ThinkProgress Logo

LGBT

NEWS FLASH

Washington House Passes Marriage Equality 55-43 | After defeating multiple amendments designed to derail the bill — including one that would require a referendum — the Washington state House of Representative has passed marriage equality with a vote of 55-43. The bill now goes to Gov. Chris Gregoire (D), who has promised to sign it. Opponents of marriage equality have already promised to challenge the law with a referendum.

Health

Oklahoma Democrat Adds ‘Every Sperm Is Sacred’ Amendment To Personhood Bill

Despite being rebuffed by voters in Mississippi and Colorado, proponents of the “personhood” movement are still pushing to enact legislation in states like Ohio and Oklahoma that would give zygotes the same rights as American citizens. These bills would not only criminalize abortion in all circumstances, they would also outlaw common forms of contraception, as well as in vitro fertilization.

To poke fun at the absurdity of the measure, Oklahoma state Sen. Constance Johnson (D), has tacked on a provision affirming — in the words of a famous Monty Python song — that every sperm is sacred:

State Senator Constance Johnson of Oklahoma City has served Oklahoma’s 48th Senate District since 2005, but it was yesterday’s introduction of Senate Bill 1433 that really pushed her over the edge. The bill sought to define human life as beginning at the moment of conception, before it’s even implanted in the womb, and offers full legal protection to those tiny multicelled lumps. In the words of the bill, “the unborn child at every stage of development (has) all the rights, privileges, and immunities available to other persons, citizens, and residents of this state.”

Johnson submitted an amendment of her own to the bill, which would have added the language,

However, any action in which a man ejaculates or otherwise deposits semen anywhere but in a woman’s vagina shall be interpreted and construed as an action against an unborn child.

Among other things, Johnson’s amendment would essentially outlaw oral sex, anal sex, and masturbation. Were it not a satirical bill, it would almost certainly be deemed unconstitutional.

To prove that her amendment was in jest, Johnson voted with her colleagues to table it later in the day. But it does illustrate a serious point: only about half of fertilized eggs develop into a pregnancy. If Republican lawmakers are willing to declare every cluster of cells with the potential to become a fetus a person, why stop at fertilized eggs? Why not sperm as well?

To protest the inherent sexism of the personhood bill, another Democratic senator attempted to add an amendment that would require the father of the child to be financially responsible for the mother’s health care, housing, and other expenses while she is pregnant.

Rep. Gohmert: Ninth Circuit ‘Not Smart Enough’ To Bring Egg And Sperm Together

Rep. Louie Gohmert (R-TX) used a House floor speech to offer a particularly disturbing reaction to yesterday’s ruling by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals that Proposition 8 is unconstitutional. In it, he suggested that marriage is about “the idea of an egg and a sperm coming together” and called the judges “not smart enough to figure out actual plumbing”:

GOHMERT: Nature seemed to like the idea of an egg and a sperm coming together because of pro-creation. Apparently [the judges] thought the sperm had far better use some other way biologically, combining it with something else. But the voters of Iowa came back and said you know what, if you’re not smart enough to figure out actual plumbing…then perhaps we need new judges, and that’s what they did.

Watch a clip:

What the judges actually found was that Proposition 8 had nothing to do with procreation, because it didn’t impact whether same-sex couples in California could raise children.

Alyssa

Why CNN Suspended Liberal Roland Martin For Offensive Comments But Not Conservative Dana Loesch

Roland Martin has been suspended from CNN after tweeting that, “If a dude at your Super Bowl party is hyped about David Beckham’s H&M underwear ad, smack the ish out of him! #superbowl.” He then insisted that, rather than making a joke about violence against men who are attracted to men, he really just hates soccer: “@DrMChatelain @notjustsexuality well that shows how ignorant you are. I rip on soccer all of the time. Learn to pay attention!”

It’s the second time in a month that CNN commentators have come under fire for controversial comments: Dana Loesch recently cheered reports of members of the United States Marine Corps urinating on the bodies of dead Afghans and suggested that had she been present, she would have joined in. But while Martin apologized and will experience an indefinite suspension, CNN and Loesch refused to apologize for her remarks, and she’s remained on the air.

The clear difference between the two cases? A sense that CNN’s audience was offended. GLAAD, which keeps a careful eye on defamation against gays and lesbians in the media, moved quickly to call for Martin’s dismissal and to track the network’s response to the incident. CNN got the message that its own constituents were upset, and that it would suffer consequences — or at least a lot of annoyance — if it failed to act.

