ThinkProgress Logo

LGBT

NEWS FLASH

Marcus Bachmann’s Agenda As ‘First Spouse’: Deny Marriage Rights To Gay People | Marcus Bachmann laid out his agenda as “first spouse” during a stop in Le Mars, Iowa, today, promising that he and Michele are “going to be the message-drivers” about how “Marriage is between one man and one woman.” “We are going to promote families,” he added. Earlier this summer, an undercover investigation by Truth Wins Out and a testimonial from one of the center’s patients confirmed long-standing rumors that Bachmann’s centers did practice so-called “ex-gay” or reparative therapy while receiving federal Medicaid funds.

Kerry Seeks ‘Equal Treatment Of LGBT Applicants’ In Financial Aid Process

Our guest blogger is Crosby Burns, special assistant for the LGBT Research and Communications Project at American Progress.

Earlier this week, Senator John Kerry (D-MA) urged the Obama administration to ensure equal treatment of LGBT applicants in the financial aid process. “Taxpayer-funded financial aid is often being misallocated based on sexual orientation when it should be based solely on financial need,” Kerry wrote in a letter addressed to Education Secretary Arne Duncan.

Indeed, as a result of the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA), the FAFSA is often unable to count parents, spouses, step-children, and other family members as part of an individual’s application for financial aid. The resulting unequal treatment leads to significant distortions in the allocation of financial aid for applicants who have two mothers or two fathers. As a recent report from the Center for American Progress found, the FAFSA can rob these families of much needed aid to finance applicants’ higher education or could even result in a larger financial aid package to families headed by same-sex couples. LGBT youth and transgender applicants also experience significant barriers to submitting a FAFSA on time, complete, or at all.

For its part, the federal government assigned more than $134 billion in financial aid to more than 14 million students last year, making it the single largest grantee of aid. Since most other financial aid depends on the FAFSA application for federal aid, these distortions will trickle down throughout the entire financial aid application process, even outside of the federal government’s support.

NEWS FLASH

Customs Agrees To Defend Binational Same-Sex Couple From Deportation | Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has agreed to oppose the deportation of a spouse from a same-sex couple that has lived with the constant fear of being separated from his husband because the federal Defense of Marriage Act does not recognize their Massachusetts marriage. The couple, Michael Thomas and John Brandoli, credit Sen. John Kerry (D-MA) for speaking out on their behalf. Brandoli’s mother expressed relief that their family would no longer have to fear Thomas’ deportation, saying of ICE’s decision, “there is no greater gift that I could ask for.” ICE recently offered new policy language to guide its case-by-case review of deportation cases that is designed to help protect same-sex couples.

Free Speech Suit Takes Aim At Anti-Bullying Policies

On October 20, 2010, Howell High School teacher Jay McDowell asked a student to leave his classroom for expressing his religious view that he does not accept homosexuality or condone homosexual acts. Now, the student’s mother, Sandra Glowacki, is suing the teacher and district for violating her son’s constitutional rights. But the lawsuit brought by the Thomas More Law Center on her behalf suggests more of a crusade against all anti-bullying policies, calling them “indoctrination” that is “hostile toward religious opposition to homosexuality.”

The incident took place on Spirit Day, a day on which teachers and students wear purple to remember those who committed suicide after experiencing relentless bullying. The lawsuit calls Spirit Day “a day in which activists exploit the tragic suicidal deaths of homosexual teenagers to promote acceptance of homosexuality in the public schools,” and then admonishes the school for allowing the teacher to participate by wearing a shirt remembering Tyler Clementi and showing a film about anti-gay bullying:

The purpose of the “anti-bullying” day, the “Tyler’s Army” t-shirts, and the movie was to indoctrinate students into believing that homosexuality is normal and to shift the blame for the destructive lifestyle of homosexuals to those who believe it is wrong and immoral. In particular, the purpose is to make those who oppose homosexuality on moral and religious grounds to feel guilty for holding those beliefs and to portray those beliefs as intolerant, harmful, hateful, and destructive. In sum, the purpose of the “anti-bullying” campaign, which is sponsored, promoted, and endorsed by the NEA, the MEA, the HEA, GLAAD, and the School District, is to shift the blame, guilt, and shame felt by homosexuals onto those who oppose homosexuality on moral and religious grounds.

