ThinkProgress Logo

LGBT

Special Topic

VIDEO: Bishop Gene Robinson Explains Why Religious People Should Support The 99 Percent Movement

Over the last few weeks, a number of clergy, religious activists, and writers — both Christian and Jewish — have spoken out in support of the Wall Street protests. This highlights one aspect of the 99 Percent Movement that has yet to be acknowledged by the mainstream media’s narrative: the growing support the protests are receiving from various faith groups and leaders around the country.

On Monday, Gene Robinson, the ninth bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of New Hampshire and a senior fellow at the Center for American Progress, stopped by the ThinkProgress office to discuss his understanding and support of the 99 Percent Movement, the moral and religious implications of the enormous economic inequality driving the movement, and why he believes the protests fit squarely within the moral critiques of wealth and power put forward in the Hebrew Old Testament and the Christian New Testament:

One-sixth of all the words Jesus spoke, and one-third of all the parables, are about the dangers of wealth and possessions. It is something that we hear from the prophets — particularly of the Old Testament, and of course that’s what Jesus was steeped in, those were his scriptures — that any culture, but certainly one that claims to be Godly, is to be judged on how well the most vulnerable are treated.

It’s more than about numbers, and it’s more than about disparity of income. It’s really about our sense of community. And indeed, do the wealthy have a responsibility to the larger community? Are we really going to live in an “every man, woman and child for themselves” world, or are we going to be a community in which the greater good, the common good, is also a value that we hold?

ThinkProgress has compiled the highlights from Bishop Robinson’s Monday interview. Watch it:

Other examples of religious support for the 99 Percent Movement include Trinity Wall Street and other churches in the Lower Manhattan area opening their doors to provide the protesters a place to rest, clergy in the Bay Area bringing a golden calf –symbolic of Wall Street greed — on a march through the financial district of San Francisco, the canon chancellor of St. Paul’s Cathedral resigning in protest over plans to evict protestors in London, the Archbishop of Canterbury calling for a financial transactions tax, and even the Vatican calling for an overhaul of global financial regulation and a return to more equitable economic relations.

NEWS FLASH

FRC Prays For Gays To No Longer ‘Possess Our Nation’s Children’ | In its latest prayer targets, the Family Research Council responds to Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand’s (D-NY) bill to end discrimination against same-sex parents by calling on God to prohibit the “radical homosexual agenda” from “possessing” children: “May God intervene and stir Americans to resist and stop this effort to advance the radical homosexual agenda and literally to possess our nation’s children. May God open our eyes!” (HT: Joe.My.God.)

Akin Would Compromise Defense Budget To Discriminate Against Same-Sex Couples

Rep. Todd Akin (R-MO) continues his quest to impose discrimination upon same-sex couples in the military through the Defense Authorization Act. He and 85 of his House colleagues have called upon the Senate to maintain the amendments he and Rep. Vicky Hartzler (R-MO) added, which extend the Defense of Marriage Act to prohibit same-sex marriages from being performed by military chaplains or on military bases:

We recognize that the national Defense Authorization Act is well underway and needed funds for our troops should be expedited without delay. However, we respectfully request that an amendment similar to that passed by the House be included to ensure that this administration follow the law as written and comply with DOMA. It is not the place of any citizen of this country to pick and choose which laws will be obeyed. We expect citizens sworn to defend those laws to set the example in their application.

Akin’s request is an overreach that directly targets servicemembers’ religious liberty. The Defense of Marriage Act defines what is recognized by the government as marriage, but in no way prohibits same-sex marriages from being performed.

Politics

Jewish Group Demands That Boehner And GOP Candidate Return Campaign Donations From Ohio Nazi Reenactor

GOP donor Rich Iott on left

Last year, Ohio millionaire Rich Iott marked the demise of his campaign against Rep. Marcy Kaptur (D-OH) with the revelation that “he likes to pretend he’s a Nazi,” defending his Nazi reenactments by stating he was “fascinated” with “a relatively small country that from a strictly military point of view accomplished incredible things.” Of course, most Republicans — let alone Ohioans — found this repulsive. The Republican Jewish Coalition “strongly commended Republican Party leaders for moving swiftly to sever ties to Ohio congressional candidate Rich Iott.”

However, it seems House Speaker John Boehner (R-OH) didn’t completely cut those strings. After the controversy broke, Boehner stood up next to Iott at a Republican Get Out The Vote rally last year. Then, this February, Iott donated to $2,400 to Boehner’s campaign. Iott also contributed $1,000 to the campaign to Ohio Treasurer Josh Mandel’s (R) Senate campaign. The National Jewish Democratic Council (NJDC) called on Boehner and Mandel, who is Jewish, to return the contributions:

“The time is long overdue for Mandel to return the money, or better yet, donate it to a Holocaust memorial. If Mandel continues to keep Iott’s money then he, like House Speaker John Boehner — who stumped for Iott and received a contribution from him recently as well — will continue to give Iott a pass for his disturbing involvement in Nazi reenactments. Failure on this basic test of political courage cannot be an option for any elected official.

