ThinkProgress Logo

Justice

Economy

Study: Income Inequality Is Tied To Increase In Homicides

In the wake of the tragic shooting at a movie theater in Aurora, CO earlier this month, the nation has been engaged in a dialogue about the best ways to prevent violent crime — including passing stricter gun control legislation, requiring more background checks for firearm purchases, and increasing mental illness reporting. However, one writer at Scientific American suggests that homicides in the U.S. actually stem from a very different kind of source: the nation’s high rates of income inequality.

Eric Michael Johnson cites a study conducted by Harvard’s Ichiro Kawachi that analyzed the homicide rates in each state and the District of Columbia. Kawachi found that as the gap between the rich and the poor rose, the rate of homicide rose along with it:

The results were unambiguous: when income inequality was higher, so was the rate of homicide. Income inequality alone explained 74% of the variance in murder rates and half of the aggravated assaults. However, social capital had an even stronger association and, by itself, accounted for 82% of homicides and 61% of assaults. Other factors such as unemployment, poverty, or number of high school graduates were only weakly associated and alcohol consumption had no connection to violent crime at all. A World Bank sponsored study subsequently confirmed these results on income inequality concluding that, worldwide, homicide and the unequal distribution of resources are inextricably tied.

Income inequality in the U.S. has been rapidly rising since 1979. And an uptick in violent crimes certainly isn’t the only documented negative effect of the widening gulf between the rich and the poor. Studies have already shown that economic disparity has caused a problematic education gap, put an outsized burden on the Social Security program, and stifled the political power of a downtrodden middle class.

NEWS FLASH

Appeals Court Temporarily Blocks Arizona 20-Week Abortion Ban | Just one day before it would go into effect, Arizona’s 20-week abortion ban has been temporarily blocked by a 9th Circuit Court of Appeals panel. A trial judge upheld HB 2036 on Monday. The appellate court will hold a hearing on the ban as soon as possible this fall. Called the most extreme ban in the nation, the law measures the gestational age of a fetus from the first day of the woman’s last period, technically prohibiting abortions after 18 weeks of pregnancy. It would have forced doctors to withhold care until a pregnancy posed an immediate threat of death or major medical damage. It also contains no exceptions for fatal fetal birth defects, giving women no choice but to carry to term a fetus with no chance of survival.

NEWS FLASH

New Legislation Would Restrict Domestic Drones | Representative Ed Markey (D-MA) has drafted a bill aimed at ensuring transparency in the use of unmanned aircraft for surveillance inside the United States by requiring FAA oversight and disclosure of how drone operators planned to use the machines. Currently, 106 different government entities are cleared to fly drones at home, and similar use by private organizations is becoming increasingly plausible. Markey worries that there are “no privacy protections or transparency measures in place” that can adequately head off the abuse of this technology.

Meet Mitt Romney’s Immigration Advisers

Of all the GOP candidates, Mitt Romney staked out the most extreme immigration positions during the Republican primary. He said his immigration plan would be to make undocumented immigrants “self-deport,” and he vowed to veto the DREAM Act. Since he effectively locked up the nomination, however, Romney tried to distance himself from his earlier hardline stances, and a Republican Party official even tried to claim that Romney is “still deciding what his position on immigration is.”

But Romney is still losing among Latino voters by an enormous (and widening) margin. While Romney has tried to moderate his immigration views from the primary to the general election, his immigration advisers and supporters still include extremely anti-immigrant officials.

KRIS KOBACH

Currently serving as Kansas’ secretary of state, Kobach is the author of harmful state and local anti-immigrant ordinances like those in Arizona, Alabama, and South Carolina. He wrote the vast majority of them as senior counselor to the restrictionist Immigration Reform Law Institute and as a private consultant. He has insisted that Romney wants SB 1070 as a national model, and he doesn’t expect Romney to soften the extreme immigration positions he took during the GOP primary. And following President Obama’s directive to halt deportations for up to 1.4 million young undocumented immigrants, Kobach called the policy “illegal.” Kobach advised Romney’s 2008 campaign on immigration and homeland security, and he returned to that role for the 2012 election after he endorsed the GOP presidential candidate in January. In April, Romney tried to distance himself from Kobach while softening his immigration positions, saying he was a “supporter,” not an “adviser” before conceding that Kobach was still an “informal adviser.”

