ThinkProgress Logo

LGBT

Alyssa

Reality TV and Risk Calculus

No matter how silly you think the Real Housewives franchise is, this is incredibly sad: Russell Armstrong, the soon-to-be-ex-husband of one of the Beverly Hills housewives, has apparently committed suicide. The Beverly Hills installment of the show was notable for both its financial excesses and its rawness: Taylor Armstrong spent $60,000 on a birthday party for her daughter with Russell, while two of the sisters on the show fought bitterly about one of their struggles with alcoholism. The Armstrongs’ were the unlucky couple who, according to the format of the show, saw their marriage dissolve during filming. Taylor accused Russell of spousal abuse in her petition for divorce.

Being reality-television famous can be modestly lucrative, but even if you think you might end up a mini-mogul like Bethenny Frankel, the price you can pay seem awfully high. The contract you have to sign if you’re going to appear on The Real World says you have to absolve MTV of responsibility if you’re raped or sexually assaulted. If your wife decides she wants to humiliate you on national television for the sake of juicing her nascent Q score, you can’t really prevent her from doing it once you’ve stepped over the line and agreed to be on the show. The incentives here are for perpetual disaster: there’s no reward for self-protection here. People have the right to do whatever they like with their lives, of course, but we’re an awfully risk-averse country except when it comes to fame. Then, we’re willing to stake everything in pursuit of it.

NEWS FLASH

Repeal Brings No Recompense For Those Discharged Under DADT | Though the repeal of the discriminatory Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell law is to be celebrated, it doesn’t bring much promise for the nearly 14,000 who were discharged under its enforcement. The military is cutting its numbers, which means it’s actually quite competitive for those who may wish to re-enlist. And as the Huffington Post noted on Saturday, there is “no restitution, no reparations, no special personnel process to help those get back in the military who were thrown out.”

Justice

Santorum: ‘Our Freedom’ Is Less ‘Whole Than It Was At The Time Of Our Founders’

At a campaign stop in Iowa this weekend, former Sen. Rick Santorum (R-PA) doled out a frothy mixture of revisionist history about what it was like to be alive in the late 1700s:

Our founders said [our] rights were given to us to pursue life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. Does anyone here believe that first inalienable right is as whole as it was at the time of our founding? It isn’t. Does anyone believe that our freedom is as whole as it was at the time of our founders? It is not.

Watch it:

Santorum’s understanding of the word “freedom” leaves a whole lot of Americans out of the picture. There’s a reason, for example, why the authors of our Constitution are sometimes referred to as the “Founding Fathers” — none of them were women. Indeed, women did not actually gain the guaranteed right to vote until the 19th Amendment was ratified in 1920, more than a century after Santorum’s utopia era of “freedom.”

Another person who probably disagrees with Santorum’s definition of the word “freedom” — this guy: Read more

Gingrich Suggests Same-Sex Marriage Is Responsible For Economic Woes

Newt Gingrich seemed to blame same-sex marriage for the country’s economic woes, during an interview with Catholic Radio of San Diego last week. Responding to a question about the connection between the “secular” attack on “the family” and economic stagnation, Gingrich argued that “freedom of faith” – which he argued is being undermined by the push for marriage equality — is directly related to “free enterprise”:

HOST: We’re becoming increasingly secular, the family is under attack and economically we’re experiencing woes like we’ve never known in our history it seems. So what is the connection here?…

GINGRICH: You have to recognize that free enterprise is based on free people and … free people are based on faith. The very basis of our belief and freedom is that we believe we are endowed by our creator with certain unalienable rights. The very source of our strength is that we believe these are truths – not theories, not ideologies, not gimmicks, not political consultants, powerpoints – truths, and so there’s a core absolute overlap between free enterprise, freedom and freedom of faith. And if you don’t have freedom of faith in the end you’re not going to have free enterprise because there’s no moral force that defends and protects you.

Listen:

Virginia Del. Bob Marshall Conflates ‘Sexual Orientation’ With ‘Paraphilia’ For Maryland

Del. Bob Marshall (R-VA)

Virginia Delegate Bob Marshall has been publicly condemned by his colleagues for his virulently anti-gay remarks, but he is undeterred. In fact, he wants other states to have to deal with his hateful rhetoric as well. In a letter in yesterday’s Baltimore Sun, Marshall attacked Maryland Gov. Martin O’Malley for supporting marriage equality and pulled no punches in attacking homosexuality, all in the name of Catholicism:

As a Catholic legislator, I disagree with Governor O’Malley. Sexual orientation is not limited to same- or complementary-sex attractions but includes attractions to children, prostitutes, multiple wives (polygamy) dead persons (necrophilia), animals, inanimate objects, and others that could not be printed in the Baltimore Sun out of deference to readers.

Of course, Marshall’s definition of sexual orientation is Marshall’s alone. Sexual orientation refers to what sex (or sexes) one is oriented toward — hence, sexual orientation. Most of the -philias in his list (children, corpses, animals, and the unprintable “Voldemorts”) are all paraphilias or psychiatric disorders, and homosexuality has not been classified as either since 1973. If Marshall wants to make a case against different sexual practices like prostitution and polygamy, he’ll have to give up his “6,000 years of Western religious and moral teachings.” Polygamy (which he highlights in his diatribe), in particular, features prominently throughout the religious teachings he cites. Not that it matters — none of this has anything to do with sexual orientation or marriage equality.