The NJDC said they purposefully waited months before calling out Mandel to give him a chance to “act responsibly.” House Majority Leader Eric Cantor (R-VA), who is also Jewish, rebuked Iott’s behavior last year. He and Boehner — and apparently Mandel — “parted ways” when it came to dealing with the Nazi reenacter, Politico reported at the time.

NEWS FLASH

$37,082.85: Amount Spent By National Anti-Gay Group To Turn Local Iowa Election Into Marriage Referendum | The National Organization for Marriage continues to meddle in the Iowa special state Senate race between Democrat Liz Mathis and Republican Cindy Golding. NOM has now spent over $37,000 supporting Golding in hopes of eliminating the Democratic majority in the Iowa Senate to allow for a rollback of marriage equality — even though Golding has repeatedly said the race should focus on local issues like jobs and economic development. Using an alliance with Iowa’s FAMiLY LEADER to compensate for its lack of on-the-ground presence, NOM is injecting an incredible amount of national money into a local race with absolutely no accountability for where the money is coming from.

Growing Number Of Maine Independents Support Same-Sex Marriage

A new poll from Public Policy Polling (PPP) finds that support for marriage equality is increasing among independents in Maine, just two years after the state “narrowly voted to overturn a law allowing same sex couples to marry.” Fifty-one percent of voters say they support marriage equality, including 53 percent of independents:

Maine is a great example of the reality that public opinion is moving on the topic of gay marriage. 2 years ago voters in the state narrowly voted to overturn a law allowing same sex couples to marry. But now 51% of voters in the state say they think gay marriage should be legal to only 42% who continue to believe it should be illegal. Opinions among Democrats and Republicans haven’t changed a whole lot over the last 2 years, but independents have gone from opposing gay marriage by a 52/46 margin to supporting it by a 53/39 spread.

We also tested proposed language for a ballot measure next year that would allow gay marriage while also making it clear that no religious institution would be required to perform those marriages if it didn’t want to. Right now voters say they would pass that by a 48/35 margin.

Look:

 

In 2009, the referendum to overturn marriage equality passed by a vote of 53 percent to 47 percent.

NEWS FLASH

Romney Endorsed Marriage Equality Advocate In 2003 Ad | Before adopting his current anti-gay stance Mitt Romney had a mixed record on gay rights. During his failed 1994 campaign for the Senate Romney, he told the Log Cabin Republicans, “We must make equality for gays and lesbians a mainstream concern,” promised to co-sponsor a federal Employment Non-Discrimination Act, and claimed he would do more for the gay community than the late Sen. Ted Kennedy. In 2003, Romney even cut a campaign ad for then-Salt Lake City mayor Rocky Anderson, who had supported full marriage equality since 1996. Watch Romney endorse Anderson:

Karl Singer

Coalition Claims Education Bill Is Insufficient, Leaves LGBT Students Out

When the Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions (HELP) Committee marked up the Elementary and Secondary Education Reauthorization Act (ESEA) of 2011 last month, two anti-bullying provisions were noticeably absent. This week, a coalition of LGBT groups and allies is calling upon the committee to do better, arguing in a letter that the bill should not advance without protections for LGBT students:

Discrimination and harassment of LGBT students, and those perceived to be LGBT, is a serious problem in public elementary and secondary school districts across the United States.  Despite this fact, the ESEA Reauthorization Act of 2011 fails to include any express protections for this vulnerable student population, or even to make reference to them.  While we recognize and appreciate the leadership of some members, including Senators Casey and Franken, who have been tireless in their advocacy on behalf of all students, including those who are LGBT, this reauthorization fails to ensure that LGBT students have access to a public education unhindered by discrimination and harassment.

Sen. Franken (D-MN) has said he plans to introduce the Student Non-Discrimination Act (SNDA) as an amendment when ESEA is brought to the Senate floor. It is unknown if Sen. Casey intends to do the same with the Safe Schools Improvement Act (SSIA). Without either, the ESEA would have no specific mention of LGBT students and the unique challenges they face.

Among the signers of the letter were legal groups GLAD and Lambda Legal, family groups PFLAG and the Family Equality Council, the ACLU, and the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force. The Washington Blade notes that the Human Rights Campaign and GLSEN did not sign the letter, though both support SNDA and SSIA.

NEWS FLASH

Meghan McCain Hits Obama For Opposing Marriage Equality | During an appearance on MSNBC this morning, marriage equality proponent Meghan McCain suggested that the GOP presidential candidates should realize that “gay marriage in this country is a civil rights issue and not a political one,” but noted that President Obama has also failed to lead on the issue. “It’s not like President Obama is out there, you know, passing gay marriage everywhere in this country,” she added. Watch it:

NEWS FLASH

Pro-LGBT Maryland State Senator Pledges To Stand By Same-Sex Marriage Advocacy In Congressional Bid | Maryland state senator and same-sex marriage advocate Robert Garagiola announced his campaign for the state’s 6th Congressional District on Tuesday and refuted notions that his strong support for LGBT equality would drive away some voters. “I just look at it as a civil rights issue, and I’m not going to run from it,” Garagiola — who led last year’s legislative effort to bring marriage equality to Maryland– told the Washington Post.