The suit does nothing to sugarcoat the anti-gay Catholic beliefs Glowacki instilled in her children, calling homosexual acts “acts of grave depravity,” “intrinsically disordered,” and “contrary to the natural law,” and “under no circumstances can they be approved.” In fact, while simultaneously claiming that the student was defamed by being called “anti-gay” and that the actions against him would “chill a person of ordinary firmness,” it goes on to suggest that any policy that tries to limit anti-gay speech or favor pro-gay speech is a violation of the Fourteenth Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause.

Ultimately, this suit seems to have little to do with the student’s rights. Rather, Thomas More Law Center is using this opportunity to demand that it be perfectly okay to condemn, ostracize, bully, and harass students for their sexual orientation, the consequences be damned. (HT: Towleroad.)

Alyssa

Coming Out Stories as Cultural Capital

Gawker reports that Anderson Cooper may be planning a coming-out episode to boost the ratings of his talk show, which have been mixed, during the February sweeps period.

There’s something fascinating to me about the fact that we’ve reached a point where coming out of the closet can—for a very small set of very privileged people, and under very specific circumstances—be extraordinarily valuable cultural capital. Cooper is all but formally out: he’s regularly photographed with men he’s dating. I think it’s probably a fair bet (if not a certainty) that he is out to friends and family. But it’s that statement that’s valuable. It’s what gets you the tune-in as people await final confirmation that the Silver Fox is in fact a Friend of Dorothy, it’s what gets you the magazine covers, and the speaking circuit, and the invitation to chair a charity or host a big fundraising dinner. It’s not coming out as we traditionally understand it, a revealing of previously unknown and often unsuspected information to friends and family that carries a risk of rejection.

I don’t think there’s anything wrong with celebrities who come out getting a benefit of community support and affiliation from it. And I do think it helps kids to have role models. But it is worth noting that we’re at a point where that experience is a commodity, and that need for role models and heroes is something that can be turned into a profit-generating enterprise.

NEWS FLASH

Ugandan President On Foreign Aid Threat: ‘Homosexuals Need Electricity Too’ | Uganda is resisting western pressure to repeal laws that criminalize homosexuality and is blasting the United States and Great Britain for threatening to withhold foreign aid over the matter. Today Ugandan President Yoweri  Museveni decried potential cuts, saying, “Homosexuals also need electricity, homosexuals also need roads, homosexuals also need railways.” Uganda punishes homosexuality with up to life in prison, and lawmakers continue to consider a bill that would allow for the death penalty on second offenses.

Minnesota Archbishop Asks Catholics To Pray Against Marriage Equality

Minnesota Archbishop John Nienstedt is asking Catholics to recite a “special prayer” condemning the right of gay and lesbian people to marry, the Star Tribune is reporting. The request is just the latest effort in the archdiocese’s campaign to whip up support against the state’s pending constitutional amendement to outlaw marriage equality. The prayer explains that marriage is “a source of blessing and joy,” before asking parishioners to deny this happiness to gay people:

Heavenly Father,

Through the powerful intercession of the Holy Family, grant to this local Church the many graces we need to foster, strengthen, and support faith-filled, holy marriages and holy families. May the vocation of married life, a true calling to share in your own divine and creative life, be recognized by all believers as a source of blessing and joy, and a revelation of your own divine goodness. Grant to us all the gift of courage to proclaim and defend your plan for marriage, which is the union of one man and one woman in a lifelong, exclusive relationship of loving trust, compassion, and generosity, open to the conception of children.

We make our prayer through Jesus Christ, who is Lord forever and ever. Amen.