Marshall, unsurprisingly, offers no substantiation for any of his fear-mongering, including his claim that “the family…will be negatively impacted.” (He must, like Michele Bachmann, believe same-sex families aren’t already “families.”) His case is built around his desire to maintain the stigmatization and demonization of same-sex couples as a societal norm. He may not like it, but the Catholic Church does not have any official authority over Maryland’s state government. And fortunately, neither does Marshall.

NEWS FLASH

Time Warner Cable Provided $70,846 Of Free Air Time To NY Same-Sex Marriage Ads | “Time Warner Cable gave advocates of same-sex marriage $70,846 of free airtime this spring,” the Times Union reports. Time Warner aired the celebrity-studded “New Yorkers for Marriage Equality” series as a public service announcement. But as the legislature drew closer to a vote, the cable company reviewed the ads and realized Human Rights Campaign declared the ads as “lobbying.”

NEWS FLASH

Bachmann Is A Talking Point Machine | As this video compilation from CNN demonstrates, Michele Bachmann relied on the same talking points in all of her Sunday show appearances: tip of the spear, America a punch to the gut, I’m a federal tax litigation attorney, and so on and so on:

NEWS FLASH

Homophobia Rampant Among Israel Defense Forces | A new survey from the Israeli Gay Youth movement finds that gay, lesbian, and bisexual soldiers face significant stigma and harassment within the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) that is often ignored by commanders:

- 40 percent of soldiers were verbally abused due to their sexual orientation.

- 20 percent claimed to have been physically or sexually assaulted due to their sexual orientation.

- 49 percent of soldiers who hear homophobic comments in military bases ignore them and do not respond.

- 37 percent participate and join in making fun of the gay soldier.

- Only 13 percent reprimand soldiers who are making fun of a gay soldier.

Why Bachmann Won’t Be Able To Reinstate Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell

The New York Times’ James Dao reports that Michele Bachmann could easily reinstate Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell if she were elected president and made good on her promise to bring back the soon-to-be repealed policy:

Turns out that it wouldn’t be hard to do, legal experts say.

That’s because the law repealing the ban that President Obama signed last December did not expressly order the Pentagon to allow openly gay or lesbian troops in the armed forces. Congress merely laid out a process under which the ban could be lifted. Under that process, the president, secretary of defense and chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff had to certify that repeal would not undermine recruiting, retention, morale and other indicators of what is commonly called military readiness.

Once that certification was made and sent to Congress, the secretary of defense then had to prepare and issue new regulations allowing gays and lesbians to serve openly. That is where the process is now: the regulations are being written and the ban will be lifted on Sept. 20.

But because Congress did not require the military to allow open service, a new president could order his or her new secretary of defense to issue new regulations that effectively reinstate the ban, said Aubrey Sarvis, executive director of the Servicemembers Legal Defense Network, which advocates for gay and lesbian troops.

But I would argue that there is some difference between having the authority to keep gay people out of the military and actually having the political capital to do so — particularly for a female president without military experience. To bring back the ban on open service, Bachmann would have to go head to head with the four service chiefs — all of whom authorized the repeal — and somehow convince the armed forces that it’s even operationally possible to push service members back into the closet. Would soldiers have to be trained to forget that some of their colleagues are gay? I mean, how would this even work? And even if she does manage to repeal the repeal, the order would be immediately challenged in court, with proponents relying on the Pentagon’s own study showing that servicemembers don’t mind serving alongside gay soldiers and the real world experience in which the services experienced few problems after the ban was lifted.

And so at the end of the day — regardless of what Bachmann is now saying on the campaign trail — once that toothpaste is out of the tube, Bachmann or any other Republican isn’t going to be able to shove it back in.

The Morning Pride: August 16, 2011

Welcome to The Morning Pride, ThinkProgress LGBT’s 8:45 AM round-up of the latest in LGBT policy, politics, and some culture too! Here’s what we’re reading this morning, but let us know what you’re checking out too.

- Remember how unworthwhile and unpopular we suggested civil unions would be in Rhode Island? In July, the first full month they were legal, only nine same-sex couples bothered to enter one.

- According to a new report from the Ballot Initiative Strategy Center, a majority of states which allow ballot initiatives receive a failing grade on fairness and transparency.

Metro Weekly highlights SCOTUSblog’s online symposium on same-sex marriage and the high court.

- The Washington Post editorial board condemned the recent decision that Anthony John Makk could no longer stay in the country to take care of his partner of 19 years because the Defense of Marriage Act does not recognize their relationship.

- The GOP race’s newest entrant, Texas Gov. Rick Perry, announced he will help fundraise for Cornerstone Action, New Hampshire’s affiliate of the Family Research Council, an anti-gay hate group.

- Anoka-Hennepin School District continues to spend tax-payer dollars defending its dangerous “neutrality” policyon sexual orientation.

- New details have come out in the case of Rutgers student Dharun Ravi, who spied on his roommate Tyler Clementi being intimate with a same-sex partner, which many believe led Clementi to commit suicide.

- A transgender woman has settled her suit with the San Francisco Department of Motor Vehicles for $50,000. When she had gone there to record her sex change, she received a letter saying homosexual acts were “an abomination that leads to hell.”

- A city in Brazil has imposed a fine for anything “distributing materials designed to induce children to become homosexuals.”

- A gay Malaysian pastor plans to marry his American partner in New York then throw a huge wedding banquet in his home country, despite criticism from government politicians.

- Over the weekend, homophobia continued to escalate in Ghana as Christians from various denominations held a large anti-gay protest, featuring signs like “Speak against Gayism,” “Avoid Gayism,” and “Don’t do it, it is wrong.”

  • Comment Icon

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up