Archbishop Dolan Wields Victim Card: Church Should Not Be Criticized For Opposing LGBT Equality

In a Deseret News feature profile, New York Archbishop Timothy Dolan uses the soapbox opportunity to pontificate on his favorite topic: how marriage equality is bad for the Catholic Church. With little consideration for the experiences of same-sex couples and their families, Dolan’s primary concern is what backlash the Church will face as it continues to discriminate against and demonize the LGBT community:

One of our arguments has always been that people of principle who feel this violates their deepest-held convictions are going to be forced to the wall,” Archbishop Dolan said. “We were told we were being Chicken Littles and that was ridiculous.”

But “no sooner was the ink dry,” he said, than priests throughout the state started coming to him with stories of couples threatening to sue if they didn’t agree to rent out their parishes for same-sex weddings.

Richard Barnes, executive director of the New York Catholic Conference, also echoed these concerns:

“I could foresee the state determining that we can’t make decisions on a moral or religious basis as we would have in the past regarding the employment of individuals who are actively defying church tenets,” Barnes said. “If that happened, we would be in a position where we were asserting our First Amendment rights in court.”

Dolan and Barnes are trying to suggest not only that they have a right to discriminate against people for being gay, but that they should also be shielded from criticism for doing so. Bishop William Lori testified before the House Judiciary Committee last week that he fears Church leaders will be smeared as “bigots” merely for practicing their “religious liberty.” But that “right” is an effort to demonize the gay community at every turn, which is why these Catholic leaders constantly try to paint themselves as the victims. Evoking sympathy for their beliefs distracts from their efforts to deny equality to the LGBT community.

It’s important to note that Dolan, Barnes, and Lori speak only on behalf of Catholic leadership, not all Catholics. In fact, only 35 percent of American Catholics oppose marriage equality, and most distrust the bishops because of their gross mishandling of the ongoing sexual abuse scandals. But that doesn’t stop individuals like Dolan from suggesting that the entire gay community should be subjugated to his minority beliefs. He claims that he’s the hero, offering “love, acceptance, dignity, and respect” to gay people, despite little understanding of the challenges their families face. Constantly harping about his own beliefs demonstrates what little concern he has for same-sex couples’ welfare.

  • Comment Icon

NEWS FLASH

New Hampshire Lawmaker Clears Way For Repeal Of Marriage Equality | New Hampshire state Rep. David Bates (R) is withdrawing his support for a constitutional amendment to prohibit same-sex marriage in hopes that conservatives will rally around a different measure to eliminate marriage equality and replace it with civil unions. “It would complicate the decision for legislators if there was another alternative out there,” Bates said of the amendment. The House Judiciary Committee advanced the repeal measure last month and the full House is expected to take it up in January. Significantly, the repeal bill would allow anyone to refuse to recognize the civil unions and discriminate against such couples in employment, housing, and public accommodations.

The Morning Pride: November 2, 2011

Welcome to The Morning Pride, ThinkProgress LGBT’s 8:45 AM round-up of the latest in LGBT policy, politics, and some culture too! Here’s what we’re reading this morning, but let us know what you’re checking out too. Follow us all day on Twitter at @TPEquality.

- An Occupy Wall Street teach-in from the Sylvia Rivera Law Project explored how the 99 Percent Movement could be more inclusive of transgender people.

- The New York Times seems to have taken the National Organization for Marriage’s bait that in the Iowa Senate race, same-sex marriage is the “most discussed” issue.

- NOM used their own photo controversy to paint themselves as the victim — that it was the institution of marriage that got “mugged,” not the Obama rally photos they used to support their New Hampshire campaign.

- Oh, and NOM’s latest video isn’t about marriage equality. It just insinuates that the gay community hates straight couples with foster children, or something.

- The superintendent of the San Diego Unified School District is furious about all the adult “bullies” from outside the community who have called with hateful comments about the lesbian couple crowned homecoming king and queen.

- The coalition of conservatives trying to overturn California’s FAIR Education Act hasn’t given up.

- An Atlanta-based print company is using its “Moral Objection Policy” to discriminate against LGBT organizations.

- A same-sex parent offers a fresh perspective about talking to his teenager about his sex life.

- A British teacher advised students to “act less gay” to avoid being bullied.

- WATCH: NAACP Chairman Julian Bond has joined HRC’s Americans for Marriage Equality video campaign.

- WATCH: Musician Tom Goss has a new video for his song, “It’s All Over.” Goss was named “Best Local Musician” in the Washington Blade’s “Best of Gay DC” awards:

  • Comment Icon

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up