Loesch’s comments on the other hand, offended human rights advocates and decent people everywhere. But that’s not the same as running afoul of an organization with a well-established plan to respond to these kinds of events and a well-worn path to media outlets who would cover and amplify their response. While Loesch’s comments were reprehensible, there was also no organized group who was likely or able to hold CNN accountable for her words, and for continuing to let her appear on-air without penalty.

Taken together, the way CNN handled Martin’s and Loesch’s comments makes it look like CNN has no consistent internal values, and no internal standard for how to respond when it commenters express sentiments that are an anathema to those values. I’m glad to know, per CNN’s statement, that “Language that demeans is inconsistent with the values and culture of our organization, and is not tolerated.” But why should it take several days of consideration for CNN to arrive at that conclusion? If the network’s truly committed to the proposition that violence against gay people is no joking matter, that’s something it should know in advance, and CNN should have a personnel policy in place to determine what the appropriate penalty is when someone violates their standards. Similarly, whether Loesch’s comments violate CNN’s internal values shouldn’t be something that’s determined by the level of outrage outside the network’s headquarters.

Update

[By Zack Ford] As reported by AMERICAblog Gay, Martin’s wife, Jacquie Hood Martin, has responded angrily to news of his suspension, suggesting that GLAAD is somehow racist and has misused the history of the civil rights movement:

She also attacked CNN, saying it has no “brand” and doesn’t deserve to be in business:

Update

Jacquie Hood Martin has deleted her entire Twitter account.

NEWS FLASH

Marriage Equality Introduced In Illinois Legislature | Illinois state Rep. Greg Harris (D) has introduced a marriage equality bill less than a year after the state legalized same-sex civil unions. The Religious Freedom and Marriage Fairness Act (HB5170) contains the same provisions as the civil union bill did, and also allows couples to convert their civil unions to marriages. Illinois legislators had been already been strategizing a plan for passing marriage equality, but reports indicated they were aiming for 2013, not this year.

Maggie Gallagher Not Interested In Evidence For Marriage Equality, Position Informed By Past

Salon’s Mark Oppenheimer has published an in-depth profile of marriage equality opponent Maggie Gallagher, co-founder of the National Organization for Marriage who now blogs for the Culture War Victory Fund. The entire profile is worth a read, even if it does downplay how anti-gay her views are, because it paints a picture of a complex woman who does not fit the gay rights opponent mold.

Largely, it seems her efforts against marriage equality have been motivated by having a child out of wedlock in her early 20s, and it is hard not to read the profile without feeling that when she says, “Every child deserves a mother and a father,” what she really means is “My child deserved a father.” This experience fostered her conviction that sex and procreation cannot be separated — as waves of feminism have taught — and led her to fight for her social conservative values. The lives of same-sex couples challenge this core tenet, but the profile reveals that no amount of evidence could ever really shake her of it:

Same-sex marriage advocates offend her hard-won wisdom in two ways. First, they imply that sex and love can in fact be separate from procreation, and no less valid for it. Second, and perhaps more troubling for Gallagher, the increasingly visible column of attentive, loving gay parents — gay male parents in particular — mocks her own romantic choices. It mocks her own son’s good-for-nothing father. There must be something wrong with these gay dads, something contrary to the natural order, such that even when they appear to be splendid dads themselves, their agenda is the cause of poor parenting in others. [...]

There is an obvious problem with this sort of argumentation: it is not really susceptible to evidence. Gallagher is unwilling to make any predictions of what doom will befall families after the legalization of same-sex marriage. She just has faith that marriage, the central institution of good child-rearing, will be weakened if same-sex couples are allowed its prestige and protections. [...]

And even if somehow the evidence showed, conclusively, that same-sex marriage were good for children? Gallagher would still be dissatisfied: “Nothing could make me call a same-sex couple a marriage, because that’s not what I believe a marriage is.”

