ThinkProgress Logo

LGBT

Alyssa

NATO Makes the ‘Bully’ Ratings Controversy Worse

Well, this is charming. The National Association of Theater Owners has decided to respond to the Weinstein Company’s complaints that the MPAA rating system was too rigid and context-resistant to deal with Bully in a nuanced, intelligent way…by being even more rigid and context-resistant! Deadline reports:

Surveys of America’s parents reflect their very strong concern with the use of harsh language in movies. The vast majority of parents surveyed have indicated that the type of language used in “Bully” should receive an automatic “R” rating. You ask us to ignore the preferences of America’s parents and our own ratings rules because of the merit of this movie. Yet were the MPAA and NATO to waive the ratings rules whenever we believed that a particular movie had merit, or was somehow more important than other movies, we would no longer be neutral parties applying consistent standards, but rather censors of content based on personal mores…I have nothing but tremendous respect for you and the work of TWC. Our industry is so much the better for your involvement. But if you decide to withdraw your support and participation in the rating system, and begin to release movies without ratings, I will have no choice but to encourage my theater owner members to treat unrated movies from The Weinstein Company in the same manner as they treat unrated movies from anyone else.

In most cases, that means enforcement as though the movies were rated NC-17 – where no one under the age of 18 can be admitted even with accompanying parents or guardians.

I’m not a parent, but this reads to me less as an attempt to be responsive to America’s parents and much more as a nuclear option to try to limit the audiences for movies that come out of studios that have the temerity to say that the ratings system doesn’t work for them. It’s one thing to enforce the ratings system, and another to jack up the rating that a movie would have gotten otherwise if a studio doesn’t want to comply with the system. That’s not safeguarding community standards: it’s about showing you have power. Particularly since some school districts are going to try to get permission for their students to see Bully anyway, something that would become impossible if the theaters started enforcing rules that required parents to accompany their children to the movie during the workday.

And of course, this is also a move that will limit tickets sales for NATO members who carry Bully. I wonder if showing you’re willing to get into an arms race with one of Hollywood’s best salesmen is worth the lost revenue.

NEWS FLASH

UPDATE: Principal Who Condemned Gay And Pregnant Students Resigns | The principal of Tennessee’s Haywood High School, Dorothy Bond, has resigned following various allegations that she has told gay students they are going to Hell and pregnant students that their lives are over. The school district released a statement saying, “The Haywood County Board of Education acknowledges its student body’s right to free speech. Further, the Haywood County Board of Education strives to provide an atmosphere of tolerance and diversity while maintaining high academic standards.” (HT: Holy Bullies and Headless Monsters.)

Maryland Becomes 8th State With Marriage Equality Following Governor’s Signature

Moments ago, Gov. Martin O’Malley signed legislation legalizing same-sex marriage in Maryland, making the state the eighth in the nation to offer marriage equality to gay and lesbian couples. Opponents of the measure have already filed the necessary paperwork to start collecting signatures for a referendum to overturn the law. They will have until June 30 to collect 56,000 valid signatures in order to successfully put the issue up to a referendum in November. The law is set to take effect in January of 2013, well after a referendum would take place.

As he prepared to sign the measure, flanked by supporters, O’Malley framed the issue as one of religious liberty and human dignity, saying, “for a free and diverse people, for people of many faiths, for people committed to the principal of religious freedom, the way forward is always found through grater respect for human rights of all, through human dignity for all.” “We are one Maryland and all of us at the end of the day want the same thing for our children. We want them to live in a loving, caring and committed home that is protected equally under the law.” Watch it:

NEWS FLASH

Opposition To North Carolina’s Marriage Inequality Amendment Has ‘Momentum’ | In just nine weeks, North Carolina voters will decide whether the state constitution should include “Amendment One,” which would ban same-sex marriage and all forms of civil unions and domestic partnerships. Protect All NC Families is leading the opposition effort on the ground, with seven campaign offices across the state, over a hundred allied organizations, and thousands of volunteers. Watch their new video about the growing momentum:

NEWS FLASH

Lesbian Who Was Denied Communion Says Episode Has ‘Strengthened My Faith In The Church’ | Barbara Johnson said she was “stunned” when a Catholic priest denied her communion at her own mother’s funeral because she was a lesbian living “a sin” and told CNN this afternoon that the now infamous episode “felt unreal.” The priest also walked out in the middle of Johnson’s eulogy to her mother. The Archdiocese of Washington has apologized for the episode and admitted that the preist — Father Marcel Guarnizo — followed improper protocol. Interestingly, Johnson claims that the outpouring of support she received from within the Church and other Catholics has actually “strengthened my faith in the Church itself.” Watch Johnson talk about the experience:

How The GOP’s Efforts To Expand ‘Religious Conscience’ Affect The LGBT Community

Our guest blogger is Andrew Cray, an LGBT health research associate at the Center for American Progress.