In October, the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis called on priests to appoint special committees to “spearhead this effort at the local level” so as to prevent a “detriment to the common good of society.” The Catholic Conference is one of three arms of “Minneosta for Marriage,” the coalition advocating for the discriminatory amendment. In a joint statement, the MCC and Archdiocese proclaimed that anyone who does not support the amendment is not in “good standing” with the church, although Catholics largely support marriage equality, even at higher rates than the general public in some polls.

Fortunately, the Episcopal Church in Minnesota, has passed a resolution opposing the proposed constitutional amendment, explaining, “The Episcopal Church in Minnesota has always stood with the marginalized” and “embraced both the Gospel mandate of love of neighbor and the Baptismal Covenant imperative to respect the dignity of every human being.”

NEWS FLASH

Fun Fact: Santorum Represented The World Wrestling Association | A Washington Post profile about struggling GOP presidential candidate Rick Santorum offers this previously underreported biographical detail: “The son of a psychologist and a nurse who worked at a VA hospital, Santorum grew up in a not terribly political or pious Catholic family. He was a young lawyer representing the World Wrestling Association when he met his wife, Karen, a law student his firm was trying to recruit.”

Politics

Rep. Allen West: ‘If Joseph Goebbels Was Around, He’d Be Very Proud Of The Democrat Party’ (Updated)

Arguably the most inflammatory member in Congress, GOP Rep. Allen West (FL) outdid himself yesterday by comparing the Democratic Party to the Nazi party. Bristling at a new poll revealing that Americans blame Republicans for Congress’s inability to function, West invoked this slur:

“If Joseph Goebbels was around, he’d be very proud of the Democrat Party, because they have an incredible propaganda machine,” West told reporters during House votes Thursday afternoon. “Let’s be honest, you know, some of the people in the media are complicit with this and enabling them to get that type of message out.” [...]

“But let’s be very honest,” he added. “You have the president, who has an incredible megaphone and a platform, and he has people all across this country believing that the only people on Capitol Hill are House Republicans. He’s not talking anything about his controlled Senate. So, it’s a great propaganda machine. And I have to give him kudos for being able to leverage that.”

Goebbels was Adolf Hitler’s Minister of Propaganda from 1933 to 1945 and was known for openly exploiting “the lowest instincts of the German people” like racism, xenophobia, and economic insecurity to engender a zealous anti-Semitism.

The National Jewish Democratic Council asked West to “apologize sincerely and immediately. As we have said repeatedly, invoking the Holocaust to make a political point is never acceptable and should be condemned by all for the sake of the memory of those who were lost.” Rep. John Conyers (D-MI) also blasted West in a personal letter, demanding that he “help raise the level of congressional discourse in a vigorous debate.”

West, as if realizing the extremity of his words, then peremptorily blamed reporters for “taking my words and twisting it around.” “What I’m talking about is a person that was the minister of propaganda. And I’m talking about propaganda,” he said. “Once again, you guys will take whatever I say and you will spin it to try to demonize me or demagogue me.” After all, he’s the victim here.

Update

Reps. Steve Israel (D-NY) and Gary Ackerman (D-NY) were also outraged by West’s comment. “Shame on him,” tweeted Israel. “Rep. West needs to apologize now for insulting the memories of the millions who lost their lives during the Holocaust.” Ackerman said, “This is exactly the type of rhetoric that turns people off to Washington…I call on Republicans and Democrats alike to join me in demanding an apology.”

Update

The Anti-Defamation League responded with “outrage and dismay” in a letter to West, noting that this was not the first time he used a Nazi analogy. “Such outrageous Holocaust analogies have no place in our political dialogue. They are offensive, they trivialize real historical events, and they diminish the memory of the six million Jews and millions of others who perished in the Holocaust,” the ADL wrote.

Update

Rep. West has doubled down on his Nazi rhetoric when firing back at Rep. Conyers in a letter. “Mr. Conyers, The Democrat Party does indeed have a vicious propaganda machine. it espouses lies and deceit and the Master of deceptive information would truly be proud,” West said. “I have been personally attacked and denigrated on countless occasions. I do not appreciate your letter…Truth is Powerful Sir! Steadfast & Loyal, Allen.”