Obviously, Gallagher’s Catholic faith also informs her views on homosexuality. As Jeremy Hooper points out, she has called homosexuality a sin, an “unfortunate thing,” and a “sexual dysfunction,” in addition to advocating for ex-gay therapy. Given how loving same-sex families so starkly contradict her perception of sexuality, she struggles to even empathize with their experiences:

At one point, breaking from my script of questions, I interrupted her to ask if, despite all of her fears about same-sex marriage, she didn’t find it heartwarming to see those pictures of joyous gay couples in Massachusetts or Iowa or California, crying and hugging as they celebrated their marriages. Before answering, she takes a long pause, the only long pause of our conversation. “Am I happy for them?” she finally says. “That’s a tough question. I like to see people happy. It’s better than seeing people sad. So yes, I am happy for them. But I am sad. But I am not sad because they are happy.

Santorum Compares 9th Circuit To Soviet Union, Says Court Is ‘Intolerant’ For Striking Down Proposition 8

During a town hall in McKinney, Texas on Wednesday afternoon, Rick Santorum lashed out at the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals for striking down Proposition 8, arguing that the judges displaced “intolerance” towards conservatives and labeled proponents of “traditional” marriage as “bigots” when they found the measure unconstitutional. Yesterday’s decision affirmed a lower court ruling and concluded that “Proposition 8 serves no purpose, and has no effect, other than to lessen the status and dignity of gays and lesbians in California, and to officially reclassify their relationships and families as inferior to those of opposite-sex couples.”

But Santorum, who did not raise the issue until the very end of the event, argued that the judges had offended religious people. “Where is the tolerance of someone having a belief structure that is based in nature, that is based in reason, that is based in faith,” Santorum asked. “The intolerance of the left, the intolerance of the secular ideology, it is a religion on to itself, it is just not a biblical based religion. And it is the most intolerant — just like we say from the days of the atheists in the Soviet Union.” Watch it:

Health

Another Anti-Abortion Smart Phone: Android App ‘Iris’ Calls Abortion ‘Wrong,’ Cites The Bible

Hellfire and brimstone in the palm of your hand.

A few months ago tech giant Apple had some explaining to do when iPhone users discovered that the voice-activated assistant Siri was giving women misleading information about emergency contraception and abortion services.

Now Right Wing Watch reports that Siri may well have an evil twin sister in the form of Iris, the popular app for Verizon’s Android:

Iris – Siri spelled backwards – is the popular electronic assistant available for Android phones. It’s been downloaded over 1 million times and is powered by ChaCha, the Internet’s “leading answers service with more than a billion questions answered.” In other words, Iris may be a knockoff, but it’s no joke.

That’s why we were surprised when we saw the Family Research Council crowing about the Android being “as pro-life as they come” and watched their video…Iris’ answers are drawn from ChaCha, which provided a string of anti-choice answers to our questions:

Anti-abortion activists are celebrating the discovery of a kindred electronic ideologue. But Right Wing Watch notes that Iris doesn’t give such dogmatic answers to other controversial questions. For instance, “Iris failed to quote scripture in response to questions about adultery, birth control, homosexuality, working on the Sabbath, and eating shellfish (which are an ‘abomination before the Lord).”

NEWS FLASH

Minnesota Teachers Endorse ‘Respectful Learning Environment’ Policy For All Students | Minnesota’s bullying-riddled Anoka-Hennepin School District is on the verge of approving a new “Respectful Learning Environment” curriculum that would replace the troublesome “neutrality” policy, which prevents teachers and staff from discussing LGBT issues with students. On Monday, the teachers union in Anoka-Hennepin endorsed the new policy, agreeing that it “works for students and we definitely can work with that.” The school board will vote on the measure next Monday and is expected to pass it. Rolling Stone magazine recently profiled the anti-gay rhetoric that plagued the district and the rash of suicides that resulted from it.

NEWS FLASH

Bishop Gene Robinson Slaps Down Marriage Equality Haters In New Hampshire | A small group of anti-gay activists protested in favor of repealing New Hampshire’s 2009 same-sex marriage law in front of the capitol yesterday and described gay unions as “unnatural and incapable of sustaining the human species.” “Do you think it’s time to move on? I think it’s time to move back. Back to the true meaning of marriage,” State Rep. David Bates (R) told the crowd. But counter protesters, including Bishop Gene Robinson, pushed back against that message. “You’re not hearing any stories about any clergy person, any congregation, any denomination, any person of faith suffering any ill effects from marriage equality here in New Hampshire,” he said. Robinson is the Episcopal Church’s first openly gay bishop in New Hampshire. Watch it:

A new WMUR/University of New Hampshire Survey Center poll released yesterday “found that 59 percent of respondents oppose” repealing marriage equality.