Sen. Roy Blunt (R-MO)

Today, the battle over coverage for the full range of medically necessary health services reached another milestone. The Blunt Amendment, which the Senate narrowly voted to table earlier today, would have given unprecedented discretion to any employer or insurance plan, whether or not religious, to exclude coverage for critical health care services on the basis of undefined “moral convictions.” This far-reaching proposal was not limited to particular services, instead restricting access to care in a manner so extreme that HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius described the measure as “dangerous and wrong.” The Amendment was the latest in the GOP’s continuing effort to limit access and autonomy in health care, a firestorm that House Speaker John Boehner (R-OH) has vowed to reignite.

 

The Blunt Amendment undermined the Affordable Care Act’s guarantee of coverage for essential health benefits, and could have placed access to preventive care services at risk for over 20 million women. Perhaps its greatest threat, though, was its potential to gut the crucial equity framework established by the Affordable Care Act, placing entire populations at risk of losing coverage for necessary, sometimes life-saving, care.

Among those with the greatest to lose from proposals like the Blunt Amendment is the lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) community. Broad and unfettered language of the kind advanced by Sen. Roy Blunt (R-MO) would grant insurers and employers the right to deny coverage for nearly any service provided to LGBT patients. For example, under the Blunt Amendment:

– An insurer could refuse to cover any health care service to a gay couple because of a religious or moral objection to such relationships.

– An employer could refuse to cover life-saving care for HIV or AIDS, due to an unfounded “moral objection.”

– An insurance plan could ban coverage for nearly any care provided to a transgender person, on the basis of moral or religious objection to their gender identity.

Denying coverage for these basic essential services – a central requirement of the Affordable Care Act – rolls back progress in public health, and places the lives of LGBT people at risk.
Read more

NEWS FLASH

New York Attorney General Endorses Marriage Equality For Democratic Platform | According to Amanda Terkel at The Huffington Post, New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman has added his support to including marriage equality as a plank of the 2012 Democratic Party platform, pointing out that “obstacles on the federal level stand in the way of full equality for all New Yorkers.” Several other prominent Democrats have joined Freedom To Marry’s “Democrats: Say I Do” campaign, including House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi (D-CA), Reps. Raul Grijalva (D-AZ) and Keith Ellison (D-MN), Sen. Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH), and former Sen. Russ Feingold (D-WI).

NEWS FLASH

Activists In Utah Protest Tabling Of Anti-Discrimination Bill | More than 100 activists rallied at Utah’s State Capitol on Feb. 29 to voice their opposition “over the state-wide nondiscrimination ordinance being tabled.” The rally “called out the legislators by name who voted to table the nondiscrimination bill that was moved into committee earlier this session. “It is absolutely ridiculous that we can’t even have a discussion on these issues in this state,” said Weston Clark, one of the organizers. “Enough is enough… We’re here to start applying just a little more pressure on these people.” The measure, which failed to pass committee, would have made it illegal “for an employer or landlord to discriminate against somebody because of their sexual orientation.”

Alyssa

Conservative Publisher Andrew Breitbart Dead At 43

It says a great deal about the quality of publisher and provocateur Andrew Breitbart’s showmanship and his commitment to carrying a performance through that, as the news broke this morning that he had passed away at the untimely age of 43, many people weren’t sure the announcement was real. At ThinkProgress, we send condolences to his family, and remember him as an expert and captivating provocateur, even in our many serious disagreements with him on the issues.

And there’s no question that Breitbart could be a captivating presence. His Twitter feed (the last missive from it was “I called you a putz cause I thought you were being intentionally disingenuous. If not I apologize.”) was a vehicle for performance art and agitprop. A New Yorker profile of him in 2010 started with the image of Breitbart tweeting “Why is Steny Hoyer in Los Angeles sitting on Anthony Weiner’s shoulders screaming the N word into my home? Weird.” He used his feed to savage Ted Kennedy in the immediate aftermath of the Senator’s death.

That flair for the dramatic persisted off the internet: in the wake of Anthony Weiner’s Twitter flirtations scandal, Breitbart stepped off the plane in New York and went straight to a press conference to answer charges that he or someone in his employ had hacked the Congressman’s Twitter account, an event at which he complained that “72 hours in Palm Springs with your family is excruciating when you are being challenged.” It was an amusing, if self-aggrandizing, performance.