PETE WILSON

After the former Republican California governor endorsed Romney, the presidential candidate named Wilson honorary California chair of his campaign. In a statement touting the endorsement, Romney said, “I’m honored to have Governor Pete Wilson’s support, because he’s one of California’s most accomplished leaders.” As governor of California, Wilson prominently supported Proposition 187, an anti-immigrant ballot initiative that made unauthorized immigrants ineligible for public services such as health care or public education. California voters approved the measure in 1994, a precursor to Arizona’s SB 1070, before courts declared it unconstitutional in 1997.

RUSSELL PEARCE

The former Arizona Senate president, who was ousted in a recall election, was the architect of Arizona’s infamous SB 1070. He threw his support behind Romney and said that the GOP presidential candidate’s “immigration policy is identical to mine.” And Pearce said Romney “absolutely” called for Arizona’s law to be used as a national “model” because Romney has advocated for self-deportation. “[Self-deportation] is in SB 1070,” Pearce said in April.

JAN BREWER

Citing only Romney’s “pro-business background” and his “political history,” Arizona’s nativist Republican governor endorsed Romney ahead of her state’s primary in February. Brewer is one of the nation’s most anti-immigrant governors, and she signed SB 1070, the first of a wave of anti-immigrant bills authored by Kobach.

RAY WALSER

After President Obama announced the directive to halt deportations for DREAM Act-eligible young adults, Romney refused to say whether or not he would undo the policy. But Walser, a co-chair of Romney’s campaign for issues pertaining to Latin America, said he thought Romney would get rid of it. “My anticipation is that he would probably rescind this directive were he to be elected in November,” he told The Daily Telegraph. He added that the decision would match up with the “very tough” positions Romney had taken on immigration. Walser is a senior policy adviser at the Heritage Foundation who spent 27 years working for the U.S. State Department.

LAMAR SMITH

The Texas Republican, who chairs the House Judiciary Committee, became one of Romney’s earliest congressional endorsers in October 2011, choosing to back the former Massachusetts governor over Texas Gov. Rick Perry. Smith has pledged to not hold a hearing on the DREAM Act in his hearing, which Romney vowed to veto.

How Did 21-Year-Old Chavis Carter Get Shot In The Head While Handcuffed In A Police Car?

21-year-old Chavis Carter, courtesy of Facebook.

Police in Jonesboro, Arkansas have launched an investigation into how 21-year-old Chavis Carter was shot in the back of a patrol car Saturday night.

Carter, who died at the hospital, was in the passenger seat of a pickup truck that was pulled over by police just before 10 pm, reports WREG. According to Officer Keith Baggett who was on the scene, Officer Ron Marsh found “some marijuana” and several new plastic baggies when he searched Carter. When they ran his information through dispatch, they found that he was wanted on a warrant in Mississippi, where he lived. The cops then handcuffed him, searched him again, and put him in the back of the patrol car. While Baggett searched the vehicle, he claims he heard “a loud thump with a metallic sound” on his trunk and saw Marsh motion to him.

The thumping noise, according to the cops, was Carter shooting himself in the head.

The police report attributed the death to a self-inflicted gunshot, though when the two officers opened the squad car door, they found Carter’s hands were still cuffed behind his back. The gun, they said, was somehow missed in both searches.

“Any given officer has missed something on a search, be it drugs, knife, razor blades, this instance it happened to be a gun,” Jonesboro Police Sergeant Lyle Waterworth said after the bizarre incident. The police believe that Chavez managed to pull out a hidden gun and shot himself in spite of the handcuffs.

Carter’s mother, Teresa, however, suspects foul play: “I think they killed him, my son wasn’t suicidal.”

According to Teresa, Carter called his girlfriend while he was pulled over to tell her he’d call her from jail. She also said her son was shot in his right temple, when he was left-handed.

The two officers involved are now on administrative leave until the investigation concludes.

Watch it, courtesy of WREG:

NEWS FLASH

House Ethics Committee Fines Rep. Laura Richardson For Violating Federal Law, House Rules | The House Committee on Ethics unanimously reprimanded Rep. Laura Richardson (D-CA) for “improperly using House resources for campaign, personal, and nonofficial purposes,” “requiring or compelling her official staff to perform campaign work,” and “obstructing the investigation of the Committee.” Richardson agreed to pay a $10,000 fine for these violations of both federal law and the House Code of Official Conduct.

Karl Rove Group May Take Advantage Of FEC Typo To Avoid Donor Disclosure

Crossroads GPS ad on websiteLast week, the Federal Election Commission announced retroactively that effective March 30, 2002 all outside groups running “electioneering communications” — independent ads run within 30 days of federal primaries or nominating conventions or within 60 days of federal general elections that mention candidates but do not expressly advocate for or against them — must identify all donors contributing over $1,000 bankrolling their efforts. But Karl Rove’s Crossroads GPS is taking advantage of a mistake on the FEC’s website to avoid disclosure of its donors.