Ellen Responds To ‘One Million Moms’ Boycott Of JC Penney: ‘My Haters Are My Motivators’

Ellen DeGeneres confronted the ‘One Million Moms’ boycott of her partnership with J.C. Penney on her daytime talk show yesterday with trademark humor quipping, “normally I don’t like to pay attention to my haters, but this time I’d like to talk about it because my haters are my motivators.” The anti-gay group, part of the American Family Association, is claiming that the store is undermining “traditional families” by selecting DeGeneres as its spokesperson.

On the show, DeGeneres read some of the supportive comments her fans left on the the group’s Facebook page and then explained her values:

I usually don’t talk about stuff like this on my show. But I really want to thank everyone who is supporting me. And if you don’t know me very well, if you’re just watching maybe for the the first time or you’re just getting to know me I want to be clear. And here are the values that I stand for. I stand for honesty, equality, kindness, compassion, treating people the way you want to be treated and helping those in need. To me those are traditional values, that’s what I stand for.

Watch it:

  • Comment Icon

Russia’s Anti-Gay Propaganda Bill Passes Second Reading, Lawmakers Compare Gays To Drug Users

St. Petersburg, Russia’s controversial anti-gay propaganda law passed the second of three readings today in a vote of 31 to 6, as activists protested the measure in front of the parliament and were later detained for seven hours.

During the debate, United Russia deputy Vitaly Milonov accused the “liberal opposition” of seeking to destroy the country and disregarding the well-being of children. He claimed that liberalism has increased the city’s “tolerance for drug use, and, in his opinion, the same can not be allowed in respect of sexual perversion.” The measure would fine groups or individuals who promote homosexuality, pedophilia, or transgenderism to minors. The version approved today includes fines that are 10 times higher than when the bill was first brought before the city’s legislature in November. The text:

“Under the public actions aimed at promoting sodomy, lesbianism, bisexuality, transgender minors, in this article should be understood as a purposeful activity, and uncontrolled dissemination of public information, manner, able to harm the health, moral and spiritual development minors, including the form they have misconceptions about the social equivalence of traditional and nontraditional marriage. ” Under the promotion of pedophilia, the bill requires to understand “purposeful activity and uncontrolled dissemination of public information, manner, carried out in order to create a society of distorted notions of conformity to social norms of intimate relationships between adults and minors. “

The anti-gay legislation has been condemned by the international community and is in violation of the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the European Convention for Human Rights, the Council of Europe Recommendations and other decrees. Lawmakers in Moscow are said to be considering similar bans.

  • Comment Icon

The Morning Pride: February 8, 2012

Welcome to The Morning Pride, ThinkProgress LGBT’s 8:45 AM round-up of the latest in LGBT policy, politics, and some culture too! Here’s what we’re reading this morning, but let us know what you’re checking out as well. Follow us all day on Twitter at @TPEquality.

- Rick Santorum has won non-binding Republican primaries in Minnesota, Missouri, and Colorado, awarding him zero delegates.

- Prop 8 proponents have announced they will appeal to the Supreme Court.Read the positive and negative reactions to yesterday’s decision and a glowing summation from the New York Times editorial board.

- Openly gay Republican presidential candidate Fred Karger will be on the California ballot.

- Marriage equality opponents rallied in New Hampshire yesterday, but a new poll show strong opposition (59 percent) to the bill that would repeal the state’s same-sex marriage provisions.

- Keisha Waites was elected to the Georgia state legislature in a special election yesterday, making her the fourth openly gay lawmaker in the state’s General Assembly.

- Atlanta police interview the victim of a brutal anti-gay beating that was caught on film.

- A bartender at an Austin, Texas gay bar was also attacked this weekend.

- Salina, Kansas, is considering expanding its anti-discrimination policy to include sexual orientation and gender identity.

- LISTEN: The Center for American Progress interviews One Colorado’s Brad Clark about gay and transgender healthcare.

- Of the 44 percent of Marylanders who oppose marriage equality, 75 percent of them are motivated by religion.

- Chaim Levin continues his work resisting the anti-gay views and ex-gay therapy prescribed by Orthodox Judaism on his new blog, “Gotta Give ‘Em Hope.”

- As expected Uganda reintroduced the “Kill the Gays” bill, and the U.S. State Department continues to oppose it.

  • Comment Icon

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up