Breitbart’s more dramatic tendencies could affect his preferences in reporting. As a publisher, Breitbart’s first scalp—and his biggest—was the Association of Community Organizations for Reform Now, which withered after a so-called sting organization by conservative prankster James O’Keefe. The video hardly damned the organization as a whole, but the report succeeded in starving ACORN of much of its funding and eventually forced the group to reorganize. Despite the diminishing returns of O’Keefe’s hoaxes, Breitbart stood by him, and compared O’Keefe to Sacha Baron-Cohen’s Borat character, saying “I think Borat got real politicians/personalities to act in real ways that we hold them to account for. O’Keefe is more serious.”

That penchant for the dramatic and boundary-pushing also led Breitbart into places no credible journalist would tread, a tendency he held up as proof of his independence, but that led to embarrassing missteps. During the Weiner press conference, he complained that “The media says Breitbart lies! Brietbart lies! Breitbart lies! Give me one example of a provable lie!” But the edited video he published the year before that implied that Department of Agriculture employee Shirley Sherrod harbored racist sentiments against white farmers was demonstrably inaccurate and biased, and resulted in Sherrod losing her job. Breitbart declined to apologize publicly to Sherrod, and she sued him for defamation, a suit that is still pending.

If his addiction to drama didn’t exactly help Breitbart’s network of sites become a bastion of credible journalism, his combativeness and hunger for pageviews sometimes meant that he lent his support to more positive causes. After blogger Dave Weigel left the Washington Post after his private emails were published by rival conservative outlet the Daily Caller, Breitbart gave him space to explain himself. And at a time when the Republican party was falling back on socially conservative positions to gain support, Breitbart joined the board of gay conservative organization GOProud, saying “If being conservative means rejecting gay conservatives because they are gay, then fine, I’m not a conservative.” He later left the organization, but remained supportive of its aims.

NEWS FLASH

Liberia Now Considering Two Anti-Gay Bills | In addition to the “Kill the Gays” bill proposed by former First Lady Jewel Howard Taylor, Liberia’s legislature is now considering a second bill introduced by Rep. Clarence Massaquoi that would criminalize homosexuality. While the new bill does not allow for the death penalty, it can apply to anyone who “seduces, encourages, (or) promotes another person of the same gender to engage in sexual activities,” with punishment of up to five years imprisonment.

Chick-fil-A Tries To Mask Anti-Gay Record As Northeastern University Rejects Contract

Students and administrators at Northeastern University agree that rejecting plans to bring Chick-fil-A as a vendor to campus was the right call. The fast food chain’s history of giving millions of dollars to anti-gay organizations simply does not align with the inclusive values the school prides itself on. But Chick-fil-A is bitter to have been dropped, and is now trying to misrepresent its well-documented reputation for opposing LGBT rights.

Calling Northeastern’s decision “hasty,” Chick-fil-A’s spokesperson claims the company is totally inclusive and has “no political agenda”:

The most important thing we need to confirm is that we are not anti-anybody and Chick-fil-A have [sic] no agenda, policy or position against anyone as some reports continue to represent. Here’s the clarification and correction. Chick-fil-A has been scrutinized of late about our charitable giving, specifically through our WinShape Foundation, and whether or not we have some hidden political agenda. We don’t. Our agenda is simple: to graciously serve great food and have a positive influence on all who come in contact with Chick-fil-A. This is the reason why we were initially invited to the campus.

The statement goes on to claim that the company’s donations have been labeled as “anti-gay” merely for being affiliated with faith-based organizations, but this is a sad attempt to hide behind religion. The donations are called “anti-gay” because they quite certainly are anti-gay. As Equality Matters has reported, Chick-fil-A’s WinShape foundation has given millions of dollars to organizations that oppose marriage equality (Marriage and Family Legacy Fund, Family Research Council), bully gay students (Fellowship of Christian Athletes, Focus on the Family), and promote harmful ex-gay therapy (Exodus International). In addition, the company has a score of 0 on HRC’s corporate equality index, offering absolutely no protections to LGBT staff and even firing employees who engage in “sinful” behavior. Compare that to how many Fortune 100 companies offer non-discrimination protections based on sexual orientation (94 percent) and gender identity (69 percent).

Northeastern was perfectly justified to oppose bringing Chick-fil-A to campus. That the company would respond by whining and deceitfully misrepresenting itself proves the point.