The Los Angeles Times reported today that the secret-money 501(c)(4) group will be running $25 million worth of attack ads against President Obama through August 6, but still does not plan to identify who is bankrolling its ads:

According to the FEC, the electioneering communications window before the Democratic National Convention begins According to the FEC, the electioneering communications window before the Democratic National Convention begins Aug. 4. However, the commission has offered confusing guidance on the topic: Last week, its website identified the start the period as Aug. 7, which the FEC then said was a mistake, noting the correct date was Aug. 4.

“The commission regrets the error,” the FEC said in a statement posted on its website Friday. “The commission will exercise its prosecutorial discretion and will not take enforcement action with respect to communications disbursements made in reasonable reliance on the erroneous information on the website in connection with EC reporting.”

Crossroads GPS spokesman Jonathan Collegio told the paper that the group has no plans to disclose donors as it does not plan to “air ads that will trigger reporting in the [electioneering communications] window.” It is hard to imagine that Rove — who regularly appears on Fox News Channel as a political analyst — and the other operatives at Crossroads GPS were really unaware of when the Democratic National Convention begins.

Still, while the FEC might be willing to let Crossroads GPS avoid disclosure, they might want to consider pulling their August 4 through 7 advertisements. Rep. Chris Van Hollen (D-MD) says he may file a lawsuit to force the group to comply, noting “I think they would have a really difficult time claiming that because of a technical FEC error, they get to violate the law.”

Update

Campaign finance reform advocate Fred Wertheimer called on the U.S. Department of Justice to investigate any non-disclosed electioneering communications in this period as “knowing and willful” violations of campaign finance law.

NEWS FLASH

Illinois Governor Proposes Assault Weapons Ban | Coming on the heels of the gun control debate sparked by the Aurora theater shooting, Gov. Pat Quinn (D-IL) has proposed an assaults weapon ban that is already sparking resistance from the gun lobby. Quinn’s plan prohibits the manufacture, delivery, sale, purchase, or possession of semiautomatic assault weapons and high-capacity ammunition magazines. People who already possess these items could keep them, but would need to register their guns with the police. Chicago, in particular, has suffered from rampant gun violence; the city’s homicide rate has spiked 38 percent in the last year. Illinois is the only state in the country without a concealed carry law, but other gun control measures have failed in the General Assembly or faced legal challenges.

Federal Court Will Review Marijuana’s Classification As A Dangerous Drug With No Health Benefits

For the first time since 1994, the question of medical marijuana will go before a federal court. The United States Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit has agreed to hear a lawsuit challenging the DEA’s classification of marijuana as a dangerous drug with no medical value. The ten-year-old suit, brought by Americans for Safe Access, will present scientific evidence on marijuana’s therapeutic properties.

The appeal brief calls the DEA’s refusal to analyze numerous studies on the drug’s medical uses “arbitrary and capricious,” and asks the court to order the DEA to conduct a hearing on the scientific evidence.

Marijuana is currently classified as a Schedule 1 substance with “high potential for abuse,” in the same legal classification as heroin and morphine. In spite of numerous petitions to reschedule the drug, the federal government has maintained that marijuana has no medical value and launched costly and aggressive eradication efforts. Just a few weeks ago, the Justice Department sued to close the largest medical marijuana dispensary in the country, even as Congress, in a rare bipartisan move, prepared a bill to protect medical marijuana possession.

But the conditions for the ASA’s case — in which oral arguments will be presented on the morning of October 16 — are optimal. Since the original petition was filed in 2002, studies have piled up evidence of marijuana’s benefits in the treatment of illnesses including multiple sclerosis, Alzheimer’s and cancer. In 2011, the National Cancer Institute listed cannabis as a complementary and alternative medicine, noting that it has been used as medicine for thousands of years. And, of course, 17 states and the District of Columbia (with Massachusetts poised to join the list) have laws on the books recognizing marijuana’s medicinal properties and enabling safe providers to open shop.

Rescheduling marijuana would help ease the tensions between these state laws and federal crackdowns. It would also remove the roadblocks that have prevented more extensive research into the drug’s properties, which, according to the American College of Physicians, is much needed.

