Susie Morgan |
ED LA |
11/10/11
|
VV |
|
508 |
Jacqueline H. Nguyen* |
9th Cir (CA) |
12/1/11
|
VV |
|
509 |
Gregg Jeffrey Costa* |
SD TX |
12/1/11
|
VV |
|
510 |
David Campos Guaderrama* |
WD TX |
12/1/11
|
VV |
|
528 |
Brian C. Wimes |
ED/WD MO |
12/15/11
|
VV (Lee objection noted) |
|
552 |
Paul J. Watford* |
9th Cir (CA) |
2/2/12 |
10-6 (party line, Graham and Kyl not voting) |
|
568 |
Kristine Gerhard Baker |
ED AR |
2/16/12
|
VV (Lee objection noted) |
|
569 |
John Z. Lee* |
ND IL |
2/16/12
|
VV (Lee objection noted) |
|
570 |
George Levi Russell* |
D MD |
2/16/12
|
VV (Lee objection noted) |
|
571 |
John J. Tharp, Jr* |
ND IL |
2/16/12
|
VV (Lee objection noted) |

Previous in TP Justice


By clicking and submitting a comment I acknowledge the ThinkProgress Privacy Policy and agree to the ThinkProgress Terms of Use. I understand that my comments are also being governed by Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, or Hotmail’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policies as applicable, which can be found here.