  • Comment Icon

NEWS FLASH

Tennessee Principal Condemns Gay Students To Hell | Tennessee principal Dorothy Bond of Haywood High School is under fire for pointing at gay students and telling them they’re going to hell. According to students at the meeting, she also said that if you’re pregnant, “your life is over.” Members of the community report that Bond has a history of remarks like this, telling students at an assembly once, “If you’re pregnant or homosexual, you’re not welcome at Haywood County High School.”

NEWS FLASH

POLL: New Jersey Marriage Equality Support Reaches 57 Percent | More New Jersey voters support marriage equality than ever before, with 57 percent saying they would approve of a same-sex marriage law. Respondents were more split, however, over Gov. Chris Christie’s (R) veto of the legislation, with 48 percent saying it was the right thing to do and 47 percent saying it was the wrong thing to do. This is explained by the fact that 67 percent support Christie’s idea to decide the issue of same-sex marriage rights by referendum.

Advocates Plan To Challenge Ohio’s Constitutional Ban Against Same-Sex Marriage

Marriage equality advocates in Ohio will attempt to overturn that state’s constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriage through a referendum, the Columbus Dispatch reports. The Freedom to Marry Coalition plans to “file more than 1,700 signatures of registered Ohio voters” with Attorney General Mike DeWine — a prominent Rick Santorum supporter — to change the Constitution’s description of marriage to “a union of two consenting adults, regardless of gender.” It also would stipulate that “no religious institution shall be required to perform or recognize a marriage.”

Supporters are optimistic, but backers of the existing anti-gay language predict that they will defeat the effort:

Tim Hagan, former Cuyahoga County commissioner, Democratic candidate for governor in 2002 and co-chairman of the campaign, called it “the most-significant civil-rights act since 1964. I don’t know how one human being can look at another human being and say, ‘You don’t have the same rights.’ “I have a sister who’s gay. I have close friends who are gay,” Hagan said. “But this is not just a gay issue. This is an issue for all of us who believe strongly in human rights.”

Phil Burress, of the Cincinnati-based group Citizens for Community Values, said that if same-sex marriage supporters put the issue on the ballot this fall “they can kiss (President Barack) Obama goodbye.… I guess they’re feeling their oats because seven states have same-sex marriage,” Burress said. “ They’re going to have their hands full. We’re prepared to meet them on the field of battle.”

Under Ohio law, the group will need 1,000 valid signatures to place the issue before Ohio voters this fall or possibly next year. “If DeWine approves the ballot language of the proposed amendment, it will be sent to the Ohio Ballot Board, which would determine whether the proposal can be placed on the ballot as one or multiple issues. At that point, the Freedom to Marry Coalition can begin the task of collecting the 385,253 valid signatures required to put the issue on the statewide ballot.”

Equality Ohio notes that some 32 percent of residents back marriage equality, but many support civil unions. It also estimates that the cost of getting on the ballot could run as high as $2.25 million.

  • Comment Icon

The Morning Pride: March 1, 2012

Welcome to The Morning Pride, ThinkProgress LGBT’s 8:45 AM round-up of the latest in LGBT policy, politics, and some culture too! Here’s what we’re reading this morning, but let us know what you’re checking out as well. Follow us all day on Twitter at @TPEquality.

- The White House continues to stay mum about an executive order that would require federal contractors to protect against LGBT discrimination.

- Rep. Tammy Baldwin (D) is leading all the potential Republican candidates in her Senate race.

- The DC Trans Coalition argues the Metropolitan Police Department is not honoring its commitment to reduce anti-transgender violence in the city, and may be lying about it too.

- Equality Matters takes an in-depth look at the National Organization for Marriage’s failed “Marriage Anti-Defamation Alliance.”

- The Family Research Council continues to eagerly defend ex-gay ministries, claiming they aren’t anti-gay.

- St. Louis Park will join three other Minnesota cities in opposing the state’s anti-equality amendment.

- Over 75,000 Change.org petitioners have called upon Union-Scioto School District in Chillicothe, Ohio to pass an anti-bullying policy that protects gays students like the 15-year-old whose assault was recently captured on video.

- Lady Gaga, flanked by the likes of Oprah Winfrey and HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius, launched her “Born This Way” Foundation yesterday to fight bullying.

- George Clooney sat down with The Advocate to discuss his support of marriage equality and how he will never deny rumors that he is gay because he just doesn’t care.

- A Washington couple who’ve been married nearly 70 years express their support for marriage equality for their two gay grandsons:

  • Comment Icon

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up