U.S. Department Of Justice Says Florida Voter Purge Violates Federal Law

Gov. Rick Scott (R)

Gov. Rick Scott (R)

As Gov. Rick Scott (R-FL) continues his Ahab-like quest to purge voters from his state’s voter roles, the U.S. Department of Justice is again accusing Scott’s administration of illegal voter suppression.

The Miami Herald reports that a federal district court filing by the DOJ claims Scott’s purge required its prior permission — and did not have it:

The July 27 filing, known as a statement of interest, asserts that before Florida began scrubbing the rolls in search of non-citizens, it was required to submit the proposal to the federal government. Under Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act of 1965, five “covered” Florida counties are subject to a process known as pre-clearance: Hillsborough, Collier, Hardee, Hendry and Monroe.

The feds say Florida never submitted the new “citizenship list maintenance practices” to them for approval, even though they did submit an unrelated change for review in 2011 — the use of Social Security numbers to verify that a voter had died.

In late June different federal judge refused to grant a DOJ request for a restraining order to halt the purge on the grounds that it violate the National Voter Registration Act — even though the purge clearly violates the National Voter Registration Act, which prohibits voter roll purges within 90 days of federal elections. That case remains ongoing.

The reason Congress enacted these laws — especially the Voting Rights Act rules governing areas with a history of voter suppression — was precisely to prevent what Scott is trying to do. His purge attempts disproportionately affect minority voters and are so error-riddled that dozens of Republican county elections supervisors have refused to continue them.

Texas Republicans Pick Ten Commandments Judge For State Supreme Court

Texas Supreme Court nominee John Devine (R)

Texas Supreme Court nominee John Devine (R)

In a nasty race with allegations of racism, former District Judge John Devine beat incumbent Texas Supreme Court Justice David Medina yesterday, by a 53 to 47 margin. With no Democratic candidate on the ballot this November, Devine is a shoe-in for the state’s high court.

Two Houston lawyers made news in recent days with allegations that Devine had made racist comments to them about the incumbent Medina’s background. The Dallas Morning News reported this week:

The race became steeped in controversy after two Houston lawyers contended Devine told them he was targeting Medina because “I can beat a guy with a Mexican last name.” Devine denies he said that or ran against Medina for that reason, noting that his wife is from Colombia. Instead, he contends, attorneys Scott Link and Frank Harmon were trying to push him out of the race.

Harmon and Link say that’s false. “He made horrible statements, and I understand he wants to run away from them,” said Link, a former friend of Devine’s. “We were like witnesses to a horrible accident.”

Devine is best known for having refused to remove a painting of the Ten Commandments in his courtroom and a “Bible monument” outside his courthouse — moves that earned him the endorsements of several Christian Right and Tea Party leaders. He proudly notes that he was named “Texas Size Hero” by Focus on the Family magazine.

While Medina, an appointee by Gov. Rick Perry (R), was also a strong conservative, Devine ran to his right. His overt political positions — listed on his campaign website as “The Devine 9” — on abortion, guns, and “states right’s” are a reminder of the danger of putting the judiciary up to a popular vote. Rather than running on judicial temperament or independence, Devine campaigned largely on the fact that he will not be a neutral arbiter when what he identifies as the “top nine issues currently affecting Texans” come before the Texas Supreme Court.

  • Comment Icon

Justiceline: August 1, 2012

Club for Growth Action ad for Senate candidate Ted Cruz (R-TX)

Club for Growth Action ad for Senate candidate Ted Cruz (R-TX)

Welcome to Justiceline, ThinkProgress Justice’s morning round-up of the latest legal news and developments. Remember to follow us on Twitter at @TPJustice

  • Former state Solicitor General Ted Cruz’s 57-43 win over Lt. Governor David Dewhurst in yesterday’s Texas Republican Senate primary runoff was heavily fueled by outside spending. Club for Growth Action alone spent more than $5.6 million on his behalf.
  • A U.S. House of Representatives race in Iowa between Rep. Steve King (R) and Christine Vilsack (D) could test the limits on outside groups republishing campaign’s materials and on using official town hall meetings as campaign events.
  • Following a preliminary hearing in which former clerks alleged serious ethical violations, a Pennsylvania judge ordered suspended state Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin (R) to stand trial on seven of the nine criminal counts recommended by a grand jury.
  • Virginia’s law prohibiting non-residents from circulating ballot petitions was struck down by a U.S. District Court judge.
  • Another federal judge is considering a challenge to the way Ohio handles provisional ballots cast in the wrong precinct.
  • And finally, New York City sold 28,000 pounds of spent police department shell casings — to a Georgia ammunition store that reloads and resells them.
  • Comment Icon

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up