NEWS FLASH

Another Anti-Gay Bill Advances In Russia | “Kostroma, a region located 300 km north east of Moscow, may become the third Russian region to outlaw so called propaganda of homosexuality to minors,” GayRussia, the nation’s LGBT advocacy group reports. Members of the local Parliament “already planned to formalize the ban of homosexual propaganda by adding two articles to the existing laws ‘On Guarantees of the Rights of the Child’ and ‘Administrative Code.’” The regions of Ryazan and Arkhangelsk passed similar legislation in 2006 and it’s now being considered in St. Petersburg, where a ban has already passed first reading.

NEWS FLASH

Tom Vilsack Only Supports Marriage Equality For Iowa | Former Iowa Governor Tom Vilsack (D), who now serves as Secretary of Agriculture, has said that he’s proud that his home state established marriage equality. He took credit for appointing some of the Iowa Supreme Court judges who overturned the ban on same-sex marriage in 2009, calling it a “good decision.” He stopped short, however, of calling for nationwide marriage equality, offering, “I will be happy to answer that question someday. That day is not today.”

Romney Challenged On Past Support For Gay Rights At Iowa Debate

Fox News’ Chris Wallace challenged Mitt Romney on his past support for gay rights during Thursday night’s GOP presidential debate in Sioux City, Iowa. The former Massachusetts governor defended his 1994 claim that he would fight harder for equality than Ted Kennedy, explaining that he “does not believe in discriminating against people based upon their sexual orientation,” and could have fought “for anti-discrimination in a way that would be even better than Senator Kennedy, as a Democrat, who would be expected to do so.” He insisted, however, that he has consistently opposed marriage equality. Watch it:

The answer didn’t satisfy Rick Santorum, however, who dredged up false accusations that Romney voluntarily signed same-sex marriage licenses himself. Santorum’s claim is a popular misconception put forward by right-wing groups that conflates the state’s One Day Marriage Designation with actual marriage licenses. As the Massachusetts state website explains, “[t]he One-Day Marriage Designation is not a marriage license,” but rather a certificate the governor can issue to “designate non-clergy individuals to solemnize a marriage.” Once same-sex marriage became legal in Massachusetts, the Romney administration granted designation applications to same and opposite sex couples.

In reality, Romney tried to limit the impact of the ruling by ordering town clerks to enforce a little-known 1913 law to deny licenses to out-of-state couples and even testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee in support of a federal marriage amendment.

In 1994, Romney also promised to co-sponsor the Federal Employment Non-Discrimination Act and claimed that marriage policy should be left to the states. He now supports a federal constitutional amendment outlawing same-sex marriage and a complicated three-tier system for married-gay couples.

  • Comment Icon

The Morning Pride: December 16, 2011

Welcome to The Morning Pride, ThinkProgress LGBT’s 8:45 AM round-up of the latest in LGBT policy, politics, and some culture too! Here’s what we’re reading this morning, but let us know what you’re checking out as well. Follow us all day on Twitter at @TPEquality.

- Meet Karen Golinski, one of several plaintiffs challenging the Defense of Marriage Act.

- Exxon Mobil is officially the first company to ever receive a negative score on HRC’s Corporate Equality Index.

- Could “exceptions on abortion” complicate The FAMiLY LEADER’s endorsement?

- Marcus Bachmann has stopped pestering Truth Wins Out over the $150 he thought he was due.

- A gay Republican in Branson, MO wants other gay Republicans to stop being “hypocrites” and come out.

- Anchorage will officially be voting in April on a non-discrimination ordinance.

- Mike Huckabee is now stumping for incredibly anti-gay Gary Glenn on his campaign to be Michigan’s next senator.

- The Media Resource Center thinks the media is too soft on kids who are bullied or who commit suicide.

- The former leader of a Boston-area HIV/AIDS organization has plead guilty to embezzling more than $100,000 from the non-profit.

- What does the future hold for the Human Rights Campaign?

- Watch as thousands of Toronto students pledge to resist bullying.

  • Comment Icon

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up